Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 40 (click to see context) from:
* ConfirmationBias: Henrietta's major problem, besides her Catarina-specific sadism. Henrietta is so emotionally fixated on Catarina's suffering for catharsis that she can't imagine a world where she isn't right to want Catarina to suffer. As such, she does everything she can to validate her sadism towards Catarina by [[SelectiveObliviousness only acknowledging things she can spin to support her perspective]] and even seemingly [[BelievingTheirOwnLies rewriting events to herself]] to comform to her beliefs.
to:
* ConfirmationBias: InUniverse. Henrietta's major problem, flaw, besides her Catarina-specific sadism. Henrietta is so emotionally fixated on Catarina's suffering for catharsis that she can't imagine a world where she isn't right to want Catarina to suffer. As such, she does everything she can to validate her sadism towards Catarina by [[SelectiveObliviousness only acknowledging things she can spin to support her perspective]] and even seemingly [[BelievingTheirOwnLies rewriting events to herself]] to comform to her beliefs.belief that Catarina is evil and deserves to suffer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 40 (click to see context) from:
* ConfirmationBias: Henrietta's major problem which causes her SelectiveOblivious behavior. Henrietta is so emotionally fixated on Catarina's suffering for catharsis that she can't imagine a world where she isn't right to want Catarina to suffer. As such, she does everything she can to validate her sadism towards Catarina and proclaims the world unjust when Catarina doesn't die a KarmicDeath.
to:
* ConfirmationBias: Henrietta's major problem which causes problem, besides her SelectiveOblivious behavior.Catarina-specific sadism. Henrietta is so emotionally fixated on Catarina's suffering for catharsis that she can't imagine a world where she isn't right to want Catarina to suffer. As such, she does everything she can to validate her sadism towards Catarina by [[SelectiveObliviousness only acknowledging things she can spin to support her perspective]] and proclaims the world unjust when Catarina doesn't die a KarmicDeath.even seemingly [[BelievingTheirOwnLies rewriting events to herself]] to comform to her beliefs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ConfirmationBias: Henrietta's major problem which causes her SelectiveOblivious behavior. Henrietta is so emotionally fixated on Catarina's suffering for catharsis that she can't imagine a world where she isn't right to want Catarina to suffer. As such, she does everything she can to validate her sadism towards Catarina and proclaims the world unjust when Catarina doesn't die a KarmicDeath.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 39 (click to see context) from:
* ChekovsGift: In chapter 5, Francine gifts her friends Catarina, Sam, and Emily handkerchiefs, each uniquely hand-embroidered and decorated with her initials as an artist's signature. [[spoiler:In chapter 9, Henrietta loses a handkerchief while fleeing from the scene of her attempted murder. The handkerchief has Francine's initials on it.]]
to:
* ChekovsGift: ChekhovsGift: In chapter 5, Francine gifts her friends Catarina, Sam, and Emily handkerchiefs, each uniquely hand-embroidered and decorated with her initials as an artist's signature. [[spoiler:In chapter 9, Henrietta loses a handkerchief while fleeing from the scene of her attempted murder. The handkerchief has Francine's initials on it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 39 (click to see context) from:
* ChekovsGun: In chapter 5, Francine gifts her friends Catarina, Sam, and Emily handkerchiefs, each uniquely hand-embroidered and decorated with her initials as an artist's signature. [[spoiler:In chapter 9, Henrietta loses a handkerchief while fleeing from the scene of her attempted murder. The handkerchief has Francine's initials on it.]]
to:
* ChekovsGun: ChekovsGift: In chapter 5, Francine gifts her friends Catarina, Sam, and Emily handkerchiefs, each uniquely hand-embroidered and decorated with her initials as an artist's signature. [[spoiler:In chapter 9, Henrietta loses a handkerchief while fleeing from the scene of her attempted murder. The handkerchief has Francine's initials on it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ChekovsGun: In chapter 5, Francine gifts her friends Catarina, Sam, and Emily handkerchiefs, each uniquely hand-embroidered and decorated with her initials as an artist's signature. [[spoiler:In chapter 9, Henrietta loses a handkerchief while fleeing from the scene of her attempted murder. The handkerchief has Francine's initials on it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* BelievingTheirOwnLies: Henrietta refuses to acknowledge that this Catarina is different from the one in the game; even when Catarina's actions right in front of Henrietta directly contradict her game characterization, to the increasing concern of those around her. The only time Henrietta is open and accepting of a possible difference from the game at all is when it allows her to rationalize ways this Catarina could be ''differently'' evil, such as when Henrietta convinces herself this Catarina is intricately manipulating others and merely ''pretending'' to be a good person as a long con, despite Catarina's game incarnation famously not being that intelligent (Henrietta's surprised to hear that this Catarina isn't at the bottom of the pack academically) and possessing little subtlety. Henrietta's only open to accepting differences from the game when they allow her to give herself new reasons to hate Catarina.
