Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince

Go To

OR

Changed: 205

Removed: 198

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the book, there is a subplot in which Harry, Ron, and Hermione have a falling out with Hagrid as he’s upset they were forced to drop his class for their sixth year of studies. They grow cold and distant from each other and eventually hostile, but eventually reconcile when Hagrid reveals that he fears that Aragog is dying, and realizes that they didn’t drop his class due to not liking him anymore.
In the film, Hagrid is only seen in the background, if at all, between taking Katie to the castle and Aragog's funeral, and no mention of Aragog, his health or otherwise, is made prior to his death.

to:

** In the book, there is a subplot in which Harry, Ron, and Hermione have a falling out with Hagrid as he’s he's upset they were forced to drop his class for their sixth year of studies. They grow cold and distant from each other and eventually hostile, but eventually reconcile when Hagrid reveals that he fears that Aragog is dying, and he realizes that they didn’t didn't drop his class due to not liking him anymore.
anymore. In the film, Hagrid is only seen in the background, if at all, between taking Katie to the castle and Aragog's funeral, and no mention of Aragog, his health or otherwise, is made prior to his death.

Added: 198

Changed: 787

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the book, Harry, Hermione, and Ron had seen very little of Hagrid for some time. He had not been attending meals, and was not seen around the school very much, and whenever they did see Hagrid, he would fail to acknowledge them. Finally, the three visit Hagrid at his hut, and notice he has a barrel of foot-long maggots, which he tells them is food for Aragog. Hagrid goes on to tell Harry, Hermione, and Ron that Aragog got sick over the summer and was not getting any better, and Hagrid fears Aragog may be dying. In the film, Hagrid is only seen in the background, if at all, between taking Katie to the castle and Aragog's funeral, and no mention of Aragog, his health or otherwise, is made prior to his death.

to:

** In the book, there is a subplot in which Harry, Hermione, Ron, and Ron had seen very little of Hermione have a falling out with Hagrid for some time. He had not been attending meals, and was not seen around the school very much, and whenever as he’s upset they did see Hagrid, he would fail were forced to acknowledge them. Finally, the three visit drop his class for their sixth year of studies. They grow cold and distant from each other and eventually hostile, but eventually reconcile when Hagrid at his hut, and notice reveals that he has a barrel of foot-long maggots, which he tells them is food for Aragog. Hagrid goes on to tell Harry, Hermione, and Ron fears that Aragog got sick over the summer is dying, and was realizes that they didn’t drop his class due to not getting any better, and Hagrid fears Aragog may be dying. liking him anymore.
In the film, Hagrid is only seen in the background, if at all, between taking Katie to the castle and Aragog's funeral, and no mention of Aragog, his health or otherwise, is made prior to his death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CassandraTruth: Bellatrix's [[spoiler:mistrust of Snape]] is rather prophetic, but this won't be apparent until the final film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At the midpoint of the film, the Death Eaters attack and burn down the Burrow, in a scene not in the books. The filmmakers added this to add a perilous beat for the characters in a second act that didn't have one otherwise, rather than the characters reading about the Death Eaters' menace in the ''Prophet'' as in the novel.

to:

** At the midpoint of the film, the Death Eaters attack and burn down the Burrow, in a scene not in the books. The filmmakers added this to add have a perilous beat for the characters in a second act that didn't have one otherwise, rather than the characters reading about the Death Eaters' menace in the ''Prophet'' as in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At the midpoint of the film, the Death Eaters attack and burn down the Burrow, in a scene not in the books.

to:

** At the midpoint of the film, the Death Eaters attack and burn down the Burrow, in a scene not in the books. The filmmakers added this to add a perilous beat for the characters in a second act that didn't have one otherwise, rather than the characters reading about the Death Eaters' menace in the ''Prophet'' as in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Subverted. In the book, the scene of Harry finally confronting Slughorn about [[spoiler:the Horcruxes]] takes a tragicomic light, with the professor being completely shitfaced and eventually devolving into crying and begging for his actions. The film is not so dramatic, as it instead keeps Slughorn relatively composed, but it makes it much more personal for him by adding an original speech, fully capitalizing on Jim Broadbent's talent, where Slughorn recalls [[spoiler:how deep his bond with Lily was and how he felt when he found out his actions had resulted in her death.]]

