Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheMarshKingsDaughter2023

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* RaceLift: in the novel, Jacob's father was Ojibwe, and he imparts some of their culture and teachings to Helena. Given he is played here by a white guy from Australia, [[UnfortunateImplications well...]] he's never attributed any Ojibwe background, and the stuff he teaches Helena is written off as cultural appropriation (and mostly inaccurate, at that -- see Slave Brand, below).

to:

* RaceLift: in the novel, Jacob's father was Ojibwe, and he imparts some of their culture and teachings to Helena. Given he is played here by a white guy from Australia, [[UnfortunateImplications well...]] well... he's never attributed any Ojibwe background, and the stuff he teaches Helena is written off as cultural appropriation (and mostly inaccurate, at that -- see Slave Brand, below).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** in the novel, Jacob is part Ojibwe and the teachings and tattoos he imparts to Helena are a part of his heritage (albeit a part he apparently romanticizes, as he didn't seem to learn it from his parent). With Jacob being played by Ben Mendelsohn, this aspect of his character is ignored, and instead the indigenous American character Clark says Jacob appropriated and warped his people's traditions.

to:

** in the novel, Jacob is part Ojibwe and the teachings and tattoos he imparts to Helena are a part of his heritage (albeit a part he apparently romanticizes, as he didn't seem to learn it from his parent).taught himself). With Jacob being played by Ben Mendelsohn, this aspect of his character is ignored, and instead the indigenous American character Clark says Jacob appropriated and warped his people's traditions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDistillation: somewhat necessary due to the book's contemplative, introspective narrative.
** Helena's life in the marsh is reduced to a relatively short sequence at the start of the film, and a few brief flashbacks thereafter.
** Helena and Beth's escape from the marsh is significantly shorter — [[spoiler:rather than the slow erosion of Helena's trust in her father as he tortures the innocent man who discovered their cabin, Jacob shoots him immediately and Beth clubs an uncooperative Helena with a rock and drives them both to safety on the man's ATV]]. Helena doesn't learn of her father's crimes until they're at the police station.
* AdaptationExpansion: …and yet, other parts of the book are expanded upon. Rather than hearing about her father's escape and immediately setting out to find him, Helena spends more time with her husband and daughter and reconnects with her positive father figure. Jacob even manages to throw the authorities off his trail by [[spoiler:faking his own death. It's only once it becomes clear that he is alive and stalking her family that Helena goes looking for him]].


Added DiffLines:

* PragmaticAdaptation: a good chunk of the book is just Helena walking silently through the woods by herself or looking at corpses, aside from her marsh flashbacks. This wouldn't make for good cinema, of course, so the film shortens some aspects and expands on others:
** Helena's life in the marsh is reduced to a short series of scenes at the start, and a few brief flashbacks thereafter.
** Helena and Beth's escape from Jacob is significantly shorter — [[spoiler:rather than Helena slowly learning the truth about her father as he tortures the innocent man who discovered their cabin, Jacob shoots him immediately and Beth clubs an uncooperative Helena with a rock and drives them both to safety on the man's ATV]]. Helena doesn't learn of her father's crimes until they're at the police station.
** Rather than immediately setting out to find her father after he escapes, Helena spends more time with her husband and daughter and reconnects with her stepfather after Jacob [[spoiler:throws the authorities off his trail by faking his own death]]. Once it becomes clear that he is [[spoiler:very much alive and stalking her family]], *then* Helena goes looking for him.
** The confrontation between [[spoiler:Helena and her father is much more drawn out, with multiple confrontations and a surprise appearance from Clark]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenPedestal: In the trailer, Helena says she admired her father as a child, with flashbacks to her childhood showing they had a close, affectionate relationship and that he taught her how to track and hunt animals. However, this was before Helena realised what an evil person her father was; in the trailer a now-grown Helena tells a police officer she hasn't spoken to her father since she was ten and she's shown to be terrified that he will come for her and her family, stating "I realised the person I believed in the most was really a monster".
* ChildByRape: Helena is this; the trailer states her father kidnapped her mother and held her captive in marshland for twelve years, with Helena being born during this time.