Added DiffLines:
* SelectiveObliviousness: Henrietta only accepts events she can rationalize as conforming to her view of Catarina as an evil person. Even after Maria and Keith have refused to denounce Catarina, Henrietta brushes this off as fear of standing up for themselves, ignoring the fact that even that would be proof that events are not following the game, as they did denounce her in ''Fortune Lover.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* EstablishingCharacterMoment: During her recollection of her PastLifeMemories, Henrietta recalls that when she played ''Fortune Lover'', her reaction to Catarina's death in the Bad End of Keith's route isn't shock or horror but rather ''glee'', seeing a bully like the one's that torment her in real life to brutally die as cathartic. It sets up her obsession for Catarina's brutal death in her new life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 35 (click to see context) from:
* BullyHunter: Played with. Catarina garners a reputation as someone who refuses to let others be bullied, best demonstrated when she steps forward to defend Maria and later Francine Ridgeway. She also did this for Emily Carrington at one point. Samantha Bale is another noble who shares Catarina's views and is inspired by her example, defending girls like Francine and Emily when Catarina's not around. It's said that Catarina's influence leads to the toxic social cliques the academy's infamous for dissolving.
to:
* BullyHunter: BullyHunter:
** Played with. Catarina garners a reputation as someone who refuses to let others be bullied, best demonstrated when she steps forward to defend Maria and later Francine Ridgeway. She also did this for Emily Carrington at one point. Samantha Bale is another noble who shares Catarina's views and is inspired by her example, defending girls like Francine and Emily when Catarina's not around. It's said that Catarina's influence leads to the toxic social cliques the academy's infamous fordissolving.dissolving.
** Henrietta fancies herself one, punishing Catarina for her bullying by ensuring she meets her Doom. Unfortunately, she's working from the false premise that Catarina Claes is exactly like her ''Fortune Lover'' counterpart, and she gets violent when this turns out to be anything but true.
** Played with. Catarina garners a reputation as someone who refuses to let others be bullied, best demonstrated when she steps forward to defend Maria and later Francine Ridgeway. She also did this for Emily Carrington at one point. Samantha Bale is another noble who shares Catarina's views and is inspired by her example, defending girls like Francine and Emily when Catarina's not around. It's said that Catarina's influence leads to the toxic social cliques the academy's infamous for
** Henrietta fancies herself one, punishing Catarina for her bullying by ensuring she meets her Doom. Unfortunately, she's working from the false premise that Catarina Claes is exactly like her ''Fortune Lover'' counterpart, and she gets violent when this turns out to be anything but true.
Changed line(s) 38 (click to see context) from:
* EvenEvilHasStandards: Downplayed, since Sirius/Raphael isn't truly evil to begin with. He begins using dark magic to manipulate Henrietta, thinking she'll be useful for his plot to have Catarina expelled and exiled. But when Henrietta openly suggests having Catarina killed and then says she'd be willing to kill her while Sirius is manipulating her, Sirius immediately undoes the manipulation, wipes memory of their conversation from Henrietta's mind, and then crosses Henrietta's name off a list of potential pawns because the idea of having an innocent woman killed is abhorrent to him.
to:
* EvenEvilHasStandards: EvenEvilHasStandards:
** Downplayed, since Sirius/Raphael isn't truly evil to begin with. He begins using dark magic to manipulate Henrietta, thinking she'll be useful for his plot to have Catarina expelled and exiled. But when Henrietta openly suggests having Catarina killed and then says she'd be willing to kill her while Sirius is manipulating her, Sirius immediately undoes the manipulation, wipes memory of their conversation from Henrietta's mind, and then crosses Henrietta's name off a list of potential pawns because the idea of having an innocent woman killed is abhorrent tohim.him.
** [[spoiler: Henrietta only wants to kill Catarina Claes because she's deluded herself into thinking that Catarina was still a bully. When it's ''finally'' forced through her head that she tried to kill an innocent woman, she's horrified.]]
