Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / JoeVsElanSchool

Go To

OR

Added: 206

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Unnamed rebellious kid]]

to:

[[folder:Unnamed rebellious kid]]Rebel]]
[[quoteright:1000:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_elan_school_comic_69f2.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:1000:''"When Elan doubled down on the abuse this kid tripled down on the rebellion."'']]

Added: 807

Changed: 407

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheConfidant: Against Joe's better judgement, Gino -- who openly sees through and rejects Elan's bullshit -- becomes Joe's confidant within Elan. Joe acknowledges that his need for Gino's confidence is almost like an addiction, as it's one of the only "real" friendships he makes in Elan. This almost comes back to bite Joe when Gino starts naming people who'd confided in him, although Gino ultimately doesn't name Joe.

to:

* TheConfidant: TheConfidant:
**
Against Joe's better judgement, Gino -- who openly sees through and rejects Elan's bullshit -- becomes Joe's confidant within Elan. Joe acknowledges that his need for Gino's confidence is almost like an addiction, as it's one of the only "real" friendships he makes in Elan. This almost comes back to bite Joe when Gino starts naming people who'd confided in him, although Gino ultimately doesn't name Joe.Joe.
** {{Averted|Trope}} when Joe begins working to take down Elan as "Dave Westminister." He ultimately decides not to tell Gino what he's doing since Gino had been working for Ron, and especially doesn't after seeing an online accusation naming Gino as an Elan recruiter. Whether or not Gino would've told Elan or Ron is a mystery that Joe consciously decides not to look into after Gino passes away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBadFriend: Joe and Gino stay in touch, and Joe later calls him "my best friend." However, their relationship is strained when Gino keeps working for Ron, and when Joe sees an online accusation that Gino may be an Elan recruiter. This eventually culminates in Gino's ambiguous reaction during their last conversation, when Gino looks "almost like he was angry and proud at the same time" after Joe admits to being "Dave Westminister."

to:

* BigBadFriend: Joe and Gino stay in touch, and Joe later calls him "my best friend." However, their relationship is strained when Gino keeps working for Ron, and when Joe sees an online accusation that Gino may be an Elan recruiter. This eventually culminates in Gino's ambiguous reaction during their last conversation, when Gino looks "almost like he was angry and proud at the same time" after Joe admits to being "Dave Westminister."" However, after Gino's death, Joe decides not to investigate, and chooses to simply remember Gino as his friend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlutShaming: Part of Elan's modus operandi. Any contact between girls and boys, no matter how benign, is forbidden; and if a girl gets caught, the program makes an example out of her through slut shaming. Christy also tells the girls in Katie's dorm that they'll become prostitutes if they don't lean how to properly clean.

to:

* SlutShaming: Part of Elan's modus operandi. Any contact between girls and boys, no matter how benign, is forbidden; and if a girl gets caught, the program makes an example out of her through slut shaming. Christy also tells the girls in Katie's dorm that they'll become prostitutes if they don't lean learn how to properly clean.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DisappearedDad: By the time Joe's own marriage has fallen apart and Joe is forced to live at home again, Joe's dad is living in another state.

to:

* DisappearedDad: By For a time; by the time Joe's own first marriage has fallen apart and Joe is forced to live at home again, Joe's dad is living in another state.state. However, Joe moves in with his father in Chapter 100 after returning to the United States with Sofi.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changing this. The comic doesn't say that she sleeps around other than Joe hearing a voice in the background of a call.


* IcyBlueEyes: Eva is a drug addict who Joe says initially started off "for sure just using me" and later sleeps around with other guys after telling Joe about her pregnancy, and is depicted with icy blue eyes.

to:

* IcyBlueEyes: Eva is a drug addict who Joe says initially started off "for sure just using me" and later sleeps around me," apparently cheating on Joe with other guys after another man before telling Joe about her pregnancy, the abortion and ending things, and she is depicted with icy blue eyes.

Added: 574

Changed: 480

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foil}}: Gino for Joe. He's a few months younger than Joe, and because he's forced into Elan to get out of a supposedly worse sentence, he's arguably in a similar predicament that Joe was in at the beginning of the story. By the time Gino shows up, though, Joe has been in Elan for a few years and is pretty far into his own indoctrination. Gino openly ridicules many of the things about Elan that Joe himself ridiculed at the beginning of the story, and this serves as a brutal contrast to what Joe has become. Later on, though, it's turned on its head: Joe leaves Elan still hating Ron, while Gino has not only bonded with Ron (due to UsefulNotes/StockholmSyndrome), but has also gone into "business" with Ron. To cap it all, when Joe Googles Gino's name after seeing Gino wracked with religious guilt, he finds that Gino was listed as an ''Elan recruiter'' by another Elan survivor. Gino eventually dies of a drug overdose a few chapters after Joe talks about cleaning up his own act.

