Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / TheSecretHistory

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCassandra: At the very beginning, Laforgue tells Richard being Julian is an elitist, that having only one teacher puts him in a precarious position, being so isolated from the rest of the school is a loss, and that this is overall a bad idea. Richard goes full steam ahead anyways.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableFeminineGoalsAndTraits: Studying Early Childhood Education.

to:

* AcceptableFeminineGoalsAndTraits: Studying Early Childhood Education.Bunny likes how she's traditionally feminine. It's simultaneously inverted into RealWomenDontWearDresses as Richard and the book's framing look down on her for the same traits that Bunny praises.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnkemptBeauty: Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, Camilla is nonetheless feminine. Not feminine in a stylized kind of way -- she has a "boyish haircut" and sometimes wears her brother's clothes -- but an innate femininity of demeanor. Bunny calls her a "bramble rose, as opposed to your hybrid tea."

to:

* UnkemptBeauty: Bunny calls Camilla a "bramble rose." Richard and Bunny both agree that 1) Camilla looks a lot like Charles and 2) she's really pretty. She has a "boyish haircut" and sometimes wears her brother's clothes, but is also mentioned wearing dresses, jewelry, and lipstick. Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, Camilla is nonetheless feminine. Not feminine in a stylized kind of way -- she has a "boyish haircut" and sometimes wears her brother's clothes -- but caries an innate femininity of demeanor. Bunny calls her a "bramble rose, as opposed to your hybrid tea."femininity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OutgrownSuchSillySuperstitions: InvertedTrope. Henry is very smart in some ways, the most skilled Classicist of the group, and also uniquely superstious. Charles calls Henry a ornithomantist (a bird-diviner). Henry "sometimes left a saucer of milk outside his door to appease any malevolent spirits who might happen to wander by." He thinks they may get caught by a PolicePsychic. But then again, given that Henry is a DitzyGenius, it may also be played pretty straight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OddFriendship: Henry and Bunny were school-assigned roommates freshman year. They were reportedly best friends for a few years. But the time Richard joins the group, it's starting to crumble.

to:

* OddFriendship: Henry and Bunny were school-assigned roommates freshman year. They were reportedly best friends for a few years. But By the time Richard joins the group, it's starting to crumble.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbusiveParents: ImpliedTrope. Henry is mostly estranged from his father for no reason that we ever learn. As a child, Henry suffered a serious injury that gave him permanent facial scarring, and Bunny says Henry gets uncomfortable talking about it. Bunny comes up with an explanation involving a car accident, but that's purely his own conjecture and doesn't seem to be true. Henry "drove fast and often recklessly" -- not the behavior you'd expect from a man who was in such a serious car accident as a child.

to:

* AbusiveParents: ImpliedTrope. Henry is mostly estranged from his father for no reason that we ever learn. As a child, Henry suffered a serious injury that gave him permanent facial scarring, and Bunny says Henry gets uncomfortable talking about it. Bunny comes up with an explanation involving a car accident, but that's purely his own conjecture and doesn't seem to be true. true -- Henry "drove fast and often recklessly" -- recklessly," which is not the behavior you'd expect from a man who was who's been in such a serious car accident as a child.accident.

Changed: 247

Removed: 508

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Richard is in awe of the whole clique, but Camilla and Henry in particular he describes in the romanticized manner of a crush. In an interview, Donna Tartt said that an editor once told her a book written by a woman from a man's POV would not sell, and that she needed to rewrite it and GenderFlip Richard. Tartt said she couldn't do that because the main character would seem too in love with Henry if she did.
--->'''[[https://www.anothermag.com/art-photography/3209/donna-tartt-on-the-secret-history Donna Tartt]]:''' I couldn't have told the story I wanted to tell from a female point of view, because then there would be the question, "Is she doing this because she's attracted to him?" It would have been an interesting novel, but it wasn't the novel I wanted to write. There had to be no question, a way to keep it a purely moral decision and that was the territory of the novel. My main character had to be male.

to:

** Richard is in awe of the whole clique, but Camilla and Henry in particular he describes in the romanticized manner of a crush. In an interview, interviews, Donna Tartt has said more than once that an editor once told her a book written by a woman from a man's POV would not sell, and that she needed to rewrite it and GenderFlip Richard. Tartt said she couldn't do that because if Richard were {{Gender Flip|ped}}, this new rendition of the main character would seem too in love with Henry if she did.
--->'''[[https://www.anothermag.com/art-photography/3209/donna-tartt-on-the-secret-history Donna Tartt]]:''' I couldn't have told the story I wanted to tell from a female point of view, because then there would be the question, "Is she doing this because she's attracted to him?" It would have been an interesting novel, but it wasn't the novel I wanted to write. There had to be no question, a way to keep it a purely moral decision and that was the territory of the novel. My main character had to be male.
Henry. (See YMMV's [=Ho Yay=] listing for details.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''[[https://youtu.be/VlfDiV85joo?si=82lLJBqZV-KVvFLv&t=4633 Donna Tartt interview]]:''' It was obvious to me from the outset that this book had to be told from the point of view of a first-person narrator. It was essential that one never know what the other characters are thinking. There couldn't be an omniscient viewpoint -- you could never go into Henry's mind or into Julian -- because this is a novel of how the narrator is sort of gradually drawn into this and gradually fooled, and the reader should be fooled along with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DissonantSerenity / TheStoic: She is surprisingly calm sometimes, such as when [[spoiler: she receives an impromptu passionate kiss from a very drunk Charles]] in front of Richard, or when she tells Richard that [[spoiler: Charles tried to kill her.]] She is as "calm as a Madonna" when [[spoiler: she witnesses Bunny's murder]].
* DudeMagnet / UnwantedHarem: She attracts the attention of ''three'' men in the classics group -- though it's at least in part just by virtue of being the [[TheSmurfettePrinciple only girl present]] in an insular group that resists socializing with outsiders. Over the course of the novel, Camilla is an object of lust for Richard himself, [[spoiler: Henry, and even her own brother Charles]]. At one point in the novel it's implied that she may have rejected Bunny's advances. If we do count Bunny, this means that her ''entire friend group'' has a crush on her, except for the gay boy.

to:

* DissonantSerenity / TheStoic: DissonantSerenity: She is surprisingly calm sometimes, such as when [[spoiler: she receives an impromptu passionate kiss from a very drunk Charles]] in front of Richard, or when she tells Richard that [[spoiler: Charles tried to kill her.]] She is as "calm as a Madonna" when [[spoiler: she witnesses Bunny's murder]].
* DudeMagnet / UnwantedHarem: DudeMagnet: She attracts the attention of ''three'' three men in the classics group -- though it's at least in part just by virtue of being the [[TheSmurfettePrinciple only girl present]] in an insular group that resists socializing with outsiders. Over the course of the novel, Camilla is an object of lust for Richard himself, [[spoiler: Henry, and even her own brother Charles]]. At one point in the novel it's implied that she may have rejected Bunny's advances. If we do count Bunny, this means that her ''entire friend group'' has a crush on her, except for the gay boy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnreliableNarrator: By his own admission. Richard's admiration and affection for Julian and the murder clique (though mostly Henry and Camilla) results in a picture of each of them that may not be entirely representative of who they truly are.

to:

* UnreliableNarrator: By his own admission. Richard's admiration and affection for Julian and the murder clique (though mostly Henry and Camilla) results in a picture of each of them that may not be entirely representative of who they truly are. He also frequently lies to his friends so that they'll have a better impression of him, which suggests he may be doing the same with the audience.

Added: 293

Changed: 73

Removed: 286

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving events to main page; they're not exactly character tropes


* AnxietyDreams: Especially during his time in Leo's warehouse.



* EmbarrassingOldPhoto: Richard destroys the only photo of his mother that he owns, for fear that Bunny will see it and realize that Richard grew up relatively poor.



* TheNondescript: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average.

to:

* TheNondescript: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average.



* ScholarshipStudent: He goes to great lengths to hide his lower-middle class upbringing from his rich friends.

to:

* ScholarshipStudent: He Richard goes to great lengths to hide his lower-middle class upbringing from his rich friends.friends.
-->'''Georges Laforgue:''' Frankly, this is the first time I have ever heard of [Julian] accepting a pupil who is on such considerable financial aid. [...] I am willing to speculate that he isn't aware you are on assistance.\\
'''Richard:''' Well, if he doesn't know, I'm not going to tell him.



