Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / NicholasAndAlexandra

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WrongGenreSavvy: Nicky is unshakably convinced that he is an idyllic setting where he is a wise and beloved ruler who knows what is best for his people who love him like a father. It's only after losing his throne that he realizes the incompetent tyrant and despot who was hopelessly unsuited to the realities of Russia that he really was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LargeHam: Tom Baker as Rasputin is exactly what you'd expect, providing enough ham to cover all of Russia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While not as bad as Alexandra, Nicholas has this too, refusing to give up any of his power or compromise with opponents and vehemently insisting that he knows what is best for the Russian people even as they march and demand voting rights, education and better living conditions. Best summed up when he claims he wants a good life for them to which Count Witte replies that he only wants them to have a good life on ''his'' terms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** {{Pride}}: Nicolas is convinced of his status as a divinely appointed ruler, that his people love and respect him too much to ever revolt and refuses to end the war with Japan for fear of appearing weak and being the first ruler ever to have Russia lose a war.

to:

*** {{Pride}}: Nicolas is convinced of his status as a divinely appointed ruler, that his people love and respect him too much to ever revolt and refuses to end the war with Japan for fear of appearing weak and being the first ruler ever to have Russia lose a war.war and he refuses to even consider giving away any part of his power or meeting protestors halfway by granting anything that might make the lives of civilians easier.

Added: 203

Changed: 151

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** HenpeckedHusband: He's married to a demanding, pampered princess with zero interest in the country, and ends up more interested in her than in governing Russia.
*** FishOutOfTemporalWater: He was simply a man unfit for the tumult and revolutions of the early 20th century. When the "winds of change" were blowing his way, he seems eager to stop them. In fact, with his family values and gentle, middle-class demeanor, it seems like he would have been much better as a figurehead head of state like many contemporary monarchs than as an old-school absolute monarch.

to:

*** HenpeckedHusband: He's married to a demanding, pampered princess with zero interest in the country, affairs of state, and ends up more interested in her than in governing Russia.
*** FishOutOfTemporalWater: BornInTheWrongCentury: He was simply a man unfit for the tumult and revolutions of the early 20th century. When the "winds of change" were blowing his way, he seems eager to stop them. In fact, with his family values and gentle, middle-class demeanor, it seems like he would have been much better as a figurehead head of state like many contemporary monarchs than as an old-school absolute monarch.



** Lenin and his wife Krupskaya, as they were in real life. While Lenin acts aloof towards others, including his fellow Bolsheviks, he shows a more sympathetic side towards his wife, showing concern for her upon noticing how exhausted she was.

to:

** Lenin and his wife Krupskaya, as they were in real life. While Lenin acts aloof towards others, including his fellow Bolsheviks, he shows a more sympathetic side towards his wife, showing concern for her upon noticing how exhausted she was.was during a late-night Bolshevik meeting.



** Alexandra plays this completely straight, being a cold-hearted bitch who thinks only of her own needs.

to:

** Alexandra plays this completely straight, being a cold-hearted bitch who thinks only of her own needs. and her son's needs.
* MyBelovedSmother: Alexandra is overprotective of Alexei due to his haemophilia, but not only is her son frustrated by her coddling, but this causes her to be blind to the problems plaguing the country.



* WellDoneSonGuy: Nicholas lives in his father's shadow. TruthInTelevision, as Alexander III had no confidence in his heir and never bothered to teach him how to be a proper ruler and assumed he'd live long enough for it not to matter, shocking everyone when he died at the age of 49.

to:

* WellDoneSonGuy: Nicholas lives in his father's shadow.shadow, and gets agitated when his mother brings him up. TruthInTelevision, as Alexander III had no confidence in his heir and never bothered to teach him how to be a proper ruler and assumed he'd live long enough for it not to matter, shocking everyone when he died at the age of 49.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Grand Duke Nicholas''': Well Nicky, let me put it this way. ''(Presents a bullet)'' This is a bullet, made in Saint Petersburg. I send it off to war. How does it get there? On a single spur of railroad track four thousand miles long. And in the middle, no track at all. God help us, it spends three days packed on sleds. This works the same way for every pair of boots, first aid kit, or pound of tea we send. Get out now, Nicky. While there is time.

to:

--> '''Grand Duke Nicholas''': Well Nicky, let me put it this way. ''(Presents a bullet)'' This is Here's a bullet, a bullet made in Saint St. Petersburg. I send it off to war. How does it get there? On a single spur of railroad track four thousand miles long. And in In the middle, no track at all. Oh, God help us, it; it spends three days packed on sleds. This works the same way for And every pair of boots, first aid kit, boot, shell or pound of tea we send. Get out now, Nicky. While there is Nicky, while there's time.