to:

* {{Foil}}: Gino for Joe. He's a few months younger than Joe, and because he's forced into Elan to get out of a supposedly worse sentence, he's arguably in a similar predicament that Joe was in at the beginning of the story. By the time Gino shows up, though, Joe has been in Elan for a few years and is pretty far into his own indoctrination. Gino openly ridicules many of the things about Elan that Joe himself ridiculed at the beginning of the story, and this serves as a brutal contrast to what Joe has become. Later on, though, it's turned on its head: Joe leaves Elan still hating Ron, while Gino has not only bonded with Ron (due to UsefulNotes/StockholmSyndrome), but has also gone into "business" with Ron. To cap it all, when Joe Googles Gino's name after seeing Gino wracked with religious guilt, he finds that Gino was listed as an ''Elan recruiter'' by another Elan survivor. Gino eventually dies of a drug overdose a few chapters after Joe talks about cleaning up his own act. However, Joe {{lampshade}}s this trope in the final chapter, saying that Gino ''wasn't'' written as an explicit counterpoint or to advance Joe's own story.



* SmallRoleBigImpact: P's presence in the narrative isn't very large, but it is far-reaching: he was there for the drug charge that got Joe sent to the Elan School in the first place, he tells Joe that the drug charges were all dropped three months into Joe's stay at Elan, and he also later introduces Joe to Website/{{Reddit}}, which becomes instrumental in helping Joe and the "core group" take down Elan for good.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: P's presence in the narrative isn't very large, but it is far-reaching: he far-reaching:
** He
was there for the drug charge that got Joe sent to the Elan School in the first place, he place.
** He
tells Joe that the drug charges were all dropped three months into Joe's stay at Elan, and he also Elan.
** He
later introduces Joe to Website/{{Reddit}}, which becomes instrumental in helping Joe and the "core group" take down Elan for good.good.
** He asks Joe about what happened at the Elan School; during their conversation, Joe asks for a pencil and paper to sketch illustrations of things. This leads Joe to create illustrations in Photoshop, leading directly to ''Joe vs. Elan School'' itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheUnReveal: In Chapter 100, Joe takes some time to reflect on his relationship with Gino, following the latter's death in Chapter 98, and the rumors that Gino, as a part of his mysterious pantership with Ron, might have been working directly for Elan as a recruiter, and could even have been one of the people who opposed Joe and his efforts, in his guise as Dave Westminister, to expose and close the place down. Joe admits he never really discovered for certain if this was the case, as he ultimately concluded that he actually wasn't interested in knowing the answer and he preferred to remember Gino as his friend and nothing else.

to:

* TheUnReveal: In Chapter 100, Joe takes some time to reflect on his relationship with Gino, following the latter's death in Chapter 98, and the rumors that Gino, as a part of his mysterious pantership with Ron, might have been working directly for Elan as a recruiter, and could even have been one of the people who opposed Joe and his efforts, in his guise as Dave Westminister, to expose Elan's crimes to the public and close the place down. Joe admits he never really discovered for certain if this was the case, as he ultimately concluded that he actually wasn't interested in knowing the answer and he preferred to remember Gino as his friend and nothing else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheUnReveal: In Chapter 100, Joe thinks ponders his relationship with Gino, and the rumors that Gino, as a part of his mysterious pantership with Ron, might have been working directly for Elan as a recruiter, and could even have been one of the people who opposed Joe and his efforts, in his guise as Dave Westminister, to expose and close the place down. Joe admits he never really discovered for certain if this was the case, as he ultimately concluded that he actually wasn't interested in knowing the answer and he preferred to remember Gino as his friend and nothing else.

to:

* TheUnReveal: In Chapter 100, Joe thinks ponders takes some time to reflect on his relationship with Gino, following the latter's death in Chapter 98, and the rumors that Gino, as a part of his mysterious pantership with Ron, might have been working directly for Elan as a recruiter, and could even have been one of the people who opposed Joe and his efforts, in his guise as Dave Westminister, to expose and close the place down. Joe admits he never really discovered for certain if this was the case, as he ultimately concluded that he actually wasn't interested in knowing the answer and he preferred to remember Gino as his friend and nothing else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheUnReveal: In Chapter 100, Joe thinks ponders his relationship with Gino, and the rumors that Gino, as a part of his mysterious pantership with Ron, might have been working directly for Elan as a recruiter, and could even have been one of the people who opposed Joe and his efforts, in his guise as Dave Westminister, to expose and close the place down. Joe admits he never really discovered for certain if this was the case, as he ultimately concluded that he actually wasn't interested in knowing the answer and he preferred to remember Gino as his friend and nothing else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCaligula: She rules over Elan 8 with cruelty, not taking any kind of slight against her rule, and constantly MovingTheGoalposts with forcing Joe to stay at Elan as her stooge. However, Joe notes that she completely shuts down with a "dumb, helpless, confused look on her face" when two high-strength students take down John during the Elan 8 riot.

