Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheBigRedOne

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Infantry Division – aka "The Big Red One" – from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically that of Sam Fuller, who served in the 1st Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.

to:

The film follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, sergeant as members of the U.S. Army's 1st Infantry Division – aka "The Big Red One" – from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically that of Sam Fuller, who served in the 1st Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:310:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Big_Red_7257.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:310:https://static.[[quoteright:305:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Big_Red_7257.jpg]]
org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_big_red_one.jpeg]]



It follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Infantry Division – aka "The Big Red One" – from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically that of Sam Fuller, who served in the 1st Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.

The original release suffered from heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received lukewarm responses in the 1980s. In that time, the Director's cut and ReCut became common with the re-releases of ''Film/HeavensGate'', ''Film/OnceUponATimeInAmerica'', ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner''; and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long version. He died in 1997 but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to secure the restoration and release of ''The Big Red One: Reconstruction'' in 2004, which received significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's forty minutes longer than the original released version, with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.

to:

It The film follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Infantry Division – aka "The Big Red One" – from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically that of Sam Fuller, who served in the 1st Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.

The original release suffered from heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received a lukewarm responses response in the 1980s. In that time, Over the ensuing years, the Director's cut Cut and ReCut became common common, with the re-releases of ''Film/HeavensGate'', ''Film/OnceUponATimeInAmerica'', ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner''; and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long full-length version. He Fuller died in 1997 1997, but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to secure the restoration and release of ''The Big Red One: Reconstruction'' in 2004, which received significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's forty The ''Reconstruction'' cut is 40 minutes longer than the original released version, with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic American UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie written directed by Creator/SamuelFuller and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Creator/RobertCarradine, and Creator/MarkHamill.

to:

''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic American UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie film written and directed by Creator/SamuelFuller and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Creator/RobertCarradine, and Creator/MarkHamill.
Creator/MarkHamill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Big_Red_7257.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:300:https://static.[[quoteright:310:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Big_Red_7257.jpg]]



''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Creator/RobertCarradine, and Creator/MarkHamill.

It follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Division--"The Big Red One"--from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically the director Fuller's, who served in the US First Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.

The original version suffered heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received lukewarm responses in the 1980s. In that time, the Director's cut and ReCut became common with the re-releases of ''Film/HeavensGate'', ''Film/OnceUponATimeInAmerica'', ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner''; and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long version. He died in 1997 but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to restore ''The Big Red One : Reconstruction'' released in 2004 which received significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's 40 minutes longer than the original version with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.

to:

''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during American UsefulNotes/WorldWarII movie written directed by Creator/SamuelFuller and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Creator/RobertCarradine, and Creator/MarkHamill.

It follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Division--"The Infantry Division – aka "The Big Red One"--from One" – from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically the director Fuller's, that of Sam Fuller, who served in the US First 1st Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.

The original version release suffered from heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received lukewarm responses in the 1980s. In that time, the Director's cut and ReCut became common with the re-releases of ''Film/HeavensGate'', ''Film/OnceUponATimeInAmerica'', ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner''; and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long version. He died in 1997 but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to restore secure the restoration and release of ''The Big Red One : One: Reconstruction'' released in 2004 2004, which received significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's 40 forty minutes longer than the original version released version, with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.

Added: 250

Removed: 263

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActionGirl / BadassBystander: Civilian women are shown killing on several occasions; the Sicilian peasants who scythe a wounded German soldier, the Resistance woman cutting throats in the madhouse, and the Belgian innkeeper who shoots dead a German infiltrator.


Added DiffLines:

* BadassBystander: Civilian women are shown killing on several occasions; the Sicilian peasants who scythe a wounded German soldier, the Resistance woman cutting throats in the madhouse, and the Belgian innkeeper who shoots dead a German infiltrator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroicBSOD: Griff falls into a fugue state upon seeing [[spoiler:what was happening at Falkenau. When he comes across a living German soldier, he kills the man and keeps shooting at the body mindlessly until the Sergeant snaps him out of it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: Lampshaded at the end when it's pointed out the squad have more in common with the German soldier they're carrying to an aid station, than the replacements who were killed before they knew their names. Namely, that all of them are still alive.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: Lampshaded NotSoDifferentRemark: Used at the end when it's pointed out the squad have more in common with the German soldier they're carrying to an aid station, than the replacements who were killed before they knew their names. Namely, that all of them are still alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the sequence of shots of the dead soldier’s wristwatch, as the minute hand on the watch advances, the coloration of the water around the hand seems to become increasingly red.

