Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / ASeriousMan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* KafkaKomedy

to:

%%* KafkaKomedy* KafkaKomedy: Larry is a well-meaning, nebbish guy put through hell for laughs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Tale of the Goy's Teeth, which has no resolution. When pressed for a resolution, the teller casually dismisses it.

to:

** The Tale of the Goy's Teeth, which has no resolution. When pressed for a resolution, the teller casually dismisses it. The point of the story was that sometimes things just happen for no reason, and we have to accept that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''A Serious Man'' is a 2009 BlackComedy/drama film conceived by Creator/TheCoenBrothers, depicting [[HumiliationConga a few crazy days]] in the life of a midwestern physics professor, Larry Gopnik.

to:

''A Serious Man'' is a 2009 BlackComedy/drama [[DarkComedy dark comedy-drama]] film conceived by Creator/TheCoenBrothers, depicting [[HumiliationConga a few crazy days]] in the life of a midwestern physics professor, Larry Gopnik.Gopnik (Creator/MichaelStuhlbarg).

Added: 701

Removed: 618

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurZombiesAreDifferent: The opening scene is framed as a Jewish/Yiddish parable in which a married couple host an old man who is actually meant to be a dybbuk in disguise. In Jewish mythology, a dybbuk is a malicious spirit stemming from the disembodied soul of a dead person; something of a cross between a zombie and a demonic possession. The dybbuk we are shown doesn’t physically appear supernatural in the least (he even bleeds after he is stabbed). The only noteworthy supernatural trait present is that he appears to be impervious to physical attacks, shrugging off a stab to the chest as if nothing happened.


Added DiffLines:

* OurZombiesAreDifferent: The opening scene shows us a Jewish/Yiddish parable in which a married couple host an old man who is actually a dybbuk in disguise. In Jewish mythology, a dybbuk is a malicious spirit stemming from the disembodied soul of a dead person; something of a cross between a zombie and a demonic possession. The dybbuk we are shown doesn’t physically appear supernatural in the least (he even bleeds after he is stabbed). The only noteworthy supernatural trait present is that he appears to be impervious to physical attacks, shrugging off a stab to the chest as if nothing happened. Realizing he’s not wanted, he leaves without further incident; pretty amicable for a zombie demon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OurZombiesAreDifferent: The opening scene is framed as a Jewish/Yiddish parable in which a married couple host an old man who is actually meant to be a dybbuk in disguise. In Jewish mythology, a dybbuk is a malicious spirit stemming from the disembodied soul of a dead person; something of a cross between a zombie and a demonic possession. The dybbuk we are shown doesn’t physically appear supernatural in the least (he even bleeds after he is stabbed). The only noteworthy supernatural trait present is that he appears to be impervious to physical attacks, shrugging off a stab to the chest as if nothing happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CosmicPlaything: Poor Larry can’t catch a break. He has to look after his socially inept brother, his wife wants to leave him, his kids are both self-centered beyond belief and he is forced to deal with a student bribing him for a passing grade. Then, when the film is about to end, [[spoiler: he is told in so many words that he may be deathly ill.]] The story hints that all of these tribulations may be God testing Larry, but it’s also possible that God is having a laugh at his expense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArcWords: "I didn't do anything."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: The North Dakota, a disreputable motel, may be a reference to the Coen Brothers' most critically acclaimed film, ''Film/{{Fargo}}'' (1996).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''A Serious Man'' is a 2009 film conceived by Creator/TheCoenBrothers, depicting [[HumiliationConga a few crazy days]] in the life of a midwestern physics professor, Larry Gopnik.

to:

''A Serious Man'' is a 2009 BlackComedy/drama film conceived by Creator/TheCoenBrothers, depicting [[HumiliationConga a few crazy days]] in the life of a midwestern physics professor, Larry Gopnik.



%%* BlackComedy

to:

%%* BlackComedy* BlackComedy: The film is about a man for whom things are going from bad to worse in all aspects of his life, who's trying to understand what he's being punished for or what any of this means, but gets no answer. Despite the grim premise, the film has all kinds of wacky characters and makes fun of the seeming absurdity and futility of the human condition. It says a lot that one of the big, unexpected laughs of the movie is a background character randomly having a heart attack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Larry's wife Judith astounds him with her announcement she intends to divorce him in favor of the more distinguished widower Sy Ableman; son Danny, whose Bar Mizvah approaches, smokes weed while he pretends to study; whiny daughter Sarah sneaks money from his wallet to save up for a nose job so she can look less Jewish. At the college, his student Clive Park attempts to bribe him for a passing grade -- [[{{Blackmail}} and Mr. Park threatens to sue him for defamation should he go public]]. He is [[ExiledToTheCouch kicked out of his own house]] and forced to live in a crummy motel with his sickly and eccentric brother Arthur. Oh, and someone's been writing anonymous letters to his university warning them not to grant Larry tenure. Can things get any worse?

