Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / Goldstein

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassRealization: Yehudah, during his fight with Terry. First he learns that Terry was only signing him up to go home for Easter break, but he's still reluctant to apologize. Eventually he writes Rabbi Zeller, asking if he's obligated to apologize to someone who isn't Jewish...and, upon realizing that he can't even find a way to ''phrase'' that question without sounding like a jerk, figures out the answer for himself.

to:

* JerkassRealization: Yehudah, during his fight with Terry. First he learns that Terry was only signing him up to go home for Easter break, but he's still reluctant to apologize. Eventually he writes Rabbi Zeller, asking if he's obligated to apologize to someone who isn't Jewish... and, upon realizing that he can't even find a way to ''phrase'' that question without sounding like a jerk, figures out the answer for himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBrotherInstinct: Terry, toward Benjamin...despite there being less than a year between their ages.

to:

* BigBrotherInstinct: Terry, toward Benjamin... despite there being less than a year between their ages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Useful Notes aren't tropes.


* UsefulNotes/JewishHolidays: They all get a mention, except for the ones during summer break. Yehudah spends some of them at a nearby Chabad house, while others he manages to celebrate at Hogwarts.
* UsefulNotes/JewishLifeEvents: Preparations for Yehudah's bar mitzvah come into focus after he turns twelve. At another point he starts to explain why his newborn brother doesn't have a name yet, but stops himself from trying to explain a bris to the other Ravenclaws.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodParents: Yehudah's parents are very strict but loving parents whom Yehudah is very reluctant to part with.

to:

* GoodParents: Yehudah's parents are very strict but loving parents whom Yehudah is very reluctant to part with. Yehudah notes if his parents were told about Voldemort, they would never have let him go to Hogwarts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Being born to a muggle family, Yehuda has little knowledge of the wizarding world and its politics. Michael is taken aback that Yehuda knows nothing about Harry Potter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeconstructionFic: The story deconstructs how religious customs and norms interact with the wizarding world. Even without religious bigotry, there is still a bit of friction over lifestyles and ways of life, with the staff needing to make some accommodations for Yehudah.

to:

* DeconstructionFic: The story deconstructs how religious customs and norms interact with the wizarding world. Even without religious bigotry, there is still a bit of friction over lifestyles and ways of life, with Yehuda trying to hold onto his traditions while upholding the staff needing to make some accommodations for Yehudah.norms of Hogwarts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeconstructionFic: The story deconstructs how religious customs and norms interact with the wizarding world. Even without religious bigotry, there is still a bit of friction over lifestyles and ways of life.

to:

* DeconstructionFic: The story deconstructs how religious customs and norms interact with the wizarding world. Even without religious bigotry, there is still a bit of friction over lifestyles and ways of life.life, with the staff needing to make some accommodations for Yehudah.

Added: 132

Changed: 76

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContrastingSequelMainCharacter: Harry was raised by a small family that he doesn't like, is happy to be a wizard and sees Hogwarts as his true home. Yehudah is basically the opposite of all that. Their Sortings are particularly noteworthy: the Hat says that Harry has a "thirst to prove himself" and almost puts him in Slytherin, but quickly rules out Slytherin for Yehudah, noting that he prefers a quiet life to any sort of ambition. (Yehudah's immediate thought: "Of course, who wouldn't?")

to:

* ContrastingSequelMainCharacter: Harry was raised by a small family that he doesn't like, is happy to be a wizard and sees Hogwarts as his true home. Yehudah is basically the opposite of all that.that, coming from a large, insular, and religious family that he genuinely loves. Their Sortings are particularly noteworthy: the Hat says that Harry has a "thirst to prove himself" and almost puts him in Slytherin, but quickly rules out Slytherin for Yehudah, noting that he prefers a quiet life to any sort of ambition. (Yehudah's immediate thought: "Of course, who wouldn't?")


Added DiffLines:

* TheSpock: Yehudah has shades of this, being quiet, reserved, and studious. The Sorting Hat declares him a good fit for Ravenclaw.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeconstructionFic: The story deconstructs how religious customs and norms interact with the wizarding world. Even without religious bigotry, there is still a bit of friction over lifestyles and ways of life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While [=McGonagall=] is adamant about Yehuda going to Hogwarts, she's willing to accommodate his spiritual needs like ensuring the house elves give him kosher food and allowing him time off to celebrate the High Holy Days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CulturalPosturing: [[SadistTeacher Snape]] believes strongly in wizarding pride, and yells at Yehuda for using a notebook and pen when "proper" wizards use quills and parchment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GoodShepherd: Rabbi Zeller, who provides Yehuda with spiritual guidance and encouragement in his quest to control his magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PickyEater: Yehudah mainly sticks to fruit and vegetables at Hogwarts. Justified since he eats strictly kosher.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GoodParents: Yehudah's parents are very strict but loving parents whom Yehudah is very reluctant to part with.


Added DiffLines:

* SugarAndIcePersonality; Meir Goldstein is a very strict father but he gives Yehudah a parting hug before sending him off to Hogwarts.

Top