Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
''Hidden in Silence'' is a 1996 MadeForTVMovie telling a true story about survivors of UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust and their rescuer. Near the beginning of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII, young Stefania "Fusia" Podgorska (Creator/KellieMartin) is a Polish Catholic teenager who works in a shop girl for the Jewish Diamant family. The Nazis invade Poland and the Diamants are sent to a ghetto, where many of them are killed or deported. Fusia tries to bring them food and hope, while also taking in her pre-teen sister Helena after the rest of their family is conscripted as laborers. When the surviving Diamants escape, Fusia provides them shelter, and then finds other residents of the ghetto want her help as well.
!!Tropes:
* AllGermansAreNazis: Narrowly averted. Every German soldier who appears is a sinister and oppressive figure, but [[spoiler:the German factory manager is helping two Jewish factory workers hide from the Gestapo and gives Fusia more food and money to help her secret guests upon deducing their existence.[[note]] This is a pice of ArtisticLicenseHistory, though.[[/note]] The two German nurses are usually rude, but do show brief concern for Fusia during the Russian advance and aren't explicitly Nazis. They have a soldier inspect the attic after hearing a noise, though.]]
* BigSisterInstinct: Fusia is kind and protective of her little sister, stroking her hair after she's beaten and being reluctant to expose her to any more danger than necessary amidst her life-saving efforts.
* ChekhovsGun: When Fusia and the others move into the new house she bought, they find a discarded photo of a German soldier. [[spoiler:Later, they leave it out so Fusia's suitor Lubek will assume she has a German boyfriend and stop coming around.]]
* [[ChekhovsGunman Chekhov's Gunwoman]]: Mrs. Zimmerman first appears when Mr. and Mrs. Diamant are being deported to their doom, urgently keeping her daughter from being taken to the train by mistake. Some time later, she and her children end up being the last refugees admitted to the Podgorska home.
* CountryMouse: Fusia grew up on a farm and is excited and awed by the city in the first few scenes, although CharacterDevelopment quickly sets in.
* HappilyFailedSuicide: Max Diamant jumps off the deportation train in a suicide attempt, but he survives the fall, and this leads to him and his remaining family members surviving the Holocaust.
* HospitalHottie: Zigzagged when Fusia [[LivingWithTheVillain is forced to board two German nurses.]] They wear conservative uniforms and act cold and humorless on duty, but they spend most of their off-duty time made up nicely and being romantic with their boyfriends.
* KidsAreCruel: Both played straight (with two Polish children shown laughing and throwing things at Jews being forced out of their homes) and averted (with LittleMissBadass Helena and the frightened but sweet three children among the thirteen refugees).
* [[LastGirlWins Last Guy Wins]]: Isaak Diamant flirts with Fusia (his mother's employee) and there are hints that she and Lubek may have a ChildhoodFriendRomance. [[spoiler:Isaak is shot while trying to escape from a work gang, and Fusia has to lie to Lubek that she's dating a Nazi because her secret is too big to trust him with, after which he angrily storms off. She ends up marrying Isaak's brother Max, who only gets a little chemistry with her, rather late in the film.]]
* LittleMissBadass: Helena is only a small child, but she proves willing to help her big sister hide and feed refugees. She endures a beating when she's caught trying to deliver a message with the address for three ghetto prisoners to go to. She eats the message and escapes from the guard by kicking his shin. A few minutes later, she sneaks back to guide the three Jews back to Fusia's apartment.
* LivingWithTheVillain: The Nazis force Fusia and Helen to board two German nurses for a nearby military hospital after nearly putting the hospital itself in her house. Since 13 Jewish refugees are hiding in the sisters' attic, this causes some tension. It doesn't help that the nurses' soldier boyfriends (at least one of whom is anti-semitic) also end up living there.
* LooseLips: Dr. Hirsch isn't very close-mouthed about Fusia offering to hide him, and she ends up with half-a-dozen unplanned (although ultimately not unwelcome) queries for refuge from ghetto inhabitants Dr. Hirsch was indiscreet toward.
* RealityIsUnrealistic: While the film has some {{Dramatization}} or PragmaticAdaptation moments, several moments which some viewers initially thought were storytelling inventions were taken directly from the real people's accounts of the story.
** Fusia's prayers are answered at key moments in a MaybeMagicMaybeMundane way, and she considered this to be a miracle in real life.
** Helena was really accosted and beaten while doing a job that Fusia couldn't risk being recognized while doing.
** The protagonists LivingWithTheVillain for several months and the Germans hearing a noise and checking the attic is real.
