Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / APeoplesHistoryOfTheAmericanEmpire

Go To

OR

Changed: 48

Removed: 242

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
redefined trope and zces


* AllAsiansWearConicalStrawHats: Averted, the Viet Cong fighters wear them but no other Asian characters do.



* TheDandy: A Chicano zoot suiter narrates a segment about the suppression of culture.

to:

%% * TheDandy: A Chicano zoot suiter narrates a segment about the suppression of culture.



* DragonLady: Invoked with Madam Nhu, who really was known as this.
* [[EndOfAnAge End of An Era]]

to:

%% * DragonLady: Invoked with Madam Nhu, who really was known as this.
%% * [[EndOfAnAge End of An Era]]



* GreaserDelinquents: They briefly appear when discussing rock 'n roll.
* TheGeneralissimo: The Somozas
* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Too many too count; all of the named characters.
* HolidayInCambodia

to:

%% * GreaserDelinquents: They briefly appear when discussing rock 'n roll.
%% * TheGeneralissimo: The Somozas
%% * HistoricalDomainCharacter: Too many too count; all of the named characters.
%% * HolidayInCambodia



* IDidWhatIHadToDo

to:

%% * IDidWhatIHadToDo



* InjunCountry: The Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge segments are set in it.

to:

%% * InjunCountry: The Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge segments are set in it.



* JungleWarfare: Most of the combat scenes.
* JustLikeRobinHood: Sandino is very much portrayed this way.
* LatinLand: Nicaragua, Cuba, and El Salvador all appear as settings.

to:

%% * JungleWarfare: Most of the combat scenes.
%% * JustLikeRobinHood: Sandino is very much portrayed this way.
* LatinLand: Nicaragua, Cuba, and El Salvador all appear as settings.
way.



* PopularHistory

to:

%% * PopularHistory



* TheRez: The political variant, shown in the Pine Ridge segment.



* TheVietnamVet
* UrbanWarfare
* WarIsHell: Invoked by one soldier's helmet.
* WasItReallyWorthIt

to:

%% * TheVietnamVet
%% * UrbanWarfare
%% * WarIsHell: Invoked by one soldier's helmet.
%% * WasItReallyWorthIt
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Loads And Loads Of Characters is a redirect that should not be linked to


* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Tons of historical figures and many unnamed characters representing the everyday people the People's History books are really about.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CIAEvilFBIGood: Very much averted, both are portrayed as sinister organizations with unchecked power.

to:

* CIAEvilFBIGood: Very much averted, both Both CIA and FBI are portrayed as sinister organizations with unchecked power.power, as opposed to having one organization be benevolent by comparison.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 181

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MixedAncestry: Sandino mentioned being the son of a native mother and father of Spanish descent. Additionally the half white Hawaiian revolutionary Robert Wilcox briefly appears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: As Zinn gets disillusioned with UsefulNotes/WorldWarII he starts to see the Axis and Allies this way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:250:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/3036329_peo1.jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Latino Is Brown has been tightened to refer to when all Latinos are brown, or when someone thinks they are. Single-character examples fit in Phenotype Stereotype and Averted Trope examples should not be listed unless notable.


* LatinoIsBrown: Zigzagged, most unnamed Latino characters are, but all of the Latin American historical figures are portrayed correctly as whatever ethnicity / race they were.

to:

* LatinoIsBrown: Zigzagged, most unnamed Latino characters are, are brown-skinned, but all of the Latin American historical figures are portrayed correctly as whatever ethnicity / race they were.

Changed: 354

Removed: 219

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor edits, and removed an example which doesn't fit.


* AllAsiansWearConicalStrawHats: Subverted, the Viet Cong fighters wear them but no other Asian characters do.
* AuthorTract: Pretty up front about this, especially since its framed as a lecture.

to:

* AllAsiansWearConicalStrawHats: Subverted, Averted, the Viet Cong fighters wear them but no other Asian characters do.
* AuthorTract: Pretty It's pretty up front about this, especially since its it's framed as a lecture.



