Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Battleship

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouHaveGotToBeKiddingMe: As they are preparing to snipe the alien ship's bridge, Hopper asks Captain Nagata where he learned to shoot. Nagata replies at summer camp, when he was 12.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DidNotThinkThisThrough: While hyperventilating, Cal tells Sam and Mick that he warned the U.S. government that sending a signal to deep space would have dire consequences, and that any alien race advanced enough to make the journey to Earth would not be arriving with peaceful intentions.
-->''I told them that something like this would happen, that if something did find us, it would be like Columbus and the Indians, or the Incas and the Conquistadors, and they said, "Oh, no, they'll be sweet..."''

Added: 411

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lt. Col. Canales is played by real life Col. Gadson. [[DisabledCharacterDisabledActor Like his character, he lost both legs in Iraq]]. He was also an honorary co-captain of the New York Giants when they won Super Bowl 42, and wears their hat throughout the movie.

to:

** Lt. Col. Canales is played by real life U.S. Army Col. Gregory Gadson. [[DisabledCharacterDisabledActor Like his character, he lost both legs in Iraq]]. He was also an honorary co-captain of the New York Giants when they won Super Bowl 42, and wears their hat throughout the movie.


Added DiffLines:

* BadassBoast: When an alien soldier approaches Sam's stalled jeep, Mick - a former champion boxer missing both his legs - says simply:
-->'''Mick''': I got this.


Added DiffLines:

* CowardlyLion: Cal, who "acquires" enough courage to retrieve his equipment from the aliens' lair, and later uses it to knock down the alien soldier attacking Mick.
-->'''Cal''': ''(to the trapped Sam)'' Calm down, okay? I'm gonna frigging save you!

Added: 305

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->"Boom."

to:

-->"Boom.--->"Boom."


Added DiffLines:

* {{Realpolitik}}: Captain Nagata reveals that for twenty years Japan has been preparing contingency plans for ''another'' war with America, including using tsunami buoys to track ships by their water displacement instead of radar. Hopper mildly calls him out on it, and Nagata shrugs, ''"rough world."''

Added: 163

Removed: 159

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* PowerWalk: Performed by the U.S. Navy veterans when they come to the aid of the ''JPJ''[='=]s survivors in getting the ''Missouri'' back into fighting shape.


Added DiffLines:

* TeamPowerWalk: Performed by the U.S. Navy veterans when they come to the aid of the ''JPJ''[='=]s survivors in getting the ''Missouri'' back into fighting shape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Overprotective Dad has been disambiguated


* OverprotectiveDad: The Admiral is implied to be this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThoseWereOnlyTheirScouts: It turns out [[spoiler: those aliens that landed on Earth was just armed advanced scouts who were sent there for a scout mission.]] Whatever their actual military ships and soldiers are, they might able to conquer Earth easily if it weren't for the main characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
corrected misspellings


** Crossing over with ArtisticLicenseEngineering, clubhauling[[labelnote:*]]turning a ship suddenly by dropping its anchor on the side that you wish to turn and using the ship's momentum to swing around[[/labelnote]] an ''Iowa''-class battleship is completely impossible: even if you used all four anchors, the ship is too massive and would be moving too fast for the chains to hold up, and more to the point, the chains simply aren't ''long'' enough to reach the sea floor in the middle of the pacific anyways.
** Bringing a museum ship up to fighting capability in under a day is impossible. Even assuming that live ammo and fuel are stored onboard strains belief. In real life it took two years to recommission an Iowa-class battleship (though that did include upgrading and installing new weapons and systems). Firing the boilers alone takes the better part of day.
** The scene where the main characters struggle to carry a 2,500lb 16-inch armor-piercing shell from the aft magazine to the forward turrets is rather ridiculous. Transferring main battery ammunition between the fore and aft magazines was a common enough operation that the designers of the ''Iowa''-class battleships included an overhead-rail trolley system in the central "Broadway" passageway to do it quickly and safely. The ship also has multiple shell dolleys for moving the big shells around the compartment, loading them onto the ready racks & ammo hoists, etc. Having eight guys try to deadlift one and lug it 500 feet is both slower and asking to kill somebody.

to:

** Crossing over with ArtisticLicenseEngineering, clubhauling[[labelnote:*]]turning a ship suddenly by dropping its anchor on the side that you wish to turn and using the ship's momentum to swing around[[/labelnote]] an ''Iowa''-class battleship is completely impossible: even if you used all four anchors, the ship is too massive and would be moving too fast for the chains to hold up, and more to the point, the chains simply aren't ''long'' enough to reach the sea floor in the middle of the pacific anyways.
Pacific anyway.
** Bringing a museum ship up to fighting capability in under a day is impossible. Even assuming that live ammo and fuel are stored onboard strains belief. In real life life, it took two years to recommission an Iowa-class battleship (though that did include upgrading and installing new weapons and systems). Firing the boilers alone takes the better part of day.
** The scene where the main characters struggle to carry a 2,500lb 16-inch armor-piercing shell from the aft magazine to the forward turrets is rather ridiculous. Transferring main battery ammunition between the fore and aft magazines was a common enough operation that the designers of the ''Iowa''-class battleships included an overhead-rail trolley system in the central "Broadway" passageway to do it quickly and safely. The ship also has multiple shell dolleys dollies for moving the big shells around the compartment, loading them onto the ready racks & ammo hoists, etc. Having eight guys try to deadlift one and lug it 500 feet is both slower and asking to kill somebody.



** In the novel Alex ''almost'' gets it out after losing the ''John Paul Jones'', but is cut off at the last word. Of course, he was in fact talking about a destroyer at the time...

to:

** In the novel novel, Alex ''almost'' gets it out after losing the ''John Paul Jones'', but is cut off at the last word. Of course, he was in fact talking about a destroyer at the time...



* AwesomeButImpractical: The battleship ''Missouri'' in a modern navy. As Alex explains to a little boy taking a tour, the battleship is essentially a dinosaur fossil even compared to ships like his much smaller destroyer. Battleships were made obsolete by aircraft, missiles and advanced targeting systems -- three things that had been nullified by the aliens making it more effective for direct combat than the destroyers. In fact, the buoy targeting method is a more advanced version of how battleship targeting was traditionally performed. But somehow Alex forgot, that in '80s Iowa-class battleship were upgraded with then-modern radars, missile weaponry and active defences, and were pretty useful in Desert Storm operation. Obsolete, but nothing like dinosaur fossil.

to:

* AwesomeButImpractical: The battleship ''Missouri'' in a modern navy. As Alex explains to a little boy taking a tour, the battleship is essentially a dinosaur fossil even compared to ships like his much smaller destroyer. Battleships were made obsolete by aircraft, missiles missiles, and advanced targeting systems -- three things that had been nullified by the aliens aliens, thus making it more effective for direct combat than the destroyers. In fact, the buoy targeting method is a more advanced version of how battleship targeting was traditionally performed. But somehow Alex forgot, forgot that in '80s the 1980s, Iowa-class battleship battleships were upgraded with then-modern radars, missile weaponry weaponry, and active defences, defenses, and were pretty useful in Desert Storm operation. Obsolete, but nothing like dinosaur fossil.fossils.



* BottomlessMagazines: In the final battle, USS ''Missouri'' fires her sixteen-inch guns several times in the span of a few seconds, only stopping so Alex Hopper can [[RuleOfDrama shout "Reload!"]] The actual rate of fire for such guns is around [[http://www.ussnewjersey.com/hist_sts.htm two rounds per gun per minute]]. Also, there is no such thing as an automatic 16 inch gun, they are reloaded after every shot.

to:

* BottomlessMagazines: In the final battle, USS ''Missouri'' fires her sixteen-inch guns several times in the span of a few seconds, only stopping so that Alex Hopper can [[RuleOfDrama shout "Reload!"]] The actual rate of fire for such guns is around [[http://www.ussnewjersey.com/hist_sts.htm two rounds per gun per minute]]. Also, there is no such thing as an automatic 16 inch gun, 16-inch gun; rather, they are reloaded after every shot.



* TheCavalry: Just when it seems Alex, Nagata and Co have sailed their last mission against the aliens [[spoiler:the armed might of the Pacific Rim navies comes to the rescue in the form Australian fighter jets blowing the enemy up]].

to:

* TheCavalry: Just when it seems that Alex, Nagata Nagata, and Co have sailed their last mission against the aliens [[spoiler:the armed might of the Pacific Rim navies comes to the rescue in the form Australian fighter jets blowing the enemy up]].



