Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / RaiseTheTitanic

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tried to fix some Justifying Edits/misuse of Justified Trope


* ArtisticLicenseMarineBiology: At a press conference, Admiral Sandecker states that the ''Titanic'' is probably very well preserved because it lies in water so deep that there are no destructive marine organisms that could have damaged it. In reality, ''Titanic'' has suffered heavy deterioration from microbial lifeforms that are slowly consuming the iron in the ship's hull, leaving behind the famous "rusticles"; likewise, wood-boring molluscs have consumed most of the wood in and on the ship.[[note]]The rate of deterioration is such that current estimates state that ''Titanic'' will collapse completely sometime in the 2030s.[[/note]] ''Titanic'' as a whole has been referred to as a deep-sea oasis, as it has been colonized by hundreds of deep-sea life forms, including some previously unknown to science. The trope is justified given that very little deep-ocean research had been done when the movie was filmed and no one knew what conditions were like on the wreck.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMarineBiology: At a press conference, Admiral Sandecker states that the ''Titanic'' is probably very well preserved because it lies in water so deep that there are no destructive marine organisms that could have damaged it. In reality, ''Titanic'' has suffered heavy deterioration from microbial lifeforms that are slowly consuming the iron in the ship's hull, leaving behind the famous "rusticles"; likewise, wood-boring molluscs have consumed most of the wood in and on the ship.[[note]]The rate of deterioration is such that current estimates state that ''Titanic'' will collapse completely sometime in the 2030s.[[/note]] ''Titanic'' as a whole has been referred to as a deep-sea oasis, as it has been colonized by hundreds of deep-sea life forms, including some previously unknown to science. The trope This is justified given that a case of DatedHistory: when the movie was filmed, very little deep-ocean research had been done when the movie was filmed done, and no one knew what conditions were like on the wreck.



* ShipshapeShipwreck: The film makers can be forgiven for [[DatedHistory getting it wrong about the Titanic splitting into two before it sank]]. However, the ship re-emerges at the surface after a dramatic sinking, a two mile plunge to the bottom of the Atlantic and 68 years underwater almost completely intact, to the extent that masts, funnels and metal guidewires are still in position. Even Titanic's famous glass dome survived.
** Justified by reflecting other assumptions widely believed about the wreck at the time--that the deep, cold, oxygen-poor, salty water the ship would have (and did) come to rest in was not hospitable to the sort of marine life that could compromise it structurally and would preserve it mostly intact, as if it were in cold storage. Today, now that we know otherwise, it is seen as likely that by the mid-21st century all that will be left of ''Titanic'' will be a big rusty spot on the sea floor.

to:

* ShipshapeShipwreck: ShipshapeShipwreck:
**
The film makers can be forgiven for [[DatedHistory getting it wrong about the Titanic splitting into two before it sank]]. However, the ship re-emerges at the surface after a dramatic sinking, a two mile plunge to the bottom of the Atlantic and 68 years underwater almost completely intact, to the extent that masts, funnels and metal guidewires are still in position. Even Titanic's famous glass dome survived.
** Justified by reflecting other
survived. [[DatedHistory This reflects various assumptions widely believed about the wreck at the time--that time]]--that the deep, cold, oxygen-poor, salty water the ship would have (and did) come to rest in was not hospitable to the sort of marine life that could compromise it structurally and would preserve it mostly intact, as if it were in cold storage. Today, now that we know otherwise, it is seen as likely that by the mid-21st century all that will be left of ''Titanic'' will be a big rusty spot on the sea floor.

Added: 852

Changed: 116

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: Pitt's best friend Al Giordino and close friend Rudi Gunn, important characters in the novel, (In fact, in nearly the entire novel series) are absent in the film. They don't have any similar counterparts, either. Instead it's Gene Seagram who partners with Pitt.



* DemotedToExtra: Dana Seagram is the female lead in the novel, even ending up on the Titanic herself. In the film, she gets only a few scenes, and never is on the ship. Capt. Prevlov fares better, but even he suffers from this, serving as a BigBad in the novel but being pretty easily defeated due to the climax of the film being drastically altered.



* TheFilmOfTheBook

to:

* TheFilmOfTheBookTheFilmOfTheBook: It's based on Clive Cussler's novel of the same name.



