Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Arrival

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigGood: [[spoiler:The Heptapods]].

to:

* BigGood: [[spoiler:The Heptapods]].Heptapods come and leave in peace to give humanity a gift that they won't see repaid for 3,000 years, already knowing that at least one of their own will be killed in the process just to save 2 human lives.]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BenevolentAlienInvasion: The alien ships appear on Earth at twelve random sites and do nothing but attempt to communicate with the humans they encounter. It even seems that they're deliberately affecting the atmosphere in their ships to accommodate the humans. Still, the worlds' governments must remain suspicious of the aliens for fear of human extinction, and a few of the aliens' more ambiguous statements give a lot of credence to the idea that they are attempting to divide humanity before an attempt at war. [[spoiler:It turns out the aliens arrived to help humans see beyond time, as repayment for saving the aliens in the future.]]

to:

* BenevolentAlienInvasion: The alien ships appear on Earth at twelve random sites and do nothing but attempt to communicate with the humans they encounter. It even seems that they're deliberately affecting the atmosphere in their ships to accommodate the humans. Still, the worlds' governments must remain suspicious of the aliens for fear of human extinction, and a few of the aliens' more ambiguous statements give a lot of credence to the idea that they are attempting to divide humanity before an attempt at war. [[spoiler:It turns out the aliens arrived to help humans see beyond time, as both means and repayment for saving the aliens in the future.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut page


** Early in the film, when Louise is on the phone to her mother, she tells her not to watch "that network" because the people on it are "idiots," implying that the channel has a long-standing reputation of it. Viewers can fill in [[Creator/FoxNewsChannel Fox News]] or MSNBC according to taste.

to:

** Early in the film, when Louise is on the phone to her mother, she tells her not to watch "that network" because the people on it are "idiots," implying that the channel has a long-standing reputation of it. Viewers can fill in [[Creator/FoxNewsChannel Fox News]] News or MSNBC according to taste.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TimeBomb: [[spoiler: Captain Marks and the escort team plant [=C4=] [[IncrediblyObviousBomb with a visible timer]] inside the alien ship. They didn't expect anyone to show up, it's facing off to the side, it looks like another piece of equipment, and [[IncrediblyObviousBomb it doesn't conspicuously beep or have a flashing red light]], so Louise and Ian fail to notice it. The Heptapods do notice, but they can't properly convey the danger to Louise and Ian until it's too late to do anything.]]

to:

* TimeBomb: [[spoiler: Captain Marks and the escort team plant [=C4=] [[IncrediblyObviousBomb with a visible timer]] inside the alien ship. They didn't expect anyone to show up, it's facing off to the side, it looks like another piece of equipment, and [[IncrediblyObviousBomb it doesn't conspicuously beep or have a flashing red light]], so Louise and Ian fail to notice it. The Heptapods do notice, but they can't properly convey the danger to Louise and Ian until it's too late to do anything. Knowing how they perceive time, they had to wait to eject the scientists to ensure events played out as they were supposed to.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Louise learns how to sway General Shang because she already did in the future. It's strongly hinted he also knew he had to close the loop, saying he came to the conference ''specifically'' to speak to ''her'', and to show her his phone number and tell her his wife's dying words in Chinese -- which she uses in the "present" to dissuade him from launching an attack on the aliens.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Louise learns how to sway General Shang because she already did in the future. It's strongly hinted he also knew that he had to close the loop, saying he came to the conference ''specifically'' to speak to ''her'', and to show her his phone number and tell her his wife's dying words in Chinese -- - which she uses in the "present" to dissuade him from launching an attack on the aliens.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequencingDeception: The scene with [[spoiler:Louise raising her daughter only for her to die at twelve years old]] doesn't actually take place at the beginning chronologically, but represents [[spoiler:the heptapods allowing her to know this will happen in the future.]]

to:

* SequencingDeception: The scene with [[spoiler:Louise raising her daughter only for her to die at twelve years old]] doesn't actually take place at the beginning chronologically, but represents [[spoiler:the heptapods heptapod language allowing her to know this will happen in the future.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Did General Shang [[spoiler: also gain the ability to perceive time non-linearly?]] The film itself hints that this could be the case and the reason [[spoiler: he specifically talks to Louise to tell her the phrase she previously told him]], but doesn't directly state either way.

