Follow TV Tropes

Following

History FanPreferredCouple / SherlockHolmes

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ZCE pothole


* ''Series/{{Elementary}}'': As is typical of most ''Sherlock Holmes'' adaptations, (Joan) Watson and Sherlock Holmes are the most popular ship overall due to their strong chemistry together, and in spite of repeated ShipSinking by the creators. While Sherlock is in love with Irene in this adaptation, most fans prefer to ship him with Joan instead, as evidenced by all the support they receive on fanfiction sites.

to:

* ''Series/{{Elementary}}'': As is typical of most ''Sherlock Holmes'' adaptations, (Joan) Watson and Sherlock Holmes are the most popular ship overall due to their strong chemistry together, and in spite of repeated ShipSinking denial by the creators. While Sherlock is in love with Irene in this adaptation, most fans prefer to ship him with Joan instead, as evidenced by all the support they receive on fanfiction sites.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'' recieves plenty of teasing, though the creators pair John with [[spoiler: Mary Morstan]]. The show's creators lean into the existing relationship by adding more homoerotic subtext to the characters' portrayals, with many side characters assuming the two are dating. The fans took these new suggestions and ran with them.

to:

* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'' recieves receives plenty of teasing, though the creators pair John with [[spoiler: Mary Morstan]]. The show's creators lean into the existing relationship by adding more homoerotic subtext to the characters' portrayals, with many side characters assuming the two are dating. The fans took these new suggestions and ran with them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheAdventuresOfShirleyHolmes'' has Bo/Shirley, and those who don't. The duo's relationship was was limited to ShipTease). They had [[OfficialCouple other relationships]] in the show.

to:

* Nearly every fan of ''Series/TheAdventuresOfShirleyHolmes'' has ships Bo/Shirley, and those who don't. The even though in canon, the duo's relationship was was limited to ShipTease).ShipTease. They had [[OfficialCouple other relationships]] in the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* For a straight pairing, Sherlock Holmes is often paired with Irene Adler, a character who only appeared in A Scandal in Bohemia. The opera singer is able to outwit Holmes, earning his admiration. While Doyle never portrays the two as having romantic interest in each other, and she marries Godfrey Norton, adaptations of the Sherlock stories may upgrade them to an Official Couple.

to:

* For a straight pairing, Sherlock Holmes is often paired with Irene Adler, a character who only appeared in A Scandal in Bohemia. The opera singer is able to outwit Holmes, earning his admiration. While Doyle never portrays the two as having romantic interest in each other, and she marries Godfrey Norton, a man who she clearly loves, adaptations of the Sherlock stories may upgrade them to an Official Couple.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/SherlockHolmes'', there is Holmes/Watson. Their strong bond and constant companionship form the core dynamic of the stories, with Watson documenting Holmes's exploits. In canon, Watson marries Mary Morstan. Most adaptaions of Holmes will have its most popular pairing be Holmes/Watson.

to:

* In ''Literature/SherlockHolmes'', there is Holmes/Watson. Their strong bond and constant companionship form the core dynamic of the stories, with Watson documenting Holmes's exploits. In canon, Watson marries Mary Morstan. Most adaptaions adaptations of Holmes will have its most popular pairing be Holmes/Watson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'' recieves plenty of teasing, though the creators pair John with [[spoiler: Mary Morstan]]. The show's creators lean into the existing relationship by adding more homoerotic subtext to the characters' portrayals, with many side characters assuming the two are dating.

to:

* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'' recieves plenty of teasing, though the creators pair John with [[spoiler: Mary Morstan]]. The show's creators lean into the existing relationship by adding more homoerotic subtext to the characters' portrayals, with many side characters assuming the two are dating. The fans took these new suggestions and ran with them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/MissSherlock'': It didn't take long for most fans to latch onto shipping Sherlock and Wato. As with most versions of the two characters, it had already started before the first episode aired, and only grew as the episodes aired. There's plenty of fanfiction, fanart, and fanvids for the ship, along with the pairing having a strong following on both Twitter and Tumblr. This is mainly due to the chemistry between their actresses, the LesYay between them, and the fact that their dynamic is the focus of the show. Wato is paired with Moriya in the show.

