Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / WhenHarryMetSally

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BechdelTest : Fails, rather spectacularly. Although on the [[WordOfGod commentary track]], Creator/RobReiner does point out that the main cast talks about things other than relationships, they just don't turn on the cameras during those conversations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Five years later, both of them re-meet after having been dumped by their other halves, and become friends. They resolve to [[JustFriends just be friends]]... for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatological humor and ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].

to:

Five years later, both of them they re-meet after having been dumped by their other halves, and become friends. They resolve to [[JustFriends just be friends]]... for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatological humor and ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ValuesDissonance: Harry mentions that she's keeping her maiden name (presumably for business purposes) during his engagement. This is clearly meant as foreshadowing since Helen's not that into Harry and will ditch him at the first opportunity. In a post-feminist world, taking your husband's last name isn't really a qualifier.

to:

** ValuesDissonance: Harry mentions that she's keeping her maiden name (presumably for business purposes) during his engagement. This is clearly meant as foreshadowing since Helen's not that into Harry and will ditch him at the first opportunity. In Twenty-five years later, a post-feminist world, taking your husband's last woman keeping her own name still isn't really that common, but it's not a qualifier.red flag.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Later used to even better effect with a ''four-way'' split screen call when Harry and Sally simultaneously call Jess and Marie.

to:

** Later used to even better effect with a ''four-way'' (three components, but four people, the middle two sharing a bed) split screen call when Harry and Sally simultaneously call Jess and Marie.

Added: 327

Changed: 268

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixing


-->'''Sally''': I'd like the chef salad, please, with the oil and vinegar on the side. And the apple pie a la mode. But I'd like the pie heated, and I don't want the ice cream on top, I want it on the side. And I'd like strawberry instead of vanilla if you have it. If not, then no ice cream, just whipped cream, but only if it's real. If it's out of a can, then nothing.

to:

-->'''Sally''': I'd like the chef salad, please, with the oil and vinegar on the side. And the apple pie a la mode. mode.
-->'''Waitress''' (writing): Chef and apple a la mode...
-->'''Sally''':
But I'd like the pie heated, and I don't want the ice cream on top, I want it on the side. And I'd like strawberry instead of vanilla if you have it. If not, then no ice cream, just whipped cream, but only if it's real. If it's out of a can, then nothing.



-->'''Sally''': No, then the pie, but not heated.

to:

-->'''Sally''': No, then just the pie, but then not heated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanMyopia: In-universe. [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Breslin Jimmy Breslin]] is pretty much the reason why Jess became a writer, but never mind.

Added: 618

Removed: 69

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* OvercomplicatedMenuOrder: Sally's EstablishingCharacterMoment is this order in a diner:
-->'''Sally''': I'd like the chef salad, please, with the oil and vinegar on the side. And the apple pie a la mode. But I'd like the pie heated, and I don't want the ice cream on top, I want it on the side. And I'd like strawberry instead of vanilla if you have it. If not, then no ice cream, just whipped cream, but only if it's real. If it's out of a can, then nothing.
-->'''Waitress''': Not even the pie?
-->'''Sally''': No, then the pie, but not heated.
* PrecisionFStrike: It's truly startling when Sally drops an F-bomb.



* PrecisionFStrike: It's truly startling when Sally drops an F-bomb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Five years later, both of them re-meet after having been dumped by their other halves, and become friends. They resolve to [[JustFriends just be friends]]... for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatalogical humor and ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].

to:

Five years later, both of them re-meet after having been dumped by their other halves, and become friends. They resolve to [[JustFriends just be friends]]... for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatalogical scatological humor and ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCameo: The director's mother Estelle Reiner as the "I'll have what she's having" woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The relationship Harry has with the younger woman is closer to a May-September romance. He\'s not drastically older than her.


* MayDecemberRomance: Harry's rebound girlfriend. Lampshaded, characteristically, by Harry himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Sally loudly fakes an orgasm in the middle of a restaurant, and a patron thinks something Sally ate was just that good.

Added: 332

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlliterativeName: Harry's ex, Helen Hillson.

to:

* AlliterativeName: Harry's ex, Helen Hillson.
** ValuesDissonance: Harry mentions that she's keeping her maiden name (presumably for business purposes) during his engagement. This is clearly meant as foreshadowing since Helen's not that into Harry and will ditch him at the first opportunity. In a post-feminist world, taking your husband's last name isn't really a qualifier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeadpanSnarker: Harry more than Sally, but Sally has her moments
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trivia


* ThrowItIn: Harry's weird accent in the museum. Meg Ryan's reaction is real; you can see her glance off-screen at Rob Reiner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Sally's habit of ordering belongs to Nora Ephron.

to:

** And Sally's habit of ordering belongs to Nora Ephron.Creator/NoraEphron.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Billy Crystal and Rob Reiner recently appeared in a [[RealTrailerFakeMovie spoof trailer]] on [=FunnyOrDie=].com for ''[[http://www.funnyordie.com/videos/0247468f28/when-harry-met-sally-2-with-billy-crystal-helen-mirren When Harry Met Sally 2]]'', where ExecutiveMeddling has turned a continuation of the original film into a shameless cashing in on the vampire craze.

to:

Billy Crystal and Rob Reiner director Creator/RobReiner recently appeared in a [[RealTrailerFakeMovie spoof trailer]] on [=FunnyOrDie=].com for ''[[http://www.funnyordie.com/videos/0247468f28/when-harry-met-sally-2-with-billy-crystal-helen-mirren When Harry Met Sally 2]]'', where ExecutiveMeddling has turned a continuation of the original film into a shameless cashing in on the vampire craze.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[DeadpanSnarker Harry Burns]] and [[WideEyedIdealist Sally Albright]] first meet when they share a drive from college in Chicago to NewYorkCity. He's seeing her friend Amanda and comes on to her; she turns him down and says they can be friends. He points out that if you're a guy, you will always be attracted to the female friend and want to sleep with her, thus they decide not to be friends. They revisit the question five years later when they are both taken and run into each other in an airport, once again resolving that no, they cannot.

to:

[[DeadpanSnarker Harry Burns]] and [[WideEyedIdealist Sally Albright]] first meet when they share a drive from college in Chicago to NewYorkCity. He's seeing her friend Amanda and comes on to her; she turns him down and but says they can be friends. He points out that if you're a guy, you the guy friend will always be attracted to the female friend and want to sleep with her, thus they decide not to be friends. They revisit the question five years later when they are both taken and run into each other in an airport, once again resolving that no, they cannot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* OralFixationFixation: Harry and his grape seeds. [*ptooey*]

to:

* OralFixationFixation: OralFixation: Harry and his grape seeds. [*ptooey*]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HypocriticalHumor: Sally can't recall the name of her room-mate in college. A scene later, she shames harry for forgetting her name, too.

to:

* HypocriticalHumor: Sally can't recall the name of her room-mate in college. A scene later, she shames harry Harry for forgetting her name, too.

Changed: 171

Removed: 533

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[DeadpanSnarker Harry Burns]] and [[WideEyedIdealist Sally Albright]] first meet when they ride from college to NewYorkCity. He's seeing her friend Amanda and comes on to her; she turns him down and says they can be friends. He points out that if you're a guy, you will always be attracted to the female friend and want to sleep with her, thus they decide not to be friends. They revisit the question five years later when they are both taken and run into each other in an airport, once again resolving that no, they cannot.

Five years later, both of them re-meet after having been dumped by their SO's, and become friends. While resolving to [[JustFriends just be friends]]...well for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatalogical humor, and ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].

In terms of the RomanticComedy genre, this movie's main contribution was its popularization of ContemplateOurNavels as a form of CharacterDevelopment and emotional connection- Harry and Sally are defined almost entirely by their interactions with each other. What external factors do exist they usually discuss with each other directly and personally.

Viewers familiar with the modern RomCom may be caught off-guard, as this movie lacks the HighConcept and HotterAndSexier tropes the genre is famous for. There's almost no sex or even provocative clothing. There's vastly more scenes of people in bed, alone, wearing pajamas and talking on the phone than getting their sex on. The "R" rating was likely due to the famed restaurant scene.

to:

[[DeadpanSnarker Harry Burns]] and [[WideEyedIdealist Sally Albright]] first meet when they ride share a drive from college in Chicago to NewYorkCity. He's seeing her friend Amanda and comes on to her; she turns him down and says they can be friends. He points out that if you're a guy, you will always be attracted to the female friend and want to sleep with her, thus they decide not to be friends. They revisit the question five years later when they are both taken and run into each other in an airport, once again resolving that no, they cannot.

Five years later, both of them re-meet after having been dumped by their SO's, other halves, and become friends. While resolving They resolve to [[JustFriends just be friends]]...well friends]]... for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatalogical humor, humor and ''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].

In terms of the RomanticComedy genre, this movie's main contribution was its popularization of ContemplateOurNavels as a form of CharacterDevelopment and emotional connection- connection -- Harry and Sally are defined almost entirely by their interactions with each other. What external factors do exist they usually discuss with each other directly and personally.

Viewers familiar with the modern RomCom may be caught off-guard, as this movie lacks the HighConcept and HotterAndSexier tropes the genre is famous for. There's almost no sex or even provocative clothing. There's vastly more scenes of people in bed, alone, wearing pajamas pyjamas and talking on the phone than getting their sex on. The "R" rating was likely due to the famed restaurant scene.
scene and couple of swearwords.



