Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / TheCliff

Go To

OR

Added: 136

Removed: 136

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BloodBrothers: Like in canon, Siegfried and Gunther take a vow of brotherhood. [[spoiler:Unlike in canon, it doesn't end in tragedy]].


Added DiffLines:

* SwornBrothers: Like in canon, Siegfried and Gunther take a vow of brotherhood. [[spoiler:Unlike in canon, it doesn't end in tragedy]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Armor Piercing Slap is no longer a trope


* HypocriticalHeartwarming: Brünnhilde calls Mime all sorts of insults all the time and occasionally fights with him physically. When Waltraute tries to insult him, all that she manages is "this disgusting, repulsive, vile Nibfffff..." before Brünnhilde gives her an ArmorPiercingSlap.

to:

* HypocriticalHeartwarming: Brünnhilde calls Mime all sorts of insults all the time and occasionally fights with him physically. When Waltraute tries to insult him, all that she manages is "this disgusting, repulsive, vile Nibfffff..." before Brünnhilde gives her an ArmorPiercingSlap.a slap.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Grumpy Bear is no longer a trope. Moving examples to other tropes when applicable.


* BefriendingTheEnemy: Brünnhilde starts trying it with the antagonists, after realizing how the PowerOfLove has changed Mime and being prompted by the Rhinemaidens. She manages to do it with [[spoiler:Hagen]], who is still a GrumpyBear by the end but at least [[spoiler:genuinely loves his family and friends]], and [[spoiler:Fafner]], who is pretty much broken by [[spoiler:all that he has done after getting the ring]] but still tries to recover and make amends. Even [[spoiler:Alberich]]’s temper slightly improves, though it’s more due to [[spoiler:Hagen’s influence]] than to [[spoiler:Brünnhilde’s]].

to:

* BefriendingTheEnemy: Brünnhilde starts trying it with the antagonists, after realizing how the PowerOfLove has changed Mime and being prompted by the Rhinemaidens. She manages to do it with [[spoiler:Hagen]], who is still a GrumpyBear grump by the end but at least [[spoiler:genuinely loves his family and friends]], and [[spoiler:Fafner]], who is pretty much broken by [[spoiler:all that he has done after getting the ring]] but still tries to recover and make amends. Even [[spoiler:Alberich]]’s temper slightly improves, though it’s more due to [[spoiler:Hagen’s influence]] than to [[spoiler:Brünnhilde’s]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* SlutShaming: Erda and the Norns take it UpToEleven. They think it's a horrible degradation for Brünnhilde when they learn she is no longer a maiden. Never mind that she only ever sleeps with her husband, the sheer fact that she does it makes Erda and the Norns react as if she is DefiledForever.

to:

* SlutShaming: Erda and the Norns take it UpToEleven. They think it's a horrible degradation for Brünnhilde when they learn she is no longer a maiden. Never mind that she only ever sleeps with her husband, the sheer fact that she does it makes Erda and the Norns react as if she is DefiledForever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JacobAndEsau: Mime and Brünnhilde's sons. Siegfried, fearless man of action, has a much closer bond with Brünnhilde, and Regin, timid smith, has a much stronger relationship with Mime. However, it doesn't mar the family peace, and the brothers get along with each other wonderfully.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ReplacementGoldfish: After Brünnhilde is put into enchanted sleep, Waltraute becomes Wotan's favourite daughter and messenger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LethalChef: In the beginning, Brünnhilde's attempt at bread turns to coals, and her attempt at cereal turns to a heap of slightly roasted grain with, for some reason, a pike underneath. According to Brünnhilde, Mime's cooking is only marginally better and his soups tastes like rainwater at best.

to:

* LethalChef: In the beginning, Brünnhilde's attempt at bread turns to coals, and her attempt at cereal turns to a heap of slightly roasted grain with, for some reason, a pike underneath. According to Brünnhilde, Mime's cooking is only marginally better and his soups tastes taste like rainwater at best.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarmlessVillain: Fafner, constantly hyped as Siegfried’s future deadly enemy, does absolutely nothing throughout the story beyond letting out a scary roar in the first chapter. [[spoiler:Until he turns back to the good side and actively helps Brünnhilde and Mime]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreeRangeChildren: Before Brünnhilde comes along, Siegfried runs around in the woods by himself from dawn till dusk. Brünnhilde makes sure he spends at least some time at home, and then, after he makes friends with the Gibichungs, he prefers spending time them to walking alone in the forest.

