Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Amistad

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Martin Van Buren didn't campaign actively for re-election, let alone from the back of a train, as it was considered ungentlemanly for people to actively seek the presidency until near the end of the 19th century.[[note]](Ironically, Van Buren's rival at that year's election, UsefulNotes/WilliamHenryHarrison '''did''' do some actual campaigning for the presidency, though even then it was to a far more limited extent than what a modern-day candidate would do.)[[/note]]

to:

** Martin Van Buren didn't campaign actively for re-election, let alone from the back of a train, as it was considered ungentlemanly for people to actively seek the presidency until near the end of the 19th century.[[note]](Ironically, [[note]]Ironically, Van Buren's rival at that year's election, UsefulNotes/WilliamHenryHarrison UsefulNotes/WilliamHenryHarrison, '''did''' do some actual campaigning for the presidency, though even then it was to a far more limited extent than what a modern-day candidate would do.)[[/note]][[/note]]



* BittersweetEnding: Adams wins the case and Cinque and the other Africans are freed and return to Africa. The ending texts reveals Cinque's family was probably carried off into slavery, his people were in a civil war, and the one which Americans were dreading the case would lead to finally consumed them.

to:

* BittersweetEnding: Adams wins the case and Cinque and the other Africans are freed and return to Africa. The ending texts reveals reveal Cinque's family was probably carried off into slavery, his people were in a civil war, and the one which Americans were dreading the case would lead to finally consumed them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VehicleTitle: The
* WhamLine

to:

* VehicleTitle: The
Technically the ship's name is prefaced with either "La" (in its original Spanish) or "The" (in the various U.S. court documents), but it otherwise fits this trope like you'd expect. The ship's logo is also used as the film's title card.
* WhamLineWhamLine:

Added: 287

Changed: 103

Removed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoHistoricalFiguresWereHarmed: Theodore Joadson, the black abolitionist played by Creator/MorganFreeman, did not exist. It's thought that Joadson is essentially a composite character made up of several real-life black abolitionists, though likely based primarily on Frederick Douglass.



* TokenMinority: Theodore Joadson, the black abolitionist played by Creator/MorganFreeman, did not exist.
* VehicleTitle

to:

* TokenMinority: Theodore Joadson, the black abolitionist played by Creator/MorganFreeman, did not exist.
* VehicleTitle
VehicleTitle: The

Added: 1226

Removed: 222

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory:
** Martin Van Buren didn't campaign actively for re-election, let alone from the back of a train, as it was considered ungentlemanly for people to actively seek the presidency until near the end of the 19th century.[[note]](Ironically, Van Buren's rival at that year's election, UsefulNotes/WilliamHenryHarrison '''did''' do some actual campaigning for the presidency, though even then it was to a far more limited extent than what a modern-day candidate would do.)[[/note]]
** The initial hearing ends with the U.S. Navy officers having their salvage claim thrown out, and the two surviving ''Amistad'' crewmembers being arrested for slave trading. In reality, the navy officers did get awarded a third of the remaining salvage aboard the ship -- which was admittedly more a gesture than anything else, as said salvage value was close to zero once you took out the slaves and perishable goods on-board -- and the surviving crewmembers were actually arrested ''before'' the case was heard; they subsequently posted bail, returned to Cuba, and the charges against them were quietly dropped on the understanding that they'd really get the book thrown at them if they were ever caught slave trading again.



* HollywoodHistory: Presidential candidates didn't campaign for votes at the time (it was considered highly unseemly), let alone from the backs of trains, and some aspects of the court case are altered for dramatic effect.

Added: 355

Changed: 446

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** President Martin Van Buren, though the film does show that he's effectively being blackmailed by John C. Calhoun into going to the lengths that he does.
** Lewis Tappan as well. After the appeal, Tappan says the Amistad Africans may be better off as martyrs, after which Joadson admonishes him as not caring about the slaves, but only about ending slavery. The real Tappan was famously known as an uncompromising anti-slavery extremist, who supported full legal rights (including gun ownership and voting) and advocated mass intermarriage to create a country without prejudice.

to:

** Zig-zagged with President Martin Van Buren, though Buren. On the film does show that he's effectively being blackmailed one hand, the real Van Buren didn't try to rig the initial court case by swapping out the judge, as this film's version does. On the other hand, in real-life Van Buren intended from the start to take the case all the way to the Supreme Court if need be, whereas the film's version is prepared to let the matter drop after the initial case, until John C. Calhoun into going to threatens him with dire consequences unless the lengths that he does.
ruling is overturned.
** Lewis Tappan as well.Tappan. After the appeal, Tappan says the Amistad Africans may be better off as martyrs, after which Joadson admonishes him as not caring about the slaves, but only about ending slavery. The real Tappan was famously known as an uncompromising anti-slavery extremist, who supported full legal rights (including gun ownership and voting) and advocated mass intermarriage to create a country without prejudice.prejudice.
** Professor Willard Gibbs in the film is depicted as an incompetent hack whose inept attempts to communicate with the slaves just end up making the situation even worse, and force Joadson to step in and come up with an actual way of finding an interpreter. The real Gibbs was actually the person who came up with the method that Joadson uses in the film.
Willbyr MOD

Added: 216

Changed: 326

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:250:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/1201867_2630.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:250:https://static.%% Image selected per Image Pickin' thread: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=1560004501093599300
%% Please do not replace or remove without starting a new thread.
%%
[[quoteright:350:https://static.
tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/1201867_2630.org/pmwiki/pub/images/amistad01.jpg]]






* AnachronismStew: {{Gustave Dore}}'s illustrated Bible is shown, but Doré was only 9 in 1841 and his Bible wouldn't be published until 1866.
* AntiVillain: It's shown in a couple of scenes that Van Buren's biggest fear was [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar civil war.]] Yes, he's worried about his own re-election campaign, but he's even more worried about keeping the peace.

to:

* AnachronismStew: {{Gustave Dore}}'s Creator/GustaveDore's illustrated Bible is shown, but Doré was only 9 in 1841 and his Bible wouldn't be published until 1866.
* AntiVillain: It's shown in a couple of scenes that Van Buren's biggest fear was [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar civil war.]] war]]. Yes, he's worried about his own re-election campaign, but he's even more worried about keeping the peace.



* EtTuBrute: Cinque, the village chief, is sold to slavers by his own people (and possibly his wife). TruthInTelevision-most African slaves were sold to Europeans by other Africans, sometimes even their own people.

to:

* EtTuBrute: Cinque, the village chief, is sold to slavers by his own people (and possibly his wife). TruthInTelevision-most TruthInTelevision--most African slaves were sold to Europeans by other Africans, sometimes even their own people.



* IronicName: Amistad (the ship's name) means Friendship in Spanish.

to:

* IronicName: Amistad (the ship's name) means Friendship "friendship" in Spanish.



* MadeASlave: After surviving the Middle Passage, several Africans aboard the ''La Amistad'' are taken ashore to be sold off at an auction in Cuba.

to:

* MadeASlave: MadeASlave:
**
After surviving the Middle Passage, several Africans aboard the ''La Amistad'' are taken ashore to be sold off at an auction in Cuba.


Added DiffLines:

Added: 558

Removed: 564

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BondOneLiner / QuipToBlack: British navy captain Fitzgerald attempts to corroborate Cinque's testimony about a slave fortress in Sierra Leone, but Forsyth's lawyer counters that since they've never found it, it may not even exist. In the film's epilogue, the Royal Navy finally locates the fortress and blasts it into rubble, prompting Fitzgerald to start dictating a letter to Forsyth:
--> '''Fitzgerald:''' My dear Mr. Forsyth, it is my great pleasure to inform you that you are, in fact, correct. The slave fortress in Sierra Leone... ''does not exist.''



* PostMortemOneLiner / QuipToBlack: British navy captain Fitzgerald attempts to corroborate Cinque's testimony about a slave fortress in Sierra Leone, but Forsyth's lawyer counters that since they've never found it, it may not even exist. In the film's epilogue, the Royal Navy finally locates the fortress and blasts it into rubble, prompting Fitzgerald to start dictating a letter to Forsyth:
--> '''Fitzgerald:''' My dear Mr. Forsyth, it is my great pleasure to inform you that you are, in fact, correct. The slave fortress in Sierra Leone... ''does not exist.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This had the first major film role for Creator/DjimonHounsou as Cinque, the leader of the slaves. It was also the second film for which Creator/AnthonyHopkins received an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward nomination for playing a U.S. president, having previously been nominated in 1995 for playing UsefulNotes/RichardNixon in ''Film/{{Nixon}}''.

to:

This had the first major film role for Creator/DjimonHounsou as Joseph Cinque, the leader of the slaves. It was also the second film for which Creator/AnthonyHopkins received an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward nomination for playing a U.S. president, having previously been nominated in 1995 for playing UsefulNotes/RichardNixon in ''Film/{{Nixon}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InsultFriendlyFire: Hammond, unimpressed with John Quincy Adams, scoffs "Is there anything more pathetic than an ex-president?" He is unaware that President Van Buren (currently in the middle of a losing re-election campaign) [[RightBehindMe had entered the room behind him]]. Van Buren leaves the room with an unimpressed expression while Hammond stammers out an explanation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*KnightInSourArmor: Captain Fitzgerald's experience with the slave trade has not made him very congenial.

Changed: 158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PostMortemOneLiner / QuipToBlack: British navy captain Fitzgerald attempts to corroborate Cinque's testimony about a slave fortress in Sierra Leone, but Forsyth's lawyer counters that since they've never found it, it may not even exist. In the film's epilogue, the Royal Navy finally locates the fortress and blasts it into rubble.
--> '''Fitzgerald:''' Take a letter, Ensign. "To His Honor, the United States Secretary of State, Mr. John Forsyth. My dear Mr. Forsyth, it is my great pleasure to inform you that you are, in fact, correct. The slave fortress in Sierra Leone... ''does not exist.''"

to:

* PostMortemOneLiner / QuipToBlack: British navy captain Fitzgerald attempts to corroborate Cinque's testimony about a slave fortress in Sierra Leone, but Forsyth's lawyer counters that since they've never found it, it may not even exist. In the film's epilogue, the Royal Navy finally locates the fortress and blasts it into rubble.
rubble, prompting Fitzgerald to start dictating a letter to Forsyth:
--> '''Fitzgerald:''' Take a letter, Ensign. "To His Honor, the United States Secretary of State, Mr. John Forsyth. My dear Mr. Forsyth, it is my great pleasure to inform you that you are, in fact, correct. The slave fortress in Sierra Leone... ''does not exist.''"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PostMortemOneLiner / QuipToBlack: British navy captain Fitzgerald attempts to corroborate Cinque's testimony about a slave fortress in Sierra Leone, but Forsyth's lawyer counters that since they've never found it, it may not even exist. In the film's epilogue, the Royal Navy finally locates the fortress and blasts it into rubble.
--> '''Fitzgerald:''' Take a letter, Ensign. "To His Honor, the United States Secretary of State, Mr. John Forsyth. My dear Mr. Forsyth, it is my great pleasure to inform you that you are, in fact, correct. The slave fortress in Sierra Leone... ''does not exist.''"

Added: 95

Removed: 112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathOfAChild: A girl drowns herself with a baby in her arms during the Middle Passage scene.



* InfantImmortality: {{Averted}}. A girl drowns herself with a baby in her arms during the Middle Passage scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The District Attorney notes that the Mende also own slaves, and have for centuries, as a means of countering the arguments made against slavery. John Covey, the translator, points out Mende "slaves" were more like [[IndenturedServitude indentured servants]], but in any case this is irrelevant with regards to the law. It amounts to a [[AdHominem tu quoque]] aimed against anti-slavery sentiment.

to:

** The District Attorney notes that the Mende also own slaves, and have for centuries, as a means of countering the arguments made against slavery. John James Covey, the translator, interpreter and a former slave himself, points out Mende "slaves" were more like [[IndenturedServitude indentured servants]], but in any case this is irrelevant with regards to the law. It amounts to a [[AdHominem tu quoque]] aimed against anti-slavery sentiment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This was the first major film role for Creator/DjimonHounsou as Cinque, the leader of the slaves. It was also the second film for which Creator/AnthonyHopkins received an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward nomination for playing a U.S. president, having previously been nominated in 1995 for playing UsefulNotes/RichardNixon in ''Film/{{Nixon}}''.

to:

This was had the first major film role for Creator/DjimonHounsou as Cinque, the leader of the slaves. It was also the second film for which Creator/AnthonyHopkins received an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward nomination for playing a U.S. president, having previously been nominated in 1995 for playing UsefulNotes/RichardNixon in ''Film/{{Nixon}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This was the second film for which Creator/AnthonyHopkins received an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward nomination for playing a U.S. president, having previously been nominated in 1995 for playing UsefulNotes/RichardNixon in ''Film/{{Nixon}}''.

to:

This was the first major film role for Creator/DjimonHounsou as Cinque, the leader of the slaves. It was also the second film for which Creator/AnthonyHopkins received an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward nomination for playing a U.S. president, having previously been nominated in 1995 for playing UsefulNotes/RichardNixon in ''Film/{{Nixon}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuctionOfEvil: Before Cinque leads the uprising against the ship's crew, ''La Amistad'' docks in Cuba where several of the captive Africans are sold off to local owners.