* CurbStompBattle: The first battle with the aliens. Due to the shield jamming their missile guidance systems they're forced to engage the alien ships with only their five-inch guns, which are piddly next to what the aliens can dish out. Both the ''Sampson'' and ''Myoko'' are destroyed very quickly one after the other, the former with all hands.

to:

* CurbStompBattle: The first battle with the aliens. Due to the shield jamming their missile guidance systems systems, they're forced to engage the alien ships with only their five-inch guns, which are piddly next to what the aliens can dish out. Both the ''Sampson'' and ''Myoko'' are destroyed very quickly one after the other, the former with all hands.



* HumanoidAliens: The invaders are basically oversized, pale humans with gecko-like eyes, goatees made of something resembling porcupine quills, and clawlike FourFingeredHands. Revisiting the film 10 years later, many have drawn comparisons between the aliens and [[MemeticMutation Craig]] from the early beta of ''VideoGame/HaloInfinite''.

to:

* HumanoidAliens: The invaders are basically oversized, pale humans with gecko-like eyes, goatees made of something resembling porcupine quills, and clawlike claw-like FourFingeredHands. Revisiting the film 10 years later, many have drawn comparisons between the aliens and [[MemeticMutation Craig]] from the early beta of ''VideoGame/HaloInfinite''.



* NotOfThisEarth: Alien debris is composed of unknown elements (and lawrencium); impressive, since our indications are that everything we haven't identified is extremely unstable. Lawrencium, number 103 on the periodic table, has a half-life of 216 minutes at its stablest known isotope, and everything above it only gets shorter-lived.

to:

* NotOfThisEarth: Alien debris is composed of unknown elements (and lawrencium); impressive, since our indications are that everything we haven't identified is extremely unstable. Lawrencium, number 103 on the periodic table, has a half-life of 216 minutes at its stablest most-stable known isotope, and everything above it only gets shorter-lived.



** When Hopper and his girlfriend are late and trying to find their way onto the battleship it's just a flimsy excuse to linger overlong on his Ford pickup.

to:

** When Hopper and his girlfriend are late and trying to find their way onto the battleship battleship, it's just a flimsy excuse to linger overlong on his Ford pickup.



* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: After Alex gets arrested and tased in the opening scene, Stone comes in and starts yelling about how he was screwing around with his commander's daughter, which therefore messes with his job, and his life, and he's through with just letting Alex repeatedly go through with stupid stuff.

to:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: After Alex gets arrested and tased tazed in the opening scene, Stone comes in and starts yelling about how he was screwing around with his commander's daughter, which therefore messes with his job, and his life, and he's through with just letting Alex repeatedly go through with stupid stuff.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdvertisingByAssociation: The film was proudly declared as coming "From {{Creator/Hasbro}}, the company that brought you ''Film/{{Transformers}}''", in spite of neither film being actually made by the same studio (note:Hasbro's film division at the time just developed the concepts for other studios. Also, they didn't create the original Battleship game, they just bought out the owners).

to:

* AdvertisingByAssociation: The film was proudly declared as coming "From {{Creator/Hasbro}}, the company that brought you ''Film/{{Transformers}}''", in spite of neither film being actually made by the same studio (note:Hasbro's [[note]]Hasbro's film division at the time just developed the concepts for other studios. Also, they didn't create the original Battleship game, they just bought out the owners).owners[[/note]].

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IKnowWhatWeCanDoCut: Alex is asked how they're going to get a two-ton artillery shell over to the battleship's remaining intact cannon. Alex thinks for a second, then we cut to the men transporting it the only way they can: by hand.

to:

* IKnowWhatWeCanDoCut: Alex is asked how they're going to get a two-ton artillery shell over to the battleship's remaining intact cannon.turrets. Alex thinks for a second, then we cut to the men transporting it the only way they can: by hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IKnowWhatWeCanDoCut: Alex is asked how they're going to get a two-ton artillery shell over to the battleship's remaining intact cannon. Alex thinks for a second, then we cut to the men transporting it the only way they can: by hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* OneBulletLeft: The ''USS Missouri'' in the climax; [[spoiler: after expending almost all of their 16-inch shells on the alien mothership, the protagonists are left with a choice to use their last remaining shell to either finish off the mothership, or destroy the hijacked signal facility the aliens are using to send a distress signal to their home fleet, at the risk of being destroyed by a final salvo launched from the now-foundering mothership. They ultimately [[HeroicSacrifice choose the latter]], but thankfully a pair of Hornets [[BigDamnHeroes arrive just in the nick of time]] to intercept the salvo and finish off the mothership.]]

