Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / ThyGoodNeighbor

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlamingTheVictim: Begrudgingly realizes that this is ''all'' he can do when Prince Rhaegar visits Lyanna Start while his wife - and Oberyn's ''sister'' - is undergoing a very stressful pregnancy. To his credit, he knows the Starks aren't at fault, but that only serves to make him angrier.

to:

* BlamingTheVictim: Begrudgingly realizes that this is ''all'' he can do when Prince Rhaegar visits Lyanna Start Stark while his wife - and Oberyn's ''sister'' - is undergoing a very stressful pregnancy. To his credit, he knows the Starks aren't at fault, but that only serves to make him angrier.

Added: 297

Changed: 407

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenPedestal: Much like Ned, Oberyn has lost a great deal of respect for [[KnightInShiningArmor Arthur Dayne]] after [[spoiler: Arthur did nothing to stop Rhaegar from visiting Lyarra Stark in private]]. This might even be worse for Oberyn than Ned, as House Dayne is a vassal of the Martells.

to:

* BlamingTheVictim: Begrudgingly realizes that this is ''all'' he can do when Prince Rhaegar visits Lyanna Start while his wife - and Oberyn's ''sister'' - is undergoing a very stressful pregnancy. To his credit, he knows the Starks aren't at fault, but that only serves to make him angrier.
* BrokenPedestal: Much like Ned, Oberyn has lost a great deal of respect for [[KnightInShiningArmor Arthur Dayne]] after [[spoiler: Arthur did nothing to stop Rhaegar from visiting Lyarra Lyanna Stark in private]]. This might even be worse for Oberyn than Ned, as House Dayne is a vassal of the Martells.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngerBornOfWorry: Oberyn's resentment of the Starks has more to due with concern that his sister Elia and her children might be cast aside by Rhaegar in favor of Lyanna. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold to his credit, he realizes that this isn't the fault of the Starks.]] Though, it doesn't help either.
* BigBrotherInstinct: For as much as a smug, philandering prat he can be, Oberyn is above all else a good brother and much of his antagonism to Brandon and Ned is born from his concern for Elia.
* BrokenPedestal: Much like Ned, Oberyn has lost a great deal of respect for [[KnightInShiningArmor Arthur Dayne]] after [[spoiler: Arthur did nothing to stop Rhaegar from visiting Lyarra Stark in private]]. This might even be worse for Oberyn than Ned, as House Dayne is a vassal of the Martells.
* EveryoneHasStandards: Angry at the Starks as he might be, even Oberyn can't condone one of his bannermen trying to kill Ned out of petty jealousy in the middle of widely public melee.
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: Oberyn antagonizes the Starks a great deal at the tourney, but its done out of love for his sister and even he knows [[MisplacedRetribution that the Starks aren't at fault for what happened.]]

to:

* AngerBornOfWorry: *AngerBornOfWorry: Oberyn's resentment of the Starks has more to due with concern that his sister Elia and her children might be cast aside by Rhaegar in favor of Lyanna. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold to To his credit, he realizes that this isn't the fault of the Starks.]] Though, it doesn't help either.
* BigBrotherInstinct: *BigBrotherInstinct: For as much as a smug, philandering prat he can be, Oberyn is above all else a good brother and much of his antagonism to Brandon and Ned is born from his concern for Elia.
* BrokenPedestal: *BrokenPedestal: Much like Ned, Oberyn has lost a great deal of respect for [[KnightInShiningArmor Arthur Dayne]] after [[spoiler: Arthur did nothing to stop Rhaegar from visiting Lyarra Stark in private]]. This might even be worse for Oberyn than Ned, as House Dayne is a vassal of the Martells.
* EveryoneHasStandards: *EveryoneHasStandards: Angry at the Starks as he might be, even Oberyn can't condone one of his bannermen trying to kill Ned out of petty jealousy in the middle of widely public melee.
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: *JerkWithAHeartOfGold: Oberyn antagonizes the Starks a great deal at the tourney, but its done out of love for his sister and even he knows [[MisplacedRetribution that the Starks aren't at fault for what happened.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AngerBornOfWorry: Oberyn's resentment of the Starks has more to due with concern that his sister Elia and her children might be cast aside by Rhaegar in favor of Lyanna. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold to his credit, he realizes that this isn't the fault of the Starks.]] Though, it doesn't help either.
* BigBrotherInstinct: For as much as a smug, philandering prat he can be, Oberyn is above all else a good brother and much of his antagonism to Brandon and Ned is born from his concern for Elia.
* BrokenPedastal: Much like Ned, Oberyn has lost a great deal of respect for [[KnightInShiningArmor Arthur Dayne]] after [[spoiler: Arthur did nothing to stop Rhaegar from visiting Lyarra Stark in private]]. This might even be worse for Oberyn than Ned, as House Dayne is a vassal of the Martells.
* EveryoneHasStandards: Angry at the Starks as he might be, even Oberyn can't condone one of his bannermen trying to kill Ned out of petty jealousy in the middle of widely public melee.
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: Oberyn antagonizes the Starks a great deal at the tourney, but its done out of love for his sister and even he knows [[MisplacedRetribution that the Starks aren't at fault for what happened.]]

