Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Foreshadowing / GlassOnion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)




to:

\n* When Helen asks Blanc if he's good at Clue, Blanc answers, "I'm very bad at dumb things. My Achilles' heel." [[spoiler:The reason it takes Blanc so long to figure out what's going on is that he hasn't considered the possibility that Miles is just dumb.]]

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Peg goes to Miles and outright BEGS him not to have Birdie make the statement revealing she [[spoiler:stupidly, unknowingly allowed the use of a sweatshop in one of her ventures]] because that would not only ruin Birdie, but Peg, herself, due to most of her resume being working for Birdie, Miles gives her the brush off and a smile as he asks her to get Birdie to make the statement. This foreshadows two big indicators of Miles: 1) he doesn't give a damn about anyone but himself, not even to offer Peg words of encouragement (such as, "Birdie told me how much you help her and do for her. You'll bounce back after this is all over") and 2: he adamantly believes his natural charisma (which he DOES have despite being an idiot) is more enough to get people to agree to whatever he asks of them.


to:

* When Peg goes to Miles and outright BEGS '''''begs''''' him not to have Birdie make the statement revealing she [[spoiler:stupidly, unknowingly allowed the use of a sweatshop in one of her ventures]] because that would not only ruin Birdie, Birdie but Peg, Peg herself, due to most of her resume being working for Birdie, Miles gives her the brush off and a smile as he asks her to get Birdie to make the statement. This foreshadows two big indicators of Miles: 1) he doesn't give a damn about anyone but himself, not even to offer Peg words of encouragement (such as, "Birdie told me how much you help her and do for her. You'll bounce back after this is all over") and 2: he adamantly believes his natural charisma (which he DOES have ''does'' have, despite being an idiot) is more enough to get people to agree to whatever he asks of them.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Peg goes to Miles and outright BEGS him not to have Birdie make the statement revealing she [[spoiler:stupidly, unknowingly allowed the use of a sweatshop in one of her ventures]] because that would not only ruin Birdie, but Peg, herself, due to most of her resume being working for Birdie, Miles gives her the brush off and a smile as he asks her to get Birdie to make the statement. This foreshadows two big indicators of Miles: 1) he doesn't give a damn about anyone but himself, not even to offer Peg words of encouragement (such as, "Birdie told me how much you help her and do for her. You'll bounce back after this is all over") and 2: he adamantly believes his natural charisma (which he DOES have despite being an idiot) is more enough to get people to agree to whatever he asks of them.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Birdie is the first one to greet Andi [[spoiler:aka Helen]]. She's similarly [[spoiler:the first one to turn on Miles at the end and side with Helen]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The individual puzzles are not deductive or logic puzzles, but simply a series of references the person solving it is expected to recognize. They do not test the participant's intelligence (or even testify to Miles' intelligence), but rather simply what bits of info or trivia they are familiar with (Do you know what a stereogram is? A compass? A memetic chess match? What a fugue is?), This foreshadows the mystery and the titular Glass Onion metaphor - [[spoiler:There's no mystery, the answer is right there]].

to:

** The individual puzzles are not deductive or logic puzzles, but simply a series of references the person solving it is expected to recognize. They do not test the participant's intelligence (or even testify to Miles' intelligence), but rather simply what bits of info or trivia they are familiar with (Do you know what a stereogram is? A compass? A memetic chess match? What a fugue is?), This foreshadows the mystery and the titular Glass Onion metaphor - [[spoiler:There's no mystery, the answer is right there]]. Like the movie's central theme, the puzzles seem clever because of the kind of knowledge and references they employ but in reality they are very simple if you simply know what they are referencing - as shown by Duke's mom sounding utterly bored with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The individual puzzles are not deductive or logic puzzles, but simply a series of references the person solving it is expected to recognize. They do not test the participant's intelligence (or even testify to Miles' intelligence), but rather simply what bits of info or trivia they are familiar with (Do you know what a stereogram is? A compass? A memetic chess match? What a fugue is?), This foreshadows the mystery and the titular Glass Onion metaphor - [[spoiler:There's no mystery, the answer is right there]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* During Duke and Whiskey's introduction, she comes on camera for a few moments to give a quick one-liner, smiling brightly for the audience. The second she steps back off the set, she looks immediately bored and checks her phone, implying that she doesn't actually care about the subject matter. [[spoiler:Initially this looks like foreshadowing her apparent affair with Miles, but later on in the film, she admits to "Andi" that the main reason she puts up with Duke is that she's just hoping to ride his fame to cultivate her own, as he's been giving her more screentime in his videos lately.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The line also sets up the other twists of the movie: [[spoiler:the puzzles might be not as impressive, but the way Blanc is dismissive of them is at odds with the more cordial attitude he is showing in the scene. That's because he didn't actually solve them or even see them properly, he only saw the pieces left, which included bright shapes and a TabletopGame/TicTacToe set, leading to his assumption. The fact that Miles doesn't contest the statement, nor seems irritated by it (which contrasts his reaction to Blanc spoiling the murder mystery) shows that not only did he not make the boxes, he didn't even bother checking them. Not only he isn't as clever as he paints himself to be, he doesn't even properly follow through on his own ideas.]]

