Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Creator / ElleryQueen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GoingByTheMatchbook: In ''Halfway House'', Ellery points out that most matchbooks are far too common for one to be incriminating. Then it turns out [[DoubleSubversion that one is]], anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HidingYourHeritage: In ''The Roman Hat Mystery'', a blackmailer has been going after several of the novel's characters. One of them was being threatened with this trope; the character in question had a black ancestor (but appeared Caucasian).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GentlemanDetective: Ellery was this is the early novels (being essentially an {{Expy}} of Literature/PhiloVance). However, as the series went on, his character developed and he lost most of his snobbishness (except on intellectual matters) and developed an interest in some decidedly blue collar pastimes such as boxing and baseball.

to:

* GentlemanDetective: Ellery was this is the early novels (being essentially an {{Expy}} of Literature/PhiloVance).Literature/PhiloVance), with his late mother having been the daughter of a New York society family. However, as the series went on, his character developed and he lost most of his snobbishness (except on intellectual matters) and developed an interest in some decidedly blue collar pastimes such as boxing and baseball.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GentlemanDetective: Ellery was this is the early novels (being essentially an {{Expy}} of Literature/PhiloVance). However, as the series went on, his character developed and he lost most of his snobbishness (except on intellectual matters) and developed an interest in some decidedly blue collar pastimes such as boxing and baseball.

Added: 194

Changed: 304

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LetOffByTheDetective: ''The Finishing Stroke''

to:

* LetOffByTheDetective: In ''The Finishing Stroke''Stroke'', Ellery is stumped by the murder for a couple of decades. When he does finally solve the case the killer, who was an older man when he committed the murder, is truly elderly and infirm. Since Ellery doesn't want to see him spend the last few years of his life in prison, he keeps his identity secret.


Added DiffLines:

* MurderByMistake: In ''The Finishing Stroke'', the murderer kills the wrong victim because [[spoiler:he was an identical triplet of the intended target whom the murderer did not know existed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MysteryWriterDetective

to:

* MysteryWriterDetectiveMysteryWriterDetective: The TropeMaker
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''I can recommend to the lover of the detective novel (which must not be confused with the mere adventure novel or those of international espionage, inevitably inhabited by sumptuous female spies that fall in love and secret documents) this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that it meets the first requirements of the genre: statement of all the terms of the problem; economy of characters and resources; primacy of the how over the whom; a solution necessary and wonderful, but not supernatural. (In detective stories, hypnotism, telepathic hallucinations, elixirs of evil operation, witches and warlocks, real magic and recreational physics, are scams.) Ellery Queen plays with the supernatural, as does Chesterton, but in a lawful way: he suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement, then forgets or denies it in the solution.''

to:

->''I can recommend to the lover of the detective novel (which must not be confused with the mere adventure novel or those of international espionage, inevitably inhabited by sumptuous female spies that fall in love and secret documents) this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that it meets the first requirements of the genre: statement of all the terms of the problem; economy of characters and resources; primacy of the how over the whom; a solution necessary and wonderful, but not supernatural. (In detective stories, hypnotism, telepathic hallucinations, elixirs of evil operation, witches and warlocks, real magic and recreational physics, are scams.) Ellery Queen plays with the supernatural, as does Chesterton, [[Creator/GKChesterton Chesterton]], but in a lawful way: he suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement, then forgets or denies it in the solution.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:344:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ellery_queen_detective.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:344:https://static.[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ellery_queen_detective.org/pmwiki/pub/images/wong_ellery_queen_is_alive_in_japan_ellery_manfred_b_lee_frederick_dannay.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Manfred B. Lee (l) and Fredric Dannay (r)]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:344:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ellery_queen_detective.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreepyCrossdresser: The murderer in ''[[spoiler:The Last Woman is His Life]]'' is one. It is the reveal of him being this (and a DepravedHomosexual) and the victim's reaction that drives him to murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DepravedHomosexual: The murderer in ''[[spoiler:The Last Woman in His Life]]''. Also a VillainousCrossdresser. Disturbingly for many modern readers, the novel (and the solution to the mystery) hinges heavily on now discredited ideas regarding the nature and causes of homosexuality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added the author's names to intro.


Golden age mystery writer, used as both a pen name for two authors and as the eponymous character.

to:

Golden age mystery writer, used as both a pen name for two authors authors, cousins Frederic Dannay and Manfred B. Lee, and as the eponymous character.

Changed: 512

Removed: 694

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse. Also, Useful Notes are not tropes and should not be listed as tropes.