to:

* BrokenPedestal: In the trailer, Helena says she admired her father as a child, with flashbacks to her Helena's childhood showing they she had a close, affectionate relationship and with her father (aside from that time he [[spoiler:chucked her in a hole for not shooting a wolf]]) who taught her how to track and hunt animals. However, this was before Helena realised what an evil person Her admiration of him causes her father was; in to actively resist her mother's escape attempt, but as an adult she knows the trailer a now-grown Helena truth. She tells a police officer she hasn't spoken to her father since she was ten and she's shown to be terrified that he will come for her and her family, stating [[spoiler:her husband]] "I realised have trust issues because everyone told me the person I believed in the most was really a monster".
monster."
* CanonForeigner: Helena's stepfather Clark, who doesn't exist in the book. He was one of the police officers who apprehended her father, and tries to be a good influence on Helena, though they don't appear to be close.
* ChildByRape: Helena; though the film is less overt about it, Beth was clearly Jacob's hostage and unwilling captive. Helena is this; the trailer states her father kidnapped thinks her mother and held resented her captive in marshland for twelve years, with Helena being born during this time. this.



* GreatEscape: The present-day plot is kicked off by Jacob Holbrook and another prisoner escaping from jail; the trailer shows them overpowering guards while being transported in a prison van, causing it to crash.
* ProtectThisHouse: The trailer shows Helena securing her house's doors and windows, setting up traps and signals and patrolling the house with weapons due to her belief her father will try to break in.

to:

* GreatEscape: The present-day plot is kicked off by Jacob Holbrook and another prisoner escaping from jail; the trailer shows them overpowering guards while being transported in a prison van, causing Jacob opens his handcuffs with a lockpick hidden in his mouth and kills the two guards.
* NeverMyFault: Jacob is a textbook narcissist, claiming he and Beth "ran away together" rather than
it being an unwilling abduction. He blames all the Marsh King stuff on "lies" told to crash.
Helena by Beth and others, though Helena doesn't believe him.
* ProtectThisHouse: The trailer shows Before she realizes [[spoiler:Jacob is still alive]], Helena securing still secures all her house's doors and windows, setting up traps and signals and patrolling the house sets up a snare with weapons due to her belief her father will try to break in. a bell and tripwire in the woods behind it. [[spoiler:Unfortunately he gets in anyway.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** in the novel, Jacob is part Ojibwe and the teachings and tattoos he imparts to Helena are a part of his heritage he romanticizes. With Jacob being played onscreen by white Australian Ben Mendelsohn, this aspect of his character is ignored, and instead the indigenous American character Clark says Jacob appropriated and warped his people's traditions.

to:

** in the novel, Jacob is part Ojibwe and the teachings and tattoos he imparts to Helena are a part of his heritage (albeit a part he romanticizes. apparently romanticizes, as he didn't seem to learn it from his parent). With Jacob being played onscreen by white Australian Ben Mendelsohn, this aspect of his character is ignored, and instead the indigenous American character Clark says Jacob appropriated and warped his people's traditions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalBackstoryChange: in the novel, Jacob is part Ojibwe and the teachings and tattoos he imparts to Helena are a part of his heritage he romanticizes. With Jacob being played onscreen by white Australian Ben Mendelsohn, this aspect of his character is ignored, and instead the indigenous American character Clark says Jacob appropriated and warped his people's traditions.

to:

* AdaptationalBackstoryChange: AdaptationalBackstoryChange:
**
in the novel, Jacob is part Ojibwe and the teachings and tattoos he imparts to Helena are a part of his heritage he romanticizes. With Jacob being played onscreen by white Australian Ben Mendelsohn, this aspect of his character is ignored, and instead the indigenous American character Clark says Jacob appropriated and warped his people's traditions.traditions.
** the film also changes Helena's post-marsh upbringing to give her a stepfather, Clark (played by Gil Birmingham). In the book Beth lived with her parents and never married.
* AdaptationalDumbass: Movie Helena is a lot less savvy than Book Helena, setting out to [[spoiler:confront her father alone, unarmed except for her hunting knife, without even telling her husband to take their daughter away from the house. She then apparently assumes that he'll leave them alone because she ''asked him nicely''.]]
* AdaptationDistillation: somewhat necessary due to the book's contemplative, introspective narrative.
** Helena's life in the marsh is reduced to a relatively short sequence at the start of the film, and a few brief flashbacks thereafter.
** Helena and Beth's escape from the marsh is significantly shorter — [[spoiler:rather than the slow erosion of Helena's trust in her father as he tortures the innocent man who discovered their cabin, Jacob shoots him immediately and Beth clubs an uncooperative Helena with a rock and drives them both to safety on the man's ATV]]. Helena doesn't learn of her father's crimes until they're at the police station.
* AdaptationExpansion: …and yet, other parts of the book are expanded upon. Rather than hearing about her father's escape and immediately setting out to find him, Helena spends more time with her husband and daughter and reconnects with her positive father figure. Jacob even manages to throw the authorities off his trail by [[spoiler:faking his own death. It's only once it becomes clear that he is alive and stalking her family that Helena goes looking for him]].
* AdaptationalJobChange: in the book, Helena makes income selling homemade jams and jellies using wild ingredients she forages for by hand. In the film, she has an unspecified bland office job involving spreadsheets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalBackstoryChange: in the novel, Jacob is part Ojibwe and the teachings and tattoos he imparts to Helena are a part of his heritage he romanticizes. With Jacob being played onscreen by white Australian Ben Mendelsohn, this aspect of his character is ignored, and instead the indigenous American character Clark says Jacob appropriated and warped his people's traditions.



* SlaveBrand: The trailer shows that Helena and Jacob have [[ThemedTattoos the same markings tattooed on their hands]], with Jacob saying it means "they're family". However, Gil Birmingham's character tells Helena "it means owned, not family. Don't confuse the two."

to:

* RaceLift: in the novel, Jacob's father was Ojibwe, and he imparts some of their culture and teachings to Helena. Given he is played here by a white guy from Australia, [[UnfortunateImplications well…]] he's never attributed any Ojibwe background, and the stuff he teaches Helena is written off as cultural appropriation (and mostly inaccurate, at that — see Slave Brand, below).
* SlaveBrand: The trailer shows that Helena and Jacob have [[ThemedTattoos the same markings tattooed on their hands]], with Jacob saying it means "they're family". "family". However, Gil Birmingham's character Helena's indigenous stepdad Clark later tells Helena "it her the tattoo actually means owned, "owned, not family. Don't confuse the two."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Helena Pelletier (Ridley) appears to be a normal woman living an idyllic life with her husband Stephen (Hedlund) and their daughters. However, her past is far from normal: she is the daughter of Jacob Holbrook (Mendelsohn), the notorious "Marsh King", a reclusive survivalist, kidnapper, rapist and murderer who abducted her mother (Pistorius) and held her captive in remote marshland for over a decade. Helena herself was raised in the wilderness, unaware she and her mother were Jacob's prisoners until she was ten years old. When Helena is informed that Jacob has recently escaped from prison, Helena fears for her family's safety. Using the survival skills her father taught her, Helena sets out to protect herself and her family, finally confronting the dark past she had tried to bury.

to:

Helena Pelletier (Ridley) appears to be a normal woman living an idyllic life with her husband Stephen (Hedlund) and their daughters.daughter Marigold. However, her past is far from normal: she is the daughter of Jacob Holbrook (Mendelsohn), the notorious "Marsh King", a reclusive survivalist, kidnapper, rapist and murderer who abducted her mother (Pistorius) and held her captive in remote marshland for over a decade. Helena herself was raised in the wilderness, unaware she and her mother were Jacob's prisoners until she was ten years old. When Helena is informed that Jacob has recently escaped from prison, Helena she fears for her family's safety. Using the survival skills her father taught her, Helena sets out to protect herself and her family, finally confronting the dark past she had tried to bury.