** Downplayed, since Sirius/Raphael isn't truly evil to begin with. He begins using dark magic to manipulate Henrietta, thinking she'll be useful for his plot to have Catarina expelled and exiled. But when Henrietta openly suggests having Catarina killed and then says she'd be willing to kill her while Sirius is manipulating her, Sirius immediately undoes the manipulation, wipes memory of their conversation from Henrietta's mind, and then crosses Henrietta's name off a list of potential pawns because the idea of having an innocent woman killed is abhorrent to
** [[spoiler: Henrietta only wants to kill Catarina Claes because she's deluded herself into thinking that Catarina was still a bully. When it's ''finally'' forced through her head that she tried to kill an innocent woman, she's horrified.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 61 (click to see context) from:
* KarmaHoudini: After Catarina's doom doesn't come, Henrietta views Catarina as this and decides [[AssassinationAttempt that she has to kill Catarina herself]] in order to bring about a "just" ending. {{Subverted|trope}} because ''this'' Catarina has [[AllLovingHero little to no bad karma]].
to:
* KarmaHoudini: After Part of Henrietta's WrongGenreSavvy is that after Catarina's doom Doom never happens, she still doesn't come, Henrietta views realize that [[AllLovingHero this Catarina as this and decides [[AssassinationAttempt was a good person]] who had ''good'' karma, instead concluding that she has to kill Catarina herself]] in order had somehow found a way to bring about cheat her Doom- and resolves that the only way to get a "just" ending. {{Subverted|trope}} because ''this'' ending is to kill Catarina has [[AllLovingHero little to no bad karma]].herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added DiffLines:
* ThinksLikeARomanceNovel: This trait of Sophia's, already seen in the source material, comes in handy when Catarina has to explain the concept of "otome games" while [[InternalReveal revealing]] her PastLifeMemories in Chapter 13. When she describes otome games as a kind of romantic fiction where the player attempts to win the heart of a character, her audience is initially mystified... save for the romance-loving Sophia, who takes over and further simplifies it as "a romance novel where you make the story yourself".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 44 (click to see context) from:
* FrameUp: Henrietta attempts to frame [[FanFic/LostAndFound Estella Morel]] for the attack on Catarina.
to:
* FrameUp: Henrietta attempts to frame [[FanFic/LostAndFound [[FanFic/LostAndFoundRosamundRosemary Estella Morel]] for the attack on Catarina.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 105 (click to see context) from:
* WokenUpAtAnUngodlyHour: In the {{omake}} ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/31809781 A Parent's Worst Nightmare]]'', when the news of Catarina's AssassinationAttempt arrives at the Claes mansion, Duke and Lady Claes have already gone to bed. While Duke Claes is relatively calm at being waken up at this hour, this is not the case for Lady Claes.
to:
* WokenUpAtAnUngodlyHour: In the {{omake}} ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/31809781 A Parent's Worst Nightmare]]'', when the news of Catarina's AssassinationAttempt arrives at the Claes mansion, Duke and Lady Madame Claes have already gone to bed. While Duke Claes is relatively calm at being waken up at this hour, this is not the case for Lady Madame Claes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* WokenUpAtAnUngodlyHour: In the {{omake}} ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/31809781 A Parent's Worst Nightmare]]'', when the news of Catarina's AssassinationAttempt arrives at the Claes mansion, Duke and Lady Claes have already gone to bed. While Duke Claes is relatively calm at being waken up at this hour, this is not the case for Lady Claes.
-->She groaned as she woke up, and looked at her husband. "Wha?..what's going on?"
-->"It's about Catarina!" replied Luigi.
-->She continued to wake up and then asked, "What did our daughter do now that required you to be woken up and you to wake me up?"
-->She groaned as she woke up, and looked at her husband. "Wha?..what's going on?"
-->"It's about Catarina!" replied Luigi.
-->She continued to wake up and then asked, "What did our daughter do now that required you to be woken up and you to wake me up?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AccompliceByInaction: Henrietta knew Maria Campbell would be bullied when she entered the academy just as Catarina did. Whereas Catarina went out of her way to help and befriend Maria well beyond any notions of self preservation, Henrietta stood back and did nothing because it would've interfered with Catarina's doom.
