Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheNightingale2019

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousEnding: A lot is left up in the air when the film ends. [[spoiler:Billy is presumably dying of his wounds, but we last see him sitting on the beach looking at the sunrise. It's anyone guess as to what happens to Clare next. She has no papers, no job prospects and no cash, though she does have a horse. She might be wanted for accessory to murder]].

to:

* AmbiguousEnding: A lot is left up in the air when the film ends. [[spoiler:Billy is presumably dying of his wounds, but we last see him sitting on the beach looking at the sunrise. It's anyone guess as to what happens to Clare next. She has no papers, no job prospects and no cash, though (though she does have a horse. She might be horse), and she could very well be wanted for accessory to murder]].



* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Clare gets her revenge but her family is still dead and Billy is now mortally wounded.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Clare gets her revenge revenge, but her family is still dead and dead, she hasn't been freed, and Billy is now mortally is heavily wounded.]] ]]



* DontGoInTheWoods: At least not without a NativeGuide. And [[spoiler: when Clare is separated from Billy]] it shows that she wouldn't have lasted long without him.
* EvenEvilHasStandards: Private Jago, despite being idiotic and cruel, didn't mean to kill Clare's baby, didn't rape her or poor Lowanna and is clearly haunted by his actions. [[spoiler: Still did quite deserve his death.]]

to:

* DontGoInTheWoods: At least not without a NativeGuide. And [[spoiler: when Clare is separated from Billy]] Billy,]] it shows that she wouldn't have lasted long without him.
* EvenEvilHasStandards: Private Jago, despite being idiotic and cruel, didn't mean to kill Clare's baby, didn't rape her or poor Lowanna and is clearly haunted by his actions. [[spoiler: Still did quite deserve That being said, his death.death at Clare's hands is still very much deserved.]]



* FaceDeathWithDignity: [[spoiler:Mortally wounded at the end, Billy can only celebrate joyously as the LastOfHisKind at having struck a blow against the English.]]

to:

* FaceDeathWithDignity: [[spoiler:Mortally [[spoiler:Badly wounded at the end, Billy can only celebrate joyously as the LastOfHisKind at having struck a blow against the English.]]



* IHaveYouNowMyPretty: Horrific example. A native woman named Lowanna is snatched from the woods by Ruse simply because he's never slept with "one of them" before. Hawkins goes along with it when Ruse offers to allow him to go first.

to:

* IHaveYouNowMyPretty: Horrific example. A particularly horrible example happens to a native woman named Lowanna is snatched Lowanna, who is snatched from the woods by Ruse simply because he's never slept with "one of them" before. Hawkins goes along with it when Ruse offers to allow him to go first.



* KickTheDog: Hawkins is already a rapist and scumbag, but when little Eddie can't shoot a man, Hawkins abandons him, after having seemingly treated him with kindness, threatening to add five years to Eddie's prison sentence just out of callous spite.

to:

* KickTheDog: Hawkins is already a rapist and scumbag, but when little Eddie can't shoot a man, Hawkins abandons him, after having seemingly treated him with kindness, threatening to add five years to Eddie's prison sentence just out of callous spite. When he continues to cry even more, Hawkins just shoots him in the chest and leaves him to die.



* LastOfHisKind: [[spoiler: Billy/Mangana later learns from Portmairremener people in chain that he is the last of Linetemairrener people.]]

to:

* LastOfHisKind: [[spoiler: Billy/Mangana later learns from some Portmairremener people in chain chains that he is the last of Linetemairrener people.the Linetemairrener.]]



* PanUpToTheSkyEnding: The ending pans up to a dawning sun [[spoiler: meaning a new beginning for the protagonist.]]

to:

* PanUpToTheSkyEnding: The ending pans up to a dawning sun [[spoiler: meaning sun, [[spoiler:marking a new beginning for the protagonist.]]



** Of the three soldiers, [[spoiler: Jago]] is probably the most moral and the least guilty for what happened to Aidan (although he is the one who [[spoiler: kills the baby, although he is remorseful]]). Of the three, his death is by far the most brutal and drawn out (because Clare's gun fails her and she has to resort to beating him with the butt, then stabbing him with his own knife). Doing this also causes Clare to have nightmares where [[spoiler: Jago]] chases her around the woods with a bloody mutilated face.

to:

** Of the three soldiers, [[spoiler: Jago]] is probably the most moral and the least guilty for what happened to Aidan (although (while he is the one who [[spoiler: kills the baby, although he is remorseful]]).baby, he's visibly remorseful]]). Of the three, his death is by far the most brutal and drawn out (because Clare's gun fails her and she has to resort to beating him with the butt, then stabbing him with his own knife). Doing this also causes Clare to have nightmares where [[spoiler: Jago]] chases her around the woods with a bloody mutilated face.



