Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / AttackOfTheClones

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anakin does understand the Jedi tenets regarding attachment, and explains them to Padme fairly succinctly: No, Jedi aren't expected to be emotionless robots. Yes, they're allowed to love and care about the people around them. Anakin obviously still loves his mother, and everyone's fine with that. He loves Obi-Wan in a familial way, and everyone's fine with that. What Jedi frown upon are ''passion'' and ''possessiveness'' - the inability to let people go, the willingness to compromise your morals and principles and shirk your duty for them. Anakin gets it. Then ''actively chooses to disregard those teachings with Padme''. Apart from his vengeance on the Tusken raiders, this signifies the beginning of his fall - he knows he's allowed to at least love and care for Padme, he doesn't have to be indifferent to her [[note]] there's some debate about whether Jedi are truly expected to be CelibateHero or if romantic or sexual entanglements are permitted, though it seems marriage is fairly staunchly off the table for them.[[/note]] But he does make a conscious choice to move forward with her in a way that actively goes against the principles he's committed to upholding and will introduce a lot of secrecy between him, Obi-Wan, and the rest of the Order.

to:

* Anakin does understand the Jedi tenets regarding attachment, and explains them to Padme fairly succinctly: No, Jedi aren't expected to be emotionless robots. Yes, they're allowed to love and care about the people around them. Anakin obviously still loves his mother, and everyone's fine with that. He loves Obi-Wan in a familial way, and everyone's fine with that. What Jedi frown upon are ''passion'' and ''possessiveness'' - the inability to let people go, the willingness to compromise your morals and principles and shirk your duty for them. Anakin gets it. Then ''actively chooses to disregard those teachings with Padme''. Apart from his vengeance on the Tusken raiders, this signifies the beginning of his fall - he knows he's allowed to at least love and care for Padme, he doesn't have to be indifferent to her her. [[note]] there's There's some debate about whether Jedi are truly expected to be CelibateHero or if romantic or sexual entanglements are permitted, though it seems marriage is fairly staunchly off the table for them.[[/note]] But he does make a conscious choice to move forward with her in a way that actively goes against the principles he's committed to upholding and will introduce a lot of secrecy between him, Obi-Wan, and the rest of the Order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anakin does understand the Jedi tenets regarding attachment, and explains them to Padme fairly succinctly: No, Jedi aren't expected to be emotionless robots. Yes, they're allowed to love and care about the people around them. Anakin obviously still loves his mother, and everyone's fine with that. He loves Obi-Wan in a familial way, and everyone's fine with that. What Jedi frown upon are ''passion'' and ''possessiveness'' - the inability to let people go, the willingness to compromise your morals and principles and shirk your duty for them. Anakin gets it. Then ''actively chooses to disregard those teachings with Padme''. Apart from his vengeance on the Tusken raiders, this signifies the beginning of his fall - he knows he's allowed to at least love and care for Padme, he doesn't have to be indifferent to her [[note: there's some debate about whether Jedi are truly expected to be CelibateHero or if romantic or sexual entanglements are permitted, though it seems marriage is fairly staunchly off the table for them.]] But he does make a conscious choice to move forward with her in a way that actively goes against the principles he's committed to upholding and will introduce a lot of secrecy between him, Obi-Wan, and the rest of the Order.

to:

* Anakin does understand the Jedi tenets regarding attachment, and explains them to Padme fairly succinctly: No, Jedi aren't expected to be emotionless robots. Yes, they're allowed to love and care about the people around them. Anakin obviously still loves his mother, and everyone's fine with that. He loves Obi-Wan in a familial way, and everyone's fine with that. What Jedi frown upon are ''passion'' and ''possessiveness'' - the inability to let people go, the willingness to compromise your morals and principles and shirk your duty for them. Anakin gets it. Then ''actively chooses to disregard those teachings with Padme''. Apart from his vengeance on the Tusken raiders, this signifies the beginning of his fall - he knows he's allowed to at least love and care for Padme, he doesn't have to be indifferent to her [[note: [[note]] there's some debate about whether Jedi are truly expected to be CelibateHero or if romantic or sexual entanglements are permitted, though it seems marriage is fairly staunchly off the table for them.]] [[/note]] But he does make a conscious choice to move forward with her in a way that actively goes against the principles he's committed to upholding and will introduce a lot of secrecy between him, Obi-Wan, and the rest of the Order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeath Beaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilUntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]

to:

* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeath Beaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilUntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]]]
* Anakin does understand the Jedi tenets regarding attachment, and explains them to Padme fairly succinctly: No, Jedi aren't expected to be emotionless robots. Yes, they're allowed to love and care about the people around them. Anakin obviously still loves his mother, and everyone's fine with that. He loves Obi-Wan in a familial way, and everyone's fine with that. What Jedi frown upon are ''passion'' and ''possessiveness'' - the inability to let people go, the willingness to compromise your morals and principles and shirk your duty for them. Anakin gets it. Then ''actively chooses to disregard those teachings with Padme''. Apart from his vengeance on the Tusken raiders, this signifies the beginning of his fall - he knows he's allowed to at least love and care for Padme, he doesn't have to be indifferent to her [[note: there's some debate about whether Jedi are truly expected to be CelibateHero or if romantic or sexual entanglements are permitted, though it seems marriage is fairly staunchly off the table for them.]] But he does make a conscious choice to move forward with her in a way that actively goes against the principles he's committed to upholding and will introduce a lot of secrecy between him, Obi-Wan, and the rest of the Order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Actually, Obi-Wan's response to ''that'', "Then why won't you listen to me?" (In particular in response to Anakin saying Obi-Wan was the closest thing he had to a father), is also Fridge Sadness in this regard. In hindsight, that whole argument, which passes quickly enough and isn't super impactful in terms of the plot, can be taken as a rather tragic foreshadowing of what will eventually happen between the two of them. Obi-Wan is saying that Anakin will kill him one day, Anakin is horrified by the idea because he ''loves'' Obi-Wan, and Obi-Wan is basically saying, "If you do love me, why do you wind up abandoning that and the values I've tried so hard to teach you and going to the DarkSide?"

Added: 1324

Changed: 253

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The comparison to Romeo and Juliet is especially accurate, not only in that neither Romeo and Juliet nor Anakin and Padme are really meant to be portrayed as some kind of ideal love, but in the root causes of the both tragedies: ''forbidden'' love. Romeo and Juliet go off the rails because they're young people getting swept up in events and desperately short on adults/cooler heads to guide them through it, because they feel they can't be open about their relationship. Their situation escalates and escalates until literally all the young people are dead, and the "all are punish'd" line to the parents is meant to reflect exactly that. It's not "they were soulmates", it was "you guys created a situation where your kids felt they couldn't talk to you, and look what happened." In the case of Anakin and Padme, they're two young people attracted and infatuated with each other. The relationship on its own may have gone well or not. But the secrecy they're forced into, the lack of other adults in the room to help them solve the problems or calm them down when their emotions are getting the better of them, triggers an escalating situation that grows beyond Anakin's or Padme's ability to manage.




to:

* In a moment of exasperation, Obi-Wan grumbles at Anakin, "Why do I get the feeling you'll be the death of me?" Which is sort of a quip in the moment and one many parents can relate to. Except Anakin will eventually end up being the death of Obi-Wan...
** Fridge Sadness when Anakin actually seems a bit upset by the comment and pleads with Obi-Wan not to talk like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anakin's thinly-veiled sales pitch for dictatorship seems at first to be a product of grooming by Palpatine, but consider the other factors that go into this. First, Anakin spent his formative years as a slave on Tatooine, where Republic laws and principles are nothing more than empty words. Then, he joins the Jedi, who are certainly not a democratic institution. What's more, Obi-Wan's comments about politicians suggest that, in their work as a Jedi, the two of them encounter the democratically elected leaders of the Republic at their worst, seeing the seedy side of things up close and personal. No wonder Anakin doesn't think much of democracy.

to:

