Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / MagicalGirlLyricalNanohaAs

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Book of Darkness does CallingYourAttacks in German. Out of the blue it casts an attack calling it "Diabolic Emission" in English. The only other attacks the Book of Darkness casts in English are Starlight Breaker and Photon Lancer Genocide Shift. Starlight Breaker being Nanoha's SignatureMove and Photon Lancer being Fate's, which makes it obvious that attacks not in German come from PowerCopying from those who had an encounter with the book and part of their magic stolen. Diabolic Emission thus must have come for one of the Book's victims. While the Wolkenritter avoided fatalities, it's a clear reminder they've been busy. It's also a clear reminder that the Wolkenritter were good fighters if they succeeded in attacking someone that has a signature attack the Book of Darkness considered appropriate to use at that specific point in time.

to:

* The Book of Darkness does CallingYourAttacks in German. Out of the blue it casts an attack calling it "Diabolic Emission" in English. The only other attacks the Book of Darkness casts in English are Starlight Breaker and Photon Lancer Genocide Shift. Starlight Breaker being Nanoha's SignatureMove and Photon Lancer being Fate's, which makes it obvious that attacks not in German come from PowerCopying from those who had an encounter with the book and part of their magic stolen. Diabolic Emission thus must have come for form one of the Book's victims. While the Wolkenritter avoided fatalities, it's a clear reminder they've been busy. It's also a clear reminder that the Wolkenritter were good fighters if they succeeded in attacking someone that has a signature attack the Book of Darkness considered appropriate to use at that specific point in time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Book of Darkness does CallingYourAttacks in German. Out of the blue it casts an attack calling it "Diabolic Emission" in English. The only other attacks the Book of Darkness casts in English are Starlight Breaker and Photon Lancer Genocide Shift. Starlight Breaker being Nanoha's SignatureMove and Photon Lancer being Fate's, which makes it obvious that attacks not in German come from PowerCopying from those who had an encounter with the book and part of their magic stolen. Diabolic Emission thus must have come for one of the Book's victims. While the Wolkenritter avoided fatalities, it's a clear reminder they've been busy. It's also a clear reminder that the Wolkenritter were good fighters if they succeeded in attacking someone that has a signature attack the Book of Darkness considered appropriate to use at that specific point in time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Considering most who get involved with a case related to the Book of Darkness end up dying in the attempt to stop it, Clyde likely knew he'd end up dying. He most likely left Durandal behind knowing this as a way of letting his wife and son know part of him would always be with them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Durandal was supposed to belong to Clyde in the movie, how did Lindy get a hold of it? Her husband died via exploding starship. That's hardly something that you can salvage a personal weapon from.

to:

* If Durandal was supposed to belong to Clyde in the movie, how did Lindy get a hold of it? Her husband died via There's no reason he wouldn't have had it on him when he died, and his cause of death was exploding starship. That's hardly something that you can salvage a personal weapon from.spaceship. I'm pretty sure it wouldn't have been salvageable after that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


!!!FridgeLogic
* If Durandal was supposed to belong to Clyde in the movie, how did Lindy get a hold of it? Her husband died via exploding starship. That's hardly something that you can salvage a personal weapon from.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chapter 19.5 of ''Manga/MagicalGirlLyricalNanohaViVid'' indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.

to:

** Chapter 19.5 of ''Manga/MagicalGirlLyricalNanohaViVid'' ''Manga/MagicalGirlLyricalNanohaVivid'' indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chapter 19.5 of ''Manga/{{ViVid}}'' indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.

to:

** Chapter 19.5 of ''Manga/{{ViVid}}'' ''Manga/MagicalGirlLyricalNanohaViVid'' indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The fact that the Masked Men's disguises as Fate and Nanoha were the wrong color is a huge clue to their identities if you're aware that [[spoiler: cat's are colorblind.]]

to:

* The fact that the Masked Men's disguises as Fate and Nanoha were the wrong color is a huge clue to their identities if you're aware that [[spoiler: cat's cats are colorblind.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The fact that the Masked Men's disguises as Fate and Nanoha were the wrong color is a huge clue to their identities when you remember that [[spoiler: cat's are colorblind.]]

to:

* The fact that the Masked Men's disguises as Fate and Nanoha were the wrong color is a huge clue to their identities when you remember if you're aware that [[spoiler: cat's are colorblind.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The fact that the Masked Men's disguises as Fate and Nanoha were the wrong color is a huge clue to their identities when you remember that [[spoiler: cat's are colorblind.]]