Added DiffLines:

* MadeASlave: After surviving the Middle Passage, several Africans aboard the ''La Amistad'' are taken ashore to be sold off at an auction in Cuba.
** At the end of the film [[spoiler: it is revealed that although Cinque returns home, his family was probably captured and sold into the New World.]]

Added: 696

Changed: 422

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NotSoDifferent: The District Attorney notes that the Mende also own slaves, and have for centuries, as a means of countering the arguments made against slavery. John Covey, the translator, points out Mende "slaves" were more like [[IndenturedServitude indentured servants]], but in any case this is irrelevant with regards to the law. It amounts to a [[AdHominem tu quoque]] aimed against anti-slavery sentiment in favor of the Africans.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferent:
**
The District Attorney notes that the Mende also own slaves, and have for centuries, as a means of countering the arguments made against slavery. John Covey, the translator, points out Mende "slaves" were more like [[IndenturedServitude indentured servants]], but in any case this is irrelevant with regards to the law. It amounts to a [[AdHominem tu quoque]] aimed against anti-slavery sentiment in favor sentiment.
** The Mende note a lot
of similarity between the Africans.Jewish customs shown in the illustrated Bible which American missionaries gave them and their own, including wrapping the body for burial inside a tomb. This may be because they're Muslim, and Islamic funeral rites are similar to those in Judaism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronismStew: {{Creator/GustaveDore}}'s illustrated Bible is shown, but Doré was only 9 in 1841 and his Bible wouldn't be published until 1866.

to:

* AnachronismStew: {{Creator/GustaveDore}}'s {{Gustave Dore}}'s illustrated Bible is shown, but Doré was only 9 in 1841 and his Bible wouldn't be published until 1866.

Added: 155

Changed: 152

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: President Martin Van Buren, though the film does show that he's effectively being blackmailed by John C. Calhoun into going to the lengths that he does.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
President Martin Van Buren, though the film does show that he's effectively being blackmailed by John C. Calhoun into going to the lengths that he does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NotSoDifferent: The District Attorney notes that the Mende also own slaves, and have for centuries, as a means of countering the arguments made against slavery. John Covey, the translator, points out Mende slaves were more like indentured servants, but in any case this is irrelevant with regards to the law. It amounts to a [[AdHominem tu quoque]] aimed against anti-slavery sentiment in favor of the Africans.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: The District Attorney notes that the Mende also own slaves, and have for centuries, as a means of countering the arguments made against slavery. John Covey, the translator, points out Mende slaves "slaves" were more like [[IndenturedServitude indentured servants, servants]], but in any case this is irrelevant with regards to the law. It amounts to a [[AdHominem tu quoque]] aimed against anti-slavery sentiment in favor of the Africans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotSoDifferent: The District Attorney notes that the Mende also own slaves, and have for centuries, as a means of countering the arguments made against slavery. John Covey, the translator, points out Mende slaves were more like indentured servants, but in any case this is irrelevant with regards to the law. It amounts to a [[AdHominem tu quoque]] aimed against anti-slavery sentiment in favor of the Africans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Amistad'' is a 1997 Creator/StevenSpielberg film based on the true story of a slave mutiny that took place aboard a ship of the same name in 1839, and the legal battle that followed. It shows how, even though the case was won at the federal district court level, it was appealed by President UsefulNotes/MartinVanBuren to the Supreme Court, and how former President UsefulNotes/JohnQuincyAdams took part in the proceedings.

to:

''Amistad'' is a 1997 Creator/StevenSpielberg film based on the true story of a slave mutiny that revolt which took place aboard a ship of the same name in 1839, and the legal battle that followed. It shows how, even though the case was won at the federal district court level, it was appealed by President UsefulNotes/MartinVanBuren to the Supreme Court, and how former President UsefulNotes/JohnQuincyAdams took part in the proceedings.