** Fusia really did sneak into the ghetto multiple times to meet with people before they came to her house.
** [[spoiler:Fusia did have a boyfriend who was tricked thinking she's dating a German officer because the group couldn't risk letting him find out about her secret houseguests.]]
** The first Russian soldier the group encounters after liberation really was another Jew.
!!Tropes:
* AllGermansAreNazis: Narrowly averted. Every German soldier who appears is a sinister and oppressive figure, but [[spoiler:the German factory manager is helping two Jewish factory workers hide from the Gestapo and gives Fusia more food and money to help her secret guests upon deducing their existence.[[note]] This is a pice of ArtisticLicenseHistory, though.[[/note]] The two German nurses are usually rude, but do show brief concern for Fusia during the Russian advance and aren't explicitly Nazis. They have a soldier inspect the attic after hearing a noise, though.]]
* BigSisterInstinct: Fusia is kind and protective of her little sister, stroking her hair after she's beaten and being reluctant to expose her to any more danger than necessary amidst her life-saving efforts.
* ChekhovsGun: When Fusia and the others move into the new house she bought, they find a discarded photo of a German soldier. [[spoiler:Later, they leave it out so Fusia's suitor Lubek will assume she has a German boyfriend and stop coming around.]]
* [[ChekhovsGunman Chekhov's Gunwoman]]: Mrs. Zimmerman first appears when Mr. and Mrs. Diamant are being deported to their doom, urgently keeping her daughter from being taken to the train by mistake. Some time later, she and her children end up being the last refugees admitted to the Podgorska home.
* CountryMouse: Fusia grew up on a farm and is excited and awed by the city in the first few scenes, although CharacterDevelopment quickly sets in.
* HappilyFailedSuicide: Max Diamant jumps off the deportation train in a suicide attempt, but he survives the fall, and this leads to him and his remaining family members surviving the Holocaust.
* HospitalHottie: Zigzagged when Fusia [[LivingWithTheVillain is forced to board two German nurses.]] They wear conservative uniforms and act cold and humorless on duty, but they spend most of their off-duty time made up nicely and being romantic with their boyfriends.
* KidsAreCruel: Both played straight (with two Polish children shown laughing and throwing things at Jews being forced out of their homes) and averted (with LittleMissBadass Helena and the frightened but sweet three children among the thirteen refugees).
* [[LastGirlWins Last Guy Wins]]: Isaak Diamant flirts with Fusia (his mother's employee) and there are hints that she and Lubek may have a ChildhoodFriendRomance. [[spoiler:Isaak is shot while trying to escape from a work gang, and Fusia has to lie to Lubek that she's dating a Nazi because her secret is too big to trust him with, after which he angrily storms off. She ends up marrying Isaak's brother Max, who only gets a little chemistry with her, rather late in the film.]]
* LittleMissBadass: Helena is only a small child, but she proves willing to help her big sister hide and feed refugees. She endures a beating when she's caught trying to deliver a message with the address for three ghetto prisoners to go to. She eats the message and escapes from the guard by kicking his shin. A few minutes later, she sneaks back to guide the three Jews back to Fusia's apartment.
* LivingWithTheVillain: The Nazis force Fusia and Helen to board two German nurses for a nearby military hospital after nearly putting the hospital itself in her house. Since 13 Jewish refugees are hiding in the sisters' attic, this causes some tension. It doesn't help that the nurses' soldier boyfriends (at least one of whom is anti-semitic) also end up living there.
* LooseLips: Dr. Hirsch isn't very close-mouthed about Fusia offering to hide him, and she ends up with half-a-dozen unplanned (although ultimately not unwelcome) queries for refuge from ghetto inhabitants Dr. Hirsch was indiscreet toward.
* RealityIsUnrealistic: While the film has some {{Dramatization}} or PragmaticAdaptation moments, several moments which some viewers initially thought were storytelling inventions were taken directly from the real people's accounts of the story.
** Fusia's prayers are answered at key moments in a MaybeMagicMaybeMundane way, and she considered this to be a miracle in real life.
** Helena was really accosted and beaten while doing a job that Fusia couldn't risk being recognized while doing.
** The protagonists LivingWithTheVillain for several months and the Germans hearing a noise and checking the attic is real.
** Fusia really did sneak into the ghetto multiple times to meet with people before they came to her house.
** [[spoiler:Fusia did have a boyfriend who was tricked thinking she's dating a German officer because the group couldn't risk letting him find out about her secret houseguests.]]
** The first Russian soldier the group encounters after liberation really was another Jew.