* WithFriendsLikeThese: Richard gets shot; nobody notices.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PseudoRomanticFriendship: Richard basically has a crush on the clique as a whole. He's captivated by, in awe of the group -- they're so beautiful, so smart, so enigmatic, so otherworldly. When Charles brings up the possibility of them living together as adults, Richard thinks it's the best thing he's ever heard. He thinks about the sexual potentiality in all of his friends -- not with ''him'', per se, but ''somewhere''. He goes on for a page and a half about could there be something between Henry and Bunny; when he finds out [[spoiler:the twins hook up sometimes]] he admits the idea had crossed his mind before, and he'd been turned on by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InformedFlaw: Francis alleges that Charles and Camilla are equally possessive over each other--but we never see anything at all that suggests Camilla is jealous over Charles, and she certainly shows no bitterness over the trysts Francis and Charles have. Of course, given that Francis is in love with Charles, he might be an UnreliableExpositor. Alternatively, Richard might be airbrushing Camilla's faults as a UnreliableNarrator.

to:

* InformedFlaw: Francis alleges that Charles and Camilla are equally both possessive over each other--but other. The only evidence we never see anything of this, though, is single vague example. At at all that suggests Camilla the end of Bunny's funeral, the twins have a fight which is jealous over Charles, and she certainly implied to be about Charles hooking up with Francis a couple hours earlier. She shows no bitterness over the trysts Francis and Charles have. Of course, given that Francis is in love with Charles, he might be an UnreliableExpositor. Alternatively, Richard might be airbrushing Camilla's faults as a UnreliableNarrator.animosity at Francis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OddFriendship: Henry and Bunny were school-assigned roommates freshman year. They were reportedly best friends for a few years. But the time Richard joins the group, it's starting to crumble.
-->'''Mr Corcoran:''' Why, I'll never forget, it was Bunny's first night at Hampden, he called me up on the telephone. "Dad," he said to me, "Dad, you ought to see this nut they gave me for a roommate." "Stick it out, son," I told him, "give it a chance" and before you could spit it was Henry this, Henry that, he's changing his major from whatever the hell it was to ancient Greek.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChickMagnet: Richard attracts attention from Judy, Sophie, Mona Beale, and a few unnamed female characters are implied or directly shown to be attracted to him. Francis also attempts to sleep with him on two separate occasions.

to:

* ChickMagnet: Richard attracts attention from Judy, Sophie, Judy Poovy, Mona Beale, Sophie Dearbold, and a few unnamed female characters are implied or directly shown to be attracted to him. Francis also attempts to sleep with him on two separate occasions. The fact that Richard got into Julian's handpicked-all-beautiful class suggests he might be a PrettyBoy.



* TheNondescript: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average. The fact that he got into Julian's class, though, suggests he might be a PrettyBoy.

to:

* TheNondescript: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average. The fact that he got into Julian's class, though, suggests he might be a PrettyBoy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving Richard's crush on Henry mostly to the YMMV page


** Richard is in awe of the whole clique, but Camilla and Henry in particular he describes in the romanticized manner of a crush. When considering the possibility of a tryst between Henry and Bunny, he's offended because he thinks Bunny's not attractive enough -- if Henry ''were'' to get with a guy, it should be a ''different'' guy. (This is right after Henry saved Richard's life and spent a month nursing him back to health.) At the end, Henry appears to Richard in a dream, and he compares it to when Patroklos appears to Achilles in a dream in the ''Literature/TheIliad''. The nature of Achilles and Patroklos's relationship is debated. In an interview, Donna Tartt said that an editor once told her a book written by a woman from a man's POV would not sell, and that she needed to rewrite it and GenderFlip Richard. Tartt said she couldn't do that because the main character would seem too in love with Henry if she did.

to:

** Richard is in awe of the whole clique, but Camilla and Henry in particular he describes in the romanticized manner of a crush. When considering the possibility of a tryst between Henry and Bunny, he's offended because he thinks Bunny's not attractive enough -- if Henry ''were'' to get with a guy, it should be a ''different'' guy. (This is right after Henry saved Richard's life and spent a month nursing him back to health.) At the end, Henry appears to Richard in a dream, and he compares it to when Patroklos appears to Achilles in a dream in the ''Literature/TheIliad''. The nature of Achilles and Patroklos's relationship is debated. In an interview, Donna Tartt said that an editor once told her a book written by a woman from a man's POV would not sell, and that she needed to rewrite it and GenderFlip Richard. Tartt said she couldn't do that because the main character would seem too in love with Henry if she did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:the clique jointly]]

to:

[[folder:the [[folder:The clique jointly]]in general]]



[[folder: the Macaulay twins jointly]]

to:

[[folder: the The Macaulay twins jointly]]in general]]



* ValleyGirl: She's from Los Angles, and thinks that she and Richard have a lot in common because they're both California kids.

to:

* ValleyGirl: She's from Los Angles, Angeles, and thinks that she and Richard have a lot in common because they're both California kids.