* SupportingProtagonist: Ironically, the novel's main lead, Dirk Pitt, ends up as this, with the role of James Sandecker beefed up, likely due to the casting of Creator/JasonRobards who ends up top billed in the film proper.



* VehicleTitle

to:

* VehicleTitleVehicleTitle: The film is about raising the sunken vessel, the Titanic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* DoubleMeaning: Brewster's crypic last words "Thank God for Southby".

to:

* DoubleMeaning: Brewster's crypic cryptic last words "Thank God for Southby".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In addition, the ''Turtle'' is at a depth of 11,000 ft and says they have ''Starfish'' in visual contact. Natural sunlight isn't able to penetrate the ocean depths beyond 3,000 ft, and most submersible lights don't have visibility beyond 10 ft.

to:

** In addition, the ''Turtle'' is at a depth of 11,000 ft and says they have ''Starfish'' in visual contact. Natural sunlight isn't able to penetrate the ocean depths beyond 3,000 ft, and most submersible lights don't have visibility beyond 10 100 ft.

Added: 682

Changed: 433

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after two minutes despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, where the pressure is about 6000 pounds per square inch, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was even aware of a problem; if such a leak had occurred, the water would have been forced through the breach with enough force to slice through a human body.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: ArtisticLicensePhysics:
**
The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after two minutes despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, where the pressure is about 6000 pounds per square inch, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was even aware of a problem; if such a leak had occurred, the water would have been forced through the breach with enough force to slice through a human body.
** In addition, the ''Turtle'' is at a depth of 11,000 ft and says they have ''Starfish'' in visual contact. Natural sunlight isn't able to penetrate the ocean depths beyond 3,000 ft, and most submersible lights don't have visibility beyond 10 ft.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They can't be forgiven for leaving the first smokestack undamaged and the second smokestack being the one fractured and mostly missing, as numerous eyewitnesses saw the first smokestack fall during the final plunge.
*** Ironically, Cussler gets the damage a bit more accurate in the novel than the film chooses to. As described in the novel, Titanic has lost her forward three smokestacks (As she did in the actual sinking) and the fourth has fallen and is lying on the deck. While the ship is inaccurately whole, Cussler at least gave the novel version of the ship logical damage to have suffered on the way down.

Added: 1434

Changed: 1078

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The searchers find a cornet belonging to a member of the ship's orchestra. However, ''Titanic'' did not have any brass musicians; the orchestra played string instruments. The only brass instrument on board was a bugle used by the ship's bugler to announce dinner for First Class, but he was not part of the orchestra.
* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after two minutes despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, where the pressure is about 6000 pounds per square inch, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was even aware of a problem.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseChemistry: The cornet that the search team recovers is not only in perfect condition, but is clean and shiny within a day or two of being brought up from the seafloor. In reality, artifacts recovered from the ocean, especially after decades of immersion, typically require months or even years of careful cleaning and conservation before they look anything like as presentable as the cornet does.
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The searchers find a cornet belonging to a member of the ship's orchestra. However, ''Titanic'' did not have any brass musicians; the orchestra played string instruments. The only brass instrument on board was a bugle used by the ship's bugler to announce dinner for First Class, but he was not part of the orchestra.
orchestra.
* ArtisticLicenseMarineBiology: At a press conference, Admiral Sandecker states that the ''Titanic'' is probably very well preserved because it lies in water so deep that there are no destructive marine organisms that could have damaged it. In reality, ''Titanic'' has suffered heavy deterioration from microbial lifeforms that are slowly consuming the iron in the ship's hull, leaving behind the famous "rusticles"; likewise, wood-boring molluscs have consumed most of the wood in and on the ship.[[note]]The rate of deterioration is such that current estimates state that ''Titanic'' will collapse completely sometime in the 2030s.[[/note]] ''Titanic'' as a whole has been referred to as a deep-sea oasis, as it has been colonized by hundreds of deep-sea life forms, including some previously unknown to science. The trope is justified given that very little deep-ocean research had been done when the movie was filmed and no one knew what conditions were like on the wreck.
* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after two minutes despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, where the pressure is about 6000 pounds per square inch, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was even aware of a problem. problem; if such a leak had occurred, the water would have been forced through the breach with enough force to slice through a human body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateHistory: Of course, the Titanic was never raised, and nor could it be.

to:

* AlternateHistory: Of course, the Titanic was never raised, and nor could now we know it be.can't be done.



