Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / NineteenSeventeen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*CrazyPrepared: It was strongly implied the Germans left no stone unturned by leaving booby traps in the event the enemy tried to invade their trenches and as fate would have it, Schofield & Blake do just that and narrowly avoid being killed after a rat sets off a trip wire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Blake and Schofield, while searching within the German bunker, collectively let out a panicked RapidFireNo when they find a rat dragging its meal [[spoiler:into a live tripwire, promptly detonating the trap right in their faces]].

to:

** Blake and Schofield, while searching within the German bunker, collectively let out a panicked RapidFireNo LittleNo when they find a rat dragging its meal [[spoiler:into a live tripwire, promptly detonating the trap right in their faces]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: Blake's telling about another soldier's unfortunate dealings with rats because of his hair oil even makes Schofield chuckle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MacGuffinEscortMission: The plot revolves around two soldiers delivering an important message across dangerous grounds to another division.

Added: 679

Changed: 397

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FatalFamilyPhoto: {{Subverted}} with [[spoiler:Blake]] who dies clutching one, but he was already fatally wounded before taking it out. {{Defied}} with [[spoiler: Schofield who does not look at his family's pictures until ''after'' he has completed his mission. He keeps his in a metal case, which he examines multiple times throughout the film, but the audience never sees the actual photos until the last scene.]]

to:

* FatalFamilyPhoto: {{Subverted}} FatalFamilyPhoto:
** Played
with when [[spoiler:Blake]] who dies clutching one, but one while he was already fatally wounded before taking it out. out.
**
{{Defied}} with [[spoiler: Schofield who does not look at his family's pictures until ''after'' he has completed his mission. He keeps his in a metal case, which he examines multiple times throughout the film, but the audience never sees the actual photos until the last scene.]]


Added DiffLines:

* JumpScare: When Schofield crosses the bridge and suddenly a sniper shoots at him.


Added DiffLines:

* MoodDissonance: When Schofield hitches a hike on the back of a truck. He is mourning the death of his friend while the other soldiers unaware of his loss are cracking [[ToiletHumour toilet jokes]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MadeOfIron: Schofield is extremely lucky to be alive after the injuries that he sustains, let alone have the strength left to finish his mission.
** He cuts his hand on filthy barbed wire right after entering no-man's land. Minutes later, he accidentally plunges the same hand into a half-rotten corpse's belly. Twelve-plus hours later, the hand is still working and he's showing no signs of sepsis.
** He gets nearly crushed to death by a collapsing tunnel, inhales so much limestone dust that he almost asphyxiates, and is temporarily blinded.
** Most harrowingly, he survives a rifle shot directly to the helmet at short range. His helmet saves him but the blast throws him down a flight of stairs, he gets a deep cut to the back of his head, and he's knocked out for something like 10 hours. An injury like that could easily cause a serious brain bleed, and even if it didn't, losing consciousness for ''thirty minutes'' is alarming. At ten hours, you'd be worried about irreversible, devastating brain damage.
** Shortly after coming to, Schofield is strong enough to keep walking, can think clearly, and even wins a hand-to-hand fight with a German soldier. He then escapes the German's comrades by taking a high dive into a fast-moving river.
** The river's current then carries him over a waterfall. He nearly drowns, and when he resurfaces, he gets swept up against a rock.
** After all of that, he still has enough left in the tank to [[spoiler:sprint 300 yards across an active battlefield, despite getting knocked down twice by oncoming soldiers]].
** All this time, his only food and drink have been about half of a ham sandwich, a few sips of milk, and less than one canteen's worth of water (he used a good bit of it washing the grit from the tunnel out of his eyes).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Loses Blake who gets stabbed to death by a German pilot.

to:

*** [[spoiler: Loses Blake who gets stabbed to death by a German pilot.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No spoiler tags allowed above the Examples line, and this one's self-fulfilling so I removed the spoilered-out text entirely.


