Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / CivilWar2006

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding link


* NothingPersonal: Defied by Underworld, one of Hammerhead's henchmen. after he betrays him. He goes around killing people for him, and always clarifies this. In the end, he turns against him, mocks on the concept, and reminds Hammerhead that he had killed his brother. Nothing Personal? Of course not. All murders are personal.

to:

* NothingPersonal: Defied by Underworld, ComicBook/{{Underworld|2006}}, one of Hammerhead's henchmen. after he betrays him. He goes around killing people for him, and always clarifies this. In the end, he turns against him, mocks on the concept, and reminds Hammerhead that he had killed his brother. Nothing Personal? Of course not. All murders are personal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The SHRA, in its most common presentation, is wildly unconstitutional, violating over ''half'' of the Bill of Rights. Wearing a costume even if you don't have superpowers and being in an unlicensed superteam even if you're not actively fighting crime are both illegal, so that's free speech (choosing what to wear is an aspect of speech) and free assembly done for, and the First Amendment violated. There are superheroes whose superpowers are "has guns", most notably the Punisher, who is somehow in violation despite his "costume" being pants and a t-shirt, so apparently the government can imprison you if you carry guns around in a manner they don't like, so that's the Second Amendment violated. Anti-reg heroes are thrown into jail without warrants issued and with no trial, so that's the Fourth (warrants), Fifth (due process), and Sixth Amendments (speedy trial, public trial, trial by jury, allowed to call and confront witnesses, assistance of counsel) violated. The jail is in the Negative Zone, which is painful for any thinking being to spend time in, which means prisoners are being tortured in their every waking moment, which more than meets the bar for "cruel and unusual punishment" and would violate the Seventh Amendment. Any half-competent lawyer could have had the act blocked one second after it went into effect, and any court would have thrown out the entire thing.

Added: 543

Changed: 284

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoversAlwaysLie: ''Fantastic Four'' #537: Dr. Doom lifting [[ComicBook/TheMightyThor Thor]]'s hammer, over the defeated bodies of the Fantastic Four. Only a tiny and limited number of "worthy" heroes have been capable to lift it. Nobody should be surprised to find out that Dr. Doom is not among them.

to:

* CoversAlwaysLie: CoversAlwaysLie:
** The cover of issue #1 features Professor X and Wolverine on Iron Man's side. Not only do the two (and the entire X-Men) have barely any involvement in the event itself, but Professor X doesn't actually appear in that issue ''nor the entire main event.''
**
''Fantastic Four'' #537: Dr. Doom lifting [[ComicBook/TheMightyThor Thor]]'s hammer, over the defeated bodies of the Fantastic Four. Only a tiny and limited number of "worthy" heroes have been capable to lift it. Nobody should be surprised to find out that Dr. Doom is not among them.

Changed: 278

Removed: 574

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This doesn't seem to have anything to do with the trope


* ShoutOut:
** Reed Richards admits to having basically invented psychohistory, but needs someone to check his figures. He asks recurring villain Mad Thinker for help, as he's an evil super-mathematician who likes to use {{Xanatos Gambit}}s. The Thinker is bowled over by the scope of Reed's calculations.
** In "Choosing Sides", Gargan criticizes Radioactive Man for his AtrociousAlias and asks why he didn't go for a name like "ComicBook/TheAtom" or "[[ComicBook/FirestormDCComics Firestorm]]" instead. Radioactive Man replies that it's because of "[[LampshadeHanging legal reasons]]".

to:

* ShoutOut:
** Reed Richards admits to having basically invented psychohistory, but needs someone to check his figures. He asks recurring villain Mad Thinker for help, as he's an evil super-mathematician who likes to use {{Xanatos Gambit}}s. The Thinker is bowled over by the scope of Reed's calculations.
**
ShoutOut: In "Choosing Sides", Gargan criticizes Radioactive Man for his AtrociousAlias and asks why he didn't go for a name like "ComicBook/TheAtom" or "[[ComicBook/FirestormDCComics Firestorm]]" instead. Radioactive Man replies that it's because of "[[LampshadeHanging legal reasons]]".

Added: 574

Changed: 290

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: Reed Richards admits to having basically invented psychohistory, but needs someone to check his figures. He asks recurring villain Mad Thinker for help, as he's an evil super-mathematician who likes to use {{Xanatos Gambit}}s. The Thinker is bowled over by the scope of Reed's calculations.

to:

* ShoutOut: ShoutOut:
**
Reed Richards admits to having basically invented psychohistory, but needs someone to check his figures. He asks recurring villain Mad Thinker for help, as he's an evil super-mathematician who likes to use {{Xanatos Gambit}}s. The Thinker is bowled over by the scope of Reed's calculations.calculations.
** In "Choosing Sides", Gargan criticizes Radioactive Man for his AtrociousAlias and asks why he didn't go for a name like "ComicBook/TheAtom" or "[[ComicBook/FirestormDCComics Firestorm]]" instead. Radioactive Man replies that it's because of "[[LampshadeHanging legal reasons]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicensePolitics: Tony attempts to manipulate/trick Storm into registering when she arrives at the White House for a diplomatic visit. While Ororo is a US citizen, she's also the ''Queen of Wakanda''--that is to say, a foreign head of state. US nationals actually don't normally get recognized as diplomatic agents of other countries and so wouldn't get diplomatic immunity, but as she is the actual queen and not just a functionary this becomes stickier. Even the laxer presentations of the SHRA are still a ridiculous amount of power for the US to expect to exercise over the monarch of another country. Moreover, the papers are simply presented to Storm as a surprise and she's asked to sign them immediately; in real life, anyone of her caliber will not be signing ''anything'' that hasn't been looked at and argued over for weeks if not months by diplomats and lawyers. The justification for springing the papers on her is that the President can't meet with unregistered heroes, but an issue that would prevent the meeting entirely should've been brought up long before she even entered the country. (While Ororo might have to ultimately renounce her American citizenship just to smooth things over, see above about how this should all have been hammered out weeks ahead of time. In fact, the citizenship question might've had to be settled as far back as her actual wedding.) When things devolve into fighting, Tony then behaves as if the Wakandans started it, and later attempts to violate diplomatic immunity by ordering the Dora Milaje to be arrested for attacking people to protect T'Challa (diplomatic immunity is complicated, but bodyguards carrying out their duty to protect their charge would most certainly fall under it).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Living up to [[ReedRichardsIsUseless the trope named after him]], Mr. Fantastic was the sole human on Earth who was informed about [[ComicBook/{{Annihilation}}, Annihilus' attempted genocide of all life in the universe that was going on at the same time.]] First from the Super Skrull, a hated enemy who literally had to '''beg''' Richards to let him use the Negative Zone portal after giving a firsthand account of Annihilus' genocide. Later Nova sent multiple distress signals to Reed, warning him that Annihilus was ''days away'' from reaching Earth. Reed told no one about either of these warnings. ''What If? Annihilation'' shows just how costly that would have been.

to:

** Living up to [[ReedRichardsIsUseless the trope named after him]], Mr. Fantastic was the sole human on Earth who was informed about [[ComicBook/{{Annihilation}}, ComicBook/{{Annihilation}}, Annihilus' attempted genocide of all life in the universe that was going on at the same time.]] time. First from the Super Skrull, a hated enemy who literally had to '''beg''' Richards to let him use the Negative Zone portal after giving a firsthand account of Annihilus' genocide. Later Nova sent multiple distress signals to Reed, warning him that Annihilus was ''days away'' from reaching Earth. Reed told no one about either of these warnings. ''What If? Annihilation'' shows just how costly that would have been.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rewriting, there is too much complaining here. As polarizing as Civil War is, it's nowhere near as hated as One More Day.


** Iron Man and Captain America first and worst, but they were ''far'' from the only ones.
** In the first issue, Maria Hill attempts to arrest Captain America under the registration act, the problem being that the act ''hadn't actually been voted on in the US Congress yet'', much less ratified by the President into official American law. Even worse, Cap never stated that he was personally going to disobey the law, only that he had no intentions of aiding in actively enforcing it, making her reasoning seem even more ridiculously flimsy, and only resulting in triggering Cap's rebellion in favor of the anti-registration side, when he would probably otherwise just have settled for quietly retiring from active duty. And the idiocy only grows from there.
** Also notably, ComicBook/SpiderMan. Yes, Spider-Man. Reveal your secret identity to the public. It's not like [[ComicBook/TheNightGwenStacyDied last time one of your enemies had it, you underwent a tragedy that took you years to cope with, cost an innocent life, and you still angst about to this day.]] And of course, history repeats itself, this time with Aunt May. Leading to [[ComicBook/OneMoreDay one of the few stories in Marvel canon that receives the same level of hatred Civil War gets.]]

to:

** The normally sensible Iron Man and Captain America first and worst, but become so entangled in their respective ideologies that they were ''far'' from escalate the only ones.
superhuman civil war instead of trying to find a peaceful solution to the conflict. [[spoiler:Once Cap realizes he has become more obsessed with destroying the opposing side than with winning the argument, he tearfully surrenders]].
** In the first issue, Maria Hill prehemptively attempts to arrest Captain America under before the registration act, the problem being that the act ''hadn't had actually been voted on in the US Congress yet'', much less ratified by Congress, as she knows his opposition to the President into official American law. act would inspire other superheroes to fight against it. Even worse, Cap never stated that he was personally going to disobey the law, only that he had no intentions of aiding in actively enforcing it, making her reasoning seem even more ridiculously flimsy, and only resulting in triggering it. Hill's actions trigger Cap's rebellion in favor of the anti-registration side, when he would probably otherwise just have settled for quietly retiring from active duty. And essentially kick-starting the idiocy only grows from there.
entire conflict.
** Also notably, ComicBook/SpiderMan. Yes, Spider-Man. Reveal your At Iron Man's request, ComicBook/SpiderMan agrees to reveal his own secret identity to the public. It's not like public, seemingly forgetting that [[ComicBook/TheNightGwenStacyDied last time one of your his enemies had it, you found it out, he underwent a tragedy that took you years to cope with, cost an innocent life, life and you still angst about took him years to this day.cope with.]] And of course, history repeats itself, this time with Aunt May. Leading May, leading to [[ComicBook/OneMoreDay one of the few stories in Marvel canon that receives the same level tragic events of hatred Civil War gets.]]''ComicBook/OneMoreDay''.