Added: 172

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Draco's efforts in the Room of Requirement are shown much earlier in the film for the sake of DramaticIrony - including using an apple and two birds to test [[spoiler: the Vanishing Cabinet]].

to:

** Draco's efforts in the Room of Requirement are shown much earlier in the film for the sake of DramaticIrony - including using an apple and two birds to test [[spoiler: the Vanishing Cabinet]].Cabinet.


Added DiffLines:

* DramaticSitDown: A shaken Dumbledore sits down rather heavily on some steps in his office after finding out that Slughorn told Tom Riddle about Horcruxes back in the day.

Added: 3758

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActionizedAdaptation:
** There has been an additional scene in the film which has no book equivalent. The Burrow is attacked by Death Eaters during the Christmas holidays. Bellatrix Lestrange and Fenrir Greyback are the only Death Eaters shown. Greyback flies and lands in a ball of flame and casts a ring of fire around the Burrow (possibly Fiendfyre, as the flames are quite large and take the form of a serpent). Lestrange lands in black smoke and taunts Harry, chanting "I killed Sirius Black! I killed Sirius Black!" Harry takes off after her in rage. Ginny takes off after him, trying to stop him. Lupin, Tonks, and Arthur Weasley follow them into the grassy marsh. While the five are lost in the field, looking for the Death Eaters, the Death Eaters take off and set the Burrow aflame, burning it presumably to the ground, before leaving. There is no further mention in the film of how the home is restored or what happened to it afterwards. The Burrow was supposed to be protected against the Death Eaters, and they simply set fire to it with no effort. By the time Harry returns to it in the film adaptation Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, the Burrow had already been rebuilt.
** Harry and Draco's duel is longer and more intense in the film. In the book, Malfoy turns around and attacks, and Harry almost immediately uses sectumsempra after the two of them cast about two spells each at each other. In the film, Harry and Malfoy shoot several spells at each other, hide behind stalls and shoot spells at each other underneath the stalls, run around the stalls while shooting spells at each other and finally Harry uses Sectumsempra on Draco when he sees him standing on the other side of the bathroom, directly after coming out from under cover.



** House-elf Kreacher and the Hippogriff Buckbeak are omitted from the film, and there is no mention of Hagrid getting Buckbeak back.
** Discussion of Bill and Fleur's wedding arrangements, Fleur's stay at the Burrow, and even both characters, have been omitted. Bill doesn't get bitten by Fenrir Greyback as he does in the book. However, in the next film, he is shown bearing scars from being attacked by Greyback. This creates a plot hole in the next film since it is unknown where, how and when the scarring happened.



** The scene with Fudge catching up the Muggle Prime Minister on what’s going on in the Wizarding World is absent.

to:

** The scene with Fudge catching up the Muggle Prime Minister on what’s what's going on in the Wizarding World is absent.



** Creator/EmmaThompson does not return as Professor Trelawney and the scene where Snape's role as double-agent is not shown or mentioned.



* ADeathInTheLimelight: [[spoiler:Michael Gambon as Dumbledore gets the largest presence in the movies and its promotion (see the above poster) as befitting his final living role in the series.]]

to:

* ADeathInTheLimelight: [[spoiler:Michael Gambon [[spoiler:Creator/MichaelGambon as Dumbledore gets the largest presence in the movies movie and its promotion (see the above poster) as befitting his final living role in the series.]]]]
* DecompositeCharacter: The way Harry is found is different in the film. In the book, Tonks finds Harry, stating that she did not see him leave the train and, knowing Harry has his cloak, decided to double check the train. In the film, it is Luna Lovegood who finds Harry with her Spectrespecs, stating that she can see Wrackspurts all over him.