* BerserkButton: When Henrietta Garland openly confesses to deliberately trying to kill Catarina with no regrets, the idea of someone as compassionate and good natured as Catarina being victimized sets off several young women who then attack Henrietta. And that includes Henrietta's former best friend Francine.
* DearJohnLetter: [[spoiler:After she's jailed for the murder attempt, Henrietta receives a letter from her fiancé Sherman Billingsley, breaking their engagement and saying he regrets ever having feelings for her.]]
* HatedByAll: Subverted. When Henrietta confesses to trying to murder Catarina, she's immediately attacked by a group of young women and almost killed before Catarina begs her to stop. It's plainly clear that Henrietta's confession turned her into one of the most hated people at the academy. [[spoiler:Catarina is still sympathetic towards her when she finds out the truth behind Henrietta's actions, and she convinces Francine and the others who attacked her to apologize for their actions (Francine was shown to regret what she did even before then).]]
* MisplacedRetribution: In the side omake focusing on the Claes parents, Estella Morel's mother goes to confront them about her daughter's reputation being slandered in this incident. Despite that Geordo and Mary proved Henrietta Garland deliberately tried to frame Estella for the crime, her mother doesn't even consider confronting the Garland family (which still would've been wrong since Henrietta's parents had nothing to do with her actions, but it still would've made more sense than attacking the Claes Family).
* NecessarilyEvil: Played with and deconstructed. Henrietta remembered from ''Fortune Lover'' that Maria Campbell and Keith Claes were horribly bullied and abused by Catarina. While she believes the Catarina of this world is a vile woman and deserves to be punished for her crimes, Henrietta is more than willing to allow the supposed "bullying" to go on if it means Catarina will eventually be judged for her actions. [[spoiler:Geordo and Mary destroy Henrietta's notions of this belief, stating if she actually cared she would've helped Maria and Keith if she really thought they needed it, and was fine with the idea of them suffering in order to see Catarina's doom. She was even willing to watch as others bullied Maria, and still had the nerve of accusing Maria and Keith of being "ungrateful" for "what she's done for them."]]
Changed line(s) 92 (click to see context) from:
* UngratefulBastard: Upon being cleared, Estella begins to insinuate that Catarina was the one who spread the rumor that she attacked her until Mary warns her not to, pointing out that Catarina didn't even realize she was attacked until Geordo and Mary spelled it out for her.
to:
* UngratefulBastard: UngratefulBastard:
** Upon being cleared, Estella begins to insinuate that Catarina was the one who spread the rumor that she attacked her until Mary warns her not to, pointing out that Catarina didn't even realize she was attacked until Geordo and Mary spelled it out for her.
** Upon being cleared, Estella begins to insinuate that Catarina was the one who spread the rumor that she attacked her until Mary warns her not to, pointing out that Catarina didn't even realize she was attacked until Geordo and Mary spelled it out for her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* BullyHunter: Played with. Catarina garners a reputation as someone who refuses to let others be bullied, best demonstrated when she steps forward to defend Maria and later Francine Ridgeway. She also did this for Emily Carrington at one point. Samantha Bale is another noble who shares Catarina's views and is inspired by her example, defending girls like Francine and Emily when Catarina's not around. It's said that Catarina's influence leads to the toxic social cliques the academy's infamous for dissolving.
Added DiffLines:
* NotSoWellIntentionedExtremist: [[spoiler:Geordo and Mary destroy Henrietta's delusions of acting for the greater good. They point out that for all her claims of Catarina abusing people such as Maria, Keith, and various students, Henrietta was more concerned with seeing Catarina punished than actually helping people with her foreknowledge of certain events, and thus was fine with letting all the supposed "bullying" happen if it meant seeing Catarina get exiled or killed.]]
Added DiffLines:
* ReplacementGoldfish: After rejecting Francine as her best friend for siding with Catarina, Henrietta briefly considers a girl named Olivia Hearn as a replacement best friend. After Catarina awakens from her magically-induced coma, in a fit of rage Henrietta rejects Olivia as yet another Catarina supporter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* AscendedExtra: Francine Ridgeway, Samantha Bale, and Emily Carrington are based on a trio of nameless girls whom Catarina was friends with, and whom vocally come to her defense when she's falsely accused of bullying other students. Here, they're given names, backgrounds and personalities as Catarina's "Thursday Lunch Club" friends whom she hangs out with when she's not with Maria and the others.