Changed: 329

Removed: 162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: What "wrong decision", exactly, was Ian angry about? Was it not telling him earlier about Hannah's fate? Was it choosing to have Hannah, knowing that she'd die young? Was it marrying him in the first place, knowing how everything would turn out?]]
** On that note, [[spoiler:why did Hannah scream "I HATE YOU!" at Louise? Was it just another argument, or did Hannah learn of the predetermination of her life?]]

to:

** [[spoiler: What "wrong decision", exactly, was Ian angry about? Was it not telling him earlier about Hannah's fate? Was it choosing to have Hannah, knowing that she'd die young? Was it marrying him in the first place, knowing how everything would turn out?]]
** On that note, [[spoiler:why did Hannah scream "I HATE YOU!" at Louise? Was it just another argument, or did Hannah learn of the predetermination of her life?]]life? In the short story, this just happens to be a simple argument between them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Arrival'' is a 2016 science fiction drama film directed by Creator/DenisVilleneuve and written by Eric Heisserer, [[TheFilmOfTheBook based on the short story]] "Story of Your Life" by author Creator/TedChiang. The film stars Creator/AmyAdams, Creator/JeremyRenner and Creator/ForestWhitaker.

to:

''Arrival'' is a 2016 science fiction drama film directed by Creator/DenisVilleneuve and written by Eric Heisserer, Creator/EricHeisserer, [[TheFilmOfTheBook based on the short story]] "Story of Your Life" by author Creator/TedChiang. The film stars Creator/AmyAdams, Creator/JeremyRenner and Creator/ForestWhitaker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SceneryPorn: Being a Denis Villeneuve movie, it naturally features quite a bit of this. A standout example, however, is Louise and Ian's arrival at the base camp.

to:

* SceneryPorn: Being a Denis Villeneuve movie, it naturally features quite a bit of this. A standout example, however, is Louise and Ian's arrival at the base camp.camp, with the heptapod ship hovering just above the ground as blankets of mist roll over the mountains and down into the valley.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WarIsHell: Referenced. General Chang's wife's last words were "War does not make winners, only widows." When Louise Banks learned this from General Chang in the future, she contacted him in the present and with those words convinced him to stand down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
firstly, as written this trope is averted and secondly it's covered by the more fitting No Biochemical Barriers


* AllPlanetsAreEarthlike: Subverted. Ian speculates that the limited window in which humans can enter the ships is because of the aliens breathing an atmosphere different from Earth's and having to cycle the ship's systems

Added: 704

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gary Donnelly is the name of the physicist working with Louise in the original story. His name was changed to Ian for the film.

to:

** Gary Donnelly is the name of the The physicist working with Louise is named Gary Donnelly in the original story. His name was changed to Ian for the film.


Added DiffLines:

* AllPlanetsAreEarthlike: Subverted. Ian speculates that the limited window in which humans can enter the ships is because of the aliens breathing an atmosphere different from Earth's and having to cycle the ship's systems


Added DiffLines:

* ConvenientlyPreciseTranslation: Played for drama. Weber is initially frustrated at Louise's slow progress until she spells out just how hard "Why did you come to Earth?" can be to translate, at which point he backs off. [[spoiler:Everyone is spooked when the heptapods respond to this question with "offer weapon", even though Louise points out that what the humans think is "weapon" could also be something more like "tool". She's ultimately right, as it should've been "gift".]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: When Louise's daughter questions the reason for her name, "Hannah", Louise explains that her name is a palindrome, that is, it is spelled the same backwards as it is forward. This reflects the theme of the film in that [[spoiler: the story starts as it finishes, due to the story's events existing in a non-linear timeline. The opening few scenes of the film are simultaneously the beginning and the end, as is the case with the order of letters that make up Hannah's name.]]