to:

** The line also sets up the other twists of the movie: [[spoiler:the puzzles might be not as impressive, but the way Blanc is dismissive of them is at odds with the more cordial attitude he is showing in the scene. That's because he didn't actually solve them or even see them properly, he only saw the pieces left, which included bright shapes and a TabletopGame/TicTacToe set, leading to his assumption. The fact that Miles doesn't contest the statement, nor seems irritated by it (which contrasts his reaction to Blanc spoiling the murder mystery) shows that not only did he not make the boxes, he didn't even bother checking them. Not only he isn't is not as clever as he paints himself to be, he doesn't even properly follow through on his own ideas.ideas, and disregards the value of others' unless he sees a way to involve himself in them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Miles welcomes everyone to the island, Blanc and Andi are left alone on the beach. The first line that Andi says to Blanc is "This rich people shit is weird." [[spoiler: This is because Helen isn't the rich CEO Cassandra Brand -- she's a humble schoolteacher -- and she expresses familiarity with Blanc because they already know each other.]]

to:

* After Miles welcomes everyone to the island, Blanc and Andi are left alone on the beach. The first line that Andi says to Blanc is "This rich people shit is weird." [[spoiler: This [[spoiler:This is because Helen isn't the rich CEO Cassandra Brand -- she's a humble schoolteacher -- and she expresses familiarity with Blanc because they already know each other.]]



** The film shows Miles and Duke sitting down and [[spoiler:Miles placing Duke's drink into his hand]], which will later be proven as [[spoiler:the way Miles pushed a tampered drink onto Duke.]] The film tries to make the viewer doubt by providing an explanation where the visual depiction changes to show [[spoiler: Duke picking up the glass mistakenly from the table]], but viewers paying attention to the guys the first time, and not to Birdie twirling in her dress like [[spoiler:Miles asked everyone to watch]], will see that the second version of events is inconsistent and a lie.

to:

** The film shows Miles and Duke sitting down and [[spoiler:Miles placing Duke's drink into his hand]], which will later be proven as [[spoiler:the way Miles pushed a tampered drink onto Duke.]] The film tries to make the viewer doubt by providing an explanation where the visual depiction changes to show [[spoiler: Duke [[spoiler:Duke picking up the glass mistakenly from the table]], but viewers paying attention to the guys the first time, and not to Birdie twirling in her dress like [[spoiler:Miles asked everyone to watch]], will see that the second version of events is inconsistent and a lie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* After Miles welcomes everyone to the island, Blanc and Andi are left alone on the beach. The first line that Andi says to Blanc is "This rich people shit is weird." [[spoiler: This is because Helen isn't the rich CEO Cassandra Brand -- she's a humble schoolteacher -- and she expresses familiarity with Blanc because they already know each other.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Yo-Yo Ma cameos to explain the musical puzzle in the box as a fugue, a tune which changes and forms a different composition when layered over itself. This foreshadows the film's unusual structure-- [[spoiler: the film flashes back to reveal a massive plot twist, initiating a replay of the film, the "same tune", but with the events completely reframed by the new information and point of view, and making a very different bigger picture.]]

to:

* Yo-Yo Ma cameos to explain the musical puzzle in the box as a fugue, a tune which changes and forms a different composition when layered over itself. This foreshadows the film's unusual structure-- [[spoiler: the [[spoiler:the film flashes back to reveal a massive plot twist, initiating a replay of the film, the "same tune", but with the events completely reframed by the new information and point of view, and making a very different bigger picture.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When he announces the beginning of the game, he starts to say "[[Literature/SherlockHolmes As Watson said to Holmes..."]] before being cut off by Blanc. Most likely, the next words he was about to say were "The game is afoot", but if you know your Sherlock Holmes, then you know that it was Holmes who said that to Watson. Miles is citing a famous quote to sound smart, but he has the citation backwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After [[spoiler:Andi is shot]], Blanc runs up to her and [[spoiler:openly calls her "Helen", the meaning of which is imminently revealed upon the approaching plot-twist replay.]] In the chaos of the scene, this detail is very easy to miss.

to:

** After [[spoiler:Andi is shot]], the blackout, Blanc runs up to her Andi and [[spoiler:openly calls her "Helen", the meaning of which is imminently revealed upon the approaching plot-twist replay.]] In the chaos of the scene, this detail is very easy to miss.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Furthermore, [[spoiler:with Duke's murder, Miles frames the incident as someone trying to kill ''him''--after Blanc warned him of this possibility. It's an early sign that he can only steal ideas suggested to him, later followed up by the blackout and burning the napkin being actions prompted by others suggesting them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Similarly, when Andi makes her entrance, Blanc is looking at the Disruptors while all of them are looking at ''her''. [[spoiler:Blanc knows exactly who "Andi" is and everything about why she's there; he has no reason to stare at her. He wants to see what kind of a stir her impossible reappearance has caused--and if one of the shocked Disruptors is the one who's startled because they thought they'd successfully murdered her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This bullet is not a catchable detail the first time around, just something in continuity with events so I'm taking it back.


** When Duke starts to confront Miles about a deal after getting a phone alert, [[spoiler:a brief flash of the phone screen toward the camera shows a photo identifiable as a portrait of Cassandra Brand, showing early on that Duke had received an alert to Andi's obituary, but keeping this from being obvious through the phone screen being far from the camera and briefly shown.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some shots in the film show [[spoiler:Miles with Duke's phone, and Miles with the gun and then stashing it away in an ice bucket]], but the framing and action is designed to keep those put of notice.

to:

** Some shots in the film show [[spoiler:Miles with Duke's phone, and Miles with the gun and then stashing it away in an ice bucket]], but the framing and action is designed to keep those put out of notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A signature trick of foreshadowing in this film is how multiple key movements and details of the mystery are dropped in plain sight, with only camera framing or distractions keeping them from being caught by the average invested viewer.
** Closely watching the shot of Birdie at the pool before Andi is revealed when Birdie takes off her hat and uncovers the frame shows [[spoiler:an object being dropped from above into Birdie's swim bag right beside her--this was Helen dropping in the recording device before sitting down.]]
** When Duke starts to confront Miles about a deal after getting a phone alert, [[spoiler:a brief flash of the phone screen toward the camera shows a photo identifiable as a portrait of Cassandra Brand, showing early on that Duke had received an alert to Andi's obituary, but keeping this from being obvious through the phone screen being far from the camera and briefly shown.]]
** The film shows Miles and Duke sitting down and [[spoiler:Miles placing Duke's drink into his hand]], which will later be proven as [[spoiler:the way Miles pushed a tampered drink onto Duke.]] The film tries to make the viewer doubt by providing an explanation where the visual depiction changes to show [[spoiler: Duke picking up the glass mistakenly from the table]], but viewers paying attention to the guys the first time, and not to Birdie twirling in her dress like [[spoiler:Miles asked everyone to watch]], will see that the second version of events is inconsistent and a lie.
** Some shots in the film show [[spoiler:Miles with Duke's phone, and Miles with the gun and then stashing it away in an ice bucket]], but the framing and action is designed to keep those put of notice.
** After [[spoiler:Andi is shot]], Blanc runs up to her and [[spoiler:openly calls her "Helen", the meaning of which is imminently revealed upon the approaching plot-twist replay.]] In the chaos of the scene, this detail is very easy to miss.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleting example that was added by a troper who was ban evading at the time.


* When [[spoiler:Helen disguised as her twin sister Andi]] arrives at the dock to get on the boat to Miles' island, all the Disruptors are staring at her in confusion and disbelief. Blanc, however, is ignoring her and carefully watching them with an intense expression on his face. This foreshadows the revelation later in the story that [[spoiler:he's working with Helen to uncover which of the Disruptors murdered Andi, and he wants to see their reactions because he knows one of them thinks Andi is dead.]]

Top