* DirectLineToTheAuthor

to:

* DirectLineToTheAuthorDirectLineToTheAuthor: In a foreword to ''The Roman Hat Mystery'', the Fictional "J. J. [=McC.=]" explains that Ellery and Inspector Richard Queen are pseudonyms picked out by the real man who inspired Ellery, and further that the "real" Ellery is married. Subsequent books drop the roman à clef conceit, and Ellery remains a bachelor throughout the series. The reason for the discrepancy is probably that this novel was written for a whodunit contest, and Dannay and Lee rethought some things when they chose to continue the series.



* UsefulNotes/JackTheRipper: In ''A Study in Terror'', Ellery reads a manuscript detailing Franchise/SherlockHolmes's battle of wits against Jack the Ripper.



* LiteraryAgentHypothesis: In a foreword to ''The Roman Hat Mystery'', the Fictional "J. J. [=McC.=]" explains that Ellery and Inspector Richard Queen are pseudonyms picked out by the real man who inspired Ellery, and further that the "real" Ellery is married. Subsequent books drop the roman à clef conceit, and Ellery remains a bachelor throughout the series. The reason for the discrepancy is probably that this novel was written for a whodunit contest, and Dannay and Lee rethought some things when they chose to continue the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: In the earliest titles, Ellery's origins as a Literature/PhiloVance {{expy}} are much more apparent; he wears a pince-nez and is prone to GratuitousFrench.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
oops, we don't have that trope


* AliveAllAlong: In ''The Lamp of God'', [[spoiler: The supposedly long-deceased Olivia is actually quite alive and impersonating her lookalike cousin Alice. The story about the death was meant to throw off suspicion that the impersonation was possible, and also cover for Olivia's senile mother not remembering to pretend she didn't know Olivia when she saw her.]]

to:

* AliveAllAlong: In ''The Lamp of God'', [[spoiler: The supposedly long-deceased Olivia is actually quite alive and impersonating her lookalike cousin Alice. The story about the death was meant to throw off suspicion that the impersonation was possible, and also cover for Olivia's senile mother not remembering to pretend she didn't know Olivia when she saw her.]]

Added: 1287

Changed: 263

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
new tropes


* AliveAllAlong: In ''The Lamp of God'', [[spoiler: The supposedly long-deceased Olivia is actually quite alive and impersonating her lookalike cousin Alice. The story about the death was meant to throw off suspicion that the impersonation was possible, and also cover for Olivia's senile mother not remembering to pretend she didn't know Olivia when she saw her.]]



* BarelyThereSwimwear: In "The Adventure of the Treasure Hunt" Ellery declines searching some people in bathing suits after a reasonably large item goes missing, stating "you couldn't conceal anything larger than a fly's wing in those costumes."



* FingerLickingPoison: ''The Three Widows'' had a victim being slowly poisoned even though everything she ate and drank was carefully screened beforehand. It turned out the would-be killer was her doctor and the poison was on the thermometer with which he took her temperature each day.

to:

* FingerLickingPoison: FingerLickingPoison:
**
''The Three Widows'' had a victim being slowly poisoned even though everything she ate and drank was carefully screened beforehand. It turned out the would-be killer was her doctor and the poison was on the thermometer with which he took her temperature each day.day.
** In "Man Bites Dog" the murder weapon was a pencil dipped in cyanide; the victim had a habit of licking the points of pencils he was writing with.


Added DiffLines:

* ImpostorForgotOneDetail: In ''The Lamp of God'', [[spoiler: The false Alice ignores the photograph of the real Alice's mother which the real Alice had made a huge fuss over as it was only the second one she'd ever seen, tipping Ellery off that she's a phony.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''In the history of the detective genre (dating from April 1841, the date of the publication of "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" by Creator/EdgarAllanPoe), Ellery Queen novels import a deviation, or a little progress. I refer to his art. The novelist often proposes a vulgar clarification of the mystery and dazzle his readers with an ingenious solution. Ellery Queen proposes, like all the others, a not so interesting explanation, suggests (at last) a very beautiful solution which the reader falls in love with, then refutes it and discovers a third solution, which is the correct one: always less strange than the second, but entirely unpredictable and satisfying. Other great novels of Ellery Queen: The Egyptian Cross Mystery, the Dutch Shoe Mystery, The Siamese Twin Mystery''

to:

->''In the history of the detective genre (dating from April 1841, the date of the publication of "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" by Creator/EdgarAllanPoe), Ellery Queen novels import a deviation, or a little progress. I refer to his art. The novelist often proposes a vulgar clarification of the mystery and dazzle mystery, then dazzles his readers with an ingenious solution. Ellery Queen proposes, like all the others, a not so interesting explanation, suggests (at last) a very beautiful solution which the reader falls in love with, then refutes it and discovers a third solution, which is the correct one: always less strange than the second, but entirely unpredictable and satisfying. Other great novels of Ellery Queen: The Egyptian Cross Mystery, the Dutch Shoe Mystery, The Siamese Twin Mystery''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''I can recommend to the lover of the detective novel (which must not be confused with the mere adventure novel or those of international espionage, inevitably inhabited by sumptuous female spies that fall in love and secret documents) this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that it meets the first requirements of the genre: statement of all the terms of the problem; economy of characters and resources; primacy of the how over the whom; a solution necessary and wonderful, but not supernatural. (In detective stories, hypnotism, telepathic hallucinations, elixirs of evil operation, witches and warlocks, real magic and recreational physics, are scams.) Ellery Queen plays with the supernatural, as does Chesterton, but in a lawful way: it suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement, forgets it or denies it in the solution.''

to:

->''I can recommend to the lover of the detective novel (which must not be confused with the mere adventure novel or those of international espionage, inevitably inhabited by sumptuous female spies that fall in love and secret documents) this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that it meets the first requirements of the genre: statement of all the terms of the problem; economy of characters and resources; primacy of the how over the whom; a solution necessary and wonderful, but not supernatural. (In detective stories, hypnotism, telepathic hallucinations, elixirs of evil operation, witches and warlocks, real magic and recreational physics, are scams.) Ellery Queen plays with the supernatural, as does Chesterton, but in a lawful way: it he suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement, then forgets it or denies it in the solution.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''I can recommend to the detective novel’s (that must not be confused with the mere adventure novel or those of international espionage, inevitably inhabited by sumptuous female spies that fall in love and secret documents) amateur this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that meets the first requirements of the genre: statement of all the terms of the problem, economy of characters and resources, primacy of the how about the whom, necessary and wonderful solution, but not supernatural. (In detective stories, hypnotism, telepathic hallucinations, elixirs of evil operation, witches and warlocks, the real magic and recreational physics, are scams.) Ellery Queen plays with the supernatural, as Chesterton, but in a lawful way: it suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement, forgets it or denies it in the solution.''

->''In the history of the detective genre (dating from April 1841, the date of the publication of "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" by Creator/EdgarAllanPoe) Ellery Queen novels import a deviation, or a little progress. I refer to his art. The novelist often propose a vulgar clarification of the mystery and dazzle his readers with an ingenious solution. Ellery Queen proposes, like all the others, a not so interesting explanation, suggests (at last) a very beautiful solution, from which the reader falls in love with, refutes it and he discovers a third solution, which is the correct one: always less strange than the second, but entirely unpredictable and satisfying. Other great novels of Ellery Queen: The Egyptian Cross Mystery, the Dutch Shoe Mystery, The Siamese Twin Mystery''

to:

->''I can recommend to the lover of the detective novel’s (that novel (which must not be confused with the mere adventure novel or those of international espionage, inevitably inhabited by sumptuous female spies that fall in love and secret documents) amateur this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that it meets the first requirements of the genre: statement of all the terms of the problem, problem; economy of characters and resources, resources; primacy of the how about over the whom, whom; a solution necessary and wonderful solution, wonderful, but not supernatural. (In detective stories, hypnotism, telepathic hallucinations, elixirs of evil operation, witches and warlocks, the real magic and recreational physics, are scams.) Ellery Queen plays with the supernatural, as does Chesterton, but in a lawful way: it suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement, forgets it or denies it in the solution.''