to:

* MeaningfulName: MeaningfulName:
** The nicknames for the two heptapods, "[[Creator/AbbottAndCostello Abbott and Costello]]", could be seen as a nod to the duo's famous "WhosOnFirst" routine, the central joke of which is based around two characters trying and failing to communicate and understand each other, much as the central conflict of the film comes from the humans misinterpreting the heptapods' attempts at communication as a threat to kill.
**
When Louise's daughter questions the reason for her name, "Hannah", Louise explains that her name is a palindrome, that is, it is spelled the same backwards as it is forward. This reflects the theme of the film in that [[spoiler: the story starts as it finishes, due to the story's events existing in a non-linear timeline. The opening few scenes of the film are simultaneously the beginning and the end, as is the case with the order of letters that make up Hannah's name.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** An angry right-wing radio host who complains that the government is mishandling the situation, accuses said government of defanging the military and ruining health care, and demands a military show of force to prove America means business. By all appearances, it's a thinly veiled portrayal of Radio/RushLimbaugh.

to:

** An angry right-wing radio host who complains that the government is mishandling the situation, accuses said government of defanging the military and ruining health care, and demands a military show of force to prove America means business. By all appearances, it's a thinly veiled portrayal of Radio/RushLimbaugh.either Radio/RushLimbaugh or Alex Jones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGunman: One of the soldiers accompanying Louise and Ian to the shell is seen later on the phone trying to calm down his nearly hysterical wife, who's convinced he's going to be killed by the aliens. Later he is shown listening to a Rush Limbaugh-esque talk radio host demanding a preemptive strike on the aliens. He eventually [[spoiler:sets a C-4 charge in the ship trying to destroy it, mortally wounding "Abbott" in the process]].

to:

* ChekhovsGunman: One of the soldiers accompanying Louise and Ian to the shell is seen later on the phone trying to calm down his nearly hysterical wife, who's convinced he's going to be killed by the aliens. Later he is shown listening to a Rush Limbaugh-esque an Alex Jones-esque right-wing talk radio host demanding a preemptive strike on the aliens. He and some like-minded soldiers eventually [[spoiler:sets [[spoiler:set a C-4 charge in the ship trying to destroy it, mortally wounding "Abbott" in the process]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CloseOnTitle: The movie title only appears at the start of the end credit.

to:

* CloseOnTitle: The movie title only appears at the start of the end credit.credits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cross-wicking entries. this is not my opinion

Added DiffLines:

* CloseOnTitle: The movie title only appears at the start of the end credit.


Added DiffLines:

* FauxFluency: The climax revolves around Creator/AmyAdams’s character having to say a phrase in Mandarin. She doesn’t speak Mandarin and had to learn the phrase phonetically. She tried for two weeks to memorize it (Mandarin is notoriously hard for native English speakers) but inevitably taped index cards with the pronunciations on the wall of the room. At best her pronunciation is WhatTheHellIsThatAccent, at worst it’s unintelligible gibberish.

Added: 1410

Removed: 607

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding new tropes


* ApocalypseAnarchy: Downplayed. The news report about increased violence and looting in the wake of the alien invasion. After the national guards failed to reinstate the order, the president declares a dusk-to-dawn curfew.



* BigHonkingTrafficJam: Early on there is a traffic jam in the university's parkade with lots of honking cars because everyone is on edge after the news of the arriving aliens was broadcasted.



* EEqualsMCHammer: There is a big whiteboard filled with complex equations at the army camp. It helps to establish Ian as a top mathematician.



* GoThroughMe: Ian stands in front of Louise and thus prevents the soldiers from shooting her while she is making her call to the Chinese president.



