Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / ICantBeAMagicalGirlYouAMagicalGirlSay

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForWantOfANail: Izuku becoming a magical girl changes the story, from major things like [[spoiler:Izuku dying and becoming the front-line warrior against Residue/Gray Men]] to potentially minor things like [[spoiler:Bakugou never being caught by the sludge villain]].

to:

* ForWantOfANail: Izuku becoming a magical girl changes the story, story drastically, from major things extremely visible points like [[spoiler:Izuku dying and becoming the front-line warrior against Residue/Gray Men]] to potentially minor things commonly overlooked points like [[spoiler:Bakugou never being caught by the sludge villain]].villain because of Izuku's death]].

Added: 511

Changed: 21

Removed: 118

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Izuku dies and is subsequently resurrected in the very first chapter. [[spoiler: Reminders of his death cause him to panic and even dissociate at times.]]

to:

* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Izuku [[spoiler:Izuku dies and is subsequently resurrected in the very first chapter. [[spoiler: Reminders of his death cause him to panic and even dissociate at times.]]



* TheCutie: Partially averted, but mostly it's just Izuku being himself. He can't help it. The boy's a cinnamon roll. That being said, he has more in mind than just petting bunnies.



* ForWantOfANail: Izuku becoming a magical girl changes the story, from major things like [[spoiler:Izuku dying and becoming the front-line warrior against Residue/Gray Men]] to potentially minor things like [[spoiler:Bakugou never being caught by the sludge villain]].



* KillTheCutie: [[spoiler: Izuku dies in the first chapter.]]



* {{Moe}}: Partially subverted, but mostly it's just Izuku being himself. He can't help it. The boy's a cinnamon roll.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Meido: Justified and partially subverted, because Izuku is a boy. [[spoiler: And though Handyman likes making magical dresses, actually, Izuku does like wearing them, even though it took Handyman putting him in one to admit it.]]

to:

* Meido: {{Meido}}: Justified and partially subverted, because Izuku is a boy. [[spoiler: And though Handyman likes making magical dresses, actually, Izuku does like wearing them, even though it took Handyman putting him in one to admit it.]]



* Moe: Partially subverted, but mostly it's just Izuku being himself. He can't help it. The boy's a cinnamon roll.

to:

* Moe: {{Moe}}: Partially subverted, but mostly it's just Izuku being himself. He can't help it. The boy's a cinnamon roll.

Added: 631

Changed: 425

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Meido: Justified and partially subverted, because Izuku is a boy. [[spoiler: And though Handyman likes making magical dresses, actually, Izuku does like wearing them, even though it took Handyman putting him in one to admit it.]]



* MommasBoy: A huge element of this fic. Just like in canon, he has a very close relationship with his mother. [[spoiler:Their relationship, though, is a mess due to their lack of communication. Their relationship is also rooted in Midoriya Inko's, and thus Izuku's, belief in his lack of power and lessened capabilities. Their relationship is one of the causes for Izuku's low self-esteem, even if Inko didn't intend for it.]]

to:

* Moe: Partially subverted, but mostly it's just Izuku being himself. He can't help it. The boy's a cinnamon roll.
* MommasBoy: A huge element of this fic. Just like in canon, he has a very close relationship with his mother. [[spoiler:Their relationship, though, is a mess due to their lack of communication. Their relationship It is also partially rooted in Midoriya Inko's, and thus Izuku's, belief in his lack of power and lessened capabilities. Their relationship It is one of the causes for Izuku's low self-esteem, even if Inko didn't intend for it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HumansAreFlawed: There are several characters who make many mistakes that has either a minor or major affect on the world around them. [[spoilers: Acknowledging and attempting to correct those flaws will be important in improving their own state of being as well as others.]]

to:

* HumansAreFlawed: There are several characters who make many mistakes that has either a minor or major affect on the world around them. [[spoilers: [[spoiler: Acknowledging and attempting to correct those flaws will be important in improving their own state of being as well as others.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ALighterShadeOfGrey: Major governing characters are continuously attempting to prove this. Inspector Yayoi has to explain this as far as the magical girl system when asked why young girls were usually chosen to be warriors, and Detective Tsukauchi has to prove he's this to Inko when he sends 15-year-old Izuku as Minute Maid to stop a Gray Man attack [[spoiler:in which Izuku is impaled through the chest with a pole and experiences another near-death]].


