Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / SherlockHolmesAGameOfShadows

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SequelAdaptationIconicCharacter: While the firstt movie featured a CanonForeigner as the movie, this movie's BigBad is the ''Sherlock Holmes''-franchise's BreakoutVillain, Sherlock's EvilCounterpart Professor James Moriaty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagicPlasticSurgery: [[spoiler:Sim's brother is made to look like one of the ambassadors as part of the peace summit plot. The "magic" part is averted, though, in that when trying to identify him, Sim and Watson look for exactly the sort of telltale clues that this trope usually ignores. It also probably helps that the guest list uses sketched portraits, not photographs, so Renee's disguise doesn't have to be a perfect replication.]]

to:

* MagicPlasticSurgery: [[spoiler:Sim's brother is made to look like one of the ambassadors as part of the peace summit plot. The "magic" part is averted, though, in that when trying to identify him, Sim and Watson look for exactly the sort of telltale clues that this trope usually ignores.ignores, such as the scars that he has to hide. It also probably helps that the guest list uses sketched portraits, not photographs, so Renee's disguise doesn't have to be a perfect replication.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* ProchronicProduct: Sherlock Holmes invented an adrenaline autoinjector in 1891, about 10 years before adrenaline was discovered in real life and 92 years before autoinjectors became widely available.

Added: 458

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AttackTheInjury: [[spoiler:When Holmes and Moriarty mentally plan out how a fight between then would go, both realise that Holmes is at a significant disadvantage due to the shoulder injury Moriarty inflicted upon him earlier in the film. Moriarty mercilessly exploits the injury, gets the upper hand, and throws Sherlock off the balcony. So when the fight is about to start for real, Sherlock [[TakingYouWithMe decides to do something a bit different]].]]



* {{Understatement}}: When Moriarty sends thugs to kill Watson and Mary as they travel to Brighton for their honeymoon, Holmes attempts to empathise by describing the situation as 'terribly inconvenient.' It doesn't quite do their predicament justice.

to:

* {{Understatement}}: When Moriarty sends thugs to kill Watson and Mary as they travel to Brighton for their honeymoon, Holmes attempts to empathise by describing the situation as 'terribly "terribly inconvenient.' " It doesn't quite do their predicament justice.



* UnitConfusion: The 6-8 miles per hour side-wind in which Moran makes his famous shot. That wind speed would barely move the air, let alone a bullet. The conditions portrayed in the flashback and which would make the shot the nigh-superhuman feat it is described as are far more in line with a 6-8 ''feet per second'' wind speed.( Which is between 4 and 5 1/2 miles per hour).

to:

* UnitConfusion: The 6-8 miles per hour side-wind in which Moran makes his famous shot. That wind speed would barely move the air, let alone a bullet. The conditions portrayed in the flashback and which would make the shot the nigh-superhuman feat it is described as are far more in line with a 6-8 ''feet per second'' wind speed.( Which speed (which is between 4 and 5 1/2 miles per hour).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HandwritingAsCharacterization: The first time Sherlock Holmes meets Professor Moriarty, he asks for an autograph, then conducts an on-the-spot graphological analysis:
-->'''Holmes:''' The upward strokes on the 'p', the 'j', the 'm', indicate a genius level intellect, while the flourishes in the lower zone denote a highly creative, yet meticulous nature... but if one observers the overall slant and the pressure of the writing, there's suggestion of acute narcissism, a complete lack of empathy, and a pronounced inclination toward-
-->'''Moriarty:''' No.
-->'''Holmes:''' Moral insanity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObfuscatingPostmortemWounds: Moriarity's plot to launch a WarForFunAndProfit involves having a sniper kill a prominent German arms mogul at a Franco-German peace conference, then having BombThrowingAnarchists blow up the conference moments later. This is to [[SerialKillingsSpecificTarget cover up the targeted killing]], since nobody (except Sherlock Holmes, of course) would look for a bullet hole in a bombing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChessMotifs: All over the place, especially in the GrandFinale, which consists largely of a literal chess game between Holmes and Moriarty. The game itself is based on a real life game between Bent Larson (Holmes) and Tigran Petrosian (Moriarty) in 1966 (with the colors inverted), with the pieces and moves on the board mirroring what's going on in the ballroom. The finale is changed, with Moriarty continuing past where Petrosian resigned. Even as the characters stop directly commenting on how each move mirror an in story event, it keeps happening (Holmes reveals he knows about the red book, and checks Moriarty. Moriarty fingers his pocket, realizes the book is still there, blocks the check, feeling confident he's foiled Holmes, only for Holmes to reveal he's already swapped the book, much like how on the board he's already got his pieces in position to checkmate Moriarty, who all along was powerless to stop the real checkmate).