Notably, the story is told in RealTime, and the film is shot and edited to look as if it were done in [[TheOner one take]][[note]][[spoiler:actually two]][[/note]] à la ''[[Film/BirdmanOrTheUnexpectedVirtueOfIgnorance Birdman]]'' or ''Film/{{Rope}}''.

to:

Notably, the story is told in RealTime, and the film is shot and edited to look as if it were done in [[TheOner one take]][[note]][[spoiler:actually two]][[/note]] take]] à la ''[[Film/BirdmanOrTheUnexpectedVirtueOfIgnorance Birdman]]'' or ''Film/{{Rope}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProductDeliveryOrdeal: An isolated regiment is scheduled to launch a full on attack on their front line. However, aerial reconnaissance has revealed that the Germans are planning to lure them into a massacre. With the field telephones to the regiment's sector cut, the only way to get word to stop the attack is to send two runners, Lance Corporal Blake and Lance Corporal Schofield, to deliver the message in writing. The two soldiers go on a hazardous, harrowing trek through enemy territory, hoping to reach the regiment and stop the attack before it's too late.

to:

* ProductDeliveryOrdeal: The crux of the film's plot. An isolated regiment is scheduled to launch a full on attack on their front line. However, aerial reconnaissance has revealed that the Germans are planning to lure them into a massacre. With the field telephones to the regiment's sector cut, the only way to get word to stop the attack is to send two runners, Lance Corporal Blake and Lance Corporal Schofield, to deliver the message in writing. The two soldiers go on a hazardous, harrowing trek through enemy territory, hoping to reach the regiment and stop the attack before it's too late.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ProductDeliveryOrdeal: An isolated regiment is scheduled to launch a full on attack on their front line. However, aerial reconnaissance has revealed that the Germans are planning to lure them into a massacre. With the field telephones to the regiment's sector cut, the only way to get word to stop the attack is to send two runners, Lance Corporal Blake and Lance Corporal Schofield, to deliver the message in writing. The two soldiers go on a hazardous, harrowing trek through enemy territory, hoping to reach the regiment and stop the attack before it's too late.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/1917.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''"There is only one way this war ends. Last man standing."'']]

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/1917.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''"There [[caption-width-right:300:''"There is only one way this war ends. Last man standing."'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
corrected characters involved


* ForTheEvulz: Captain Smith advises Blake to make sure there are witnesses when he gives Colonel Mackenzie the message to stop the attack because Mackenzie might choose to ignore them for this reason.

to:

* ForTheEvulz: Captain Smith advises Blake Schofield to make sure there are witnesses when he gives Colonel Mackenzie the message to stop the attack because Mackenzie might choose to ignore them for this reason.



* HomeByChristmas: DiscussedTrope. Blake mentions early on that command had said that all it would take is one big push and everyone would be home by Christmas. Given that the movie takes place in ''April'', that push either fizzled out some time ago or is a long time coming, and Schofield angrily mocks him for it. [[note]]The Battle of Arras -- the British Army's spring offensive -- began on April 9, 1917, or two days after events in the movie concludes. The characters at one point mention feeling that something big was once again in the air.[[/note]]

to:

* HomeByChristmas: DiscussedTrope. Blake mentions early on that command had said that all it would take is one big push and everyone would be home by Christmas. Given that the movie takes place in ''April'', that push either fizzled out some time ago or is a long time coming, and Schofield angrily the Sergeant mocks him for it. [[note]]The Battle of Arras -- the British Army's spring offensive -- began on April 9, 1917, or two days after events in the movie concludes. The characters at one point mention feeling that something big was once again in the air.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OffscreenAirplanePullup: a disabled German plane flies out of sight behind a hill, presumably to crash - but then abruptly pulls up and crests the hill, to menace Blake and Schofield.

to:

* OffscreenAirplanePullup: a A disabled German plane flies out of sight behind a hill, presumably to crash - but then abruptly pulls up and crests the hill, to menace Blake and Schofield.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OffscreenAirplanePullup: a disabled German plane flies out of sight behind a hill, presumably to crash - but then abruptly pulls up and crests the hill, to menace Blake and Schofield.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Notably, the story is told in RealTime and shot and edited to look as if it were done in [[TheOner one take]][[note]][[spoiler:actually two]][[/note]] a la ''[[Film/BirdmanOrTheUnexpectedVirtueOfIgnorance Birdman]]'' or ''Film/{{Rope}}''.

to:

Notably, the story is told in RealTime RealTime, and the film is shot and edited to look as if it were done in [[TheOner one take]][[note]][[spoiler:actually two]][[/note]] a à la ''[[Film/BirdmanOrTheUnexpectedVirtueOfIgnorance Birdman]]'' or ''Film/{{Rope}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgonizingStomachWound: [[spoiler:Blake gets stabbed by a German pilot he'd [[UngratefulBastard rescued from a burning plane]]. Despite Schofield's attempts to get him back on his feet, every small movement makes him scream or groan in agony and he continuously falls back over.]] In the end, there's nothing that can be done to save him, and he dies slowly and painfully while [[spoiler:Schofield]] [[ComfortTheDying stays by his side to ease his terror of death, assuring him that he will finish their mission.]]

to:

* AgonizingStomachWound: [[spoiler:Blake [[spoiler:Blake]] gets stabbed by a German pilot he'd [[UngratefulBastard rescued from a burning plane]]. Despite Schofield's the other soldier's attempts to get him back on his feet, every small movement makes him scream or groan in agony and he continuously falls back over.]] over. In the end, there's nothing that can be done to save him, and he dies slowly and painfully while [[spoiler:Schofield]] [[ComfortTheDying stays by his side to ease his terror of death, assuring him that he will finish their mission.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The first two are Blake prioritizing the mission and saving others over his own life, and the third was just the pilot attempting a risky escape instead of becoming a POW. None of this is strictly stupid.


* TooDumbToLive:
** [[spoiler:If Blake simply saw reason and listened to Schofield's suggestion to wait until nightfall, then he might have not died.]]
** [[spoiler:Blake's death could have also been avoided if he simply let Schofield kill the German pilot.]]
** [[spoiler:The aforementioned German pilot who knifes his rescuer, doubling as an UngratefulBastard.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreshClue: More of a suspense trigger than an actual clue. At the German trenches, the two protagonists find a bucket with still glowing coals in it, a sign that the Germans couldn't have left long ago.
* FriendOrFoe: While roaming through the French town and encountering a building up in flames, Schofield sees the silhouette of a soldier walking towards him from it. It's unclear whose side he's on at first, but after a moment, he realizes who he's looking at...and opens fire on Schofield

to:

* FreshClue: More of a suspense trigger than an actual clue. At the German trenches, the two protagonists find a bucket with still glowing still-glowing coals in it, a sign that the Germans couldn't have left long ago.
* FriendOrFoe: While roaming through the French town and encountering a building up in flames, Schofield sees the silhouette of a soldier walking towards him from it. It's unclear whose side he's on at first, but after a moment, he the soldier realizes who he's looking at...and opens fire on Schofield
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FrontlineGeneral: Both General Erinmore and Colonel McKenzie lead their men in the frontline of trenches.

to:

* FrontlineGeneral: Both General Erinmore and Colonel McKenzie Macknzie lead their men in the frontline of trenches.

Added: 107

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FriendOrFoe: While roaming through the French town and encountering a building up in flames, Schofield sees the silhouette of a soldier walking towards him from it. It's unclear whose side he's on at first, but after a moment, he realizes who he's looking at...and opens fire on Schofield.

to:

* FriendOrFoe: While roaming through the French town and encountering a building up in flames, Schofield sees the silhouette of a soldier walking towards him from it. It's unclear whose side he's on at first, but after a moment, he realizes who he's looking at...and opens fire on Schofield.Schofield
* FrontlineGeneral: Both General Erinmore and Colonel McKenzie lead their men in the frontline of trenches.

