Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheMonumentsMen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In the film he gives a lecture to Roosevelt and identifies a work by "Da Vinci", rather than Leonardo. This is a classic post -- ''TheDaVinciCode'' mistake that '''no''' art historian -- and certainly none living in the 1940s -- would have made. The ''name'' of the artist was Leonardo and he ''was born'' in the town of Vinci -- Leonardo Da Vinci means "Leonardo, of Vinci".

to:

*** In the film he gives a lecture to Roosevelt and identifies a work by "Da Vinci", rather than Leonardo. This is a classic post -- ''TheDaVinciCode'' ''Literature/TheDaVinciCode'' mistake that '''no''' art historian -- and certainly none living in the 1940s -- would have made. The ''name'' of the artist was Leonardo and he ''was born'' in the town of Vinci -- Leonardo Da Vinci means "Leonardo, of Vinci".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CheeseEatingSurrenderMonkeys: [[DefiedTrope Defied]] by Claire Simone in the prison scene.
-->'''Granger''': ''"If it wasn't for us, you'd be speaking German right now."''
-->'''Simone''': ''"Wrong. If it wasn't for you, I'd be dead right now, but I would still speak French."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Note about 'A Million Is a Statistic'—by necessity, the art seized by the Soviets from Nazi collections would include Soviet art too (from the occupation of the USSR), counting as repatriation, as well as theft from the other countries.


* AMillionIsAStatistic: Subverted, it is noted that the Russians are seizing the art they recover as reparations for the 20 million men they have lost in the war, and this loss is treated with decent gravity. They are still treated as rivals at best and the lesser evil at worst, since most of the art they are stealing was already stolen from the ''other'' millions of people the Nazis conquered and killed.

to:

* AMillionIsAStatistic: Subverted, it is noted that the Russians are seizing the art they recover as reparations for the 20 million men they have lost in the war, and this loss is treated with decent gravity. They are still treated as rivals at best and the lesser evil at worst, since most of the art they are stealing was already stolen from the ''other'' millions of people the Nazis conquered and killed.killed (as well as repatriating Soviet art).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The characters call the Soviet unit the "Trophy" Brigade, not "Triumph" Brigade—similar sounding name?


* EvilCounterpart: the Triumph Brigade, the Monuments Men's Soviet counterparts, who don't give back the art they take.

to:

* EvilCounterpart: the Triumph Trophy Brigade, the Monuments Men's Soviet counterparts, who don't give back the art they take.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* XMeetsY: ''OceansEleven'' meets ''IndianaJones''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The movie completely ignores a crucial debate concerning the rescued art: Soon after the war, US authorities ordered over 200 priceless works of art be shipped to the United States. The Monuments Men, en masse, signed a declaration, called the ''Weisbaden Manifesto'' (after the city and Allied military base of Wiesbaden where the artworks were first centrally depoted for final disposition), protesting the decision. They claimed that whatever the true intentions of the US military, it could not help but be seen as trophy taking on the level of the Soviets or even Hitler. The decision would not be rescinded until 1948.

Added: 250

Changed: 119

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CreatorCameo: AlexandreDesplat not only composed the score but also appears onscreen as a member of the Resistance in several scenes.

to:

* CreatorCameo: CreatorCameo:
**
AlexandreDesplat not only composed the score but also appears onscreen as a member of the Resistance in several scenes.scenes (he plays Emile, who helps Granger get to Paris).
** George Clooney's producing partner Grant Heslov plays a doctor in one scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is just not true. First, no one was on the gold standard by that point. Second, Germany was just about done by that point anyway. The Allied armies were already inside Germany: the British and Americans were over the Rhine, and the Soviets were closing in on Berlin. Germany was finished very soon no matter how much gold they had. Finding the gold was a real win, but it was nowhere near that important.


