Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / PaperGirls

Go To

OR

Added: 104

Changed: 114

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie is prone to offhand homophobic comments and is later revealed to be an actual homophobe, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually contributes to her death from leukemia in the '90s]]. All of this helps establish her as the girl from the WrongSideOfTheTracks.
** Erin mentions several times that Mac isn't just ''a'' papergirl, she's the ''first'' papergirl, at least in Cleveland, because delivering newspapers was traditionally considered boy's work. Younger readers might be surprised to learn that the glass ceiling was that low fairly recently.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie is prone to offhand homophobic comments and is later revealed to be an actual homophobe, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant homophobe because most people considered casual homophobia of normal in the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually contributes to her death from leukemia in the '90s]]. All of this helps establish her as the redneck girl from the WrongSideOfTheTracks.
** Erin mentions several times that Mac isn't just ''a'' papergirl, she's the ''first'' papergirl, at least in Cleveland, because delivering newspapers was traditionally considered boy's work. Younger readers might be surprised to learn that the glass ceiling was that low fairly recently.as recent as 1988.



* ForeverWar: The future appears to be locked in a perpetual inter-generational war, with adults as the villains and teens leading LaResistance.

to:

* ForeverWar: The future appears to be locked in a perpetual inter-generational war, with adults as the villains enemy and teens leading LaResistance.



* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin]] asks several very personal questions in a row to verify that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] is who she claims to be. Subverted in that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] doesn't know the answer to the first one (her social security number), and the last one isn't a Trust Password at all, it's a genuine question that [[spoiler:2016!Erin]] has always wondered about.

to:

* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin]] asks several very personal questions in a row to verify that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] is who she claims to be. Subverted in that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] doesn't know the answer to the first one (her social security number), and the last one isn't a Trust Password at all, it's a genuine question that [[spoiler:2016!Erin]] has always wondered about.about.
* UnusualEuphemism: The alien translation devices produce some very odd but still understandable idioms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{McGuffin)): the girls find a mysterious, futuristic high-tech artifact--instantly recognizable to modern readers as an old IPod -- but it's the apple symbol that's significant, not the object itself.

to:

* {{McGuffin)): the girls find a mysterious, futuristic high-tech artifact--instantly recognizable to modern readers as an old IPod [=IPod=] -- but it's the apple symbol that's significant, not the object itself.



** She also has a FarSide page-a-day calendar which depicts an actual Far Side cartoon and may just show the correct cartoon for November 1, 1988.

to:

** She also has a FarSide ''[[TheFarSide Far Side]]'' page-a-day calendar which depicts an actual Far Side cartoon and may just show the correct cartoon for November 1, 1988.

Added: 372

Changed: 7

Removed: 261

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultsAreUseless: worse than useless, they're the actual enemy.

to:

* AdultsAreUseless: worse than useless, they're the actual enemy.



* ArcSymbol: apples and biblical and mythological references to apples show up everywhere, and Erin's first name (rather irish sounding for an Asian-American girl) is awfully close to ''Eris'' the Greek goddess who created the original AppleOfDiscord.



** Erin also mentions, off-hand, that her neighbors don't like her family, likely due to good 'ol middle American racism.



* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin]] asks several very personal questions in a row to verify that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] is who she claims to be. Subverted in that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] doesn't know the answer to the first one (her social security number), and the last one isn't a Trust Password at all, it's a genuine question that [[spoiler:2016!Erin]] has always wondered about.
* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic: apples and biblical and mythological references to apples show up everywhere, and Erin's first name (rather irish sounding for an Asian-American girl) is awfully close to ''Eris'' the greek goddess who created the ApplesOfDiscord.

to:

* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin]] asks several very personal questions in a row to verify that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] is who she claims to be. Subverted in that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] doesn't know the answer to the first one (her social security number), and the last one isn't a Trust Password at all, it's a genuine question that [[spoiler:2016!Erin]] has always wondered about.
* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic: apples and biblical and mythological references to apples show up everywhere, and Erin's first name (rather irish sounding for an Asian-American girl) is awfully close to ''Eris'' the greek goddess who created the ApplesOfDiscord.
about.

Added: 609

Changed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadFuture: Where the invaders seem to hail from. [[spoiler:1988!Erin also seems to think this about 2016, much to her older self's annoyance.]]

to:

* BadFuture: Where the invaders seem CatholicSchoolGirlsRule: Erin and Tiffany go to hail from. [[spoiler:1988!Erin different Catholic schools, KJ is Jewish but also seems goes to think this about 2016, much to her older self's annoyance.]]a private school, Mac is the sole public school girl.



* {{McGuffin)): the girls find a mysterious, futuristic high-tech artifact--instantly recognizable to modern readers as an old IPod -- but it's the apple symbol that's significant, not the object itself.



