Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / CourageUnderFire

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheRashomon: Walden's entire downed helicopter crew survived except for her, and all give different accounts of what she was like. Ilario sings her praises, while Monfriez calls her a coward who collapsed under pressure. Altameyer is dying of cancer and seems to become despondent whenever the topic is even brought up, and Rady was shot in the head and unconcscious the entire time. By the end, [[spoiler: Ilario tells Serling the real story, that Montfriez and Altameyer got scared and rebelled against Walden's authority when she refused to leave Rady behind. Ilario timdily sided with them, leading to a standoff between Walden and Montfriez when she demanded his weapon. Walden then shot an approaching Iraqi soldier only for Montfriez to think she was shooting at him and shoot her in the stomach. When rescue arrived, the injured Walden held back the Iraqis on her own while the three escaped with Rady, assuming they would come back for her. But Montfriez told the rescue party she was dead, abandoning the captain to her fate to avoid a court-martial, which lead to the whole crash site (and presumably Walden) being napalmed. Altameyer was wounded and could not protest, while Ilario was too afraid to. [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone The three men were subsequently traumatized by guilt to varying degrees.]]]]

to:

* TheRashomon: Walden's entire downed helicopter crew survived except for her, and all give different accounts of what she was like. Ilario sings her praises, while Monfriez calls her a coward who collapsed under pressure. Altameyer is dying of cancer and seems to become despondent whenever the topic is even brought up, and Rady was shot in the head and unconcscious unconscious the entire time. By the end, [[spoiler: Ilario tells Serling the real story, that Montfriez and Altameyer got scared and rebelled against Walden's authority when she refused to leave Rady behind. Ilario timdily sided with them, leading to a standoff between Walden and Montfriez when she demanded his weapon. Walden then shot an approaching Iraqi soldier only for Montfriez to think she was shooting at him and shoot her in the stomach. When rescue arrived, the injured Walden held back the Iraqis on her own while the three escaped with Rady, assuming they would come back for her. But Montfriez told the rescue party she was dead, abandoning the captain to her fate to avoid a court-martial, which lead to the whole crash site (and presumably Walden) being napalmed. Altameyer was wounded and could not protest, while Ilario was too afraid to. [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone The three men were subsequently traumatized by guilt to varying degrees.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: The first time Serling goes to question Montfriez, he shows up just in time to watch him give hell to a soldier who had just abandoned a comrade during a training exercise. [[spoiler: It's his guilt over leaving Walden to die to save his own ass talking.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: [[spoiler: Ilario and even Montfriez have this reaction as they watch Walden's position get napalmed after leaving her to die.]]

Changed: 1299

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheRashomon

to:

* TheRashomonTheRashomon: Walden's entire downed helicopter crew survived except for her, and all give different accounts of what she was like. Ilario sings her praises, while Monfriez calls her a coward who collapsed under pressure. Altameyer is dying of cancer and seems to become despondent whenever the topic is even brought up, and Rady was shot in the head and unconcscious the entire time. By the end, [[spoiler: Ilario tells Serling the real story, that Montfriez and Altameyer got scared and rebelled against Walden's authority when she refused to leave Rady behind. Ilario timdily sided with them, leading to a standoff between Walden and Montfriez when she demanded his weapon. Walden then shot an approaching Iraqi soldier only for Montfriez to think she was shooting at him and shoot her in the stomach. When rescue arrived, the injured Walden held back the Iraqis on her own while the three escaped with Rady, assuming they would come back for her. But Montfriez told the rescue party she was dead, abandoning the captain to her fate to avoid a court-martial, which lead to the whole crash site (and presumably Walden) being napalmed. Altameyer was wounded and could not protest, while Ilario was too afraid to. [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone The three men were subsequently traumatized by guilt to varying degrees.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Serling figures out the mystery behind Walden's death and her daughter receives her mother's Medal of Honor. Serling also tells Boylar's parents what happened to their son, and it is is implied he will eventually come to terms with what happened. Aside from that, the movie doesn't end particularly happily for anybody.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: When Montfriez chews out a soldier for leaving a comrade behind behind, it's unclear if it's [[spoiler: hypocrisy or guilt.]]