Added: 529

Changed: 132

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: [[{{AncientRome}} Camilla]] was also the sister of the [[{{SiblingTeam}} Horatii]], who [[{{CombatByChampion}} killed her fiance]].

to:

* MeaningfulName: [[{{AncientRome}} Camilla]] MeaningfulName:
-->'''[[https://www.today.com/today/amp/rcna62501 Donna Tartt]]:''' I can't remember how Charles got his name, but Camilla got hers from Camilla the warrior maiden in ''Literature/TheAeneid'' -- Virgil calls her "a sacred falcon" and there is a beautiful passage where the mothers of Italy gather to watch Camilla heading off to battle. I
was also reading the sister of ''Aeneid'' for a class right around the [[{{SiblingTeam}} Horatii]], who [[{{CombatByChampion}} killed time I started writing ''The Secret History''. Camilla is as strong and heroic as any soldier in the poem, and her fiance]].name stuck with me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNondescript: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average.

to:

* TheNondescript: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average. The fact that he got into Julian's class, though, suggests he might be a PrettyBoy.



* LonelyRichKid: In his childhood: his family is very rich and he appears to have been friendless or nearly so.

to:

%% * LonelyRichKid: In his childhood: his family is very rich and he appears to have been friendless or nearly so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OnlySaneWoman: She's pretty sharp for a "senseless cokehead". BookDumb Judy is a stark {{Foil}} to Richard's BookSmart by DitzyGenius classics friends.

to:

* OnlySaneWoman: She's pretty sharp for a "senseless cokehead". BookDumb Judy is a stark {{Foil}} to Richard's BookSmart by DitzyGenius classics friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSmurfettePrinciple: Richard remarks, "Being the only female in what was basically a boys' club must have been difficult for her." Camilla deals with being the only woman with intelligence and verve, for the most part, but being the object of three men's lust and love takes its toll after a while. Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, she is nonetheless feminine.
-->''Things would have been terribly strange and unbalanced without her. [[CardGames She was the Queen who finished out the suit of dark Jacks, dark King, and Joker.]]''

to:

* TheSmurfettePrinciple: Richard remarks, "Being the only female in what was basically a boys' club must have been difficult for her." Camilla deals with being the only woman with intelligence and verve, for the most part, but being the object of three men's lust and love takes its toll after a while. Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, she is nonetheless feminine.
-->''Things -->''Being the only female in what was basically a boys' club must have been difficult for her. […] Things would have been terribly strange and unbalanced without her. [[CardGames She was the Queen who finished out the suit of dark Jacks, dark King, and Joker.]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->[Julian's] students […] were imposing enough, and different as they were they shared a certain coolness, a cruel, mannered charm which was not modern in the least but had a strange cold breath of the ancient world: they were magnificent creatures, such eyes, such hands, such looks--''sic oculos, sic ille manus, sic ora ferebat''. I envied them, and found them attractive; moreover this strange quality, far from being natural, gave every indication of having been intensely cultivated.

to:

-->[Julian's] students […] were imposing enough, and different -->…different as they were they shared a certain coolness, a cruel, mannered charm which was not modern in the least but had a strange cold breath of the ancient world: they were magnificent creatures, such eyes, such hands, such looks--''sic oculos, sic ille manus, sic ora ferebat''. I envied them, and found them attractive; moreover this strange quality, far from being natural, gave every indication of having been intensely cultivated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DitzyGenius: The classics clique are initially introduced as a GeniusBookClub of TheBeautifulElite. Once Richard actually starts hanging out with them, we start to learn they're actually pretty impractical people outside of their studies (Henry's bizarre and convoluted plans to cover up the murder). They are shown to be bizarrely technologically illiterate, eerily unaware of any history that has taken place since about 1940 (Henry has never heard of the moon landing!), and to have trouble comprehending contemporary attitudes towards a variety of subjects (Camilla ends up ComicallyMissingThePoint of an anti-war film).