to:

%%* * OneBulletLeft: The ''USS Missouri'' in the climax; [[spoiler: after expending almost all of their 16-inch shells on the alien mothership, the protagonists are left with a choice to use their last remaining shell to either finish off the mothership, or destroy the hijacked signal facility the aliens are using to send a distress signal to their home fleet, at the risk of being destroyed by a final salvo launched from the now-foundering mothership. They ultimately [[HeroicSacrifice choose the latter]], but thankfully a pair of Hornets [[BigDamnHeroes arrive just in the nick of time]] to intercept the salvo and finish off the mothership.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
your wish for context is my command.


%%* OneBulletLeft: The ''USS Missouri'' in the climax.

to:

%%* OneBulletLeft: The ''USS Missouri'' in the climax. climax; [[spoiler: after expending almost all of their 16-inch shells on the alien mothership, the protagonists are left with a choice to use their last remaining shell to either finish off the mothership, or destroy the hijacked signal facility the aliens are using to send a distress signal to their home fleet, at the risk of being destroyed by a final salvo launched from the now-foundering mothership. They ultimately [[HeroicSacrifice choose the latter]], but thankfully a pair of Hornets [[BigDamnHeroes arrive just in the nick of time]] to intercept the salvo and finish off the mothership.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ZCE, do not re-add without adding context


* OneBulletLeft: The ''USS Missouri'' in the climax.

to:

* %%* OneBulletLeft: The ''USS Missouri'' in the climax.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OneBulletLeft:

to:

* OneBulletLeft: The ''USS Missouri'' in the climax.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneBulletLeft:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VasquezAlwaysDies: Averted by Cora Raikes despite being both [[VasquezAlwaysDies the tough gunner girl]] and [[BlackDudeDiesFirst black]].

to:

* VasquezAlwaysDies: Averted by Cora Raikes despite being both [[VasquezAlwaysDies [[ActionGirl the tough gunner girl]] and [[BlackDudeDiesFirst black]].[[AmbiguouslyBrown not white]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AFatherToHisMen: Admiral Shane tells off his superiors for wanting to sacrifice more men.

to:

* AFatherToHisMen: Admiral Shane tells off his superiors for wanting to sacrifice sod off after being told that the best strategy they can come up with is to keep slamming more men.jets into the shield in the hopes that one of them will somehow get through.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HumanoidAliens: The invaders are basically oversized, pale humans with gecko-like eyes, goatees made of something resembling porcupine quills, and clawlike FourFingeredHands.

to:

* HumanoidAliens: The invaders are basically oversized, pale humans with gecko-like eyes, goatees made of something resembling porcupine quills, and clawlike FourFingeredHands. Revisiting the film 10 years later, many have drawn comparisons between the aliens and [[MemeticMutation Craig]] from the early beta of ''VideoGame/HaloInfinite''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ConvenientlyEmptyBuildings: Averted; early in the film one of the alien ships gets knocked off course and the debris rains down onto Hong Kong. Most of the pieces just barely buzz by and land in the harbor without hitting any structures, but one chunk takes out the top section of the Bank of China and causes it to crash to the street. It's mentioned later in the film that this alone caused 25,000 casualties.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The CO and XO of the ship being taken out with a single hit, instead of them being at different battle stations to avoid just this scenario.

to:

** The CO and XO of the ship being taken out with a single hit, instead of them being at different battle stations to avoid just this scenario. (though given the size/placement of the explosions, its possible both battle stations were destroyed)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BackToCameraPose: * The [[https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/battleship_0.png poster]] features Hopper looking up in awe at the alien battleship with his back to the audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Crossing over with ArtisticLicenseEngineering, clubhauling[[labelnote:*]]turning a ship suddenly by dropping its anchor on the side that you wish to turn and using the ship's momentum to swing around[[/labelnote]] an ''Iowa''-class battleship is completely impossible: even if you used all four anchors, the ship is too massive and would be moving too fast for the chains to hold up.

to:

** Crossing over with ArtisticLicenseEngineering, clubhauling[[labelnote:*]]turning a ship suddenly by dropping its anchor on the side that you wish to turn and using the ship's momentum to swing around[[/labelnote]] an ''Iowa''-class battleship is completely impossible: even if you used all four anchors, the ship is too massive and would be moving too fast for the chains to hold up.up, and more to the point, the chains simply aren't ''long'' enough to reach the sea floor in the middle of the pacific anyways.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Battleship'' is a sci-fi action film released in 2012, directed by Peter Berg and starring Creator/LiamNeeson, Taylor Kitsch, Creator/BrooklynDecker, Creator/AlexanderSkarsgard, and Music/{{Rihanna}}, ''very loosely based'' on the board game {{TabletopGame/Battleship}}. [[LiveActionAdaptation Yes, the one with red and white pegs and a grid and "you sunk my battleship!"]]

to:

''Battleship'' is a sci-fi action film released in 2012, directed by Peter Berg and starring Creator/LiamNeeson, Taylor Kitsch, Creator/TaylorKitsch, Creator/BrooklynDecker, Creator/AlexanderSkarsgard, and Music/{{Rihanna}}, ''very loosely based'' on the board game {{TabletopGame/Battleship}}. [[LiveActionAdaptation Yes, the one with red and white pegs and a grid and "you sunk my battleship!"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ZCE, do not re-add without adding context


* LampshadeHanging: Mercilessly in the novelization.

to:

* %%* LampshadeHanging: Mercilessly in the novelization.

Added: 101

Changed: 244

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Likely for the sake of landlubbers watching, the characters avoid nearly all nautical terms which would be second nature to any sailor.
** It's rather odd how often the new commanding officer of the destroyer finds himself all alone with no subordinates or only Raikes supporting him.

to:

** Likely for the sake of landlubbers watching, the characters avoid nearly all nautical terms which would be second nature to any sailor.
sailor (using left and right instead of port and starboard).
** It's rather odd how often the new commanding officer The CO and XO of the destroyer finds himself all alone ship being taken out with no subordinates or only Raikes supporting him.a single hit, instead of them being at different battle stations to avoid just this scenario.
** Hopper, as weapons officer, would not be the next in line to command the ship after the CO and XO.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
natter


** The impractical part of the battleship is its cost in relation to its capabilities. Originally they were designed to fight other battleships and then the rest of the surface fleet. However submarines and aircraft were far better in this role, so they ended up relegated to shore bombardment mostly. With missile upgrades and add ons they still had value, just not enough value to compensate for the immense cost of building and maintaining them.

Added: 543

Changed: 353

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoRangeLikePointBlankRange: Although the sixteen-inch guns of the ''Missouri'' can easily engage at over twenty miles away, the battleship is practically spitting distance from the alien craft when they actually attack. Having only a small handful of shells, however, plus an undersized crew they could hardly afford to waste shots getting the range for a longer ranged engagement.

to:

* NoRangeLikePointBlankRange: NoRangeLikePointBlankRange:
** Hopper distracts one of the aliens on the deck of the John Paul Jones while Raikes rotates the 5" gun straight at its head. She fires when the alien is roughly three feet from the gun.
**
Although the sixteen-inch guns of the ''Missouri'' can easily engage at over twenty miles away, the battleship is practically spitting distance from the alien craft when they actually attack. Having only a small handful of shells, however, plus an undersized crew they could hardly afford to waste shots getting the range for a longer ranged engagement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Even better? ''None of that was faked!'' The movie showed the actual ''Missouri'' being properly activated by real Navy vets, some of which were actual ''Missouri'' crewmembers during her active service.

Added: 206

Changed: 206

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor typo


* EpicLaunchSequence: The eponymous warship, USS ''Missouri'', is given [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zMwQbD3ZI4o a proper revival]] when it's needed for the final assault.** Even better? ''None of that was faked!'' The movie showed the actual ''Missouri'' being properly activated by real Navy vets, some of which were actual ''Missouri'' crewmembers during her active service.

to:

* EpicLaunchSequence: The eponymous warship, USS ''Missouri'', is given [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zMwQbD3ZI4o a proper revival]] when it's needed for the final assault.assault.
** Even better? ''None of that was faked!'' The movie showed the actual ''Missouri'' being properly activated by real Navy vets, some of which were actual ''Missouri'' crewmembers during her active service.

Top