* AnimalMotif: Deer come up repeatedly in the trailer, associated with Helena and her family. At the start of the trailer, Helena's daughter Miracle shows her mother a diorama she made of a baby deer's habitat, with rocks for the deer to hide from hunters behind, to which Helena replies it's a "smart deer". Helena is shown hunting a deer as a child and has a deer tattooed on her neck, explaining that her father gave her the tattoo when she made her first kill.

to:

* AnimalMotif: Deer come up repeatedly in the trailer, associated with Helena and her family. At the start of the trailer, Helena's daughter Miracle Marigold shows her mother a diorama she made of a baby deer's habitat, with rocks for the deer to hide from hunters behind, to which Helena replies it's a "smart deer". Helena is shown hunting a deer as a child and has a deer tattooed on her neck, explaining that her father gave her the tattoo when she made her first kill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Marsh King's Daughter'' is an upcoming PsychologicalThriller film, based on the novel of the same name by Karen Dionne. The film was directed by Creator/NeilBurger, with the screenplay co-written by Mark L. Smith and Elle Smith. It stars Creator/DaisyRidley, Creator/BenMendelsohn, Creator/GarrettHedlund, Creator/GilBirmingham and Creator/CarenPistorius.

to:

''The Marsh King's Daughter'' is an upcoming a 2023 PsychologicalThriller film, based on the novel of the same name by Karen Dionne. The film was directed by Creator/NeilBurger, with the screenplay co-written by Mark L. Smith and Elle Smith. It stars Creator/DaisyRidley, Creator/BenMendelsohn, Creator/GarrettHedlund, Creator/GilBirmingham and Creator/CarenPistorius.



The film is set for release on November 3rd 2023. The trailer can be viewed [[https://youtu.be/FDnUVhLMqI0?si=lz8dPt95tVC0bd6t here]].

to:

The film is set for release was released on November 3rd 2023. The trailer can be viewed [[https://youtu.be/FDnUVhLMqI0?si=lz8dPt95tVC0bd6t here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Tagline}}: "Fear the past or face it".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producer and co-writer of ''Film/TheRevenant'' and "From the director of ''Film/{{Limitless}}''".

to:

* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producer and co-writer of ''Film/TheRevenant'' ''Film/TheRevenant''" and "From the director of ''Film/{{Limitless}}''".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producer and co-writer of ''Film/TheRevenant'' and "From the director of ''Film/{{Limitless}}''.

to:

* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producer and co-writer of ''Film/TheRevenant'' and "From the director of ''Film/{{Limitless}}''.''Film/{{Limitless}}''".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producer and co-writer of ''Film/TheRevenant''.

to:

* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producer and co-writer of ''Film/TheRevenant''.''Film/TheRevenant'' and "From the director of ''Film/{{Limitless}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producers of ''Film/TheRevenant''.

to:

* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producers producer and co-writer of ''Film/TheRevenant''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdvertisingByAssociation: It was advertised as being "From the producers of ''Film/TheRevenant''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TimeShiftedActor: Daisy Ridley plays Helena as an adult, while Brooklynn Prince portrays her as a child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TripwireTrap: The trailer depicts Helena tying a wire between trees low to the ground and attaching a bell, presumably to alert her if anyone walks into it.

to:

* TripwireTrap: TripTrap: The trailer depicts Helena tying a wire tripwire between trees low to the ground and attaching a bell, presumably to alert her if anyone walks into it.