Added DiffLines:
* SpannerInTheWorks: Henrietta's plan to pin the attempt on Catarina's life on Estella Morel gets derailed thanks to two witnesses. While Henrietta thought of this (which is why she dressed up as Estella in the first place in case anyone saw her), the witnesses pointed out that "Lady Morel" seemed shorter than she should be. One of them followed her and says she saw "Lady Morel" enter a room but only saw Henrietta Garland exit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
''Catarina Claes MUST DIE!'' is a ''LightNovel/MyNextLifeAsAVillainessAllRoutesLeadToDoom'' fanfic by [[https://archiveofourown.org/users/SixthOctavarium/pseuds/SixthOctavarium SixthOctavarium]].
to:
''Catarina Claes MUST DIE!'' is a ''LightNovel/MyNextLifeAsAVillainessAllRoutesLeadToDoom'' ''Literature/MyNextLifeAsAVillainessAllRoutesLeadToDoom'' fanfic by [[https://archiveofourown.org/users/SixthOctavarium/pseuds/SixthOctavarium SixthOctavarium]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 49 (click to see context) from:
* IHaveNoSon: Inverted. After Henrietta is interrogated by Geordo and Mary and realizes that her actions were based on incorrect assumptions, she wrote a letter to her parents stating that as of the day of her actions, she disclaimed herself from House Garland in order to save her family from the fallout. As a result of this and her genuine remorse, Geordo decides to absolve House Garland of blame for their daughter's crime. [[spoiler: And played straight after her parents accept her [[DisinheritedChild disclaim]], telling her via letter that they need time before they will speak to her again. The effect of the disclaim is shown when Henrietta tells Catarina that the latter should address her as ''Miss'' Garland instead of ''Lady''.]]
to:
* IHaveNoSon: Inverted. After Henrietta is interrogated by Geordo and Mary and realizes that her actions were based on incorrect assumptions, she wrote a letter to her parents stating that as of the day of her actions, she disclaimed herself from House Garland in order to save her family from the fallout. As a result of this and her genuine remorse, Geordo decides to absolve House Garland of blame for their daughter's crime. [[note]]It's easy to turn cases like this into a political witch hunt, in which case House Garland could easily just be the ''earliest'' victims.[[/note]] [[spoiler: And played straight after her parents accept her [[DisinheritedChild disclaim]], telling her via letter that they need time before they will speak to her again. The effect of the disclaim is shown when Henrietta tells Catarina that the latter should address her as ''Miss'' Garland instead of ''Lady''.]]
Changed line(s) 55 (click to see context) from:
* KarmaHoudini: After Catarina's doom doesn't come, Henrietta views Catarina as this and decides [[AssassinationAttempt that she has to kill Catarina herself]] in order to bring about a "just" ending.
to:
* KarmaHoudini: After Catarina's doom doesn't come, Henrietta views Catarina as this and decides [[AssassinationAttempt that she has to kill Catarina herself]] in order to bring about a "just" ending. {{Subverted|trope}} because ''this'' Catarina has [[AllLovingHero little to no bad karma]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* PhlebotinumAnalogy: In Chapter 11, [[spoiler:Catarina has to make the InternalReveal about her PastLifeMemories, especially the fact that she sees herself being reincarnated into an OtomeGame she played in her past life. The world she's now in, however, is a standard MedievalEuropeanFantasy, and as a result, nobody would have any idea what a VideoGame is. She describes otome games as a kind of romance fiction that is "projected towards you" where the player "attempt[s] to win the heart of a character." The audience still finds the idea bizarre, but [[ThinksLikeARomanceNovel Sophia]] is able to get what Catarina says, and further simplifies it as "a romance novel where you make the story yourself" for the rest of the cast.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 73 (click to see context) from:
--->'''Franince''': '''''YOU VILE WOMAN!'''''
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* {{Courier}}: The omake starts with a detailed description of a courier, under Keith's orders, delivering news about Henrietta's AssassinationAttempt on Catarina. When Luigi meets Dan the next day, Dan mentions Sophia doing the same thing.
