Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / KellysHeroes

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FrontlineGeneral: Zigzagged with General Colt, whose Introduced comfortable at headquarters jautbbossing people around but does feel stirred to personally lead the charge to join in Kelly’s push after hearing how far they’ve gotten on the radio.
* GentlemenRankers: Kelly used to be a lieutenant, but was scapegoated and broken down to private after half his platoon was wiped out due to incorrect orders from his superiors.

to:

* FrontlineGeneral: Zigzagged with General Colt, whose Introduced who starts the movie comfortable at headquarters jautbbossing bossing people around around, but does feel stirred to personally lead the charge to join in Kelly’s push after hearing how far they’ve gotten on the radio.
* GentlemenRankers: Kelly used to be a lieutenant, but was scapegoated and broken down demoted to private after half his platoon was wiped out due to incorrect orders from his superiors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Germans also comment on the sudden bell ringing from the clock tower, wondering what is going on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's about a squad of American soldiers in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII France who learn about a secret stash of [[NaziGold German gold]] in a bank deep behind enemy lines. Unappreciated by their [[TheNeidermeyer clueless, profiteering captain]] and continually denied any chance at decent R&R, they are ripe for the promise of heroic adventure and enthusiastically embark on their new, unauthorized mission. With the help of tank commander Oddball and his squad of misfits, an incompetent artillery officer, a greedy supply officer, a marching band, and a grave digger battalion, they stand to make a fortune.

to:

It's about a A squad of American soldiers in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII France who learn about a secret stash of [[NaziGold German gold]] in a bank deep behind enemy lines. Unappreciated by their [[TheNeidermeyer clueless, profiteering captain]] and continually denied any chance at decent R&R, they are ripe for the promise of heroic adventure and enthusiastically embark on their new, unauthorized mission. With the help of tank commander Oddball and his squad of misfits, an incompetent artillery officer, a greedy supply officer, a marching band, and a grave digger battalion, they stand to make a fortune.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WeaponsUnderstudies: Three Russian T-34 tanks were converted into very life-like German Tiger Tanks (the real glaring error was the wheels of the tanks and its longer engine deck). Contrary to some claims, the Tigers weren't made for ''Kelly's Heroes'' but for an earlier film made in Yugoslavia starring Creator/YulBrynner called ''The Battle of Neretva''. The Shermans also come from that film. A close up shows the bow machine gun is an [=MG42=], which was never used in any German tank due to the quick-change barrel being removed from the front; the [=MG34=] was used instead because the barrel could be changed from inside the tank.

to:

* WeaponsUnderstudies: Three Russian T-34 tanks were converted into very life-like German Tiger Tanks (the real glaring error was the wheels of the tanks and its longer engine deck). Contrary to some claims, the Tigers weren't made for ''Kelly's Heroes'' but for an earlier film made in Yugoslavia starring Creator/YulBrynner called ''The Battle of Neretva''.''Film/TheBattleOfNeretva''. The Shermans also come from that film. A close up shows the bow machine gun is an [=MG42=], which was never used in any German tank due to the quick-change barrel being removed from the front; the [=MG34=] was used instead because the barrel could be changed from inside the tank.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForDoomTheBellTolls: Cowboy rings the church bells to cover the sound of the Sherman driving into town. They continue ringing for almost the entire final battle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MookFaceTurn: In the end, the squad runs out of ways to defeat the Tigers, and are forced to negotiate. [[spoiler:It turns out that the commander of Tiger 113 doesn't know what he is guarding, and is vulnerable to greed.]]

to:

* MookFaceTurn: In the end, the squad runs out of ways to defeat the Tigers, and are forced to negotiate. [[spoiler:It turns out that the commander of Tiger 113 115 doesn't know what he is guarding, and is vulnerable to greed.]]



