Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / DeathBecomesHer

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A [[https://deathbecomesherbroadway.com musical adaptation]] is scheduled to premiere in Chicago on April 30th, 2024, starring Creator/MeganHilty as Madeline Ashton, Creator/JenniferSimard as Helen Sharp, Creator/ChristopherSieber as Ernest Menville, and Music/MichelleWilliams as [[AdaptationNameChange Viola Van Horn]].

to:

A [[https://deathbecomesherbroadway.com musical adaptation]] is scheduled to premiere premiered in Chicago on April 30th, 2024, starring Creator/MeganHilty as Madeline Ashton, Creator/JenniferSimard as Helen Sharp, Creator/ChristopherSieber as Ernest Menville, and Music/MichelleWilliams as [[AdaptationNameChange Viola Van Horn]].

Added: 1466

Changed: 981

Removed: 1149

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlphaBitch: Implied with Madeline, not so much when she's a WhiteDwarfStarlet. Not so much Alpha, that is, - she's still a Bitch alright.
* AmusingInjuries: This film has the most disturbing catalogue of such injuries this side of a Creator/TexAvery cartoon.
* AnAesop:

to:

* AlphaBitch: Implied with Madeline, not so much when she's a WhiteDwarfStarlet. Not so much Alpha, that is, is - she's still a Bitch alright.
* AmusingInjuries: This film has the most disturbing catalogue of such injuries this side of a Creator/TexAvery cartoon.
cartoon. Madeline's (first) fall down the stairs leaves her head twisted around 180 degrees, Helen gets hit by a shotgun blast that leaves a hole in her abdomen nearly a foot in diameter, and at the end of the film, [[spoiler:''both'' ladies fall down a flight of stairs, causing their bodies to shatter into fragments at the bottom]].
* AnAesop: AnAesop:



* AndIMustScream: When all is said and done, this is what comes of immortality in this movie, as Lisle stresses than a person who takes the potion can only stay in the public eye for 10 years before going underground '''literally forever'''. That means no outside contact with other people save other immortals, with whom companionship is not guaranteed, basically forcing an exile less the secret of eternal life is revealed to the wider world, and everyone knows isolation can result in maddening boredom. And the thing about eternal life is that you cannot escape it, ever. It gets worse if you die immortal, since you will gradually rot away, and if completely dismemberment isn't enough to cease one's function, then what is?

to:

* AndIMustScream: When all is said and done, this is what comes of immortality in this movie, as Lisle stresses than a person who takes the potion can only stay in the public eye for 10 years before going underground '''literally forever'''. That means no outside contact with other people save other immortals, with whom companionship is not guaranteed, basically forcing an exile less lest the secret of eternal life is revealed to the wider world, and everyone knows isolation can result in maddening boredom. And the thing about eternal life is that you cannot escape it, ever. It gets worse if you die immortal, since you will gradually rot away, and if completely complete dismemberment isn't enough to cease one's function, then what is?



* ArtisticLicensePhysics: The BrickJoke regarding stairs. When Madeline (and then later, Helen) is about to tumble down the steps, she seems to barely keep balance using the bottom of her heels even though the majority of her weight was leaning toward the stairwell. In reality, it wouldn't necessarily take a ''Series/{{Mythbusters}}'' episode to conclude that someone would automatically fall in that situation. This possibly was just a minor {{Slapstick}} gag PlayedForLaughs given the tone of the story.

to:

* ArtisticLicensePhysics: ArtisticLicensePhysics:
**
The BrickJoke regarding stairs. When Madeline (and then later, Helen) is about to tumble down the steps, she seems to barely keep balance using the bottom of her heels even though the majority of her weight was leaning toward the stairwell. In reality, it wouldn't necessarily take a ''Series/{{Mythbusters}}'' episode to conclude that someone would automatically fall in that situation. This possibly was just a minor {{Slapstick}} gag PlayedForLaughs given the tone of the story.



* BatmanGambit: Helen's complex plan to murder Madeline also relies on the unlikely event of Madeline inviting her over for dinner. This becomes a moot point thanks to Ernest.
** On the other hand, the plan would still have probably worked just the same if Ernest had managed to make Madeline drink from one of those glasses under any pretext.

to:

* BatmanGambit: Helen's complex plan to murder Madeline also relies on the unlikely event of Madeline inviting her over for dinner. This becomes a moot point thanks to Ernest.
**
Ernest. On the other hand, the plan would still have probably worked just the same if Ernest had managed to make Madeline drink from one of those glasses under any pretext.