to:

* ChessMotifs: All over the place, especially in the GrandFinale, which consists largely of a literal chess game between Holmes and Moriarty. The game itself is based on a real life game between Bent Larson (Holmes) and Tigran Petrosian (Moriarty) in 1966 (with the colors inverted), with the pieces and moves on the board mirroring what's going on in the ballroom. The finale is changed, with Moriarty continuing past where Petrosian resigned. Even as the characters stop directly commenting on how each move mirror an in story event, it keeps happening (Holmes happening. Holmes reveals he knows about the red book, and checks Moriarty. Moriarty fingers his pocket, realizes the book is still there, blocks the check, feeling confident he's foiled Holmes, only for Holmes to reveal he's already swapped the book, much like how on the board he's already got his pieces in position to checkmate Moriarty, who all along was powerless to stop the real checkmate).checkmate. Similarly the game ends with a "discover check"[[note]]when a piece is moved out of the way, allowing another piece to now check the king thanks to no longer being blocked[[/note]] - which mirrors the whole exchange - Moriarty was defeated before this all started, he only realized it when Holmes told him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChessMotifs: All over the place, especially in the GrandFinale, which consists largely of a literal chess game between Holmes and Moriarty.

to:

* ChessMotifs: All over the place, especially in the GrandFinale, which consists largely of a literal chess game between Holmes and Moriarty. The game itself is based on a real life game between Bent Larson (Holmes) and Tigran Petrosian (Moriarty) in 1966 (with the colors inverted), with the pieces and moves on the board mirroring what's going on in the ballroom. The finale is changed, with Moriarty continuing past where Petrosian resigned. Even as the characters stop directly commenting on how each move mirror an in story event, it keeps happening (Holmes reveals he knows about the red book, and checks Moriarty. Moriarty fingers his pocket, realizes the book is still there, blocks the check, feeling confident he's foiled Holmes, only for Holmes to reveal he's already swapped the book, much like how on the board he's already got his pieces in position to checkmate Moriarty, who all along was powerless to stop the real checkmate).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DemotedToExtra: Inspector Lestrade gets hit by this. He may not have been one of the most central characters in the first, but he still had a decent amount of scenes and relevance to the plot. In the second movie, he is entirely left out, only briefly appearing at the end with few lines. His sergeant gets about the same amount of screentime, though he had a number of scenes in the original film as well.

to:

* DemotedToExtra: Inspector Lestrade gets hit by this. He may not have been one of the most central characters in the first, but he still had a decent amount of scenes and relevance to the plot. In the second movie, he is entirely left out, only briefly appearing at the end with few lines. His sergeant gets about the same amount of screentime, though he had a number of scenes in the original film as well. It's justified in that much of the movie takes place outside of London, where Lestrade operates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the film, eccentric amateur detective Holmes and his companion Watson travel across Europe with a gypsy adventuress to foil an intricate plot by their cunning nemesis, Professor Moriarty. The film follows an original premise incorporating elements of Conan Doyle's short stories "The Final Problem" and "The Empty House".

to:

In the film, eccentric amateur detective Holmes and his companion Watson travel across Europe UsefulNotes/{{Europe}} with a gypsy adventuress to foil an intricate plot by their cunning nemesis, Professor Moriarty. The film follows an original premise incorporating elements of Conan Doyle's short stories "The Final Problem" and "The Empty House".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequelHook: While [[spoiler:Moriarty dies in the end by means of the famous [[DisneyVillainDeath Reichenbach Falls fight]] and is plan is unsuccessful, Moran--who was immensely loyal to him and enraged when he almost got killed before--is shown to have escaped and still be at large. Also, the world has yet to know Holmes [[DisneyDeath survived the fall himself]] and given he only hints at that to Watson rather than outright reveals himself to him,]] he may want to keep it that way for the time being.

to:

* SequelHook: While [[spoiler:Moriarty dies in the end by means of the famous [[DisneyVillainDeath Reichenbach Falls fight]] and is his plan is unsuccessful, Moran--who was immensely loyal to him and enraged when he almost got killed before--is shown to have escaped and still be at large. Also, the world has yet to know Holmes [[DisneyDeath survived the fall himself]] and given he only hints at that to Watson rather than outright reveals himself to him,]] he may want to keep it that way for the time being.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SequelHook: While [[spoiler:Moriarty dies in the end by means of the famous [[DisneyVillainDeath Reichenbach Falls fight]] and is plan is unsuccessful, Moran--who was immensely loyal to him and enraged when he almost got killed before--is shown to have escaped and still be at large. Also, the world has yet to know Holmes [[DisneyDeath survived the fall himself]] and given he only hints at that to Watson rather than outright reveals himself to him,]] he may want to keep it that way for the time being.

