Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / WhatEverHappenedToBabyJane

Go To

OR

Added: 252

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CarFu: [[spoiler:It turns out Jane didn't run over Blanche by accident. Instead, Blanche was the one driving the car and was trying to run over Jane, only to wreck out and cripple herself. She then convinced Jane that the whole thing was her fault.]]



** [[spoiler: Though she hides it better, Blanche is also quite petty: murdering her own sister out of pure sisterly rivalry, lying about it, and using that lie to abusively manipulate her own sister for ''decades'']].

to:

** [[spoiler: Though she hides it better, Blanche is also quite petty: murdering attempting to kill her own sister out of pure sisterly rivalry, lying about it, and using that lie to abusively manipulate her own sister for ''decades'']].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeautyInversion: Creator/BetteDavis happily did this to play Jane, as noted above. Creator/JoanCrawford on the other hand struggled to look unattractive for the role - wanting to have impeccable hair and make-up, despite being an invalid who hadn't left her room in twenty years. Although, in the book, it is mentioned multiple times that Blanche had aged gracefully and kept her good looks.

to:

* BeautyInversion: Creator/BetteDavis Creator/BetteDavis, who had aged very gracefully, happily did this to play Jane, as noted above. Creator/JoanCrawford on the other hand struggled to look unattractive for the role - wanting to have impeccable hair and make-up, despite being an invalid who hadn't left her room in twenty years. Although, in the book, it is mentioned multiple times that Blanche had aged gracefully and kept her good looks.



* IWasQuiteALooker: Jane was an angelic little girl and a reasonably attractive young woman but has now grown old and is a complete mess. In contrast, Blanche has aged well enough. [[spoiler: Weirdly enough, once she learns the truth from Blanche, her face brightens up a bit.]]

to:

* IWasQuiteALooker: Jane was an angelic little girl and a reasonably attractive young woman but has now grown old and is a complete mess.mess, mainly due to her excessive make-up and insistence on still dressing as she did as a child. In contrast, Blanche has aged well enough. [[spoiler: Weirdly enough, once she learns the truth from Blanche, her face brightens up a bit.]]



* LargeHam: Bette Davis' portrayal of Jane. Joan Crawford has a few moments too, resulting in HamToHamCombat.

to:

* LargeHam: Bette Davis' portrayal of Jane.Jane is really something and you can tell she's having the time of her life playing such a revolting character. Joan Crawford has a few moments too, resulting in HamToHamCombat.



* SmallNameBigEgo: Jane has no idea that "Baby Jane Hudson" has been totally forgotten, and thinks lots of people would love to see her make a comeback.

to:

* SmallNameBigEgo: Jane has no idea that "Baby Jane Hudson" has been totally forgotten, and thinks lots of people would love to see her make a comeback.comeback and believes herself to have been and still be a great talent than a mediocre singer and actress who only had one notable song.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on work content (Hays Code)


* AddedAlliterativeAppeal: The young Baby Jane Hudson is billed as "the diminutive dancing duse from Duluth".

to:

* AddedAlliterativeAppeal: The young Baby Jane Hudson is billed as "the diminutive dancing duse Duse [[note]]from legendary actress [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eleonora_Duse Eleanora Duse]] -- "Duse" became a kind of slang appellation describing actresses who were good at portraying intense emotion[[/note]] from Duluth".



* TakeOurWordForIt: We never find out what Jane wrote about Blanche on the envelope containing her fan letters, with Elvira only saying, "I can't remember the last time I saw words like that written down". (In 1962, it probably would've been impossible to say such words in a movie.)

to:

* TakeOurWordForIt: We never find out what Jane wrote about Blanche on the envelope containing her fan letters, with Elvira only saying, "I can't remember the last time I saw words like that written down". (In 1962, it probably would've been impossible to say such words in a movie. The Hays Code had been relaxed somewhat, but wouldn't be abolished until '68.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StockFootage: Clips from real Bette Davis movies ''Film/ParachuteJumper'' and ''Ex-Lady'' are used to show how Jane Hudson's attempt to make it as a grown-up actress went bad.

to:

* StockFootage: Clips from real Bette Davis movies ''Film/ParachuteJumper'' and ''Ex-Lady'' ''Film/ExLady'' are used to show how Jane Hudson's attempt to make it as a grown-up actress went bad.

