Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheWhale

Go To

OR

Added: 1124

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BreakTheCutie: Charlie has a lot of these moments, but two stand out in particular -- when his wife confronts him and when the pizza delivery man notices him.



* EveryoneHasStandards: Mary isn't exactly the sweetest person around, but she nonetheless won't shame Charlie over his partner's demise.
* ExtremeDoormat: Charlie seems rather tolerant of Ellie's behavior towards him, not saying a word when she openly insults and torments him.



* GoodCannotComprehendEvil: Charlie seems to be in denial over Ellie's nasty behavior, claiming she does have some goodness in her.



* JerkassHasAPoint: While it still doesn't justify her horrible behavior, Ellie's resentment towards Charlie is rather understandable given the latter abandoned her alongside her mother when she was only a child. Charlie admits that he was wrong.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: While it still doesn't justify her horrible behavior, Ellie's resentment towards Charlie is rather understandable given the latter abandoned her alongside her mother when she was only a child. Charlie admits that he was wrong.


Added DiffLines:

* SpringtimeForHitler: {{Implied|Trope}}. [[spoiler:Ellie reports Thomas' secret to the latter's family. In turn, they manage to reconcile with Thomas through forgiveness. Given her attitude throughout most of the film, it seems to have been an unsuccessful attempt in humiliating him.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TroublingUnchildlikeBehavior: Ellie, a 17-year-old high school student, is shown smoking and stealing pills from her mother to get high.


Added DiffLines:

* UsedToBeASweetChild: Ellie appears to have been much sweeter as a child, based on the flashbacks and Charlie's monologues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TeensAreMonsters: Ellie exemplifies this trope. She has severe behavioral issues, including cyberbullying, drug use, and blackmailing. She was even suspended from school for her behavior, and her grades have suffered as a result. The [[FreudianExcuse main cause]] of this is [[DisappearedDad Charlie's]] [[ParentalAbandonment abandonment]] when she was a child.

to:

* TeensAreMonsters: Ellie exemplifies this trope. She has severe behavioral issues, including cyberbullying, drug use, and blackmailing. She was even suspended from school for her behavior, and her grades have suffered as a result. The [[FreudianExcuse main cause]] of this is [[DisappearedDad Charlie's]] [[ParentalAbandonment abandonment]] when she was a child.



-->'''Charlie:''' I need to know that I have done ''one'' right thing with my life!

to:

-->'''Charlie:''' --->'''Charlie:''' I need to know that I have done ''one'' right thing with my life!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:''"I need to know that I have done '''one''' right thing with my life!"'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''"I need to know [[caption-width-right:350:''"Do you ever get the feeling that I have done '''one''' right thing with my life!"'']]people are incapable of not caring? People are amazing."'']]



->''"Do you ever get the feeling that people are incapable of not caring? People are amazing."''

to:

->''"Do you ever get the feeling that people are incapable of not caring? People are amazing.->''"[[Literature/MobyDick This book]] made me think about my own life, and then it made me feel glad for my..."''

Added: 207

Removed: 207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PottyEmergency: When Liz first arrives, Charlie says he desperately has to go to the bathroom because he's been "holding it in all day" because how difficult it is to move even short distances at his size.



* PottyEmergency: When Liz first arrives, Charlie says he desperately has to go to the bathroom because he's been "holding it in all day" because how difficult it is to move even short distances at his size.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TeensAreMonsters: Ellie exemplifies this trope. According to her mother, she frequently got into trouble at school for severe behavioral issues. She is also incredibly hostile and aggressive towards Charlie when she visits him at his apartment complex.

to:

* TeensAreMonsters: Ellie exemplifies this trope. According to her mother, she frequently got into trouble at school for She has severe behavioral issues. issues, including cyberbullying, drug use, and blackmailing. She is also incredibly hostile was even suspended from school for her behavior, and aggressive towards Charlie her grades have suffered as a result. The [[FreudianExcuse main cause]] of this is [[DisappearedDad Charlie's]] [[ParentalAbandonment abandonment]] when she visits him at his apartment complex. was a child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mary is also very unsympathetic towards Charlie, but is a prescription pill addict and [[TheAlcoholic alcoholic]] who is also at best a struggling and overwhelmed mother.
** Thomas preaches the word of God to Charlie and encourages him to repent for his "sin" (his sexuality) but is estranged from his own church and family due to stealing money and being seemingly addicted to weed, even falling OffTheWagon when he's with Ellie.

to:

** Mary is also very unsympathetic towards Charlie, but she is a prescription pill addict and [[TheAlcoholic alcoholic]] who is also also, at best best, a struggling and overwhelmed mother.
mother.
** Thomas preaches the word of God to Charlie and encourages him to repent for his "sin" (his sexuality) sexuality), but he is estranged from his own church and family due to stealing money and being seemingly addicted to weed, even falling OffTheWagon when he's with Ellie. Ellie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BullyingTheDisabled: Ellie constantly treats her morbidly obese father like dirt. At one point, she moves his wheelchair to force him to get up despite his inability to do so.

to:

* BullyingTheDisabled: Ellie constantly frequently treats her morbidly obese father like dirt. At one point, she moves pushes his wheelchair to force him to get so that he must stand up despite his inability to do so. even though he is unable to.