** Tiger 113 is "a beautiful tank". [[spoiler:Even Oddball thinks so, seeing as how he uses his share of the gold to buy it from its crew.]]

to:

** Tiger 113 115 is "a beautiful tank". [[spoiler:Even Oddball thinks so, seeing as how he uses his share of the gold to buy it from its crew.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tiger 115 is "a beautiful tank". [[spoiler:Even Oddball thinks so, seeing as how he uses his share of the gold to buy it from its crew.]]

to:

** Tiger 115 113 is "a beautiful tank". [[spoiler:Even Oddball thinks so, seeing as how he uses his share of the gold to buy it from its crew.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MookFaceTurn: In the end, the squad runs out of ways to defeat the Tigers, and are forced to negotiate. [[spoiler:It turns out that the commander of Tiger 115 doesn't know what he is guarding, and is vulnerable to greed.]]

to:

* MookFaceTurn: In the end, the squad runs out of ways to defeat the Tigers, and are forced to negotiate. [[spoiler:It turns out that the commander of Tiger 115 113 doesn't know what he is guarding, and is vulnerable to greed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When the final battle begins, the German take commander's expression suggests annoyance or weariness more than surprise or concern.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 76mm could penetrate a Tiger's armor but it didn't mean it always worked. The United States fell behind the Germans when it came to Anti-Tank weaponry, and while the 76mm was an improvment, a Tiger's armor could still bounce a shot depending on the angle/trajectory. Oddball's attitude was typical of tankers of the time, who didn't trust the guns and felt that the only sure-fire way to take out a Tiger was to flank it, particularly since the ''88mm'' gun on the Tiger could easily knock a Sherman out.

to:

** The 76mm could penetrate a Tiger's armor but it didn't mean it always worked. The United States fell behind the Germans when it came to Anti-Tank weaponry, and while the 76mm was an improvment, a Tiger's armor could still bounce a shot depending on the angle/trajectory. Oddball's attitude was typical of tankers of the time, who didn't trust the guns and felt that the only sure-fire way to take out a Tiger was to flank it, particularly since the ''88mm'' gun on the Tiger could easily knock a Sherman out. His attitude towards treating the Tiger as TheDreaded is appropriate as well; out in the French countryside, the Shermans held the advantage, using their superior speed and numbers, along with Allied air and ground support, to outflank the large, ponderous Tigers and take them down from the sides and back, but in a crowded city, with no reinforcements or support, a Tiger was the ''last'' thing an Allied tanker wanted to face down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommunicationsOfficer: Little Joe is the squads radioman. Booker serves as Colts communications officer but finds himself utterly confused by the contradictory messages he’s getting from Kelly and his Men’s attack when they aren’t supposed to be there.

to:

* CommunicationsOfficer: Little Joe is the squads radioman.radioman and isn't afraid to protest crazy orders to the people giving them himself when none of his superiors are nearby. Booker serves as Colts communications officer but finds himself utterly confused by the contradictory messages he’s getting from Kelly and his Men’s attack when they aren’t supposed to be there.

Added: 224

Changed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rewatching that scene I can only see make out two Americans in the jeep, not three; Kelly and another man I think is Gutowski (according to the opening credits order of appearances listing for the platoon members).


** How Kelly's American Jeep with three American soldiers and one German colonel get in the middle of a German column in the opening is never really explained.

to:

** How Kelly's American Jeep with three two American soldiers and one German colonel get in the middle of a German column in the opening is never really explained.



* OffscreenMomentOfAwesome: Whatever happened before the opening shots, to get Kelly, in a Jeep with American markings and three uniformed American soldiers and one German colonel into the middle of a German column in the opening.

to:

* OffscreenMomentOfAwesome: OffscreenMomentOfAwesome:
**
Whatever happened before the opening shots, shots to get Kelly, Kelly and Gutowski, in a Jeep with American markings and three uniformed markings, while wearing their American soldiers and one Army uniforms with a German colonel into as their prisoner, in the middle of a German column in the opening.column.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeletedRole: Production designer John Barry as a British airmen hiding in the town who witnesses the final battle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HomeGuard: the squad are members of the 35th Infantry Division, which is a National Guard unit which was activated for WW2.