* TooDumbToLive: [[spoiler: Walden makes it crystal clear to Ilario (the only non-incapacitated crew member who's still on her side by that point) that she plans to court-marshall him along with the others when they are rescued for going against her authority. Needlessly alienating the one ally she had in the middle of a dangerous combat situation essentially seals her fate, as when Montfriez reports her dead, Illario is too afraid of being sent to the stockade to disagree with him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: When Montfriez chews out a soldier for leaving a comrade behind behind, it's unclear if it's [[spoiler: hypocrisy or guilt.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TooDumbToLive: [[spoiler: Walden makes it crystal clear to Ilario (the only non-incapacitated crew member who's still on her side by that point) that she plans to court-marshall him along with the others when they are rescued for going against her authority. Needlessly alienating the one ally she had in the middle of a dangerous combat situation essentially seals her fate, as when Montfriez reports her dead, Illario is too afraid of being sent to the stockade to disagree with him.]]

Changed: 2

Removed: 56

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSquadette: Walden. Justified as she's actually a Medical helicopter pilot**, but the plot revolves around her having to take this role for her crew when they're shot down.
** No, she's not. WTHCastingAgency: Creator/MarkKermode.

to:

* TheSquadette: Walden. Justified as she's actually a Medical helicopter pilot**, pilot, but the plot revolves around her having to take this role for her crew when they're shot down.
** No, she's not. WTHCastingAgency: Creator/MarkKermode.
down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TheAtoner: Serling

to:

* %%* TheAtoner: Serling



* UsefulNotes/GulfWar

to:

* %%* UsefulNotes/GulfWar



* NoOneGetsLeftBehind: Subverted; Monfriez, a [[DrillSergeantNasty drill sergeant]], yells at a trainee about leaving a comrade who was tangled in barbed wire behind. We later learn, however, that [[spoiler: he'd done just that to his wounded commanding officer after she'd threatened to court martial him]].

to:

* NoOneGetsLeftBehind: Subverted; Monfriez, a [[DrillSergeantNasty drill sergeant]], DrillSergeantNasty, yells at a trainee about leaving a comrade who was tangled in barbed wire behind. We later learn, however, that [[spoiler: he'd done just that to his wounded commanding officer after she'd threatened to court martial him]].



-->"It doesn't matter if I'm on this inquiry or not, it doesn't matter if I'm in this Army or not! I'm gonna find out the truth, I guarantee!"

to:

-->"It --->"It doesn't matter if I'm on this inquiry or not, it doesn't matter if I'm in this Army or not! I'm gonna find out the truth, I guarantee!"



* TrappedBehindEnemyLines

to:

* %%* TrappedBehindEnemyLines
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMilitary / ArtisticLicenseAwards: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set. On the other hand, Walden would have been the first to receive the Medal of Honor for actually taking part in combat, plus the only Medal of Honor recipient for Desert Storm.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary / ArtisticLicenseAwards: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set. On the other hand, Walden would have been the first to receive the Medal of Honor for actually taking part in combat, plus the only Medal of Honor recipient for Desert Storm.

Added: 56

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSquadette: Walden. Justified as she's actually a Medical helicopter pilot, but the plot revolves around her having to take this role for her crew when they're shot down.

to:

* TheSquadette: Walden. Justified as she's actually a Medical helicopter pilot, pilot**, but the plot revolves around her having to take this role for her crew when they're shot down.down.
** No, she's not. WTHCastingAgency: Creator/MarkKermode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set. On the other hand, Walden would have been the first to receive the Medal of Honor for actually taking part in combat, plus the only Medal of Honor recipient for Desert Storm.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: ArtisticLicenseMilitary / ArtisticLicenseAwards: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set. On the other hand, Walden would have been the first to receive the Medal of Honor for actually taking part in combat, plus the only Medal of Honor recipient for Desert Storm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set.On the hand Walden would have been the first to receive the Medal of Honor for actually taking part in combat.Plus the only Medal of Honor recipient for Desert Storm.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set. On the hand other hand, Walden would have been the first to receive the Medal of Honor for actually taking part in combat.Plus combat, plus the only Medal of Honor recipient for Desert Storm.