to:

* ''Series/MissSherlock'': It didn't take long for most fans to latch onto shipping Sherlock and Wato. As with most versions of the two characters, it had already started before the first episode aired, and only grew as the episodes aired. There's plenty of fanfiction, fanart, and fanvids for the ship, along with the pairing having a strong following on both Twitter and Tumblr. This is mainly due to the chemistry between their actresses, the LesYay between them, and the fact that their dynamic is the focus of the show. Wato is paired with Moriya in the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/SherlockHolmes'', there is Holmes/Watson - one of the, if not ''the'', most slashed pairing ever. In fact, pretty much every adaptation of Holmes will have its most popular pairing be Holmes/Watson. Non-yaoi fans can also [[PromotedToLoveInterest promote Irene Adler to love interest]], which many, many, writers, playwrights and scriptwriters have done throughout the years.


to:

* In ''Literature/SherlockHolmes'', there is Holmes/Watson - one Holmes/Watson. Their strong bond and constant companionship form the core dynamic of the, if not ''the'', most slashed pairing ever. the stories, with Watson documenting Holmes's exploits. In fact, pretty much every adaptation canon, Watson marries Mary Morstan. Most adaptaions of Holmes will have its most popular pairing be Holmes/Watson. Non-yaoi fans can also [[PromotedToLoveInterest promote Holmes/Watson.
* For a straight pairing, Sherlock Holmes is often paired with
Irene Adler Adler, a character who only appeared in A Scandal in Bohemia. The opera singer is able to love interest]], which many, many, writers, playwrights outwit Holmes, earning his admiration. While Doyle never portrays the two as having romantic interest in each other, and scriptwriters have done throughout she marries Godfrey Norton, adaptations of the years.

Sherlock stories may upgrade them to an Official Couple.



* ''Film/SherlockHolmes2009'': Most fans prefer to pair Sherlock Holmes and John Watson together over their canon pairings of Irene Adler and Mary respectively. This mostly due to the (deliberate) HoYay between the two and the chemistry between their actors. This has also led to some fans [[ActorShipping shipping said actors together]]. Most of the fanfics, shipping videos, and fanart of the movie centers around the ship.

to:

* ''Film/SherlockHolmes2009'': Most fans prefer to pair Sherlock Holmes and John Watson together over their canon pairings of Irene Adler and Mary respectively. This mostly due to the (deliberate) HoYay between the two and the chemistry between their actors. This has also led to some fans [[ActorShipping shipping said actors together]]. Most of the fanfics, shipping videos, and fanart of the movie centers around the ship.



* Virtually ''every'' fan of ''Series/TheAdventuresOfShirleyHolmes'' ships Bo/Shirley, and those who don't, well, they don't really mind the pairing either. The duo's relationship was never romantic in the series (save for some harmless ShipTease); in fact, they both had [[OfficialCouple other relationships]]. Thankfully, since the fandom was fairly small and the respective {{Love Interest}}s were very likable, the DieForOurShip was pretty much nonexistent.
* ''Series/{{Elementary}}'': As is typical of most ''Sherlock Holmes'' adaptations, (Joan) Watson and Sherlock Holmes are the most popular ship overall due to their strong chemistry together, and in spite of repeated ShipSinking by the creators. While Sherlock is in love with Irene, even after the reveal she's Moriarty, most fans prefer to ship him with Joan instead, as evidenced by all the support they receive on fanfiction sites.
* ''Series/MissSherlock'': It didn't take long for most fans to latch onto shipping Sherlock and Wato. As with most versions of the two characters, it had already started before the first episode aired, and only grew as the episodes aired. There's plenty of fanfiction, fanart, and fanvids for the ship, along with the pairing having a strong following on both Twitter and Tumblr. This is mainly due to the chemistry between their actresses, the LesYay between them, and the fact that their dynamic is the focus of the show. This continued even after Wato was given a proper love interest, Moriya, though thankfully he managed to avoid DieForOurShip, and continues even after the show ended.
* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'', but this is hardly surprising considering it's a modern revival of one of the oldest bromances in literature, and both actors are quite good-looking. The number of fanfics that ''don't'' have John/Sherlock as the main couple is really very low compared to those featuring the [[spoiler: now canon]] John/Mary Morstan and the liberally ship-teased Sherlock/Irene or the less-teased-but-more-plausible Sherlock/Molly; and most of ''those'' are Mycroft/Lestrade fics that include John/Sherlock as the BetaCouple. On Archive of our Own, it doesn't just outclass all the other pairings; it outclasses them all ''combined.'' Just how much of it is fans reading into things, how much is [[BaitAndSwitchLesbians genuine intentional implications]], and how much is a RelationshipWritingFumble causing them both to read as [[HaveIMentionedIAmHeterosexualToday less straight and more in denial]] is a topic of debate, but no matter the outcome, it pretty much consumed discussions of the show from every angle.