to:

* HomeGuard: the squad are members of the 35th Infantry Division, which is a National Guard unit which was activated for WW2.UsefulNotes/WW2.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbiguousEnding: The ending of the movie leaves it vague as to whether Kelly and his companions are planning to [[spoiler: outright desert and ride out the war in Swtizerland, or merely hide the gold before rejoining the war effort, in order to be able to go home afterwards]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FriendlySniper: Gutowski is a bit trigger happy, but serves as the platoons sniper and lets himself show a little concern and reflection in the process.

Added: 1481

Changed: 125

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BunnyEarsLawyer: Oddball, for all his [[CloudCuckoolander myriad of quirks]], is a highly skilled tanker and extremely resourceful.

to:

* BunnyEarsLawyer: Oddball, for all his [[CloudCuckoolander myriad of quirks]], is a highly skilled tanker and extremely resourceful. He claims that he and his men deliberately try to appear zany and incompetent in order to avoid being sent on risky missions.


Added DiffLines:

* CaptainSmoothAndSergeantRough: Maitland and Big Joe, although Maitlands smoothness comes from apathy and being [[ArmchairMilitary as distant from the main action as possible]].
* CategoryTraitor: Little Joe is Italian and worries about being seen as this and shot if he’s captured.


Added DiffLines:

* CommunicationsOfficer: Little Joe is the squads radioman. Booker serves as Colts communications officer but finds himself utterly confused by the contradictory messages he’s getting from Kelly and his Men’s attack when they aren’t supposed to be there.


Added DiffLines:

* DeletedRole: Production designer John Barry as a British airmen hiding in the town who witnesses the final battle.


Added DiffLines:

* DrivesLikeCrazy: Cowboy cheerfully drives through walls and into their impromptu headquarters while returning from reconnaissance.


Added DiffLines:

* FrontlineGeneral: Zigzagged with General Colt, whose Introduced comfortable at headquarters jautbbossing people around but does feel stirred to personally lead the charge to join in Kelly’s push after hearing how far they’ve gotten on the radio.


Added DiffLines:

** Most of the fight at the bridge is offscreen, including one of Oddballs tanks making it across the river but then being destroyed.


Added DiffLines:

* RuggedScar: The tiger tank commander has one on his cheek.


Added DiffLines:

* ThoseTwoGuys: SouthernFriedPrivate’s Cowboy and Willard.


Added DiffLines:

* UncertainDoom: It’s unclear whether any of the crews of Oddballs other two tanks could have survived their losses, but even if they did, they don’t seem to have accompanied the others to Clermont.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HomeGuard: According to the should sleeve insignia, the squad are members of the 35th Infantry Division, which is a National Guard unit.

to:

* HomeGuard: According to the should sleeve insignia, the squad are members of the 35th Infantry Division, which is a National Guard unit.unit which was activated for WW2.

Added: 880

Removed: 880

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlackAndGrayMorality: The Allied side is full of soldiers obeying orders being tossed to the wolves by GloryHound generals [[ColonelKilgore that go around acting like the war is some kind of game]], JerkAss executive officers that loot everything that is not nailed to the ground yet remind the aforementioned soldiers that looting is an offense punishable with death [[TheNeidermeyer on top of other idiotic (and morale-killing) decisions]] and [[TrialByFriendlyFire other even more idiotic soldiers]], soldiers that are looking out for Number One and decide getting richer is worth going (and swindling other people) into a possible SuicideMission (''our heroes'', ladies and gentlemen) and the other side... yeah, they're the Nazis, and even then the couple that actually interact with the protagonists probably wouldn't be so bad if there wasn't a war going on... ''maybe''.