to:

Larry's wife Judith astounds him with her announcement she intends to divorce him in favor of the more distinguished widower Sy Ableman; son Danny, whose Bar Mizvah approaches, smokes weed while he pretends to study; whiny daughter Sarah sneaks money from his wallet to save up for a nose job so she can look less Jewish. At the college, his student Clive Park attempts to bribe him for a passing grade -- [[{{Blackmail}} and Mr. Park threatens to sue him for defamation should he go public]].report it]]. He is [[ExiledToTheCouch kicked out of his own house]] and forced to live in a crummy motel with his sickly and eccentric brother Arthur. Oh, and someone's been writing anonymous letters to his university warning them not to grant Larry tenure. Can things get any worse?



* AsianAndNerdy: Clive, aiming for a scholarship, failed his physics exam because he ''didn't know it would have math'' and his father prefers to offer bribes to his teachers rather than to get his son to study harder.

to:

* AsianAndNerdy: Averted. Clive, aiming for a scholarship, failed his physics exam because he ''didn't know it would have math'' and his father prefers to offer bribes to his teachers rather than to get his son to study harder.harder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisproportionateRetribution: If you interpret the ending events as punishment, then [[spoiler:Larry is stricken with a fatal illness for raising a student's grade, and Danny is going to be run down by a tornado for listening to music in class]].

to:

* DisproportionateRetribution: If you interpret the ending events as punishment, then [[spoiler:Larry is might be stricken with a fatal illness for raising a student's grade, and Danny is going to might be run down by a tornado for listening to music in class]].

Added: 95

Changed: 289

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''A Serious Man'' is a 2009 film conceived by Creator/TheCoenBrothers, depicting [[HumiliationConga a few crazy days]] in the life of a midwestern physics professor, Larry Gopnik. InfoDump a-go-go:

to:

''A Serious Man'' is a 2009 film conceived by Creator/TheCoenBrothers, depicting [[HumiliationConga a few crazy days]] in the life of a midwestern physics professor, Larry Gopnik. InfoDump a-go-go:\n



%%* ButtMonkey: Larry.

to:

%%* * ButtMonkey: Larry.The plot entirely centers on Larry getting frustrated.



* PropertyLine: Larry is in a low-simmering dispute with his neighbor over their property line.



%%* ShaggyDogStory:
%%** The Tale of the Goy's Teeth. The teller doesn't seem to realize that it's an example.
%%** Arguably, [[spoiler:the whole movie, if not ShootTheShaggyDog]].

to:

%%* * ShaggyDogStory:
%%** ** The Tale of the Goy's Teeth. The Teeth, which has no resolution. When pressed for a resolution, the teller doesn't seem to realize that it's an example.
%%** Arguably, [[spoiler:the whole movie, if not ShootTheShaggyDog]].
casually dismisses it.
** The film itself has NoEnding and no resolution on any of its plot threads.

Added: 309

Changed: 1993

Removed: 677

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Zero Context Examples. Tropes can't be listed in pairs. Never ever hide a trope's name under a spoiler tag. Repair Dont Respond. Weblinks Are Not Examples. Fan Myopia in Trauma Conga Line.


* AdultFear: More like an encyclopedia of Adult Fears.

to:

* %%* AdultFear: More like an encyclopedia of Adult Fears.



* AsianAndNerdy[=/=][[EducationMama Education Papa]]: Both these Asian stereotypes are subverted; Clive, aiming for a scholarship, failed his physics exam because he ''didn't know it would have math'' and his father prefers to offer bribes to his teachers rather than to get his son to study harder.

to:

* AsianAndNerdy[=/=][[EducationMama Education Papa]]: Both these Asian stereotypes are subverted; AsianAndNerdy: Clive, aiming for a scholarship, failed his physics exam because he ''didn't know it would have math'' and his father prefers to offer bribes to his teachers rather than to get his son to study harder.



* BigWhat: Larry, three times in a row, upon learning that [[spoiler: Sy Ableman has died in a car crash]].

to:

* BigWhat: Larry, three times in a row, upon learning that [[spoiler: Sy [[spoiler:Sy Ableman has died in a car crash]].



