Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Art / LeDejeunerSurLHerbe

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While the figures have impressive attention to detail, the grass and other details in the background looked loose and unfinished, something that would later define other Impressionist painters.

to:

** While the figures have impressive attention to detail, the grass and other details in the background looked loose and unfinished, something that would later define other Impressionist painters.{{painters}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also ''{{Art/Olympia}}'', another Manet painting decried by the nudity.

to:

See also ''{{Art/Olympia}}'', another Manet painting decried by the which was criticised for its nudity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

See also ''{{Art/Olympia}}'', another Manet painting decried by the nudity.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ColorContrast: The forest scenery is painted in dark greens and browns, with the exception of the pond and the two men wear black suit jackets. By contrast, the picnic implements are painted in comparatively saturated hues (blue, orange, and light beige), while the two women are naked and white-skinned. This helps draw the eye to the aforementioned elements.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NippleAndDimed: The woman in the foreground's nipples are completely covered by her arm and the shadow it casts. They don't cover her {{sideboob}}s, though.

to:

* NippleAndDimed: The nipples of the woman in the foreground's nipples foreground are completely covered by her arm and the shadow it casts. They don't cover her {{sideboob}}s, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiningInTheBuff: Depicts one of the women enjoying the picnic completely naked.

to:

* DiningInTheBuff: Depicts one of the women enjoying the picnic completely naked. It's meant to elicit a jarring contrast because the other characters are clothed (even if the other woman's naked body can be appreciated under her soaked dress). Apparently, this lady is a nudist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheXOfY: The title is fashioned this way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsNotPornItsArt: This painting was met with outrage from critics for placing nude women in an everyday setting. Back then, nudity was okay as long as they were goddesses, nymphs, sprites, etc. However, real women being nude in {{art}}works was a big no-no (with the possible exception of paintings depicting nude models posing, such as a RecliningVenus). Manet's response to them was this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Impressionism}}: It captures a SliceOfLice scene -- the characters are merely having a picnic. It also disrupts two Elements of art: the scenery's textures are left purposefully in poor detail and the perspective (aka, space) is wrong, giving the impression of an absence of separation between the forefront and the background.

to:

* {{Impressionism}}: It captures a SliceOfLice SliceOfLife scene -- the characters are merely having a picnic. It also disrupts two Elements of art: the scenery's textures are left purposefully in poor detail and the perspective (aka, space) is wrong, giving the impression of an absence of separation between the forefront and the background.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Impressionism}}: It captures a SliceOfLice scene -- the characters are merely having a picnic. It also disrupts two Elements of art: the scenery's textures are left purposefully in poor detail and the perspective (aka, space) is wrong, giving the impression of an absence of separation between the forefront and the background.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NippleAndDimed: The woman in the foreground's nipples are completely covered by her arm and the shadow it casts, though there is {{Sideboob}}.

to:

* NippleAndDimed: The woman in the foreground's nipples are completely covered by her arm and the shadow it casts, though there is {{Sideboob}}.casts. They don't cover her {{sideboob}}s, though.



** The nude woman is depicted with an absence of contrast you would see from nudes in other paintings, critics commenting that the lighting looks as though it was done in a studio. What few shadows there are depicts them as stark compared to her light skin, the shadows almost outlining her figure.

to:

** The nude woman is depicted with an absence of contrast you would see from nudes in other paintings, with critics commenting that the lighting looks as though it was done in a studio. What few shadows there are depicts them as stark compared to her light skin, the shadows almost outlining her figure.



* TakeThat: The whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored, and parodying the quirks of pieces venerated as flawless.

to:

* TakeThat: The whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] art"]]. The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored, and parodying the quirks of pieces venerated as flawless.

Added: 179

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MenAreStrongWomenArePretty: {{Downplayed}}. The men are fully clothed in Parisian fashion. One of the women is wearing a white dress that is made transparent due to her time in the water, while the other is completely naked, the blue dress and hat beside her implying that she had stripped where they had laid out their picnic.

to:

* MenAreStrongWomenArePretty: {{Downplayed}}. The men are fully clothed in Parisian fashion. One of the women is wearing a white dress that is made transparent [[VaporWear transparent]] due to her time in the water, while the other is completely naked, the blue dress and hat beside her implying that she had stripped where they had laid out their picnic.