Added: 790

Changed: 265

Removed: 373

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolOldGuy: Sarge might order his men to run into their deaths as necessary, but he's clearly neither heartless nor ineffective at being a sergeant.

to:

* CigarChomper: Zab has a cigar in his mouth very frequently, even keeping one in his mouth while landing in Omaha Beach where all of the water he's wading in naturally ruins it. This was based after Creator/SamuelFuller himself.
* CoolOldGuy: Sarge might order his men to run into their deaths as necessary, necessary and even push them forward with nearby shots, but he's clearly neither heartless nor ineffective at being a sergeant.



* FriendOrFoe: Sergeant Schroeder gets shot in the back by a Panzer's machine gun in the Kasserine Pass.



* MaleGaze: The camera stares at the rear of a woman walking before the party, which is an IronicEcho given Kaiser has just died and expressed a particular interest in female butts beforehand.



* TeamKiller: Schroeder gunned down one of his men who refused to continue fighting in his first scene. Creator/LeeMarvin's character is regarded by TheSquad as perfectly capable of this, and on Omaha Beach he starts shooting nearby Griff when he hesitates to run forward with the bangalore torpedo.



* UnfriendlyFire: Sergeant Schroeder gets shot in the back by a Panzer's machine gun in the Kasserine Pass. Earlier he'd gunned down one of his men who refused to continue fighting. Creator/LeeMarvin's character is regarded by TheSquad as perfectly capable of this, and on Omaha Beach he starts shooting at Griff when he hesitates to run forward with the bangalore torpedo.

Added: 2280

Changed: 1497

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The original version suffered heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received lukewarm responses in the 1980s. In that time, the Director's cut and ReCut became common with the re-releases of ''Film/HeavensGate'', ''Film/OnceUponATimeInAmerica'', ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner''; and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long version. He died in 1997 but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to restore ''The Big Red One : Reconstruction'' released in 2004 which recieved significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's 40 minutes longer than the original version with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.

to:

The original version suffered heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received lukewarm responses in the 1980s. In that time, the Director's cut and ReCut became common with the re-releases of ''Film/HeavensGate'', ''Film/OnceUponATimeInAmerica'', ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner''; and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long version. He died in 1997 but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to restore ''The Big Red One : Reconstruction'' released in 2004 which recieved received significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's 40 minutes longer than the original version with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.



* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:The squad saves Schroeder, but Zab realizes that so many others had died during the whole damn mess.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:The squad saves all survive and save Schroeder, but Zab realizes that so many others had died during the whole damn mess.]]



* {{Bookends}}: The movie opens - during UsefulNotes/WorldWarI - and ends - during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII - with Creator/LeeMarvin knifing Germans who both insist their wars are over. They're both right. [[spoiler: the squad is able to save the life of the second German in time.]]

to:

* {{Bookends}}: The movie opens - during UsefulNotes/WorldWarI - and ends - during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII - with Creator/LeeMarvin knifing Germans who both insist their wars are over. They're both right. [[spoiler: the [[spoiler:The squad is able to save the life of the second German in time.]]



* CoolOldGuy: Sarge.
* CreatorCameo (deleted scene): Sam Fuller plays a war correspondent.

to:

* CoolOldGuy: Sarge.
Sarge might order his men to run into their deaths as necessary, but he's clearly neither heartless nor ineffective at being a sergeant.
* CreatorCameo (deleted scene): Sam Fuller plays a war correspondent. correspondent.
* DeadMansTriggerFinger: A Vichy French officer is killed by one of his men while trying to man a machine gun after said officer shot another man for refusing to shoot at Americans, but the officer's finger ends up shooting the machine gun anyway and causing a battle for a little while.
* DeadpanSnarker: Zab, especially in some of his narrations.
--> ''You know how you smoke out a sniper? You send a guy out in the open and you see if he gets shot. They thought that one up at West Point.''



* DramaticAmmoDepletion: [[spoiler:When Griff opens the oven at Falkenau where a German soldier is hiding, he's only saved from the soldier's MP 40 being apparently empty after two attempts at a shot on him.]]
* EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep: Sarge/Sergeant is just that. No one ever says his actual name, and indeed no other sort of backstory or any other past information about him else is ever revealed about him.



* FriendToAllChildren: The Sarge.

to:

* FriendToAllChildren: The Sarge. He accepts Mateo's deal that they help him bury his mother in a good coffin to end up later getting him an even better coffin than agreed upon, as well as a young girl's gift to him by taking his helmet to decorate its netting with flowers before returning it. Sarge also tries to befriend and feed a boy that was imprisoned at Falkenau [[spoiler:but ends up having to bury the boy after he dies while sitting on Sarge's shoulders.]]