to:

* AngerBornOfWorry: *AngerBornOfWorry: Oberyn's resentment of the Starks has more to due with concern that his sister Elia and her children might be cast aside by Rhaegar in favor of Lyanna. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold to his credit, he realizes that this isn't the fault of the Starks.]] Though, it doesn't help either.
* BigBrotherInstinct: *BigBrotherInstinct: For as much as a smug, philandering prat he can be, Oberyn is above all else a good brother and much of his antagonism to Brandon and Ned is born from his concern for Elia.
* BrokenPedastal: *BrokenPedestal: Much like Ned, Oberyn has lost a great deal of respect for [[KnightInShiningArmor Arthur Dayne]] after [[spoiler: Arthur did nothing to stop Rhaegar from visiting Lyarra Stark in private]]. This might even be worse for Oberyn than Ned, as House Dayne is a vassal of the Martells.
* EveryoneHasStandards: *EveryoneHasStandards: Angry at the Starks as he might be, even Oberyn can't condone one of his bannermen trying to kill Ned out of petty jealousy in the middle of widely public melee.
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: *JerkWithAHeartOfGold: Oberyn antagonizes the Starks a great deal at the tourney, but its done out of love for his sister and even he knows [[MisplacedRetribution that the Starks aren't at fault for what happened.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Oberyn Martell, the Red Viper]]
!!Oberyn Martell
The Red Viper, second Prince of Dorne, and brother to Elia Martell, Prince Rhaegar Targaryen's wife.
----
*AngerBornOfWorry: Oberyn's resentment of the Starks has more to due with concern that his sister Elia and her children might be cast aside by Rhaegar in favor of Lyanna. [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold to his credit, he realizes that this isn't the fault of the Starks.]] Though, it doesn't help either.
*BigBrotherInstinct: For as much as a smug, philandering prat he can be, Oberyn is above all else a good brother and much of his antagonism to Brandon and Ned is born from his concern for Elia.
*BrokenPedastal: Much like Ned, Oberyn has lost a great deal of respect for [[KnightInShiningArmor Arthur Dayne]] after [[spoiler: Arthur did nothing to stop Rhaegar from visiting Lyarra Stark in private]]. This might even be worse for Oberyn than Ned, as House Dayne is a vassal of the Martells.
*EveryoneHasStandards: Angry at the Starks as he might be, even Oberyn can't condone one of his bannermen trying to kill Ned out of petty jealousy in the middle of widely public melee.
*JerkWithAHeartOfGold: Oberyn antagonizes the Starks a great deal at the tourney, but its done out of love for his sister and even he knows [[MisplacedRetribution that the Starks aren't at fault for what happened.]]
* MisplacedRetribution: Oberyn Martel's anger at the Starks, [[spoiler:after Rhaegar visits Lyanna in her apartment]]. He's incredibly frustrated by both Aery's only arranging his sister Elia's marriage to the prince as nothing but a tool to spite Tywin, and [[AngerBornOfWorry then facing the possibility his sister and her children will be cast aside by Rhaegar]]. However, as he's powerless to retaliate against the dragons, he chooses to direct his ire at the Starks as they are the only ones he can target.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenPedestal: Like many aspiring knights, Ned idolized and looked up to Arthur Dayne, who is hailed as the strongest knight in Westeros' recent memory. His opinion of Arthur plummets after he learns of Rhaegar's visit to Lyanna and that Arthur did nothing despite the damage Rhaegar's visit would cause, both to Lyanna and to House Dayne were word to spread.

Added: 222

Changed: 34

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IronicName: The brutally pragmatic, incredibly deadly HumanoidAbomination who initially gained his powers via a blood transfusion is from the Fairchild family, while the kind and gentle Doll is from the Vileblood family.