to:

* FreeRangeChildren: Before Brünnhilde comes along, Siegfried runs around in the woods by himself from dawn till dusk. Brünnhilde makes sure he spends at least some time at home, and then, after he makes friends with the Gibichungs, he prefers spending time with them to walking alone in the forest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Just like Mime, Regin is cautious, careful, and absolutely loves smithery. He also gets his Nibelung looks (from Br&umml;nnhilde, he only inherits her black eyes and human height).

to:

** Just like Mime, Regin is cautious, careful, and absolutely loves smithery. He also gets his Nibelung looks (from Br&umml;nnhilde, Brünnhilde, he only inherits her black eyes and human height).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CloudCuckoolander: Erda is very absent-minded and often lapses into mumbling disaster predictions. However, Mime, Brünnhilde, Siegfried and Gibich's family are so used to weirdness they don't pay much attention to it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllAmazonsWantHercules: Just after waking up, Brünnhilde is most of all repulsed by Mime's cowardice and muses she wouldn't have minded his looks if only he had been a heroic warrior. However, as they grow on each other, she realises she is perfectly happy with Mime the CowardlyLion.


Added DiffLines:

* AloofAlly:
** [[spoiler:Hagen]] ends up like this, a brooding and aloof man living separately from the heroes, [[spoiler:even his mother's family]], but always helping them when necessary.
** [[spoiler:Fafner]] comes to help in [[spoiler:the battle against Wotan]] but barely interacts with anyone afterwards. [[spoiler:He gradually warms to the heroes, but still prefers living alone]].


Added DiffLines:

* BastardBastard: Hagen, the illegitimate son of Alberich and Grimhild, is mean and selfish, planning to seize the Ring for himself. Alberich cultivates all the negative traits in him, which leads to Hagen alienating Grimhild's relations, which only embitters him all the more. [[spoiler:When Brünnhilde starts treating him kindly and urges Mime, Siegfried and even Grane to do the same, Hagen gradually gets better]].


Added DiffLines:

* BeingEvilSucks: Pride, cruelty or greed lead to dreary, lonely existence. [[spoiler:Fafner]], who has never known a moment of joy since turning evil, can testify to that. And if one longs for the RingOfPower, [[spoiler:in the end of the fic, when said ring is returned to the Rhine, their feelings are akin to heavy GoingColdTurkey, and it takes years for Alberich and Hagen to recover from it]].


Added DiffLines:

* CloudCuckooland: The forest and Gibich's castle have weirdness happening there all the time. The events leading up to the climax deserve a special mention ([[spoiler:a dragon scatters his own treasure hoard around the forest by sneezing, because he is allergic to poplar fluff]]). In the interquel, Erda explains it is caused by the high level of magic, the result of the many magical beings living in such a small area. In the epilogue, Grimhild is happy that [[spoiler:her daughter-in-law Helmi]] is revealed to have a sense of humour, because one can't survive without it in this place.
* CompletedFic: The main fic and the alternate chapter version are completed.


Added DiffLines:

* OriginalCharacter:
** Epilogue-only: [[spoiler:Gunther's wife Helmi and their sons Friedmund and Frohwalt]], and Regin, son of Mime and Brünnhilde.
** Mentioned in the main story but only appearing in the interquel: Gibich's second cousin Amalrica, her husband Ramon and their daughters Miguela and Monica.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlutShaming: Erda and the Norns take it UpToEleven. They think it's a horrible degradation for Brünnhilde when they learn she is no longer a maiden. Never mind that she only ever sleeps with her husband, Erda and the Norns still react as if Brünnhilde is DefiledForever.

to:

* SlutShaming: Erda and the Norns take it UpToEleven. They think it's a horrible degradation for Brünnhilde when they learn she is no longer a maiden. Never mind that she only ever sleeps with her husband, the sheer fact that she does it makes Erda and the Norns still react as if Brünnhilde she is DefiledForever.

Added: 847

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CannonFodder: [[spoiler:The dead hero army of Valhalla]] turns out to be this, since they don't have any free will or intelligence of their own anymore. They get defeated ridiculously easily by ''five'' opponents.