* SeventiesHair: Sally is sporting Farrah Hair in college.

to:

* SeventiesHair: Sally is sporting Farrah Hair hair in college.



** Harry may be alone and loveless on New Year's, but at least he can.... catch up on his window shopping?



* BrickJoke: In the 70s, Harry scoffs at the notion that Sally could ever have "great sex" with a guy named Sheldon. Guess [[GoMadFromTheRevelation who his wife leaves him for]]? [[spoiler:Ira.]]



* DangerTakesABackSeat: PlayedForLaughs on the plane, when Sally fails to escape Harry's facial recognition.

to:

* DangerTakesABackSeat: PlayedForLaughs on the plane, when Sally fails to escape Harry's facial recognition.



** Couple #4 is an inversion; they were born in the same building, worked in the same office, and never met once (until a fateful elevator ride).

to:

** Couple #4 is an inversion; they were born in the same building, worked in the same office, and never met once (until a fateful elevator ride).ride in another city).



** Also, Harry's confession that his dates always end with him desperate to yank on his clothes and flee out the door.

to:

** Also, Harry's confession that his dates always end with him desperate to yank on pull his clothes on and flee out the door.



-->"Mr. Kline died yesterday, leaving behind a wife, two children, and [[TheTriple a spacious three bedroom apartment with a wood burning fireplace]]."

to:

-->"Mr. -->"Mr Kline died yesterday, leaving behind a wife, two children, and [[TheTriple a spacious three bedroom apartment with a wood burning fireplace]]."



* TheGhost: Mr. Zero.



* HypocriticalHumor: Sally can't recall the name of her roommate in college. A scene later, she shames harry for forgetting her name, too.

to:

* HypocriticalHumor: Sally can't recall the name of her roommate room-mate in college. A scene later, she shames harry for forgetting her name, too.



** Jess and Marie promising not to ditch their dates... and then diving headfirst into the nearest cab.

to:

** Jess and Marie promising not to ditch their dates... and then diving headfirst head-first into the nearest cab.



--->"Buenos dias Senor Cleaver. Donde esta Wallace y Theodore?"
* InelegantBlubbering: Sally hearing the news of her ex's wedding engagement.

to:

--->"Buenos dias Senor Señor Cleaver. Donde ¿Donde esta Wallace y Theodore?"
* InelegantBlubbering: Sally hearing the news of her ex's wedding engagement.



** UptightLovesWild: A rare [[InvertedTrope inversion]] of this trope. Sally starts the film as a chaste Christian, while Harry is a greasy bohemian.



* SkunkStripe: The Asian gentleman's wife has this hairstyle.



* SoundtrackDissonance: Harry mistakingly sing a song from ''{{Theatre/Oklahoma}}'' in a department store, summoning his ex-wife and her boyfriend over. "Surry With a Fringe on Top" continues to blare over the awkward silence.

to:

* SoundtrackDissonance: Harry mistakingly sing mistakenly sings a song from ''{{Theatre/Oklahoma}}'' in a department store, summoning his ex-wife and her boyfriend over. "Surry With a Fringe on Top" continues to blare over the awkward silence.



'''Harry:''' An [[FunWithAcronyms L.M]]. Definitely

to:

'''Harry:''' An [[FunWithAcronyms L.M]].M. Definitely



* ThrowItIn: Harry's weird accent in the museum. Meg Ryan's reaction is real; you can see her glance offscreen at Rob Reiner.

to:

* ThrowItIn: Harry's weird accent in the museum. Meg Ryan's reaction is real; you can see her glance offscreen off-screen at Rob Reiner.



* YourCheatingHeart: Marie has a long-term affair with the married Arthur. Sally continually reminds her that Arthur is never going to leave his wife; Marie always admits to it, but a few scenes later, she's discussing him yet again...

to:

* YourCheatingHeart: Marie has a long-term affair with the married Arthur. Sally continually reminds her that Arthur is never going to leave his wife; Marie always admits to it, agrees, but a few scenes later, she's discussing him yet again...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IncrediblyLameFun: Battery-operated pith [[AdventurerOutfit helmet]]! [[AndADietCoke With fan.]]

to:

* IncrediblyLameFun: Battery-operated pith [[AdventurerOutfit pith helmet]]! [[AndADietCoke With fan.]]

Added: 440

Removed: 233

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdventurerOutfit: Battery-operated pith helmet. [[AndADietCoke With fan!]]
-->'''Sally:''' [wearing hat] [[IncrediblyLameFun Why is this necessary in life]]?\\
'''Harry:''' [[SlicesDicesAndMakesJulienneFries Also makes great fries.]]