* OffscreenMomentOfAwesome: The Monuments Men accidentally stumble upon [[NaziGold Germany's gold reserves]] while searching for stolen art, but in the film it's treated as just something that happened that seemed irrelevant to their primary mission. In RealLife, though, this accidental discovery did more to end the war than almost any soldiering on the part of any of the Allies: the world was still on the gold standard, and when word got out that there was nothing backing the Deutschmark, the Third Reich had no way to continue to fund their war effort, and the ''Wehrmacht'' fell apart very quickly after that. ''That'' is why Generals UsefulNotes/DwightDEisenhower, George S. Patton and Omar Bradley are getting their picture taken.

to:

* OffscreenMomentOfAwesome: The Monuments Men accidentally stumble upon [[NaziGold Germany's gold reserves]] while searching for stolen art, but in the film it's treated as just something that happened that seemed irrelevant to their primary mission. In RealLife, though, this accidental discovery did more to played some importance in hastening the end the war than almost any soldiering on the part of any of the Allies: the world was still on the gold standard, and when word got out that there was nothing backing the Deutschmark, the Third Reich had no way to continue to fund their war effort, and the ''Wehrmacht'' fell apart very quickly after that. ''That'' is why Generals UsefulNotes/DwightDEisenhower, George S. Patton and Omar Bradley are getting their picture taken.war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PacingProblems: Many reviews cited this issue with the film. The film goes off on too many arcs at once, and sometimes shows two events back and forth at the same time which have little relation to each other. One historian wrote that the story(s) may have been better suited for a TV series than a movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Averted with Preston Savitz who clearly says early in the film that he hopes to shoot someone, but never does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The film seems to leave the impression that the top generals were boorish, greedy fools for focusing on the captured German gold in the mine and not the art. In point of fact, even with the incalculable cultural value the art possessed, the seizure of the gold was vastly more important in winning the war. By capturing the gold of the Reichsbank, the Allies had essentially seized Germany's bank account and had starved the Nazi regime of the hard currency reserves it desperately needed to prop up the German economy and continue what little fighting it could.

Added: 367

Changed: 437

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added page image.


'''''The Monuments Men''''' is a 2014 War Movie directed by Creator/GeorgeClooney and starring himself, Creator/MattDamon, Creator/BillMurray, John Goodman, Jean Dujardin, Bob Balaban, Hugh Bonneville, and Creator/CateBlanchett. It is based on the history book ''The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves and the Greatest Treasure Hunt in History'' by Robert M. Edsel.

to:

'''''The [[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the-monuments-men-poster_5957.jpg]]

''The
Monuments Men''''' Men'' is a 2014 War Movie directed by Creator/GeorgeClooney and starring himself, Creator/MattDamon, Creator/BillMurray, John Goodman, Jean Dujardin, Bob Balaban, Hugh Bonneville, and Creator/CateBlanchett. It is based on the history book ''The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves and the Greatest Treasure Hunt in History'' by Robert M. Edsel.



!Tropes displayed include:

to:

!Tropes !!Tropes displayed include:

Added: 172

Removed: 120

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EverybodySmokes: Aside from Savitz and that horse.
* EvilCounterpart: the Triumph Brigade, the Monuments Men's Soviet counterparts, who don't give back the art they take.



* EvilCounterpart: the Triumph Brigade, the Monuments Men's Soviet counterparts, who don't give back the art they take.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


To that task, Lt. Frank Stokes assembles an elite team of experts to accomplish this mission. However, they find their work complicated by their own combat units who hardly see the point of risking their own lives being delicate around art and the Nazis who determined to keep their loot or destroy it if they are defeated. Furthermore, they have to deal with natives like French curator Claire Simone who suspect the US wants to steal the art for themselves and the Soviets who definitely want to do that as reparations for the horrors they have suffered in that war.

to:

To that task, Lt. Frank Stokes assembles an elite team of experts to accomplish this mission. However, they find their work complicated by their own combat units who hardly see the point of risking their own lives being delicate around art and the Nazis who determined to keep their loot or destroy it if they are defeated. Furthermore, they have to deal with natives like French curator Claire Simone who suspect the US wants to steal the art for themselves and the Soviets who definitely want to do that as reparations for the horrors they have suffered in that war.



* TheAtoner: Jeffries regards his WW2 service as making up for his alcoholism, which has ruined his reputation and [[WellDoneSonGuy disgraced his father]]. His father even writes to Stoltz thanking him for giving his son the [[RedemptionEqualsDeath chance to redeem himself]].

to:

* TheAtoner: Jeffries regards his WW2 service as making up for his alcoholism, which has ruined his reputation and [[WellDoneSonGuy disgraced his father]]. His father even writes to Stoltz Stokes, thanking him for giving his son the [[RedemptionEqualsDeath chance to redeem himself]].