* LikeFatherLikeSon:
** Just like Mime, Regin is cautious, careful, and absolutely loves smithery. He also gets his Nibelung looks (from Br&umml;nnhilde, he only inherits her black eyes and human height).
** Gunther and Gutrune are friendly, kind and trusting, like their parents.
** Hagen is ([[spoiler:initially, at least]]) paranoid and gloomy, like Alberich.



* ShrinkingViolet: [[spoiler:Gunther's wife]] is terribly shy for the first couple of years, before [[TookALevelInCheerfulness taking a level in cheerfulness]].

to:

* ShrinkingViolet: [[spoiler:Gunther's wife]] is terribly shy around almost everyone for the first couple of years, before [[TookALevelInCheerfulness taking a level in cheerfulness]].


Added DiffLines:

* SlutShaming: Erda and the Norns take it UpToEleven. They think it's a horrible degradation for Brünnhilde when they learn she is no longer a maiden. Never mind that she only ever sleeps with her husband, Erda and the Norns still react as if Brünnhilde is DefiledForever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood:
** Alberich can't believe that no, Brünnhilde really doesn't want the ring or any other treasures for herself, and yes, she really is trying to get him and Mime to reconcile.
** Waltraute is shocked that Brünnhilde doesn't want to eliminate the Nibelungs, wishes the RingOfPower to be returned to the Rhinemaidens, and is genuinely happy with her life on earth.


Added DiffLines:

* KnowWhenToFoldEm: When [[spoiler:Wotan's spear is broken and his chief raven is defeated]], [[spoiler:Valhalla's army]] acknowledges defeat pretty quickly.


Added DiffLines:

* LetsFightLikeGentlemen: Discussed. Thanks to Brünnhilde's lessons, the rule of oneself and one's opponent having equal chances gets firmly instilled in Siegfried's heart, so much that [[spoiler:he is ready to assist with the dragon's medical treatment to make sure he won't fight a sick enemy]].


Added DiffLines:

* ThreatBackfire: Wotan tries to frighten Siegfried by pointing out the latter has seen the Valkyries and is therefore doomed. Siegfried calmly replies he sees a Valkyrie every day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChekhovsSkill: Siegfried and Gunther's extensive archery training, the description of which looks like a simple filler scene inserted before [[spoiler:the dragon's sneezing leads up to the events of the story's climax]]. However, thanks to that training, they are able to [[spoiler:save Mime's life by shooting down Wotan's chief raven]].


Added DiffLines:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Brünnhilde gives one to Waltraute when the latter calls her to fight against the Nibelungs and seize the ring for Wotan. She says that the residents of Valhalla have nothing to their credit but pride, selfishness, empty pathos and MeaninglessMeaningfulWords, and none of the warmth, trust and true friendship she has learned during her life on earth.


Added DiffLines:

* TuckAndCover: [[spoiler:Mime]] shields [[spoiler:Brünnhilde]] from an attack by Wotan's ravens. The head raven only has time to tear at [[spoiler:his]] clothes before [[spoiler:being shot by Siegfried and Gunther]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OCStandIn: Gibich and Grimhild are dead in canon, and the only thing we know is that they existed. Here, they are prominent supporting characters.


Added DiffLines:

** Obviously, Mime and Brünnhilde for each other (in canon, they don't even meet).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InterclassFriendship: Gibich is a pretty wealthy lord while Mime and Brünnhilde only have their forest hut. When Brünnhilde first visits Gibich's family, she hastily lies that they have a castle of their own as well, but after the truth gets revealed, turns out their new friends don't care. The interquel reveals that Gibich and Grimhild offer their friends to move to the castle permanently several times, but Mime and Brünnhilde always refuse, and eventually the matter is just dropped.

Added: 542

Changed: 337

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BestFriendsInLaw: Siegfried eventually marries his best friend's sister.