Added: 408

Removed: 638

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultFear:
** Schofield mentions to Blake that he avoids applying for leave time since he hates the idea of briefly going home, knowing that he has to leave again for possibly the last time and [[spoiler:leave behind his wife and daughter.]]
** Blake's main motivation.
--->'''Gen. Erinmore:''' You have a brother in the second battalion.\\
'''Lcpl. Blake:''' Yes, sir. Is he...\\
'''Gen. Erinmore:''' Alive. And with your help, I'd like to keep it that way. But they're walking into a trap. Your orders are to deliver a message calling off tomorrow morning's attack. If you don't, we will lose sixteen hundred men. Your brother among them.


Added DiffLines:

* IHaveAFamily: Blake's main motivation.
--->'''Gen. Erinmore:''' You have a brother in the second battalion.\\
'''Lcpl. Blake:''' Yes, sir. Is he...\\
'''Gen. Erinmore:''' Alive. And with your help, I'd like to keep it that way. But they're walking into a trap. Your orders are to deliver a message calling off tomorrow morning's attack. If you don't, we will lose sixteen hundred men. Your brother among them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeadpanSnarker: General Erinmore speaks in a very deadpan voice despite a war going on. This is likely because he is used to the fighting and doesn’t have any hope the war will end anytime soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The British soldiers in the film, even the officers, seem unprofessional and mostly unfriendly to one another. Probably very accurate, given how long the war had lasted by the time the film takes place. The pre-war professional British Army of 100,000 men (the "Old Contemptibles") had been used up in the opening months of the war, and the British Army in France in 1917 was made up of hastily trained men recruited into "Pals Battalions."

to:

** The British soldiers in the film, even the officers, seem unprofessional and mostly unfriendly to one another. [[TropesAreTools Probably very accurate, accurate]], given how long the war had lasted by the time the film takes place. The pre-war professional British Army of 100,000 men (the "Old Contemptibles") had been used up in the opening months of the war, and the British Army in France in 1917 was made up of hastily trained men recruited into "Pals Battalions."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The first shot of the film, believe it or not. [[spoiler:Schofield is placed in the "stage front" of the frame, with Blake in the background. This serves to represent Blake's status as DecoyProtagonist and Schofield being the true {{Protagonist}} of the film.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PrecisionFStrike: [[spoiler:"Now ''fuck off'', Lance Corporal."]]

Added: 519

Changed: 589

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The story takes place on April 6-7, 1917, in the midst of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI World War I]]. With the Germans in apparent retreat, the Devonshire Regiment is scheduled to launch a full on attack on their front line. However, aerial reconnaissance has revealed that the Germans are planning to lure the Devons into a massacre. With the field telephones to the Devons' sector cut, the only way to get word to stop the attack is to send two runners: Lance Corporal Blake (Dean-Charles Chapman) and Lance Corporal Schofield (George [=MacKay=]). Blake has been chosen to deliver the message because he'll have extra motivation: his brother is an officer with the regiment. Having received their orders, the two soldiers go on a hazardous, harrowing trek through no man's land, hoping to reach the Devonshires and stop the attack before it's too late.

to:

The story takes place on from April 6-7, 1917, in the midst of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI World War I]]. With the Germans in apparent retreat, the Devonshire Regiment is scheduled to launch a full on attack on their front line. However, aerial reconnaissance has revealed that the Germans are planning to lure the Devons into a massacre. massacre.

With the field telephones to the Devons' sector cut, the only way to get word to stop the attack is to send two runners: Lance Corporal Blake (Dean-Charles Chapman) and Lance Corporal Schofield (George [=MacKay=]). Blake has been chosen to deliver the message because he'll have extra motivation: his brother is an officer with the regiment. Having received their orders, the two soldiers go on a hazardous, harrowing trek through no man's land, hoping to reach the Devonshires and stop the attack before it's too late.



