Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Greyhound

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Eagle is explicitly referred to as a British Destroyer in the film


* MultinationalTeam: As expected from the Western Allies, the escorts consist of an American destroyer (GREYHOUND), a Canadian corvette (DICKIE) a British destroyer (HARRY), and a Polish destroyer (EAGLE). The convoy itself is even more diverse, including one Greek ship.

to:

* MultinationalTeam: As expected from the Western Allies, the escorts consist of an American destroyer (GREYHOUND), a Canadian corvette (DICKIE) a (DICKIE), and two British destroyer (HARRY), destroyers (HARRY) and a Polish destroyer (EAGLE). The convoy itself is even more diverse, including one Greek ship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DamageControl: After a surface engagement with a U-boat, Krause has a quick discussion with DICKY about their damage. DICKY reports three hits above the waterline that they say will be patched up and they'll be back in the hunt shortly. Later HARRY takes some damage that threatens the ship itself. Her CO says they will do their best, but by morning it's clear the ship will not be saved and they request permission to abandon ship.

to:

* DamageControl: After a surface engagement with a U-boat, Krause has a quick discussion with DICKY about their damage. DICKY reports three hits above the waterline that they say will be patched up and they'll be back in the hunt shortly. Later HARRY EAGLE takes some damage that threatens the ship itself. Her CO says they will do their best, but by morning it's clear the ship will not be saved she won't survive and they request permission to abandon ship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Vulnerable Convoy only applies to police transporting prisoners


* VulnerableConvoy: When Convoy HX 25 enters the Black Pit, the U-boats have the advantage with no Allied aircraft looking for them from above.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RookieRedRanger: Despite his age, rank, and position (he's not just GREYHOUND's captain, he's also commander of the escort force), Krause is undertaking his first crossing. Many of his junior sailors have much more experience than him.

to:

* RookieRedRanger: Despite his age, rank, and position (he's not just GREYHOUND's captain, he's also commander of the escort force), Krause is undertaking his first crossing. Many of his junior sailors have much more experience than him.he does.

Added: 899

Changed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MultinationalTeam: As expected from the Western Allies, the escorts consist of one American (GREYHOUND), one Canadian (DICKIE) a British warship (HARRY), and a Polish ship (EAGLE). The convoy itself is even more diverse, including one Greek ship.

to:

* MultinationalTeam: As expected from the Western Allies, the escorts consist of one an American destroyer (GREYHOUND), one a Canadian corvette (DICKIE) a British warship destroyer (HARRY), and a Polish ship destroyer (EAGLE). The convoy itself is even more diverse, including one Greek ship.



** Antisubmarine sensors, weapon systems, and tactics of 1942 are portrayed realistically. notwithstanding a "Hollywood radar" display [[NeverTrustATrailer that only appears in the trailer]].

to:

** Antisubmarine sensors, weapon systems, and tactics of 1942 are portrayed realistically. realistically, notwithstanding a "Hollywood radar" display [[NeverTrustATrailer that only appears in the trailer]].



* TheVoice: The captains of the other escort ships (and the head u-boat captain) are often heard over the radio, and their ships are seen, but they never appear in person.

to:

* TheVoice: The captains of the other escort ships (and the head u-boat U-boat captain) are often heard over the radio, and their ships are seen, but they never appear in person.person.
* TruthInTelevision:
** The U-Boat/destroyer duel. Even though this seems unrealistic due to that a destroyer would outgun a submarine, destroyer-vs-submarine duels actually did occur on one or two real-life occasions. The movie's duel, while based on an event in the book, seems to have been inspired by a real-life clash on November 1st, 1943 between the ''USS Borie'' and ''U-405'', in which the ''Borie'' tried to ram the U-Boat when a wave caused it's bow to come down on top of the U-boat, which trapped both ships. The U-boat was too close for the destroyer's guns, so the crew members had to use rifles, submachine guns, and machine guns to return fire, resulting in the sinking of ''U-405'', while the ''Borie'' was badly damaged and scuttled the following day.
*** And there was also a similar duel between ''HMCS Assiniboine'' (escorting Convoy SC 94) and ''U-210'' on the 6th August, 1942.