**She also has a FarSide page-a-day calendar which depicts an actual Far Side cartoon and may just show the correct cartoon for November 1, 1988.



* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin]] asks several very personal questions in a row to verify that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] is who she claims to be. Subverted in that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] doesn't know the answer to the first one (her social security number), and the last one isn't a Trust Password at all, it's a genuine question that [[spoiler:2016!Erin]] has always wondered about.

to:

* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin]] asks several very personal questions in a row to verify that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] is who she claims to be. Subverted in that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] doesn't know the answer to the first one (her social security number), and the last one isn't a Trust Password at all, it's a genuine question that [[spoiler:2016!Erin]] has always wondered about.about.
* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic: apples and biblical and mythological references to apples show up everywhere, and Erin's first name (rather irish sounding for an Asian-American girl) is awfully close to ''Eris'' the greek goddess who created the ApplesOfDiscord.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TeensAreMonsters: namechecked. The future appears to be locked in a wa

to:

* TeensAreMonsters: namechecked. The future appears to be locked in a wawar between kids and adults.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlienInvasion: An oversimplification of the world.

to:

* AlienInvasion: An oversimplification of the world.world, though it's perfectly natural for young girls primed by pop culture to draw this interpretation.

Added: 1268

Changed: 696

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultsAreUseless: worse than useless, they're the actual enemy.



* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually contributes to her death from leukemia in the '90s]].

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of Mackenzie is prone to offhand homophobic comments, comments and is later revealed to be an actual homophobe, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually contributes to her death from leukemia in the '90s]]. All of this helps establish her as the girl from the WrongSideOfTheTracks.
**Erin mentions several times that Mac isn't just ''a'' papergirl, she's the ''first'' papergirl, at least in Cleveland, because delivering newspapers was traditionally considered boy's work. Younger readers might be surprised to learn that the glass ceiling was that low fairly recently.



* EntertaininglyWrong: Mac says her father told her there was no future in the newspaper business because "we've used up all of the trees" and "people will get all their news from television."
* ForeverWar: The future appears to be locked in a perpetual inter-generational war, with adults as the villains and teens leading LaResistance.



* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mac insists on retrieving her father's gun for protection but they find it in the hands of her drunken and suicidal stepmother, who promptly shoots Erin in the stomach by accident.
* MostWritersAreAdults: The girls are all 12-14, but talk and act like hard-drinking, hard-smoking longshoremen.

to:

* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mac insists on retrieving her father's gun for protection but they find it in the hands of her drunken and suicidal stepmother, who stepmother and Erin promptly shoots Erin in the stomach gets shot by accident.
* InTheBlood: A police officer accuses Mac of vandalism just because she's Mackenzie Coyle and asks if she's getting into the family business.
* MostWritersAreAdults: The girls are all 12-14, 12, but talk and act like hard-drinking, hard-smoking longshoremen.longshoremen...or maybe like 12 year olds who are trying to act tough.



* TimeyWimeyBall: One of the aliens, when asked if they are time travelers or space travelers, helpfully points out that time travel has to ''be'' space travel because the planet is always in motion: If you traveled in time without travelling in space you'd end up drifting in vacuum where the planet used to be.

to:

* TimeyWimeyBall: One TimeyWimeyBall:
** The girls quickly loose track of where or when they may be after issue 5.
**One
of the aliens, when asked if they are time travelers or space travelers, helpfully points out that time travel has to ''be'' space travel because the planet Earth is always in motion: moving: If you traveled in time without travelling in space you'd end up drifting in vacuum where the planet used vacuum.
* TeensAreMonsters: namechecked. The future appears
to be.be locked in a wa
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrayShotsStrikeNothing: Averted: When Mac wrestles her father's gun away from her suicidal stepmother it goes off. The bullet strikes Erin in the stomach.

to:

* StrayShotsStrikeNothing: Averted: When Mac wrestles her Mac's father's gun goes off as she's wrestling it away from her suicidal stepmother it goes off. The the bullet strikes Erin in the stomach.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TimeyWimeyBall: One of the "aliens", when asked if he is a time traveler or a space traveler, points out that time travel ''is'' space travel because the planet is always in motion: If you traveled in time without travelling in space you'd just end up drifting in vacumm where the planet used to be.

to:

* TimeyWimeyBall: One of the "aliens", aliens, when asked if he is a they are time traveler travelers or a space traveler, travelers, helpfully points out that time travel ''is'' has to ''be'' space travel because the planet is always in motion: If you traveled in time without travelling in space you'd just end up drifting in vacumm vacuum where the planet used to be.

