Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / ToRuleThemAllALordOfTheRingsISOT

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This or these examples of Surprisingly Realistic Outcome seem to violate at least one of these rules, which disqualifies them: No character reactions (characters get angry, don't forgive, don't change their personality instantly, etc.); Too fantastical (depends on the properties of magic, powers, sci-fi tech, monsters, etc.); Not surprising (a character was warned about the outcome, it's used to provide Karma or An Aesop, or it simply follows normal conventions for this genre or medium); Plot happens (the example only describes an event, but not why audiences would expect a different, unrealistic outcome); Not an outcome (a character just explains why something wouldn't work as expected, or something is just an innate aspect of the setting or character that has a logical reason for being present); More of a Deconstruction (the event has major, lasting effects on the plot, make something more realistic, but not completely realistic, or a parody/fanwork applies realistic consequences to the events of a different work); or fits better under a different trope. See the trope's definition for more details. If you believe a removal was a mistake, please bring it up in the cleanup thread.


* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: The ISOT is stated to cause gigantic earthquakes. These devastate the affected regions, with descriptions of entire villages being wiped off the map as a result.
** When said earthquakes happen next to large bodies of water, Tidal Waves happen. Said waves proceed to cause even more damage.
** There's another major one going on in the Holy Roman Empire, which threatens to tip the whole of western Europe into a major war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* TheCameo: [[UpToEleven Every single Vala (except Morgoth)]] appears at least briefly in Chapter 3.

to:

* TheCameo: [[UpToEleven Every single Vala (except Morgoth)]] Morgoth) appears at least briefly in Chapter 3.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Loads And Loads Of Characters is no longer a trope


* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Starting to approach this, especially as the War with Mordor begins to spread further and further and more and more nations are drawn in.

Added: 322

Removed: 307

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RealityEnsues: The ISOT is stated to cause gigantic earthquakes. These devastate the affected regions, with descriptions of entire villages being wiped off the map as a result.
** When said earthquakes happen next to large bodies of water, Tidal Waves happen. Said waves proceed to cause even more damage.


Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: The ISOT is stated to cause gigantic earthquakes. These devastate the affected regions, with descriptions of entire villages being wiped off the map as a result.
** When said earthquakes happen next to large bodies of water, Tidal Waves happen. Said waves proceed to cause even more damage.

Changed: 86

Removed: 71

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Commented out a few zces


* SacrificialLamb: Poor [[spoiler: Leszek the White]].
* ShoutOut: Myth/RobinHood gets a reference from John of England when the latter is complaining about disloyalty among his subjects.
** KingArthur is also brought up several times later in the same scene.

to:

* %%* SacrificialLamb: Poor [[spoiler: Leszek the White]].
* ShoutOut: Myth/RobinHood gets a reference from John of England when the latter is complaining about disloyalty among his subjects.
** KingArthur
subjects. Myth/KingArthur is also brought up several times later in the same scene.



** Constance of Aragon, towards Andrew of Hungary (as mentioned above).
** Dominic of Osma does this to Thranduil, again as a brief outburst of frustration.

to:

** %%** Constance of Aragon, towards Andrew of Hungary (as mentioned above).
** Dominic of Osma does this to Thranduil, again as a brief outburst of frustration.



* TemptingFate: See DramaticIrony above.

to:

* %%* TemptingFate: See DramaticIrony above.

Added: 1384

Changed: 411

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAtoner: [[{{Literature/TheSilmarillion}} Maglor]] is set up to become this.



* TheCameo: [[UpToEleven Every single Vala (except Morgoth)]] appears at least briefly in Chapter 3.



* DivineIntervention: What the Vala have been limited to, as explained below (see GodsHandsAreTied).
* DreamingOfThingsToCome: The main form of the Vala's intervention: multiple "Champions" are given visions of the future/direct warning from the Vala in Chapter 3, giving them a head start on the coming war.



* GodsHandsAreTied: The Vala can't directly intervene against Sauron for fear of [[{{Literature/TheSilmarillion}} destroying a large portion of what they're trying to protect]].