* ReassignedToAntarctica: Australia in the 19th century might as well be Antarctica. Clare and her husband are former criminals who are sent there for forced labor. It's an undesirable post for the English soldiers stationed there as well. Hawkins is enraged that he's been stuck there for three years.

to:

* ReassignedToAntarctica: Australia in the 19th century might as well be Antarctica. Clare and her husband are former criminals who are sent there for forced labor. It's an undesirable post for the English soldiers stationed there as well. well, and Hawkins in particular is enraged that he's been stuck there for three years. years.



* RegencyEngland: Although it's set in Australia 1825 (at that time a British colony), the fashions and military uniforms match this era.

to:

* RegencyEngland: Although it's set in Australia 1825 (at 1820s Australia (at that time a British colony), the fashions and military uniforms match this era.



* SceneryPorn: Both played straight and {{averted}}. The movie was filmed in the Tazmanian wilderness, so there's a lot of striking plant life around, but it was also shot in the unusual 4:3 aspect ratio, which tends to focus the eye on the characters and their (frequently very brutal) actions rather than the world around them.
* SmallNameBigEgo: Hawkins fancies himself a war hero worthy for command. In truth, he's a jumped up thug who's achieved nothing save to terrorize those weaker than him.

to:

* SceneryPorn: Both played straight and {{averted}}. The movie was filmed in the Tazmanian Tasmanian wilderness, so there's a lot of striking plant life around, but it was also shot in the unusual 4:3 aspect ratio, which tends to focus the eye on the characters and their (frequently very brutal) actions rather than the world around them.
* SmallNameBigEgo: Hawkins fancies himself a war hero worthy for command. In truth, he's a jumped up thug who's achieved nothing save to terrorize those weaker than him.



* UndignifiedDeath: [[spoiler:Hawkins is caught by Billy in a brothel and impaled on the spot. Ruse fares little better.]]
* ViolenceIsDisturbing: We are not spared from the goriest sights. The plainest example is when [[spoiler: Clare]] kills [[spoiler: Jago]] the viewer would expect it to be a cathartic moment, but it becomes a messy, gruesome sight more similar to RasputinianDeath.

to:

* UndignifiedDeath: [[spoiler:Hawkins is caught by Billy in a brothel and impaled on gets a spear to the spot.heart before he's even out of bed. Ruse fares little better.]]
* ViolenceIsDisturbing: We are not spared from the goriest sights. The plainest example is when [[spoiler: Clare]] kills [[spoiler: Jago]] Jago]]: the viewer would expect it to be a cathartic moment, but it becomes a messy, gruesome sight more similar to RasputinianDeath.



* WouldHurtAChild: [[spoiler:Hawkins eventually shoots little Eddie for begging him for a second chance, simply snarling he "can't stand the fucking noise of it."]]

to:

* WouldHurtAChild: [[spoiler:Hawkins eventually shoots little Eddie for begging him for a second chance, simply snarling that he "can't stand the fucking noise of it."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* RegencyEngland: Although it’s set in Australia 1825 (at that time a British colony), the fashions and military uniforms match this era.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DontGoInTheWoods: At least not without a NativeGuide. And [[spoiler: when Clare is separated from Billy]] it shows that she wouldn't have last long without him.

to:

* DontGoInTheWoods: At least not without a NativeGuide. And [[spoiler: when Clare is separated from Billy]] it shows that she wouldn't have last lasted long without him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WantsAPrizeForBasicDecency: A couple who assist Clare and Billy expect Billy to be much more grateful than is warranted just for letting him eat at their table, prompting him to tearfully exclaim that they're in his country.

to:

* WantsAPrizeForBasicDecency: A couple who assist Clare and Billy expect Billy to be much more grateful than is warranted just for letting him eat at their table, table rather than on the floor, prompting him to tearfully exclaim that they're the ones in his country.''his'' country, not vice versa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Clare (Aisling Franciosi) is an Irish indentured servant at a British military outpost in 1825 Tasmania. She is forced to endure the murders of her husband and baby, as well as her own brutal rape, by an officer named Hawkins (Creator/SamClaflin) and his henchmen. Unable to find justice, Clare enlists the help of an Aboriginal tracker named Billy (Baykali Ganambarr) to guide her through the harsh Australian wilderness as she seeks revenge against Hawkins's band. [[FromBadToWorse Things do not get better from here.]]