Added: 175

Changed: 343

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** While the U-boats did have conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla.[[note]](Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).[[/note]]
* BigBad: U-103 ''Grauerwolf'' (Grey Wolf) is the closest to one in the movie, as the only U-Boat commander to have an identity and interacts with Krause through threats and gloats.

to:

*** While the U-boats did have conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla.[[note]](Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).''Film/DasBoot'').[[/note]]
*** The U-boats seem to be a mix of designs: Their forward deck guns are positioned closer to the bow, reminiscent of the Type IX. However, the conning tower shape/design is that of a Type IA which had it's deck gun mounted closer to the tower.
* BigBad: U-103 ''Grauerwolf'' (Grey Wolf) is the closest to one in the movie, as the only U-Boat commander to have an identity and interacts with Krause through threats and gloats.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla.[[note]](Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).[[/note]]

to:

*** While the U-boats had did have conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla.[[note]](Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** NO Kriegsmariner would have been caught dead taunting an enemy destroyer even if they HAD such radios. That was TemptingFate in a massive way even in the framework of the movie, and any ''Alte'' that was stupid enough to do it probably would have been launched out of one of his own torpedo tubes.

to:

*** NO Kriegsmariner U-Boat in the Kriegsmarine would have been caught dead taunting an enemy destroyer even if they HAD such radios. That was TemptingFate in a massive way even in the framework of the movie, and any ''Alte'' that was stupid enough to do it probably would have been launched out of one of his own torpedo tubes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla.[note](Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).[/note]

to:

*** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla.[note](Actually [[note]](Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).[/note][[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla. (Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).

to:

*** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th U-Boot Flotilla. (Actually [note](Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).[/note]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th Kriegsmarine Flotilla.

to:

*** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th Kriegsmarine Flotilla.U-Boot Flotilla. (Actually seen in Film/DasBoot).

Changed: 180

Removed: 158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**
* BigBad: Grey Wolf is the closest to one in the movie, as the only U-Boat commander to have an identity and interacts with Krause through threats and gloats.

to:

**
* BigBad: Grey Wolf U-103 ''Grauerwolf'' (Grey Wolf) is the closest to one in the movie, as the only U-Boat commander to have an identity and interacts with Krause through threats and gloats.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** NO Kriegsmariner would have been caught dead taunting an enemy destroyer even if they HAD such radios. That was TemptingFate in a massive way even in the framework of the movie.

to:

*** NO Kriegsmariner would have been caught dead taunting an enemy destroyer even if they HAD such radios. That was TemptingFate in a massive way even in the framework of the movie.movie, and any ''Alte'' that was stupid enough to do it probably would have been launched out of one of his own torpedo tubes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** NO Kriegsmariner would have been caught dead taunting an enemy destroyer even if they HAD such radios. That was TemptingFate in a massive way even in the framework of the movie.
** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th Kriegsmarine Flotilla.

to:

** *** NO Kriegsmariner would have been caught dead taunting an enemy destroyer even if they HAD such radios. That was TemptingFate in a massive way even in the framework of the movie.
** *** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th Kriegsmarine Flotilla.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The most blatant concerns the U-boats:
*** There was no radio that allowed ship to ship communication in them, period. Wolfpack attacks were coordinated from shore, then once they were out of range they attacked convoys individually from every compass point at once.
** NO Kriegsmariner would have been caught dead taunting an enemy destroyer even if they HAD such radios. That was TemptingFate in a massive way even in the framework of the movie.
** While the U-boats had conning tower art, it would never have been so blatant as Grauerwolf's, which would have stuck out like a sore thumb against the sea and added ''another'' layer of TemptingFate. They tended toward irreverent or humorous little icons instead, such as the famous [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_U-boat_Flotilla#/media/File:Uboat_Flo09_logo.svg Der lachende Schwertfisch]], "The Laughing Sawfish" of the 9th Kriegsmarine Flotilla.
**
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IntercomVillainy: The movie never cuts to the Germans on their U-boats; instead, they're characterized only by the taunts and threats they send over the radio. The audio is distorted, only making them seem more monstrous as they mock the soldier's fallen comrades and go into detail about how their wives will move onto new lovers after the Germans kill them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DroppedInSpeechClip: The movie begins with clips of speeches from President Roosevelt and Prime Minister Churchill of the need, and their determination, to send supplies over the Atlantic to the front lines in Europe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DamageControl: After a surface engagement with a U-boat, Krause has a quick discussion with DICKY about their damage. DICKY reports three hits above the waterline that they say will be patched up and they'll be back in the hunt shortly. Later HARRY takes some damage that threatens the ship itself. Her CO says they will do their best, but by morning it's clear the ship will not be saved and they request permission to abandon ship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DueToTheDead: During an engagement with a U-boat, GREYHOUND takes a hit from the sub's deck gun. Later, Commander Krause is informed three of his crew were killed. Since they don't have room to carry bodies for any length of time, he orders an immediate burial at sea. The three bodies are draped in American flags as the crew gathers on deck, the ship slows to a stop, the bell is rung and one by one the names are read and the bodies are dropped overboard accompanied by a TwentyOneGunSalute. The event is marred slightly when the body of Mess Mate George Cleveland, Krause's personal steward, gets caught on the flag, and has to be shaken loose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnOfficerAndAGentleman: Krause is a ReasonableAuthorityFigure who is fair to his crew, only demanding that two that got into a fight explain their actions, but is called to the bridge before he can mete out discipline so lets the matter drop, does not swear and doesn't allow it in his presence, is quick to give credit where it is due and perhaps more importantly does not blame his men for things that go wrong if it's out of their control, and is a devout Christian.

to:

* AnOfficerAndAGentleman: OfficerAndAGentleman: Krause is a ReasonableAuthorityFigure who is fair to his crew, only demanding that two that got into a fight explain their actions, but is called to the bridge before he can mete out discipline so lets the matter drop, does not swear and doesn't allow it in his presence, is quick to give credit where it is due and perhaps more importantly does not blame his men for things that go wrong if it's out of their control, and is a devout Christian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnOfficerAndAGentleman: Krause is a ReasonableAuthorityFigure who is fair to his crew, only demanding that two that got into a fight explain their actions, but is called to the bridge before he can mete out discipline so lets the matter drop, does not swear and doesn't allow it in his presence, is quick to give credit where it is due, and is a devout Christian.

to:

* AnOfficerAndAGentleman: Krause is a ReasonableAuthorityFigure who is fair to his crew, only demanding that two that got into a fight explain their actions, but is called to the bridge before he can mete out discipline so lets the matter drop, does not swear and doesn't allow it in his presence, is quick to give credit where it is due, due and perhaps more importantly does not blame his men for things that go wrong if it's out of their control, and is a devout Christian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnOfficerAndAGentleman: Krause is a ReasonableAuthorityFigure who is fair to his crew, only demanding that two that got into a fight explain their actions, but is called to the bridge before he can mete out discipline so lets the matter drop, does not swear and doesn't allow it in his presence, is quick to give credit where it is due, and is a devout Christian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SneezeOfDoom: The Talker (the sailor who relays messages sent via the sound-powered telephone) pauses to sneeze as they're closing in on a U-boat, and so has to ask for a message from the sonar operator to be repeated. His superior is ''not'' amused and he's warned he'll be relieved of duty if he does that again.

to:

* SneezeOfDoom: SneezeInterruption: The Talker (the sailor who relays messages sent via the sound-powered telephone) pauses to sneeze as they're closing in on a U-boat, and so has to ask for a message from the sonar operator to be repeated. His superior is ''not'' amused and he's warned he'll be relieved of duty if he does that again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BookEnds: We meet Krause kneeling at his bed in prayer which he does again at the end, right before lying down for some much-needed sleep.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SceneryDissonance: As the wolfpack attacks the convoy in force on the first night, the camera pans out and up over the entire battle until it's over the cloud layer and we see the aurora borealis hanging quietly over the carnage below. It's one of the more haunting scenes in the movie.

to:

* SceneryDissonance: As the wolfpack attacks the convoy in force on the first night, the camera pans zooms out and up over the entire battle until it's over the cloud layer and we see the aurora borealis hanging quietly over the carnage below. It's one of the more haunting scenes in the movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SceneryDissonance: As the wolfpack attacks the convoy in force on the first night, the camera pans out and up over the entire battle until it's over the cloud layer and we see the aurora borealis hanging quietly over the carnage below. It's one of the more haunting scenes in the movie.