to:

* TheCaligula: She Christy rules over Elan 8 with cruelty, not taking abject sadism. She severely punishes any kind of perceived slight against her; at one point she screams to have Joe hogtied while he's ignoring her rule, during a HeroicBSOD, and she later goes on a sexist diatribe and denies breakfast to Katie's group for not dusting the light covers well enough. She orders the staff to read and [[CrushTheKeepsake destroy]] any letters from Joe's sister in front of Joe after deducing that Joe is close with his sister. She also abuses her authority by constantly MovingTheGoalposts with forcing putting off Joe's graduation date in order to force Joe to stay at Elan as her stooge. However, Joe notes that she completely shuts down with a "dumb, helpless, confused look on her face" when two high-strength students take down John during the Elan 8 a house riot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCaligula: She rules over Elan 8 with cruelty, not taking any kind of slight against her rule, and constantly MovingTheGoalposts with forcing Joe to stay at Elan as her stooge. However, Joe notes that she completely shuts down with a "dumb, helpless, confused look on her face" when two high-strength students take down John during the Elan 8 riot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoodleIncident: We aren't told specifically why Katie was sent to Elan, other than her stepfather wanted to send her there and manipulated her mother into agreeing to it.

Added: 564

Changed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarnYourHappyEnding: Joe swears off his post-Elan bad behaviors and focuses fully on his self-improvement, falls in love with and marries Maria, figures out a financial situation that allows him and his new wife to permanently move away from his parents, and relocates to New York City.

to:

* EarnYourHappyEnding: EarnYourHappyEnding:
** At the end of the second part,
Joe swears off his post-Elan bad behaviors and focuses fully on his self-improvement, falls in love with and marries Maria, figures out a financial situation that allows him and his new wife to permanently move away from his parents, and relocates to New York City.City. However, [[HappyEndingOverride this doesn't last]] and he later ends up divorced.
** It does happen again after Elan closes and Joe divorces Maria. Joe spends his time traveling around the world and improving himself again, and he dates and falls in love with Sofi.

Added: 78

Removed: 78

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Numbers are alphabetized before letters.


* EleventhHourRanger: Sofi shows up four chapters before the end of the story.



* EleventhHourRanger: Sofi shows up four chapters before the end of the story.

Added: 336

Changed: 458

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MovingTheGoalposts: Christy ultimately prolongs Joe's stay at Elan because she wants to keep him running Elan 8 as her lackey. It takes Ron directly calling her out for it and threatening to "go to the top" to get her to finally schedule Joe's graduation date, which [[ShameIfSomethingHappened she constantly holds over Joe's head]].

to:

* MoochingMaster: Downplayed; Christy makes a big deal about Joe becoming a "full coordinator," then later a "re-entry" student, but in reality she only does it to force Joe to stay longer and run Elan 8 for her without being paid for it. Ron (of all people) eventually returns to call her out for turning Joe into her slave.
* MovingTheGoalposts: Christy ultimately continually prolongs Joe's stay at Elan because she wants to keep him running Elan 8 as her lackey. It takes Ron directly calling her out for it and threatening to "go to the top" to get her to finally schedule Joe's graduation date, which [[ShameIfSomethingHappened she constantly holds over Joe's head]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Joe gets interviewed (with his face [[{{Pixellation}} blurred]]) for a documentary about Elan called ''The Last Stop''. However, when he sits down to watch it, he gets a panic attack about three minutes in; he can't even bring himself to fast forward through it to his interview, as even brief snippets of Elan imagery sets off his PTSD. He notes that he still can't watch it to this day.

to:

** Joe gets interviewed (with his face [[{{Pixellation}} blurred]]) for a documentary about Elan called ''The Last Stop''. However, when he sits down to watch it, he gets a panic attack about three minutes in; he can't even bring himself to fast forward through it to his interview, as even brief snippets of Elan imagery sets set off his PTSD. He notes that he still can't watch it to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Joe gets interviewed (with his face [[{{Pixellation}} blurred]]) for a documentary about Elan called ''The Last Stop''. However, when he sits down to watch it, he gets a panic attack about three minutes in; he can't even bring himself to fast forward through it to his interview, as even brief snippets of Elan imagery sets off his PTSD. He notes that he still can't watch it to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LastGirlWins: She's Joe's last love interest in the story, who Joe is still with today.

to:

* LastGirlWins: She's Joe's last love interest in the story, who Joe marries and is still with today.