* LeaveTheTwoLovebirdsAlone: After making sure [[spoiler:Brünnhilde wasn’t seriously wounded in the battle]], everyone, including Siegfried, leaves the hut for Gibich’s castle to give Mime and Brünnhilde some privacy. After more than ten years of CannotSpitItOut, the two finally confess their love (and, [[ConfessionTriggersConsummation well]]... conceive Regin).

to:

* LeaveTheTwoLovebirdsAlone: LeaveTheTwoLovebirdsAlone:
** When it becomes clear Siegfried and Gutrune are an item, everyone starts tactfully giving them space even at family gatherings.
**
After making sure [[spoiler:Brünnhilde wasn’t seriously wounded in the battle]], everyone, including Siegfried, leaves the hut for Gibich’s castle to give Mime and Brünnhilde some privacy. After more than ten years of CannotSpitItOut, the two finally confess their love (and, [[ConfessionTriggersConsummation well]]... conceive Regin).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlliterativeFamily: As in canon, there are Gibich and Grimhild whose children are called Gunther and Gutrune. Plus they have [[OddNameOut Hagen]], Grimhild's son by Alberich.

Added: 878

Changed: 864

Removed: 443

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContentWarning: The English version has one. "Not recommended for Wotan's fans, the Gibichungs' haters and/or Wagnerian purists".

to:

* ContentWarning: ContentWarning:
**
The English version has one. "Not recommended for Wotan's fans, the Gibichungs' haters and/or Wagnerian purists".
** There is one in the interquel, warning those who don’t want to see fun made of Wagner operas, as well as those who love Siegfried and hate Mime, to tread carefully.



** Gutrune, OneOfTheBoys during childhood, becomes more gentle and feminine in her teens.

to:

** Gutrune, The interquel reveals Gutrune was OneOfTheBoys during childhood, childhood. She becomes more gentle and feminine in her teens.



* SpeaksFluentAnimal: Wotan can understand the forest bird. He [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech isn't pleased by what he hears from her]].

to:

* SpeaksFluentAnimal: SpeaksFluentAnimal:
**
Wotan can understand the forest bird. He [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech isn't pleased by what he hears from her]].her]].
** In the interquel, it's revealed Erda can also understand the forest birds and reply in their language.



* WorthlessYellowRocks: The characters are so tired of all the fuss going on around the dragon’s treasure hoard that they stop really caring about it. [[spoiler:When the gold is scattered around the forest, it’s gathered by its rightful owners the residents of Nibelheim]].

to:

* WorthlessYellowRocks: WorthlessYellowRocks:
**
The characters are so tired of all the fuss going on around the dragon’s treasure hoard that they stop really caring about it. [[spoiler:When the gold is scattered around the forest, it’s gathered by its rightful owners the residents of Nibelheim]].
** In the interquel, Cristobal Junta has zero interest in using magic to make gold, preferring the more philosophical pursuits.



* ContentWarnings: The fic has a joking one, warning those who don’t want to see fun made of Wagner operas, as well as those who love Siegfried and hate Mime, to tread carefully.



* ShipperOnDeck: Like the forest bird, Amalrica and her daughters see through Mime and Brünnhilde's [[SlapSlapKiss stormy]] interactions at once.
* SpeaksFluentAnimal: It's revealed Erda can understand the forest birds and reply in their language.
* UpliftedAnimal: Erda explains that the forest birds' family has become sapient due to the high level of magic present in the forest.
* WorthlessYellowRocks: Cristobal Junta has zero interest in using magic to make gold, preferring the more philosophical pursuits.

to:

* ShipperOnDeck: Like OneOfTheBoys: Gutrune happily takes part in the forest bird, Amalrica boys' messy, active games, so much that Grimhild is very glad for her to meet her more feminine Spanish cousins and her daughters see through Mime and Brünnhilde's [[SlapSlapKiss stormy]] interactions at once.
* SpeaksFluentAnimal: It's revealed Erda can understand the forest birds and reply in their language.
interact with girls for once.
* UpliftedAnimal: Erda explains that the forest birds' family has become sapient due to the high level of magic present in the forest.
* WorthlessYellowRocks: Cristobal Junta has zero interest in using magic to make gold, preferring the more philosophical pursuits.
forest.

Added: 653

Removed: 493

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SiblingYinYang:
** Half-siblings Hagen and the Gibichungs. Hagen is gloomy, silent and constantly angry. Gunther and Gutrune are friendly, cheerful and sociable.
** Downplayed with Siegfried and Regin, who are technically cousins through Brünnhilde but are brothers by adoption. Siegfried is a fearless, energetic, charismatic fighter but not too keen on studies or smithing. Regin is a timid NonActionGuy who makes quick progress with his studies and spends all his free time in the smithy.