to:

* DitzyGenius: The classics clique are initially introduced as a GeniusBookClub of TheBeautifulElite.GeniusBookClub. Once Richard actually starts hanging out with them, we start to learn they're actually pretty impractical people outside of their studies (Henry's bizarre and convoluted plans to cover up the murder). They are shown to be bizarrely technologically illiterate, eerily unaware of any history that has taken place since about 1940 (Henry has never heard of the moon landing!), and to have trouble comprehending contemporary attitudes towards a variety of subjects (Camilla ends up ComicallyMissingThePoint of an anti-war film).

Added: 490

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBeautifulElite: Henry and Francis are so rich they'll never have a to work. Charles and Camilla are less so, but nonetheless wealthy enough their family can send them to Hampden without any aid. Bunny and Richard pretend to be wealthy to fit in with them, even though they're not.

to:

* TheBeautifulElite: Richard thinks they're all so attractive, so enigmatic, so smart. They're also rich. Henry and Francis are so rich they'll never have a to work. Charles and Camilla are less so, but nonetheless wealthy enough their family can send them to Hampden without any aid. Bunny and Richard pretend to be wealthy to fit in with them, even though they're not.not.
-->[Julian's] students […] were imposing enough, and different as they were they shared a certain coolness, a cruel, mannered charm which was not modern in the least but had a strange cold breath of the ancient world: they were magnificent creatures, such eyes, such hands, such looks--''sic oculos, sic ille manus, sic ora ferebat''. I envied them, and found them attractive; moreover this strange quality, far from being natural, gave every indication of having been intensely cultivated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheBeautifulElite: Henry and Francis are so rich they'll never have a to work. Charles and Camilla are less so, but nonetheless wealthy enough their family can send them to Hampden without any aid. Bunny and Richard pretend to be wealthy to fit in with them, even though they're not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSmurfettePrinciple: Richard remarks, "Being the only female in what was basically a boys' club must have been difficult for her." Camilla deals with being the only woman with intelligence and verve, for the most part, but being the object of three men's lust and love takes its toll after a while. Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, she is nonetheless femininize.

to:

* TheSmurfettePrinciple: Richard remarks, "Being the only female in what was basically a boys' club must have been difficult for her." Camilla deals with being the only woman with intelligence and verve, for the most part, but being the object of three men's lust and love takes its toll after a while. Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, she is nonetheless femininize.feminine.



* UnkemptBeauty: Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, Camilla is nonetheless femininize. Not feminine in a stylized kind of way -- she has a "boyish haircut" and sometimes wears her brother's clothes -- but an innate femininity of demeanor. Bunny calls her a "bramble rose, as opposed to your hybrid tea."

to:

* UnkemptBeauty: Richard emphasizes that despite hanging out with all guys, Camilla is nonetheless femininize.feminine. Not feminine in a stylized kind of way -- she has a "boyish haircut" and sometimes wears her brother's clothes -- but an innate femininity of demeanor. Bunny calls her a "bramble rose, as opposed to your hybrid tea."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LovingAShadow: Richard's crush on Camilla is… weird. He imagines her far more innocent than she is; in fact she's Henry's closest confidant in the group. In the very first Greek class, Richard says he doesn't stand a chance with her when she's constantly surrounded by these "clever rich boys in dark suits". If he ''were'' to attract her attentions, that would be the ultimate symbol that he's just as good as them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SouthernGentleman: DownplayedTrope. He's from Virginia, has a slight southern accent, and is the most socially graceful of the group -- neither standoffish like Henry and Francis not overbearing like Bunny. His habit of dressing in white also has some associations to this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HidingTheHandicap: DownplayedTrope, but Henry has "long scar at his hairline, all dented and puckered, with ridges of white flesh cutting across it to the browbone". He parts his hair so that it covers the scar from view.

Added: 210

Removed: 207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheEveryman: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average.


Added DiffLines:

* TheNondescript: Richard lovingly describes the appearances of his friends, but not himself. He mentions he's "prone to freckles", and that's it. Readers are left assuming he must look just sort of... average.

Top