* LoveInterest: Joe first meets Sofi in the "cold city" after seeing her at a salsa dancing class. They go on a few dates before his visa expires, but he later returns and stays with her for two years.

to:

* LoveInterest: Joe first meets Sofi in the "cold city" after seeing her at a salsa dancing class. They go on a few dates before his visa expires, but he later returns and returns, stays with her for two years.years, and marries her.



* SecondLove: Sofi and Joe meet, date, and get together some time after Joe's divorce from Maria.

to:

* SecondLove: Sofi and Joe meet, date, get together, and get together marry some time after Joe's divorce from Maria.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sofi is Joe's love interest who he meets in the "cold city" while traveling the world after his divorce.

to:

Sofi is Joe's love interest second wife who he first meets in the "cold city" while traveling the world after his divorce.divorce from Maria.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallRoleBigImpact: P's presence in the narrative isn't very large, but it is far-reaching: he was there for the drug charge that got Joe sent to the Elan School in the first place, and he also later introduces Joe to Website/{{Reddit}}, which becomes instrumental in helping Joe and the "core group" take down Elan for good.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: P's presence in the narrative isn't very large, but it is far-reaching: he was there for the drug charge that got Joe sent to the Elan School in the first place, he tells Joe that the drug charges were all dropped three months into Joe's stay at Elan, and he also later introduces Joe to Website/{{Reddit}}, which becomes instrumental in helping Joe and the "core group" take down Elan for good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
correcting a word


* OffToBoardingSchool: Katie's stepfather sent Katie to Elan over her mother's wishes.

to:

* OffToBoardingSchool: Katie's stepfather sent Katie to Elan over against her mother's wishes.

Added: 283

Removed: 272

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: During one of his call center jobs in New York, Joe is so disgusted by the center's predatory sales methods that he learns the account deletion code, quietly spends the next four days deleting people's numbers and faking sales, then leaves for good.



* WhatYouAreInTheDark: During one of his call center jobs in New York, Joe is so disgusted by the center's predatory sales methods that he learns the account deletion code, quietly spends the next four days deleting people's numbers and faking sales, then leaves for good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallRoleBigImpact: Dee-Ray agrees to provide testimony about Elan, casually mentioning that he wouldn't believe that he endured Elan if not for track meet results on Google. This gives Joe the idea to Google recent track meet results for Elan School, and to use that data to comb through his call center's databases and find contact info for the kids' parents. This directly leads to Katie's rescue from Elan, which in turn leads to Sandra and other children being rescued.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Dee-Ray agrees to provide testimony about Elan, casually mentioning that he wouldn't believe that he endured Elan if not for track meet results on Google. This gives Joe the idea to Google recent track meet results for Elan School, and to use that data to comb through his call center's databases and find contact info for the kids' parents. This directly leads to Katie's rescue from Elan, which in turn leads to Sandra and other children being rescued.rescued, which contributes to Elan's eventual closure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Dee-Ray agrees to provide testimony about Elan, casually mentioning that he wouldn't believe that he endured Elan if not for track meet results on Google. This gives Joe the idea to Google recent track meet results for Elan School, and to use that data to comb through his call center's databases and find contact info for the kids' parents. This directly leads to Katie's rescue from Elan, which in turn leads to Sandra and other children being rescued.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatYouAreInTheDark: During one of his call center jobs in New York, Joe is so disgusted by the center's predatory sales methods that he learns the account deletion code, quietly spends the next four days deleting people's numbers and faking sales, then leaves for good.

Added: 466

Changed: 48

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HateSink: Joe has absolutely no problem vilifying Cirri. Cirri started out as a petty thug, got roped into the Synanon-inspired Daybreak Village in the Sixties, and walks away with it with enough knowledge of its methodology to co-found Elan School. From Elan, Cirri rakes in ''millions'' of dollars in tuition fees at the expense of the children's well-being, and personally oversaw its earliest punishment methods, which included horrors like dumping buckets of human waste on its residents. Joe alleges that Cirri burned down several buildings he owned at Elan and at his racetrack to collect the insurance money, drove his wife to a breakdown that required a hospital stay, and has enough clout in the Maine political scene to [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections keep law enforcement at bay]].

to:

* HateSink: Joe has absolutely no problem vilifying Cirri. Cirri started out as a petty thug, got roped into the Synanon-inspired Daybreak Village in the Sixties, and walks away with it with enough knowledge of its methodology to co-found Elan School. From Elan, Cirri rakes in ''millions'' of dollars in tuition fees at the expense of the children's well-being, and personally oversaw its earliest punishment methods, which included horrors like dumping buckets of human waste on its residents. Joe alleges that Cirri burned down several buildings he owned at Elan and at his racetrack to collect the insurance money, drove his wife to a breakdown that required a hospital stay, and has enough clout in the Maine political scene to [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections keep law enforcement at bay]]. Even after Cirri dies, Joe still hates him.