* BitchInSheepsClothing: Although he is almost absurdly courteous to Larry's face, it is heavily implied that Sy Ableman [[spoiler: was the one writing the anonymous and defamatory letters to the tenure board about Larry]]
* BlackComedy[=/=]KafkaKomedy

to:

* BitchInSheepsClothing: Although he is almost absurdly courteous to Larry's face, it is heavily implied that Sy Ableman [[spoiler: was [[spoiler:was the one writing the anonymous and defamatory letters to the tenure board about Larry]]
* BlackComedy[=/=]KafkaKomedy%%* BlackComedy



* [[spoiler: BolivianArmyEnding]]

to:

* [[spoiler: BolivianArmyEnding]]%%* BolivianArmyEnding



* ButtMonkey: Larry.

to:

* %%* ButtMonkey: Larry.



* CloudCuckoolander: Arthur

to:

* %%* CloudCuckoolander: ArthurArthur.



* DeusAngstMachina: Larry is a modern-day Job; the misfortunes just keep piling up.

to:

* %%* DeusAngstMachina: Larry is a modern-day Job; the misfortunes just keep piling up.



* FemmeFatale: Mrs. Samsky [[spoiler: seems to be one ... but really isn't.]]

to:

* %%* FemmeFatale: Mrs. Samsky [[spoiler: seems [[spoiler:seems to be one ... but really isn't.]]



* GainaxEnding[=/=]NoEnding: [[spoiler: Larry accepts the bribe and is immediately called by his doctor to discuss some findings during an examination. Meanwhile, a tornado has touched down outside Danny's school]]. The film ends before we find out what happens next to them. Good luck determining what it means.



* KafkaKomedy

to:

* %%* KafkaKomedy



* MortonsFork: A student who has failed his exam leaves an envelope of money in Larry's office, as a bribe to get a passing grade. When Larry discusses the matter with the student's father, he realises that he has three equally unpleasant options that fit in well with the previously explained theme of UsefulNotes/SchrodingersCat.
** Accept the bribe.
** Give the money back to the student, in which case the father will sue Larry for slander (for accusing the student and his family of bribery).
** Keep the money and fail the student anyway, in which case the father will report him for theft.

to:

* MortonsFork: A student who has failed his exam leaves an envelope of money in Larry's office, as a bribe to get a passing grade. When Larry discusses the matter with the student's father, he realises that he has three equally unpleasant options that fit in well with the previously explained theme of UsefulNotes/SchrodingersCat.
** Accept
UsefulNotes/SchrodingersCat: (1) accept the bribe.
** Give
bribe, (2) give the money back to the student, in which case the father will sue Larry for slander (for accusing the student and his family of bribery).
** Keep
bribery), or (3) keep the money and fail the student anyway, in which case the father will report him for theft.



* NeverTrustATrailer:
** Averted. [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7iggyFPls4w The trailer is an incredible work of art in its own right.]]
** TrailersAlwaysSpoil: However, it does spoil that [[spoiler:Larry never gets to meet the old rabbi.]]

to:

* NeverTrustATrailer:
** Averted.
TrailersAlwaysSpoil: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7iggyFPls4w The trailer is an incredible work of art in its own right.]]
** TrailersAlwaysSpoil: However, it does spoil
trailer]] spoils that [[spoiler:Larry never gets to meet the old rabbi.]]rabbi]].
* NoEnding: [[spoiler:Larry accepts the bribe and is immediately called by his doctor to discuss some findings during an examination. Meanwhile, a tornado has touched down outside Danny's school]]. The film ends before we find out what happens next to them. Good luck determining what it means.



* RomanticFalseLead: Sy.
* RuleOfThree: [[http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1019452/board/nest/168165555?p=1#168170037 Examined here.]]

to:

* %%* RomanticFalseLead: Sy.
* %%* RuleOfThree: [[http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1019452/board/nest/168165555?p=1#168170037 Examined here.]]



* ShaggyDogStory:
** The Tale of the Goy's Teeth. The teller doesn't seem to realize that it's an example.
** Arguably, [[spoiler:the whole movie, if not ShootTheShaggyDog]].
* ShoutOut: To Literature/TheBible, obviously.

to:

* %%* ShaggyDogStory:
** %%** The Tale of the Goy's Teeth. The teller doesn't seem to realize that it's an example.
** %%** Arguably, [[spoiler:the whole movie, if not ShootTheShaggyDog]].
* ShoutOut: To Literature/TheBible, obviously. ShoutOut:



* TheSixties: The story is set in 1967.
** Although both of the main selections mentioned by the Columbia Record Club employee were released in [[TheSeventies 1970]].

to:

%% ** To Literature/TheBible.
* TheSixties: The story is set in 1967.
** Although
1967, although both of the main selections mentioned by the Columbia Record Club employee were released in [[TheSeventies 1970]].