* OutsideContextProblem: The Fairchilds' existence is this to Westeros at large, if not the rest of the known world. They hail from beyond the Sunset Sea, a stretch of ocean no one has managed to explore, have enough resources and wealth to feed starving smallfolk and provide [[spoiler:enough materials to build no less than ''six glass greenhouses'']], and have access to advanced techniques in science and medicine that Westeros could very much benefit from. That such a boon found itself in House Stark's territory is one of the reasons why [[spoiler:two noble houses and rivals try to take them out to no avail]].

to:

* OutsideContextProblem: The Fairchilds' existence is this to Westeros at large, if not the rest of the known world. They ([[AmbiguousSituation possibly]]) hail from beyond the Sunset Sea, a stretch of ocean no one has managed to explore, have enough resources and wealth to feed starving smallfolk and provide [[spoiler:enough materials to build no less than ''six glass greenhouses'']], and have access to advanced techniques in science and medicine that Westeros could very much benefit from. That such a boon found itself in House Stark's territory is one of the reasons why [[spoiler:two noble houses and rivals try to take them out to no avail]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalBadass: In canon, his only known achievement was beating a younger Petyr Baelish in a duel, and is never mentioned as being among the greats when others remember the most notable knights and swordsmen. Thanks to Cyril's training, he manages to beat the Greatjon Umber, has won against every single challenger in the North, and is widely known for slaying an entire Ironborn raiding party. Afterwards, he's known as [[RedBaron the Northern Blade]], and is frequently compared to the likes of [[TheAce Arthur Dayne]].

to:

* AdaptationalBadass: In canon, his only known achievement was beating a younger Petyr Baelish in a duel, and is never mentioned as being among the greats when others remember the most notable knights and swordsmen. Thanks to Cyril's training, he manages to beat the Greatjon Umber, has won against every single challenger in the North, and is widely known for slaying an entire Ironborn raiding party. Afterwards, he's known as [[RedBaron the Northern Blade]], and is frequently compared to the likes of [[TheAce Arthur Dayne]].Dayne]], with the Martells even being concerned that he (or Ned) may end up taking his title of Westeros' greatest swordsman.



* AdaptationalBadass: While Ned was known as an accomplished warrior in canon, he himself notes that he would have died against [[TheAce Arthur Dayne]] in his famed duel if not for Howland Reed (though the exact details surrounding the event have yet to be revealed in the book series). In this story, thanks to Cyril's training and regular spars with Brandon, he's become skilled enough to the point he's compared more directly to Dayne; especially after he is knighted for single-handily killing a mountain war chief. He also further proves this, during the Harrenhal tournament, where he manages to win against the older Tygett Lannister; who killed three members of the Golden Company at age ten, and was noted to be only matched by Jaime as the Westerland's best warrior.

to:

* AdaptationalBadass: While Ned was known as an accomplished warrior in canon, he himself notes that he would have died against [[TheAce Arthur Dayne]] in his famed duel if not for Howland Reed (though the exact details surrounding the event have yet to be revealed in the book series). In this story, thanks to Cyril's training and regular spars with Brandon, he's become skilled enough to the point he's compared more directly to Dayne; especially after he is knighted for single-handily killing a mountain war chief. He also further proves this, during the Harrenhal tournament, where he manages to win against the older Tygett Lannister; who killed three members of the Golden Company at age ten, and was noted to be only matched by Jaime as the Westerland's best warrior. While more concerned with Brandon's skill, the Martells are also somewhat worried that Ned may end up taking Arthur Dayne's place as Westeros' greatest swordsman



* RedOniBlueOni: Downplayed. Initially, he was the blue oni to Brandon's red, though the latter's tutilage under Cyril [[spoiler:and loss of status as House Stark's heir]] has made him almost as leveled as his brother.

to:

* RedOniBlueOni: Downplayed. Initially, he was the blue oni to Brandon's red, though the latter's tutilage under Cyril [[spoiler:and loss of status as House Stark's heir]] has made him almost as leveled as his brother. It does still show up in places, especially combat: during the melee tournament at Harrenhal, [[spoiler:it is noted that while Brandon unhorsed more men than any other participant, Ned was responsible for the North having more of their men make it to the final round, focusing more on defending and leading their team than attacking (though he still unhorsed a respectable number of opponents)]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A prominent family of the Northern lands of Westeros whose family line can be traced back to eight thousand years ago. Its current patriarch is Rickard Stark.