Added: 4

Changed: 2062

Removed: 164

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeHorror:
** Possible lethal uses of Shamal's and Yuuno's powers.
*** To elaborate: Yunno can teleport people against their will. He did so to Arf in the first season and the Book of Darkness Corruption in the second. He could teleport you to the bottom of the sea and you'd die before getting to the surface (or simply be crushed by the pressure if deep enough). He could teleport you into solid matter or into the position of a human shield. And if he can teleport parts of people, he could teleport vital organs out leaving the owner dead or dying. And while Vivid 19.5 shows some Masters were kind, it is almost certain others were monsters, meaning Shamal probably has done such things. The fact that she didn't in the series can't be taken as proof otherwise because Hayate was giving her Knights the option of choice and any Master who would have given Shamal such an order certainly wouldn't have.
** The hypothetical PainfulTransformation caused by the Book of Darkness on males.
** The history of the Wolkenritter. Were all their previous masters cruel? Or were there equally loving ones that the Book purged/altered their memories thereof?
*** Chapter 19.5 of ''Manga/ViVid'' indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.

to:

!!!FridgeHorror:
* FridgeHorror:
**
Possible lethal uses of Shamal's and Yuuno's powers.
*** To elaborate:
powers. Yunno can teleport people against their will. He did so to Arf in the first season and the Book of Darkness Corruption in the second. He could teleport you to the bottom of the sea and you'd die before getting to the surface (or simply be crushed by the pressure if deep enough). He could teleport you into solid matter or into the position of a human shield. And if he can teleport parts of people, he could teleport vital organs out leaving the owner dead or dying. And while Vivid 19.5 shows some Masters were kind, it is almost certain others were monsters, meaning Shamal probably has done such things. The fact that she didn't in the series can't be taken as proof otherwise because Hayate was giving her Knights the option of choice and any Master who would have given Shamal such an order certainly wouldn't have.
** * The hypothetical PainfulTransformation caused by the Book of Darkness on males.
** * The history of the Wolkenritter. Were all their previous masters cruel? Or were there equally loving ones that the Book purged/altered their memories thereof?
*** ** Chapter 19.5 of ''Manga/ViVid'' ''Manga/{{ViVid}}'' indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.



* FridgeBrilliance
** The use of what apppears to be a dead ringer for Admiral Clyde as the form for the Wolkenritter's MysteriousProtector becomes even more appropriate when you consider that [[spoiler:Admiral Graham's familiars]] know Chrono is covering the case, and know about his father's death, potentially hoping to use it against him. After Chrono points out that their plan to deal with the book is illegal, [[spoiler:Lotte]] tries to argue that following the law resulted in many people, Chrono's father included, dying before [[spoiler:Graham]] silences her.
** When the Book of Darkness started casting [[WaveMotionGun Starlight Breaker]] to get rid of Nanoha and Fate, Nanoha thought that they do not have to run as far away as possible. Fate corrected her, saying that they NEED to be as far away as possible as their shields would not be able to withstand the attack. This is because Nanoha has never been on the receiving end of her most powerful attack, thus has no idea how strong it really is. Fate, on the other hand, is the first person to be on its receiving end, so she knows exactly what to expect.
** The roles of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depicted the truth, the TSAB will be seriously compromised politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove a nine-year-old girl from a neutral world into an eternally frozen void, and personally interfering with the TSAB's battles against the Wolkenritter.

to:

!!!FridgeBrilliance
* FridgeBrilliance
**
The use of what apppears to be a dead ringer for Admiral Clyde as the form for the Wolkenritter's MysteriousProtector becomes even more appropriate when you consider that [[spoiler:Admiral Graham's familiars]] know Chrono is covering the case, and know about his father's death, potentially hoping to use it against him. After Chrono points out that their plan to deal with the book is illegal, [[spoiler:Lotte]] tries to argue that following the law resulted in many people, Chrono's father included, dying before [[spoiler:Graham]] silences her.
** * When the Book of Darkness started casting [[WaveMotionGun Starlight Breaker]] to get rid of Nanoha and Fate, Nanoha thought that they do not have to run as far away as possible. Fate corrected her, saying that they NEED to be as far away as possible as their shields would not be able to withstand the attack. This is because Nanoha has never been on the receiving end of her most powerful attack, thus has no idea how strong it really is. Fate, on the other hand, is the first person to be on its receiving end, so she knows exactly what to expect.
** * The roles of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depicted the truth, the TSAB will be seriously compromised politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove a nine-year-old girl from a neutral world into an eternally frozen void, and personally interfering with the TSAB's battles against the Wolkenritter.Wolkenritter.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** To elaborate: Yunno can teleport people against their will. He did so to Arf in the first season and the Book of Darkness Corruption in the second. He could teleport you to the bottom of the sea and you'd die before getting to the surface (or simply be crushed by the pressure if deep enough). He could teleport you into solid matter or into the position of a human shield. And if he can teleport parts of people, he could teleport vital organs out leaving the owner dead or dying. And while Vivid 19.5 shows some Masters were kind, it is almost certain others were monsters, meaning Shamal probably has done such things. The fact that she didn't in the series can't be taken as proof otherwise because Hayate was giving her Knights the option of choice and any Master who would have given Shamal such an order certainly wouldn't have.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove a nine-year-old girl from a neutral world into an eternally frozen void, and personally interfering with the TSAB's battles against the Wolkenritter.

to:

** The role roles of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict depicted the truth, the TSAB will be seriously compromised, compromised politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove a nine-year-old girl from a neutral world into an eternally frozen void, and personally interfering with the TSAB's battles against the Wolkenritter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove a nine-year-old girl from a neutral world into an eternally frozen void, and personally undermining the effort to stop the terror action of the Book's Knights. That's magical equivalent of Iran-Contra scandal.

to:

** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove a nine-year-old girl from a neutral world into an eternally frozen void, and personally undermining interfering with the effort to stop TSAB's battles against the terror action of the Book's Knights. That's magical equivalent of Iran-Contra scandal.Wolkenritter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove the Book of Darkness forever into an innocent little girl from a neutral world, and personally undermining the effort to stop the terror action of the Book's Knights. That's magical equivalent of Iran-Contra scandal.

to:

** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove the Book of Darkness forever into an innocent little a nine-year-old girl from a neutral world, world into an eternally frozen void, and personally undermining the effort to stop the terror action of the Book's Knights. That's magical equivalent of Iran-Contra scandal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically.

to:

** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically. This is a high-ranking TSAB officer conspiring to shove the Book of Darkness forever into an innocent little girl from a neutral world, and personally undermining the effort to stop the terror action of the Book's Knights. That's magical equivalent of Iran-Contra scandal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The role of Admiral Graham and his two {{Cat Girl}}s are axed in the movie version. This seems odd, until you remember that the movies are supposed to be TSAB propaganda. If they actually depict the truth, TSAB will be seriously compromised, politically.

Removed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* FridgeLogic
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


*FridgeLogic
** When the Book of Darkness started casting [[WaveMotionGun Starlight Breaker]] to get rid of Nanoha and Fate, Nanoha thought that they do not have to run as far away as possible. Fate corrected her, saying that they NEED to be as far away as possible as their shields would not be able to withstand the attack. This is because Nanoha has never been on the receiving end of her most powerful attack, thus has no idea how strong it really is. Fate, on the other hand, is the first person to be on its receiving end, so she knows exactly what to expect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeLogic
** If the knights could so easily disobey Hayate's orders not to go fight anymore (and therefore prove that they have free will), then why couldn't they just do the same with their worse masters? Were they that [[IdiotBall dense]]? Did they really not give a f*ck? And, as said below, several other masters were nice to the Wolks too, so saying that Hayate's goodness/decent treatment of them made them nicer/have free will/etc. would be a plot hole in and of itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If the knights could so easily disobey Hayate's orders not to go fight anymore (and therefore prove that they have free will), then why couldn't they just do the same with their worse masters? Were they that [[IdiotBall dense]]? Did they really not give a f*ck? And, as said below, several other masters were nice to the Wolks too, so saying that Hayate's goodness/decent treatment of them made them nicer/not murderous/etc. would be a plot hole in and of itself.

