Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / AdAstra

Go To

OR

Added: 860

Removed: 878

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking, Misplaced, moving to the correct tab


* SciFiWritersHaveNoSenseOfScale:
** Roy has to cross Neptune's rings from one spaceship to another. The first time he did this in a pod, but the pod tumbled away, so he has to use his feet to push off from one spaceship and get to the other, while using a piece of hull plating as a shield. Ignoring the sheer improbability of him actually hitting his mark, the rings of Neptune are at least several kilometers thick, which would make it impossible for him to make it across in under a minute just by pushing off with his feet.
** [[spoiler:Clifford claims that he spent years scanning the galaxy for other life forms and found nothing. The conclusion is that humans are alone in the universe. Except he's been parked near Neptune all this time. That's like sitting on your patio and looking around for any elephants, then deciding that elephants don't exist.]]



* SpiritualSuccessor: To Gray's ''Film/TheLostCityOfZ''. Both films are character studies about explorers venturing out into the great unknown in search of another world that face mortal dangers, strained relationships with family, fathers and sons reflecting the desires of the need to know more life out there, and marvelously [[SceneryPorn well done visuals]]. But where the two differ is in perspective and origin: ''Z'' was BasedOnATrueStory of the real life Percy Fawcett whereas ''Ad Astra'' was an original idea Gray had cooking in his noggin since 2011. On top of that, whereas ''Z'' was about a father searching for unknown civilizations and then having his son almost inheriting that desire, ''Ad Astra'' is about a father [[spoiler: who becomes a lunatic and the son, who is a fellow explorer, is terrified of becoming his dad due the actions his father committed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* GoMadFromTheIsolation: Touched upon with Roy who admits he once thought he'd enjoy not having people around and now can feel himself losing his grip on reality during his 79 day solo voyage between Mars and Neptune. [[spoiler: Turns out this has already happened to his father.]]

to:

* GoMadFromTheIsolation: Touched upon with Roy who admits he once thought he'd enjoy not having people around and now can feel himself losing his grip on reality during his 79 day 79-day solo voyage between Mars and Neptune. [[spoiler: Turns out this has already happened to his father.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheAntiNihilist: [[spoiler: In the absence of finding other intelligence life in the universe, Roy concludes "we're all we've got", and that is, by itself, a meaningful discovery.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor plot error


[[TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture In the near future]], the Solar System is struck by mysterious power surges of unknown origin, threatening the future of human life. After surviving an incident on an immense space antenna caused by one of these surges, Major Roy [=McBride=] is informed that the source of the surges has been traced to the "Lima Project" base, a space station orbiting Neptune where his father, Clifford, was stationed twenty-six years ago. And there's reason to believe that his father may still be alive. What follows is a race against time as he and Colonel Pruitt, an old friend of the senior [=McBride=], try to locate Roy's father and find out what exactly happened to the Lima Project.

to:

[[TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture In the near future]], the Solar System is struck by mysterious power surges of unknown origin, threatening the future of human life. After surviving an incident on an immense space antenna caused by one of these surges, Major Roy [=McBride=] is informed that the source of the surges has been traced to the "Lima Project" base, a space station orbiting Neptune where his father, Clifford, was stationed twenty-six twenty-nine years ago. And there's reason to believe that his father may still be alive. What follows is a race against time as he and Colonel Pruitt, an old friend of the senior [=McBride=], try to locate Roy's father and find out what exactly happened to the Lima Project.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SleeperShip: ''Cepheus'' is shown to have equipment to allow crew to spend parts of long trips in sedation. Roy fits himself with a feeding tube and applies electric muscle stimulators to his limbs before going under.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Helen Lantos has her career ruined and the remaining crew of the Cepheus died just because Roy McBride had to reconnect with his daddy. Had he obeyed the order to go back to Earth after finishing his mission on Mars, the Cepheus crew would have probably destroyed the Lima ship anyways. McBride's punishment? Back on Earth he also gets to reconnect with his estranged wife instead of being arrested.