Added: 224

Changed: 222

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing indentation (Too Dumb To Live)


* TooDumbToLive: [[spoiler:Elvira, despite knowing for a fact that Jane is mentally unstable, leaves a hammer within her reach and turns her back on her. She doesn't make it more than a few steps into Blanche's room before she's killed.]]

to:

* TooDumbToLive: [[spoiler:Elvira, despite TooDumbToLive:
** Elvira, [[spoiler:despite
knowing for a fact that Jane is mentally unstable, leaves a hammer within her reach and turns her back on her. She doesn't make it more than a few steps into Blanche's room before she's killed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambig


* DaylightHorror: [[spoiler:Blanche's presumed death, and Jane's final descent into madness,]] take place at a crowded beach on a sunny day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Goes double for Dominick in the remake, [[spoiler:who inexplicably stops helping Blanche to put down the scissors he's using to cut her free (positioning them on the bed in such a way that it's almost like he's trying to make it convenient for Jane to grab them), and who, unlike Elvira in the original film, had already seen Jane get physical with him while he was heading up the stairs, making his decision to turn his back to her and leave a sharp object within her reach even more baffling.]]

Added: 479

Removed: 479

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheUnfavorite: Blanche in the 1910s. Her father seems to openly dislike her and though her mother is kinder to her, she is largely overlooked. It's quite possible the roles are reversed when the sisters go to live with their aunt, who openly favors Blanche the same way their father favored Jane.



* TheUnfavorite: Blanche in the 1910s. Her father seems to openly dislike her and though her mother is kinder to her, she is largely overlooked. It's quite possible the roles are reversed when the sisters go to live with their aunt, who openly favors Blanche the same way their father favored Jane.



* VillainousBreakdown: Jane goes completely insane at the end, and when she's discovered by the police, and as a crowd gathers around her, she starts her old song-and-dance routine.



* VillainousBreakdown: Jane goes completely insane at the end, and when she's discovered by the police, and as a crowd gathers around her, she starts her old song-and-dance routine.

Added: 1317

Changed: -5

Removed: 1318

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwentyMinutesIntoThePast: The main portion of the film claims to be set "yesterday."

to:

* TwentyMinutesIntoThePast: The main portion of the film claims to be set "yesterday.""yesterday".



* DeathbedConfession: On the beach, [[spoiler:when Blanche thinks that she's dying, she tells Jane the truth about the car accident.]]



* DeadAnimalWarning: Jane begins denying Blanche food, until she serves Blanche's dead pet parakeet—and, at a later meal, a dead rat—to her on a dinner platter

to:

* DeadAnimalWarning: Jane begins denying Blanche food, until she serves Blanche's dead pet parakeet—and, at a later meal, a dead rat—to her on a dinner platterplatter.
* DeathbedConfession: On the beach, [[spoiler:when Blanche thinks that she's dying, she tells Jane the truth about the car accident.]]



* EvilAllAlong: [[spoiler:Blanche was endlessly bitter about the preferential treatment her sister got as a child. The situation only declined further when they were adults, as their careers were tied together. Every film Blanche made, one had to be made with Jane, and Jane couldn't act; meaning every flop Jane made damaged Blanche's career. Finally Blanche had enough, and tried to kill her sister, but ended up crippling herself. Blanche made it look like Jane was responsible; even Jane believed this, since she was drunk, and couldn't remember the night. Thus, she was forced to live with guilt for the rest of her life. Still bitter, Blanche forced her sister to wait on her hand and foot for thirty years before Jane loses her mind, and TheDogBitesBack.]]



* EvilAllAlong: [[spoiler:Blanche was endlessly bitter about the preferential treatment her sister got as a child. The situation only declined further when they were adults, as their careers were tied together. Every film Blanche made, one had to be made with Jane, and Jane couldn't act; meaning every flop Jane made damaged Blanche's career. Finally Blanche had enough, and tried to kill her sister, but ended up crippling herself. Blanche made it look like Jane was responsible; even Jane believed this, since she was drunk, and couldn't remember the night. Thus, she was forced to live with guilt for the rest of her life. Still bitter, Blanche forced her sister to wait on her hand and foot for thirty years before Jane loses her mind, and TheDogBitesBack.]]



* GoodColorsEvilColors: The fact that Jane is blonde and wears white, while Blanche has black hair and wears dark clothes, should be the first clue that all is not as it seems. It's especially noticeable because Blanche's name ''means'' "white."



* GoodColorsEvilColors: The fact that Jane is blonde and wears white, while Blanche has black hair and wears dark clothes, should be the first clue that all is not as it seems. It's especially noticeable because Blanche's name ''means'' "white".



* OneHitWonder: In-universe example: Jane with "I've Written a Letter to Daddy." [[invoked]] She did appear to have other songs, but that appeared to be her most requested one.


Added DiffLines:

* OneHitWonder: In-universe example: Jane with "I've Written a Letter to Daddy" [[invoked]] She did appear to have other songs, but that appeared to be her most requested one.

Added: 275

Changed: 98

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreyingMorality: The movie seems to be about a psychotic biddy tormenting her disabled disaster. [[spoiler: Than you learn that the disabled sister crippled herself while trying to kill her sister and spent years tormenting her, and the movie's tone changes quite a bit.]]