Added DiffLines:

* EvilEvolves: The Residue/Gray Men are constantly evolving their abilities and sizes, either through feeding off of human quirks or through MonstrousCannibalism [[spoiler:in their pursuit to become human]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheScapegoat: Izuku. Mass media moguls like Tazmine Gal will often directly correlate Residue/Gray Man activity to Minute Maid, even going as far as to say that Minute Maid is the cause of the disaster. Through glimpses of media, like Twitter posts and interviews, it's shown that the media personalities aren't the only ones suspecting Minute Maid of being ObviouslyEvil or a DevilInPlainSight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku, big time. Because of his quirklessness and his social status, he's not accustomed to talking with other people than his mother very often. [[spoilers:This comes particularly strongly when talking with law enforcement because he became a vigilante when he started using his magical powers.]]

to:

* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku, big time. Because of his quirklessness and his social status, he's not accustomed to talking with other people than his mother very often. [[spoilers:This [[spoiler:This comes particularly strongly when talking with law enforcement because he became a vigilante when he started using his magical powers.]]

Added: 535

Removed: 215

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OriginalCharacter: Oh boy, there are ''a lot'' of them. Handyman, Inspector Yayoi, Detective Hashiro, Nightquake, Climantine, Mach Barrier, Blackjack, Falcon, Copper Devil, and Shimizu Mako are just to name a few.



* OriginalCharacter: Oh boy, there are ''a lot'' of them. Handyman, Inspector Yayoi, Detective Hashiro, Nightquake, Climantine, Mach Barrier, Blackjack, Falcon, Copper Devil, and Shimizu Mako are just to name a few.


Added DiffLines:

* SociallyAwkwardHero: Izuku, big time. Because of his quirklessness and his social status, he's not accustomed to talking with other people than his mother very often. [[spoilers:This comes particularly strongly when talking with law enforcement because he became a vigilante when he started using his magical powers.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OriginalCharacter: Oh boy, there are ''a lot'' of them. Handyman, Inspector Yayoi, Detective Hashiro, Nightquake, Climantine, Mach Barrier, Blackjack, Falcon, Copper Devil, and Shimizu Mako are just to name a few.

Added: 704

Changed: 226

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HumansAreFlawed: There are several characters who make many mistakes that has either a minor or major affect on the world around them. [[spoilers: Acknowledging and attempting to correct those flaws will be important in improving their own state of being as well as others.]]



* MommasBoy: A huge element of this fic. Just like in canon, he has a very close relationship with his mother. [[spoiler:Their relationship, though, is a mess due to their lack of communication. Their relationship is also rooted in Midoriya Inko's, and thus Izuku's, belief in his lack of power and lessened capabilities. Their relationship is one of the causes for Izuku's low self-esteem, even if Inko didn't intend for it.]]



* SenseiChan: Mostly Averted. She is a subjectively attractive teacher with a close relationship with her student, Izuku, but she has explicitly expressed [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781/chapters/33049623 no romantic interest in him whatsoever]].

to:

* SenseiChan: Mostly Averted. She is a subjectively attractive teacher with a close relationship with her student, Izuku, but she has explicitly expressed [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781/chapters/33049623 no romantic interest in him whatsoever]]. [[spoiler:She is also too young to fully fit the trope, as she's 22. Still, her age in relation to Izuku causes her to feel uncomfortable with being called "sensei", which prompts her to prefer being called "senpai" instead.]]

Added: 583

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanBoy: Izuku still has his several hero notebooks, with ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781/chapters/33049623 even the police impressed by his attention to detail]]''.

to:

* FanBoy: Izuku still has his several hero notebooks, with ''[[https://archiveofourown.[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781/chapters/33049623 even the police impressed by his attention to detail]]''.detail]].


Added DiffLines:

* HeroicSelfDeprecation: Izuku constantly doesn't recognize the improvements he's made since starting his battles against the Residues/Gray Men. In those moments, Handyman acts as his BestFriend by praising him.


Added DiffLines:

* ParentalSubstitute: Shimizu Mako, to an extent. She gives him the support he wishes his mother would give him.


Added DiffLines:

* SenseiChan: Mostly Averted. She is a subjectively attractive teacher with a close relationship with her student, Izuku, but she has explicitly expressed [[https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781/chapters/33049623 no romantic interest in him whatsoever]].

Added: 181

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: Despite it being the year 2224, there is not much different from normal society save for the heroics and villainy that's a common entity in various Boku no Hero AlternateUniverses.

to:

* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: Despite it being the year 2224, there is not much different from normal society save for the heroics and villainy that's a common entity in various Boku no Hero AlternateUniverses.AlternateUniverseFic.


