Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / OnlyTheBrave

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Only the Brave'' is a 2017 {{Dramatization}} about the Granite Mountain Hotshots of the Prescott Fire Dept. starring Creator/JoshBrolin, Creator/JenniferConnelly, Creator/JeffBridges and Creator/MilesTeller.

to:

''Only the Brave'' is a 2017 {{Dramatization}} about the Granite Mountain Hotshots of the Prescott Fire Dept. , directed by Creator/JosephKosinski and starring Creator/JoshBrolin, Creator/JenniferConnelly, Creator/JeffBridges and Creator/MilesTeller.




to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Mooning}}: Very briefly in one scene when the guys are headed to a fire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ManlyTears: [[spoiler:After he finds out the Granite Mountain crew all died (save one) in the Yarnell fire, the mayor breaks down into a sobbing heap.]]

to:

* ManlyTears: [[spoiler:After he finds out the Granite Mountain crew all died (save one) in the Yarnell fire, the mayor fire chief breaks down into a sobbing heap.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDistillation: By necessity a lot of the story and several of the fires the Granite Mountain crew fights are left out before the fateful [[spoiler:Yarnell fire. After their deaths, there also was a [[https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-story-that-only-the-brave-leaves-out massive fight]] over survivor benefits with the town of Prescott, which denied them to the widows for ''years''. They also used some breathtakingly nasty tactics, such as telling the town their taxes would have to go up specifically because of the widows and driving some of them out of town. They finally lost a series of very public court battles over it and were forced to divulge the benefits. The movie simply skips over all this to a 'three years later' epilogue, making it seem like the town was still grateful and supportive to the fallen firefighters.]]

to:

* AdaptationDistillation: By necessity a lot of the story and several of the fires the Granite Mountain crew fights are left out before the fateful [[spoiler:Yarnell fire. After their deaths, there also was a [[https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-story-that-only-the-brave-leaves-out massive fight]] over survivor benefits with the town of Prescott, which denied them to the widows for ''years''. They also used some breathtakingly nasty tactics, such as telling the town their taxes would have to go up specifically because of the widows and driving letting the townspeople drive some of them out of town. They finally lost a series of very public court battles over it and were forced to divulge the benefits. The movie simply skips over all this to a 'three years later' epilogue, making it seem like the town was still grateful and supportive to the fallen firefighters.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeroicBSOD: Brendan suffers a ''massive'' one [[spoiler:when he finds out the rest of the crew was killed just outside Yarnell.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ManlyTears: [[spoiler:After he finds out the Granite Mountain crew all died (save one) in the Yarnell fire, the mayor breaks down into a sobbing heap.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDistillation: By necessity a lot of the story and several of the fires the Granite Mountain crew fights are left out before the fateful [[spoiler:Yarnell fire. After their deaths, there also was a [[https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-story-that-only-the-brave-leaves-out massive fight]] over survivor benefits with the town of Prescott, which denied them to the widows for ''years''. They also used some breathtakingly nasty tactics, such as telling the town their taxes would have to go up specifically because of the widows and driving some of them out of town. They finally lost a very public court battle over it and were forced to divulge the benefits. The movie simply skips over all this to a 'three years later' epilogue, making it seem like the town was still grateful and supportive to the fallen firefighters.]]

to:

* AdaptationDistillation: By necessity a lot of the story and several of the fires the Granite Mountain crew fights are left out before the fateful [[spoiler:Yarnell fire. After their deaths, there also was a [[https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-story-that-only-the-brave-leaves-out massive fight]] over survivor benefits with the town of Prescott, which denied them to the widows for ''years''. They also used some breathtakingly nasty tactics, such as telling the town their taxes would have to go up specifically because of the widows and driving some of them out of town. They finally lost a series of very public court battle battles over it and were forced to divulge the benefits. The movie simply skips over all this to a 'three years later' epilogue, making it seem like the town was still grateful and supportive to the fallen firefighters.]]