* TraumaCongaLine: This is a [[Creator/TheCoenBrothers Coen Brothers film]], so expect this to be done to absurd levels.

to:

* TraumaCongaLine: This is a [[Creator/TheCoenBrothers Coen Brothers film]], so expect this to be done to absurd levels.%%* TraumaCongaLine



* WhamLine: [[spoiler:"Oh, Sy Ableman died in a car crash".]] Especially funny in that the person delivering the line thinks of it wholly as an afterthought.
** Oddly enough, there're bits of dialogue that subtly ''subverts'' this trope. For example, Larry's co-worker often delivers news of the tenure proceedings without really confirming anything, but the audience is made to understand that's confirmation of certain events.
* XanatosGambit - Clive's and his father's plan against Larry is one. If Larry reports the bribe, he will be sued for defamation. If he pretends the bribe didn't happen but doesn't raise Clive's grade, he will be sued for taking money. Ultimately his only option is to take the bribe or risk losing everything.

to:

* WhamLine: WhamLine:
**
[[spoiler:"Oh, Sy Ableman died in a car crash".]] Especially funny in that the person delivering the line thinks of it wholly as an afterthought.
** Oddly enough, there're bits of dialogue that subtly ''subverts'' ''subvert'' this trope. For example, Larry's co-worker often delivers news of the tenure proceedings without really confirming anything, but the audience is made to understand that's confirmation of certain events.
* XanatosGambit - XanatosGambit: Clive's and his father's plan against Larry is one. If Larry reports the bribe, he will be sued for defamation. If he pretends the bribe didn't happen but doesn't raise Clive's grade, he will be sued for taking money. Ultimately his only option is to take the bribe or risk losing everything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Useful Notes/ pages are not tropes


* [[SchrodingersCat Schrödinger's Cat]]: Occurs multiple times as a general theme, both on a literal and metaphorical level. It can be seen as a metaphor for general uncertainty in the world.
** Discussed literally in the film since Larry is a physics teacher
** Larry's marriage is in completely the opposite state to what he thought it was,
** When Larry both is and isn't being bribed.
---> '''Mr. Park''': Please. Accept the mystery.
** The question of whether something deadly lurks in Larry's chest is about to be resolved at the end of the film, as if the story was the superposition of possible X-ray examination outcomes which collapses into a single state when the box is opened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MortonsFork: A student who has failed his exam leaves an envelope of money in Larry's office, as a bribe to get a passing grade. When Larry discusses the matter with the student's father, he realises that he has three equally unpleasant options that fit in well with the previously explained theme of SchroedingersCat.

to:

* MortonsFork: A student who has failed his exam leaves an envelope of money in Larry's office, as a bribe to get a passing grade. When Larry discusses the matter with the student's father, he realises that he has three equally unpleasant options that fit in well with the previously explained theme of SchroedingersCat.UsefulNotes/SchrodingersCat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadLiar: Larry is repeatedly assured in a completely weak and unconvincing way that the students' letters against him will not affect his chances at tenure, leading the audience to believe that they've killed his opportunity. [[spoiler:Subverted when they really ''don't'' affect anything, and he receives tenure.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GodIsEvil: Or at least appears that way as a result of being [[EldritchAbomination completely incomprehensible]]. [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation Alternately]], He is just, but harsh to Old Testament levels. Or maybe he is just working in mysterious ways. The short term format of the film means that the consequences of our characters actions are left ambiguous. And that is assuming that God exists/is involved in the plot at all.

to:

* GodIsEvil: Or at least appears that way as a result of being [[EldritchAbomination completely incomprehensible]]. [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation Alternately]], He is just, expecting that humankind only "be good," but harsh to Old Testament levels.levels against even seemingly inconsequential sins. Or maybe he is just working in mysterious ways. The short term format of the film means that the consequences of our characters actions are left ambiguous. And that is assuming that God exists/is involved in the plot at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Larry didn't get tenure after accepting the bribe, he got a call about a serious medical condition.


* {{Blackmail}}: Clive and his father. Larry finally relents, and is rewarded by his employer, to give you an idea [[CrapsackWorld what kind of values are at work here]].

to:

* {{Blackmail}}: Clive and his father. Larry finally relents, [[CantGetAwayWithNuthin and is rewarded by his employer, to give you an idea immediately punished]], showing [[CrapsackWorld what kind of values are at work here]].