** In the third part, however, Joe finds that this good publicity lasted even after Cirri's death in 2001. To his disgust, he sees that the Maine legislature had a "Jay Cirri Day" and paid homage to him with a speech.

to:

** In the third part, however, Joe finds that this good publicity lasted even after Cirri's death in 2001. To his disgust, he sees that the Maine legislature had a "Jay Cirri Day" and paid homage to him with speeches.
--->'''State Representative:''' [Jay] had the foresight to found Elan. A special adolescent treatment center designed not only to get young people off drugs and alcohol and other substances, but also to prepare them for
a speech.productive adult life. [...] [He] was a man of tireless energy who enlivened our lives and left Maine just a little bit better for it. We will all miss him.\\
'''Joe:''' ''[narrating]'' Speak for yourself, fuckstick, I wish he'd never been born.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSvengali: More or less becomes one to Gino after Gino leaves Elan, turning Gino into what looks like a drug runner.

to:

* TheSvengali: More or less becomes one to Gino after Gino leaves Gino, grooming him with gifts, books, and personal attention during Gino's time in Elan, and eventually turning Gino into what looks like a drug runner.runner and possible Elan recruiter.



** In Joe. He gradually "befriends" Joe in Elan, then later attempts to get Joe to leave Elan with him, and gets into a spat with Christy over Joe's graduation date. During Joe's senior year of college, Gino says that Ron sometimes asks Gino about Joe, which makes it somewhat alarming when Joe doesn't hear from Gino again "for a very long time" after Joe refuses to go visit Ron with him.
** To a lesser extent, Gino, who becomes one of Ron's buddies and flunkies thanks to Gino's lingering UsefulNotes/StockholmSyndrome. Joe doesn't have the heart to tell Gino that Gino's experience with Ron happened almost ''exactly'' the same way it did with Joe, with the only difference being that Joe couldn't stand the thought of Ron after Elan.

to:

** In Joe. He gradually "befriends" Joe in Elan, then later attempts to get Joe to leave Elan with him, and gets into a spat with Christy over Joe's graduation date. On Joe's graduation date, he gets Joe alone and declares that he's going to keep in touch and they'll be lifelong friends. During Joe's senior year of college, Gino says that Ron sometimes asks Gino about Joe, which makes it somewhat alarming when Joe doesn't hear from Gino again "for a very long time" after Joe refuses to go visit Ron with him.
** To a lesser extent, Gino, who becomes one of Ron's buddies and flunkies thanks to Gino's lingering UsefulNotes/StockholmSyndrome. During Gino's time in Elan, Ron grooms Gino with gifts, books, and personal talks, causing Gino to bond with him, which eventually leads to some kind of nebulous business arrangement after Gino graduates. Joe doesn't have the heart to tell Gino that Gino's experience with Ron happened almost ''exactly'' the same way it did with Joe, with the only difference being that Joe couldn't stand the thought of Ron after Elan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallRoleBigImpact: His role in the story isn't very large, but he does get Joe involved with Elan's running team. Joe keeps up with running even after leaving Elan; in a late chapter, Joe mentions that he routinely runs for exercise and exploration while traveling the world.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: His role in the story isn't very large, but he does get Joe involved with Elan's running team. Joe then keeps up with running even after leaving Elan; he runs to alleviate his stress and depression in a late chapter, Joe mentions that college, and later on he routinely runs for exercise and exploration while traveling the world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Gino is a snarky teen from Staten Island, just a few months younger than Joe, who is first introduced in Chapter 54 as a new student. Shortly after the Elan 8 riot, Joe makes friends with Gino, breaking one of Elan's cardinal rules about "contracts" between inmates. The two later keep in touch after Elan.

to:

Gino is a snarky teen young man from Staten Island, just a few months younger than Joe, who is first introduced in Chapter 54 as a new Elan student. Shortly after the Elan 8 riot, Joe makes friends with Gino, breaking one of Elan's cardinal rules about "contracts" between inmates. The two later keep in touch after Elan.Elan, with Gino often dropping in to visit Joe.

Top