* KickTheDog: Ellie has a lot of these moments towards Charlie, such as telling him it's ''better off'' that his online students don't know what he looks like and spiking him with drugs to incapacitate him.

to:

* KickTheDog: Ellie frequently has a lot of these moments towards with Charlie, such as including telling him it's ''better off'' that his online students don't know what he looks like pupils are unaware of his appearance and spiking him with drugs to incapacitate him.

Added: 263

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrugglingSingleMother: Although it isn't explicitly shown, it is made clear that Mary has been struggling to care for Ellie since Charlie's absence. It doesn't help that Ellie directs her anger and hostility towards her as much as she does with everyone else.



* TeensAreMonsters: Ellie exemplifies this trope. According to her mother, she had frequently gotten in trouble at school for serious behavioral issues. She is also incredibly hostile and aggressive towards Charlie when she visits him at his apartment complex.

to:

* TeensAreMonsters: Ellie exemplifies this trope. According to her mother, she had frequently gotten in got into trouble at school for serious severe behavioral issues. She is also incredibly hostile and aggressive towards Charlie when she visits him at his apartment complex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FatSlob: PlayedForDrama and {{Deconstructed|Trope}}. Even though he's aware of his horrendous health, Charlie continues to binge eat at excessive amounts instead of taking proper care of himself at the insistence of Liz. His obesity and binge eating is depicted as [[FreudianExcuse a coping mechanism to the immense trauma he has faced in his life.]] The "slob" part is also downplayed in that, outside of his eating habits, he does put ''some'' effort into taking care of himself and his appearance, such as shaving and showering.

to:

* FatSlob: PlayedForDrama and {{Deconstructed|Trope}}. Even though he's aware of his horrendous health, Charlie continues to binge eat at excessive amounts instead of taking proper care of himself at the insistence of Liz. His obesity and binge eating is depicted as [[FreudianExcuse a coping mechanism to the immense trauma he has faced in his life.]] life]]. The "slob" part is also downplayed in that, outside of his eating habits, he does put ''some'' effort into taking care of himself and his appearance, such as shaving and showering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BullyingTheDisabled: Ellie constantly treats her morbidly obese father like dirt. At one point, she moves his wheelchair to force him to get up despite his inability to do so.


Added DiffLines:

* KickTheDog: Ellie has a lot of these moments towards Charlie, such as telling him it's ''better off'' that his online students don't know what he looks like and spiking him with drugs to incapacitate him.


Added DiffLines:

* TeensAreMonsters: Ellie exemplifies this trope. According to her mother, she had frequently gotten in trouble at school for serious behavioral issues. She is also incredibly hostile and aggressive towards Charlie when she visits him at his apartment complex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Hikikomori}}: Charlie never leaves his apartment and has as few social connections as possible. Prior to the start of the film, his only social contacts are Liz and his online students, whom he teaches with his camera disconnected. He asks the pizza delivery man to simply leave the pizzas outside his door and take money from the mailbox so he won't see him. His social circle only expands at the start of the film when [[TheMissionary Thomas]] drops by, and when he tries to [[MustMakeAmmends reconnect with his daughter]] after Liz tells him he's dying.

to:

* {{Hikikomori}}: Charlie never leaves his apartment and has as few social connections as possible. Prior to the start of the film, his only social contacts are Liz and his online students, whom he teaches with his camera disconnected. He asks the pizza delivery man to simply leave the pizzas outside his door and take money from the mailbox so he won't see him. His social circle only expands at the start of the film when [[TheMissionary Thomas]] drops by, and when he tries to [[MustMakeAmmends [[MustMakeAmends reconnect with his daughter]] after Liz tells him he's dying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Hikikomori}}: Charlie never leaves his apartment and has as few social connections as possible. Prior to the start of the film, his only social contacts are Liz and his online students, whom he teaches with his camera disconnected. He asks the pizza delivery man to simply leave the pizzas outside his door and take money from the mailbox so he won't see him. His social circle only expands at the start of the film when [[TheMissionary Thomas]] drops by, and when he tries to reconnect with his daughter after Liz tells him he probably has less than a week to live.

to:

* {{Hikikomori}}: Charlie never leaves his apartment and has as few social connections as possible. Prior to the start of the film, his only social contacts are Liz and his online students, whom he teaches with his camera disconnected. He asks the pizza delivery man to simply leave the pizzas outside his door and take money from the mailbox so he won't see him. His social circle only expands at the start of the film when [[TheMissionary Thomas]] drops by, and when he tries to [[MustMakeAmmends reconnect with his daughter daughter]] after Liz tells him he probably has less than a week to live.he's dying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GodIsEvil: Charlie tells Thomas that this was his conclusion after reading Literature/TheBible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BuryYourGays: Charlie's ex-boyfriend is said to have killed himself over religious guilt after being expelled from his family/church for his relationship with Charlie, and Charlie himself is very slowly killing himself via over-eating. [[spoiler:And he likely dies at the end of the movie]].

to:

* BuryYourGays: Charlie's ex-boyfriend late boyfriend Alan is said to have killed himself over religious guilt after being expelled from his family/church for his relationship with Charlie, and Charlie himself is very slowly killing himself via over-eating.overeating. [[spoiler:And he likely dies at the end of the movie]].



* DrivenToSuicide: Charlie's boyfriend, Liz's brother, after being outcast from their church, and Charlie himself might be said to indulge in a form of this by overeating.

to:

* DrivenToSuicide: Alan, Charlie's boyfriend, late boyfriend and Liz's brother, after being outcast cast out from their church, and church. Charlie himself might appears to be said to indulge indulging in a form of this by overeating. overeating and refusing to seek medical care.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film leaves it open for interpretation whether [[spoiler:Charlie dies at the end of the movie. It certainly doesn't look good for him, but it's also possible his ascension is metaphorical.]]

to:

** The film leaves it open for interpretation whether [[spoiler:Charlie dies at the end of the movie. It certainly doesn't look good for him, but it's also possible his ascension is metaphorical.metaphorical and what flies away at the end is his guilt.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:''"I need to know that I did '''one''' right thing with my life!"'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''"I need to know that I did have done '''one''' right thing with my life!"'']]



-->'''Charlie:''' I need to know that I did ''one'' thing right with my life!

to:

-->'''Charlie:''' I need to know that I did have done ''one'' right thing right with my life!

Changed: 108

Removed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[caption-width-right:350:''"I need to know that I did '''one''' right thing with my life!"'']]



-->--'''Charlie'''

to:

-->--'''Charlie'''
-->-- '''Charlie'''




-----

to:

\n---------



-->'''Charlie:''' I need to know that I've done ''one'' thing right with my life!

to:

-->'''Charlie:''' I need to know that I've done I did ''one'' thing right with my life!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UncertainDoom: [[spoiler:Charlie at the end of the film. The final scene , in which he finally stands up on his own, walks towards Ellie, is bathed in light coming in from the outside, has a flashback to a happy visit to the beach, and then physically lifts off the ground, could very well indicate that he dies, but it's not made certain]].

to:

* UncertainDoom: [[spoiler:Charlie at the end of the film. The final scene , scene, in which he finally stands up on his own, walks towards Ellie, is bathed in light coming in from the outside, has a flashback to a happy visit to the beach, and then physically lifts off the ground, could very well indicate that he dies, but it's not made certain]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
reverting edit war by striking a medium between the two versions


* DoubleMeaningTitle: The film begins and ends with the reading of an essay about Literature/MobyDick, and "whale" is a common slur used against fat people like Charlie.

to:

* DoubleMeaningTitle: The film ''The Whale'' begins and ends with the reading of an essay about Literature/MobyDick, and ''Literature/MobyDick'', but it also references Charlie himself, as "whale" is a common slur can be used against fat people like Charlie.as a rude term for obese people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotAfraidToDie: When Liz tells him his heart is failing, Charlie simply shrugs it off and says he'd better get to work; he has a lot of essays to grade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Using the word "whale" to describe a fat person, no matter how fat they are, inherently dehumanizes fat people by comparing them to animals. More information here and here.


* DoubleMeaningTitle: The film begins and ends with the reading of an essay about Literature/MobyDick, but it also references Charlie himself, who is large enough to be labelled a "whale".

to:

* DoubleMeaningTitle: The film begins and ends with the reading of an essay about Literature/MobyDick, but it also references Charlie himself, who and "whale" is large enough to be labelled a "whale".common slur used against fat people like Charlie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser, plays the disheveled and slovenly Charlie. Even though Charlie only stopped caring about his appearance after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was not particularly good-looking beforehand.

to:

* BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser, Fraser plays the disheveled and slovenly Charlie. Even though Charlie only stopped caring about his appearance after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was not particularly good-looking beforehand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Being fat, even as fat as Charlie, does not automatically translate to being ugly.


* BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser, who has a normal, somewhat heavy build, plays the obese, balding, and slovenly Charlie. Even though the weight gain happened mostly after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was always quite large and was not particularly good looking beforehand.

to:

* BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser, who has a normal, somewhat heavy build, plays the obese, balding, disheveled and slovenly Charlie. Even though the weight gain happened mostly Charlie only stopped caring about his appearance after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was always quite large and was not particularly good looking good-looking beforehand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
duplicate trope name


* BeautyInversion: BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser, who has a normal, somewhat heavy build, plays the obese, balding, and slovenly Charlie. Even though the weight gain happened mostly after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was always quite large and was not particularly good looking beforehand.

to:

* BeautyInversion: BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser, who has a normal, somewhat heavy build, plays the obese, balding, and slovenly Charlie. Even though the weight gain happened mostly after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was always quite large and was not particularly good looking beforehand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LettingHerHairDown: Both Liz and Ellie wear their hair up or back for the majority of the film. Their key moments [[spoiler: involving reconciling with Charlie as he appears to die]] have their hair being down for the first time.

to:

* LettingHerHairDown: Both Liz and Ellie wear their hair up or back for the majority of the film. Their key moments [[spoiler: involving [[spoiler:involving reconciling with Charlie as he appears to die]] have their hair being down for the first time.



* UncertainDoom: [[spoiler: Charlie at the end of the film. The final scene , in which he finally stands up on his own, walks towards Ellie, is bathed in light coming in from the outside, has a flashback to a happy visit to the beach, and then physically lifts off the ground, could very well indicate that he dies, but it's not made certain]].
* UnseenNoMore:

to:

* UncertainDoom: [[spoiler: Charlie [[spoiler:Charlie at the end of the film. The final scene , in which he finally stands up on his own, walks towards Ellie, is bathed in light coming in from the outside, has a flashback to a happy visit to the beach, and then physically lifts off the ground, could very well indicate that he dies, but it's not made certain]].
* UnseenNoMore: UnseenNoMore:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
reverting some agenda-based edits


* BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser plays the disheveled and slovenly Charlie. Even though the weight gain happened mostly after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was always quite large and was not particularly good looking beforehand.

to:

* BeautyInversion: BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser Fraser, who has a normal, somewhat heavy build, plays the disheveled obese, balding, and slovenly Charlie. Even though the weight gain happened mostly after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was always quite large and was not particularly good looking beforehand.



* DoubleMeaningTitle: The film begins and ends with the reading of an essay about Literature/MobyDick, and "whale" is a common slur used against fat people like Charlie.

to:

* DoubleMeaningTitle: The film begins and ends with the reading of an essay about Literature/MobyDick, and "whale" but it also references Charlie himself, who is large enough to be labelled a common slur used against fat people like Charlie."whale".

Added: 1572

Changed: 163

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAlcoholic: Mary, Charlie's ex and Ellie's mother, is stated to be a functional alcoholic. After the drama involving Ellie and the money, Mary finds a bottle in Charlie's cupboard and starts drinking from it.



* BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser plays the disheveled and slovenly Charlie.

to:

* BeautyInversion: The handsome and well-groomed Brendan Fraser plays the disheveled and slovenly Charlie. Even though the weight gain happened mostly after Alan's death, Charlie maintains that he was always quite large and was not particularly good looking beforehand.


Added DiffLines:

* ChekhovsSkill: Early on, Ellie says that she never forgets anything. [[spoiler: At the end, when we find out the significance of the ''Moby Dick'' analysis, she instantly remembers it as something she wrote years ago]].


Added DiffLines:

* CreatorThumbprint: Several themes from the director's previous works appear.
** [[Film/TheWrestler A middle-aged man estranged from his daughter, who is implied to be a lesbian.]] In this case, the roles are switched around, where the daughter is the less sympathetic one.
** [[Film/TheFountain A character dying of an illness with an interest in classic literature, who desperately tries to get a family member to read something that ties into that]]. This time, it's from the point of view of the former.
** [[spoiler: An ending in which [[Film/BlackSwan the protagonist appears to die but does so as they achieve something difficult]].]] This time, it's slightly more uplifting.


Added DiffLines:

* LettingHerHairDown: Both Liz and Ellie wear their hair up or back for the majority of the film. Their key moments [[spoiler: involving reconciling with Charlie as he appears to die]] have their hair being down for the first time.


Added DiffLines:

* MostWritersAreWriters: Although Charlie is a teacher, he teaches classes on literature, and is obsessed with helping Ellie improve her grades in English. He also has a fascination with an analysis of ''Literature/MobyDick''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrutalHonesty: Charlie repeatedly asks people for honesty. He characterizes Ellie's rudeness as honesty, and his final assignment to his class is to write something honest. He reads aloud several rather depressing submissions, impressed by the uninhibited honesty.

Top