Added DiffLines:

** In the book, Harry, Hermione, and Ron had seen very little of Hagrid for some time. He had not been attending meals, and was not seen around the school very much, and whenever they did see Hagrid, he would fail to acknowledge them. Finally, the three visit Hagrid at his hut, and notice he has a barrel of foot-long maggots, which he tells them is food for Aragog. Hagrid goes on to tell Harry, Hermione, and Ron that Aragog got sick over the summer and was not getting any better, and Hagrid fears Aragog may be dying. In the film, Hagrid is only seen in the background, if at all, between taking Katie to the castle and Aragog's funeral, and no mention of Aragog, his health or otherwise, is made prior to his death.


Added DiffLines:

* DueToTheDead: Professor [=McGonagall=] joins the crowd who discovered Dumbledore's body in the foot of the Astronomy Tower. She leads the Hogwarts students and staff in raising their wands to be rid of the Dark Mark and in respect for the now-deceased Headmaster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The scene with Fudge catching up the Muggle Prime Minister on what’s going on in the Wizarding World is absent.
** Rufus Scrimgeour and Percy Weasley also don’t appear in the film as their scene at Christmas got cut.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince'' is the sixth ''Film/HarryPotter'' film, released in 2009.

to:

''Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince'' is the sixth ''Film/HarryPotter'' film, directed by Creator/DavidYates and released in 2009.

Added: 695

Changed: 585

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrappedWithTheTherapySession: Harry and Ron are in a train compartment together when Lavender, Ron's girlfriend, comes up and breathes on the glass pane of the door so she can draw a heart with her and Ron's initials. Harry starts examining his armrest as if he's never seen one before.
* VomitDiscretionShot: At one point, Cormac is shown leaning down out of camera shot and vomiting on Snape's shoes.

to:

* TrappedWithTheTherapySession: TrappedWithTheTherapySession:
**
Harry and Ron are in a train compartment together when Lavender, Ron's girlfriend, comes up and breathes on the glass pane of the door so she can draw a heart with her and Ron's initials. Harry starts examining his armrest as if he's never seen one before.
** When Ron is in the hospital wing unconscious from a poisoning, Lavender Brown (who he had been dating) rushes to his bedside. She starts to call his name, which causes him to stir... and croak out Hermione's name. Lavender runs off in furious tears, while Hermione takes her place sitting by Ron. Professor Snape, presumably dragged to the hospital wing by Dumbledore, has a sour look on his face throughout as he watches the teenage love triangle drama. But Dumbledore finds it amusing.
--->'''Dumbledore:''' Ah, to be young, and to feel love's keen sting.
* VomitDiscretionShot: At one point, Cormac is shown leaning down out of camera shot and vomiting on Snape's shoes. Snape is not amused.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


After ''Goblet of Fire'' and ''Order of the Phoenix'' began cutting plots and characters left and right to fit as movies, this film has an air of just going with it, and happily continues in the direction set by the films so far, cuts and all. While it may cause fans to nitpick (it's rather involuntary at this point), it's nevertheless easily one of the biggest fan-favorites of the series. Perhaps most notable is the major factor that the final book had been released by this film's premiere, allowing this film to begin some heavier foreshadowing of the next films since the writer finally knew how the story would end.

to:

After ''Goblet of Fire'' and ''Order of the Phoenix'' began cutting plots and characters left and right to fit as movies, this film has an air of just going with it, and happily continues in the direction set by the films so far, cuts and all. While it may cause fans to nitpick (it's rather involuntary at this point), it's nevertheless easily one of the biggest fan-favorites of the series. Perhaps most notable is the major factor that the final book had been released by this film's premiere, allowing this film to begin some heavier foreshadowing of the next films since the writer finally knew how the story would end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BackToBackBadasses: During the attack at the Burrow, the Harry, Ginny, Arthur, Lupin, and Tonks are all facing outwards in a circle as they are watching out for hidden Death Eaters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AshFace: Seamus Finnegan ([[RunningGag as usual]]) during a failed attempt to brew the Draught of Living Death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NasalTrauma: As with the book, Harry is caught spying on Malfoy and gets his nose kicked in for his trouble. However, the film adds an extra layer of this when Luna Lovegood has to pop his nose back into place with magic, resulting in a loud cracking sound and a yelp of pain from Harry - bit of a change from the original novel in which Tonks' Episkey spell was completely painless.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrappedWithTheTherapySession: Harry and Ron are in a train compartment together when Lavender, Ron's girlfriend, comes up and breathes on the glass pane of the door so she can draw a heart with her and Ron's initials. Harry starts examining his armrest as if he's never seen one before.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Addressing a common complaint of the novel, Ginny has several more one-on-one exchanges with Harry than in the novel to better build a romantic connection between the two.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking.


* CagedBirdMetaphor: Draco is shown framed through the spherical cage of the songbirds he is using to test the vanishing cabinet, mirroring his duress at the task he has been ordered to complete. The final bird he is left with matches his unusual hair color.



* CastingGag: Helen [=McCrory=] who plays Narcissa, was the original actress cast for Bellatrix - but she had to back out after getting pregnant. And her replacement (and on-screen sister) Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter was pregnant during production of this film.

to:

* CastingGag: Helen [=McCrory=] who plays Narcissa, was the original actress cast for Bellatrix - -- but she had to back out after getting pregnant. And her replacement (and on-screen sister) Creator/HelenaBonhamCarter was pregnant during production of this film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewTheRulesIMakeThem: Dumbledore and Harry apparate, arriving ''within'' the Hogwarts grounds, something it was repeatedly pointed out in the books was impossible. Were it possible, Draco wouldn't have had to fiddle with a Vanishing Cabinet for months to get the Death Eaters in. But Dumbledore hints that there's a special exemption in the defensive barriers for the Headmaster:

to:

* ScrewTheRulesIMakeThem: Dumbledore and Harry apparate, arriving ''within'' the Hogwarts grounds, something it was repeatedly pointed out in the books was impossible. (In the book, Harry and Dumbledore walk to Hogsmeade before apparating to the cave, and return to Hogsmeade before flying back to Hogwarts. For obvious time-constraint reasons, this gets trimmed to apparating directly to and from Hogwarts.) Were it possible, Draco wouldn't have had to fiddle with a Vanishing Cabinet for months to get the Death Eaters in. But Dumbledore hints that there's a special exemption in the defensive barriers for the Headmaster:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moderator restored to earlier version
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ADeathInTheLimelight: [[spoiler:Michael Gambon as Dumbledore gets the largest presence in the movies and its promotion (see the above poster) as befitting his final living role in the series.]]

to:

* ADeathInTheLimelight: [[spoiler:Michael Gambon as Dumbledore gets the largest presence in the movies and its promotion (see the above poster) as befitting his final living role in the series.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/harrypotter6.png]]

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/harrypotter6.png]] org/pmwiki/pub/images/aa98bbc2_0caa_4e3d_b952_59248837c36f.jpeg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoodWhiplash: Right after Slughorn cures Ron of Romilda's love potion, he, Ron and Harry attempt to have a drink together, which causes Ron to collapse. At first, it seems like a CrowningMomentOfFunny... until Ron starts spasming and nearly convulsing on the floor.

to:

* MoodWhiplash: Right after Slughorn cures Ron of Romilda's love potion, he, Ron and Harry attempt to have a drink together, which causes Ron to collapse. At first, it seems like a CrowningMomentOfFunny...SugarWiki/{{Funny Moment|s}}... until Ron starts spasming and nearly convulsing on the floor.