* HonorBeforeReason: Serling wants the committee that's investigating the incident where he accidentally fired on another of his tanks to give a real evaluation rather than just sweep it under the table[[note]]His reasons have little to do with honor, however: he's trying to make sure that he was justified in what he did, and that Boylar's death, while regretable, was not actually his fault, in an attempt to deal with his guilt[[/note]]. He's also determined to investigate Walden's case thoroughly and honestly, rather than just creating a good PR story, even after his CO removes him from the assignment.

to:

* HonorBeforeReason: Serling wants the committee that's investigating the incident where he accidentally fired on another one of his own tanks to give a real evaluation rather than just sweep it under the table[[note]]His reasons have little to do with honor, however: he's trying to make sure that he was justified in what he did, and that Boylar's death, while regretable, was not actually his fault, in an attempt to deal with his guilt[[/note]]. He's also determined to investigate Walden's case thoroughly and honestly, rather than just creating a good PR story, even after his CO removes him from the assignment.



* OhCrap: Serling in the opening battle. **"Cease fire! Cease fire! You just lit up a friendly!"**

to:

* OhCrap: Serling in the opening battle. **"Cease fire! Cease fire! You just lit up a friendly!"**friendly!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->"It doesn't matter if I'm on this inquiry or not, it doesn't matter if I'm in this Army or not. I'm gonna find out the truth, I guarantee."

to:

-->"It doesn't matter if I'm on this inquiry or not, it doesn't matter if I'm in this Army or not. not! I'm gonna find out the truth, I guarantee."guarantee!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Specialist Illario]] is also a functional addict, shooting up morphine between his toes to dull his own guilt over what happened in the war.


Added DiffLines:

* OhCrap: Serling in the opening battle. **"Cease fire! Cease fire! You just lit up a friendly!"**
** Monfriez, after dismissing Serling and finds himself nose to nose with the pissed off Colonel.
-->"It doesn't matter if I'm on this inquiry or not, it doesn't matter if I'm in this Army or not. I'm gonna find out the truth, I guarantee."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a trope.


* YanksWithTanks: Quite literally, given the tank battle that starts off the film.

to:

* YanksWithTanks: Quite literally, given the tank battle that starts off the film.

Changed: 166

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set.On the hand Walden would have been the first to receive the Medal of Honor for actually taking part in combat.Plus the only Medal of Honor recipient for Desert Storm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HonorBeforeReason: Serling wants the committee that's investigating the incident where he accidentally fired on another of his tanks to give a real evaluation rather than just sweep it under the table. He's also determined to investigate Walden's case thoroughly and honestly, rather than just creating a good PR story, even after his CO removes him from the assignment.

to:

* HonorBeforeReason: Serling wants the committee that's investigating the incident where he accidentally fired on another of his tanks to give a real evaluation rather than just sweep it under the table.table[[note]]His reasons have little to do with honor, however: he's trying to make sure that he was justified in what he did, and that Boylar's death, while regretable, was not actually his fault, in an attempt to deal with his guilt[[/note]]. He's also determined to investigate Walden's case thoroughly and honestly, rather than just creating a good PR story, even after his CO removes him from the assignment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor (Captain) Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery.artillery during the US Civil War. That's 135 years prior to when this film is set.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseMilitary: Captain Walden would actually have been the second woman to earn a Congressional Medal of Honor for courage under fire. The first was Doctor Mary Edwards Walker, who earned the award for her refusal to stop treating patients and evacuate when her field hospital was shelled by Confederate artillery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The way it was worded could of been misinterpreted as things other than the subject matter stopped the military backing the film. Moving stuff to Trivia


* BackedByThePentagon: It wasn't due to the subject matter. This led to the issue with the tanks used in the beginning of the film being mock ups.