to:

Clare (Aisling Franciosi) (Creator/AislingFranciosi) is an Irish indentured servant at a British military outpost in 1825 Tasmania. She is forced to endure the murders of her husband and baby, as well as her own brutal rape, by an officer named Hawkins (Creator/SamClaflin) and his henchmen. Unable to find justice, Clare enlists the help of an Aboriginal tracker named Billy (Baykali Ganambarr) to guide her through the harsh Australian wilderness as she seeks revenge against Hawkins's band. [[FromBadToWorse Things do not get better from here.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BeautyIsNeverTarnished: Averted. Clare is bruised from where she gets hit by Hawkins and Jago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* AdultFear:
** Hawkins' sex slave Lowanna's infant son is left in the middle of the woods alone.
** The first 30 minutes are Clare's personal nightmare, her husband and child are killed and she is gang-raped by Hawkins' henchmen.
** Lowanna's husband tries to rescue his wife only [[spoiler: for her to be killed before his eyes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DefrostingIceQueen: Clare gradually warms up to Billy over the course of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BeautyIsNeverTarnished: Averted. Clare is bruised from where she gets hit by Hawkins and Jago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroicBsod: Happens to Clare after [[spoiler: her daughter is killed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The first 20 minutes are Clare's personal nightmare, her husband and child are killed and she is gang-raped by Hawkins' henchmen.

to:

** The first 20 30 minutes are Clare's personal nightmare, her husband and child are killed and she is gang-raped by Hawkins' henchmen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CharacterDevelopment: Clare's racism towards the Aborigines softens as a result of bonding with Billy.
* CrapsackWorld: Van Diemen's Land-era Tasmania is a penal colony where racism and genocide against Aborigines happens regularly.

to:

* CharacterDevelopment: Clare's racism towards the Aborigines Aboriginals softens as a result of bonding with Billy.
* CrapsackWorld: Van Diemen's Land-era Tasmania is a penal colony where racism and genocide against Aborigines Aboriginals happens regularly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing irrelevant detail per "Is this an example?" forum.


* RapeAsDrama: [[spoiler:Clare is raped ''three'' separate times in the first half hour of the film, providing a lot of her motivation for the rest of the film. This actually caused some backlash from critics who found the sheer amount of rape to be excessive]].

to:

* RapeAsDrama: [[spoiler:Clare is raped ''three'' separate times in the first half hour of the film, providing a lot of her motivation for the rest of the film. This actually caused some backlash from critics who found the sheer amount of rape to be excessive]].film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: Clare starts off treating Billy like he's barely above an animal, while he (quite accurately at that point) thinks she's no different than any other white person. After their first FriendshipMoment when Billy calls Clare "English", they realise they have far more in common than they thought, including the fact that English is neither's first language.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: Clare starts off treating Billy like he's barely above an animal, while he (quite accurately at that point) thinks she's no different than any other white person. After their first FriendshipMoment when Billy calls Clare "English", they realise they have far more in common than they thought, including the fact that English is neither's first language.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SceneryPorn: Both played straight and {{averted}}. The movie was filmed in the Tazmanian wilderness, so there's a lot of striking plant life around, but it was also shot in the unusual 4:3 aspect ratio, which tends to focus the eye on the characters and their (frequently very brutal) actions rather than the world around them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Tropes inclide:

to:

!!Tropes inclide:include:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Of the three soldiers, [[spoiler: Jago]] is probably the most moral and the least guilty for what happened to Aidan (although he is the one who [[spoiler: kills the baby, although he is remorseful]]). Of the three, his death is by far the most brutal and drawn out (because Clare's gun fails her and she has to resort to beating him with the butt, then stabbing him with his own knife). Doing this also causes Clare to have nightmares where [[spoiler: Jago]] chases her around the woods with a bloody mutilated face.

Added: 1310

Changed: 1148

Removed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reality Ensues is about characters expecting reality to behave like fiction


* AmbiguousEnding: A lot is left up in the air when the film ends. [[spoiler:Billy is presumably dying of his wounds, but we last see him sitting on the beach looking at the sunrise. It's anyone guess as to what happens to Clare next. She has no papers, no job prospects and no cash, though she does have a horse. She might be wanted for accessory to murder]].