* EveryHelicopterIsAHuey: Apparently, the Soviet Navy uses Huey helicopters instead of Kamov's.

to:

* EveryHelicopterIsAHuey: Apparently, the Soviet Navy uses Huey helicopters instead of Kamov's.Kamovs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseShips: Bigalow tells Pitt that the Byzanium was in Cargo Hold 9. ''Titanic'' only had six cargo holds, three in the bow and three in the stern.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseShips: Bigalow tells Pitt that the Byzanium was in Cargo Hold 9. ''Titanic'' only had six cargo holds, three in the bow and three in the stern. He also says the cargo hold was on D Deck. All of the holds were actually on the orlop and tank top decks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseShips: Bigalow tells Pitt that the Byzanium was in Cargo Hold 9. ''Titanic'' only had six cargo holds, three in the bow and three in the stern.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalNameChange: Arthur Brewster was Joshua Hayes Brewster in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: The trailer gives away that Pitt and co will succeed in raising the ship. (Granted, it ''is'' kind of in the name.)

to:

* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: The trailer gives away that Pitt and co will succeed in raising the ship. (Granted, it ''is'' kind of in the name.name, though that can be excused as what they are ''attempting'', and doesn't necessarily reveal whether or not they succeed.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the soviet navy (and russia's too) have never used Mi helicopters they have always used Kamov's exclusiviy


* EveryHelicopterIsAHuey: Apparently, the Soviet Navy uses Huey helicopters instead of Mils.

to:

* EveryHelicopterIsAHuey: Apparently, the Soviet Navy uses Huey helicopters instead of Mils.Kamov's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after two minutes despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was even aware of a problem.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after two minutes despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, where the pressure is about 6000 pounds per square inch, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was even aware of a problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The searchers find a cornet belonging to a member of the ship's orchestra. However, ''Titanic'' did not have any brass musicians; the orchestra played string instruments. There was a bugle on board, used by the ship's bugler to announce dinner for First Class, but he was not part of the orchestra.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The searchers find a cornet belonging to a member of the ship's orchestra. However, ''Titanic'' did not have any brass musicians; the orchestra played string instruments. There The only brass instrument on board was a bugle on board, used by the ship's bugler to announce dinner for First Class, but he was not part of the orchestra.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The searchers find a cornet belonging to a member of the ship's orchestra. However, ''Titanic'' did not have any brass musicians; the orchestra played string instruments.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The searchers find a cornet belonging to a member of the ship's orchestra. However, ''Titanic'' did not have any brass musicians; the orchestra played string instruments. There was a bugle on board, used by the ship's bugler to announce dinner for First Class, but he was not part of the orchestra.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The searchers find a cornet belonging to a member of the ship's orchestra. However, ''Titanic'' did not have any brass musicians; the orchestra played string instruments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after about a minute despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was aware of a problem.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The submersible ''Starfish'' springs a leak on the way down to ''Titanic'' and implodes after about a minute two minutes despite the crew's attempts to surface. At 12,000 ft, the submersible would have imploded well before the crew was even aware of a problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShipshapeShipwreck : The film makers can be forgiven for [[DatedHistory getting it wrong about the Titanic splitting into two before it sank]]. However, the ship re-emerges at the surface after a dramatic sinking, a two mile plunge to the bottom of the Atlantic and 68 years underwater almost completely intact, to the extent that masts, funnels and metal guidewires are still in position. Even Titanic's famous glass dome survived.

to:

* ShipshapeShipwreck : ShipshapeShipwreck: The film makers can be forgiven for [[DatedHistory getting it wrong about the Titanic splitting into two before it sank]]. However, the ship re-emerges at the surface after a dramatic sinking, a two mile plunge to the bottom of the Atlantic and 68 years underwater almost completely intact, to the extent that masts, funnels and metal guidewires are still in position. Even Titanic's famous glass dome survived.

Top