* DyeingForYourArt: Creator/MattDamon lost 40 pounds for his role, causing his health to become so frail he had to be put under medical supervision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BackedByThePentagon: It wasn't due to the subject matter. This led to the issue with the tanks used in the beginning of the film being mock ups.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Lieutenant Colonel Nathaniel Serling (Washington) is tortured by an incident he was involved in during combat in the GulfWar. He was an M1 Abrams tank battalion commander who, during the nighttime confusion of Iraqi tanks infiltrating his unit's lines, gave the order to fire, thereby destroying one of his own tanks and killing his friend Captain Boylar. Out of remorse, he has resigned himself to a desk job.

to:

Lieutenant Colonel Nathaniel Serling (Washington) is tortured by an incident he was involved in during combat in the GulfWar.UsefulNotes/GulfWar. He was an M1 Abrams tank battalion commander who, during the nighttime confusion of Iraqi tanks infiltrating his unit's lines, gave the order to fire, thereby destroying one of his own tanks and killing his friend Captain Boylar. Out of remorse, he has resigned himself to a desk job.



* GulfWar

to:

* GulfWarUsefulNotes/GulfWar
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DyeingForYourArt: MattDamon lost 40 pounds for his role, causing his health to become so frail he had to be put under medical supervision.

to:

* DyeingForYourArt: MattDamon Creator/MattDamon lost 40 pounds for his role, causing his health to become so frail he had to be put under medical supervision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DyingForYourArt: MattDamon lost 40 pounds for his role, causing his health to become so frail he had to be put under medical supervision.

to:

* DyingForYourArt: DyeingForYourArt: MattDamon lost 40 pounds for his role, causing his health to become so frail he had to be put under medical supervision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DyingForYourArt: MattDamon lost 40 pounds for his role, causing his health to become so frail he had to be put under medical supervision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TanksButNoTanks: The Abrams tanks in this movie are actually British Centurion tanks modified to look like Abrams, a common practice in movies that aren't BackedByThePentagon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Good Looking Privates now only deals with in-story acknowledgement that the person is better looking because of the uniform. Re-add with correct context if this example fits.


* GoodLookingPrivates: Washington and Ryan's characters, of course. The other soldiers under Walden's command include Lou Diamond Phillips, a young Matt Damon, and Seth Gilliam. Although Matt Damon's character in the present of the timeline could be considered a mild subversion as he's noticeably pale and gaunt [[spoiler:due to having become a drug addict]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/courage_under_fire_6736.jpg]]

'''''Courage Under Fire''''' is a 1996 drama film directed by Edward Zwick, and starring DenzelWashington and MegRyan.

Lieutenant Colonel Nathaniel Serling (Washington) is tortured by an incident he was involved in during combat in the GulfWar. He was an M1 Abrams tank battalion commander who, during the nighttime confusion of Iraqi tanks infiltrating his unit's lines, gave the order to fire, thereby destroying one of his own tanks and killing his friend Captain Boylar. Out of remorse, he has resigned himself to a desk job.

His latest assignment is to decide whether Army Captain Karen Emma Walden (Ryan) should be the first woman to receive (posthumously) the Medal of Honor for valor in combat. She was a helicopter pilot who saved the lives of the crew of another helicopter that was downed, after which she and her crew were downed themselves. Said latter crew was rescued the next day, but by then Walden was dead.

It is Serling's job to go and speak with the surviving crewmembers to discern what happened during the night and thus decide whether Walden deserves the Medal or not. It all looks as though it will be straightforward... [[TheRashomon but then the surviving crewmembers offer differing explanations for what happened, and differing descriptions of what Walden was like...]] and Serling, haunted by the way the Army has swept his own responsibility for the tank incident under the rug, refuses to be part of doing the same with someone else.