* {{Bandito}}: Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one. Pancho Villa and Zapata also briefly appear.
* BombThrowingAnarchists: Sandino again, this trope is discussed as part of the reason Sacco and Vanzetti were convicted.

to:

* {{Bandito}}: Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican non-Mexican one. Pancho Villa and Zapata also briefly appear.
* BombThrowingAnarchists: Sandino again, this again. This trope is also discussed as part of the reason Sacco and Vanzetti were convicted.



* GreaserDelinquents: Briefly appear when discussing rock n roll.

to:

* GreaserDelinquents: Briefly They briefly appear when discussing rock n 'n roll.



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Too many too count, all of the named characters.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Too many too count, count; all of the named characters.



* HopelessWar: Very strong message that ultimately war is senseless.

to:

* HopelessWar: Very strong Zinn's message is that ultimately war is senseless.



* InjunCountry: The Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge

to:

* InjunCountry: The Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge segments are set in it.



* JustLikeRobinHood: Sandino is very much portrayed this way
* LatinLand: Nicaragua, Cuba, and El Salvador all appear as settings

to:

* JustLikeRobinHood: Sandino is very much portrayed this way
way.
* LatinLand: Nicaragua, Cuba, and El Salvador all appear as settingssettings.



* PreventTheWar: The whole reason Zinn is giving this lecture is with the hope of doing this, it fails.
* RebelLeader: Several are featured such as Emilio Aguinaldo, Antonio Maceo, and Augusto Sandino.
* TheRez: The political variant

to:

* PreventTheWar: The whole reason Zinn is giving this lecture is with the hope of doing this, this; it fails.
* RebelLeader: Several are featured featured, such as Emilio Aguinaldo, Antonio Maceo, Maceo and Augusto Sandino.
* TheRez: The political variantvariant, shown in the Pine Ridge segment.



* TwilightOfTheOldWest: The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era. The Ludlow Massacre is also detailed, which occurred in 1914 which was either at the very end or just after the end of the Old West depending on who you ask.

to:

* TwilightOfTheOldWest: The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era. The Ludlow Massacre is also detailed, which occurred in 1914 which and was either at the very end or just after the end of the Old West depending on who you ask.



* WeirdTradeUnion: The Industrial Workers of the World play a prominent role in several of the storylines.
* WhiteMansBurden: President [=McKinley=] gives a speech justifying the invasion of the Philippines by saying it is America's duty to "civilize and Christianize" the Filipinos (even though they were already Christians).

to:

* WeirdTradeUnion: The Industrial Workers of the World play a prominent role in several of the storylines.
* WhiteMansBurden: President [=McKinley=] gives a speech justifying the invasion of the Philippines by saying it is America's duty to "civilize and Christianize" the Filipinos (even though they were already mostly Christians).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 421

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorTract: Pretty up front about this, especially since its framed as a lecture.



* LatinoIsBrown: Zigzagged, most unnamed Latino characters are, but all of the Latin American historical figures are portrayed correctly as whatever ethnicity / race they were.
* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Tons of historical figures and many unnamed characters representing the everyday people the People's History books are really about.



* TwilightOfTheOldWest: The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era. The Ludlow Massacre is also detailed, which occurred in 1914 which was either at the very end or just after the end of the Old West depending on who you ask

to:

* TwilightOfTheOldWest: The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era. The Ludlow Massacre is also detailed, which occurred in 1914 which was either at the very end or just after the end of the Old West depending on who you askask.

Added: 103

Changed: 162

Removed: 30

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllAsiansWearConicalStrawHats Subverted, the Viet Cong fighters wear them but no other Asian characters do.
* BananaRepublic Nicaragua is portrayed this way.
* Bandito Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one. Pancho Villa and Zapata also briefly appear.
* BombThrowingAnarchists Sandino again, this trope is discussed as part of the reason Sacco and Vanzetti were convicted.
* BraidsBeadsAndBuckskins The Sioux in both the Wounded Knee and later Pine Ridge segments dress this way.
* ChummyCommies Zinn mentions having several Communist friends growing up.

to:

* AllAsiansWearConicalStrawHats AllAsiansWearConicalStrawHats: Subverted, the Viet Cong fighters wear them but no other Asian characters do.
* BananaRepublic BananaRepublic: Nicaragua is portrayed this way.
* Bandito {{Bandito}}: Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one. Pancho Villa and Zapata also briefly appear.
* BombThrowingAnarchists BombThrowingAnarchists: Sandino again, this trope is discussed as part of the reason Sacco and Vanzetti were convicted.
* BraidsBeadsAndBuckskins BraidsBeadsAndBuckskins: The Sioux in both the Wounded Knee and later Pine Ridge segments dress this way.
* ChummyCommies ChummyCommies: Zinn mentions having several Communist friends growing up.up.
* CIAEvilFBIGood: Very much averted, both are portrayed as sinister organizations with unchecked power.



* DragonLady Invoked with Madam Nhu, who really was known as this.
* TheEndOfAnAge
* ForeverWar A major point the book makes is that the United States has been locked into a cycle of endless wars for most of its existence.
* GreaserDelinquents Briefly appear when discussing rock n roll.
* FBIGoodCIAEvil Very much averted, both are portrayed as sinister organizations with unchecked power.
* TheGeneralissimo The Somozas

to:

* DragonLady DragonLady: Invoked with Madam Nhu, who really was known as this.
* TheEndOfAnAge
[[EndOfAnAge End of An Era]]
* ForeverWar ForeverWar: A major point the book makes is that the United States has been locked into a cycle of endless wars for most of its existence.
* GreaserDelinquents GreaserDelinquents: Briefly appear when discussing rock n roll.
* FBIGoodCIAEvil Very much averted, both are portrayed as sinister organizations with unchecked power.
* TheGeneralissimo
TheGeneralissimo: The Somozas



* HopelessWar Very strong message that ultimately war is senseless.
* IDidWhatIHadTo

to:

* HopelessWar HopelessWar: Very strong message that ultimately war is senseless.
* IDidWhatIHadToIDidWhatIHadToDo



* InjunCountry The Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge
* InterchangeableAsianCultures A rare Middle Eastern example occurs with CIA operative Donald Wilber who hilariously lampshades it. "I know, I'm wearing an Arab kaffiyeh. A little eccentric for a Persian specialist. But we CIA men take such liberties because we can!"
* JungleWarfare Most of the combat scenes.

to:

* InjunCountry InjunCountry: The Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge
* InterchangeableAsianCultures InterchangeableAsianCultures: A rare Middle Eastern example occurs with CIA operative Donald Wilber who hilariously lampshades it. "I know, I'm wearing an Arab kaffiyeh. A little eccentric for a Persian specialist. But we CIA men take such liberties because we can!"
* JungleWarfare JungleWarfare: Most of the combat scenes.



* LatinLand Nicaragua, Cuba, and El Salvador all appear as settings

to:

* LatinLand LatinLand: Nicaragua, Cuba, and El Salvador all appear as settings



* RebelLeader Several are featured such as Emilio Aguinaldo, Antonio Maceo, and Augusto Sandino.
* TheRez The political variant
* SleazyPolitician All of them, with the noted exception of Socialist presidential candidate Eugene Debbs.
* SoapboxSadie Zinn is by all means a heroic version, and his history of activism is detailed.
* TwilightOfTheOldWest The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era. The Ludlow Massacre is also detailed, which occurred in 1914 which was either at the very end or just after the end of the Old West depending on who you ask

to:

* RebelLeader RebelLeader: Several are featured such as Emilio Aguinaldo, Antonio Maceo, and Augusto Sandino.
* TheRez TheRez: The political variant
* SleazyPolitician SleazyPolitician: All of them, with the noted exception of Socialist presidential candidate Eugene Debbs.
* SoapboxSadie SoapboxSadie: Zinn is by all means a heroic version, and his history of activism is detailed.
* TwilightOfTheOldWest TwilightOfTheOldWest: The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era. The Ludlow Massacre is also detailed, which occurred in 1914 which was either at the very end or just after the end of the Old West depending on who you ask



* WarIsHell Invoked by one soldier's helmet.

to:

* WarIsHell WarIsHell: Invoked by one soldier's helmet.