Added: 461

Changed: 206

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Though he seems dubious about the feasibility of basing a Hotshot crew in their town, the mayor gives them the time they need to prove themselves and get certified. Eric himself as the crew's supervisor can be hard on them but makes sure to praise them too, and when he [[spoiler: tears into Brendan for wanting to switch off wildfires, he apologizes the next morning]].

to:

* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Though he seems dubious about the feasibility of basing a Hotshot crew in their town, the mayor gives them the time they need to prove themselves and get certified.
**
Eric himself as the crew's supervisor can be hard on them but makes sure to praise them too, too. When they do their certification and Eric yells at the supervisor, he's remorseful about having jeopardized his crew's chances at earning their certification and blames himself. later in the film, when he [[spoiler: tears into Brendan for wanting to switch off wildfires, he apologizes makes sure to apologize the next morning]].morning and promises to help Brendan as much as he can]].

Added: 774

Changed: 732

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Likewise, the movie skips over the [[spoiler: finger pointing in the aftermath of the fire, in which a state watchdog organization eventually found the Arizona state Forestry Division (in charge of the Yarnell fire) more focused on protecting property over the lives of the firefighters, which ultimately resulted in a hefty fine being leveled against the organization. The movie itself definitely shows some of the dysfunction and mismanagement, but stops short of laying blame on anyone]].



** The fire shelters and the deployment drills of them come up a lot in the first act of the film, as the crew works to get their Type 1 certification, before [[spoiler: they actually have to use them at the end of the film, where, tragically, they failed to protect the crew.]]



* {{Foreshadowing}}: The burning bear is seen repeatedly, including in a dream of the supervisor Eric [[spoiler:right before they dispatch to Yarnell.]]
* GoryDiscretionShot: Though you see the burnover at the deployment site and the charred remains of their tools and fire shelters, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see their own charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirm their deaths.]]

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: The burning bear is seen repeatedly, repeatedly before actually being described by Eric in the final act of the film, including in a dream of the supervisor Eric [[spoiler:right before they dispatch to Yarnell.]]
* GoryDiscretionShot: Though you see the burnover at the deployment site and the charred remains of their tools and fire shelters, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see their own charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirm their deaths.deaths; even the broad scene of their shelters are out of focus as the camera pans selectively over the site to focus on their gear and showing a few close ups of the burnt shelters.]]



* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Though he seems dubious about the feasibility of basing a Hotshot crew in their town, the mayor gives them the time they need to prove themselves and get certified.
* RecoveredAddict: Brendan is a former pothead, but he's trying to stay clean and get a steady job so he can be a good father for his infant daughter.

to:

* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Though he seems dubious about the feasibility of basing a Hotshot crew in their town, the mayor gives them the time they need to prove themselves and get certified. Eric himself as the crew's supervisor can be hard on them but makes sure to praise them too, and when he [[spoiler: tears into Brendan for wanting to switch off wildfires, he apologizes the next morning]].
* RecoveredAddict: Brendan is a former pothead, but he's trying to stay clean and get a steady job so he can be a good father for his infant daughter. [[spoiler: Eric and Amanda are both former addicts as well. Eric tears into Brendan for trying to get out and tells him that he'll just relapse without the passion that being a hotshot brings, but Amanda points out that it applies to him more than Brendan.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoryDiscretionShot: Though you see the burnover at the deployment site and the charred remains of their tools and fire shelters, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see the charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirms their deaths.]]

to:

* GoryDiscretionShot: Though you see the burnover at the deployment site and the charred remains of their tools and fire shelters, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see the their own charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirms confirm their deaths.]]



* {{Jerkass}}: The Hotshot crew lead early in the film is very dismissive of Eric's suggestions to save a community threatened by fire, basically telling them to stay out of the way and let the professionals work. Eric turns out to have been right, and the town goes up in smoke.

to:

* {{Jerkass}}: The Hotshot crew lead early in the film is very dismissive of Eric's suggestions to save a community threatened by fire, basically telling them to stay out of the way and let the professionals work. Eric turns out to have been right, and the town goes up in smoke.



* {{Retirony}}: As they're heading to Yarnell, Eric tells Jesse this will be his last fire season. Then he's one of those caught in the fire.

to:

* {{Retirony}}: As they're heading to Yarnell, Eric tells Jesse this will be his last fire season. Then [[spoiler:Then he's one of those caught killed in the fire. fire.]]