-----
!!This film provides examples of:

* TheAlcoholic: Serling has turned to drinking to help drown out the memories, and he's barely keeping it under wraps.
* TheAtoner: Serling
* BurnBabyBurn: [[spoiler: What happened to Walden's body. "Oh Jesus... the fire..."]]
* DeathFromAbove: Walden implements an ad-hoc version of this by having the chopper's auxiliary fuel tank dumped on an Iraqi tank and then set off by a flare gun. Also the airstrikes sent in to cover the rescue of Walden and the others.
* DrillSergeantNasty: Monfriez has become this since the war.
* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler: Monfriez. Driving headfirst into a ''train'' no less]]
* FemaleMisogynist: Rady's wife shows some of this, feeling that Walden needlessly took them into danger and makes some comments that border on being anti-gay against Walden. Rady basically tells her to shut up and that she doesn't know what she's talking about.
* FunctionalAddict: Sterling is this, but his alcohol problems are getting worse due to SurvivorsGuilt, among other factors.
* GoodLookingPrivates: Washington and Ryan's characters, of course. The other soldiers under Walden's command include Lou Diamond Phillips, a young Matt Damon, and Seth Gilliam. Although Matt Damon's character in the present of the timeline could be considered a mild subversion as he's noticeably pale and gaunt [[spoiler:due to having become a drug addict]].
* GulfWar
* HeManWomanHater: Monfriez has elements of this.
* HonorBeforeReason: Serling wants the committee that's investigating the incident where he accidentally fired on another of his tanks to give a real evaluation rather than just sweep it under the table. He's also determined to investigate Walden's case thoroughly and honestly, rather than just creating a good PR story, even after his CO removes him from the assignment.
* IsThatAThreat: Serling, when Monfriez warns him to leave the investigation alone.
-->"Son, I work for the Pentagon, so I admit I'm a little slow on the uptake, but did you just threaten me?"
* KillItWithFire: Walden's improvised fuel tank firebomb and the A-10's napalm run.
* NonActionGuy: Matt Damon's character.
* NoOneGetsLeftBehind: Subverted; Monfriez, a [[DrillSergeantNasty drill sergeant]], yells at a trainee about leaving a comrade who was tangled in barbed wire behind. We later learn, however, that [[spoiler: he'd done just that to his wounded commanding officer after she'd threatened to court martial him]].
* PerspectiveFlip: The events involving Walden are told from the POV's of the various members of her crew. A critical plot point as the members give conflicting stories.
* PosthumousCharacter: Walden is dead during the course of the film occupied by Serling. All her appearances take place in flashbacks.
* TheRashomon
* TheSquadette: Walden. Justified as she's actually a Medical helicopter pilot, but the plot revolves around her having to take this role for her crew when they're shot down.
* StabTheScorpion: Walden and one of the soldiers under her command are having an argument. Suddenly she shoots behind him, at an Iraqi soldier that was about to kill him. [[spoiler:Alas, he thinks she was shooting at ''him'', and he shoots her back.]]
* TankGoodness: The film starts off showing a night tank battle between U.S. and Iraqi tank divisions.
* TrappedBehindEnemyLines
* UnfriendlyFire: Occurs in both the film's plot and sub-plot. [[spoiler:Monfriez shoots at Walden after he mistakenly believes she's shooting at him]]. Serling accidentally kills a soldier under his command when he fires on his tank mistaking it for an enemy tank.
* WithDueRespect: [[spoiler: "I strongly urge you to dismount the vehicle, ''sir!'' Yaaaaaaaaahhhh!!!"]]
* WorstAid: At some points the soldiers are fairly liberal with moving Rady, not something you usually want to do when someone has a head wound. Justified, as they're better about it when not under attack, and the time when they're really swinging him around is when they're trying to evacuate a combat zone.
* YanksWithTanks: Quite literally, given the tank battle that starts off the film.

-----

Top