Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / Anthropology

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Her nickname, Lyra, turns out [[spoiler:to be her real name, which convinces Audrey that she's telling the truth about being Thomas' long-lost daughter when she finds out that he did in fact have another daughter named Lyra who was mysteriously kidnapped about sixteen years before the story. It's also the name of a constellation, which is named because it resembles the [[ClassicalMythology lyre of Orpheus from Greek mythology]]]]

to:

** Her nickname, Lyra, turns out [[spoiler:to be her real name, which convinces Audrey that she's telling the truth about being Thomas' long-lost daughter when she finds out that he did in fact have another daughter named Lyra who was mysteriously kidnapped about sixteen years before the story. It's also the name of a constellation, which is named because it resembles the [[ClassicalMythology [[Myth/ClassicalMythology lyre of Orpheus from Greek mythology]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: CelebrityParadox: WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic doesn't appear to exist in this version of 2012 Earth.]]
** Averted in the non-canonical April Fools Day special, which starts out with [[spoiler: Lyra spotting an episode on TV.]] [[WordOfGod According to the author]], he "took that concept and [[BlatantLies pushed it to its most logical conclusion.]]"
** In a bit of LeaningOnTheFourthWall, [[spoiler:Thomas suggests that Lyra could make money by publishing the "stories" she'd been telling Chloe(actually just actual events that happened in Ponyville), and that her mother could do the pictures for them]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllGirlsLovePonies: [[spoiler: Chloe, Lyra's human little sister, is deep in what her father calls the unicorn phase. Lyra bonds with her by telling her stories about Equestria, disguising them as stories Lyra made up, though after Discord shows up she tells Chloe the truth. She gets along well with Fluttershy, who was her favourite pony in the stories. In the finale, she mentions to Bon-Bon that she's thinking of asking Celestia to bring Chloe over to visit Equestria as a Christmas present]]

to:

* AllGirlsLovePonies: AllGirlsLikePonies: [[spoiler: Chloe, Lyra's human little sister, is deep in what her father calls the unicorn phase. Lyra bonds with her by telling her stories about Equestria, disguising them as stories Lyra made up, though after Discord shows up she tells Chloe the truth. She gets along well with Fluttershy, who was her favourite pony in the stories. In the finale, she mentions to Bon-Bon that she's thinking of asking Celestia to bring Chloe over to visit Equestria as a Christmas present]]

Added: 2335

Changed: 527

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I removed unicorn from the couple and raised by, since her "mother" was a pegasus(which is somewhat important, because she thought that her mother being a pegasus was why she took so long to figure out how to do magic


* AllGirlsLovePonies: [[spoiler: Chloe, Lyra's human little sister, is deep in what her father calls the unicorn phase. Lyra bonds with her by telling her stories about Equestria, disguising them as stories Lyra made up, though after Discord shows up she tells Chloe the truth. She gets along well with Fluttershy, who was her favourite pony in the stories. In the finale, she mentions to Bon-Bon that she's thinking of asking Celestia to bring Chloe over to visit Equestria as a Christmas present]]



** In a bit of LeaningOnTheFourthWall, [[spoiler:Thomas suggests that Lyra could make money by publishing the "stories" she'd been telling Chloe(actually just actual events that happened in Ponyville), and that her mother could do the pictures for them]].



** Her nickname, Lyra, turns out [[spoiler:to be her real name, which convinces Audrey that she's telling the truth about being Thomas' long-lost daughter when she finds out that he did in fact have another daughter named Lyra who was mysteriously kidnapped about sixteen years before the story. It's also the name of a constellation, which is named because it resembles the [[ClassicalMythology lyre of Orpheus from Greek mythology]]]]



* {{Deconstruction}}: The story deconstructs the popular {{Fanon}} interpretation of Lyra having a fixation on humans. It's by no means dark, but it shows that no matter how benign Lyra's behavior and beliefs are, they are nevertheless still deemed inappropriate in Equestrian society, to the point of becoming an increasingly more severe point of contention with her roommate. Lyra becomes paranoid, believing that pony's ignorance of humanity is all a government conspiracy.

to:

* {{Deconstruction}}: The story deconstructs the popular {{Fanon}} interpretation of Lyra having a fixation on humans. It's by no means dark, but it shows that no matter how benign Lyra's behavior and beliefs are, they are nevertheless still deemed inappropriate in Equestrian society, to the point of becoming an increasingly more severe point of contention with her roommate. Lyra becomes paranoid, believing that pony's ignorance of humanity is all a government conspiracy. [[spoiler: Though she does turn out to be right]].



