Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / DonnieBrasco

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Much of Lefty's (good) personality traits in the film actually belonged to Sonny Black in real life, while Sonny Black's worse traits are actually from Tony Mirra, a gangster so brutal he was loathed by other gangsters and who is AdaptedOut of the film.

to:

** Much of Lefty's (good) personality traits in the film actually belonged to Sonny Black in real life, while Sonny Black's worse worst traits are actually from Tony Mirra, a gangster so brutal he was loathed by other gangsters and who is AdaptedOut of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: Lefty is pissed that a man who owed him money tried to pass off a fake diamond ring as the real thing in order to settle the debt. However, he's ''disgusted'' when he finds out the ring belonged to the man's wife (likely her wedding ring). The implication being that not only did the man take the ring from his wife to settle the debt, but also that something the wife thought was special and valuable was actually a piece of worthless junk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* UnusualHiringPractices: PlayedWith. [[CharacterTitle Donnie]] exploits this to pose as a jewel expert/thief in order to infiltrate the Mob through Lefty by claiming the diamond that the latter got as collateral is a "''fugazy''", a fake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadGuysPlayPool: Lefty and Sonny Black play pool together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DecompositeCharacter: Sonny Black's more positive character traits were given to Lefty, while his worse traits are taken from Tony Mirra, a deeply unpleasant gangster who is AdaptedOut.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Much of Lefty's (good) personality traits in the film actually belonged to Sonny Black in real life.

to:

** Much of Lefty's (good) personality traits in the film actually belonged to Sonny Black in real life.life, while Sonny Black's worse traits are actually from Tony Mirra, a gangster so brutal he was loathed by other gangsters and who is AdaptedOut of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SmallNameBigEgo: Lefty brags about being known in every borough of New York and all over the world, but in reality he's just a low-level soldier and hitman in the Bonanno family. He barely gets any respect from the other members of his own crew.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Donnie brings in enough intel to convict dozens of Mafia figures and is able to reunite with his family. But on the other hand, while Donnie is alive and with his family, it's clear he has regret over having to do what he had to since he got so close to Lefty and the end credits reveal there's a hit on him. Plus, Lefty is killed because he vouched for Donnie.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Donnie brings in enough intel to convict dozens of Mafia figures and is able to reunite with his family. But on On the other hand, while Donnie is alive and with his family, it's clear he has clearly feels regret over having to do what he had to since he got he's done in getting so close to Lefty and the end credits reveal there's a hit on him. Plus, Lefty Lefty, who is killed because he vouched for Donnie.Donnie. The end credits reveal that Donnie/Pistone and his family have had to move to an undisclosed location due to the mob putting out a hit on him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ManlyFacialHair: Donnie starts off with a healthy mustache, but Lefty makes him shave it off as part of the Mafia code of conduct.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** {{Inverted|Trope}} for Lefty: he did many horrible things for the mafia, but he does not get any respect or promotion.

to:

** {{Inverted|Trope}} for Lefty: he did many horrible things Lefty. He's been in the Mafia for 30 years and killed 26 people, but the mafia, but rest of the crew practically ignores him and he does not get any respect or promotion.gets passed over for promotion in favor of the younger Sonny Black.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of the last scenes, where Lefty goes to meet his end. He takes off his valuables and leaves them behind for his wife. These actions were, in real life, Sonny Black's. Black gave his belongings to a bartender before going away and being whacked.
** Lefty was not the first mobster that Pistone met during the latter's time undercover. Mirra (and several others) came to Pistone before Lefty. It was also Mirra, not Lefty, who tore apart the dashboard in Joe's car looking for "a noise"- in actuality, checking for recording devices.

to:

** One of Near the last scenes, where end, Lefty goes to meet his end. He takes off gets "sent for" and leaves his valuables and leaves them behind for his wife. These actions were, in wife, expecting to be killed. In real life, these actions were performed by Sonny Black's. Black Black, who gave his belongings things to a his bartender before going away reporting in and being whacked.
shot to death. Lefty was sent for, but Pistone arranged for him to be arrested before the Bonannos could kill him.
** Lefty was not the first mobster that Pistone met during the latter's time undercover. Tony Mirra (and several others) came to Pistone before Lefty. It was also Mirra, not Lefty, who tore apart the dashboard in Joe's car looking for "a noise"- in actuality, checking for recording devices.