* HairTriggerTemper: Hawkins' three years in Tasmania have worn his patience to nothing, and he's prone to rages at the slightest provocation. He can't stand noise.



* KarmicDeath: [[spoiler: Jago bashed Clare's baby's head against a wall and clubbed her with the butt of a rifle. She kills him by bashing his head in with the butt of a rifle]].



* KnifeNut: [[spoiler: Clare]] repeatedly stabs [[spoiler: Jago]] to death with his own knife.



* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: The visiting officer who should recommend Hawkins for his promotion can plainly see how [[ArmyOfThievesAndWhores petty and corrupt]] his unit is and said promotion should never land on him. Too bad he doesn't see even more of him, perhaps ridding the army of this scumbag.
* RealityEnsues: You'd expect for Clare to go on a RoaringRampageOfRevenge and mercilessly kill her abusers. Instead the journey is perilous and takes his toll on her, and she finds out that she hasn't the killer instinct like Hawkins, and kill someone is a bloody, messy affair.
* ReassignedToAntarctica: Or the thing closest to Antarctica. Clare (formerly a petty thief) and her husband are Irish convicts sent for forced labour in Van Diemen's Land (modern-day Tasmania), or as Clare sees it "this arse-end of the world".

to:

* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: RapeAsDrama: [[spoiler:Clare is raped ''three'' separate times in the first half hour of the film, providing a lot of her motivation for the rest of the film. This actually caused some backlash from critics who found the sheer amount of rape to be excessive]].
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure:
**
The visiting officer who should recommend Hawkins for his promotion inspecting Hawkins' post can plainly see how [[ArmyOfThievesAndWhores petty and corrupt]] his unit is and said promotion should never land on him. Too bad he doesn't see even more of him, perhaps ridding the army of this scumbag.
* RealityEnsues: You'd expect
how he's abusing his indentured servants. He tells Hawkins plainly that he's not going to recommend him for a promotion, though he does nothing else to stop Hawkins' current activities.
** When
Clare [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech calls Hawkins out]] in front of a roomful of British officers, none of them interrupt her. They soberly listen to go on a RoaringRampageOfRevenge her entire speech and mercilessly kill don't acknowledge any of Hawkins' attempts to brush her abusers. Instead the journey is perilous and takes his toll on her, and she finds out that she hasn't the killer instinct like Hawkins, and kill someone is a bloody, messy affair.
aside.
* ReassignedToAntarctica: Or Australia in the thing closest to 19th century might as well be Antarctica. Clare (formerly a petty thief) and her husband are Irish convicts former criminals who are sent there for forced labour in Van Diemen's Land (modern-day Tasmania), or as Clare sees it "this arse-end of labor. It's an undesirable post for the world".English soldiers stationed there as well. Hawkins is enraged that he's been stuck there for three years.


Added DiffLines:

* ReliablyUnreliableGuns: Clare's gun misfires as often as it fires.

Added: 729

Changed: 757

Removed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There were subtitles in the version I saw.


* ArmyOfThievesAndWhores: Lieutenant Hawkins' unit are petty, racist, morally loose and perpetually intoxicated with alcohol. You'd think it's just by chance that most of them aren't convicts themselves. Hawkins calls them "the sorriest unit ever" but doesn't do anything to discipline them, and it bites him in the arse when the visiting officer who should promote him isn't remotely impressed with them.

to:

* AnimalMotif: Clare is a nightingale, while Billy is a blackbird. They both sing throughout the film.
* ArmyOfThievesAndWhores: Lieutenant Hawkins' unit are petty, racist, morally loose and perpetually intoxicated with alcohol.drunk. You'd think it's just by chance that most of them aren't convicts themselves. Hawkins calls them "the sorriest unit ever" but doesn't do anything to discipline them, and it bites him in the arse when the visiting officer who should promote him isn't remotely impressed with them.



* DarkAndTroubledPast: Billy saw English soldiers killing his family members and get separated from his mother.

to:

* DarkAndTroubledPast: Billy saw English soldiers killing his family members and get got separated from his mother.



* TheDogBitesBack: After watching Hawkins and company repeatedly abusing aboriginals, [[spoiler:Charlie leads them to the middle of nowhere and abandons them]].