--> '''Tsar Nicholas II''': All my life. My whole life I've done what you want. I gave mother up. You hated her, so we don't see her anymore. I gave my friends up. Do you know I haven't a single friend ? I've got my family. Four girls, one sick boy...and you. I ask myself, before I eat, sleep, or change my clothes, is this what Sunny wants ? And it never is. There's always more! Sweet JESUS how much do you want of me?

to:

--> '''Tsar Nicholas II''': All my life. My whole life I've done what you want. I gave mother up. You hated her, so we don't see her anymore. I gave my friends up. Do you know I haven't a single friend ? friend? I've got my family. Four girls, one sick boy...and you. I ask myself, before I eat, sleep, or change my clothes, is this what Sunny wants ? And it never is. There's always more! Sweet JESUS how much do you want of me?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The execution of the Romanovs took several minutes in real life (some reports say up to 20), due to several of the gunmen being drunk and the room quickly filling up with gunsmoke, making it hard to aim. The girls had also sewn their jewelry into their dresses which acted as makeshift bulletproof vests. One of them may have been alive for as long as it took them to transport the bodies to the truck. They also read off a death warrant before opening fire, whereas in the film they just start shooting without a word. And the two chairs were not in the room when the family entered, either; Alexandra asked for some and Yurovsky brought them in.

to:

** The execution of the Romanovs took several minutes in real life (some reports say family's assassinations was a horrible, drawn out affair that by some accounts lasted up to 20), due twenty minutes. However, it's shown to several of be done quickly and efficiently in the gunmen being movie. The guards did not want to kill the girls and got drunk and to build up the courage to do so. They couldn't aim well in their state so the small room quickly filling up with gunsmoke, making it hard became a smoke filled mess where no one could see and thus they began to aim. The shoot indiscriminately. Nicholas, Alexandra, and Alexei all died pretty quickly but the girls had also sewn their jewelry jewels into their dresses which acted as makeshift bulletproof vests. One of them may have been alive for as long as it took them to transport the bodies to the truck. They The guards also read off a death warrant before opening fire, whereas in to the film family but here they just start shooting without a word. And the two shooting. The chairs were not waiting on them in the room when basement like is shown in the family entered, either; movie either, Alexandra asked for some and Yurovsky brought them in.for herself and Alexei who was going through a hemophilia flair-up at the time and could not walk on his own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The execution of the Romanovs took several minutes in real life (some reports say up to 20), due to several of the gunmen being drunk and the room quickly filling up with gunsmoke, making it hard to aim. They also read off a death warrant before opening fire, whereas in the film they just start shooting without a word. And the two chairs were not in the room when the family entered, either; Alexandra asked for some and Yurovsky brought them in.

to:

** The execution of the Romanovs took several minutes in real life (some reports say up to 20), due to several of the gunmen being drunk and the room quickly filling up with gunsmoke, making it hard to aim. The girls had also sewn their jewelry into their dresses which acted as makeshift bulletproof vests. One of them may have been alive for as long as it took them to transport the bodies to the truck. They also read off a death warrant before opening fire, whereas in the film they just start shooting without a word. And the two chairs were not in the room when the family entered, either; Alexandra asked for some and Yurovsky brought them in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rasputin was introduced to the titular couple by a pair of princesses nicknamed "The Crow Sisters", not by Grand Duke Nicholas. The build-up to his introduction--a previous charlatan named "Doctor" Phillipe, whose "help", Alexandra believed, had allowed her to give birth to Alexei, had died, but not before predicting that another would take his place--is also absent.

to:

** Rasputin was introduced to the titular couple by a pair of princesses who were married to Nicholas’s cousins nicknamed "The Crow Sisters", not by Grand Duke Nicholas. The build-up to his introduction--a previous charlatan named "Doctor" Phillipe, whose "help", Alexandra believed, had allowed her to give birth to Alexei, had died, but not before predicting that another would take his place--is also absent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Nicholas is begging for Nagorny's life, he says "No man should have that that power." The commander coldly tells him "You had it." Nicholas is forced to admit that he did, and that he let it destroy him.

to:

** When Nicholas is begging for Nagorny's life, he says "No man should have that that power." The commander coldly tells him "You had it." Nicholas is forced to admit that he did, and that he let it destroy him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotEvenBotheringWithTheAccent: None of the cast make an effort to affect Russian accents and keep their natural British ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Nicholas is the royal variant: he's too milquetoast to be considered a [[TheCaligula Caligula]], but he makes a series of inept and tone-deaf decisions that alienate even his own family and lead to the collapse of his dynasty.

to:

** Nicholas is the royal variant: he's too milquetoast to be considered a [[TheCaligula Caligula]], Caligula]] and he genuinely means well, but he makes a series of inept and tone-deaf decisions that alienate even his own family and lead to the collapse of his dynasty.