->''In the history of the detective genre (dating from April 1841, the date of the publication of "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" by Creator/EdgarAllanPoe) Creator/EdgarAllanPoe), Ellery Queen novels import a deviation, or a little progress. I refer to his art. The novelist often propose proposes a vulgar clarification of the mystery and dazzle his readers with an ingenious solution. Ellery Queen proposes, like all the others, a not so interesting explanation, suggests (at last) a very beautiful solution, from solution which the reader falls in love with, then refutes it and he discovers a third solution, which is the correct one: always less strange than the second, but entirely unpredictable and satisfying. Other great novels of Ellery Queen: The Egyptian Cross Mystery, the Dutch Shoe Mystery, The Siamese Twin Mystery''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CanonDiscontinuity: The first novel ''The Roman Hat Mystery'' suposedly describes an event that happened some time in the past and mentions that Ellery now lives in Italy with his wife and daughter. The wife, daughter and retirement to Italy are never mentioned in any of the subsequent books that establish that Ellery is a bachelor who lives with his father in New York (apart from a brief period of living in Hollywood).
* CanonImmigrant: Ellery's secreatary Nikki Porter was originally created for the radio show, but went on to appear in two of the novels and several short stories.

to:

* CanonDiscontinuity: The first novel ''The Roman Hat Mystery'' suposedly supposedly describes an event that happened some time in the past past, and mentions that Ellery now lives in Italy with his wife and daughter. The wife, daughter and retirement to Italy are never mentioned in any of the subsequent books that establish that Ellery is a bachelor who lives with his father in New York (apart from a brief period of living in Hollywood).
* CanonImmigrant: Ellery's secreatary secretary Nikki Porter was originally created for the radio show, but went on to appear in two of the novels and several short stories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DistaffCounterpart: ''MurderSheWrote''

to:

* DistaffCounterpart: ''MurderSheWrote''''Series/MurderSheWrote''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Potholes are not allowed in page quotes.


->''I can recommend to the [[MysteryLiterature detective novel’s]] (that must not be confused with the mere [[{{Adventure}} adventure novel]] or those of [[SpyFiction international espionage]], [[ClicheStorm inevitably inhabited by]] [[SexFaceTurn sumptuous female spies that fall in love]] and [[MacGuffin secret documents]]) amateur this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that meets [[FairPlayWhoDunnit the first requirements of the genre]]: [[TheSummation statement of all the terms of the problem]], [[ClosedCircle economy of characters and resources]], [[LockedRoomMystery primacy of the how about the whom]], necessary and wonderful solution, but not [[OutOfGenreExperience supernatural]]. (In detective stories, [[HypnoFool hypnotism]], [[{{Telepathy}} telepathic hallucinations]], [[LovePotion elixirs of evil operation]], [[WitchSpecies witches and warlocks]], [[FunctionalMagic the real magic]] and [[ArtisticLicensePhysics recreational physics]], [[AssPull are scams]].) Ellery Queen [[Literature/FatherBrown plays with the supernatural, as Chesterton]], but in a lawful way: [[MaybeMagicMaybeMundane it suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement]], [[ScoobyDooHoax forgets it or denies it in the solution]].''

->''In the history of the [[MysteryLiterature detective genre]] ([[UrExample dating from April 1841, the date of the publication of "The Murders in the Rue Morgue"]] by EdgarAllanPoe) Ellery Queen novels import [[GrowingTheBeard a deviation, or a little progress]]. I refer to his art. The novelist often propose a [[MundaneSolution vulgar clarification of the mystery]] and [[ComplexityAddiction dazzle his readers with an ingenious solution]]. Ellery Queen proposes, [[FollowTheLeader like all the others]] , a not so interesting explanation, suggests (at last) a very beautiful solution, from which the reader falls in love with, [[YourPrincessIsInAnotherCastle refutes it]] and he [[TakeAThirdOption discovers a third solution]] , which is the correct one: [[MadeOfWin always less strange than the second, but entirely unpredictable and satisfying]]. Other great novels of Ellery Queen: The Egyptian Cross Mystery, the Dutch Shoe Mystery, The Siamese Twin Mystery''

-->--'''JorgeLuisBorges.''' Revista Hogar, October 30, 1936



to:

->''I can recommend to the [[MysteryLiterature detective novel’s]] novel’s (that must not be confused with the mere [[{{Adventure}} adventure novel]] novel or those of [[SpyFiction international espionage]], [[ClicheStorm espionage, inevitably inhabited by]] [[SexFaceTurn by sumptuous female spies that fall in love]] love and [[MacGuffin secret documents]]) documents) amateur this last book of Ellery Queen. I can say that meets [[FairPlayWhoDunnit the first requirements of the genre]]: [[TheSummation genre: statement of all the terms of the problem]], [[ClosedCircle problem, economy of characters and resources]], [[LockedRoomMystery resources, primacy of the how about the whom]], whom, necessary and wonderful solution, but not [[OutOfGenreExperience supernatural]]. not supernatural. (In detective stories, [[HypnoFool hypnotism]], [[{{Telepathy}} hypnotism, telepathic hallucinations]], [[LovePotion hallucinations, elixirs of evil operation]], [[WitchSpecies operation, witches and warlocks]], [[FunctionalMagic warlocks, the real magic]] magic and [[ArtisticLicensePhysics recreational physics]], [[AssPull physics, are scams]].scams.) Ellery Queen [[Literature/FatherBrown plays with the supernatural, as Chesterton]], Chesterton, but in a lawful way: [[MaybeMagicMaybeMundane it suggests it to make the mystery bigger in the problem statement]], [[ScoobyDooHoax statement, forgets it or denies it in the solution]].solution.''