--> '''Amanda:'''What's up?
--> '''Eric:'''Oh, a skunker[[note]]low-burning, uncrowned, minor fire[[/note]] down in Yarnell. It's no big deal.
--> '''Amanda:'''I love you Short Stop.
--> '''Eric:'''You too, Sugar Tits. Go back to sleep. I'll probably be home for dinner.

to:

--> '''Amanda:'''What's '''Amanda:''' What's up?
--> '''Eric:'''Oh, '''Eric:''' Oh, a skunker[[note]]low-burning, uncrowned, minor fire[[/note]] down in Yarnell. It's no big deal.
--> '''Amanda:'''I '''Amanda:''' I love you Short Stop.
--> '''Eric:'''You '''Eric:''' You too, Sugar Tits. Go back to sleep. I'll probably be home for dinner.



* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: Mostly averted; a little drama is added but for the most part, the story is exactly as it took place in real life. [[spoiler:One of the only real differences is that in the real world, not all the burned bodies of the firemen were found in fire shelters, and to this day it is not known why as they were all deployed.]]

to:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: Mostly averted; a little drama is added but for the most part, the story is exactly as it took place in real life.life, though see AdaptationDistillation above for how events took a very nasty turn ''after'' the Yarnell fire. [[spoiler:One of the only real differences is that in the real world, not all the burned bodies of the firemen were found in fire shelters, and to this day it is not known why as they were all deployed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BearsAreBadNews: Certainly ones made of fire, representing the danger fires bring. This comes from Eric's memory of one of his earliest fires, an entire forest goes up in flames and out comes running a bear on fire. He says he'd never seen anything so beautiful or so terrifying.

to:

* BearsAreBadNews: Certainly ones made of fire, representing the danger fires wildfires bring. This comes from Eric's memory of one of his earliest fires, an entire forest goes up in flames and out comes running runs a grizzly bear on fire.''on fire''. It bulls right past the crew and disappears into the bush. He says he'd never seen anything so beautiful or so terrifying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationDistillation: By necessity a lot of the story and several of the fires the Granite Mountain crew fights are left out before the fateful [[spoiler:Yarnell fire. After their deaths, there also was a [[https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-story-that-only-the-brave-leaves-out massive fight]] over survivor benefits with the town of Prescott, which denied them to the widows for ''years'' before they finally lost a very public court battle over it. The movie simply skips over all this to a 'three years later' epilogue, making it seem like the town was still grateful and supportive to the fallen firefighters.]]

to:

* AdaptationDistillation: By necessity a lot of the story and several of the fires the Granite Mountain crew fights are left out before the fateful [[spoiler:Yarnell fire. After their deaths, there also was a [[https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-story-that-only-the-brave-leaves-out massive fight]] over survivor benefits with the town of Prescott, which denied them to the widows for ''years'' before they ''years''. They also used some breathtakingly nasty tactics, such as telling the town their taxes would have to go up specifically because of the widows and driving some of them out of town. They finally lost a very public court battle over it. it and were forced to divulge the benefits. The movie simply skips over all this to a 'three years later' epilogue, making it seem like the town was still grateful and supportive to the fallen firefighters.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoryDiscretionShot: Though you see the burnover at the deployment site, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see the charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirms their deaths.]]

to:

* GoryDiscretionShot: Though you see the burnover at the deployment site, site and the charred remains of their tools and fire shelters, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see the charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirms their deaths.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoryDiscretionShot: Fortunately, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see the charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirms their deaths.]]

to:

* GoryDiscretionShot: Fortunately, Though you see the burnover at the deployment site, you neither [[spoiler:have to watch the firefighters burn in their shelters, nor see the charred remains when the rescue teams arrive at the site and confirms their deaths.]]

Added: 141

Changed: 104

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TempingFate: As part of {{Retirony}}, this fateful conversation:
--> '''Eric:'''Oh, a skunker[[note]]low-burning, minor fire[[/note]] down in Yarnell. It's no big deal.

to:

* TempingFate: TemptingFate: As part of {{Retirony}}, this fateful conversation:
conversation:

--> '''Amanda:'''What's up?
--> '''Eric:'''Oh, a skunker[[note]]low-burning, uncrowned, minor fire[[/note]] down in Yarnell. It's no big deal.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TempingFate: As part of {{Retirony}}, this fateful conversation:
--> '''Eric:'''Oh, a skunker[[note]]low-burning, minor fire[[/note]] down in Yarnell. It's no big deal.
--> '''Amanda:'''I love you Short Stop.
--> '''Eric:'''You too, Sugar Tits. Go back to sleep. I'll probably be home for dinner.
--> [[spoiler:It's the last time she sees him alive.]]

Top