Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / U571

Go To

OR

Changed: 5

Removed: 491

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No arguing in articles. And the Class XIV did NOT have weaponry, so they would have needed to identify a different boat


** The Enigma was cracked as early as 1928 by the Polish.
*** AN Enigma was cracked as early as that. 'The Enigma' is actually not one machine but a family of machines all employing the same basic mechanics/electronics and undergoing several upgrades and changes.

to:

** The An Enigma was cracked as early as 1928 by the Polish.
*** AN Enigma was cracked as early as that. 'The Enigma' is actually not one machine but a family of machines all employing the same basic mechanics/electronics and undergoing several upgrades and changes.
Polish.



** Which can also imply, conversely, that it wasn't a resupply boat to begin with, and was instead sent to ''destroy'' U-571 in the first place rather than help it. The crew could've just been ''told'' it was a resupply boat to prevent them from surrendering or defecting to the Allies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As much as I despise U571 and its inaccuracies, even the best soldiers breaking down under pressure has always happened and will always happen


** When captured U-Boat is being buzzed by a German plane, the order is given for everyone to act like they are the German crew and not raise any suspicion. The sailor manning the deck gun decides he is going to shoot the plane down and has to be physically restrained from doing so. A submarine crew, especially during WWII, are highly trained and disciplined to remain calm under fire and to immediately follow orders (think of Das Boot with the depth charges exploding around them). There is no way in hell a crewman would even think of disobeying orders in such a situation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Released in 2000, this UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]] Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago, though by “partly,” we mean “altered so much as to be unrecognizable.”

to:

Released in 2000, this UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships [[UsefulNotes/BritsWithBattleships British.]] Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago, though by “partly,” we mean “altered so much as to be unrecognizable.”

Changed: 71

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Released in 2000, this UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]] Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago.

to:

Released in 2000, this UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]] Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago.
Chicago, though by “partly,” we mean “altered so much as to be unrecognizable.”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Enigma machines were actually captured multiple times from U-Boats during the war, and one such action ''was'' accomplished by the US Navy, but the real event was nothing at all like the movie.


Added DiffLines:

* SpecialEffectsFailure: While the exterior sets and models for the modified ''S''-class sub and the Type-VII U-boats are decent enough, the film can’t seem to decide what class of destroyer they are facing, as that model switches between ''Narvik''- and ''Z-31''-class configurations between shots. Look for the forward guns flip-flopping between two single mounts and one twin mount.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RefugeInAudacity: When the captured U-571 is spotted by a German patrol plane, the Americans wave at it, just as German sailors would to friendly flyers. Since the Germans don't know the sub has been captured yet, it works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Messmen (later stewards) were the only black sailors allowed to serve on U.S. submarines during the war. Seventy-four black messmen/stewards went on "eternal patrol." EO9981, segregating the U.S. military, was issued in 1948.

to:

** Messmen (later stewards) were the only black sailors allowed to serve on U.S. submarines during the war. Seventy-four black messmen/stewards went on "eternal patrol." EO9981, segregating Executive Order 9981, desegregating the U.S. military, was issued in 1948.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Messmen (later stewards) were the only black sailors allowed to serve on U.S. submarines during the war. Seventy-four black messmen/stewards went on "eternal patrol." EO9981, segregating the U.S. military, was issued in 1948.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** For what it's worth, American veterans of the Battle of the Atlantic who saw the movie generally agreed with the British.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** AN Enigma was cracked as early as that. 'The Enigma' is actually not one machine but a family of machines all employing the same basic mechanics/electronics and undergoing several upgrades and changes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That said, in the film, [[EveryoneHasStandards the German captain seems to hold distaste for this policy]], [[PunchClockVillain and his men are just as unhappy as he is when he is forced to order them to murder the helpless survivors of a British ship they just sank.]]

to:

** That said, in the film, [[EveryoneHasStandards the German captain seems to hold distaste for this policy]], [[PunchClockVillain and his men are just as unhappy as he is when he is forced to order them they are ordered to murder the helpless survivors of a British ship they just sank.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That said, in the film, [[EveryoneHasStandards the German captain seems to hold distaste for this policy]], [[PunchClockVillain and his men are just as unhappy as he is when they are ordered to murder the helpless survivors of a British ship they just sank.]]

