Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / HacksawRidge

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 383

Changed: 361

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoesntLikeGuns: Desmond's become allergic to guns as a result of his traumatic confrontation with his dad when trying to protect his mom.

to:

* DoesntLikeGuns: Desmond's become basically allergic to guns as a result of his traumatic confrontation with his dad when trying to protect his mom.



* HiddenDepths: Captain Glover comes across, in his own words, as a "hardass who only cares about rules and regulations" but reveals to Desmond that he is also a devout Christian who struggles to reconcile his faith with his duty as a soldier. He even seems to respect Desmond's beliefs, just feeling they're not compatible with being a soldier.

to:

* HiddenDepths: Captain Glover comes across, in his own words, as a "hardass who only cares about rules and regulations" but reveals to Desmond that he is also a devout Christian who struggles to reconcile his faith with his duty as a soldier. He even seems to respect Desmond's beliefs, beliefs and his sincere devotion to them, just feeling they're not compatible with being a soldier.



* HumbleHero: Doss never thinks of himself as anything more than a regular soldier and medic just trying to do his duty. As the epilogue shows, this was very much truth in television as the real Doss would dismiss any claims that he was a hero by saying the real heroes were the ones who had given their lives in combat.

to:

* HumbleHero: Doss never thinks of himself as anything more than a regular soldier and medic just trying to do his duty. As the epilogue shows, this was very much truth in television as the real Doss would dismiss any claims that he was a hero by saying the real heroes were the ones who had given their lives in combat.combat and claiming the feeling of helping a soldier who thought he'd been blinded would've been more than enough.



** Smitty. He acts quite assholish to Desmond because of the latter's nonviolent beliefs, even smacking him with his bible. He was also ''[[EverybodyHasStandards against]]'' another group of men for beating up Doss for the reason. And later on, he proves to be quite brave and selfless in battle, and even admits that he can be an asshole.

to:

** Smitty. He acts quite assholish to Desmond because of the latter's nonviolent beliefs, even smacking him with his bible. He was also ''[[EverybodyHasStandards against]]'' another group of men for beating up Doss for the reason. And later on, he proves to be quite brave and selfless in battle, battle and opens up to Doss and comes to respect him, and even admits that he can be an asshole.



** Captain Glover works with Howell to try and force Desmond out but he has a moment of private connection with him where he speaks about his own faith and pleads with Doss to simply leave before he is dishonorably discharged. He also cares deeply for the men under his watch and tells Desmond he was wrong and asks his forgiveness after he sees how bravely he served in rescuing other soldiers.

to:

** Captain Glover works with Howell to try and force Desmond out but he has a moment of private connection with him where he speaks about his own faith and his difficulty in reconciling it with his duty as a soldier and pleads with Doss to simply leave before he is dishonorably discharged.discharged, ruining his life. He also cares deeply for the men under his watch and tells Desmond he was wrong and asks his forgiveness after he sees how bravely he served in rescuing other soldiers.



* MusclesAreMeaningless: Doss' skinny frame, which earns him the nickname "private cornstock" from Howell, doesn't stop him from lifting and hoisting grown men and running them across the battlefield. The footage at the end shows the real Doss was similarly built.



* NiceGuy: Desmond is a sweet-natured, humble and sincere young man who even hardass soldiers like Smitty come to like.



** Smitty offers one of his cigarettes to one of the soldiers who has been at Hacksaw Ridge longer and is traumatized by it.

to:

** Smitty offers one of his cigarettes to one of the soldiers who has been at Hacksaw Ridge longer and is traumatized by it. He also opens up to Doss when they share a hole together and comes to respect him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not an example, this is accurate for the time.


* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: During the basic training scenes, none of the recruits have shaved heads, which is the standard for recruits going through boot camp. Given the hard work Gibson put in to make certain the film was as historically accurate as possible, this is very puzzling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* IconicLogo: Subtly done. The movie poster, the DVD cover, and the title screen of the film itself all include a very tasteful [[UsefulNotes/TheRedCross Red Cross]]. Ironic in that almost the first thing that Doss is told when he arrives at Okinawa is to lose his.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Better to move past "they all look the same" implications.