* WellDoneSonGuy: Nicholas lives in his father's shadow. TruthInTelevision, as Alexander III had no confidence in his heir and never bothered to teach him how to be a proper ruler.

to:

* WellDoneSonGuy: Nicholas lives in his father's shadow. TruthInTelevision, as Alexander III had no confidence in his heir and never bothered to teach him how to be a proper ruler.ruler and assumed he'd live long enough for it not to matter, shocking everyone when he died at the age of 49.

Added: 264

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** FishOutOfTemporalWater: He was simply a man unfit for the tumult and revolutions of the early 20th century. When the "winds of change" were blowing his way, he seems eager to stop them. In fact, with his family values and gentle, middle-class demeanor it seems like he would have been much better as a figurehead head of state like many contemporary monarchs than as an old-school absolute monarch.

to:

*** FishOutOfTemporalWater: He was simply a man unfit for the tumult and revolutions of the early 20th century. When the "winds of change" were blowing his way, he seems eager to stop them. In fact, with his family values and gentle, middle-class demeanor demeanor, it seems like he would have been much better as a figurehead head of state like many contemporary monarchs than as an old-school absolute monarch. monarch.
*** {{Pride}}: Nicolas is convinced of his status as a divinely appointed ruler, that his people love and respect him too much to ever revolt and refuses to end the war with Japan for fear of appearing weak and being the first ruler ever to have Russia lose a war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Russian public is depicted as apathetic-at-best and hostile-at-worst during the Romanov Tercentenary. In reality, Nicholas was greeted with great acclaim, as foreign investment had helped stabilize the economy; and (the now dead) Stolypin had, by that point, passed several workers' rights legislation ''and'' abolished serf redemption debts, allowing many to acquire their own land and prosper from it.

Added: 1243

Changed: 127

Removed: 1204

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainDowngrade[=/=]HistoricalVillainUpgrade[=/=]HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The movie plays around with its depictions of historical figures.
** Nicholas receives all of these at once, as the movie plays up both his incompetence and the [[PetTheDog love he had for his family]]. His accomplishments, while not being able to stop the revolution did lead to some improvements in Russian lives, are not touched upon. Nor, on the other hand, are his blatant racism[[note]]such as frequently referring to the Japanese as "monkeys," even in official correspondence[[/note]] and anti-Semitism[[note]]Not only did Nicholas condone, if not actively encourage several pogroms through his reign, along with his meddling in the Bellis blood libel case, he was convinced that the Protocols of the Elders of Zion were genuine and urged his advisers to read it[[/note]] so much as mentioned.

to:

* HistoricalVillainDowngrade[=/=]HistoricalVillainUpgrade[=/=]HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The movie plays around with its depictions of historical figures.
** Nicholas receives all of these at once, as the movie plays up both his incompetence and the [[PetTheDog love he had for his family]]. His accomplishments, while not being able to stop the revolution did lead to some improvements in Russian lives, are not touched upon. Nor, on the other hand, are his blatant racism[[note]]such as frequently referring to the Japanese as "monkeys," even in official correspondence[[/note]] and anti-Semitism[[note]]Not only did Nicholas condone, if not actively encourage several pogroms through his reign, along with his meddling in the Bellis blood libel case, he was convinced that the Protocols of the Elders of Zion were genuine and urged his advisers to read it[[/note]] so much as mentioned.
HistoricalHeroUpgrade



** Dowager Empress Maria is shown to be a fan of autocracy, to an extent. In real life, she understood that the time of absolute monarchy was over and supported reform, but couldn't force Nicholas to go through with it because Alexandra controlled his ears. It got to the point where she and a circle of supporters hatched a plot to ''depose'' Nicholas and place a more liberal-minded (or at least more pragmatic) family member on the throne, but it never went anywhere.