* InfoDump: Around half of Chapter 3 (Instruments of the Great Music) is a massive ExpositionDump that details the historical background of most of the European cast.



** There's another major one going on in the Holy Roman Empire, which threatens to tip the whole of western Europe into a major war.
* TakeAThirdOption: The Vala's (particularly the Vala all but stated to be Tulkas') solution to the SuccessionCrisis in the HRE: rather than choose a side in the brewing Civil War, send the warning about Sauron to the largely neutral King of Bohemia.





to:

\n** Another future (OTL) Saint, Saint Sava of Serbia, is introduced in Chapter 3, being given a warning by one of the Vala (all but stated to be Vaire) and sent on a quest to save the Byzantine Empire.
** The future Emperor Baldwin of the Latin Empire (the portion of the Byzantine Empire that was conquered by the 4th Crusade) is briefly mentioned in Chapter 3 as a major member of the still-forming 4th Crusade.
* YouAreNotAlone: A recurring message in the Vala's messages to their Champions, and explicitly spelled out by the one heavily implied to be Manwe when talking to the Pope.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeWhoFightsMonsters: Saruman is interpreted as being this: it's stated that his 'desire to know all he could about his opponent had slowly been warped from begrudging respect to envious admiration and now, finally, to open allegiance.'

Added: 880

Changed: 155

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DramaticIrony: Duke Leopold VI of Austria thinks very little of the reports of a freak blizzard in his Alpine territories, thinking that whatever problems it caused will be easily solved.



* FromBadToWorse: Norway is in the middle of a ''70 year long Civil War.'' Cue the ISOT dropping the Withered Heath within spitting distance of the Kingdom's capital.



* RealityEnsues: The ISOT is stated to cause gigantic earthquakes. These devastate the affected regions, with descriptions of entire villages being wiped off the map as a result.
**When said earthquakes happen next to large bodies of water, Tidal Waves happen. Said waves proceed to cause even more damage.
* SuccessionCrisis: A particularly brutal one is going on in Norway: due to the Kingdom's lack of clear Laws of Succession, there's been a intermittent Civil War going on for ''70 years'' by the time the story starts.





to:

\n* YoungFutureFamousPeople: The (OTL) future Saint Dominic of Osma appears in Chapter 2 (a Brave New World), leading rescue efforts in Osma after the ISOT.

Added: 177

Changed: 324

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: ''2nd Severak Version (''Between Heaven and Hell'')'']]

to:

[[folder: ''2nd Severak Version (''Between ''(Between Heaven and Hell'')'']]
Hell)'' '']]





to:

\n* ForWantOfANail: A tiny pebble, described as being "no bigger than a man's little finger", causes Gandalf to pull the strike that would have in canon killed the Balrog.
* PointOfDivergence: Gandalf [[ForWantOfANail slipping on a small stone]] during his duel with the Balrog, leaving him unable to kill it as in canon.
* UnstoppableRage: The Balrog starts fighting like this after Gandalf manages to land a critical blow [[PointOfDivergence that in canon would have killed it]] during their duel.

Added: 11

Changed: 84

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Said Reboot was launched on Christmas Day 2019, and can be read [[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.480711/#post-19978771 here]], [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.813008/ here]], [[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.59888/ here]], [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/21958516/chapters/52400578 here]] or [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13461018/1/To-Rule-Them-All-Between-Heaven-and-Hell here]].

to:

Said Reboot Reboot, subtitiled "Between Heaven and Hell", was launched on Christmas Day 2019, and can be read [[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.480711/#post-19978771 here]], [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.813008/ here]], [[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.59888/ here]], [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/21958516/chapters/52400578 here]] or [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13461018/1/To-Rule-Them-All-Between-Heaven-and-Hell here]].



[[folder: ''1st Severak Version]]

to:

[[folder: ''1st Severak Version]]
Version and original'']]



[[folder: ''2nd Severak Version'']]

to:

[[folder: ''2nd Severak Version'']]
Version (''Between Heaven and Hell'')'']]


Added DiffLines:



[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/jpeg_map.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350: The Gates of Hell have opened...]]