Added: 319

Changed: 79

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Again in the finale [[spoiler:when Sherlock has started his sacrifice and Watson steps out onto the balcony, which would have guaranteed Moriarty's defeat had the fight actually broken out.]]

to:

** Again in the finale [[spoiler:when Sherlock has started his sacrifice and Watson steps out onto the balcony, which would have almost guaranteed Moriarty's defeat had the fight actually broken out.out. Holmes isn't willing to take the chance, and sacrifices himself anyway.]]


Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler:Neither man foresaw Watson stepping outside, which would've greatly improved Holmes' chances. Holmes still decides to take the near-certain odds of TakingYouWithMe rather than risk Watson. Similarly, Moriarty didn't consider the idea that Holmes would sacrifice himself, on account of being a sociopath.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BookedFullOfMooks: Irene Adler chooses to meet with Professor Moriarity for tea at her favorite restaurant, expecting he'd kill her for outliving her usefulness if they met in private. However, he reveals that he bribed everyone in the restaurant to leave at once, [[spoiler:giving him the privacy needed to dispatch with her.]]

Added: 21

Changed: 421

Removed: 404

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BattleInTheCenterOfTheMind: Holmes and Moriarty have an AwesomenessByAnalysis-off as they plan their attacks.
** Though the twist is that it's showing exactly how a real fist-fight ''would'' go if they went for it. They just both happen to be predicting the same sequence of events [[spoiler:in which Moriarty wins and throws Holmes off the balcony. To avoid this, Holmes blows the ashes of his pipe into Moriarty's eyes, temporarily blinding him and giving Holmes enough time to send them both over the balcony]].

to:

* BattleInTheCenterOfTheMind: Holmes and Moriarty have an AwesomenessByAnalysis-off as they plan their attacks.
**
attacks. Though the twist is that it's showing exactly how a real fist-fight ''would'' go if they went for it. They just both happen to be predicting the same sequence of events [[spoiler:in which Moriarty wins and throws Holmes off the balcony. To avoid this, Holmes blows the ashes of his pipe into Moriarty's eyes, temporarily blinding him and giving Holmes enough time to send them both over the balcony]].



* FanDisservice: Naked Stephen Fry.

to:

* FanDisservice: FanDisservice:
**
Naked Stephen Fry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InvoluntaryCharityDonation: [[spoiler:The assets seized from Moriarty by the police are used to make an anonymous donation to the Widows and Orphans of War fund. Because Moriarty is TheSociopath, he doesn't have any person he cares about. But his war chest? That stabs Moriarty as badly as his killing Irene did to Sherlock. The donation recipient is just the final insult of the deed by Sherlock.]]

to:

* InvoluntaryCharityDonation: [[spoiler:The assets seized from Moriarty by the police are used to make an anonymous donation to the Widows and Orphans of War fund. Because Moriarty is TheSociopath, he doesn't have any person he cares about. But Holmes directing the authorities to seize his war chest? That stabs Moriarty as badly as his killing Irene did to Sherlock. The donation recipient is just the final insult of the deed by Sherlock.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope


* NeatFreak: Mycroft is implied to be this. Doesn't like to shake hands, barely goes anywhere other than his home and office, carries [[ChekhovsGun a personal supply of oxygen]]... even his habit of walking around his house naked could be a reference to SuperOCD sufferer Creator/HowardHughes, and / or the biopic, ''Film/TheAviator''.

to:

* NeatFreak: Mycroft is implied to be this. Doesn't like to shake hands, barely goes anywhere other than his home and office, carries [[ChekhovsGun a personal supply of oxygen]]... even his habit of walking around his house naked could be a reference to SuperOCD OCD sufferer Creator/HowardHughes, and / or the biopic, ''Film/TheAviator''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows'' is a 2011 British-American action mystery film directed by Creator/GuyRitchie and produced by Joel Silver, Lionel Wigram, Susan Downey and Dan Lin. It is a sequel to the 2009 film ''Film/{{Sherlock Holmes|2009}}'', and likewise features the Franchise/SherlockHolmes and Dr. John Watson characters created by Sir Creator/ArthurConanDoyle. The screenplay was written by Michele Mulroney and Kieran Mulroney. Creator/RobertDowneyJr and Creator/JudeLaw reprise their roles as Holmes and Watson and were joined by Creator/NoomiRapace as Simza, Creator/StephenFry as Mycroft Holmes and Jared Harris as Professor Moriarty.