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Helen Lantos has her career ruined and the remaining crew of the Cepheus died just because Roy McBride [=McBride=] had to reconnect with his daddy. Had he obeyed the order to go back to Earth after finishing his mission on Mars, the Cepheus crew would have probably destroyed the Lima ship anyways. McBride's [=McBride=]'s punishment? Back on Earth he also gets to reconnect with his estranged wife instead of being arrested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Helen Lantos has her career ruined and the remaining crew of the Cepheus died just because Roy McBride had to reconnect with his daddy. Had he obeyed the order to go back to Earth after finishing his mission on Mars, the Cepheus crew would have probably destroyed the Lima ship anyways. McBride's punishment? Back on Earth he also gets to reconnect with his estranged wife instead of being arrested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EasilyForgiven: After everything he's done, [[spoiler:viewers would expect Roy to be court-martialed at best, if not shot outright upon his return to Earth. The ending shows him at a coffee shop reconnecting with his wife, implying that he at least maintained his freedom. Successfully saving all life in the solar system may have given him some leeway]].

to:

* EasilyForgiven: After everything he's done, [[spoiler:viewers would expect Roy to be court-martialed at best, if not shot outright upon his return to Earth. The ending shows him at a coffee shop reconnecting with his wife, implying that he at least maintained his freedom. Successfully saving all life in the solar system may have given him some leeway]].leeway. Cynically, a court case against him might also open an investigation into things Space Comm wouldn't want coming out, giving them incentive not to pursue.]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CastingGag: [[Film/{{Armageddon}} Once again]], Creator/LivTyler plays the SatelliteLoveInterest of an astronaut who goes on a dangerous mission to save the world by detonating a nuclear warhead in space.

to:

* CastingGag: [[Film/{{Armageddon}} [[Film/Armageddon1998 Once again]], Creator/LivTyler plays the SatelliteLoveInterest of an astronaut who goes on a dangerous mission to save the world by detonating a nuclear warhead in space.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CasualInterplanetaryTravel: There are regular commercial flights from Earth to the colonised Moon, and then it's 19 days from the Moon to colonised Mars, and 79 days from Mars to Neptune.

to:

* CasualInterplanetaryTravel: There are regular commercial flights from Earth to the colonised Moon, and then it's Moon. It takes just 19 days from the Moon to colonised Mars, Mars and 79 days ''Cepheus'' takes a detour to investigate a distress signal without worrying about using up resources. It's a 79-day trip from Mars to Neptune.Neptune, which is definitely considered long range, but characters treat it without fanfare and Roy's presence is alarming because he's not authorized rather than an extra body who'll use up air, water, and food.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CastingGag: [[Film/{{Armageddon}} Once again]], Creator/LivTyler plays the SatelliteLoveInterest of an astronaut who goes on a dangerous mission to save the world by detonating a nuclear warhead in space.


Added DiffLines:

* SpaceIsNoisy: Largely {{averted}}. Most of the sounds heard in space have a muffled quality, as if they were vibrations transmitted through Roy's spacesuit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfitForGreatness: The ''Cepheus''' second captain [[spoiler:after the first one is killed by baboons]] expresses anxiety and cowardice from the very start that Roy picks up on immediately. This leads to [[spoiler:Roy having to take control of the ''Cepheus'' during a problematic landing on Mars due to the captain locking up in fear, but Roy afterwards promises not to report the incident to [=SpaceCom=].]]

to:

* UnfitForGreatness: The ''Cepheus''' ''Cepheus'''s second captain [[spoiler:after the first one is killed by baboons]] expresses anxiety and cowardice from the very start that Roy picks up on immediately. This leads to [[spoiler:Roy having to take control of the ''Cepheus'' during a problematic landing on Mars due to the captain locking up in fear, but Roy afterwards promises not to report the incident to [=SpaceCom=].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItsAllAboutMe: Clifford was absolutely dead-set on discovering alien life in deep space, believing it to be his destiny, at the expense of his family [[spoiler:(who he admits he never cared for and didn't miss during his decades out in space). He even considered his crew to be completely expendable (and killed several when they mutinied against his fruitless search) so long as he completed his mission.]]