* WeirdTradeUnion The Industrial Workers of the World play a prominent role in several of the storylines.
* WhiteMansBurden President McKinley gives a speech justifying the invasion of the Philippines by saying it is America's duty to "civilize and Christianize" the Filipinos (even though they were already Christians).

to:

* WeirdTradeUnion WeirdTradeUnion: The Industrial Workers of the World play a prominent role in several of the storylines.
* WhiteMansBurden WhiteMansBurden: President McKinley [=McKinley=] gives a speech justifying the invasion of the Philippines by saying it is America's duty to "civilize and Christianize" the Filipinos (even though they were already Christians).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NotSoDifferent As Zinn gets disillusioned with the WW2 he starts to see the Axis and Allies this way.

to:

* NotSoDifferent NotSoDifferent: As Zinn gets disillusioned with the WW2 UsefulNotes/WorldWarII he starts to see the Axis and Allies this way.



* PretextForWar Zinn notes that pretexts for war are frequently hoaxes, such as the Gulf of Tonkin incident.
* PreventTheWar The whole reason Zinn is giving this lecture is with the hope of doing this, it fails.

to:

* PretextForWar PretextForWar: Zinn notes that pretexts for war are frequently hoaxes, such as the Gulf of Tonkin incident.
* PreventTheWar PreventTheWar: The whole reason Zinn is giving this lecture is with the hope of doing this, it fails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JustLikeRobinHood: Sandino is very much portrayed this way
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 305

Changed: 223

Removed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DistinguishedGentlemansPipe: Mark Twain smokes one during his appearance.



* TheEndOfAnAge



* EndOfAnEra



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Too many too count.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Too many too count.count, all of the named characters.



* RebelLeader Several are featured such as Emilio Aguinaldo, Augusto Sandino and Robert Wilcox.

to:

* RebelLeader Several are featured such as Emilio Aguinaldo, Antonio Maceo, and Augusto Sandino and Robert Wilcox.Sandino.



* TwilightOfTheOldWest The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era.

to:

* TwilightOfTheOldWest The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era. The Ludlow Massacre is also detailed, which occurred in 1914 which was either at the very end or just after the end of the Old West depending on who you ask



* WeirdTradeUnion The Industrial Workers of the World play a prominent role in several of the storylines.

to:

* WeirdTradeUnion The Industrial Workers of the World play a prominent role in several of the storylines.storylines.
* WhiteMansBurden President McKinley gives a speech justifying the invasion of the Philippines by saying it is America's duty to "civilize and Christianize" the Filipinos (even though they were already Christians).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TwilightOfTheAmericanWest Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era/

to:

* TwilightOfTheAmericanWest TwilightOfTheOldWest The opening is about the massacre at Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era/era.

Added: 181

Changed: 560

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Bandito Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one.

to:

* Bandito Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one. Pancho Villa and Zapata also briefly appear.



* GreaserDelinquants Briefly appear when discussing rock n roll.

to:

* GreaserDelinquants GreaserDelinquents Briefly appear when discussing rock n roll.



* HopelessWar

to:

* HopelessWarHopelessWar Very strong message that ultimately war is senseless.



* InjunCountry

to:

* InjunCountryInjunCountry The Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge



* JungleWarfare

to:

* JungleWarfareJungleWarfare Most of the combat scenes.



* MixedAncestry: Sandino mentioned being the son of a native mother and father of Spanish descent. Additionally the half white Hawaiian revolutionary Robert Wilcox briefly appears.



* PretextForWar

to:

* PretextForWar Zinn notes that pretexts for war are frequently hoaxes, such as the Gulf of Tonkin incident.



* RebelLeader
* TheRez

to:

* RebelLeader
RebelLeader Several are featured such as Emilio Aguinaldo, Augusto Sandino and Robert Wilcox.
* TheRezTheRez The political variant



* SoapboxSadie

to:

* SoapboxSadieSoapboxSadie Zinn is by all means a heroic version, and his history of activism is detailed.