to:

''Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows'' is a 2011 British-American action mystery film directed by Creator/GuyRitchie and produced by Joel Silver, Lionel Wigram, Susan Downey and Dan Lin. It is a sequel to the 2009 film ''Film/{{Sherlock Holmes|2009}}'', and likewise features the Franchise/SherlockHolmes and Dr. John Watson characters created by Sir Creator/ArthurConanDoyle. The screenplay was written by Michele Mulroney and Kieran Mulroney. Creator/RobertDowneyJr and Creator/JudeLaw reprise their roles as Holmes and Watson and were joined by Creator/NoomiRapace as Simza, Creator/StephenFry as Mycroft Holmes and Jared Harris Creator/JaredHarris as Professor Moriarty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GPSEvidence: When looking at some letters that Simza's brother Rene has sent her, Holmes and Watson notice that they are of the stock used by a printing press, and are musty, as if stored in a damp place. A wine stain on one of the sheets allows Holmes to conclude that they were from a wine cellar near a printing press, which is how they locate the anarchist leader Claude Ravache.

to:

* GPSEvidence: When looking at some letters that Simza's brother Rene has sent her, Holmes and Watson notice that they are of the stock used by a printing press, and are musty, as if stored in a damp place. A wine stain on one of the sheets allows Holmes to conclude that they were from a wine cellar near a printing press, which is how they locate the anarchist leader Claude Ravache. Less egregious than most examples, however. The only deduction Holmes and Watson make is reasonable but non-specific. They then simply ask Sim if their deduction means anything to her, and she immediately points to the anarchists and Ravache.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Viewers may spot that Holmes’ deduction that the bomb [[spoiler: is at the opera is wrong well before Holmes himself. Moran is shown bringing two Don Giovanni tickets to Professor Moriarty, only to be told that he (Moran) won’t be needing his. Why would Moriarty be attending an opera where his bomb was set to go off?]]

Added: 279

Removed: 148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SerialKillingsSpecificTarget: Moriarty bombs an entire hotel full of industrialists in order to obfuscate Moran's murder of one specific delegate.


Added DiffLines:

* SmokescreenCrime: Professor Moriarty arranges for a group of [[BombThrowingAnarchist anarchists to bomb the conference room]] at a peace summit in Paris, as a diversion from the sniper he employed to shoot one of the [=VIPs=] at the conference immediately before the explosion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AluminiumChristmasTrees: It wasn't unheard of for British aristocrats to walk around naked in front of their servants, who were [[ValuesDissonance regarded as part of the furniture]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: {{Averted|Trope}}. Among the various actors who have played Mycroft Holmes, Creator/StephenFry is one of the very few who is genuinely fat, as Mycroft was described in Conan Doyle's stories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* UpToEleven: Almost every trope in the first film is cranked up in the second.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Shortly before Watson has one when he holds up his cap to the small gap between the gun's barrel and shield, only for Moran to instantly put a bullet through it.

to:

*** Shortly before Watson has one when he [[OutfitDecoy holds up his cap cap]] to the small gap between the gun's barrel and shield, only for Moran to instantly put a bullet through it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheEndOrIsIt: [[spoiler:A Not Quite Dead Sherlock sneaks into the room where Watson is typing the story of their adventure and types a question mark after "THE END" in Watson's manuscript.]]

to:

* TheEndOrIsIt: [[spoiler:A [[spoiler:[[InvokedTrope Invoked]] by a Not Quite Dead Sherlock Sherlock. He sneaks into the room where Watson is typing the story of their adventure and types a question mark after "THE END" in Watson's manuscript.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoSympathyBetweenMooks: A set of flat-cap wearing twins are Moriarty's main two enforcers besides Moran, frequently seen following the latter's orders throughout the film, and both are [[spoiler:killed consecutively during the escape from Heilbronn]]. However, after the first twin [[spoiler:is shot down]], the second twin callously [[spoiler:shoves his fallen "brother" aside to get a better shot before being killed himself instead of going to his aid]]. It is this apparent lack of even basic sibling loyalty that tips Holmes and Watson off to the fact that [[spoiler:they're not actually twins, but a surgical experiment aimed to make one man resemble another.]]