** Stoltz asks for permission to continue searching for the Raphael painting ''Portrait of a young man'', in the belief that it survived the war. The painting is shown being destroyed by the Nazis earlier in the movie.
** In his first lecture Stoltz states that the war will be over in a few months once the Allies invade, when it actually lasts another year.
* {{Egopolis}}: References are made to Hitler's proposed "Fuhrermuseum" near his birthplace in Austria.

to:

** Stoltz Stokes asks for permission to continue searching for the Raphael painting painting, ''Portrait of a young man'', Young Man'', in the belief that it survived the war. The painting is shown being destroyed by the Nazis earlier in the movie.
** In his first lecture Stoltz Stokes states that the war will be over in a few months once the Allies invade, when it actually lasts another year.
* {{Egopolis}}: References are made to Hitler's proposed "Fuhrermuseum" "Führermuseum" near his birthplace in Austria.



** Stoltz looking at the BloodStainedLetter Jeffries is narrating in voiceover cues the audience to his death just before we see it happen.

to:

** Stoltz Stokes looking at the BloodStainedLetter Jeffries is narrating in voiceover cues the audience to his death just before we see it happen.



*** In the film he gives a lecture to Roosevelt and identifies a work by "Da Vinci", rather than Leonardo. This is a classic post -- ''TheDaVinciCode'' mistake that '''no''' art historian- and certainly none living in the 1940's- would have made. The ''name'' of the artist was Leonardo and he ''was born'' in the town of Vinci -- Leonardo Da Vinci means "Leonardo, of Vinci".

to:

*** In the film he gives a lecture to Roosevelt and identifies a work by "Da Vinci", rather than Leonardo. This is a classic post -- ''TheDaVinciCode'' mistake that '''no''' art historian- historian -- and certainly none living in the 1940's- 1940s -- would have made. The ''name'' of the artist was Leonardo and he ''was born'' in the town of Vinci -- Leonardo Da Vinci means "Leonardo, of Vinci".



* XMeetsY: OceansEleven meets IndianaJones.

to:

* XMeetsY: OceansEleven ''OceansEleven'' meets IndianaJones.''IndianaJones''.

Changed: 211

Removed: 201

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* RunningGag: French people constantly asking Granger to please ''not speak French.'' TruthInTelevision, as Granger says that he learned French while studying in Quebec, which has a dialect quite different from that spoken in France.
** Apart from some slang, not to that extent. People ask him to stop speaking French because he is beyond terrible at it (pronounciation, grammar, syntax are all wrong and he is barely understandable).

to:

* RunningGag: French people constantly asking Granger to please ''not speak French.'' TruthInTelevision, as Granger says He states that he learned French while studying it in Quebec, which has a dialect quite different from that spoken in France.
** Apart
but apart from some slang, not to that extent. People ask him to stop speaking French because he is he's beyond terrible at it in that dialect as well (pronounciation, grammar, syntax are all wrong and he is barely understandable).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Apart from some slang, not to that extent. People ask him to stop speaking French because he is beyond terrible at it (pronounciation, grammar, syntax are all wrong and he is barely understandable).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BilingualBackfire: The Allies capture a group of Germans who were transporting stolen art to Germany. The German-American refugee soldier Epstein quietly listens on as the Germans' captain and his XO (who switched uniforms before being captured) talk about where they took it. Then Epstein walks up, and in fluent German promises the captain that he'll give Hitler his regards when they take Berlin.