* WarIsHell

to:

* WarIsHellWarIsHell Invoked by one soldier's helmet.



* WeirdTradeUnion

to:

* WeirdTradeUnionWeirdTradeUnion The Industrial Workers of the World play a prominent role in several of the storylines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Bandido Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one.

to:

* Bandido Bandito Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 169

Changed: 492

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheGeneralissimo

to:

* TheGeneralissimo The Somozas
* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Too many too count.



* InformedJudaism: Zinn was Jewish, but this is only mentioned when he gets married and a Rabbi officiates the ceremony.



* InterchangeableAsianCultures
* JungleWarfar

to:

* InterchangeableAsianCultures
InterchangeableAsianCultures A rare Middle Eastern example occurs with CIA operative Donald Wilber who hilariously lampshades it. "I know, I'm wearing an Arab kaffiyeh. A little eccentric for a Persian specialist. But we CIA men take such liberties because we can!"
* JungleWarfarJungleWarfare



* NotSoDifferent

to:

* NotSoDifferentNotSoDifferent As Zinn gets disillusioned with the WW2 he starts to see the Axis and Allies this way.



* PreventTheWar

to:

* PreventTheWarPreventTheWar The whole reason Zinn is giving this lecture is with the hope of doing this, it fails.



* SleazyPolitician All of them, with the exception of Socialist presidential candidate Eugene Debbs.

to:

* SleazyPolitician All of them, with the noted exception of Socialist presidential candidate Eugene Debbs.



* TwilightOfTheAmericanWest

to:

* TwilightOfTheAmericanWest Wounded Knee, which is usually seen as a catalyst of that era/
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

A People's History of the American Empire is a graphic novel written by Howard Zinn and Mike Konopacki and drawn by Paul Buhle. It a combined adaptation of Zinn's books A People's History of the United States and You Can't Be Neutral On A Moving Train, as well as other sources. The book begins with 9/11, with Howard Zinn writing an opinion piece opposing the Iraq War. Then Zinn is shown speaking at an antiwar rally where he provides a history of American wars and interventions, which forms the framing device for the narrative. Beginning with Wounded Knee and ending with Guantanamo Bay, Zinn makes a case for opposing further overseas intervention.

----
!!This book provides examples of:

*AllAsiansWearConicalStrawHats Subverted, the Viet Cong fighters wear them but no other Asian characters do.
*BananaRepublic Nicaragua is portrayed this way.
*Bandido Nicaraguan Augusto Sandino provides a rare heroic example and even rarer non Mexican one.
*BombThrowingAnarchists Sandino again, this trope is discussed as part of the reason Sacco and Vanzetti were convicted.
*BraidsBeadsAndBuckskins The Sioux in both the Wounded Knee and later Pine Ridge segments dress this way.
*ChummyCommies Zinn mentions having several Communist friends growing up.
*TheDandy: A Chicano zoot suiter narrates a segment about the suppression of culture.
*DragonLady Invoked with Madam Nhu, who really was known as this.
*ForeverWar A major point the book makes is that the United States has been locked into a cycle of endless wars for most of its existence.
*GreaserDelinquants Briefly appear when discussing rock n roll.
*EndOfAnEra
*FBIGoodCIAEvil Very much averted, both are portrayed as sinister organizations with unchecked power.
*TheGeneralissimo
*HolidayInCambodia
*HopelessWar
*IDidWhatIHadTo
*InjunCountry
*InterchangeableAsianCultures
*JungleWarfar
*LatinLand Nicaragua, Cuba, and El Salvador all appear as settings
*NotSoDifferent
*PopularHistory
*PretextForWar
*PreventTheWar
*RebelLeader
*TheRez
*SleazyPolitician All of them, with the exception of Socialist presidential candidate Eugene Debbs.
*SoapboxSadie
*TwilightOfTheAmericanWest
*TheVietnamVet
*UrbanWarfare
*WarIsHell
*WasItReallyWorthIt
*WeirdTradeUnion

Top