Changed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForgetsToEat: Cleveland keeps making Krause meals and bringing them up specially, and then they'll hit another crisis and Krause won't eat a bite.

to:

* ForgetsToEat: Mess Steward Cleveland keeps making Krause meals and bringing them up specially, and then they'll hit another crisis and Krause won't eat a bite.bite. Cleveland worries about Krause's well-being as a result, reminding that he won't be able to do his job at all if he collapses from exhaustion.

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film recounts the story of Commander Ernest Krause (Hanks), commanding officer of the destroyer USS ''Keeling'' (radio callsign GREYHOUND) on the first escort mission of his career, in charge of convoy HX 25. As the ships enter the dread Mid-Atlantic gap (aka "The Black Pit") that Allied air forces don't have the range to cover, a U-boat wolfpack finds them. Krause's destroyers are now the only protection available until the convoy can reach safety within Britain's air range, an arduous three days sailing while under constant attack...

to:

The film recounts the story of Commander Ernest Krause (Hanks), commanding officer of the destroyer USS ''Keeling'' (radio callsign GREYHOUND) on the first escort mission of his career, in charge of convoy HX 25. As the ships enter the dread Mid-Atlantic gap (aka "The Black Pit") that Allied air forces don't have the range to cover, a U-boat wolfpack finds them. Krause's destroyers are now the only protection available until the convoy can reach safety within Britain's air range, an range. An arduous three days sailing while under constant attack...attack lies ahead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film recounts the story of Commander Ernest Krause (Hanks), commanding officer of the destroyer USS ''Keeling'' (radio callsign GREYHOUND) on his first escort mission of his career, in charge of convoy HX 25. As the ships enter the dread Mid-Atlantic gap (aka "The Black Pit") that Allied air forces don't have the range to cover, a U-boat wolfpack finds them. Krause's destroyers are now the only protection available until the convoy can reach safety within Britain's air range, an arduous three days sailing while under constant attack...

to:

The film recounts the story of Commander Ernest Krause (Hanks), commanding officer of the destroyer USS ''Keeling'' (radio callsign GREYHOUND) on his the first escort mission of his career, in charge of convoy HX 25. As the ships enter the dread Mid-Atlantic gap (aka "The Black Pit") that Allied air forces don't have the range to cover, a U-boat wolfpack finds them. Krause's destroyers are now the only protection available until the convoy can reach safety within Britain's air range, an arduous three days sailing while under constant attack...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film recounts the story of Commander Ernest Krause (Hanks), commanding officer of the destroyer USS ''Keeling'' (radio callsign GREYHOUND on his first escort mission of his career, in charge of convoy HX 25. As the ships enter the dread Mid-Atlantic gap (aka "The Black Pit") that Allied air forces don't have the range to cover, a U-boat wolfpack finds them. Krause's destroyers are now the only protection available until the convoy can reach safety within Britain's air range, an arduous three days sailing while under constant attack...

to:

The film recounts the story of Commander Ernest Krause (Hanks), commanding officer of the destroyer USS ''Keeling'' (radio callsign GREYHOUND GREYHOUND) on his first escort mission of his career, in charge of convoy HX 25. As the ships enter the dread Mid-Atlantic gap (aka "The Black Pit") that Allied air forces don't have the range to cover, a U-boat wolfpack finds them. Krause's destroyers are now the only protection available until the convoy can reach safety within Britain's air range, an arduous three days sailing while under constant attack...

Top