Added DiffLines:

* ARareSentence: When the Monuments Men learn that the Germans are going to destroy the looted artwork in the event of Hitler's death, they realize the urgency of their mission while Jean-Claude remarks that Hitler better doesn't die. He acknowledges that he didn't think he'd ever hear himself utter that sentence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilCounterpart: the Triumph Brigade, the Monuments Men's Soviet counterparts, who don't give back the art they take.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguouslyJewish: Epstein. Although he doesn't display any stereotypically "Jewish" traits, it's easy to read between the lines when he mentions that his family immigrated to the U.S. from Germany in 1938. Also, during the ending montage, he's the one shown returning a Torah to a synagogue.

to:

* AmbiguouslyJewish: Epstein. Although he doesn't display any stereotypically "Jewish" traits, it's easy to read between the lines when he mentions that his family immigrated to the U.S. from Germany in 1938.1938[[spoiler: and his grandfather being sent to Dachau]]. Also, during the ending montage, he's the one shown returning a Torah to a synagogue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Stoltz looking at the blood-splattered letter Jeffries is speaking in voiceover cues the audience to his death just before we see it happen.

to:

** Stoltz looking at the blood-splattered letter BloodStainedLetter Jeffries is speaking narrating in voiceover cues the audience to his death just before we see it happen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* XMeetsY: Oceans11 meets IndianaJones.

to:

* XMeetsY: Oceans11 OceansEleven meets IndianaJones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Indiana Jones more or less covers the WWII part and its more of a caper than a Band of Brothers style drama.


* XMeetsY: BandOfBrothers meets IndianaJones.

to:

* XMeetsY: BandOfBrothers Oceans11 meets IndianaJones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* XMeetsY: BandOfBrothers meets IndianaJones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BurnBabyBurn: When the Nazis destroy an art depository with [[FireBreathingWeapon flamethrowers]], ''Portrait of a young man'' by Raphael is prominently displayed as it burns.

to:

* BurnBabyBurn: When the Nazis destroy an art depository with [[FireBreathingWeapon flamethrowers]], ''Portrait of a young man'' Young Man'' by Raphael is prominently displayed as it burns.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Justified -- Stahl shoots at Claire at the railway station and misses even though she doesn't try to take cover, but he's a non-combatant soldier using a Luger pistol at long range. Colonel Wegner kills Jeffries with his Luger after being shot in the shoulder, but he's an experienced soldier firing at a much closer range.

to:

* ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Justified -- Stahl shoots at Claire at the railway station and misses even though she doesn't try to take cover, but he's a non-combatant soldier using a Luger pistol at long range.range, and he's shooting from a moving train. Colonel Wegner kills Jeffries with his Luger after being shot in the shoulder, but he's an experienced soldier firing at a much closer range.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HopeSpot: Jeffries sneaks into German-occupied Bruges to ensure the safety of Michelangelo's ''Madonna and Child'', and is relieved to discover it untouched by bombing or looting. Then a Nazi colonel enters the church to steal it at gunpoint.

to:

* HopeSpot: Jeffries sneaks into German-occupied Bruges to ensure the safety of Michelangelo's ''Madonna and Child'', and is relieved to discover it the statue untouched by bombing or looting. Then a Nazi colonel enters the church to steal it at gunpoint.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpitefulSpit: Viktor Stahl tells Claire Simon to [[YouGetMeCoffee fetch him another champagne glass]] so he can share a toast with Hermann Goering. She selects a glass from the kitchen and spits in it. A member of the staff is looking on in surprise, but [[ZeroPercentApprovalRating when Claire informs her it's for Stahl she spits in the glass as well]].

to:

* SpitefulSpit: Viktor Stahl tells Claire Simon Simone to [[YouGetMeCoffee fetch him another champagne glass]] so he can share a toast with Hermann Goering. She selects a glass from the kitchen and spits in it. A member of the staff is looking on in surprise, but [[ZeroPercentApprovalRating when Claire informs her it's for Stahl she spits in the glass as well]].

Changed: 162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* YourCheatingHeart: Averted -- Granger stays faithful to his wife despite Claire dropping hints that she's interested and noting that he is, after all, in Paris.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoldTooth: The Men find an entire barrel full of them.

to:

* GoldTooth: The Men find [[FinalSolution an entire barrel full of them.them]].

Added: 187

Changed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}}: Claire reads about the arrest of Viktor Stahl as a small story buried within her newspaper, while drinking coffee and smoking a cigarette at a cafe. See the ButForMeItWasTuesday entry.

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: {{Foreshadowing}}
**
Claire reads about the arrest of Viktor Stahl as a small story buried within her newspaper, while drinking coffee and smoking a cigarette at a cafe. See the ButForMeItWasTuesday entry.

Top