* GrayAndBlackMorality: The Allied side is full of soldiers obeying orders being tossed to the wolves by GloryHound generals [[ColonelKilgore that go around acting like the war is some kind of game]], JerkAss executive officers that loot everything that is not nailed to the ground yet remind the aforementioned soldiers that looting is an offense punishable with death [[TheNeidermeyer on top of other idiotic (and morale-killing) decisions]] and [[TrialByFriendlyFire other even more idiotic soldiers]], soldiers that are looking out for Number One and decide getting richer is worth going (and swindling other people) into a possible SuicideMission (''our heroes'', ladies and gentlemen) and the other side... yeah, they're the Nazis, and even then the couple that actually interact with the protagonists probably wouldn't be so bad if there wasn't a war going on... ''maybe''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FreudianExcuse: Kelly used to be a lieutenant and a good officer, but he was given orders to attack the wrong hill and half of his company was killed. His superiors then scapegoated him, demoted him to private, and put him in a unit that is almost always on the frontlines but also always taken off them right before they can catch any good breaks. (Like occupying a city with actual running water) With a background as depressing as that, it is easy to see why Kelly has ''zero'' loyalty to the army and why he's only out to line his pockets with some good old-fashioned Nazi gold bullion then desert before his wildly incompetent commanders can get him killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** To be fair, it was dark, cold, and raining. We had to see well enough as an audience, but it's safe to assume that conditions were bad enough to make it difficult for anyone to actually see, hear, and understand what was going on. Combine this with the all-too-human tendency to assume that nothing is going wrong, and to not believe what your senses are telling you when confronted with something completely unexpected, and it's not too far-fetched.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
minor corrections to quotes


-->'''Oddball:''' To a New Yorker like you, a hero is some kind of weird sandwich, not some nut who goes up against three Tigers!

to:

-->'''Oddball:''' To a New Yorker like you, a hero is some kind of weird sandwich, not some nut who goes up against takes on three Tigers!



-->'''Oddball:''' "Why can't you be righteous and hopeful for a change?"\\

to:

-->'''Oddball:''' "Why can't you be say something righteous and hopeful for a change?"\\

Added: 640

Removed: 620

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Three Russian T-34 tanks were converted into very life-like German Tiger Tanks (the real glaring error was the wheels of the tanks and its longer engine deck). Contrary to some claims, the Tigers weren't made for ''Kelly's Heroes'' but for an earlier film made in Yugoslavia starring Creator/YulBrynner called ''The Battle of Neretva''. The Shermans also come from that film. A close up shows the bow machine gun is an [=MG42=], which was never used in any German tank due to the quick-change barrel being removed from the front; the [=MG34=] was used instead because the barrel could be changed from inside the tank.


Added DiffLines:

* WeaponsUnderstudies: Three Russian T-34 tanks were converted into very life-like German Tiger Tanks (the real glaring error was the wheels of the tanks and its longer engine deck). Contrary to some claims, the Tigers weren't made for ''Kelly's Heroes'' but for an earlier film made in Yugoslavia starring Creator/YulBrynner called ''The Battle of Neretva''. The Shermans also come from that film. A close up shows the bow machine gun is an [=MG42=], which was never used in any German tank due to the quick-change barrel being removed from the front; the [=MG34=] was used instead because the barrel could be changed from inside the tank.

Added: 800

Removed: 370

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NominalHero: Kelly and his crew are motivated purely by opportunistic self-interest, and participate in the events of the film only for a chance to line their pockets. While they don't do anything particularly evil, they also exhibit nothing resembling selfless heroic behavior, either. Thus they are either "hero in name only" or a bunch of {{Villain Protagonist}}s.
** Kelly in particular. He convinces everyone (including a reluctant Big Joe) to abandon their posts and go deep into enemy lines for the gold while never mentioning, until it's too late to turn back, that the Germans are guarding the gold with greatly superior armaments (the three Tiger tanks). Big Joe is horrified when he learns about the Tigers, and even the eternally optimistic Oddball has to be talked into taking them on.