Changed line(s) 35 (click to see context) from:
* {{Foil}}: Henrietta to Catarina. Both of them are ignorant of the fact that the world they now live in is not a linear story like ''Fortune Lover'' was. Catarina however is optimistic, selfless, and empathetic, while Henrietta is pessimistic, selfish, and callous. Catarina also tries to make an effort to change her fate, while Henrietta does nothing because of her need for personal catharsis.
to:
* {{Foil}}: {{Foil}}:
** Henrietta to Catarina. Both of them are [[WrongGenreSavvy ignorant of the factthat that]] the world they now live in is not a linear story like ''Fortune Lover'' was. Catarina however is optimistic, selfless, and empathetic, while Henrietta is pessimistic, selfish, and callous. Catarina also tries to make an effort to change her fate, while Henrietta does nothing because of her need for personal catharsis.catharsis.
** Henrietta in her past life is also one to Atsuko, especially before the latter befriended the girl who became Catarina. Both of them were heavily bullied nerds and relied on romance fiction as a form of {{Escapism}}. However, while Atsuko mainly seeks WishFulfillment for [[IJustWantToHaveFriends companionship]] by self-insertion (which is often the author's intent), Henrietta's past life [[PsychologicalProjection projected her bullies]] on AlphaBitch characters (such as ''Fortune Lover'''s Catarina) and seek their "death" as a form of catharsis, to the point of ''repeatedly'' "killing" Catarina through deliberately choosing routes where the latter dies. It's not surprising that, after reading the first chapter, ''many'' readers suggested Henrietta was already a "walking bomb" in her past life.
** Henrietta to Catarina. Both of them are [[WrongGenreSavvy ignorant of the fact
** Henrietta in her past life is also one to Atsuko, especially before the latter befriended the girl who became Catarina. Both of them were heavily bullied nerds and relied on romance fiction as a form of {{Escapism}}. However, while Atsuko mainly seeks WishFulfillment for [[IJustWantToHaveFriends companionship]] by self-insertion (which is often the author's intent), Henrietta's past life [[PsychologicalProjection projected her bullies]] on AlphaBitch characters (such as ''Fortune Lover'''s Catarina) and seek their "death" as a form of catharsis, to the point of ''repeatedly'' "killing" Catarina through deliberately choosing routes where the latter dies. It's not surprising that, after reading the first chapter, ''many'' readers suggested Henrietta was already a "walking bomb" in her past life.
Changed line(s) 39 (click to see context) from:
* HourglassPlot: With canon. Catarina was a spoiled and selfish child who hit her head and woke up with past life memories that made her self-aware she was living the life of ''Fortune Lover'''s villainess, but through her kindness, she never earned the bad karma that caused her doom flags. Meanwhile, Henrietta was a kind and talented girl who became self-aware of her status as a character not particularly involved with any of the doom flags and able to live out a life of privilege without challenge, [[spoiler:but her choice to enable and eventually actively cause bad things for her own satisfaction earns her the functional role of new villainess, and she is eventually imprisoned.]]
to:
* HourglassPlot: With canon. Catarina was a spoiled and selfish child who hit her head and woke up with past life memories that made her self-aware she was living the life of ''Fortune Lover'''s villainess, but through her kindness, she never earned the bad karma that caused her doom flags. Meanwhile, Henrietta was a kind and talented girl who became self-aware of her status as a character not particularly involved with any of the doom flags and able to live out a life of privilege without challenge, [[spoiler:but her choice to enable and eventually actively cause bad things for her own satisfaction earns her the functional role of the new villainess, and she is eventually imprisoned.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 64 (click to see context) from:
* PowerFantasy: ''Catarina Claes MUST DIE'' is a textbook deconstruction of this trope. Henrietta's past life engaged this by "killing" Catarina through deliberately choosing routes where the latter dies, so the fact that [[AllLovingHero nobody has a single motive to kill]] ''this'' universe's Catarina drove her nuts.
to:
* PowerFantasy: ''Catarina Claes MUST DIE'' is a textbook deconstruction of this trope. Henrietta's past life engaged this by "killing" Catarina through deliberately choosing routes where the latter dies, so the fact that [[AllLovingHero nobody has a single motive to kill]] ''this'' universe's Catarina drove her nuts. To add further to the deconstruction, Geordo and Mary are both disgusted when Henrietta talks about playing ''Fortune Lover'' just to watch Catarina die, feeling she's mentally ill to be that obsessed with watching someone die over and over again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 31 (click to see context) from:
* BulliedIntoDepression: Henrietta's issues stems from the heavy bullying during her past life.
to:
* BulliedIntoDepression: Henrietta's issues stems from the heavy bullying during Henrietta nearly descended into this in her past life.life after being relentlessly bullied her whole life. Then she watched Catarina die in one of ''Fortune Lovers''' bad endings and became worse in a completely different way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 17 (click to see context) from:
** Finally, Henrietta calls ''herself'' a vile woman after talking with Catarina, [[IronicEcho underscoring how wrong her actions were.]]
to:
** Finally, Henrietta calls ''herself'' a vile woman after talking with Catarina, [[IronicEcho underscoring how wrong her actions were.]]]]