Added: 251

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added another instance of the Schrödinger paradox present in the story, the most important one IMO


* [[SchrodingersCat Schrodinger's Cat]]: Occurs multiple times as a general theme, both on a literal and metaphorical level. It can be seen as a metaphor for general uncertainty in the world.

to:

* [[SchrodingersCat Schrodinger's Schrödinger's Cat]]: Occurs multiple times as a general theme, both on a literal and metaphorical level. It can be seen as a metaphor for general uncertainty in the world.


Added DiffLines:

** The question of whether something deadly lurks in Larry's chest is about to be resolved at the end of the film, as if the story was the superposition of possible X-ray examination outcomes which collapses into a single state when the box is opened.

Added: 283

Changed: 398

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added some tropes.


* CloudCuckoolander: Arthur



* CloudCuckoolander: Arthur

to:

* CloudCuckoolander: ArthurCrisisOfFaith: Larry goes through one [[FromBadToWorse as more things pile up in his life]], seeing multiple rabbis in an attempt to figure out what's going on.



* FakeOutOpening

to:

* FakeOutOpeningExtremeDoormat: Larry takes ''way'' too much abuse over the course of this movie, yet just seems to passively accept it. Even his attempts to talk to the rabbis [[CrisisOfFaith are trying to get someone else to help solve his problems for him]].
* FakeOutOpening: The opening scene displays a Jewish couple in the distant past and their experience with a rabbi who may be [[OurDemonsAreDifferent a dybbuk]]. However, the movie then moves on to 1960s America with Larry for the rest of the running time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Larry seeing his neighbour sunbathing topless is reminiscent of David seeing Bathsheba.
** The overarching story itself has been compared to the story of Job.

to:

** Larry seeing watching his neighbour sunbathing topless is reminiscent of [[Literature/BooksOfSamuel David seeing Bathsheba.
Bathsheba]].
** The overarching story itself has been compared to the story of Job.Literature/BookOfJob.

Added: 53

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If you're fast enough to catch it, apparently Larry's wife is using Tuchman Marsh, aka the Law Firm briefly mentioned in the Coen Brother's previous film, ''Film/BurnAfterReading''.

to:

** If you're fast enough to catch it, apparently Larry's wife is using Tuchman Marsh, aka the Law Firm law firm briefly mentioned in the Coen Brother's Coens' previous film, ''Film/BurnAfterReading''.''Film/BurnAfterReading''.
** Larry's son is an ardent fan of ''Series/FTroop''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:[-We're Going To Be Fine...-] ]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:[-We're Going To Be Fine...going to be fine...-] ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KafkaKomedy
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CloudCuckoolander: Arthur
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudini: Clive and his father [[spoiler: get away with their scheme to force Larry to change Clive's grade, although Larry does give Clive the lowest possible passing grade]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BitchInSheepsClothing: Although he is almost absurdly courteous to Larry's face, it is heavily implied that Sy Ableman [[spoiler; was the one writing the anonymous and defamotory letters to the tenure board about Larry]]

to:

* BitchInSheepsClothing: Although he is almost absurdly courteous to Larry's face, it is heavily implied that Sy Ableman [[spoiler; [[spoiler: was the one writing the anonymous and defamotory defamatory letters to the tenure board about Larry]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BitchInSheepsClothing: Although he is almost absurdly courteous to Larry's face, it is heavily implied that Sy Ableman [[spoiler; was the one writing the anonymous and defamotory letters to the tenure board about Larry]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CatchPhrase: Larry's "I haven't *done* anything!", showing his desperation in the face of having his traditional "actions and consequences" worldview challenged. He simply can't understand why things keep happening to him unprovoked.

to:

* CatchPhrase: Larry's "I haven't *done* ''done'' anything!", showing his desperation in the face of having his traditional "actions and consequences" worldview challenged. He simply can't understand why things keep happening to him unprovoked.

Added: 534

Removed: 299

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsianAndNerdy[=/=][[EducationMama Education Papa]]: Both these Asian stereotypes are subverted; Clive, aiming for a scholarship, failed his physics exam because he ''didn't know it would have math'' and his father prefers to offer bribes to his teachers rather than to get his son to study harder.



* AsianAndNerdy[=/=][[EducationMama Education Papa]]: Both these Asian stereotypes are subverted; Clive, aiming for a scholarship, failed his physics exam because he ''didn't know it would have math'' and his father prefers to offer bribes to his teachers rather than to get his son to study harder.


Added DiffLines:

* CatchPhrase: Larry's "I haven't *done* anything!", showing his desperation in the face of having his traditional "actions and consequences" worldview challenged. He simply can't understand why things keep happening to him unprovoked.

Top