** [[spoiler: Lyra, which was a human name she chose because she liked the sound of it, turns out to actually be what her ''human'' parents named her]]



* EntertaininglyWrong: Paul's theory about why Lyra acts so odd and is [[spoiler:reading up on history that is common knowledge and would have already been taught in school]]? She's a time traveller.



* FaeriesDontBelieveInHumansEither: Nopony has even heard of humans before, except for Celestia and Luna, [[spoiler:and Lyra's parents, before she found the ancient books]].

to:

* FaeriesDontBelieveInHumansEither: Nopony has even heard of humans before, except for Celestia and Luna, [[spoiler:and Lyra's parents, before she found the ancient books]]. And possibly Pinky Pie and her grandmother(see PlotHole below), who actually gave her accurate information about humans.



* IAteWhat: Lyra's reaction to [[spoiler: finding out what a hamburger is made of]]. She admits she liked it, though.
* InterspeciesAdoption: [[spoiler: it is revealed that Lyra was being adopted by a foal-less unicorn couple [[DoorstopBaby after they found her in the Royal gardens of Canterlot]].]]

to:

* IAteWhat: Lyra's reaction to [[spoiler: finding out what a hamburger is made of]]. She admits she liked it, though.
though, but [[spoiler:she decides not to eat meat ever again]].
* InterspeciesAdoption: [[spoiler: it is revealed that Lyra was being adopted by a foal-less unicorn couple [[DoorstopBaby after they found her in the Royal gardens of Canterlot]].]]



** The implication is that Twilight is acting as an UnwittingPawn to Celestia in order to spy on Lyra, which could make her ProperlyParanoid.

to:

** The implication is that Twilight is acting as an UnwittingPawn to Celestia in order to spy on Lyra, which could make her ProperlyParanoid.[[spoiler: Which turns out to be true]].



* PlotHole: At one point, Pinky Pie mentions that she'd heard about humans from her grandmother, but later she says she'd heard of them from Bon-Bon talking about how Lyra always talked about them. She also notes the second time that it seems like she's one of the only ones who had ever heard of humans, even though there seem to be a fair number, [[spoiler:though only a few that know they actually exist]].



* TheReveal: [[spoiler: Humanity is extinct, and Lyra is human.]]
* [[RaisedByWolves Raised By Unicorns]]: [[spoiler: Lyra somehow ended up in Equestria and was being [[RaisedByNatives raised by unicorns]].]]

to:

* TheReveal: [[RaisedByWolves Raised By Ponies]]: [[spoiler: Humanity is extinct, and Lyra is human.somehow ended up in Equestria and was being [[RaisedByNatives raised by ponies]].]]
* [[RaisedByWolves Raised By Unicorns]]: TheReveal: [[spoiler: Lyra somehow ended up in Humanity on Equestria is extinct, and was being [[RaisedByNatives raised by unicorns]].Lyra is human.]]


Added DiffLines:

** Audrey and Nathan both make references to Franchise/TheLegendOfZelda when they find out that Lyra plays the lyre.
** After telling Monica his theory that Lyra is a time traveler, he comments that she acts like someone out of a movie. Specifically, a Creator/TimBurton movie, if the "[[Film/EdwardScissorhands quirky outsider]] played by Creator/JohnnyDepp was a teenage girl instead".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* MarySue: {{In-Universe}}, this is Lyra's opinion of [[spoiler:''WesternAnimation/TheLastUnicorn''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted in the non-canonical April Fools Day special, which starts out with [[spoiler: Lyra spotting an episode on TV.]] [[WordOfGod According to the author]], he "took that concept and pushed it to its most logical conclusion."

to:

** Averted in the non-canonical April Fools Day special, which starts out with [[spoiler: Lyra spotting an episode on TV.]] [[WordOfGod According to the author]], he "took that concept and [[BlatantLies pushed it to its most logical conclusion."]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreSavvy: [[spoiler: Thomas, who can tell that Lyra's lyre necklace is important simply from the fact that she got it from Celestia. Then again, he ''is'' a writer of {{Troperiffic}} fantasy.]]