** Possibly justified as an AcceptableBreakFromReality since viewers might find it harder to tell individual characters apart if they were all young(ish) bald white men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HumbleHero: Doss never thinks of himself as anything more than a regular soldier and medic just trying to do his duty. As the epilogue shows, this was very much truth in television as the real Doss would dismiss any claims that he was a hero by saying the real heroes were the ones who had given their lives in combat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GeekPhysiques: Doss' skinny frame is mocked extensively by Sergeant Howell. Not that [[MusclesAreMeaningless it slows him down at all]]. Footage of the real Doss at the end shows it wasn't just due to Andrew Garfield's casting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* AdultFear:
** Desmond's parents get a heavy dose of this in the beginning when Desmond and Hal get into a fight ending with the former knocking the latter unconscious with a brick. Hal thankfully survives, but Desmond and his mother are aware that Desmond could've killed him.
** Tom Doss faces his when both his boys enlist in WWII. He is terrified they will be killed and, though he doesn't say so, equally terrified that they will survive and end up [[ShellShockedVeteran like him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SatchelCharge: US M37 Satchel charges are used to clear out Japanese bunkers, tunnels, and surface defenses during the fight to take the titular ridge. When used alongside flamethrowers, they prove to be very efficient at wiping out huge swathes of hiding Japanese soldiers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EverybodyHasStandards: Smitty and Howell, two of Desmond's most vocal critics, aren't particularly impressed when Desmond's squadmates start beating on him, and Smitty actually sticks up for him. Howell even seems genuinely (but subtly) aghast when he sees Desmond's face in the morning, and sympathetically tries to convince Desmond to quit and go home for his own safety.

to:

* EverybodyHasStandards: Smitty and Howell, two of Desmond's most vocal critics, aren't particularly impressed when Desmond's squadmates start beating on him, and Smitty actually sticks up for him. Howell even seems genuinely (but subtly) aghast when he sees Desmond's face in the morning, and sympathetically tries to convince Desmond to quit and go home for his own safety.safety, telling him there's no shame in not being suited to life as a soldier.



* OneManArmy: Several of Desmond's fellow soldiers, as the battle rages on, but Sergeant Howell and Smitty stand out.

to:

* OneManArmy: Several of Desmond's fellow soldiers, as the battle rages on, but Sergeant Howell and Smitty stand out. Desmond also qualifies in his own way, rescuing dozens of soldiers on his own.

Added: 833

Changed: 47

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HiddenDepths: Captain Glover comes across, in his own words, as a "hardass who only cares about rules and regulations" but reveals to Desmond that he is also a devout Christian who struggles to reconcile his faith with his duty as a soldier. He even seems to respect Desmond's beliefs, just feeling they're not compatible with being a soldier.



** Howell is just a guy [[DrillSergeantNasty doing his job]] [[JerkassHasAPoint who doesn't think a guy who doesn't want to even touch a gun should be allowed into a combat zone where other soldiers will be forced to rely on him.]] He comes to respect Doss after he takes a vicious beating from his squadmates but still refuses to quit.

to:

** Howell is just a guy [[DrillSergeantNasty doing his job]] [[JerkassHasAPoint who doesn't think a guy who doesn't want to even touch a gun should be allowed into a combat zone where other soldiers will be forced to rely on him.]] He comes to respect Doss after he takes a vicious beating from his squadmates but still refuses to quit.quit and later during their time in combat together.


Added DiffLines:

** Captain Glover works with Howell to try and force Desmond out but he has a moment of private connection with him where he speaks about his own faith and pleads with Doss to simply leave before he is dishonorably discharged. He also cares deeply for the men under his watch and tells Desmond he was wrong and asks his forgiveness after he sees how bravely he served in rescuing other soldiers.


Added DiffLines:

* RealMenEatMeat: Averted. Doss is a vegetarian. Smitty only responds that "of course he is".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EverybodyHasStandards: Smitty and Howell, two of Desmond's most vocal critics, aren't particularly impressed when Desmond's squadmates start beating on him, and Smitty actually sticks up for him. Howell even seems genuinely (but subtly) aghast when he sees Desmond's face in the morning.

to:

* EverybodyHasStandards: Smitty and Howell, two of Desmond's most vocal critics, aren't particularly impressed when Desmond's squadmates start beating on him, and Smitty actually sticks up for him. Howell even seems genuinely (but subtly) aghast when he sees Desmond's face in the morning.morning, and sympathetically tries to convince Desmond to quit and go home for his own safety.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Possibly justified as an [[AcceptableBreaksfromReality Acceptable Break from Reality]], since viewers might find it harder to tell individual characters apart if they were all young(ish) bald white men.

to:

** Possibly justified as an [[AcceptableBreaksfromReality Acceptable Break from Reality]], AcceptableBreakFromReality since viewers might find it harder to tell individual characters apart if they were all young(ish) bald white men.