** C'mon, Captain America. You let the Punisher join you and then recruit a pair of supervillains the next day. What did you ''think'' Castle was gonna do?

to:

** C'mon, Captain America. You let America lets the Punisher join you and his side, then recruit recruits a pair of supervillains the next day. What did you ''think'' Unsurprisingly, Castle was gonna do?kills them both in cold blood, and Cap can blame no one but himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Annihilation was released at the same time.


The 2006–2007 Marvel CrisisCrossover.

to:

The A 2006–2007 Marvel CrisisCrossover.

Added: 1033

Changed: 2883

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es), Not enough context (ZCE)


* ChekhovsGun: What is that CD with the number "42" in it? Sorry, classified information.

to:

* ChekhovsGun: What is that Sue notices a CD with the number "42" in it? Sorry, classified information.it and asks Reed what it is. [[spoiler:It's later revealed that the CD contains the files required to build the Negative Zone Prison, which is designed to contain superheroes who refuse to register. Freeing the captives becomes the Anti-Registration side's main goal near the end of the story]].



* CListFodder: Goliath, Plunderer, Goldbug and the New Warriors in the main series. Bantam and Typeface in ''Front Lines''.

to:

* %%* CListFodder: Goliath, Plunderer, Goldbug and the New Warriors in the main series. Bantam and Typeface in ''Front Lines''.



* CluelessAesop: The storyline featured the superheroes favoring registration fighting the superheroes opposing it. Apparently, the two sides were supposed to be presented evenly with Mark Millar starting we're ultimately supposed to side with the Pro-reg side. But due to the clear Aesops of the last century saying that secret identities are ''good'' and government oversight of superheroes is ''evil'', so many writers disagreed the Pro-regs were oft depicted as a bunch of borderline fascists who mind-control or threaten heroes and villains into working for them and casually toss people into the Negative Zone for refusing to register. Some tie-in writers depicted the anti-regs as borderline terrorists who were putting everyone at risk while others portrayed them as being the heroes standing against a WellIntentionedExtremist tyranny. The one agreed on part is that the story couldn't seem to decide which side it was rooting for.
** The X-Men, bizarrely, stayed ''neutral'' for the entire debate surrounding the Super Human Registration Act -- even though in their own comics, government registration of mutants was always portrayed as the first step towards state-sponsored internment/genocide of anyone with an X-gene. Is that really something they should suddenly be neutral about? Emma Frost justified this by pointing out that the X-Men were being asked to do things for the government of America on the grounds of 'humanitarian' reasons and when Stark tried to throw the deaths of the people of Stamford up as a reason they should side with him, her immediate response was "Where were the Avengers when ''our children'' were dying?" referring to the total and complete destruction of Genosha. But since this particular incident happened under Creator/GrantMorrison and his ComicBook/NewXMen run which very deliberately went out of it's way to keep as many non-X-Men heroes out of the storyline as possible to give it more of it's unique identity, meaning the ''actual'' reason the Avengers weren't involved was a case of WriterOnBoard.

to:

* CluelessAesop: CluelessAesop:
**
The storyline featured features the superheroes favoring who favor registration fighting the superheroes opposing it. Apparently, Although the two sides were supposed to be presented evenly with evenly, Mark Millar starting states we're ultimately supposed to side with the Pro-reg side. But due to the clear Aesops of the last century saying that secret identities are ''good'' and government oversight of superheroes is ''evil'', so many other writers disagreed and depicted the Pro-regs were oft depicted as a bunch of borderline fascists who mind-control or threaten heroes and villains into working for them and casually toss people into the Negative Zone for refusing to register. Some In contrast, some tie-in writers also depicted the anti-regs as borderline terrorists who were putting everyone at risk while others portrayed instead of portraying them as being the heroes standing against a WellIntentionedExtremist tyranny. The one agreed on part is that the story couldn't seem Ultimately, these creative differences made it harder for readers to decide which fully support either side it was rooting for.
of the conflict.
** The X-Men, bizarrely, stayed ''neutral'' for the entire debate surrounding the Super Human Registration Act -- even though in their own comics, government registration of mutants was always portrayed as the first step towards state-sponsored internment/genocide of anyone with an X-gene. Is that really something they should suddenly be neutral about? Emma Frost justified this by pointing out that the X-Men were being asked to do things for the government of America on the grounds of 'humanitarian' reasons and when Stark tried to throw the deaths of the people of Stamford up as a reason they should side with him, her immediate response was "Where were the Avengers when ''our children'' were dying?" referring to the total and complete destruction of Genosha. But since this particular incident happened under Creator/GrantMorrison and his ComicBook/NewXMen run in Creator/GrantMorrison's ''ComicBook/NewXMen'' run, which very deliberately went out of it's its way to keep as many non-X-Men heroes out of the storyline as possible to give it more of it's its unique identity, meaning the ''actual'' reason the Avengers weren't involved was a case of WriterOnBoard.

Top