* TheUnfairSex: Very, very much averted. Ernest is depicted as a NiceGuy and TheWoobie[[invoked]] no matter what he does -- including dumping his fiancé for her friend and trying to murder his nasty wife -- while the main women in the film are thoroughly irredeemable. Some of it gets subverted on the grounds that Ernest dumping Helen for Madeline bit him hard when his life turned into a joke, going from a respected plastic surgeon to a funeral cosmetologist, becoming an alcoholic, and getting stuck in a loveless relationship. It's not so much that Ernest is a NiceGuy, as the shit he pulls isn't as bad as the vindictive hatred Helen and Madeline have for each other.



* UnsympatheticComedyProtagonist: Madeline and Helen, who are both vain and selfish female leads with the former concerned with obtaining her youth and the latter wanting to steal back Ernest and get her revenge on Madeline. Their manipulative and murderous ways make them lean more toward VillainProtagonist.



* TheUnfairSex: Very, very much averted. Ernest is depicted as a NiceGuy and TheWoobie[[invoked]] no matter what he does -- including dumping his fiancé for her friend and trying to murder his nasty wife -- while the main women in the film are thoroughly irredeemable. Some of it gets subverted on the grounds that Ernest dumping Helen for Madeline bit him hard when his life turned into a joke, going from a respected plastic surgeon to a funeral cosmetologist, becoming an alcoholic, and getting stuck in a loveless relationship. It's not so much that Ernest is a NiceGuy, as the shit he pulls isn't as bad as the vindictive hatred Helen and Madeline have for each other.
* UnsympatheticComedyProtagonist: Madeline and Helen, who are both vain and selfish female leads with the former concerned with obtaining her youth and the latter wanting to steal back Ernest and get her revenge on Madeline. Their manipulative and murderous ways make them lean more toward VillainProtagonist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)(Black Comedy)


** The doctor who takes Madeline's vital signs after her tumble down the stairs, who's initially sceptical about her "revival", [[{{Irony}} ends up needing to be revived himself and dies shortly after]].

to:

** The doctor who takes Madeline's vital signs after her tumble down the stairs, who's initially sceptical skeptical about her "revival", [[{{Irony}} ends up needing to be revived himself and dies shortly after]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EstablishingCharacterMoment: A variation, where the character has already been introduced, but is only truly established later on. Fourteen years after stealing away Ernest from Helen and marrying him, Madeline is reintroduced into the story on a typical morning. She's wearing a beauty product meant to make her face less wrinkly, and her maid is waking her up with a compliment. Madeline then pointedly reminds her maid she nearly forgot to say the phrase she says every morning: "Oh Madame, [[BlatantLies you look younger every day]]." This displays that not only is she rather unfriendly, but still as vain and self-centered as ever, on top of trying to pretend her age isn't showing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A key example for Helen is her telling Ernest she still brought him to Madeline's play despite fear he'd fall out of love, because she wanted to apply the "Madeline Ashton" test to see if he was true to her. On two levels does Helen tragically neglect to realize this is on her. First, if her past experience taught her that Madeline steals her lovers without fail, then perhaps common sense would dictate she shouldn't have introduced her fiancé to her hated rival to begin with. She had a choice to not go through with it at all. Second, when Ernest ''does'' fail the "test", she sees it more as an excuse to obsess over her hatred towards Madeline for the next 7 years, instead of realizing that perhaps Ernest (and all her past boyfriends) weren't worth it if they could be swayed so easily.

to:

** A key example for Helen is her telling Ernest she still brought him to Madeline's play despite fear he'd fall out of love, because she wanted to apply the "Madeline Ashton" test to see if he was true to her. On two levels does Helen tragically neglect to realize this is on her. First, if her past experience taught her that Madeline steals her lovers without fail, then perhaps common sense would dictate she shouldn't have introduced her fiancé to her hated rival to begin with. She had a choice to not go through with it at all. Second, when Ernest ''does'' fail the "test", she sees it more as an excuse to obsess over her hatred towards Madeline for the next 7 years, years (and then some), instead of realizing that perhaps Ernest (and all her past boyfriends) lovers weren't worth it if they Madeline could be swayed sway them so easily.