* {{Infodump}}: After the scene where Louise and Ian are able to establish who they are individually to the Heptapods, we get a montage where Ian in voiceover covers various discoveries about the Heptapods and their language over a period of several months, allowing us to skip to the point where Louise is ordered to ask what exactly the aliens want. It sticks out a bit as it's the only non-diegetic dialogue given by Ian in the entire film.



* {{Infodump}}: After the scene where Louise and Ian are able to establish who they are individually to the Heptapods, we get a montage where Ian in voiceover covers various discoveries about the Heptapods and their language over a period of several months, allowing us to skip to the point where Louise is ordered to ask what exactly the aliens want. It sticks out a bit as it's the only non-diegetic dialogue given by Ian in the entire film.



* OpeningMonologue: The movie is opened with a few lines about memory and time narrated by Louise.



* SceneryPorn: Being a Denis Villeneuve movie, it naturally features quite a bit of this. A standout example, however, is Louise and Ian's arrival at the base camp.



* SceneryPorn: Being a Denis Villeneuve movie, it naturally features quite a bit of this. A standout example, however, is Louise and Ian's arrival at the base camp.

Added: 547

Changed: 24

Removed: 529

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After Louise's daughter dies in the prologue, Louise is seen walking down a hallway that is clearly curving into a circle [[spoiler: indicating both the films ArcSymbol and the [[StableTimeLoop nature of the heptapods', and later her own, abilities]]]].



* {{Homage}}: The film includes a dream sequence in which Louise looks at something off-camera, and a cut reveals that it's an enormous heptapod that flexes its legs. This is a reference to the much more shocking last scene of Villeneuve's previous film ''Film/{{Enemy}}''.



* InternalHomage: The film includes a dream sequence in which Louise looks at something off-camera, and a cut reveals that it's an enormous heptapod that flexes its legs. This is a reference to the much more shocking last scene of Villeneuve's previous film ''Film/{{Enemy}}''.



* KuleshovEffect: The film received praise for its mastery of this film technique. [[spoiler: We ''assume'' that the scenes after we see Hannah die indicate that Louise is sleepwalking through life in a deep depression over her daughter's passing and trying to recover from it. However, our assumption turns out wrong.]]

to:

* KuleshovEffect: The film received praise for its mastery of this film technique. [[spoiler: We ''assume'' that the scenes after we see Hannah die indicate that Louise is sleepwalking through life in a deep depression over her daughter's passing and trying to recover from it. However, [[SequencingDeception our assumption turns out wrong.wrong]].]]


Added DiffLines:

* {{Symbolism}}: After Louise's daughter dies in the prologue, Louise is seen walking down a hallway that is clearly curving into a circle [[spoiler: indicating both the films ArcSymbol and the [[StableTimeLoop nature of the heptapods', and later her own, abilities]]]].

Added: 145

Changed: 1366

Removed: 145

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BookEnds: When Louise's daughter questions the reason for her name, "Hannah", Louise explains that her name is a palindrome, that is, it is spelled the same backwards as it is forward. This reflects the theme of the film in that [[spoiler: the story starts as it finishes, due to the story's events existing in a non-linear timeline. The opening few scenes of the film are simultaneously the beginning and the end, as is the case with the order of letters that make up Hannah's name.]]
-->'''Louise:''' I used to think this was the beginning of your story.
-->'''Louise:''' So, [[spoiler: Hannah]]...this is where your story begins.

to:

* BookEnds: When The movie opens and closes with the same shot panning down from the ceiling of the lakehouse with Max Richter's "On The Nature of Daylight" playing on the soundtrack. This can be seen as a temporal palindrome and echoes Louise's daughter questions the reason for her name, "Hannah", Louise explains that her name is a palindrome, that is, it is spelled the same backwards as it is forward. This reflects the theme of the film in that [[spoiler: the story starts as it finishes, due ability to the story's events existing perceive memories in a non-linear timeline. The opening few scenes of the film are simultaneously the beginning and the end, as is the case with the order of letters that make up Hannah's name.]]
-->'''Louise:''' I used to think this was the beginning of your story.
-->'''Louise:''' So, [[spoiler: Hannah]]...this is where your story begins.
way.