to:

* GenreSavvy: [[spoiler: Thomas, who can tell that Lyra's lyre necklace is important simply from the fact that she got it from Celestia. Then again, Celestia, as he ''is'' is a writer of {{Troperiffic}} fantasy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


An audio-drama is in the works, chapter one is already out and can be found [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZPjYHqJyvE here]].

to:

An audio-drama is in The story has also been fully adapted into an audio-drama, the works, chapter one is already out and first part of which can be found [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZPjYHqJyvE here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added spoiler tags.


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: It's never explained how Lyra ended up in Equestria in the first place.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: [[spoiler: It's never explained how Lyra ended up in Equestria in the first place.]]

Added: 215

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chapter 29 contains a reference to TayZonday's popular song ''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwTZ2xpQwpA Chocolate Rain]]''.

to:

** Chapter 29 contains a reference to TayZonday's Music/TayZonday's popular song ''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwTZ2xpQwpA Chocolate Rain]]''.Rain]]''.
* TakeThat: When Lyra finds [[spoiler:the book ''Literature/TheLastUnicorn'', she thinks it is insulting, since it is not how unicorns are like at all, and doesn't understand why Amalthea doesn't like being human.]]

Added: 83

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt: People claim this is what Discord's causing. Naturally, he takes great joy in mentioning this to Lyra.

to:

* TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt: [[spoiler: People claim this is what Discord's causing. Naturally, he takes great joy in mentioning this to Lyra.Lyra]].


Added DiffLines:

* ExpositoryThemeTune: [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4dWMxTWTXE Lyra's Song]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not a trope, a Useful Notes page


* FurryFandom: [[{{InvertedTrope}} Inverted]], as Lyra is a creature obsessed with humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrueCompanions: Lyra and her [[spoiler: human]] friends. [[spoiler: They are able to defeat Discord with the Elements of Harmony.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GoodSamaritan: Audrey takes in Lyra after finding her on the streets of Des Moines, [[spoiler:which earns her the Element of Kindness]].


Added DiffLines:

* UndyingLoyalty: Randall towards Lyra, [[spoiler:earning him the Element of Loyalty]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: It is [[PlayedForDrama played for drama]] when Lyra ends up in the human world. She knows that most people wouldn't believe her past, and struggles to find a good cover story. When she tells Audrey the truth about her, Audrey loses a lot of her faith in Lyra, who can't even tell the truth to her human family, and pretends to be amnesiac... up until Discord turns her back into a pony.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContrivedCoincidence: It's a bit of a stretch for Lyra's human father to be so incredibly famous that literally the ''fourth'' person she has more than a fleeting conversation with recognizes his photograph.

to:

* ContrivedCoincidence: [[spoiler: It's a bit of a stretch for Lyra's human father to be so incredibly famous that literally the ''fourth'' person she has more than a fleeting conversation with recognizes his photograph. photograph.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FantasticAnthropologist: It's right there in the title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* COntrivedCoincidence: It's a bit of a stretch for Lyra's human father to be so incredibly famous that literally the ''fourth'' person she has more than a fleeting conversation with recognizes his photograph.

to:

* COntrivedCoincidence: ContrivedCoincidence: It's a bit of a stretch for Lyra's human father to be so incredibly famous that literally the ''fourth'' person she has more than a fleeting conversation with recognizes his photograph.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* COntrivedCoincidence: It's a bit of a stretch for Lyra's human father to be so incredibly famous that literally the ''fourth'' person she has more than a fleeting conversation with recognizes his photograph.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReveal: [[spoiler: Humanity is extinct, and Lyra is human.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Deconstruction}}: The story deconstructs the popular {{Fanon}} interpretation of Lyra having a fixation on humans. It's by no means dark, but it shows that no matter how benign Lyra's behavior and beliefs are, they are nevertheless still deemed inappropriate in Equestrian society, to the point of becoming an increasingly more severe point of contention with her roommate.

to:

* {{Deconstruction}}: The story deconstructs the popular {{Fanon}} interpretation of Lyra having a fixation on humans. It's by no means dark, but it shows that no matter how benign Lyra's behavior and beliefs are, they are nevertheless still deemed inappropriate in Equestrian society, to the point of becoming an increasingly more severe point of contention with her roommate. Lyra becomes paranoid, believing that pony's ignorance of humanity is all a government conspiracy.