->''In the history of the [[MysteryLiterature detective genre]] ([[UrExample dating genre (dating from April 1841, the date of the publication of "The Murders in the Rue Morgue"]] Morgue" by EdgarAllanPoe) Creator/EdgarAllanPoe) Ellery Queen novels import [[GrowingTheBeard a deviation, or a little progress]].progress. I refer to his art. The novelist often propose a [[MundaneSolution vulgar clarification of the mystery]] mystery and [[ComplexityAddiction dazzle his readers with an ingenious solution]]. solution. Ellery Queen proposes, [[FollowTheLeader like all the others]] , others, a not so interesting explanation, suggests (at last) a very beautiful solution, from which the reader falls in love with, [[YourPrincessIsInAnotherCastle refutes it]] it and he [[TakeAThirdOption discovers a third solution]] , solution, which is the correct one: [[MadeOfWin one: always less strange than the second, but entirely unpredictable and satisfying]].satisfying. Other great novels of Ellery Queen: The Egyptian Cross Mystery, the Dutch Shoe Mystery, The Siamese Twin Mystery''

-->--'''JorgeLuisBorges.-->--'''Creator/JorgeLuisBorges.''' Revista Hogar, October 30, 1936


1936
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ComicBookTime: Ellery goes through numerous changes during his run, but he stays at about the same age from 1929 to 1971. Some books (like ''The Finishing Stroke'') acknowledge the passage of time, and Inspector Queen eventually retires, but Ellery is certainly not in his 60s (or older) by the time of ''A Fine and Private Place''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CanonDiscontinuity: The first novel ''The Roman Hat Mystery'' suposedly describes an event that happened some time in the past and mentions that Ellery now lives in Italy with his wife and daughter. The wife, daughter and retirement to Italy are never mentioned in any of the subsequent books that establish that Ellery is a bachelor who lives with his father in New York (apart from a brief period of living in Hollywood).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EurekaMoment: Ellery is prone to these. For example, in ''The Scarlet Letters'' he is watching some wet paint run in the rain when the meaning the victim's DyingClue suddenly becomes apparent to him.

Added: 210

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BetterManhandleTheMurderWeapon: In "No Place to Live", one suspect is found standing over the body holding a pistol. It is later revealed that she picked the gun up because she recognised it as her husband's.



* MysteryMagnet: While some of Ellery's cases come to him via his father, it also seems that Ellery cannot travel anywhere without stumbling across a mystery. This even gets {{lampshaded}} in the novella "Mum's the Word" when the chief of police comments that Ellery can't visit Wrightsville without a major crime taking place.

to:

* MysteryMagnet: While some of Ellery's cases come to him via his father, it also seems that Ellery cannot travel anywhere without stumbling across a mystery. This even gets {{lampshaded}} in the novella "Mum's "Mum is the Word" when the chief of police comments that Ellery can't visit Wrightsville without a major crime taking place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MysteryMagnet: While some of Ellery's cases come to him via his father, it also seems that Ellery cannot travel anywhere without stumbling across a mystery. This even gets {{lampshaded}} in the novella "Mum's the Word" when the chief of police comments that Ellery can't visit Wrightsville without a major crime taking place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JackTheRipper: In ''A Study in Terror'', Ellery reads a manuscript detailing Franchise/SherlockHolmes's battle of wits against Jack the Ripper.

to:

* JackTheRipper: UsefulNotes/JackTheRipper: In ''A Study in Terror'', Ellery reads a manuscript detailing Franchise/SherlockHolmes's battle of wits against Jack the Ripper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ClearTheirName: In ''Calamity Town'' Ellery tries to help Patricia Wright clear her brother-in-law Jim Haight when he is accused of the attempted poisoning of his wife Nora and the AccidentalMurder of his sister Rosemary. Not only does all available evidence work to convict Jim, but he flat out refuses to testify on his own behalf.

Top