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MauveShirt: Of the party of gypsies that accompany Holmes, Watson and Simza to Moriarty's factory in Heilbronn, only Tamas is given any sort of characterisation, as the guy who stole Watson's scarf. Though he has little few lines and little screentime, he is immediately identifiable because of the scarf, and eventually is allowed to keep it by Watson. [[spoiler:As such, he is the only gypsy besides Simza to survive the escape from the factory, and becomes a crucial element to Holmes' plan to undermine Moriarty's entire fortune by delivering his stolen ledger to Mary, allowing her to decode it.]]

Added: 3153

Changed: 252

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGunman: Tamas is only really established as the guy who stole and kept Watson's cool scarf, and is the only other gypsy besides Simza given any decent amount of screentime. [[spoiler:After surviving Heilbronn, Holmes offhandedly mentions that he has an errand for him to run, and he disappears from the film from that point on. That is, until the climax, where the errand is revealed: delivering Moriarty's stolen ledger to Mary and Scotland Yard for them to decode, allowing them to seize Moriarty's entire fortune.]]



* FreezeFrameBonus: Pay close attention: when Moriarty first joins Holmes on the balcony, Holmes [[spoiler:is taking a puff on Mycroft's oxygen device. He quickly palms it, distracts Moriarty by having him set up their chess game, and then slips it back into his pocket.]]

to:

* FreezeFrameBonus: FreezeFrameBonus:
** During the opening scene with Irene, Moriarty's bodyguard escorts can be seen casually walking by in the background of multiple shots before Holmes points them out.
** When Holmes and Watson enter Simza's gypsy camp searching for her, Simza herself can be seen hidden amongst the crowd of gypsies behind Holmes, just out of focus, warily watching them until Holmes explains that it is about her brother, upon which she reveals herself.
**
Pay close attention: when Moriarty first joins Holmes on the balcony, Holmes [[spoiler:is taking a puff on Mycroft's oxygen device. He quickly palms it, distracts Moriarty by having him set up their chess game, and then slips it back into his pocket.]]


Added DiffLines:

* SpottingTheThread: Moriarty's final plot is revealed to hinge around henchmen and assassins [[spoiler:surgically modified to convincingly resemble other people]]. The henchmen seen in question are a set of unnamed "twins" and Simza's brother Rene, [[spoiler:both of whom are exposed by very subtle details.]]
** The twins are exposed as [[spoiler:not actually being twins]] during the escape from Heilbronn. [[spoiler:Holmes and Watson gun down one of the twins, only for the other coming up behind to callously shove his "brother's" corpse aside. The action, though quick, is enough to cause both Holmes and Watson to pause, and later it is the smoking gun to Holmes' revelation that they were not actually brothers.]]
** Rene is [[spoiler:surgically disguised as one of the ambassadors attending the Reichenbach peace summit, and attempts to spot him conventionally fail as Rene's disguise and performance are nigh-impeccable. Watson, however, manages to expose him by suddenly knocking over a plate of wineglasses - the other ambassadors all turn in surprise, but as Holmes explains, Rene's performance was ''too'' perfect; he was too consumed with his own performance that he could not adapt to sudden and spontaneous events, and he is the only ambassador to not react whatsoever.]]
--->'''Holmes:''' [[spoiler:So perhaps it's the opposite. A ''failure'' to behave naturally. An actor so consumed with his performance that the only characteristic he cannot accommodate... is spontaneous reaction.]]


Added DiffLines:

* SurgicalImpersonation: A key element of Moriarty's plot is revealed to be [[spoiler:the use of assassins surgically modified to resemble other people, courtesy of Dr Hoffmanstahl, a master surgeon under Moriarty's employ. Moriarty's "twin" henchmen are revealed to be an early experiment into this, and his final plot centres around causing an international incident by disguising his assassin Rene as an ambassador via surgery.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PoisonedDrinkDrop: Irene Adler has tea in her favorite restaurant, but is confronted by Professor Moriarty, who just had his plans thwarted by Sherlock Holmes. He admits he doesn't blame her for the plan's failure but also dismisses her from his employ. Adler, who had just had a few sips from a cup of poisoned tea hastily departs, but not before collapsing and pulling down a table setting offscreen, which crashes in the process.

Top