* AnachronismStew: Creator/GustaveDore 's illustrated Bible is shown, but Doré was only 9 in 1841 and his Bible wouldn't be published until 1866.

to:

* AnachronismStew: Creator/GustaveDore 's {{Creator/GustaveDore}}'s illustrated Bible is shown, but Doré was only 9 in 1841 and his Bible wouldn't be published until 1866.



* BittersweetEnding: Adams wins the case and Cinque and the other Africans are freed and return to Africa. The ending texts reveals Cinque's family were probably carried off into slavery, his people were in a civil war, and the one which Americans were dreading the case would lead to finally consumed them.

to:

* BittersweetEnding: Adams wins the case and Cinque and the other Africans are freed and return to Africa. The ending texts reveals Cinque's family were was probably carried off into slavery, his people were in a civil war, and the one which Americans were dreading the case would lead to finally consumed them.



* TheDogBitesBack: The slaves rise up and kill the slavers.
* DrivenToSuicide: During the Middle Passage sequence, a slave girl dives off from the ship with a baby in her arms, preferring death than endure suffering aboard at the slavers' hands.

to:

* TheDogBitesBack: The slaves rise up and kill the slavers.
slavers (except for two to steer the ship).
* DrivenToSuicide: During the Middle Passage sequence, a slave girl dives off from the ship with a baby in her arms, preferring death than to endure suffering aboard at the slavers' hands.



** Lewis Tappan as well. After the appeal, Tappan says the Amistad Africans may be better off as martyrs, after which Joadson admonishes him as not caring about the slaves, but only about ending slavery. The real Tappan was famously known as an uncompromising anti-slavery extremist, who supported full rights (including gun ownership and voting) and advocated mass intermarriage to create a country without prejudice.

to:

** Lewis Tappan as well. After the appeal, Tappan says the Amistad Africans may be better off as martyrs, after which Joadson admonishes him as not caring about the slaves, but only about ending slavery. The real Tappan was famously known as an uncompromising anti-slavery extremist, who supported full legal rights (including gun ownership and voting) and advocated mass intermarriage to create a country without prejudice.



* InfantImmortality: Averted. A girl drowns herself with a baby in her arms during the Middle Passage scene.

to:

* InfantImmortality: Averted.{{Averted}}. A girl drowns herself with a baby in her arms during the Middle Passage scene.



* ItWillNeverCatchOn: Adams' first appearance is during a session of the House to determine whether or not to honor an old man's request that his possessions form an institute of national treasure. The representative addressing Adams dismisses the collection as "bunch of junk". The old man? James Smithson, founding donor of the Smithsonian Institution.

to:

* ItWillNeverCatchOn: Adams' first appearance is during a session of the House to determine whether or not to honor an old man's request that his possessions form an institute of national treasure. The representative addressing Adams dismisses the collection as a "bunch of junk". The old man? James Smithson, founding donor of the Smithsonian Institution.



* RoyalBrat: 10-years old Queen Isabel II of Spain (the fact that her mother was regent and the actual head of state at the time is omitted under the RuleOfFunny).

to:

* RoyalBrat: 10-years 10 year old Queen Isabel II of Spain (the fact that her mother was regent and the actual head of state at the time is omitted under the RuleOfFunny).



* TheStoic: Captain Fitzgerald. In a really awesome badass way.

to:

* TheStoic: Captain Fitzgerald. In Fitzgerald, in a really awesome badass way.

Added: 97

Removed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DaylightHorror: The scene where slaves are tossed overboard to drown during the Middle Passage.



* DaylightHorror: The scene where the slaves are tossed overboard to drown during the middle passage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SlaveLiberation: The Destruction of the Lomboko fortress.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: The revolt on the Amistad in the beginning of the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HorrorInBroadDaylight: The scene where the slaves are tossed overboard to drown during the middle passage.

to:

* HorrorInBroadDaylight: DaylightHorror: The scene where the slaves are tossed overboard to drown during the middle passage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HorrorInBroadDaylight: The scene where the slaves are tossed overboard to drown during the middle passage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSpock: Captain Fitzgerald

to:

* TheSpock: TheStoic: Captain FitzgeraldFitzgerald. In a really awesome badass way.

Added: 30

Removed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadpanSnarker: Captain Fitzgerald has great moments both on the witness stand and after coolly supervising the destruction of the Lomboko slave fortress.


Added DiffLines:

* TheSpock: Captain Fitzgerald

Top