Added DiffLines:

* FanBoy: Izuku still has his several hero notebooks, with ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781/chapters/33049623 even the police impressed by his attention to detail]]''.

Added: 404

Changed: 59

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: Despite it being the year 2224 [[spoiler:, the year that Izuku dies,]] there is not much different from normal society save for the heroics and villainy that's a common entity in the Boku no Hero Universe.

to:

* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: Despite it being the year 2224 [[spoiler:, the year that Izuku dies,]] 2224, there is not much different from normal society save for the heroics and villainy that's a common entity in the various Boku no Hero Universe.AlternateUniverses.


Added DiffLines:

* AnimalMotifs: Izuku's outfit motif is both of maids and of rabbits.


Added DiffLines:

* EldritchAbomination: The Handyman, apparently. They have been described as being a strange, white rabbit with glowing pink eyes and multiple pupils[[spoiler:, but they apparently have many more eyes, enough to fill a whole room with many of various sizes. The rabbit form also sports a set of very sharp fangs with which they grin]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Information

Added DiffLines:

* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: Despite it being the year 2224 [[spoiler:, the year that Izuku dies,]] there is not much different from normal society save for the heroics and villainy that's a common entity in the Boku no Hero Universe.
* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: Izuku dies and is subsequently resurrected in the very first chapter. [[spoiler: Reminders of his death cause him to panic and even dissociate at times.]]

Added: 102

Removed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SharkMan:Izuku's Muay Thai instructor is 22 year-old Shimuzu Mako, who has a mutant type shark Quirk.


Added DiffLines:

*SharkMan: Izuku's Muay Thai instructor, Shimuzu Mako has a shark mutation quirk similar to Gang Orca.

Added: 553

Changed: 552

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RecruitTeenagersWithAttitude: JustifiedTrope, as said by Inspector Yayoi, ''“Because even when the adults are called on, it doesn’t mean they’ll act. Girls, young ones, who are often socially discriminated against, who have their emotions demeaned and caricatured, who are often told more what they can’t do rather than what they can, would fight tooth and nail to feel important, like the things they do actually mean something, like they can affect the world around them. It's often the young girls that feel the need for power, and so the universe grants it to them, knowing they often will use it when given a target…”''

to:

* RecruitTeenagersWithAttitude: JustifiedTrope, as said by Inspector Yayoi, ''“Because Yayoi:
-->''“Because
even when the adults are called on, it doesn’t mean they’ll act. Girls, young ones, who are often socially discriminated against, who have their emotions demeaned and caricatured, who are often told more what they can’t do rather than what they can, would fight tooth and nail to feel important, like the things they do actually mean something, like they can affect the world around them. It's often the young girls that feel the need for power, and so the universe grants it to them, knowing they often will use it when given a target…”''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/magical_girl_deku_1.png]]
[[caption-width-right:350: Magical Girl Izuku, fanart by ''[[https://tax-cannot-draw-sry.tumblr.com/post/166480795634/curving-their-body-midair-the-kid-landed-feet tax-cannot-draw-sry]]'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 67

Removed: 67

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I put it in the wrong place alphabetically. Cut me some slack, it's 3:19 am <:3


* GovernmentAgencyofFiction: The International Special Forces Unit.



* GovernmentAgencyofFiction: The International Special Forces Unit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Eh, it's informative

Added DiffLines:

* GratuitousJapanese: The characters often use Japanese suffixes when referring to each other. Not in all cases, as hero names and job titles get English prefixes instead. i.e. Detective Tsukauchi and Mx. Nightquake vs Midoriya-san.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*AwesomeByAnalysis: Much like in canon, Izuku. Shimuzu Mako, a Muay Thai practitioner notes that he's able to pick up on her moves after watching her a few times (albeit forgetting that he doesn't have to compensate for a tail) and it helps him out against the Gray Men.


Added DiffLines:

*BarrierWarrior:One of the pro hero OCs,Mach Barrier can create barriers from the air.


Added DiffLines:

*FloweryElizabethanEnglish: Or, Japanese. The pro hero Nightquake talks like this. Mach Barrier is surprised that they actually just talk like that, and aren't just putting it on.


Added DiffLines:

*OhCrap: Detective Naomasa and company have a massive one when they realise [[spoiler:that the Gray Man they just captured is intending to absorb all the other Gray Men that couldn't be defeated by Minute Maid that are locked up in Tartarus]].
*ParasolOfPain: A cute umbrella Izuku buys gets modified into this by Handyman. It's used more in the shield sense to protect civilians from a collapsing building.