Added: 256

Removed: 731

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MythologyGag: Lyra's birthname was Heartstrings, but she was more accustomed to the name Lyra after reading it in a book, a reference to the fact that Lyra's original name in the toyline was Heartstrings, but the fandom demanded that she be renamed Lyra.



* StrawmanHasAPoint: Bon Bon can come across as frustrated and sarcastic, and we should see her as an insufferable skeptic, but she makes some fairly decent points: Lyra hasn't any real proof besides some books and dreams, something [[Twilight Bookworm]] agrees with, her behavior is shown to be weird by the description of strangers, and Lyra needs to improve her image to advance her career, with [[ProperLady Rarity]] agrees with, and her limit is pushed by the fact that Lyra nearly hurt somepony with the cart she brought to life. [[spoiler: Of course when Lyra comes back to Equestria with not only proof of humanity, but the fact that she herself is [[HumanAllAlong human]] all that is left is her sarcasm and frustration.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreSavvy: Thomas, who can tell that Lyra's lyre necklace is important simply from the fact that she got it from Celestia. Then again, he ''is'' a writer of {{Troperiffic}} fantasy.

to:

* GenreSavvy: [[spoiler: Thomas, who can tell that Lyra's lyre necklace is important simply from the fact that she got it from Celestia. Then again, he ''is'' a writer of {{Troperiffic}} fantasy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The necklace that Lyra receives from Princess Celestia [[spoiler: before being sent back to the human world, turned out to be charmed, in case Lyra ever got her magic back, and needed to return to Equestria.]]

to:

** The cutie-mark shaped necklace that Lyra receives from Princess Celestia [[spoiler: before being sent back to the human world, turned out to be charmed, in case and when Discord turns Lyra ever got back into a pony, it sends her magic back, back to Equestria, allowing her to bring the Elements of Harmony to Earth and needed to return to Equestria.stop him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The necklace that Lyra receives from Princess Celestia [[spoiler: before being sent back to the human world, turned out to be charmed, in case Lyra ever got her magic back, and needed to return to Equestria.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
important trope
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: Bon Bon can come across as frustrated and sarcastic, and we should see her as an insufferable skeptic, but she makes some fairly decent points: Lyra hasn't any real proof besides some books and dreams, something [[Twilight Bookworm]] agrees with, her behavior is shown to be weird by the description of strangers, and Lyra needs to improve her image to advance her career, with [[ProperLady Rarity]] agrees with, and her limit is pushed by the fact that Lyra nearly hurt somepony with the cart she brought to life. [[spoiler: Of course when Lyra comes back to Equestria with not only proof of humanity, but the fact that she herself is [[HumanAllAlong human]] all that is left is her sarcasm and frustration.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IntriguedByHumanity: More or less the main plot point of the story. The[[spoiler: first part the]] story deals with what Lyra would deal with believing in a creature that has not been proven to exist:namely the skepticism of her peers (and the frustration of Bon Bon) and the fear that the government is hiding the fact that they exist. [[spoiler: Her obsession is attributed to the fact they she was in fact [[HumanAllAlong born a human]].]]

to:

* IntriguedByHumanity: More IntriguedByHumanity:Lyra obviously, and more or less the main plot point of the story. The[[spoiler: first part the]] story deals with what Lyra would deal with shows the consequences of believing in a creature that has not been proven to exist:namely exist, and adopting their habits:namely the skepticism of her peers (and the frustration of Bon Bon) and the fear that the government is hiding the fact that they exist. [[spoiler: Her obsession is attributed to the fact they she was in fact [[HumanAllAlong born a human]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IntriguedByHumanity: More or less the main plot point of the story. The[[spoiler: first part the]] story deals with what Lyra would deal with believing in a creature that has not been proven to exist:namely the skepticism of her peers (and the frustration of Bon Bon) and the fear that the government is hiding the fact that they exist. [[spoiler: Her obsession is attributed to the fact they she was in fact [[HumanAllAlong born a human]].]]

Top