** Subverted by the one asylum resident who picks up a submachine gun and joins the battle, declaring himself sane in the process.

to:

** Subverted by the one asylum resident who picks up a submachine gun and joins the battle, battle (and also murdering one of the other patients), declaring himself sane in the process.process. Zab wryly notes that he did have trouble telling the difference between the two at that point.
* GroinAttack: A replacement asks the squad if he's going to get hit like all the other ones. He promptly triggers a tripwire mine that doesn't kill him, but does castrate him. Sarge tosses away one of his testicles and tells him that's why he was given two.



* MadeOfExplodium: By design, the Bangalore Torpedo is a big pipe bomb. One character has to assemble one of these while being shot at by the Germans. When he hesitates, Sarge shoots at him to keep him moving.

to:

* KarmaHoudini: Schroeder shoots another German dead for not wanting to fight and disliking Hitler and maintains his fellows' stillness during the ambush by the threat of death. [[spoiler:Schroeder survives the war, though only at the squad saving his life after Sarge stabs him as he was trying to surrender while Sarge was unaware the war was over]].
* MadeOfExplodium: By design, the Bangalore Torpedo is a big pipe bomb. One character has Griff ends up having to assemble one of these while being shot at by the Germans. When he hesitates, Sarge shoots at nearby him to keep him moving.



* MauveShirt: Kaiser likes Zab's writing, shown by enjoying the book he wrote, and survives an ambush orchestrated by Shroeder [[spoiler:but is later killed in a forest by a German. He managed to return the favor on the inflictor of his mortal wound and lasts just long enough to hear Sarge tell him yes after asking Sarge if Kaiser killed the man who killed him.]]



* NotSoDifferent: Lampshaded at the end when it's pointed out the squad have more in common with the German soldier they're carrying to an aid station, than the replacements who were killed before they knew their names.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: Lampshaded at the end when it's pointed out the squad have more in common with the German soldier they're carrying to an aid station, than the replacements who were killed before they knew their names. Namely, that all of them are still alive.



** Was one of the first war movies to not focus on a specific battle or person, detailing instead the drudgery and sudden shocks that happen in every battlefield any Army unit enters.
* RedShirt: Replacements get killed, but not the 'four horsemen' veterans who've learned to survive on the battlefield.

to:

** Was The film was one of the first war movies to not focus on a specific battle or person, detailing instead the drudgery and sudden shocks that happen in every battlefield any Army unit enters.
* RedShirt: Replacements get killed, but not the 'four horsemen' veterans who've learned to survive on the battlefield. Said veterans end up not bothering to learn the replacements' names.



* ScreamingBirth

to:

* ScreamingBirthScreamingBirth: Further complicated by Johnson and Sarge feeling the pressure of trying to help a woman give birth while not knowing French and being quite unequipped for it.



* SpotTheImposter (deleted scene): During the Battle of the Bulge the men are dining at a Belgian inn; the woman who owns it realises one of them is a German infiltrator from the way he eats.

to:

* SpotTheImposter (deleted scene): During the Battle of the Bulge the men are dining at a Belgian inn; the woman who owns it realises realizes one of them is a German infiltrator from the way he eats.



* TakingYouWithMe: [[spoiler:Kaiser is shot by a German in a smoky forest, but manages to kill his assailant. Kaiser lives just long enough to ask Sarge if he killed the man who got him and hear him reply yes.]]



* ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill: [[spoiler:After discovering human bones inside Falkenau's ovens, Griff fills the German soldier he finds hiding in one of them ([[DramaticAmmoDepletion who was fortunately out of ammunition]]) with so many rounds, the rest of the squad hears it to notice something's off and Sarge comes over to him.]]



--> ''""We'd all made it through we were alive. I'm gonna dedicate my book to those who shot but didn't get shot, because it's about survivors. And surviving is the only glory in war, if you know what I mean."''

to:

--> ''""We'd ''"We'd all made it through we were alive. I'm gonna dedicate my book to those who shot but didn't get shot, because it's about survivors. And surviving is the only glory in war, if you know what I mean."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilTwin: Schroeder, the German sergeant who keeps popping up on the opposite side of the battlefield from our heroes. [[spoiler:He's the German that Sarge stabs on the eve of Germany's surrender.]]

to:

* EvilTwin: EvilCounterpart: Schroeder, the German sergeant who keeps popping up on the opposite side of the battlefield from our heroes. [[spoiler:He's the German that Sarge stabs on the eve of Germany's surrender.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Robert Carradine, and Creator/MarkHamill.

to:

''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Robert Carradine, Creator/RobertCarradine, and Creator/MarkHamill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The original version suffered heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received lukewarm responses in the 1980s. In that time, the Director's cut and ReCut became common with the re-release of ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner'' and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long version. He died in 1997 but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to restore ''The Big Red One : Reconstruction'' released in 2004 which recieved significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's 40 minutes longer than the original version with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.