Added: 1152

Changed: 275

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Narcissa is a combination - where she's completely blonde in the book but gets two-toned hair (blonde and black) for the film.



** The scene where Narcissa has an argument with the trio and taunts Harry about Sirius's death is left out of the film, so that she looks entirely like a concerned mother.



* AscendedExtra: Ginny, who goes from minor character to a rather vital person in Harry's life. A common complaint of the book is that this happens too much in a "tell, don't show" manner, so the film tries to temper this by giving her character more development (and more time around Harry).

to:

* AscendedExtra: AscendedExtra:
**
Ginny, who goes from minor character to a rather vital person in Harry's life. A common complaint of the book is that this happens too much in a "tell, don't show" manner, so the film tries to temper this by giving her character more development (and more time around Harry).Harry).
** Bellatrix just appeared in the Unbreakable Vow chapter in the book. In the film she gets additional scenes where she attacks the Burrow with Fenrir Greyback - and [[spoiler: leads the Death Eaters into Hogwarts at the end. She also gets to cast the Dark Mark after Dumbledore is killed and set fire to Hagrid's house]].


Added DiffLines:

* SettingUpdate: Though the previous film had hinted at one from the 90s to the 2000s - Mr Weasley using an Oyster Card, the fashions on some of the characters - this one confirms it with the opening showing the Millennium Bridge being destroyed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Subplots involving Ron's insecurity and Cormac [=MacLaggen=]'s bossiness were cut for time, leaving Ron without much of a character arc and Cormac as a mere DesignatedVillain.

to:

** Subplots involving Ron's insecurity and Cormac [=MacLaggen=]'s bossiness were cut for time, leaving Ron without much of a character arc and Cormac as a mere DesignatedVillain.[[invoked]]

Added: 110

Changed: 207

Removed: 327

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActorAllusion:
** Whether intentional or not, Slughorn called Ron 'Rupert', a reference to Rupert Grint, who plays Ron in the movies.
** Creator/AlanRickman had a reaction like this when filming [[spoiler: Dumbledore's death scene]], since it wasn't the first time he'd been involved in someone being shot off [[Film/DieHard a high building]].

to:

* ActorAllusion:
** Whether intentional or not, Slughorn called Ron 'Rupert', a reference to Rupert Grint, who plays Ron in the movies.
**
ActorAllusion: Creator/AlanRickman had a reaction like this when filming [[spoiler: Dumbledore's death scene]], since it wasn't the first time he'd been involved in someone being shot off [[Film/DieHard a high building]].


Added DiffLines:

** At the midpoint of the film, the Death Eaters attack and burn down the Burrow, in a scene not in the books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Draco's efforts in the Room of Requirement are shown much earlier in the book for the sake of DramaticIrony - including using an apple and two birds to test [[spoiler: the Vanishing Cabinet]].

to:

** Draco's efforts in the Room of Requirement are shown much earlier in the book film for the sake of DramaticIrony - including using an apple and two birds to test [[spoiler: the Vanishing Cabinet]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DenserAndWackier: Downplayed, but the film has a lot more comedic moments and [[WorldOfSnark more snarking from all characters]]. The Felix Felicis scene is played much more for comedy than it is in the book. Some reviews even labelled the film a RomanticComedy. There are however plenty of serious moments (including introducing some tear jerker scenes that weren't in the book).

to:

* DenserAndWackier: Downplayed, but the film has a lot more comedic moments and [[WorldOfSnark more snarking from all characters]]. The Felix Felicis scene is played much more for comedy than it is in the book. Some reviews even labelled the film a RomanticComedy. There are however plenty of serious moments (including introducing some tear jerker scenes that weren't in the book).



* ExpositoryHairstyleChange: Malfoy's hair shortening into a neater short, back and sides signals his transition into a more serious and conflicted character.

to:

* ExpositoryHairstyleChange: Malfoy's hair shortening into a neater short, back and sides signals his transition into a more serious and conflicted character.