Added DiffLines:

*PrehensileHair: The pro hero Nightquake has incredibly strong hair that can be used to restrain opponents.


Added DiffLines:

*RequiredSecondaryPowers: The Gray Men can't steal Quirks, but they can steal aspects of or potential to use them. In Chapter 9 a young man with an ice quirk [[spoiler:later revealed to be one of Shouto Todoroki's older brothers]] is attacked. Later on it's mentioned that the Gray Man took his ability to regulate his own temperature, and that he now can't create more than a mild frost without getting hypothermia and going into a coma.
* SharkMan:Izuku's Muay Thai instructor is 22 year-old Shimuzu Mako, who has a mutant type shark Quirk.


Added DiffLines:

*WeatherManipulation: Pro hero Climantine is able to manipulate water in the air and thus change the weather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SecretIdentity: Because Minute Maid is obviously a girl with a Light Quirk, Izuku reasons no one would suspect a Quirkless boy to be "her".

Added: 4

Changed: 224

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, a Magical Girl, Say Is an Alternate Universe MyHeroAcademia fanfic by [=RMXStudio=]. It can be found here https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781

to:

''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781 I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, a Magical Girl, Say Is an Alternate Universe MyHeroAcademia fanfic Say]]'' is a ''Manga/MyHeroAcademia'' AlternateUniverseFic by [=RMXStudio=]. It can be found here https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781
[=RMXStudio=].



This story thus details Midoriya Izuku's life as a magical girl in the world of heroes

to:

This story thus details Midoriya Izuku's life as a magical girl in the world of heroes
heroes.



!!'''I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, A Magical Girl, Say contains examples of:'''

to:

!!'''I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, A Magical Girl, Say !!This fanfic contains examples of:'''
of:



* CrackFic: The author describes the premise as 'Crack Treated Seriously'

to:

* CrackFic: The author describes the premise as 'Crack Treated Seriously'Seriously'.



* WingdingEyes: Part of Izuku's transformation turns his irises and pupils into yellow four pointed stars.

to:

* WingdingEyes: Part of Izuku's transformation turns his irises and pupils into yellow four pointed stars.stars.

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ClingyMacGuffin: Handyman takes the form of a watch that can't be taken off.

to:

* ClingyMacGuffin: Handyman takes the form of a watch on his right wrist that can't be taken off.

Added: 599

Changed: -10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BagOfHolding: Since Izuku was wearing his trademark backpack during the slime villain attack, it becomes part of his magical girl outfit and can now hold way more than what its size suggests when transformed.

to:

* BagOfHolding: Since Izuku was wearing his trademark backpack during the slime villain Sludge Villain attack, it becomes part of his magical girl outfit and can now hold way more than what its size suggests when transformed.



* FrillsOfJustice: Like many examples in the genre Izuku's magical girl outfit has a frilly skirt, collar, socks fingerless gloves and an apron.

to:

* FrillsOfJustice: Like many examples in the genre Izuku's magical girl outfit has a frilly skirt, collar, socks socks, fingerless gloves and an apron.



* RecruitTeenagersWithAttitude: JustifiedTrope, as said by Inspector Yayoi, “Because even when the adults are called on, it doesn’t mean they’ll act. Girls, young ones, who are often socially discriminated against, who have their emotions demeaned and caricatured, who are often told more what they can’t do rather than what they can, would fight tooth and nail to feel important, like the things they do actually mean something, like they can affect the world around them. It's often the young girls that feel the need for power, and so the universe grants it to them, knowing they often will use it when given a target…”

to:

* RecruitTeenagersWithAttitude: JustifiedTrope, as said by Inspector Yayoi, “Because ''“Because even when the adults are called on, it doesn’t mean they’ll act. Girls, young ones, who are often socially discriminated against, who have their emotions demeaned and caricatured, who are often told more what they can’t do rather than what they can, would fight tooth and nail to feel important, like the things they do actually mean something, like they can affect the world around them. It's often the young girls that feel the need for power, and so the universe grants it to them, knowing they often will use it when given a target…”target…”''
*SchoolBullyingIsHarmless: Averted big style. Handyman points out at one point that if Izuku's HealingFactor wasn't there, one of Bakugou's attacks should have left ''2nd degree burns'' and that covering for him in order to not screw up Bakugou's chances of becoming a hero won't help either of them in the long run.
*StockShoujoBullyingTactics: Coming back to school after the Sludge Villain incident, Izuku find himself on the receiving end of the flowers on desk for a funeral tactic, complete with envelope for the next life with "''A Quirk ''" written inside it. It's as upsetting as it sounds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BreakingTheFourthWall: The Handyman has his moments...