Added DiffLines:

* VaporWear: The woman in the background is completely soaked, which causes her white dress to be partially transparent. This reveals that she's not wearing any sort of underwear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtImitatesArt: Manet had a deep understanding of art history, having based the painting off of ''Judgement of Paris'' (ca. 1515) by Marcantonio Raimondi and Raphael, ''Pastoral Concert'' by Giorgione or Titian, ''Art/TheTempest'' by Creator/{{Giorgione}} and ''La Partie Carrée'' by Antoine Watteau.

to:

* ArtImitatesArt: Manet had a deep understanding of art history, having based the painting off of on ''Judgement of Paris'' (ca. 1515) by Marcantonio Raimondi and Raphael, ''Pastoral Concert'' by Giorgione or Titian, ''Art/TheTempest'' by Creator/{{Giorgione}} and ''La Partie Carrée'' by Antoine Watteau.



* MenAreStrongWomenArePretty: Downplayed. The men are fully-clothed in Parisian fashion. One of the women is wearing a white dress that is made transparent due to her time in the water, while the other is completely naked, the blue dress and hat beside her implying that she had stripped where they had laid out their picnic.
* NippleAndDimed: Her nipples are completely covered by her arm and the shadow it casts, though there is {{Sideboob}}.

to:

* MenAreStrongWomenArePretty: Downplayed. {{Downplayed}}. The men are fully-clothed fully clothed in Parisian fashion. One of the women is wearing a white dress that is made transparent due to her time in the water, while the other is completely naked, the blue dress and hat beside her implying that she had stripped where they had laid out their picnic.
* NippleAndDimed: Her The woman in the foreground's nipples are completely covered by her arm and the shadow it casts, though there is {{Sideboob}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtImitatesArt: Manet had a deep understanding of art history, having based the painting off of ''Judgement of Paris'' (ca. 1515) by Marcantonio Raimondi and Raphael, ''Pastoral Concert'' by Giorgione or Titian, ''The Tempest'' by Giorgione and ''La Partie Carrée'' by Antoine Watteau.

to:

* ArtImitatesArt: Manet had a deep understanding of art history, having based the painting off of ''Judgement of Paris'' (ca. 1515) by Marcantonio Raimondi and Raphael, ''Pastoral Concert'' by Giorgione or Titian, ''The Tempest'' ''Art/TheTempest'' by Giorgione Creator/{{Giorgione}} and ''La Partie Carrée'' by Antoine Watteau.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'', known to English-speakers as ''The Luncheon on the Grass'', is a 81.9 x 104.1 in (208 by 264.5 cm) oil painting by father of Impressionism Édouard Manet. Originally titled ''Le Bain'' (''The Bath''), ''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'' depicts two men and two women at what remains of a picnic out in the open. The men are fully clothed, while one woman faces the viewer, having stripped down to nothing, while the other woman is scantily clad in the pond in the background.

to:

''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'', known to English-speakers as ''The Luncheon on the Grass'', is a 81.9 x 104.1 in (208 by 264.5 cm) oil painting {{painting|s}} by father of Impressionism [[Creator/EdouardManet Édouard Manet.Manet]]. Originally titled ''Le Bain'' (''The Bath''), ''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'' depicts two men and two women at what remains of a picnic out in the open. The men are fully clothed, while one woman faces the viewer, having stripped down to nothing, while the other woman is scantily clad in the pond in the background.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Pretty much" is Word Cruft; also fixing typographical error and awkward grammar.





** The woman in the pond it too large for the amount of distance the painting implies her to be, with her thumb lining up with the man on the right's thumb to collapse the illusion of depth.

to:

** The woman in the pond it is too large for the amount of distance how far away the painting implies her to be, with her thumb lining up with the man on the right's thumb to collapse the illusion of depth.