Added: 2296

Changed: 799

Removed: 134

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Exclusive to the film is Slughorn's story about Francis, a fish Lily Evans made out of a lily petal as a student which she gave to Slughorn. He lost it 16 years ago, the very day Lily Potter was killed, a fact which makes Slughorn guilty enough to help Lily's son at the expense of his own security.

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: AdaptationExpansion:
**
Exclusive to the film is Slughorn's story about Francis, a fish Lily Evans made out of a lily petal as a student which she gave to Slughorn. He lost it 16 years ago, the very day Lily Potter was killed, a fact which makes Slughorn guilty enough to help Lily's son at the expense of his own security.security.
** Draco's efforts in the Room of Requirement are shown much earlier in the book for the sake of DramaticIrony - including using an apple and two birds to test [[spoiler: the Vanishing Cabinet]].



** Romilda Vane had a rather unattractive personality in the book, and was an AbhorrentAdmirer to Harry. Here however when Hermione tells him she's interested in him, he's not opposed to the idea.



* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Despite being set in 1996-97, they manage to destroy the Millennium Bridge, which wasn't started until 1998.



* CreepyChild: Tom Riddle, but especially so in the movie (which works really well, seeing it's the nephew of the guy who plays him as an adult!). A good example - in both the book and the movie Dumbledore sets Tom's collection of trophies he's stolen from the other orphans on fire to both show him he's not lying and (attempt to) teach him a lesson. Book Tom's reaction to a bonfire erupting in his room is awed shock and a bit of fake apology. Movie's Tom's reaction is an ''undeniably giddy smile.'' <shudder>

to:

* CreepyChild: CreepyChild:
**
Tom Riddle, but especially so in the movie (which works really well, seeing it's the nephew of the guy who plays him as an adult!). A good example - in both the book and the movie Dumbledore sets Tom's collection of trophies he's stolen from the other orphans on fire to both show him he's not lying and (attempt to) teach him a lesson. Book Tom's reaction to a bonfire erupting in his room is awed shock and a bit of fake apology. Movie's Tom's reaction is an ''undeniably giddy smile.'' <shudder>


Added DiffLines:

** Dean's status as Ginny's boyfriend gets less attention, and they split up much sooner (allowing Ginny and Harry to flirt more before their eventual hook-up).
* DenserAndWackier: Downplayed, but the film has a lot more comedic moments and [[WorldOfSnark more snarking from all characters]]. The Felix Felicis scene is played much more for comedy than it is in the book. Some reviews even labelled the film a RomanticComedy. There are however plenty of serious moments (including introducing some tear jerker scenes that weren't in the book).


Added DiffLines:

* ExpositoryHairstyleChange: Malfoy's hair shortening into a neater short, back and sides signals his transition into a more serious and conflicted character.


Added DiffLines:

* NeverTrustATrailer: The trailer showed a shot of what looked like Death Eaters apparating towards Hogwarts. In the film, said scene ends with the Death Eaters slamming into the defensive barriers preventing them from getting in.


Added DiffLines:

* PromotedToLoveInterest: Remus and Tonks being involved is a surprise twist that comes at the very end of the book. The film has them already being a couple by Christmas.

Added: 322

Removed: 322

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Exclusive to the film is Slughorn's story about Francis, a fish Lily Evans made out of a lily petal as a student which she gave to Slughorn. He lost it 16 years ago, the very day Lily Potter was killed, a fact which makes Slughorn guilty enough to help Lily's son at the expense of his own security.



* AdaptationExpansion: Exclusive to the film is Slughorn's story about Francis, a fish Lily Evans made out of a lily petal as a student which she gave to Slughorn. He lost it 16 years ago, the very day Lily Potter was killed, a fact which makes Slughorn guilty enough to help Lily's son at the expense of his own security.

Top