to:

** If the knights could so easily disobey Hayate's orders not to go fight anymore (and therefore prove that they have free will), then why couldn't they just do the same with their worse masters? Were they that [[IdiotBall dense]]? Did they really not give a f*ck? And, as said below, several other masters were nice to the Wolks too, so saying that Hayate's goodness/decent treatment of them made them nicer/not murderous/etc.nicer/have free will/etc. would be a plot hole in and of itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FridgeLogic
** If the knights could so easily disobey Hayate's orders not to go fight anymore (and therefore prove that they have free will), then why couldn't they just do the same with their worse masters? Were they that [[IdiotBall dense]]? Did they really not give a f*ck? And, as said below, several other masters were nice to the Wolks too, so saying that Hayate's goodness/decent treatment of them made them nicer/not murderous/etc. would be a plot hole in and of itself.

Changed: 674

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The extraction of a mage's Linker core is shown to be very painful, evidenced in multiple instances such when Vita was collecting pages for the Book of darkness from several TSAB agents, who were wincing in pain as their cores were collected, Fate passed out after her core was forcibly extracted and all of the Wolkenritter were screaming in agony as their linker cores were absorbed. Now just imagine what kind of hellish pain Nanoha had to go through when her linker core was assimilated, on top of being physically exhausted and beaten, while charging up and firing her most powerful spell, which, as we will learn in the 3rd season, puts a lot of stress on her body.



** The use of what apppears to be a dead ringer for Admiral Clyde as the form for the Wolkenritter's MysteriousProtector becomes even more appropriate when you consider that [[spoiler:Admiral Graham's familiars]] know Chrono is covering the case, and know about his father's death, potentially hoping to use it against him. After Chrono points out that their plan to deal with the book is illegal, [[spoiler:Lotte]] tries to argue that following the law resulted in many people, Chrono's father included, dying before [[spoiler:Graham]] silences her.

to:

** The use of what apppears to be a dead ringer for Admiral Clyde as the form for the Wolkenritter's MysteriousProtector becomes even more appropriate when you consider that [[spoiler:Admiral Graham's familiars]] know Chrono is covering the case, and know about his father's death, potentially hoping to use it against him. After Chrono points out that their plan to deal with the book is illegal, [[spoiler:Lotte]] tries to argue that following the law resulted in many people, Chrono's father included, dying before [[spoiler:Graham]] silences her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*In the final battle, all of the components are clearly parts from creatures we've seen defeated previously. Except for in the beguining, where an appendage looking like the upper torso of a human is making strange beastly noises...Until you realize thats probably the embodiment of all the people who ever succumbed to the book of darkness, screaming in terror, pain and despair...for who knows how many CENTURIES...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Chapter 19.5 of ViVid indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.

to:

*** Chapter 19.5 of ViVid ''Manga/ViVid'' indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The history of the Wolkenritter. Were all their previous masters cruel? Or were there equally loving ones that the Book purged/altered their memories thereof?

to:

** The history of the Wolkenritter. Were all their previous masters cruel? Or were there equally loving ones that the Book purged/altered their memories thereof?thereof?
*** Chapter 19.5 of ViVid indicates that some people were kind to the Wolkenritter, but until Hayate became their master, no one could overcome the curse.

*FridgeBrilliance
**The use of what apppears to be a dead ringer for Admiral Clyde as the form for the Wolkenritter's MysteriousProtector becomes even more appropriate when you consider that [[spoiler:Admiral Graham's familiars]] know Chrono is covering the case, and know about his father's death, potentially hoping to use it against him. After Chrono points out that their plan to deal with the book is illegal, [[spoiler:Lotte]] tries to argue that following the law resulted in many people, Chrono's father included, dying before [[spoiler:Graham]] silences her.

Top