to:

* Virtually ''every'' fan of ''Series/TheAdventuresOfShirleyHolmes'' ships has Bo/Shirley, and those who don't, well, they don't really mind the pairing either. don't. The duo's relationship was never romantic in the series (save for some harmless ShipTease); in fact, they both was limited to ShipTease). They had [[OfficialCouple other relationships]]. Thankfully, since relationships]] in the fandom was fairly small and the respective {{Love Interest}}s were very likable, the DieForOurShip was pretty much nonexistent.
show.
* ''Series/{{Elementary}}'': As is typical of most ''Sherlock Holmes'' adaptations, (Joan) Watson and Sherlock Holmes are the most popular ship overall due to their strong chemistry together, and in spite of repeated ShipSinking by the creators. While Sherlock is in love with Irene, even after the reveal she's Moriarty, Irene in this adaptation, most fans prefer to ship him with Joan instead, as evidenced by all the support they receive on fanfiction sites.
* ''Series/MissSherlock'': It didn't take long for most fans to latch onto shipping Sherlock and Wato. As with most versions of the two characters, it had already started before the first episode aired, and only grew as the episodes aired. There's plenty of fanfiction, fanart, and fanvids for the ship, along with the pairing having a strong following on both Twitter and Tumblr. This is mainly due to the chemistry between their actresses, the LesYay between them, and the fact that their dynamic is the focus of the show. This continued even after Wato was given a proper love interest, Moriya, though thankfully he managed to avoid DieForOurShip, and continues even after is paired with Moriya in the show ended.
show.
* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'', but this is hardly surprising considering it's a modern revival ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'' recieves plenty of one of teasing, though the oldest bromances in literature, and both actors are quite good-looking. The number of fanfics that ''don't'' have John/Sherlock as the main couple is really very low compared to those featuring the creators pair John with [[spoiler: now canon]] John/Mary Morstan and the liberally ship-teased Sherlock/Irene or the less-teased-but-more-plausible Sherlock/Molly; and most of ''those'' are Mycroft/Lestrade fics that include John/Sherlock as the BetaCouple. On Archive of our Own, it doesn't just outclass all the other pairings; it outclasses them all ''combined.'' Just how much of it is fans reading Mary Morstan]]. The show's creators lean into things, how much is [[BaitAndSwitchLesbians genuine intentional implications]], and how much is a RelationshipWritingFumble causing them both to read as [[HaveIMentionedIAmHeterosexualToday less straight and the existing relationship by adding more in denial]] is a topic of debate, but no matter homoerotic subtext to the outcome, it pretty much consumed discussions of characters' portrayals, with many side characters assuming the show from every angle.two are dating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'', but this is hardly surprising considering it's a modern revival of one of the oldest bromances in literature, and both actors are quite good-looking. The number of fanfics that ''don't'' have John/Sherlock as the main couple is really very low compared to those featuring the [[spoiler: now canon]] John/Mary Morstan and the liberally ship-teased Sherlock/Irene or the less-teased-but-more-plausible Sherlock/Molly; and most of ''those'' are Mycroft/Lestrade fics that include John/Sherlock as the BetaCouple. On Archive of our Own, it doesn't just outclass all the other pairings; it outclasses them all ''combined.'' Just how much of it is fans reading into things, how much is [[BaitAndSwitchLesbians genuine intentional implications]], and how much is a RelationshipWritingFumble causing them both to read as [[HaveIMentionedIAmHeterosexualToday less straight and more in denial]] is a topic of debate, but no matter the outcome, it pretty much consumed discussions of the show from every angle.