Added: 459

Changed: 309

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:300:From left to right: Mac, KJ, Tiffany, and Erin]]''Paper Girls'' is a 2015 ongoing Creator/ImageComics comic book series written by Creator/BrianKVaughan and illustrated by Cliff Chiang. Early on the morning of All Saint's Day 1988, newspaper girl named Erin goes on her normal route in a Cleveland suburb only to be rescued by a trio of other paper girls from middle-school boys with suspicious intentions. That's when things start to get strange.

to:

[[caption-width-right:300:From left to right: Mac, KJ, Tiffany, and Erin]]''Paper Girls'' is a 2015 ongoing Creator/ImageComics comic book series written by Creator/BrianKVaughan and illustrated by Cliff Chiang. Early on the morning of All Saint's Day 1988, 12 year old newspaper delivery girl named Erin Tieng goes on her normal route in a Cleveland suburb only to be rescued by a trio of other paper girls from middle-school boys with suspicious intentions.intentions by a trio of other paper girls. That's when things start to get strange.



* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually contibutes to her death from leukemia in the '90s]].

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually contibutes contributes to her death from leukemia in the '90s]].



* IHatePastMe / FutureMeScaresMe: First played straight, then averted as [[spoiler:the Erins come to an understanding with each other.]]
* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mac insists on retrieving her father's gun for protection and promptly shoots Erin in the stomach by accident because she doesn't know the first thing about gun safety.

to:

* IHatePastMe / FutureMeScaresMe: First played straight, then averted as [[spoiler:the Erins come to an understanding with each other.]] Reconstructed when [[spoiler: far-future Erin turns out to be a treacherous clone.]]
* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mac insists on retrieving her father's gun for protection but they find it in the hands of her drunken and suicidal stepmother, who promptly shoots Erin in the stomach by accident because she doesn't know the first thing about gun safety.accident.


Added DiffLines:

* StrayShotsStrikeNothing: Averted: When Mac wrestles her father's gun away from her suicidal stepmother it goes off. The bullet strikes Erin in the stomach.
* TimeyWimeyBall: One of the "aliens", when asked if he is a time traveler or a space traveler, points out that time travel ''is'' space travel because the planet is always in motion: If you traveled in time without travelling in space you'd just end up drifting in vacumm where the planet used to be.

Added: 102

Changed: 245

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnnoyingYoungerSibling: Erin has an extremely frustrating relationship with her little sister Missy.



* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually leads to her death from leukemia in the '90s]].

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually leads contibutes to her death from leukemia in the '90s]].



* HumanAlien: Save for their strange speech, clothing, and mounts, the invaders could pass for human.

to:

* HumanAlien: Save for their strange speech, clothing, and mounts, the invaders could pass for human. [[spoiler: because they're time travellers, not aliens.]]



* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mere minutes after getting their hands on a gun, one of the paper girls is accidentally shot.

to:

* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mere minutes after getting their hands Mac insists on a gun, one of retrieving her father's gun for protection and promptly shoots Erin in the paper girls is accidentally shot.stomach by accident because she doesn't know the first thing about gun safety.

Added: 113

Removed: 112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllWritersAreAdults: The girls are all 12-14, but talk and act like hard-drinking, hard-smoking longshoremen.


Added DiffLines:

* MostWritersAreAdults: The girls are all 12-14, but talk and act like hard-drinking, hard-smoking longshoremen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllWritersAreAdults: The girls are all 12-14, but talk and act like hard-drinking, hard-smoking longshoremen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeathSeeker: [[spoiler:Mac seems to have a mild case after learning the exact time and cause of her impending death. She rationalizes it with the statement that, since she knows when she's going to die, any OTHER given situation she finds herself in won't kill her. Tiffany doesn't seem to buy it.]]


Added DiffLines:

* MemoryWipingCrew [[spoiler: 2016!Erin theorizes this is why she can't remember being shot, despite her still having the scar and 1988!Erin recalling it quite clearly. Old Erin concludes that sometime between 1988 and 2016, her memory was wiped.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s. She also smokes cigarettes, [[spoiler: which eventually leads to her death from leukemia in the '90s]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadFuture: Where the invaders seem to hail from. [[spoiler:1988!Erin also seems to think this about 2016, much to her older self's annoyance.]]