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainDowngrade: Zigzagged with Nicholas, as the movie plays up both his incompetence and the [[PetTheDog love he had for his family]]. His accomplishments, while not being able to stop the revolution did lead to some improvements in Russian lives, are not touched upon. Nor, on the other hand, are his blatant racism[[note]]such as frequently referring to the Japanese as "monkeys," even in official correspondence[[/note]] and anti-Semitism[[note]]Not only did Nicholas condone, if not actively encourage several pogroms through his reign, along with his meddling in the Bellis blood libel case, he was convinced that the Protocols of the Elders of Zion were genuine and urged his advisers to read it[[/note]] so much as mentioned.
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade
** Dowager Empress Maria is shown to be a fan of autocracy, to an extent. In real life, she understood that the time of absolute monarchy was over and supported reform, but couldn't force Nicholas to go through with it because Alexandra controlled his ears. It got to the point where she and a circle of supporters hatched a plot to ''depose'' Nicholas and place a more liberal-minded (or at least more pragmatic) family member on the throne, but it never went anywhere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Nicholas and Alexandra'' is a 1971 EpicMovie directed by Franklin J. Schaffner. [[TheFilmOfTheBook Based on the nonfiction book]] by Robert K. Massie, it is a {{Biopic}} of the last Russian tsar, UsefulNotes/NicholasII (Creator/MichaelJayston), and his wife Alexandra (Janet Suzman), dramatizing their lives from 1904 to 1918, as their world collapses around them, they are overthrown and are eventually murdered by the Bolsheviks. The film shows the personal side of Nicholas and Alexandra, their loving and affectionate relationships with each other and their children, while also portraying their incompetence as rulers and their many mistakes that led to their destruction. Other scenes follow Kerensky (John [=McEnery=]), who struggles to establish a democratic government in Russia following the overthrow of the Romanovs, and Lenin (Michael Bryant), who rises from obscure rabble-rouser to the first ruler of the Soviet Union.

to:

''Nicholas and Alexandra'' is a 1971 EpicMovie directed by Franklin J. Schaffner. [[TheFilmOfTheBook Based on the nonfiction book]] by Robert K. Massie, it is a {{Biopic}} of the last Russian tsar, UsefulNotes/{{Tsar|Tsar Autocrats}}, UsefulNotes/NicholasII (Creator/MichaelJayston), and his wife Alexandra (Janet Suzman), dramatizing their lives from 1904 to 1918, as their world collapses around them, they are overthrown and are eventually murdered by the Bolsheviks. The film shows the personal side of Nicholas and Alexandra, their loving and affectionate relationships with each other and their children, while also portraying their incompetence as rulers and their many mistakes that led to their destruction. Other scenes follow Kerensky (John [=McEnery=]), who struggles to establish a democratic government in Russia following the overthrow of the Romanovs, and Lenin (Michael Bryant), who rises from obscure rabble-rouser to the first ruler of the Soviet Union.

Removed: 66

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS cleanup: not enough context


* ManOnFire: Seen when a leftist printing press goes up in flames.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OnlySaneMan: Count Witte, who recognizes the need for reform and the recklessness of going to the first World War in 1914--see TheCassandra above. Kerensky is almost this, save for his fatal error of deciding to keep Russia in the unwinnable war. Alexei is this among the family, who sadly understands that they may not be alive in the near future.

to:

* OnlySaneMan: Count Witte, who recognizes the need for reform and the recklessness of going to the first World War in 1914--see TheCassandra above. Kerensky is almost this, save except for his fatal error of deciding to keep Russia involved in the World War I when it was unwinnable war.for Russia. Alexei is this among the family, who sadly understands that they may not be alive in the near future.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The other four servants who accompanied the Romanovs to Ekaterinburg, and--barring a kitchen boy named Leonid--died alongside them.

to:

** The other four servants who accompanied the Romanovs to Ekaterinburg, and--barring a kitchen boy named Leonid--died Leonid, whom the Bolsheviks decided to spare--died alongside them.

Added: 296

Changed: 132

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: The other four servants who accompanied the Romanovs to Ekaterinburg, and--barring a kitchen boy named Leonid--died alongside them.

to:

* AdaptedOut: AdaptedOut:
** Nicholas's brother, Michael, and his sisters, Olga and Xenia, are nowhere to be seen. Pretty surprising, given that Xenia had a vicious rivalry with Alexandra.
**
The other four servants who accompanied the Romanovs to Ekaterinburg, and--barring a kitchen boy named Leonid--died alongside them.

Top