to:

** That said, in the film, [[EveryoneHasStandards the German captain seems to hold distaste for this policy]], [[PunchClockVillain and his men are just as unhappy as he is when they are ordered he is forced to order them to murder the helpless survivors of a British ship they just sank.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That said, in the film, [[EveryoneHasStandards the German captain seems to hold distaste for this policy]], [[PunchClockVillain and his men are just as unhappy as he is when they are ordered to murder the helpless survivors of a British ship they just sank.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added namespaces.


Released in 2000, this WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]] Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago.

to:

Released in 2000, this WorldWarII UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]] Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago.



* OldSoldier: Chief Gunner Klough, who served on submarines during WorldWarI.

to:

* OldSoldier: Chief Gunner Klough, who served on submarines during WorldWarI.UsefulNotes/WorldWarI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The real U-571 and S-33 didn't even operate in the same ocean as each other. In addition, the Germans never sent their destroyers that far west.



* [[CaptainObvious Chief Obvious]]: "Everything's in German!"



----

to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When captured U-Boat is being buzzed by a German plane, the order is given for everyone to act like they are the German crew and not raise any suspicion. The sailor manning the deck gun decides he is going to shoot the plane down and has to be physically restrained from doing so. A submarine crew, especially during WWII, are highly trained and disciplined to remain calm under fire and to immediately follow orders (think of Das Boot with the depth charges exploding around them). There is no way in hell a crewman would even think of disobeying orders in such a situation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericaWonWorldWarII - [[invoked]] Infamously so. In RealLife, the Enigma Machine ''was'' stolen from a German submarine... by the British.

to:

* AmericaWonWorldWarII - AmericaWonWorldWarII: [[invoked]] Infamously so. In RealLife, the Enigma Machine ''was'' stolen from a German submarine... by the British.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: There's more examples of this than you can shake a stick at, but one stands out to those familiar with military history. The cook on board the sub is a black man. This would not have occurred during World War II, as the armed forces were not desegregated until 1947. However, the filmmakers may have been aware of this and simply chose to ignore it. Extra credit has to be given to them for portraying him as a intelligent and capable individual, who takes over the sub's helm when the regular helmsman is killed, and never gives in to panic or fear. Also, he's treated as an equal by everyone on board, with absolutely no hint of racism from anyone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
America Wins The War has been renamed because of Missing Supertrope Syndrome. Misuse and Zero Context Examples will be cut.


* AmericaWinsTheWar - [[invoked]] Infamously so. In RealLife, the Enigma Machine ''was'' stolen from a German submarine... by the British.

to:

* AmericaWinsTheWar AmericaWonWorldWarII - [[invoked]] Infamously so. In RealLife, the Enigma Machine ''was'' stolen from a German submarine... by the British.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"They did get one thing right: there were U-boats in the North Atlantic turning the war."''

to:

->''"They did get one thing right: there were U-boats in the North Atlantic turning during the war."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''"They did get one thing right: there were U-boats in the North Atlantic turning the war."''
-->-- A former German U-boat commander's reaction to the film
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Germany exported civilian versions of the Enigma machine in 1930s. British government had a few of these even before the war began.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grammar Nazi at work


* FalseFlagOperation: In addition to boarding the ship, they have to pretend to be Germans in order to avoid being attacked by German forces in the area. At one point this involves cheerfully waving at a Messerschmidt fighter that spots them and makes a low pass.

to:

* FalseFlagOperation: In addition to boarding the ship, they have to pretend to be Germans in order to avoid being attacked by German forces in the area. At one point this involves cheerfully waving at a Messerschmidt Messerschmitt fighter that spots them and makes a low pass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Released in 2000, this WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]] (Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago.

to:

Released in 2000, this WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]] (Although Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Generally, a submarine could not be within of a destroyer without getting ripped to shreds.

to:

* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Generally, a submarine could not be within short range of a destroyer without getting ripped to shreds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Released in 2000, this WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the mission was carried out by the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]]

to:

Released in 2000, this WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the mission first to capture the submarine-based ENIGMA machine was carried out by the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]]
]] (Although the film is also partly based on the American action that led to the capture of the U-Boat now on display at the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved to ymmv


** Many have stated the film could have been better had it been about the historical capture of U-505 by American forces.