Added DiffLines:

* IHatePastMe / FutureMeScaresMe: First played straight, then averted as [[spoiler:the Erins come to an understanding with each other.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin uses one to verify that 1988!Erin is who she claims to be.]]

to:

* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin uses one 2016!Erin]] asks several very personal questions in a row to verify that 1988!Erin [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] is who she claims to be.]]be. Subverted in that [[spoiler:1988!Erin]] doesn't know the answer to the first one (her social security number), and the last one isn't a Trust Password at all, it's a genuine question that [[spoiler:2016!Erin]] has always wondered about.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TranslatorMicrobes: With the help of translators attached to their throats, the invaders can speak heavily-accented English.

to:

* TranslatorMicrobes: With the help of translators attached to their throats, the invaders can speak heavily-accented English.English.
* TrustPassword: [[spoiler: 2016!Erin uses one to verify that 1988!Erin is who she claims to be.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: Erin has a ''Film/MonsterSquad'' poster in her bedroom.

to:

* ShoutOut: Erin has a ''Film/MonsterSquad'' ''Film/TheMonsterSquad'' poster in her bedroom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut: Erin has a ''Film/MonsterSquad'' poster in her bedroom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NotalgiaAintLikeItUsedToBe: The series is both nostalgic and realistic, pointing out some of the less glamorous parts of the '80s (such as the casual use of homophobic slurs, or young teens smoking without any regard for the health risks).

to:

* NotalgiaAintLikeItUsedToBe: NostalgiaAintLikeItUsedToBe: The series is both nostalgic and realistic, pointing out some of the less glamorous parts of the '80s (such as the casual use of homophobic slurs, or young teens smoking without any regard for the health risks).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotalgiaAintLikeItUsedToBe: The series is both nostalgic and realistic, pointing out some of the less glamorous parts of the '80s (such as the casual use of homophobic slurs, or young teens smoking without any regard for the health risks).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Paper Girls'' is a 2015 ongoing Creator/ImageComics comic book series written by Creator/BrianKVaughan and illustrated by Cliff Chiang. Early on the morning of All Saint's Day 1988, newspaper girl named Erin goes on her normal route in a Cleveland suburb only to be rescued by a trio of other paper girls from middle-school boys with suspicious intentions. That's when things start to get strange.

to:

''Paper [[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/papergirls1_2x3_300.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:300:From left to right: Mac, KJ, Tiffany, and Erin]]''Paper
Girls'' is a 2015 ongoing Creator/ImageComics comic book series written by Creator/BrianKVaughan and illustrated by Cliff Chiang. Early on the morning of All Saint's Day 1988, newspaper girl named Erin goes on her normal route in a Cleveland suburb only to be rescued by a trio of other paper girls from middle-school boys with suspicious intentions. That's when things start to get strange.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DomesticatedDinosaurs: One of the alien leaders rides a pterosaur.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TranslatorCollar: With the help of translators attached to their throats, the invaders can speak heavily-accented English.

to:

* TranslatorCollar: TranslatorMicrobes: With the help of translators attached to their throats, the invaders can speak heavily-accented English.

Added: 124

Removed: 129

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AliensSpeakingEnglish: With the help of translators attached to their throats, the invaders can speak heavily-accented English.



* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mere minutes after getting their hands on a gun, one of the paper girls is accidentally shot.

to:

* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mere minutes after getting their hands on a gun, one of the paper girls is accidentally shot.shot.
* TranslatorCollar: With the help of translators attached to their throats, the invaders can speak heavily-accented English.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added missing brackets


* Cliffhanger: In classic Vaughan style, every issue seems to end with one.

to:

* Cliffhanger: {{Cliffhanger}}: In classic Vaughan style, every issue seems to end with one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cliffhanger

Added DiffLines:

* Cliffhanger: In classic Vaughan style, every issue seems to end with one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
creating page

Added DiffLines:

''Paper Girls'' is a 2015 ongoing Creator/ImageComics comic book series written by Creator/BrianKVaughan and illustrated by Cliff Chiang. Early on the morning of All Saint's Day 1988, newspaper girl named Erin goes on her normal route in a Cleveland suburb only to be rescued by a trio of other paper girls from middle-school boys with suspicious intentions. That's when things start to get strange.

----
!!Tropes:
* ActionGirl: All the girls qualify, to varying degrees.
* AlienAbduction: Everyone in Stony Stream is vanishing into thin air. In issue #5 we find out where they've gone.
* AlienInvasion: An oversimplification of the world.
* AliensSpeakingEnglish: With the help of translators attached to their throats, the invaders can speak heavily-accented English.
* ArtificialScript: Without their translators, alien speech is rendered as indecipherable script.
* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Mackenzie, one of the protagonists, makes a series of offhand homophobic comments, which Vaughan says was important to use to establish the rampant casual homophobia of the 80s.
* FourTemperamentEnsemble:
** '''Sanguine''': Erin
** '''Choleric''': Mackenzie ("Mac")
** '''Melancholic''': KJ ("Kaje")
** '''Phlegmatic''': Tiffany
* HumanAlien: Save for their strange speech, clothing, and mounts, the invaders could pass for human.
* IJustShotMarvinInTheFace: Mere minutes after getting their hands on a gun, one of the paper girls is accidentally shot.

Top