* IWasQuiteALooker: Jane was an angelic little girl and a reasonably attractive young woman but has now grown old and is a complete mess. In contrast, Blanche has aged well enough.

to:

* IWasQuiteALooker: Jane was an angelic little girl and a reasonably attractive young woman but has now grown old and is a complete mess. In contrast, Blanche has aged well enough. [[spoiler: Weirdly enough, once she learns the truth from Blanche, her face brightens up a bit.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Aging sisters Blanche (Crawford) and "Baby" Jane Hudson (Davis) live together in a decaying Hollywood mansion. Jane is a former {{vaudeville}} child star from the 1910s, but her fame disappeared a long time ago. Blanche, meanwhile, was a successful film actress in the '30s, but was crippled in a mysterious car accident involving Jane and in now confined to a wheelchair.

to:

Aging sisters Blanche (Crawford) and "Baby" Jane Hudson (Davis) live together in a decaying Hollywood mansion. Jane is a former {{vaudeville}} child star from the 1910s, but her fame disappeared a long time ago. Blanche, meanwhile, was a successful film actress in the '30s, but was crippled in a mysterious car accident involving Jane and in is now confined to a wheelchair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IntimateHairBrushing: In the remake, there's a PetTheDog moment between the sisters is when Blanche gets Jane to wash her hair and comb it. Unfortunately, Jane then starts [[TraumaticHaircut cutting it]].

to:

* IntimateHairBrushing: In the remake, there's a PetTheDog moment between the sisters is when Blanche gets Jane to wash her hair and comb it. Unfortunately, Jane then starts [[TraumaticHaircut cutting it]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RichSiblingPoorSibling: The movie has several reversals through a DeconReconSwitch that is at the heart of the story. First, Jane is the spoiled sister, as the beloved child star and vaudeville act while her sister Blanche is shy and reserved. Then, after Jane's act falls out of favor, she becomes TheAlcoholic and Blanche becomes an acclaimed prestige actress who leaves Jane totally in her shadow. Then it gets deconstructed after Blanche's car accident, when she is dependent on Jane, which Jane uses to torture Blanche and get her revenge.

to:

* RichSiblingPoorSibling: The movie has several reversals through a DeconReconSwitch that is at the heart of the story. First, Jane is the spoiled sister, as the beloved child star and vaudeville act while her sister Blanche is shy and reserved. Then, after Jane's act falls out of favor, she becomes TheAlcoholic and Blanche becomes an acclaimed prestige actress who leaves Jane totally in her shadow. Then it gets deconstructed after Blanche's car accident, when she is dependent on Jane, which Jane uses to torture Blanche and get her revenge. [[spoiler: And finally with the revelation that Blanche manipulated Jane into taking care of her as a cripple.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalHeroism: [[spoiler:As in the book, Blanche is revealed as the culprit behind the accident that crippled her. But the book also reveals that Blanche prevented Jane from seeking psychiatric help afterwards, worrying that she would remember what happened if she did. This is left out of the movie]].

to:

* AdaptationalHeroism: [[spoiler:As in the book, Blanche is revealed as the culprit behind the accident that crippled her. But the book also reveals that Blanche prevented Jane from seeking psychiatric help afterwards, worrying that she would remember what happened if she did. This is mostly left out of the movie]].movie (Blanche was still very reluctant to call the psychiatrist for Jane, but no particular explanation was given)]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwentyMinutesIntoThePast: The main portion of the film avoids giving a specific time date, only using "yesterday" as a scale of time.

to:

* TwentyMinutesIntoThePast: The main portion of the film avoids giving a specific time date, only using "yesterday" as a scale of time.claims to be set "yesterday."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TwentyMinutesIntoThePast: The main portion of the film avoids giving a specific time date, only using "yesterday" as a scale of time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StockFootage: Clips from real Bette Davis movies ''Film/ParachuteJumper'' and ''Ex-Lady'' are used to show how Jane Hudson's attempt to make it as a grown-up actress went bad.

Changed: 8

Removed: 806

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminumChristmasTrees: While "I've Written a Letter to Daddy" was invented for this movie, it's a parody of a very real song called [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uv7AaF1R534 "I Want A Pardon for Daddy"]], itself only one of a small universe of popular vaudeville tearjerkers written from the perspective of young children with dead/imprisoned parents, with titles such as "Roses On Mother's Grave" (the roses dear Mother tended with such care now decorate her grave), "The Empty Chair" (a list of all the chairs in which dear Father will never sit again), and "Mother Never Laughs Anymore" (the lyrics are unclear if Mother is grieving Father or if she stopped laughing because she herself is dead). Point being, "I've Written a Letter to Daddy" may be a parody, but it's ''barely'' an exaggeration.



* RaceLift: The cleaning lady in the book was a white woman called Edna. In the book, she's a Black woman called Elvira.

to:

* RaceLift: The cleaning lady in the book was a white woman called Edna. In the book, film, she's a Black woman called Elvira.

Top