to:

A prominent family The current Lords Paramount of the Northern North lands of Westeros whose Westeros; the family line can be traced back to eight thousand years ago.years. Its current patriarch is Rickard Stark.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: Rickard often misreads Cyril and Evette's intentions, due to the latter operating off of social values that's utterly foreign to the former. When he meets with Melisandre, the priestess often misreads and misinterprets his intentions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AffluentAscetic: Played with. By all rights, the Fairchilds live a modest life in their manse despite having access to enough wealth and resources to rival a great noble house, if not make said house green with envy. Said manse, on the other hand, is seen as being ludicrously luxurious by the rest of Westeros.

to:

* AffluentAscetic: Played with. By all rights, the Fairchilds live a modest life in ''Victorian'' standards, their manse home is on the better side of middle class despite having access to their great wealth. By ''Westerosi'' standards, they're living in enough wealth and resources opulence to rival a great noble house, if not make said house green with envy. Said manse, on the other hand, is seen as being ludicrously luxurious by the rest most decadent of Westeros.kings blush.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCharmer: Zig-zagged. He’s noted to have the almost supernatural Targaryen good looks, and can sing and play the harp well enough that practically every woman in attendance is openly lustful for him. However, it’s averted on Lyanna, who regards his music with a more critical mindset, and is deeply disconcerted and uncomfortable in his intruding into her apartment while her brother’s are away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpottingTheThread: After the singers tourney, Rhaegar makes an unexpected visit to her room after overhearing her music, hoping to hear it for himself. It's only after he leaves that Lyanna remembers the royal apartments are on the other side of Harrenhal and realizes Rhaegar lied about overhearing her music.

to:

* SpottingTheThread: After the singers tourney, Rhaegar makes an unexpected visit to her room after overhearing room, claiming he overheard her music, practicing on the way back to the royal apartments and was hoping to hear it for himself. It's only after he leaves that Lyanna remembers the royal apartments are on the other side of Harrenhal and realizes Rhaegar lied about overhearing her music.music in passing -- at the very least, he would have to go out of his way to the Stark apartments to overhear her in the first place.

Added: 180

Changed: 47

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAce: As in canon, Rhaegar is noted to be exceptionally good looking, and is talented enough in the harp that Lyanna is impressed even while having Lady Evetta as a comparison.



* BlatantLies: In Book 2 Chapter 2, he tells Lyanna he overheard her music while roaming the halls and wished for a private concert. It's only after he leaves Lyanna remembers the royal apartments are on the other side of Harrenhal, meaning there's no way he would have overheard her music.

to:

* BlatantLies: In Book 2 Chapter 2, he tells Lyanna he overheard her music while roaming walking to the halls royal apartments and wished for a private concert. It's only after he leaves Lyanna remembers the royal apartments are on the other side of Harrenhal, meaning there's no way he would have overheard her music.music, while just walking by.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalJerkass: In a manner of speaking - due to being a PosthumousCharacter, most of what we hear about Rhaegar comes from secondhand sources, and according to those who liked him but weren't blind to his faults (read: Barristan), he was the archetypical KnightInShiningArmor. In just his first appearance in this story, he comes off as quite creepy in his interactions with Lyana, and also seems to brush off concerns about his wife Elia (who is going through a very stressful pregnancy).

to:

* AdaptationalJerkass: In a manner of speaking - due to being a PosthumousCharacter, most of what we hear about Rhaegar comes from secondhand sources, and according to those who liked him but weren't blind to his faults (read: Barristan), he was the archetypical KnightInShiningArmor. In just his first appearance in this story, he comes off as quite creepy in his interactions with Lyana, and also seems to brush off concerns about his wife Elia (who is going through a very stressful pregnancy). There's a ''tiny'' implication that the prophecy he received about House Targaryen in canon is weighing more heavily on him now with his father's obvious decline, but again, it's a ''tiny'' implication.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArrangedMarriage: With Lyanna like in the books and TV show. [[spoiler:Having seen how HappilyMarried the Fairchilds are, how faithful Rickard remains to her late mother, and hearing of how much of a skirt-chaser Robert is, Lyanna is ''not'' happy. The only reason she gives him a chance is because of Evetta's encouragement. Robert is]]

to:

* ArrangedMarriage: With Lyanna like in the books and TV show. [[spoiler:Having seen how HappilyMarried the Fairchilds are, how faithful Rickard remains to her late mother, and hearing of how much of a skirt-chaser Robert is, Lyanna is ''not'' happy. The only reason she gives him a chance is because of Evetta's encouragement. ]] Robert is]]is presented as aware of how much he was coddled by Jon Arryn due to his martial skill, and has made slow steps at improving himself, one of them making genuine efforts at knowing Lyanna.