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/jpeg_map.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350: The
org/pmwiki/pub/images/isot_map_imgur_7.png]]
[[caption-width-right:350:The
Gates of Hell have opened...opened.]]


Added DiffLines:

Added: 142

Changed: 550

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

Said Reboot was launched on Christmas Day 2019, and can be read [[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.480711/#post-19978771 here]], [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.813008/ here]], [[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-between-heaven-and-hell.59888/ here]], [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/21958516/chapters/52400578 here]] or [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13461018/1/To-Rule-Them-All-Between-Heaven-and-Hell here]].


Added DiffLines:

[[foldercontrol]]

[[folder: ''1st Severak Version]]


Added DiffLines:


[[/folder]]


[[folder: ''2nd Severak Version'']]

*ContinuityReboot: To the 1st Severak Version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/to-rule-them-all-a-lord-of-the-rings-isot.411863/ To Rule Them All: A Lord of the Rings ISOT]]'' is a ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fanfic written by Severak, first appearing on {{Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom}}, later being cross-posted to {{Website/SpaceBattles}} [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.514036/ here]] (as well as Spacebattles' sister site Sufficent Velocity [[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.46586/ here]]), {{Website/FanfictionDotNet}} [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12690966/1/To-Rule-Them-All/ here]] and {{Website/ArchiveofOurOwn}} [[http://archiveofourown.org/works/12497936/chapters/28453596 here]]. It is a reboot of a classic AH.com thread (found [[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/mordor-isengard-misty-mountains-isoted-to-medieval-europe.198299/ Here]]). Unfortunately, that version of story was never completed, becoming a DeadFic in 2012. Five years later, a writing challenge was posted on Alternate History to reboot the story, resulting in the new version, which was launched on March 12, 2017.

to:

''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/to-rule-them-all-a-lord-of-the-rings-isot.411863/ To Rule Them All: A Lord of the Rings ISOT]]'' is a ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fanfic written by Severak, first appearing on {{Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom}}, later being cross-posted to {{Website/SpaceBattles}} [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.514036/ here]] (as well as Spacebattles' sister site Sufficent Velocity [[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.46586/ here]]), {{Website/FanfictionDotNet}} [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12690966/1/To-Rule-Them-All/ here]] and {{Website/ArchiveofOurOwn}} [[http://archiveofourown.org/works/12497936/chapters/28453596 here]]. It is a reboot of a classic AH.com thread (found [[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/mordor-isengard-misty-mountains-isoted-to-medieval-europe.198299/ Here]]). Unfortunately, that version of story was never completed, becoming a DeadFic in 2012. Five years later, a writing challenge was posted on Alternate History to reboot the story, resulting in the new version, which was launched on March 12, 2017.
2017. That version was ''also'' declared a DeadFic on July 25, 2019, after nearly a year without updating. WordOfGod claims that a Reboot is now in the works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RiskingTheKing: King Emeric of Hungary, Grand Prince Rurik of Kiev and Count Thomas of Savoy all lead personal expeditions into the ISOTed lands that appear near their realms. It works out differently for all three of them.

to:

* RiskingTheKing: King Emeric of Hungary, Grand Prince Rurik of Kiev and Count Thomas of Savoy all lead personal expeditions into the ISOTed [=ISOT=]ed lands that appear near their realms. It works out differently for all three of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: {{Myth/RobinHood}} gets a reference from John of England when the latter is complaining about disloyalty among his subjects.
** {{Myth/KingArthur}} is also brought up several times later in the same scene.

to:

* ShoutOut: {{Myth/RobinHood}} Myth/RobinHood gets a reference from John of England when the latter is complaining about disloyalty among his subjects.
** {{Myth/KingArthur}} KingArthur is also brought up several times later in the same scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/to-rule-them-all-a-lord-of-the-rings-isot.411863/ To Rule Them All: A Lord of the Rings ISOT]]'' is TheLordoftheRings Fanfiction written by Severak, first appearing on {{Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom}}, later being cross-posted to {{Website/SpaceBattles}} [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.514036/ here]] (as well as Spacebattles' sister site Sufficent Velocity [[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.46586/ here]]), {{Website/FanfictionDotNet}} [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12690966/1/To-Rule-Them-All/ here]] and {{Website/ArchiveofOurOwn}} [[http://archiveofourown.org/works/12497936/chapters/28453596 here]]. It is a reboot of a classic AH.com thread (found [[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/mordor-isengard-misty-mountains-isoted-to-medieval-europe.198299/ Here]]). Unfortunately, that version of story was never completed, becoming a DeadFic in 2012. Five years later, a writing challenge was posted on Alternate History to reboot the story, resulting in the new version, which was launched on March 12, 2017.