to:

* ItsAllAboutMe: Clifford was absolutely dead-set on discovering alien life in deep space, believing it to be his destiny, at the expense of his family [[spoiler:(who [[spoiler:(whom he admits he never cared for and didn't miss during his decades out in space). He even considered his crew to be completely expendable (and killed several when they mutinied against his fruitless search) so long as he completed his mission.]]mission]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: The opening credits scrawl specifically says the film takes place in the not so distant future. However an adult claims to be born on Mars, so the film is set several decades after Mars was colonized.

to:

* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: The opening credits scrawl specifically says the film takes place in the not so distant future. However an adult claims to be have been born on Mars, so the film is set several decades after Mars was colonized.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RecycledInSpace: The basic story is ''Film/ApocalypseNow'' in, well, space. Both feature a protagonist who must voyage beyond civilization to confront a man who seems to have gone insane and present a threat to his homeland. In both stories, the external voyage mirrors an internal journey of self-discovery.

to:

* RecycledInSpace: The basic story is ''Film/ApocalypseNow'' in, well, space. Both feature a protagonist who must voyage beyond civilization to confront a man who seems to have gone insane and present presents a threat to his homeland. In both stories, the external voyage mirrors an internal journey of self-discovery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A bit pedantic


* GratuitousLatin: Right in the title, which is Latin for "to the stars." The fact that nobody in the film ever travels further out than Neptune makes it a case of NeverTrustATitle. The phrase itself tends to show up a lot in [[PretentiousLatinMotto Pretentious Latin Mottos]], often as part of a longer phrase (''per aspera ad astra''), which is fitting for a show about astronauts facing hardships for the sake of exploration.

to:

* GratuitousLatin: Right in the title, which is Latin for "to the stars." The fact that nobody in the film ever travels further out than Neptune makes it a case of NeverTrustATitle. The phrase itself tends to show up a lot in [[PretentiousLatinMotto Pretentious Latin Mottos]], often as part of a longer phrase (''per aspera ad astra''), which is fitting for a show about astronauts facing hardships for the sake of exploration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Their [[AsteroidThicket particle density]] is likely exaggerated too, as well as the particles' size, with data suggesting that most of their mass be micrometre-sized dust. However, data is very scarce on the subject, so this may simply be a case of pre-ScienceMarchesOn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


*** Similarly, the brawl aboard it also would have resulted in the fighters being PunchedAcrossTheRoom every time they dealt or received a blow.

to:

*** Similarly, the ** The brawl aboard it also would have resulted in the fighters being PunchedAcrossTheRoom every time they dealt or received a blow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreatOffScreenWar: When asked if he's seen combat, Roy cites "three years over the Arctic Circle." It's implied there's a SpaceColdWar going on [[NoBloodForPhlebotinum over resources]] with privateers being given safe haven by certain countries on the Moon.

to:

* GreatOffScreenWar: When asked if he's seen combat, Roy cites "three years over the Arctic Circle." It's implied there's a SpaceColdWar going on [[NoBloodForPhlebotinum over resources]] with privateers {{privateer}}s being given safe haven by certain countries on the Moon.