Added: 172

Changed: 45

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Donnie''': Twice a week, at least. Why?\\
'''Lefty''': There it is, “At least.” I cook for you.\\

to:

'''Donnie''': Twice a week. Twice a week, at least. Why?\\
least.\\
'''Lefty''': There it is, is. “At least.” I cook for you.\\



'''Lefty''': If ever I had any money, I’d give you. I never had any money. But if ever I had... $100 in my pocket, I gave you $50, right?\\

to:

'''Lefty''': If ever I had any money, I’d give you.you... I never had any money. But if ever I had... $100 had a hundred bucks in my pocket, I gave I'd give you $50, fifty, right?\\


Added DiffLines:

* ReliablyUnreliableGuns: During the murder of Sonny Red and his guys, Lefty's shotgun jams and he has to bang it against a counter in order to break it open for reloading.

Added: 149

Changed: 109

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Donnie helps arrest a large amount of members in the Mafia and is able to reunite with his family. But on the other hand, while Donnie is alive and with his family, it's clear he has regret over having to do what he had to since he got so close to Lefty and the end credits reveal there's a hit on him. Plus, Lefty is killed for bringing Donnie in.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Donnie helps arrest a large amount brings in enough intel to convict dozens of members in the Mafia figures and is able to reunite with his family. But on the other hand, while Donnie is alive and with his family, it's clear he has regret over having to do what he had to since he got so close to Lefty and the end credits reveal there's a hit on him. Plus, Lefty is killed because he vouched for bringing Donnie in.]]Donnie.]]
* BoomHeadshot: How Nicky finishes off Sonny Red during the ambush once the crew returns from Miami, and how Lefty kills Nicky immediately afterward.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShotgunsAreJustBetter: Sonny Black's crew uses these to kill Sonny Red and his associates (a pump model for Nicky, [[SawedOffShotgun sawed-off]] double-barreled guns for the others).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
corrected misspellings


* LastSecondChance: [[spoiler:Just before the FBI swoop in to make the climatic busts, Donnie essentially gives Lefty a chance to walk away and escape the deadly mob consequences of letting in an police undercover agent into their world. Lefty indignantly turns it down and chooses to face the expected consequences.]]

to:

* LastSecondChance: [[spoiler:Just before the FBI swoop in to make the climatic busts, Donnie essentially gives Lefty a chance to walk away and escape the deadly mob consequences of letting in an a police undercover agent into their world. Lefty indignantly turns it down and chooses to face the expected consequences.]]



* TheMafia: With the real life Donnie Brasco, Joseph Pistone, providing the source book and on-set assistance the movie is packed with detail. The paradoxical world of the Mafia is explored: hierarchy, loyalty, codes of honor. But also harsh penalties for failure or transgression, betrayal, and promotion via dead men's shoes. In fact, the movie deconstructs the glamour surrounding the mob.

to:

* TheMafia: With the real life real-life Donnie Brasco, Joseph Pistone, providing the source book and on-set assistance assistance, the movie is packed with detail. The paradoxical world of the Mafia is explored: hierarchy, loyalty, codes of honor. But also harsh penalties for failure or transgression, betrayal, and promotion via dead men's shoes. In fact, the movie deconstructs the glamour surrounding the mob.



* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: The movie purports to be "a true story", and while Joseph Pistone's book memoir was mostly faithful to real events in which he participated, the screenwriters and the director preferred a very wide ArtisticLicense. The movie invents events and characters, removes real ones, turns other FBI personnel into useless fools (one of the clownish characters in the movie was actually an FBI agent ''posing as a dangerous mob turf boss'' during the operation), and has Pistone [[HollywoodLaw engage in activities that would have thrown him to prison in reality]] (being that he was of Sicilian and Calabrian heritage, Pistone was offered the chance to be made by killing off the son of a deceased capo but the FBI pulled the plug before this could happen). Lefty, the movie's faithful friend, [[AdaptationalHeroism was in fact a genuine thug]] often despised by Pistone, and many of the positive traits of his movie character were taken from the real-life Dominick "Sonny Black" Napolitano - the only gangster whom the real Pistone actually felt some kinship and considered to have a genuinely good side. He, in turn, [[AdaptationalVillainy was of course turned]] into a BigBad in the film... with his worst traits actually taken from Pistone's earliest mob mentor Anthony Mirra, a gangster [[AxCrazy whose personality was such]] that he was widely ''[[TheDreaded loathed by other gangsters]]'', but eventually went into hiding, knowing that he was a marked man. Unsurprisingly, his character is ''completely absent'' from the film.

to:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: The movie purports to be "a true story", story," and while Joseph Pistone's book memoir was mostly faithful to real events in which he participated, the screenwriters and the director preferred a very wide ArtisticLicense. The movie invents events and characters, removes real ones, turns other FBI personnel into useless fools (one of the clownish characters in the movie was actually an FBI agent ''posing as a dangerous mob turf boss'' during the operation), and has Pistone [[HollywoodLaw engage in activities that would have thrown him to prison in reality]] (being that he was of Sicilian and Calabrian heritage, Pistone was offered the chance to be made by killing off the son of a deceased capo but the FBI pulled the plug before this could happen). Lefty, the movie's faithful friend, [[AdaptationalHeroism was in fact a genuine thug]] often despised by Pistone, and many of the positive traits of his movie character were taken from the real-life Dominick "Sonny Black" Napolitano - the only gangster with whom the real Pistone actually felt some kinship and considered to have a genuinely good side. He, in turn, [[AdaptationalVillainy was of course turned]] into a BigBad in the film... with his worst traits actually taken from Pistone's earliest mob mentor Anthony Mirra, a gangster [[AxCrazy whose personality was such]] that he was widely ''[[TheDreaded loathed by other gangsters]]'', but eventually went into hiding, knowing that he was a marked man. Unsurprisingly, his character is ''completely absent'' from the film.

Added: 318

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/MichaelMadsen plays Sonny, the boss of Lefty's crew. Creator/BrunoKirby plays Nicky, another member of the crew. Creator/PaulGiamatti shows up briefly as an FBI tech. A young Creator/GretchenMol has a bit part as Sonny's girlfriend.

to:

Creator/MichaelMadsen plays Sonny, Sonny Black, the boss of Lefty's crew. Creator/BrunoKirby plays Nicky, Nicky Santora, another member of the crew. Creator/PaulGiamatti shows up briefly as an FBI tech. A young Creator/GretchenMol has a bit part as Sonny's girlfriend.


Added DiffLines:

** In the film, Nicky is shot and killed by Lefty for doing an unauthorized drug deal, and also on suspicion that he told the Miami cops about Sonny Black's club to get it raided. The real-life Nicky Santora rose to serve as the underboss of the Bonanno crime family for three years, and died in 2018 at the age of 76.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Donnie Brasco'' is a 1997 crime drama staring Creator/AlPacino (Lefty), and Creator/JohnnyDepp (Donnie) set in the [[UsefulNotes/TheMafia Mafia]] [[{{Gangsterland}} gangland]] of 1970s-80s New York. An imposing mafia hitman, one Benjamin "Lefty" Ruggiero needs some advice on a jewel he has been given as collateral. Nothing here is as it seems: the jewel is a fake and the guy giving him advice, expert jewel thief Donnie Brasco, is in truth working deep cover for the FBI.

to:

''Donnie Brasco'' is a 1997 crime drama staring Creator/AlPacino (Lefty), and Creator/JohnnyDepp (Donnie) Creator/JohnnyDepp, set in the [[UsefulNotes/TheMafia Mafia]] [[{{Gangsterland}} gangland]] of 1970s-80s New York. An imposing mafia hitman, one Mafia hitman Benjamin "Lefty" Ruggiero (Pacino) needs some advice on a jewel he has been given as collateral. Nothing here is as it seems: the jewel is a fake and the guy giving him advice, expert jewel thief Donnie Brasco, Brasco (Depp), is in truth working deep cover for the FBI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Joe Pistone risks his life in the infiltration mission, but he does not get much consideration from his wife, and even the FBI, for that.

to:

** Joe Pistone risks his life in the infiltration mission, but he does not get much consideration from his wife, and even the FBI, for that. Somewhat understandable since his family doesn't actually know what he's doing, apart from being on assignment for the FBI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CastingGag: In ''Film/TheGodfather'', Al Pacino played the son of a Mafia kingpin who eventually becomes The Don himself. Here, Pacino's character is about as low down the hierarchy as can be, and struggling just to maintain that place.

Top