to:

''[[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/to-rule-them-all-a-lord-of-the-rings-isot.411863/ To Rule Them All: A Lord of the Rings ISOT]]'' is TheLordoftheRings Fanfiction a ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fanfic written by Severak, first appearing on {{Website/AlternateHistoryDotCom}}, later being cross-posted to {{Website/SpaceBattles}} [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.514036/ here]] (as well as Spacebattles' sister site Sufficent Velocity [[https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/to-rule-them-all-lord-of-the-rings-and-1200-ad-europe.46586/ here]]), {{Website/FanfictionDotNet}} [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12690966/1/To-Rule-Them-All/ here]] and {{Website/ArchiveofOurOwn}} [[http://archiveofourown.org/works/12497936/chapters/28453596 here]]. It is a reboot of a classic AH.com thread (found [[https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/mordor-isengard-misty-mountains-isoted-to-medieval-europe.198299/ Here]]). Unfortunately, that version of story was never completed, becoming a DeadFic in 2012. Five years later, a writing challenge was posted on Alternate History to reboot the story, resulting in the new version, which was launched on March 12, 2017.

Added: 695

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorAppeal: DramaticIrony. The examples listed below are just the "in-your-face" ones.



** Alfonso of Castile also starts contemplating suicide after losing most of his family, along with roughly half of his Kingdom, to the ISOT.



** Tulkas pops up to Alfonso of Castile in "Three Beginnings" to give some aid to Alfonso of Castile.



* GodsHandsAreTied: The Valar have this problem: it's stated that if they directly intervene, the entire world will ''shatter'' do to their presence finishing off the already-damaged fabric of reality so they're limited to indirect aid.



* KissingCousins: A historical example: Alfonso of Castile's daughter Berengaria is married to his nephew, Alfonso of Leon.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted. There are two Philips and two Conrads. Played With by Stefan of Serbia's father Stefan Nemanja: said father is referred to by his monastic name of "Simeon" more often than not, and he dies of old age at the end of his introductory scene.

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted. There are two Philips Philips, two Conrads and two Conrads.Alfonsos. Played With by Stefan of Serbia's father Stefan Nemanja: said father is referred to by his monastic name of "Simeon" more often than not, and he dies of old age at the end of his introductory scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KingInTheMountain: [[spoiler: Leszek]] becomes one after [[spoiler: the duel between the Balrog and Galadriel]].


Added DiffLines:

** {{Myth/KingArthur}} is also brought up several times later in the same scene.

Added: 177

Changed: 88

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FallenHero: [[spoiler: Maglor]], as described in the {{Literature/TheSilmarillion}}. As referenced above, however, they have been given the chance to become TheAtoner instead.



* ShoutOut:{{Myth/RobinHood}} gets a BlinkAndYoullMissIt reference from John of England.

to:

* ShoutOut:{{Myth/RobinHood}} ShoutOut: {{Myth/RobinHood}} gets a BlinkAndYoullMissIt reference from John of England.England when the latter is complaining about disloyalty among his subjects.

Added: 1066

Changed: 374

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DreamingOfThingsToCome: Used thrice so far: [[ChurchMilitant Pope Innocent III]] is given a vision by [[BigGood Eru/God]] that Foreshadows much of the plot. Likewise, the canonical Mirror of Galadriel is used to show glimpses of coming events. Played With by the vision given to Konchek of the Cumans, which serves more a as a general warning, and doesn't show the future, instead showing him the events currently unfolding in Poland and Hungary.

to:

* DreamingOfThingsToCome: Used thrice so far: [[ChurchMilitant Pope Innocent III]] is given a vision by [[BigGood Eru/God]] that Foreshadows much of the plot. Likewise, the canonical Mirror of Galadriel is used to show glimpses of coming events. Played
**Played
With by the vision given to Konchek of the Cumans, which serves more a as a general warning, and doesn't show the future, instead showing him the events currently unfolding in Poland and Hungary.Hungary.
**Stefan Nemanja also receives a vision of his sons just before his death, although the audience themselves is not shown it.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted. There are two Philips and two Conrads. Also, Stefan of Serbia's father is also named Stefan, although said father has only been mentioned in passing.

