History Fanfic / IfWishesWerePonies

* ExoticExtendedMarriage: While traditional marriage is known to exist in Equestria the way the CMC react to Harry agreeing to form a herd with them heavily implys this trope, though the fact that all four of them are 10 or so when they agree to this raises a few questions about how legitimate this agreement is and how the practice of "herding" actually works.

* ExoticExtendedMarriage: While traditional marriage is known to exist in Equestria the way the CMC react to Harry agreeing to form a herd with them heavily implys this trope, though the fact that all four of them are 10 or so when they agree to this raises a few questions about how legitimate this agreement is and how the practice of"herding" actually works.

* ExoticExtendedMarriage: While traditional marriage is known to exist in Equestria the way the CMC react to Harry agreeing to form a herd with them heavily implys this trope, though the fact that all four of them are 10 or so when they agree to this raises a few questions about how legitimate this agreement is and how "herding" actually work.

* TooCleverByHalf: Dumbledore as the almost the same as he is in canon. Except this time when setting up the protection around Harry at the Dursley's he accidentally makes it so his monitoring spells prevent him from knowing that Harry is being abused by the Dursley's.

* TheStationsOfTheCanon: It looks like several plot points from the first three books could happen during the first year! Before Harry even he goes to Hogwarts is informed of his godfathers supposed betrayal and jailing without a trial. Harry finds out about the lack of a trial and after talking about it to Twilight both agree that many of the facts do not add up and want to have the entire incident looked into and a proper investigation to happen. Thanks to telling Twilight about reviving Myrtle she decides to talk to her about how she died. This leads to the discovery of the Chamber of Secrets and what inhabitants it.

* GenderBender: Neville Longbottom and Sweetie Belle somehow to temporarily cause this to themselves and the entire potions class during their first lesson. When the Weasley twins find out about it they immediately grill the two about how they did it and set out to duplicate the results, scaring anyone who finds out about it.

* VoluntaryShapeshifting: Thanks to Discord deciding to have some fun the Equestrians have figured out how to change from human form back into pony form while on Earth with Harry, Hermione, most of the Weasley family and the entire Gryffindor Quidditch team becomes pony Animagus.

* GendderBender: Neville Longbottom and Sweetie Belle somehow to temporarily cause this to themselves and the entire potions class during their first lesson. When the Weasley twins find out about it they immediately grill the two about how they did it and set out to duplicate the results, scaring anyone who finds out about it.

* GendderBender: Neville Longbottom and Sweetie Belle somehow cause this to themselves and the entire potions class during their first lesson. When the Weasley twins find out about it they immediately grill the two about how they did it and set out to duplicate the results, scaring anyone who finds out about it.

* GodGuise: Ollivander thinks that Twilight and Pinkie goddesses after they enter his shop when they are looking for wands. After seeing the hairs of Celestia and Luna he thinks the same of them as well. Rarity later refutes this to Dumbledore, the Grangers, and Molly Weasley stating that alicorns are not deities and do not like worship.

* VoluntaryShapeshifting: Thanks to Discord deciding to have some fun the Equestrians have figured out how to change from human form back into pony form while on Earth with Harry, Hermione, most of the Weasley family and the entire Gryffindor Quidditch team becomes a pony a Animagus

* InterspeciesAdoption: Ever since Harry stumbled onto Equestria 15 months before his first year at Hogwarts Twilight has been taking care of him at the suggestion of Princess Celestia and once formal diplomatic relations between Equestria and Muggle Great Britain even asked to formally adopt the boy.

* AliensSpeakingEnglish: Played straight as an arrow and somewhat exaggerated Equestrians not only speak a language identical to english but some such as Applejack and Apple Bloom possess accents identical to those spoken in the American south.

* GodGuise: Ollivander thinks that Twilight and Pinkie are after they enter his shop when they are looking for wands. After seeing the hairs of Celestia and Luna he thinks the same of them as well. Rarity later refutes this to Dumbledore, the Grangers, and Molly Weasley stating that alicorns are not deities and do not like worship.

* DisappointedInYou: Dumbledore says this to Petunia after learning of the abuse that her family subjected Harry to. He chooses to leave her to her fate as she sits in jail for failing to report, a missing Harry for over a year.

* AliensSpeakingEnglish: Played straight as an arrow and somewhat exaggerated Equestrians not only speak a language identical to english but they most notably Applejack and Apple Bloom possess accents identical to those spoken in the American south.

* {{Atlantis}}: Since the Equestrians have not been forthcoming when it comes to their origins when it comes to the Wizarding World (they were VERY forthcoming with the Muggle Government), Dumbledore has been forced to work under the assumption that they are from Atlantis based on their idiosyncrasies and extremely powerful magic, and according to Wizarding mythology Atlantis is a powerful island nation magicly hidden from the rest of the world and is believed to be the cradle of Wizarding civilization.

Updates on Mondays and Thursdays (and every 100 up-votes on FiMFiction).

* BackFromTheDead: Using Ancient Equestrian magic the first year Gryffindors manage to do this to “Moaning” Myrtle Warren to the shock and confusion of the Wizarding World as up until then such a complete resurrection was thought to be impossible and the fact that the ritual required a willing unicorn participent goes against everything they believe about necromancy as British Unicorns are creatures of pure light and necromancy is seen as the most evil of dark magic.