* NominalHero: Kelly and his crew are motivated purely by opportunistic self-interest, and participate in the events of the film only for a chance to line their pockets. While they don't do anything particularly evil, they also exhibit nothing resembling selfless heroic behavior, either. Thus they are either "hero in name only" or a bunch of {{Villain Protagonist}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The 76mm could penetrate a Tiger's armor but it didn't mean it always worked. The German tank was a tough nut to crack, and even a shot from the 76mm had a good chance bouncing off the armor depending on the angle or trajectory. Oddball's attitude was typical of tankers of the time, who didn't trust the guns and felt that the only sure-fire way to take out a Tiger was to flank it, particularly since the ''88mm'' gun on the Tiger could easily knock a Sherman out.

to:

** The 76mm could penetrate a Tiger's armor but it didn't mean it always worked. The German tank was a tough nut United States fell behind the Germans when it came to crack, Anti-Tank weaponry, and even a shot from while the 76mm had was an improvment, a good chance bouncing off the Tiger's armor could still bounce a shot depending on the angle or trajectory.angle/trajectory. Oddball's attitude was typical of tankers of the time, who didn't trust the guns and felt that the only sure-fire way to take out a Tiger was to flank it, particularly since the ''88mm'' gun on the Tiger could easily knock a Sherman out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The 76mm could penetrate a Tiger's armor but it didn't mean it always worked. The German tank was a tough nut to crack, and even a shot from the 76mm had a good chance bouncing off the armor depending on the angle or trajectory. Oddball's attitude was typical of tankers of the time, who didn't trust the guns and felt that the only sure-fire way to take out a Tiger was to flank it, particularly since the ''88mm'' gun on the Tiger could easily knock a Sherman out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlasPoorVillain: While "villain" is really stretching it, one can't help but feel bad for poor Colonel Dankhopf, wandering drunkenly across the battlefield until he's shot by one of his own Tiger tanks mistaking him for an American in the dark. Even Kelly looks visibly disturbed at his death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SuspiciouslySpecificDenial: When asked about "broads," Dankhopf says there is "a house," but then hastily insists, while avoiding eye contact with Big Joe, that "I cannot give you the directions, I've never been there..."

Added: 172

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Big Joe turns up at the farmhouse with a chaplain and some movies for the guys to watch, after he hears Kelly's speech he decides to go along with the plan which they start preparing. However the chaplain is still waiting in the jeep outside for a lift back to HQ.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Big Joe turns up at the farmhouse with a chaplain and some movies for the guys to watch, after he hears Kelly's speech he decides to go along with the plan which they start preparing. However the chaplain is still waiting in the jeep Jeep outside for a lift back to HQ. HQ.
** One surviving German soldier is seen running away from the minefield shootout. Nobody apparently notices him or tries to stop him. We never find out what happens to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InVinoVeritas: Kelly uses a bottle of brandy to interrogate Colonel Dankopf, getting him too drunk to be capable of lying.

to:

* InVinoVeritas: Kelly uses a bottle of brandy to interrogate Colonel Dankopf, Dankhopf, getting him too drunk to be capable of lying.



* ReadingTheEnemysMail: How Kelly finds out about the gold; it is hidden as a lead bar in Dankopf's satchel.

to:

* ReadingTheEnemysMail: How Kelly finds out about the gold; it is hidden as a lead bar in Dankopf's Dankhopf's satchel.



** The German Colonel's name, Dankopf, sounds terribly similar to Dummkopf ("idiot" in German).

to:

** The German Colonel's colonel's name, Dankopf, Dankhopf, sounds terribly similar to Dummkopf ("idiot" in German).German). Ironically he's "a colonel in Intelligence."



** Big Joe doesn't care about any intel Dankopf might have, he just wants to know which hotel at their objective is the nicest and if there are girls there.

to:

** Big Joe doesn't care about any intel Dankopf Dankhopf might have, he just wants to know which hotel at their objective is the nicest and if there are girls there.

Top