Added: 57

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Enigma was cracked as early as 1928 by the Polish.



* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Generally, a submarine could not be within 1000 meters of a destroyer without getting ripped to shreds.

to:

* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Generally, a submarine could not be within 1000 meters within of a destroyer without getting ripped to shreds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FalseFlagOperation: In addition to boarding the ship, they have to pretend to be Germans in order to avoid being attacked by German forces in the area. At one point this involves cheerfully waving at a Messerschmidt fighter that spots them and makes a low pass.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:275:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/u571_poster_9058.jpg]]

Released in 2000, this WorldWarII movie VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory is about a submarine crew who board a disabled German sub to [[ReadingTheEnemysMail steal an Enigma Machine]], a secret German encryption device used to send coded messages. Caused a degree of controversy as the film places the [[AmericaSavesTheDay Americans in center role as the heroes...]] except that in real life, the mission was carried out by the [[BritsWithBattleships British.]]

----
!!This film provides examples of:

* AmericaWinsTheWar - [[invoked]] Infamously so. In RealLife, the Enigma Machine ''was'' stolen from a German submarine... by the British.
** As can be expected, this did cause one hell of an uproar in the UK, to the point it was called "An Affront to British Sailors" during Prime Ministers Question Time upon release!
** Many have stated the film could have been better had it been about the historical capture of U-505 by American forces.
* BangingForHelp: A captured prisoner uses a wrench to knock out a message in [[EveryoneKnowsMorse Morse Code]] for other German ships to hear on Sonar: [[spoiler: I am U-571... destroy me!]]
* CallingTheOldManOut: Rather early in the film, [[YouAreInCommandNow Lieutenant Tyler]] gets this from [[OldSoldier Chief Gunner Klough]], for admitting to his crew that he didn't know what to do next, thus undermining his own crew's confidence in his leadership.
** Also, the beginning of the film: Tyler is itching for a command of his own, and knows that the only thing that could stop him from being promoted and getting it is if his current CO doesn't recommend him. When he is passed over he seeks his CO out and demands to know why.
* TheChainsOfCommanding: The reason Lt. Tyler doesn't get his first command is that his commander doesn't think he's ready for the burdens of that responsibility. Of course, Tyler [[YouAreInCommandNow ends up bearing that responsibility unexpectedly.]]
* CunningLinguist: Two of them in this film, including a professional linguist and a sailor who is half German.
* DarkSecret: Mild example. One of the American sailors doesn't want his crewmates to know he's half German.
* DressingAsTheEnemy: How the crew gets aboard the ''U-571''.
* EveryoneKnowsMorse: Justified. On a WWII warship, everyone did.
* HollywoodHistory: Very, very much so.
* HotSubOnSubAction: Of a preposterous nature. The German boat that sinks the American sub is stated as being a resupply boat. The Type XIV "Milchkuh" (or "milk cow") did not even have torpedo tubes.
** Which can also imply, conversely, that it wasn't a resupply boat to begin with, and was instead sent to ''destroy'' U-571 in the first place rather than help it. The crew could've just been ''told'' it was a resupply boat to prevent them from surrendering or defecting to the Allies.
* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Generally, a submarine could not be within 1000 meters of a destroyer without getting ripped to shreds.
* OldSoldier: Chief Gunner Klough, who served on submarines during WorldWarI.
* ReadingTheEnemysMail
* SinkTheLifeBoats: To prove how evil the German U-boat crew is. In reality, out of the tens of thousands of hours logged by the U-boat Force, there is only one recorded incident of a crew attacking survivors. It was much more common for German submariners to provide aide to the crews they sank.
* YouAreInCommandNow: Lieutenant Tyler, when his submarine is torpedoed and sunk, while he is leading a boarding party on the U-571.
----

Top