* MeaningfulName: [[spoiler: Louise names her daughter Hannah because it's spelled as a palindrome. The choice of having it be a palindrome echoes Louise's ability to perceive memories of her daughter before experiencing their events. The film's prologue can also be interpreted as a temporal palindrome as it's the story of Hannah's existence and is book-ended with the same circumstances; Hannah's life begins and ends in a hospital bed where her mother reaches to embrace her and tells her to "Come back to me."]]

to:

* MeaningfulName: [[spoiler: Louise names her daughter Hannah because it's spelled as a palindrome. The choice of having it be a palindrome echoes When Louise's ability to perceive memories of her daughter before experiencing their events. The film's prologue can also be interpreted questions the reason for her name, "Hannah", Louise explains that her name is a palindrome, that is, it is spelled the same backwards as a temporal palindrome as it's it is forward. This reflects the theme of the film in that [[spoiler: the story starts as it finishes, due to the story's events existing in a non-linear timeline. The opening few scenes of the film are simultaneously the beginning and the end, as is the case with the order of letters that make up Hannah's existence and is book-ended with name.]]
-->'''Louise:''' I used to think this was
the same circumstances; Hannah's life begins and ends in a hospital bed beginning of your story.
-->'''Louise:''' So, [[spoiler: Hannah]]...this is
where her mother reaches to embrace her and tells her to "Come back to me."]]your story begins.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
checked the scene, the person shot was a scientist, not the one recording the msg


* LethallyExpensive: They play a voice recording from a secure Russian channel which we have to assume was paid for with the life of the person relaying it, judging by the machine-gun fire at the end of the transmission.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moving to ymmv


* SpiritualSuccessor: In many ways to ''Film/CloseEncountersOfTheThirdKind'' and ''Film/{{Contact}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooDesperateToBePicky: Col. Weber acknowledges that there are probably better suited linguists in America but Louise is an expert, already has top secret security clearance from doing some translating for military intelligence, and the government needs to get to work too quickly to clear someone else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TooDesperateToBePicky: Col. Weber acknowledges that there are probably better linguists in America but Louise already has top secret security clearance from doing some translating for military intelligence and the government needs to get to work too quickly to clear someone else.

to:

* TooDesperateToBePicky: Col. Weber acknowledges that there are probably better suited linguists in America but Louise is an expert, already has top secret security clearance from doing some translating for military intelligence intelligence, and the government needs to get to work too quickly to clear someone else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TooDesperateToBePicky: Col. Weber acknowledges that there are probably better linguists in America but Louise already has top secret security clearance from doing some translating for military intelligence and the government needs to get to work too quickly to clear someone else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: [[spoiler: All the other ships that landed on Earth, the Chinese plot and the events after the aliens' departure are expanded.]]

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: [[spoiler: All Details on the other ships that landed on Earth, Earth are included, antagonism against the aliens among some members of the American and Chinese plot military are introduced, and the reasons for the aliens' arrival and the events after the aliens' their departure are expanded.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


They discover the ship is inhabited by two cephalopod-like "heptapods" (after their seven limbs), who communicate by forming ink into complex circular symbols. As Louise and the heptapods slowly learn each other's languages, a geopolitical drama plays out in the background as competing governments attempt to discover the aliens' purpose.

to:

They discover the ship is inhabited by two cephalopod-like "heptapods" (after (named after their seven limbs), who communicate by forming ink into complex circular symbols. As Louise and the heptapods slowly learn each other's languages, a geopolitical drama plays out in the background as competing governments attempt to discover the aliens' purpose.

Top