-->You need to trust me! ''Jump!''

to:

-->You -->"You need to trust me! ''Jump!''''Jump!''"



* TheOner: The movie is largely shot and edited to look like it was filmed in a single take, with hidden cuts happening during moments of darkness or as the heroes pass through a doorway. However, there is actually one visible hard cut in the film, [[spoiler:when the German sniper shoots Schofield's helmet off, knocking him out, and the film cuts to black for a while. This mostly serves as a plot device meant to skip time forward a few hours, one which a non-Oner film would not have a problem with. Also serves as an OhCrap moment to the audience.]]

to:

* TheOner: The movie is largely shot and edited to look like it was filmed in a single take, with hidden cuts happening during moments of darkness or as the heroes pass through a doorway. However, there is actually one visible hard cut in the film, [[spoiler:when the German sniper shoots Schofield's helmet off, knocking him out, and the film cuts to black for a while. This mostly serves as a plot device meant to skip time forward a few hours, one which a non-Oner non-oner film would not have a problem with. Also This also serves as an OhCrap moment to for the audience.]]



** [[spoiler:If Blake simply saw reason and listened to Schofield's suggestion to wait until nightfall then he might have not died.]]
** [[spoiler:Again Blake's death could have been avoided if he simply let Schofield kill the German pilot.]]
** [[spoiler:The German aviator, who knifes his rescuer. Doubles with an UngratefulBastard.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:If Blake simply saw reason and listened to Schofield's suggestion to wait until nightfall nightfall, then he might have not died.]]
** [[spoiler:Again Blake's [[spoiler:Blake's death could have also been avoided if he simply let Schofield kill the German pilot.]]
** [[spoiler:The aforementioned German aviator, pilot who knifes his rescuer. Doubles with rescuer, doubling as an UngratefulBastard.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Notably, the story is told in RealTime and shot and edited to look as if it were done in [[TheOner one take]] a la ''Film/BirdmanOrTheUnexpectedVirtueOfIgnorance'' or ''Film/{{Rope}}''.

to:

Notably, the story is told in RealTime and shot and edited to look as if it were done in [[TheOner one take]] take]][[note]][[spoiler:actually two]][[/note]] a la ''Film/BirdmanOrTheUnexpectedVirtueOfIgnorance'' ''[[Film/BirdmanOrTheUnexpectedVirtueOfIgnorance Birdman]]'' or ''Film/{{Rope}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''1917'' is a [[MilitaryAndWarfareFilms war film]] co-written and directed by Creator/SamMendes and starring Creator/GeorgeMacKay, Dean-Charles Chapman, Creator/BenedictCumberbatch, Creator/RichardMadden, Creator/MarkStrong, Creator/AndrewScott and Creator/ColinFirth.

to:

''1917'' is a [[MilitaryAndWarfareFilms war film]] co-written and directed by Creator/SamMendes and starring Creator/GeorgeMacKay, Dean-Charles Chapman, Creator/DeanCharlesChapman, Creator/BenedictCumberbatch, Creator/RichardMadden, Creator/MarkStrong, Creator/AndrewScott and Creator/ColinFirth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MisplacedWildlife: When Blake and Schofield enter the abandoned German trench, we can hear a loon call. The loon has a spooky call, but it is also a North American water bird.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* HighConcept: The clip used for the trailers.
-->'''Gen. Erinmore:''' You have a brother in the second battalion.\\
'''Lcpl. Blake:''' Yes, sir. Is he...\\
'''Gen. Erinmore:''' Alive. And with your help, I'd like to keep it that way. But they're walking into a trap. Your orders are to deliver a message calling off tomorrow morning's attack. If you don't, we will lose sixteen hundred men. [[AdultFear Your brother among them.]]

Top