to:

* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'', but this is hardly surprising considering it's a modern revival of one of the oldest bromances in literature, and both actors are quite good-looking. The number of fanfics that ''don't'' have John/Sherlock as the main couple is really very low compared to those featuring the [[spoiler: now canon]] John/Mary Morstan and the liberally ship-teased Sherlock/Irene or the less-teased-but-more-plausible Sherlock/Molly; and most of ''those'' are Mycroft/Lestrade fics that include John/Sherlock as the BetaCouple. On Archive of our Own, it doesn't just outclass all the other pairings; it outclasses them all ''combined.'' Just how much of it is fans reading into things, how much is [[BaitAndSwitchLesbians genuine intentional implications]], and how much is a RelationshipWritingFumble causing them both to read as [[HaveIMentionedIAmHeterosexualToday less straight and more in denial]] is a topic of debate, but no matter the outcome, it pretty much consumed discussions of the show from every angle.angle.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/SherlockHolmes2009'': Most fans prefer to pair Sherlock Holmes and John Watson together over their canon pairings of Irene Adler and Mary respectively. This mostly due to the HoYay between the two and the chemistry between their actors. This has also led to some fans [[ActorShipping shipping said actors together]]. Most of the fanfics, shipping videos, and fanart of the movie centers around the ship.

to:

* ''Film/SherlockHolmes2009'': Most fans prefer to pair Sherlock Holmes and John Watson together over their canon pairings of Irene Adler and Mary respectively. This mostly due to the (deliberate) HoYay between the two and the chemistry between their actors. This has also led to some fans [[ActorShipping shipping said actors together]]. Most of the fanfics, shipping videos, and fanart of the movie centers around the ship.

Changed: 407

Removed: 309

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rewriting per discussion on the FPC thread.


* ''Series/{{Elementary}}'':
** Joan and Sherlock is the most popular ship overall. Repeated ShipSinking by WordOfGod doesn't deter the shippers much. Keep in mind this takes the preferred couple from Sherlock Holmes and makes Watson female.
** Joan/[[spoiler: Moriarty ]] is gaining reasonable amounts of fans after the season one finale.

to:

* ''Series/{{Elementary}}'':
** Joan
''Series/{{Elementary}}'': As is typical of most ''Sherlock Holmes'' adaptations, (Joan) Watson and Sherlock is Holmes are the most popular ship overall. Repeated overall due to their strong chemistry together, and in spite of repeated ShipSinking by WordOfGod doesn't deter the shippers much. Keep in mind this takes the preferred couple from creators. While Sherlock Holmes and makes Watson female.
** Joan/[[spoiler: Moriarty ]]
is gaining reasonable amounts of fans in love with Irene, even after the season one finale. reveal she's Moriarty, most fans prefer to ship him with Joan instead, as evidenced by all the support they receive on fanfiction sites.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/SherlockHolmes2009'': Most fans prefer to pair Sherlock Holmes and John Watson together over their canon ones of Irene Adler and Mary respectively. This mostly due to the HoYay between the two and the chemistry between their actors. This has also lead to some fans [[ActorShipping shipping said actors together]]. Most of the fanfics, shipping videos, and fanart of the movie centers around the ship.

to:

* ''Film/SherlockHolmes2009'': Most fans prefer to pair Sherlock Holmes and John Watson together over their canon ones pairings of Irene Adler and Mary respectively. This mostly due to the HoYay between the two and the chemistry between their actors. This has also lead led to some fans [[ActorShipping shipping said actors together]]. Most of the fanfics, shipping videos, and fanart of the movie centers around the ship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The famous detective Franchise/SherlockHolmes, and his supporting cast, has a bunch of [[FanPreferredCouple pairings that fans prefer]] to ship him with, be it with John Watson, Irene Adler, or other characters.