** The very last line of the fic has Henrietta declaring to herself that Catarina ''never'' was or will be a vile woman.
** The very last line of the fic has Henrietta declaring to herself that Catarina ''never'' was or will be a vile woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* PsychologicalProjection: Henrietta doesn't see Catarina as a person so much as the physical embodiment of all of her tormentors in her old life, which colors all of her interactions with the canonical Catarina and keeps her from seeing Catarina for the kind person she very clearly is.
* TeensAreMonsters: Becoming consumed by her hatred for Catarina causes Henrietta to resort to attempting to murder her.
Changed line(s) 79 (click to see context) from:
* TroubledTeen: Henrietta in her old life was one, showing signs of becoming a budding {{Sadist}} if not worse as she began using Catarina's grisly fates in ''Fortune Lover'' as a form of catharsis to deal with the rampant bullying she endured, deriving a disturbing amount of pleasure from watching her be killed. She only gets worse in her new life when her past memories reawaken, and she realizes that she's in the same world now as Catarina.
to:
* TroubledTeen: Henrietta in her old life was one, showing signs of becoming a budding {{Sadist}} if not worse as she began using Catarina's grisly fates in ''Fortune Lover'' as a form of catharsis to deal with the rampant bullying she endured, deriving a disturbing amount of pleasure from watching her be killed. [[TeensAreMonsters She only gets worse worse]] in her new life when her past memories reawaken, and she realizes that she's in the same world now as Catarina.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* TroubledTeen: Henrietta in her old life was one, showing signs of becoming a budding {{Sadist}} if not worse as she began using Catarina's grisly fates in ''Fortune Lover'' as a form of catharsis to deal with the rampant bullying she endured, deriving a disturbing amount of pleasure from watching her be killed. She only gets worse in her new life when her past memories reawaken, and she realizes that she's in the same world now as Catarina.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* StealthPun: Because of Henrietta's [[ProtagonistJourneyToVillain eventual fate,]] the fanfic could be described as the story of ''her next life as a Villainess.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ironic, but not related to trope
Changed line(s) 38 (click to see context) from:
* HourglassPlot: With canon. Catarina was a spoiled and selfish child who hit her head and woke up with past life memories that made her self-aware she was living the life of ''Fortune Lover'''s villainess, but through her kindness, she never earned the bad karma that caused her doom flags. Meanwhile, Henrietta was a kind and talented girl who became self-aware of her status as a character not particularly involved with any of the doom flags and able to live out a life of privilege without challenge, [[spoiler:but her choice to enable and eventually actively cause bad things for her own satisfaction earns her the functional role of new villainess, and she is eventually imprisoned. The only thing that spares her from worse punishment is Catarina's selfless and compassionate nature.]]
to:
* HourglassPlot: With canon. Catarina was a spoiled and selfish child who hit her head and woke up with past life memories that made her self-aware she was living the life of ''Fortune Lover'''s villainess, but through her kindness, she never earned the bad karma that caused her doom flags. Meanwhile, Henrietta was a kind and talented girl who became self-aware of her status as a character not particularly involved with any of the doom flags and able to live out a life of privilege without challenge, [[spoiler:but her choice to enable and eventually actively cause bad things for her own satisfaction earns her the functional role of new villainess, and she is eventually imprisoned. The only thing that spares her from worse punishment is Catarina's selfless and compassionate nature.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* HourglassPlot: With canon. Catarina was a spoiled and selfish child who hit her head and woke up with past life memories that made her self-aware she was living the life of ''Fortune Lover'''s villainess, but through her kindness, she never earned the bad karma that caused her doom flags. Meanwhile, Henrietta was a kind and talented girl who became self-aware of her status as a character not particularly involved with any of the doom flags and able to live out a life of privilege without challenge, [[spoiler:but her choice to enable and eventually actively cause bad things for her own satisfaction earns her the functional role of new villainess, and she is eventually imprisoned. The only thing that spares her from worse punishment is Catarina's selfless and compassionate nature.]]