to:

The original version suffered heavy ExecutiveMeddling and received lukewarm responses in the 1980s. In that time, the Director's cut and ReCut became common with the re-release re-releases of ''Film/HeavensGate'', ''Film/OnceUponATimeInAmerica'', ''Film/LawrenceOfArabia'' and ''Film/BladeRunner'' ''Film/BladeRunner''; and Fuller hoped for a restoration of his long version. He died in 1997 but his widow Christa Fuller and film historian Richard Schickel managed to restore ''The Big Red One : Reconstruction'' released in 2004 which recieved significant acclaim and allowed the film to be VindicatedByHistory as one of the greatest and most accurate WarMovies ever made. It's 40 minutes longer than the original version with new scenes and sequences clarifying and deepening the story.

Added: 442

Changed: 444

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Robert Carradine and Creator/MarkHamill. It follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Division--"The Big Red One"--from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically the director Fuller's, who served in the US First Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.

to:

''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Robert Carradine Carradine, and Creator/MarkHamill. Creator/MarkHamill.

It follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Division--"The Big Red One"--from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically the director Fuller's, who served in the US First Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Subverted by the one asylum resident who picks up a rifle and joins the battle, declaring himself sane in the process.

to:

** Subverted by the one asylum resident who picks up a rifle submachine gun and joins the battle, declaring himself sane in the process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Robert Carradine and Creator/MarkHamill. It follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically the director Fuller's, who served in the US First Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.

to:

''The Big Red One'' (1980) is a classic war movie directed by Creator/SamuelFuller, set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and starring Creator/LeeMarvin, Robert Carradine and Creator/MarkHamill. It follows a [[TheSquad squad of soldiers]] and their GrizzledVeteran sergeant from sergeant, members of the U.S. Army's 1st Division--"The Big Red One"--from the beginning of America's participation in the war in the African and European theater to the end. This film is BasedOnATrueStory, specifically the director Fuller's, who served in the US First Infantry Division during the war and observed and participated in many of the events the film depicts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A Man Is Not A Virgin is no longer a trope.


* AManIsNotAVirgin: Griff gets some grief among his buddies for being a little too shy around women. [[spoiler:Zab spots Griff providing cover for the LaResistance woman during the asylum raid and grins mischievously.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to the Trivia tab.


* CaliforniaDoubling: Most of the film was shot in Israel. Led to a HarsherInHindsight moment for the director when he noticed a large number of film extras take off their German helmets to reveal their Jewish yarmulkes during lunch breaks.
** Handwaved when someone asks what palm trees are doing in a Belgian monastery. Apparently the monk "had a yen for them".

Changed: 235

Removed: 327

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* UsefulNotes/GaulsWithGrenades: In this case, Vichy and Moroccan Goumier soldiers.



* UsefulNotes/NazisWithGnarlyWeapons
* UsefulNotes/NewRomanLegions: The squad, and pretty much the rest of the 1st Infantry fights Italian troops when they hit the Sicilian beaches.



* UsefulNotes/WorldWarI: The story actually starts with "Sarge" scouting on Nov 11, 1918, and [[spoiler:killing a German soldier after the 11 am official end to the War. It's bookended with the German Sergeant at the end of the movie]]
* UsefulNotes/WorldWarII: Well, duh.
* UsefulNotes/YanksWithTanks

to:

* UsefulNotes/WorldWarI: The story actually starts with "Sarge" scouting on Nov 11, 1918, and [[spoiler:killing a German soldier after the 11 am official end to the War. It's bookended with the German Sergeant at the end of the movie]]
* UsefulNotes/WorldWarII: Well, duh.
* UsefulNotes/YanksWithTanks
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ValuesDissonance: This is in fact a theme of the film. Soldiers by definition have to be killers during wartime but not peacetime. These circumstances are defined, as Sarge explains to Griff, by their leaders and politicians who arrange an armistice, after which killing is not permitted anymore and a soldier has in fact committed murder. The difference between the two actions is shown to be more meaningful to Sarge, an old soldier from WW1 than it is to the far younger squad of Zab and Griff.

to:

** ValuesDissonance: This is in fact a theme of the film. Soldiers by definition have to be killers during wartime but not peacetime. These circumstances are defined, as Sarge explains to Griff, by their leaders and politicians who arrange an armistice, after which killing is not permitted anymore and a soldier has in fact committed murder. The difference between the two actions is shown to be more meaningful to Sarge, an old soldier from WW1 UsefulNotes/WW1 than it is to the far younger squad of Zab and Griff.

Top