to:

The famous detective Franchise/SherlockHolmes, and along with his supporting cast, has a bunch of [[FanPreferredCouple pairings that fans prefer]] to ship him with, be it with John Watson, Irene Adler, or other characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The famouse detective Franchise/SherlockHolmes has a whole bunch of [[FanPreferredCouple pairings that fans prefer]], be it with John Watson, Irene Adler, or others

to:

The famouse famous detective Franchise/SherlockHolmes Franchise/SherlockHolmes, and his supporting cast, has a whole bunch of [[FanPreferredCouple pairings that fans prefer]], prefer]] to ship him with, be it with John Watson, Irene Adler, or others
other characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The famouse detective Franchise/SherlockHolmes has a whole bunch of [[FanPreferredCouple pairings that fans prefer]], be it with John Watson, Irene Adler, or others

----

!!Literature


* In ''Literature/SherlockHolmes'', there is Holmes/Watson - one of the, if not ''the'', most slashed pairing ever. In fact, pretty much every adaptation of Holmes will have its most popular pairing be Holmes/Watson. Non-yaoi fans can also [[PromotedToLoveInterest promote Irene Adler to love interest]], which many, many, writers, playwrights and scriptwriters have done throughout the years.


!!Live-Action Films

* ''Film/SherlockHolmes2009'': Most fans prefer to pair Sherlock Holmes and John Watson together over their canon ones of Irene Adler and Mary respectively. This mostly due to the HoYay between the two and the chemistry between their actors. This has also lead to some fans [[ActorShipping shipping said actors together]]. Most of the fanfics, shipping videos, and fanart of the movie centers around the ship.

!!Live-Action TV

* Virtually ''every'' fan of ''Series/TheAdventuresOfShirleyHolmes'' ships Bo/Shirley, and those who don't, well, they don't really mind the pairing either. The duo's relationship was never romantic in the series (save for some harmless ShipTease); in fact, they both had [[OfficialCouple other relationships]]. Thankfully, since the fandom was fairly small and the respective {{Love Interest}}s were very likable, the DieForOurShip was pretty much nonexistent.
* ''Series/{{Elementary}}'':
** Joan and Sherlock is the most popular ship overall. Repeated ShipSinking by WordOfGod doesn't deter the shippers much. Keep in mind this takes the preferred couple from Sherlock Holmes and makes Watson female.
** Joan/[[spoiler: Moriarty ]] is gaining reasonable amounts of fans after the season one finale.
* ''Series/MissSherlock'': It didn't take long for most fans to latch onto shipping Sherlock and Wato. As with most versions of the two characters, it had already started before the first episode aired, and only grew as the episodes aired. There's plenty of fanfiction, fanart, and fanvids for the ship, along with the pairing having a strong following on both Twitter and Tumblr. This is mainly due to the chemistry between their actresses, the LesYay between them, and the fact that their dynamic is the focus of the show. This continued even after Wato was given a proper love interest, Moriya, though thankfully he managed to avoid DieForOurShip, and continues even after the show ended.
* Sherlock/John in BBC's ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'', but this is hardly surprising considering it's a modern revival of one of the oldest bromances in literature, and both actors are quite good-looking. The number of fanfics that ''don't'' have John/Sherlock as the main couple is really very low compared to those featuring the [[spoiler: now canon]] John/Mary Morstan and the liberally ship-teased Sherlock/Irene or the less-teased-but-more-plausible Sherlock/Molly; and most of ''those'' are Mycroft/Lestrade fics that include John/Sherlock as the BetaCouple. On Archive of our Own, it doesn't just outclass all the other pairings; it outclasses them all ''combined.'' Just how much of it is fans reading into things, how much is [[BaitAndSwitchLesbians genuine intentional implications]], and how much is a RelationshipWritingFumble causing them both to read as [[HaveIMentionedIAmHeterosexualToday less straight and more in denial]] is a topic of debate, but no matter the outcome, it pretty much consumed discussions of the show from every angle.

Top