Added DiffLines:

* ShrinkingViolet: [[spoiler:Gunther's wife]] is terribly shy for the first couple of years, before [[TookALevelInCheerfulness taking a level in cheerfulness]].
* SiblingYinYang:
** Half-siblings Hagen and the Gibichungs. Hagen is gloomy, silent and constantly angry. Gunther and Gutrune are friendly, cheerful and sociable.
** Downplayed with Siegfried and Regin, who are technically cousins through Brünnhilde but are brothers by adoption. Siegfried is a fearless, energetic, charismatic fighter but not too keen on studies or smithing. Regin is a timid NonActionGuy who makes quick progress with his studies and spends all his free time in the smithy.

Added: 383

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CheerfulChild: Both the Gibichungs are like this as children, being very friendly, curious and playful. Unlike in canon, no traumatic events or Hagen's EvilChancellor advice take place to change it as they grow to adulthood.



* HandOnWomb: Brünnhilde announces her pregnancy by telling Mime he'll soon know what having one's own children is like, and putting her hand on her stomach.



** Gunther jokingly says that if Mime wasn't so skilled with a hammer, he would have married Brünnhilde, which is what he does in ''The Twilight of the Gods''.

to:

** Gunther jokingly says that if Mime wasn't so skilled with a hammer, he would have married Brünnhilde, Brünnhilde himself, which is what he does in ''The Twilight of the Gods''.

Added: 145

Removed: 145

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ParentalAbandonment: Revealed by Mime to be the norm in Nibelung culture. Children are left to be RaisedByTheCommunity soon after being weaned.



* ParentalAbandonment: Revealed by Mime to be the norm in Nibelung culture. Children are left to be RaisedByTheCommunity soon after being weaned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoMacguffinNoWinner: Downplayed with respect to the entire plot, as [[spoiler:the Rhinemaidens do get the ring, but they aren’t planning to use it for world domination]]. Played straight in the context of chapter 21, where neither side [[spoiler:in the battle]] has even any chance to [[spoiler:get the Ring]], as it has already been [[spoiler:blown into the Rhine]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BabiesEverAfter: Mime and Brünnhilde’s son Regin is born between the last chapter and the epilogue, [[spoiler:as are Gunther’s two sons]].


Added DiffLines:

* DefrostingIceQueen: Brünnhilde starts as proud and haughty, but becomes much more easy-going and cheerful further on as her romance with Mime, as well as her motherly relationship with Siegfried and friendship with Gibich’s family, progress.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContentWarning: The English version has one. "Not recommended for Wotan's fans, the Gibichungs' haters and/or Wagnerian purists".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AccidentallyBrokeTheMacGuffin: [[spoiler:The Tarnhelm, the only thing from the treasure hoard Mime still really wants to have, considering he made it]], is stepped on [[spoiler:in the battle against Wotan]] and twisted and damaged beyond repair.


Added DiffLines:

* BigBrotherBully: Mime reveals Alberich had bullied him relentlessly even long before the ring came into the picture.


Added DiffLines:

* WorthlessYellowRocks: The characters are so tired of all the fuss going on around the dragon’s treasure hoard that they stop really caring about it. [[spoiler:When the gold is scattered around the forest, it’s gathered by its rightful owners the residents of Nibelheim]].


Added DiffLines:

* ContentWarnings: The fic has a joking one, warning those who don’t want to see fun made of Wagner operas, as well as those who love Siegfried and hate Mime, to tread carefully.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CowardlyLion: Mime is easily frightened of practically everything. But if Brünnhilde insists on going on a dangerous mission, he accompanies her to make sure her bravery won’t get her killed, and woe betide you if you actually try to harm Brünnhilde, Siegfried or [[VitriolicBestBuds the forest bird]].

to:

* CowardlyLion: Mime is easily frightened of by practically everything. But if Brünnhilde insists on going on a dangerous mission, he accompanies her to make sure her bravery won’t get her killed, and woe betide you if you actually try to harm Brünnhilde, Siegfried or [[VitriolicBestBuds the forest bird]].

Top