* ExtremeMeleeRevenge: [[spoiler: Jago is already injured when]] gets first shot by [[spoiler: Clare]], but when the rifle fails to function (a RunningGag), he gets repeatedly stabbed with his own knife and then his face beaten to a pulp with said rifle. [[NightmareFuel It's not a pretty sight]].

to:

* ExtremeMeleeRevenge: [[spoiler: Jago Jago]] is already injured when]] when he gets first shot by [[spoiler: Clare]], but when the rifle fails to function (a RunningGag), he gets repeatedly stabbed with his own knife and then his face beaten to a pulp with said rifle. [[NightmareFuel It's not a pretty sight]].



* NativeGuide: Billy, actual name Mangana, the “blackbird” guides Clare through the woods, as there is no way she can make it by herself.
** Uncle Charlie serves as an unwilling one to Hawkins. [[spoiler: As he got fed up with their murdering and raping, he get them lost in the wilderness, but his scheme is found out and he's killed for it.]]

to:

* NativeGuide: NativeGuide:
**
Billy, actual name Mangana, the “blackbird” an aboriginal, guides Clare through the woods, as there is no way she can make it by herself.
** Uncle Charlie serves as an unwilling one to Hawkins. [[spoiler: As he got fed up with their murdering and raping, he get them [[spoiler:But Hawkins' repeated abuse of those around him, particularly the native population, isn't lost in the wilderness, but his scheme is found out on him, and he's killed for it.]]he betrays Hawkins]].



* RealityHasNoSubtitles: The film contains dialogue in both unsubtitled Irish and Palawa kani.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrusadingWidow: It's not just RapeAndRevenge, but poor Clare ha also a family to avenge by tracking down her assaulters.

to:

* CrusadingWidow: It's not just RapeAndRevenge, but poor Clare ha has also a family to avenge by tracking down her assaulters.

Added: 244

Changed: 636

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReassignedToAntarctica: Or the thing closest to Antarctica. Clare (formerly a petty thief) and her husband are Irish convicts sent for forced labor in Van Diemen's Land (modern-day Tasmania), or as Clare sees it "this arse-end of the world".

to:

* RealityHasNoSubtitles: The film contains dialogue in both unsubtitled Irish and Palawa kani.
* ReassignedToAntarctica: Or the thing closest to Antarctica. Clare (formerly a petty thief) and her husband are Irish convicts sent for forced labor labour in Van Diemen's Land (modern-day Tasmania), or as Clare sees it "this arse-end of the world".



* RoadTripPlot: The actions develops are the villains are traveling north of the island through the woods and the protagonists follow them to get their vengeance.

to:

* RoadTripPlot: The actions develops action happens as Hawkins and a group of men are the villains are traveling travelling north of the island to Launceston so he can buy his promotion, directly through the woods and the protagonists follow them to get their vengeance.Tasmania's interior.



* YouKilledMyFather: Most of Billy's friends, family members, [[spoiler: and fellow tribesmembers]] are killed by English soldiers [[spoiler: and he is now the last of his kind.]] This is what made to help Clare to enact on her revenge.

to:

* YouKilledMyFather: Most of Billy's friends, friends and family members, [[spoiler: and fellow tribesmembers]] are were killed by English soldiers soldiers. What makes him decide to help Clare get their final revenge is when [[spoiler: and he learns that he is now the last of his kind.]] This is what made to help Clare to enact on her revenge.entire people.]]

Added: 143

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LastOfHisKind: [[spoiler: Billy/Mangala later learns from Portmairremener people in chain that he is the last of Linetemairrener people.]]

to:

* LastOfHisKind: [[spoiler: Billy/Mangala Billy/Mangana later learns from Portmairremener people in chain that he is the last of Linetemairrener people.]]


Added DiffLines:

* MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: When Clare is lost in the woods, an actual blackbird shows up and appears to guide her to the road, saving her life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NotSoDifferent: As much as Clare having racism towards the Aborigines like Billy, they both find a commonality in hating English people for what they have done to their homeland.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: As much as Clare having racism towards the Aborigines starts off treating Billy like Billy, he's barely above an animal, while he (quite accurately at that point) thinks she's no different than any other white person. After their first FriendshipMoment when Billy calls Clare "English", they both find a commonality in hating English people for what realise they have done to their homeland.far more in common than they thought, including the fact that English is neither's first language.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/nightingale_2019_poster.jpg]]

Top