Added DiffLines:

* WholesomeCrossdresser: Oh, ''Izuku''. It has the effect to help him hide his identity, since everyone meeting him in his FrillsOfJustice immediately concludes he's a girl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, a Magical Girl, Say Is an Alternate Universe MyHeroAcademia fanfic by RMXStudio. It can be found here https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781

to:

I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, a Magical Girl, Say Is an Alternate Universe MyHeroAcademia fanfic by RMXStudio.[=RMXStudio=]. It can be found here https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781



'''I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, A Magical Girl, Say contains examples of:'''

to:

'''I !!'''I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, A Magical Girl, Say contains examples of:'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Glamour: In his transformed state, the only thing witnesses can remember about his face is his WingdingEyes. This allows him to go unrecognised without needing a mask or ClarkKenting. It also affects camera footage.

to:

* Glamour: {{Glamour}}: In his transformed state, the only thing witnesses can remember about his face is his WingdingEyes. This allows him to go unrecognised without needing a mask or ClarkKenting. It also affects camera footage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, a Magical Girl, Say Is an Alternate Universe MyHeroAcademia fanfic by RMXStudio. It can be found here https://archiveofourown.org/works/11654781

Magic.

It's like entropy--inaccessable energy in a system. To have magic is to break the rules of your universe, and to become a magical girl is to take that power and use it for good.

April 10th, Izuku broke the rules of his universe, and now, with the world facing a growing, seemingly undefeatable threat, he and his Handyman get ready for the ride of a lifetime.

This story thus details Midoriya Izuku's life as a magical girl in the world of heroes

----
'''I Can't Be A Magical Girl!! You, A Magical Girl, Say contains examples of:'''

*AlternateUniverseFic: All Might arrives slightly too late to save Izuku, and he is saved by a mysterious entity known as 'The Handyman' who turns him into a magical girl.
*BadassAdorable: Izuku, even more so than in canon now that he's wearing a cute magical girl outfit.
*BagOfHolding: Since Izuku was wearing his trademark backpack during the slime villain attack, it becomes part of his magical girl outfit and can now hold way more than what its size suggests when transformed.
*ClingyMacGuffin: Handyman takes the form of a watch that can't be taken off.
*CrackFic: The author describes the premise as 'Crack Treated Seriously'
*FrillsOfJustice: Like many examples in the genre Izuku's magical girl outfit has a frilly skirt, collar, socks fingerless gloves and an apron.
*Glamour: In his transformed state, the only thing witnesses can remember about his face is his WingdingEyes. This allows him to go unrecognised without needing a mask or ClarkKenting. It also affects camera footage.
*GovernmentAgencyofFiction: The International Special Forces Unit.
*HairDecorations: Izuku gets a bunny shaped hairclip as part of his transformation.
*HealingFactor: Part of the transformation into a magical girl is that his cells now run on magic, allowing him to quickly heal small injuries. Bigger ones need more time.
*MagicalGirlWarrior: Izuku becoming one instead of receiving One for All is the premise of the story.
*MentorMascot: Handyman. He aids Izuku in his quest against the Residues/Gray Men by explaining his powers, regulating his HealingFactor and occasionally upgrading items Izuku finds to be more useful in combat. Unlike most examples, he's not a cute animal, but a watch that doubles as a TransformationTrinket.
*PowerGlows: Izuku in Magical Girl form. It makes All Might believe he has a quirk when they first meet this time round.
*Really700YearsOld: Inspector Yayoi Gin, of the International Special Forces Unit called in to investigate Izuku's activities as Minute Maid and the Gray men.
*RecruitTeenagersWithAttitude: JustifiedTrope, as said by Inspector Yayoi, “Because even when the adults are called on, it doesn’t mean they’ll act. Girls, young ones, who are often socially discriminated against, who have their emotions demeaned and caricatured, who are often told more what they can’t do rather than what they can, would fight tooth and nail to feel important, like the things they do actually mean something, like they can affect the world around them. It's often the young girls that feel the need for power, and so the universe grants it to them, knowing they often will use it when given a target…”
*TransformationTrinket: Handyman.
*WingdingEyes: Part of Izuku's transformation turns his irises and pupils into yellow four pointed stars.

Top