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted. There are two Philips and two Conrads. Also, Played With by Stefan of Serbia's father is also named Stefan, although Stefan Nemanja: said father has only been mentioned in passing.is referred to by his monastic name of "Simeon" more often than not, and he dies of old age at the end of his introductory scene.


Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut:{{Myth/RobinHood}} gets a BlinkAndYoullMissIt reference from John of England.
* SmallRoleBigImpact: Stefan Nemanja dies in his introductory scene, but spends it setting up his son Sava's subplot.


Added DiffLines:

* SuddenlyShouting: Several examples, most of them short outbursts:
** Constance of Aragon, towards Andrew of Hungary (as mentioned above).
** Dominic of Osma does this to Thranduil, again as a brief outburst of frustration.
** [[spoiler: Maglor]] does this as well, when trying to convince Nienna that he can't be her Champion.


Added DiffLines:

*YoungFutureFamousPeople: Several of them. The future Saints Dominic of Osma and Sava have both made appearances, and WordOfGod has confirmed that Francis of Assisi has a critical role to play in the future.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
New WOG clarified some implications


** In "Arise from Slumber," Nienna and a figure implied to be Vaire appear to [[spoiler: Maglor]] and John of England respectively.

to:

** In "Arise from Slumber," Nienna and a figure implied Vaire [[spoiler: pretending to be Vaire the Lady of the Lake]] appear to [[spoiler: Maglor]] and John of England respectively.



** A figure implied to be Vaire gives a ''scathing'' one to John of England. Played With later in the same chapter by [[spoiler: Maglor]], who gives ''himself'' a "Reason '''I''' Suck" speech.

to:

** A figure implied to be Vaire [[spoiler: by WOG is actually Vaire pretending to be the Lady of the Lake]] gives a ''scathing'' one to John of England. Played With later in the same chapter by [[spoiler: Maglor]], who gives ''himself'' a "Reason '''I''' Suck" speech.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A figure implied to be Vaire gives a ''scathing'' one to John of England.

to:

** A figure implied to be Vaire gives a ''scathing'' one to John of England. Played With later in the same chapter by [[spoiler: Maglor]], who gives ''himself'' a "Reason '''I''' Suck" speech.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Used again with Saphadin, who thinks about how the only thing that can undermine his efforts to stabilize the Ayyubids is a demonic army marching out of Arabia.

Added: 526

Changed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAtoner: [[spoiler: Maglor]] is set up to be one of these.



* DareToBeBadass: Nienna gives one of these to [[spoiler: Maglor]] to inspire him to be her Champion.



* DivineIntervention: Eru/God is a lot more open about this than they are in canon. It's heavily implied several times that they are actively working to make sure several people are in the right place, such as Dominic going to Thranduil and Gandalf making it to Rome. Similarly, a woman that is all but stated to be [[MotherNature Yavanna]] appears to Konchek of the Cumans to warn him about Sauron's spreading influence.

to:

* DivineIntervention: Eru/God is a lot more open about this than they are in canon. It's heavily implied several times that they are actively working to make sure several people are in the right place, such as Dominic going to Thranduil and Gandalf making it to Rome. Similarly,
**Similarly,
a woman that is all but stated to be [[MotherNature Yavanna]] appears to Konchek of the Cumans to warn him about Sauron's spreading influence.influence.
**In "Arise from Slumber," Nienna and a figure implied to be Vaire appear to [[spoiler: Maglor]] and John of England respectively.


Added DiffLines:

** A figure implied to be Vaire gives a ''scathing'' one to John of England.

Top