Changed: 29

Removed: 287

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Ad Astra'' is a 2019 [[HardScienceFiction aesthetically Hard Science Fiction]] SpaceOpera [[GenreBusting with a dash of action/adventure]] written and directed by James Gray with Ethan Gross attached as a cowriter. The film stars Creator/BradPitt as Major Roy [=McBride=], Creator/TommyLeeJones as H. Clifford [=McBride=], Creator/LivTyler as Eve [=McBride=], Creator/RuthNegga as Helen Lantos, and Creator/DonaldSutherland as Colonel Pruitt.

to:

''Ad Astra'' is a 2019 [[HardScienceFiction aesthetically Hard Science Fiction]] hard science fiction SpaceOpera [[GenreBusting with a dash of action/adventure]] written and directed by James Gray with Ethan Gross attached as a cowriter. The film stars Creator/BradPitt as Major Roy [=McBride=], Creator/TommyLeeJones as H. Clifford [=McBride=], Creator/LivTyler as Eve [=McBride=], Creator/RuthNegga as Helen Lantos, and Creator/DonaldSutherland as Colonel Pruitt.



* MohsScaleOfScienceFictionHardness: Initially very hard but progressively softer as the film goes on. ''Ad Astra'' clearly tries to be as realistic as possible, but ultimately takes too many [[ArtisticLicensePhysics liberties with the laws of physics]] to be considered real hard scifi.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rings_of_Neptune#General_properties rings of Neptune]] are depicted a rather bright blue in the film. In real life, they are extremely thin, dark, and a very, very slight reddish hue.
*** Their [[AsteroidThicket particle density]] is likely exaggerated too, as well as the particles' size, with data suggesting that most of their mass be micrometre-sized dust. However, data is very scarce on the subject, so this may simply be a case of pre-ScienceMarchesOn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OldSoldier: Roy is a 55-year old major, and Pruitt is a 84-year old colonel.

Added: 341

Removed: 345

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Merged per TRS


* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy: The Norwegian research station that Roy investigates on his way to Mars is stated to be orbiting an asteroid. There are no asteroids in stable orbits between Earth and Mars (the asteroid belt is further out, between Mars and Jupiter), and there's no reason to tow one there just to have a space station zip around it.


Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseSpace: The Norwegian research station that Roy investigates on his way to Mars is stated to be orbiting an asteroid. There are no asteroids in stable orbits between Earth and Mars (the asteroid belt is further out, between Mars and Jupiter), and there's no reason to tow one there just to have a space station zip around it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ad_astra_ver2.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''"The world awaits our discovery, my son."'']]

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ad_astra_ver2.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:''"The
org/pmwiki/pub/images/2feaab58_ccfe_4061_991c_374ed0fdf08f.jpeg]]
[[caption-width-right:350: ''"The
world awaits our discovery, my son."'']]"'']]

Added: 215

Changed: 99

Removed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ColorContrast:
** Roy and Helen wear contrasting colors in their scenes together -- he wears white, she wears black.
** At the Lima station, there are multiple shots contrasting blue and yellow lighting.

to:

* ColorContrast:
**
ColorContrast: Roy and Helen wear contrasting colors in their scenes together -- he wears white, she wears black.
** At the Lima station, there are multiple shots contrasting blue and yellow lighting.
black.


Added DiffLines:

* OrangeBlueContrast: At the Lima station, there are multiple shots contrasting blue and yellow lighting. In at least one scene, this contrasts the coldness and isolation of space with humanity and human connection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExplosiveDecompression: Roy opens an airlock to dispatch [[spoiler: the killer primates.]] It results in LudicrousGibs.

to:

* ExplosiveDecompression: Roy opens an airlock to dispatch [[spoiler: the killer primates.]] primates]]. It results in LudicrousGibs.

Changed: 30

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExplosiveDecompression: Employed by Roy to dispatch [[spoiler: the killer primates.]] It results in LudicrousGibs.

to:

* ExplosiveDecompression: Employed by Roy opens an airlock to dispatch [[spoiler: the killer primates.]] It results in LudicrousGibs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film premiered at the Venice Film Festival on August 29th, 2019 before enjoying a wider release by Creator/{{Disney}} under the Creator/TwentiethCenturyFox banner on September 20th, 2019.

to:

The film premiered at the Venice Film Festival on August 29th, 2019 before enjoying a wider release by Creator/{{Disney}} under the Creator/TwentiethCenturyFox banner on September 20th, 2019.

Top