Added: 988

Changed: 188

Removed: 870

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Apparently, the example suits "Never my Fault" more than "Dramatically Missing the Point".


* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: The movie begins with Helen explaining to Ernest that though she worries he'll fall out of love with her to pursue Madeline, she still brought him to her play because she wanted to apply the "Madeline Ashton" test to see if he was true to her. On two levels does Helen tragically misunderstand the purpose of her own test. First, if her past experience taught her that Madeline steals her lovers without fail, then perhaps common sense would dictate she shouldn't have introduced her fiancé to her hated rival to begin with. She had a choice to not go through with it at all. Second, when Ernest ''does'' fail the "test", she sees it more as an excuse to obsess over her hatred towards Madeline for the next 7 years, instead of realizing that perhaps Ernest (and all her past boyfriends) weren't worth it if they could be swayed so easily.



* NeverMyFault: Neither Madeline nor Helen are willing to accept any responsibility for the bad things that happen in their lives, endlessly blaming each other and any other excuse they can come up with.

to:

* NeverMyFault: NeverMyFault:
**
Neither Madeline nor Helen are willing to accept any responsibility for the bad things that happen in their lives, endlessly blaming each other and any other excuse they can come up with.
** A key example for Helen is her telling Ernest she still brought him to Madeline's play despite fear he'd fall out of love, because she wanted to apply the "Madeline Ashton" test to see if he was true to her. On two levels does Helen tragically neglect to realize this is on her. First, if her past experience taught her that Madeline steals her lovers without fail, then perhaps common sense would dictate she shouldn't have introduced her fiancé to her hated rival to begin
with. She had a choice to not go through with it at all. Second, when Ernest ''does'' fail the "test", she sees it more as an excuse to obsess over her hatred towards Madeline for the next 7 years, instead of realizing that perhaps Ernest (and all her past boyfriends) weren't worth it if they could be swayed so easily.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: The movie begins with Helen explaining to Ernest that though she worries he'll fall out of love with her to pursue Madeline, she still brought him to her play because she wanted to apply the "Madeline Ashton" test to see if he was true to her. On two levels does Helen tragically misunderstand the purpose of her own test. First, if her past experience taught her that Madeline steals her lovers without fail, then perhaps common sense would dictate she shouldn't have introduced her fiancé to her hated rival to begin with. She had a choice to leave well enough alone. Second, when Ernest ''does'' fail the "test", she sees it more as an excuse to obsess over Madeline and her hatred of her, instead of realizing that perhaps Ernest (and all her past boyfriends) weren't worth it if they could be swayed so easily.

to:

* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: The movie begins with Helen explaining to Ernest that though she worries he'll fall out of love with her to pursue Madeline, she still brought him to her play because she wanted to apply the "Madeline Ashton" test to see if he was true to her. On two levels does Helen tragically misunderstand the purpose of her own test. First, if her past experience taught her that Madeline steals her lovers without fail, then perhaps common sense would dictate she shouldn't have introduced her fiancé to her hated rival to begin with. She had a choice to leave well enough alone. not go through with it at all. Second, when Ernest ''does'' fail the "test", she sees it more as an excuse to obsess over Madeline and her hatred of her, towards Madeline for the next 7 years, instead of realizing that perhaps Ernest (and all her past boyfriends) weren't worth it if they could be swayed so easily.

Added: 609

Changed: 1114

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarnYourHappyEnding: [[spoiler:After Ernest escaped, he managed to find happiness in the following 37 years and truly atoned for his misdeeds. He found love, had children, had a thriving career and newfound fame, developed fulfilling hobbies and devoted his time to helping people realize that getting older was not the end of the world -- ''and'' he opened an AA chapter and two clinics, to boot. When he does die, Madeline and Helen arrive at his funeral dressed all in black and mock most of the eulogy, even though they're pretty much badly-painted, barely-holding-together corpses.]]

to:

* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: The movie begins with Helen explaining to Ernest that though she worries he'll fall out of love with her to pursue Madeline, she still brought him to her play because she wanted to apply the "Madeline Ashton" test to see if he was true to her. On two levels does Helen tragically misunderstand the purpose of her own test. First, if her past experience taught her that Madeline steals her lovers without fail, then perhaps common sense would dictate she shouldn't have introduced her fiancé to her hated rival to begin with. She had a choice to leave well enough alone. Second, when Ernest ''does'' fail the "test", she sees it more as an excuse to obsess over Madeline and her hatred of her, instead of realizing that perhaps Ernest (and all her past boyfriends) weren't worth it if they could be swayed so easily.
* EarnYourHappyEnding: [[spoiler:After Ernest escaped, he managed to find happiness in the following 37 years and truly atoned for his misdeeds. He found love, had children, had a thriving career and newfound fame, developed fulfilling hobbies and devoted his time to helping people realize that getting older was not the end of the world -- ''and'' he opened an AA chapter and two clinics, to boot. When he does die, Madeline and Helen arrive at his funeral dressed all in black and mock most of the eulogy, even though [[PyrrhicVictory they're pretty much badly-painted, barely-holding-together corpses.corpses]].]]



* EvilCannotComprehendGood: Lisle and company are genuinely puzzled when Ernest refuses the potion. They are too self-centred and shallow to care about the reasons he has for not wanting to be immortal. They similarly mock the eulogy at his funeral which says that while Ernest has died, his legacy would live on and it was through his family, friends and good deeds that he had achieved immortality.

to:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: Lisle and company are genuinely puzzled when Ernest refuses the potion. They are too self-centred self-centered and shallow to care about the reasons he has for not wanting to be immortal. They similarly Similarly, Helen and Madeline later mock the eulogy at his funeral which says that while Ernest has died, his legacy would live on and it was through his family, friends and good deeds that he had achieved immortality.



* TrueBeautyIsOnTheInside: Ernest's relationship with both Madeline and Helen is a study in the consequences of only liking somebody for their looks. He broke up with one woman to marry the other because she was prettier. But many years later, Madeline's looks have faded, and he's left with nothing but a shrew who has [[AwfulWeddedLife ruined his life]]. And it doesn't help that the two women's rivalry makes them tiresome in his eyes. [[spoiler: Towards the climax, he's [[CharacterDevelopment come to a place]] where he recognizes that the potion wouldn't really make him happy and simply damn him to eternity with Madeline and Helen. In the end, after his death, his eulogy implies that he developed many redeeming qualities long after his youth and looks faded.]]

to:

* TrueBeautyIsOnTheInside: Ernest's relationship with both Madeline and Helen is a study in the consequences of only liking somebody for their looks. He broke up with one woman to marry the other because she was prettier. But many years later, Madeline's looks have faded, and he's left with nothing but a shrew who has [[AwfulWeddedLife ruined his life]]. And it doesn't help that the two women's rivalry makes them tiresome in his eyes. [[spoiler: Towards the climax, he's [[CharacterDevelopment come to a place]] where he recognizes that the potion wouldn't really make him happy and happy, but simply damn him to eternity with Madeline and Helen. In the end, after his death, his eulogy implies that he developed many redeeming qualities long after his youth and looks faded.]]



* YankTheDogsChain: When faced with a life-or-death situation, Madeline and Helen nearly convince Ernest to take the potion. No doubt he believed for a moment that they were concerned for his well-being for once. ...And then they say out loud that he ''must'' take the potion because they need him to maintain their dead bodies. This is reconstructed, as it finally lets Ernest see both girls' [[ItsAllAboutMe true nature]] and truly sever his ties with them.

to:

* YankTheDogsChain: When faced with a life-or-death situation, Madeline and Helen nearly convince Ernest to take the potion. No doubt he believed for a moment that they were concerned for his well-being for once. ...And then they say out loud that he ''must'' take the potion because they need him to maintain their dead bodies. This is reconstructed, as it finally lets Ernest see both girls' [[ItsAllAboutMe true nature]] and truly sever his ties with them.them once and for all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


A [[https://deathbecomesherbroadway.com musical adaptation]] is scheduled to premiere in Chicago on April 30th, 2024, starring Creator/MeganHilty as Madeline Ashton and Creator/JenniferSimard as Helen Sharp.

to:

A [[https://deathbecomesherbroadway.com musical adaptation]] is scheduled to premiere in Chicago on April 30th, 2024, starring Creator/MeganHilty as Madeline Ashton and Ashton, Creator/JenniferSimard as Helen Sharp. Sharp, Creator/ChristopherSieber as Ernest Menville, and Music/MichelleWilliams as [[AdaptationNameChange Viola Van Horn]].

Top