Added DiffLines:

* IncrediblyLameFun: Battery-operated pith [[AdventurerOutfit helmet]]! [[AndADietCoke With fan.]]
-->'''Sally:''' [wearing hat] ''Why'' is this necessary in life?\\
'''Harry:''' [[SlicesDicesAndMakesJulienneFries Also makes great fries.]]
** Grieving over his ex, Harry finds himself watching reruns of ''LeaveItToBeaver'' on Telemundo. By his own admission, he's not a well man.
--->"Buenos dias Senor Cleaver. Donde esta Wallace y Theodore?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Later used to even better effect with a ''four-way'' split screen call when Harry and Sally simultaneously call Jess and Marie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking trope

Added DiffLines:

* StatusCellPhone: Harry has a fake plastic car phone, just so he can fake talking on it, to look rich and important when someone else is talking on theirs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Five years later, both of them re-meet after having been dumped by their SO's, and become friends. While resolving to [[JustFriends just be friends]]...well for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatalogical humor, and {{Casablanca}}. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].

to:

Five years later, both of them re-meet after having been dumped by their SO's, and become friends. While resolving to [[JustFriends just be friends]]...well for most of the movie they ''succeed'' in this. Their relationship has little sexual tension, and is punctuated by extended conversations where they discuss love, friendship, scatalogical humor, and {{Casablanca}}.''Film/{{Casablanca}}''. The {{Aesop}} seems to be that people really [[ThePowerOfFriendship need friendships]]- the nonsexual comfort zone Harry and Sally establish with each other is what allows them to move on from their failed relationships. To each other, in case you haven't [[ForegoneConclusion figured that out yet]].



* SeinfeldianConversation: Arguing over whether Ingrid Bergman should have stayed with Bogart in ''{{Casablanca}}''.

to:

* SeinfeldianConversation: Arguing over whether Ingrid Bergman should have stayed with Bogart in ''{{Casablanca}}''.''Film/{{Casablanca}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Joisey}}: In the doomed date with Maries, Harry reveals his birthplace: [[Franchise/{{Halloween}} Haddonfield]].

to:

* {{Joisey}}: In the During his doomed date with Maries, Marie, Harry reveals his birthplace: [[Franchise/{{Halloween}} Haddonfield]].



* MostWritersAreWriters: When Harry reveals that his wife's been cheating, Jess all but breaks the fourth wall. "I'm a writer, I ''know'' dialogue, and that was ''particularly'' harsh!"

to:

* MostWritersAreWriters: When After Harry reveals that his wife's been cheating, Jess all but breaks the fourth wall. "I'm a writer, I ''know'' know dialogue, and that was ''particularly'' harsh!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Joisey}}: In the doomed date with Maries, Harry reveals his birthplace: [[{{Film/Halloween}} Haddonfield]].

to:

* {{Joisey}}: In the doomed date with Maries, Harry reveals his birthplace: [[{{Film/Halloween}} [[Franchise/{{Halloween}} Haddonfield]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BreakUpMakeUpScenario

Changed: 23

Removed: 84

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForInconveniencePressOne: Harry parodies this in one of his apologetic voicemails.



'''Jess:''' NO ONE I KNOW WOULD CALL AT THIS HOUR!

to:

'''Jess:''' [[IRejectYourReality NO ONE I KNOW WOULD CALL AT THIS HOUR!HOUR!]]

Added: 863

Removed: 757

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FunnyAnsweringMachine: In reverse. Harry fills up Sally's machine with profuse apologies.
--> *beep* "Hi, it's me! It is the holiday season and I thought I'd just remind you that this is the season for charity and forgiveness. And although it's not widely known, it is also [[AintTooProudToBeg the season of groveling]]. So if you felt like calling me back, I'd be more than happy to do the traditional Christmas grovel."
** And in the next scene:
-->"The fact that you're not answering leads me to believe you're either [[ForInconveniencePressOne (a) not at home, (b) home but don't want to talk to me]], or [[BreadEggsMilkSquick (c) home, desperately want to talk to me, but trapped under something heavy]]. If it's either (a) or (c), please call me back."


Added DiffLines:

** Harry may be alone and loveless on New Year's, but at least he can.... catch up on his window shopping?


Added DiffLines:

* FunnyAnsweringMachine: In reverse. Harry fills up Sally's machine with profuse apologies.
--> *beep* "Hi, it's me! It is the holiday season and I thought I'd just remind you that this is the season for charity and forgiveness. And although it's not widely known, it is also [[AintTooProudToBeg the season of groveling]]. So if you felt like calling me back, I'd be more than happy to do the traditional Christmas grovel."
** And in the next scene:
-->"The fact that you're not answering leads me to believe you're either [[ForInconveniencePressOne (a) not at home, (b) home but don't want to talk to me]], or [[BreadEggsMilkSquick (c) home, desperately want to talk to me, but trapped under something heavy]]. If it's either (a) or (c), please call me back."

Top