** From a practical perspective, Doss’ refusal to carry a weapon does nothing to impede him in carrying out his duty as TheMedic, and several scenes make it abundantly clear that if it weren’t for his armed comrades he would have died on Hacksaw Ridge. His rescue of Sergeant Howell is the clearest example of this: Howell kills a sniper that nearly blew Doss’ head off and kept him from getting to the sergeant, then provides essential covering fire while Doss hauls him to the cliff, killing several Japanese soldiers that would otherwise have shot Doss in the back.

to:

** From a practical perspective, Doss’ Doss' refusal to carry a weapon does nothing to impede him in carrying out his duty as TheMedic, and several scenes make it abundantly clear that if it weren’t weren't for his armed comrades he would have died on Hacksaw Ridge. His rescue of Sergeant Howell is the clearest example of this: Howell kills a sniper that nearly blew Doss’ Doss' head off and kept him from getting to the sergeant, then provides essential covering fire while Doss hauls him to the cliff, killing several Japanese soldiers that would otherwise have shot Doss in the back.



** Also invoked by Thomas Doss when Desmond’s brother, who has just enlisted, wears his uniform to the dinner table. Their father is quite disturbed, then tells his older son that he should hope to be shot in the chest, "A nice, clean entry wound," before telling them of one of the friends he lost in the last war, a handsome fellow who attracted plenty of girls in his Army greens, only to be killed by shrapnel that entered his back and exited the front, “Spilled his insides everywhere, ruined his uniform!” The elder Doss, now sobbing uncontrollably, tells his sons to get out of his sight.

to:

** Also invoked by Thomas Doss when Desmond’s Desmond's brother, who has just enlisted, wears his uniform to the dinner table. Their father is quite disturbed, then tells his older son that he should hope to be shot in the chest, "A nice, clean entry wound," before telling them of one of the friends he lost in the last war, a handsome fellow who attracted plenty of girls in his Army greens, only to be killed by shrapnel that entered his back and exited the front, “Spilled "Spilled his insides everywhere, ruined his uniform!” uniform!" The elder Doss, now sobbing uncontrollably, tells his sons to get out of his sight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Possibly justified as an [[AcceptableBreaksfromReality Acceptable Break from Reality]], since viewers might find it harder to tell individual characters apart if they were all young(ish) bald white men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory:
** In real life, Desmond's wife Dorothy Schutte was not a nurse when they met and in fact did not become one until after the war, mainly to help support the family and take care of her husband due to his disability from war wounds. Also, they married shortly before he joined the army, not in the timeframe depicted in the film.
** Although Desmond was threatened with a court martial by an officer because he refused to touch a weapon, he was never actually court martialed as depicted in the film.
** While Doss' father did make calls on his son's behalf to help him get better treatment from the army, he never personally showed up in his old WWI uniform to plead on his behalf.
** The film depicts Doss' actions in Okinawa as if it was his first time in combat and his first chance to prove himself to his fellow soldiers. In real life, Doss had already earned two bronze stars before then in previous battles on Guam and the Phillippines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film is set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and BasedOnATrueStory, that of private Desmond Thomas Doss (Garfield), a [[UsefulNotes/{{Christianity}} Seventh-day Adventist]] conscientious objector who refused to bear arms and became a combat medic. He ended up awarded the Medal of Honor by President UsefulNotes/HarryTruman for single-handedly saving the lives of over 75 of his comrades while under constant enemy fire during the [[WorldWarII/WarInAsiaAndThePacific Battle of Okinawa]].

to:

The film is set during UsefulNotes/WorldWarII and BasedOnATrueStory, that of private Desmond Thomas Doss (Garfield), a [[UsefulNotes/{{Christianity}} Seventh-day Adventist]] conscientious objector who refused to bear arms and became a combat medic. He ended up awarded the Medal of Honor by President UsefulNotes/HarryTruman UsefulNotes/HarrySTruman for single-handedly saving the lives of over 75 of his comrades while under constant enemy fire during the [[WorldWarII/WarInAsiaAndThePacific Battle of Okinawa]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CasualDangerDialogue: Captain Glover engages in some of this while calling for artillery support while in the middle of a Japanese counter-attack.
-->'''Captain Glover''': ''[on the radio]'' Yes, I know that's where the hell we are, but I don't expect to be here much longer!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbusiveParents: Desmond's father, a veteran of the first World War, is a physically abusive alcoholic, though the movie goes to lengths to humanize him despite his faults ([[RealitySubtext Mel Gibson himself has problems with alcohol]]). It is shown quite plainly that he does love his sons and wife, but his experiences in the horror that was the Great War and his subsequent alcoholism have turned him into the person he is. It also helps that he [[spoiler:saves Desmond from being court-martialed by presenting a letter from the Brigadier General.]]

to:

* AbusiveParents: Desmond's father, a veteran of the first World War, is a physically abusive alcoholic, though the movie goes to lengths to humanize him despite his faults ([[RealitySubtext Mel Gibson himself has problems with alcohol]]).faults. It is shown quite plainly that he does love his sons and wife, but his experiences in the horror that was the Great War and his subsequent alcoholism have turned him into the person he is. It also helps that he [[spoiler:saves Desmond from being court-martialed by presenting a letter from the Brigadier General.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Doss' shower after his long night on Hacksaw Ridge looks like a bucket of water baptizing him, as water and blood flow down, the same as flowed out of UsefulNotes/{{Jesus}} on the cross.

to:

** Doss' shower after his long night on Hacksaw Ridge looks like [[SymbolicBaptism a bucket of water baptizing him, him]], as water and blood flow down, the same as flowed out of UsefulNotes/{{Jesus}} on the cross.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 96

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Adorkable}}: Desmond Doss. Just look at his first interactions with Dorothy in the hospital.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MassOhCrap: The American reaction to the Japanese launching a massive counterattack.


Added DiffLines:

** In flashback, Desmond has a genuine look of horror on his face [[spoiler: when he points a gun at his father and Thomas Doss breaks down in self-loathing tears]]


Added DiffLines:

* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: What snaps Desmond out of his HeroicBSOD after [[spoiler: Smitty's death]] is hearing wounded men left behind calling out for help, at which point Desmond dusts himself off, dons his helmet and charges back into the fire and smoke to save as many as he can.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: After being injured and taken off the battlefield, Doss actually rolled off the stretcher when he noticed a man more injured than him and demanded they take him instead. While they were gone, he was shot by a sniper, shattering his left arm, and he crawled 300 yards by himself in the hellfire of battle to safety.]] This was omitted because Gibson feared that nobody would believe that had happened.

to:

** [[spoiler: After being injured and taken off the battlefield, Doss actually rolled off the stretcher when he noticed a man more injured than him and [[GreaterNeedThanMine demanded they take him instead.instead]]. While they were gone, he was shot by a sniper, shattering his left arm, and he crawled 300 yards by himself in the hellfire of battle to safety.]] This was omitted because Gibson feared that nobody would believe that had happened.

Added: 73

Removed: 69

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed to Head Turning Beauty per TRS; this is misuse


* HelloNurse: Dorthy is a nurse played by the gorgeous Teresa Palmer.


Added DiffLines:

* HospitalHottie: Dorthy is a nurse played by the gorgeous Teresa Palmer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneManArmy: Several of Desmond's fellow soldiers, as the battle rages on, but Sergeant Howell and Smitty stand out.


Added DiffLines:

** Many of the other soldiers on the battlefield are also doing this, although some are caught and killed before Desmond can reach them.


Added DiffLines:

** The soldiers who Desmond's unit is sent to reinforce, who've already spent a while trying to take Hacksaw Ridge, tend to have ThousandYardStare's and display a good deal of cynicism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Determinator}}: Doss was resolved to save as many lives as he could, even if there's just a remote chance of helping them, until he either collapsed or died trying.

to:

* {{Determinator}}: DeterminedDoctor: Doss was resolved to save as many lives as he could, even if there's just a remote chance of helping them, until he either collapsed or died trying.trying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DomesticAbuser: Desmond's father would sometimes be physically abusive to Desmond's mother.

to:

* DomesticAbuser: DomesticAbuse: Desmond's father would sometimes be physically abusive to Desmond's mother.



** Thomas Doss is an alcoholic AbusiveDad and a DomesticAbuser, but sincerely loves his sons and wife and hates himself for his horrible treatment of them.

to:

** Thomas Doss is an alcoholic AbusiveDad and a DomesticAbuser, {{Domestic Abuse}}r, but sincerely loves his sons and wife and hates himself for his horrible treatment of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he's not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought up when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help them and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had no weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.

to:

* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his their men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he's not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought up when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help them and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had no weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he's not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought up when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had not weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.

to:

* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he's not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought up when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help them and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had not no weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he's not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had not weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.

to:

* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he's not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought up when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had not weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had not weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.

to:

* AFatherToHisMen: While they initially had doubts about Desmond joining, DrillSergeantNasty Howell and Glover are both caring towards his men under their command whilst on the battlefield and they were worried that Desmond's refusal to bear arms could mean the deaths of brothers-in-arms around him if he he's not armed to defend himself and others in need, something that both of them brought when Howell orders his platoon not to rely on Desmond to help and Glover also telling him what would happen if Desmond on the battlefield had not weapon to protect himself and a wounded comrade. However, both superiors eventually warmed over and respected Desmond for being a BadassPacifist and how he did managed to save many of his brothers-in-arms despite being unarmed himself.

Top