Added: 158

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkSecret: The trailer shows that Helena kept her distubing past a secret from her husband, as Stephen is initially confused when the police show up at their house asking about his wife's father and says he was under the impression both her parents died in a car accident. Helena reluctantly states [[ILied "That's what I told you"]]. Considering that Helena's father is a notorious violent criminal who kidnapped and raped her mother, it wouldn't be surprising Helena wanted to put it all behind her and have a normal life, though later in the trailer Stephen tells her he wishes she'd told him the truth.

to:

* DarkSecret: The trailer shows that Helena kept her distubing disturbing past a secret from her husband, as Stephen is initially confused when the police show up at their house asking about his wife's father and says he was under the impression both her parents died in a car accident. Helena reluctantly states [[ILied "That's what I told you"]]. Considering that Helena's father is a notorious violent criminal who kidnapped and raped her mother, it wouldn't be surprising Helena wanted to put it all behind her and have a normal life, though later in the trailer Stephen tells her he wishes she'd told him the truth.


Added DiffLines:

* TripwireTrap: The trailer depicts Helena tying a wire between trees low to the ground and attaching a bell, presumably to alert her if anyone walks into it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FairytaleMotif: The title and basic premise are references to the Creator/HansChristiansenAndersen fairytale of the same name, in which the titular character is the daughter of a cruel [[TheFairFolk Marsh King]] and the fairy princess he kidnapped.

to:

* FairytaleMotif: The title and basic premise are references to the Creator/HansChristiansenAndersen Creator/HansChristianAndersen fairytale of the same name, in which the titular character is the daughter of a cruel [[TheFairFolk Marsh King]] and the fairy princess he kidnapped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FairytaleMotif: The title and basic premise are references to the Creator/HansChristiansenAndersen fairytale of the same name, in which the titular character is the daughter of a cruel [[TheFairFolk Marsh King]] and the fairy princess he kidnapped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkSecret: The trailer shows that Helena kept her distubing past a secret from her husband, as Stephen is initially confused when the police show up at his house asking about his wife's father and says he was under the impression both her parents died in a car accident. Helena reluctantly states [[ILied "That's what I told you"]]. Considering that Helena's father is a notorious violent criminal who kidnapped and raped her mother, it wouldn't be surprising Helena wanted to put it all behind her and have a normal life, though later in the trailer Stephen tells her he wishes she'd told him the truth.

to:

* DarkSecret: The trailer shows that Helena kept her distubing past a secret from her husband, as Stephen is initially confused when the police show up at his their house asking about his wife's father and says he was under the impression both her parents died in a car accident. Helena reluctantly states [[ILied "That's what I told you"]]. Considering that Helena's father is a notorious violent criminal who kidnapped and raped her mother, it wouldn't be surprising Helena wanted to put it all behind her and have a normal life, though later in the trailer Stephen tells her he wishes she'd told him the truth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FacialMarkings: Helena has faint dots tattoed across her cheeks, given to her by her father as a child; in the trailer she says "these were the only tears my father ever wanted to see".

to:

* FacialMarkings: Helena has faint dots tattoed tattooed across her cheeks, given to her by her father as a child; in the trailer she says "these were the only tears my father ever wanted to see".

Added: 279

Changed: 179

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheFilmOfTheBook: It's based on the 2017 novel of the same name.

to:

* FacialMarkings: Helena has faint dots tattoed across her cheeks, given to her by her father as a child; in the trailer she says "these were the only tears my father ever wanted to see".
* TheFilmOfTheBook: It's based on the 2017 novel of the same name. name.
* GreatEscape: The present-day plot is kicked off by Jacob Holbrook and another prisoner escaping from jail; the trailer shows them overpowering guards while being transported in a prison van, causing it to crash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkSecret: The trailer shows that Helena kept her distubing past a secret from her husband, as Stephen is initially confused when the police show up at his house asking about his wife's father and says he was under the impression both her parents died in a car accident. Helena reluctantly states [[ILied "That's what I told you"]]. Considering that Helena's father is a notorious violent criminal who kidnapped and raped her mother, the trailer implies Helena wanted to put it all behind her and have a normal life, though Stephen tells her he wishes she'd told him the truth.

to:

* DarkSecret: The trailer shows that Helena kept her distubing past a secret from her husband, as Stephen is initially confused when the police show up at his house asking about his wife's father and says he was under the impression both her parents died in a car accident. Helena reluctantly states [[ILied "That's what I told you"]]. Considering that Helena's father is a notorious violent criminal who kidnapped and raped her mother, the trailer implies it wouldn't be surprising Helena wanted to put it all behind her and have a normal life, though later in the trailer Stephen tells her he wishes she'd told him the truth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''The Marsh King's Daughter'' is an upcoming PsychologicalThriller film, based on the novel of the same name by Karen Dionne. The film was directed by Creator/NeilBurger, with the screenplay co-written by Mark L. Smith and Elle Smith. It stars Creator/DaisyRidley, Creator/BenMendelsohn, Creator/GarrettHedlund, Creator/GilBirmingham and Creator/CarenPistorius.

Helena Pelletier (Ridley) appears to be a normal woman living an idyllic life with her husband Stephen (Hedlund) and their daughters. However, her past is far from normal: she is the daughter of Jacob Holbrook (Mendelsohn), the notorious "Marsh King", a reclusive survivalist, kidnapper, rapist and murderer who abducted her mother (Pistorius) and held her captive in remote marshland for over a decade. Helena herself was raised in the wilderness, unaware she and her mother were Jacob's prisoners until she was ten years old. When Helena is informed that Jacob has recently escaped from prison, Helena fears for her family's safety. Using the survival skills her father taught her, Helena sets out to protect herself and her family, finally confronting the dark past she had tried to bury.

The film is set for release on November 3rd 2023. The trailer can be viewed [[https://youtu.be/FDnUVhLMqI0?si=lz8dPt95tVC0bd6t here]].
----
!!Tropes found here include:
* AnimalMotif: Deer come up repeatedly in the trailer, associated with Helena and her family. At the start of the trailer, Helena's daughter Miracle shows her mother a diorama she made of a baby deer's habitat, with rocks for the deer to hide from hunters behind, to which Helena replies it's a "smart deer". Helena is shown hunting a deer as a child and has a deer tattooed on her neck, explaining that her father gave her the tattoo when she made her first kill.
* ArchnemesisDad: The villain of the story is Jacob Holbrook, the evil father of main protagonist Helena Pelletier. He held her and her mother captive until Helena was ten and has recently escaped from prison. Helena fears he will now come after her and her family.
* BrokenPedestal: In the trailer, Helena says she admired her father as a child, with flashbacks to her childhood showing they had a close, affectionate relationship and that he taught her how to track and hunt animals. However, this was before Helena realised what an evil person her father was; in the trailer a now-grown Helena tells a police officer she hasn't spoken to her father since she was ten and she's shown to be terrified that he will come for her and her family, stating "I realised the person I believed in the most was really a monster".
* ChildByRape: Helena is this; the trailer states her father kidnapped her mother and held her captive in marshland for twelve years, with Helena being born during this time.
* DarkSecret: The trailer shows that Helena kept her distubing past a secret from her husband, as Stephen is initially confused when the police show up at his house asking about his wife's father and says he was under the impression both her parents died in a car accident. Helena reluctantly states [[ILied "That's what I told you"]]. Considering that Helena's father is a notorious violent criminal who kidnapped and raped her mother, the trailer implies Helena wanted to put it all behind her and have a normal life, though Stephen tells her he wishes she'd told him the truth.
* TheFilmOfTheBook: It's based on the 2017 novel of the same name.
* ProtectThisHouse: The trailer shows Helena securing her house's doors and windows, setting up traps and signals and patrolling the house with weapons due to her belief her father will try to break in.
* SlaveBrand: The trailer shows that Helena and Jacob have [[ThemedTattoos the same markings tattooed on their hands]], with Jacob saying it means "they're family". However, Gil Birmingham's character tells Helena "it means owned, not family. Don't confuse the two."
----

Top