* InadequateInheritor: Viewed by his father and himself. Robert knows he's not qualified to be the next head of the family and often dreamed of striking out on his own, but Steffon's [[SparedByTheAdaptation survival]] and learning of his son's flaws endeavored him to take Robert's studies more seriously to the point of personally supervising him.

to:

* InadequateInheritor: Viewed by his father and himself. Robert knows he's not qualified to be the next head of the family and often dreamed of striking out on his own, but Steffon's [[SparedByTheAdaptation survival]] and learning of his son's flaws endeavored made him to take Robert's studies more seriously to the point of personally supervising him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UngratefulBastard: He still forced Jaime into the Kingsguard, depriving Tywin of his preferred heir and son. Even Robert can see this can only end in trouble.

Added: 1389

Changed: 87

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNiceGuy: ''Maybe''. It's never made clear whether Robert saw Lyanna as another notch on his belt or someone he genuinely loved, albeit in a very unhealthy manner. Here, Robert's attraction to Lyanna is genuine and makes efforts to prove himself to her when she gives him the opportunity. [[spoiler:Part of this has to do with his parents' survival]], though WordOfGod notes he's still a flawed individual, albeit one who's trying to make up for said flaws.



* ArrangedMarriage: With Lyanna like in the books and TV show. [[spoiler:Having seen how HappilyMarried the Fairchilds are, how faithful Rickard remains to her late mother, and hearing of how much of a skirt-chaser Robert is, Lyanna is ''not'' happy.]]

to:

* ArrangedMarriage: With Lyanna like in the books and TV show. [[spoiler:Having seen how HappilyMarried the Fairchilds are, how faithful Rickard remains to her late mother, and hearing of how much of a skirt-chaser Robert is, Lyanna is ''not'' happy.]] The only reason she gives him a chance is because of Evetta's encouragement. Robert is]]


Added DiffLines:

* InadequateInheritor: Viewed by his father and himself. Robert knows he's not qualified to be the next head of the family and often dreamed of striking out on his own, but Steffon's [[SparedByTheAdaptation survival]] and learning of his son's flaws endeavored him to take Robert's studies more seriously to the point of personally supervising him.


Added DiffLines:

* WeUsedToBeFriends: With Steffon Baratheon. Steffon himself notes how the dynamic between him, Aerys, and Tywin has changed to the point that as much as he would like to consider Rickard a friend, he doesn't want him to be "in poor company". In the second arc, Robert remembers how his father received a letter from Aerys following his "failure" to find Rhaegar a Valyrian bride; the contents of the letter are unknown, save that whatever was written made Steffon fly into a rage so violent even his wife couldn't console him and has ceased calling the Targaryens "kin".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdpatationalJerkass: In a manner of speaking - due to being a PosthumousCharacter, most of what we hear about Rhaegar comes from secondhand sources, and according to those who liked him but weren't blind to his faults (read: Barristan), he was the archetypical KnightInShiningArmor. In just his first appearance in this story, he comes off as quite creepy in his interactions with Lyana, and also seems to brush off concerns about his wife Elia (who is going through a very stressful pregnancy).

to:

* AdpatationalJerkass: AdaptationalJerkass: In a manner of speaking - due to being a PosthumousCharacter, most of what we hear about Rhaegar comes from secondhand sources, and according to those who liked him but weren't blind to his faults (read: Barristan), he was the archetypical KnightInShiningArmor. In just his first appearance in this story, he comes off as quite creepy in his interactions with Lyana, and also seems to brush off concerns about his wife Elia (who is going through a very stressful pregnancy).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdpatationalJerkass: In a manner of speaking - due to being a PosthumousCharacter, most of what we hear about Rhaegar comes from secondhand sources, and according to those who liked him but weren't blind to his faults (read: Barristan), he was the archetypical KnightInShiningArmor. In just his first appearance in this story, he comes off as quite creepy in his interactions with Lyana, and also seems to brush off concerns about his wife Elia (who is going through a very stressful pregnancy).

Top