* Anakin's thinly-veiled sales pitch for dictatorship seems at first to be a product of grooming by Palpatine, but consider the other factors that go into this. First, Anakin spent his formative years as a slave on Tatooine, where Republic laws and principles are nothing more than empty words. Then, he joins the Jedi, who are certainly not a democratic institution. What's more, Obi-Wan's comments about politicians suggest that, in their work as a Jedi, the two of them encounter the democratically elected leaders of the Republic at their worst, seeing the seedy side of things up close and personal. In other words, to Anakin, the principles of democracy are hypocritical BS that benefited neither him nor his mother, and have the effect of putting corrupt assholes into power. No wonder Anakin he doesn't think much of democracy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anakin's thinly-veiled sales pitch for dictatorship seems at first to be a product of grooming by Palpatine, but consider the other factors that go into this. First, Anakin spent his formative years as a slave on Tatooine, where Republic laws and principles are nothing more than empty words. Then, he joins the Jedi, who are certainly not a democratic institution. What's more, Obi-Wan's comments about politicians suggest that, in their work as a Jedi, the two of them encounter the democratically elected leaders of the Republic at their worst, seeing the seedy of things up close and personal. No wonder Anakin doesn't think much of democracy.

to:

* Anakin's thinly-veiled sales pitch for dictatorship seems at first to be a product of grooming by Palpatine, but consider the other factors that go into this. First, Anakin spent his formative years as a slave on Tatooine, where Republic laws and principles are nothing more than empty words. Then, he joins the Jedi, who are certainly not a democratic institution. What's more, Obi-Wan's comments about politicians suggest that, in their work as a Jedi, the two of them encounter the democratically elected leaders of the Republic at their worst, seeing the seedy side of things up close and personal. No wonder Anakin doesn't think much of democracy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Anakin’s thinly-veiled sales pitch for dictatorship seems at first to be a product of grooming by Palpatine, but consider the other factors that go into this. First, Anakin spent his formative years as a slave on Tatooine, where Republic laws and principles are nothing more than empty words. Then, he joins the Jedi, who are certainly not a democratic institution. What’s more, Obi-Wan’s comments about politicians suggest that, in their work as a Jedi, the two of them encounter the democratically elected leaders of the Republic at their worst, seeing the seedy of things up close and personal. No wonder Anakin doesn’t think much of democracy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* There's a gag where C-3PO's head ends up on a battle droid's body. Why are both walking around, shooting Jedi? A deleted scene shows the battle droids being independently controlled after the Jedi raid the control ship. This would imply that the battle droids have two control systems - one in their "backpack" which links to the control ship, and a backup one in their head unit. C3PO's head was on the battle droid's body, which received commands from the control ship, and the other head, not detecting the control ship signal, operated C3PO's body independently.

Changed: 547

Removed: 474

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Seems more like Fridge Brilliance



to:

* Anakin's recounting of the murder of Tuskens is widely hated, especially in regards to how Padmé doesn't seem to hold it against him, but fans haven't considered his emotional state. He's in shock. His mother died in his arms after being kidnapped and tortured, then he flew into a rage and slaughtered them all, even the children. Especially the line "They're dead!" sounds like someone in stupor who can't believe what he has witnessed. He's horrified of what he's done and what he's becoming. He can't be expected to act calmly or rationally.



* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeath Beaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilUntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]
* Anakin's recounting of the murder of Tuskens is widely hated but fans haven't considered his emotional state. He's in shock. His mother died in his arms after being kidnapped and tortured, then he flew into a rage and slaughtered them all, even the children. Especially the line "They're dead!" sounds like someone in stupor who can't believe what he has witnessed. He's horrified of what he's done and what he's becoming. He can't be expected to act calmly or rationally.

to:

* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeath Beaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilUntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]
* Anakin's recounting of the murder of Tuskens is widely hated but fans haven't considered his emotional state. He's in shock. His mother died in his arms after being kidnapped and tortured, then he flew into a rage and slaughtered them all, even the children. Especially the line "They're dead!" sounds like someone in stupor who can't believe what he has witnessed. He's horrified of what he's done and what he's becoming. He can't be expected to act calmly or rationally.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeath Beaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilUntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]

to:

* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeath Beaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilUntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]]]
* Anakin's recounting of the murder of Tuskens is widely hated but fans haven't considered his emotional state. He's in shock. His mother died in his arms after being kidnapped and tortured, then he flew into a rage and slaughtered them all, even the children. Especially the line "They're dead!" sounds like someone in stupor who can't believe what he has witnessed. He's horrified of what he's done and what he's becoming. He can't be expected to act calmly or rationally.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** That's the whole point of the Prequel Trilogy, and Luke's failing come ''Film/TheLastJedi''. The Jedi Order of the Prequels had become so ideologically inbred Anakin was a literal OutsideContextProblem for them. Luke, in seeking to emulate the previous Jedi Order, also emulated its failures, instead of learning from them and building something better. One hopes the lesson finally sinks in with Rey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anakin might not like sand but what ends up saving Padme when she falls out of the gunship during the Battle of Geonois? That's right, '''sand'''. It might be "course, rough and irritating" but it's also '''soft'''.

to:

* Anakin might not like sand but what ends up saving Padme when she falls out of the gunship during the Battle of Geonois? Geonosis? That's right, '''sand'''. It might be "course, rough and irritating" but it's also '''soft'''.



* Having Dooku hit Anakin with Force lightning isn't just an in-universe tactical decision to separate him and Obi-Wan so Dooku could fight each on their own. It also serves as foreshadowing for ''Return of the Jedi.'' Rewatch the scene where Luke is being tortured. The ''moment'' Palpatine starts throwing lightning at Luke, Vader looks around and is clearly disturbed. This isn't just a father watching his son getting tortured; he's remembering how terribly debiliating it was from his own personal experience!

to:

* Having Dooku hit Anakin with Force lightning isn't just an in-universe tactical decision to separate him and Obi-Wan so Dooku could fight each on their own. It also serves as foreshadowing for ''Return of the Jedi.'' Rewatch the scene where Luke is being tortured. The ''moment'' Palpatine starts throwing lightning at Luke, Vader looks around and is clearly disturbed. This isn't just a father watching his son getting tortured; he's remembering how terribly debiliating debilitating it was from his own personal experience!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeathBeaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilOntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]

to:

* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeathBeaten]], [[CruelAndUnusualDeath Beaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilOntoEvil [[PayEvilUntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The fear that the Sand People show for Obi-Wan Kenobi in ''A New Hope'' is much more understandable when you realize that a lone Jedi was also responsible for slaying an entire tribe of them living in the same area a little over two decades earlier.

to:

* The fear that the Sand People show for Obi-Wan Kenobi in ''A New Hope'' is much more understandable when you realize that a lone Jedi was also responsible for slaying an entire tribe of them living in the same area a little over two decades earlier.earlier.
* When you look at Shmi's condition, she appears barely responsive to stimulus and is deprived of strength. She was clearly tortured at the hands of her captors. [[CruelAndUnusualDeathBeaten]], [[ATasteOfTheLash whipped]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starved]], and quite probably... ''raped.'' With all of this in mind, it's no wonder that when Anakin realizes the cruelty of how she died upon discovery, and the sheer unfairness of it all... [[PayEvilOntoEvil he unleashes his anger so completely.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's also confirmed that Anakin IS DesperateForAffection due to his abandonment issues--it's the most evident with Padme, but he also clutches Obi-Wan and Ahsoka in the same kind of emotional vice-grip.

to:

** It's also confirmed that Anakin IS DesperateForAffection [[DesperatelyCravesAffection severely love-starved,]] due to his former slave status and abandonment issues--it's the most evident with Padme, but he also clutches Obi-Wan and Ahsoka in the same kind of emotional vice-grip.



*** Perhaps the ''Star Wars'' universe differs from reality on this point, but as far as reality is concerned, ''accents are not inherited through genetics''. And unless I'm mistaken (I haven't really dug into any EU material), the clones weren't raised by Jango Fett...they were age-accelerated and boot-camped. So why should they share his accent at all? (Boba Fett, on the other hand, appears to have been raised by him, so ''his'' accent makes sense.)

to:

*** Perhaps the ''Star Wars'' universe differs from reality on this point, but as far as reality is concerned, ''accents are not inherited through genetics''. And unless I'm mistaken (I haven't really dug into any EU material), the clones weren't raised by Jango Fett... they were age-accelerated and boot-camped. So why should they share his accent at all? (Boba Fett, on the other hand, appears to have been raised by him, so ''his'' accent makes sense.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's also confirmed that Anakin IS DesperateForAffection due to his abandonment issues--it's the most evident with Padme, but he also clutches Obi-Wan and Ahsoka in the same kind of emotional vice-grip.

Top