* TakeThat: The whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that pretty much-defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored, and parodying the quirks of pieces venerated as flawless.

to:

* TakeThat: The whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that pretty much-defined defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored, and parodying the quirks of pieces venerated as flawless.
flawless.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'', known to English-speakers as ''The Luncheon on the Grass'', is a 81.9 x 104.1 in (208 by 264.5 cm) oil painting by father of Impressionism Édouard Manet. Originally titled ''Le Bain'' (''The Bath''), ''Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe'' depicts two men and two women at what remains of a picnic out in the open. The men are fully clothed, while one woman faces the viewer, having stripped down to nothing, while the other woman is scantily clad in the pond in the background.

to:

''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'', known to English-speakers as ''The Luncheon on the Grass'', is a 81.9 x 104.1 in (208 by 264.5 cm) oil painting by father of Impressionism Édouard Manet. Originally titled ''Le Bain'' (''The Bath''), ''Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe'' l'herbe'' depicts two men and two women at what remains of a picnic out in the open. The men are fully clothed, while one woman faces the viewer, having stripped down to nothing, while the other woman is scantily clad in the pond in the background.



* TakeThat: the whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that pretty much defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored, and parodying the quirks of pieces venerated as flawless.

to:

* TakeThat: the The whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that pretty much defined much-defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored, and parodying the quirks of pieces venerated as flawless.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurNudityIsDifferent: In a case of YourNormalIsOurTaboo, one of the reasons behind the painting's controversy is due to the figures in the painting were modern, the clothed figures wearing fashionable Parisian hinting at the painting being set in modern times. At the time, nude men and women depicted in paintings were normally goddesses and other mythical figures, so the fact that the nude woman is a regular human without the pretense of myth and time was considered scandalous for its day. Others followed in that trend, such as Gustave Courbet with ''Art/LOrigineDuMonde''.

to:

* OurNudityIsDifferent: In a case of YourNormalIsOurTaboo, one of the reasons behind the painting's controversy is due to the figures in the painting were modern, the clothed figures wearing fashionable Parisian hinting at the painting being set in modern times. At the time, nude men and women depicted in paintings were normally goddesses and other mythical figures, figures (see Creator/WilliamAdolpheBouguereau's art for instance), so the fact that the nude woman is a regular human without the pretense of myth and time was considered scandalous for its day. Others followed in that trend, such as Gustave Courbet with ''Art/LOrigineDuMonde''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurNudityIsDifferent: In a case of YourNormalIsOurTaboo, one of the reasons behind the painting's controversy is due to the figures in the painting were modern, the clothed figures wearing fashionable Parisian hinting at the painting being set in modern times. At the time, nude men and women depicted in paintings were normally goddesses and other mythical figures, so the fact that the nude woman is a regular human without the pretense of myth and time was considered scandalous for its day.

to:

* OurNudityIsDifferent: In a case of YourNormalIsOurTaboo, one of the reasons behind the painting's controversy is due to the figures in the painting were modern, the clothed figures wearing fashionable Parisian hinting at the painting being set in modern times. At the time, nude men and women depicted in paintings were normally goddesses and other mythical figures, so the fact that the nude woman is a regular human without the pretense of myth and time was considered scandalous for its day. Others followed in that trend, such as Gustave Courbet with ''Art/LOrigineDuMonde''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: the whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that pretty much defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored.

to:

* TakeThat: the whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that pretty much defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored.
favored, and parodying the quirks of pieces venerated as flawless.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* TakeThat: the whole piece is Manet's artistic middle finger to the Salon, a long-running annual French exhibition that pretty much defined art at the time by virtue of [[ReviewsAreTheGospel "If the Salon rejects it, it's not art."]] The painting tightly follows all of the technical aspects of the style that the Salon endorsed, while blatantly mocking the StrictlyFormula themes and subjects the juries traditionally favored.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_luncheon_on_the_grass.jpg]]

''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'', known to English-speakers as ''The Luncheon on the Grass'', is a 81.9 x 104.1 in (208 by 264.5 cm) oil painting by father of Impressionism Édouard Manet. Originally titled ''Le Bain'' (''The Bath''), ''Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe'' depicts two men and two women at what remains of a picnic out in the open. The men are fully clothed, while one woman faces the viewer, having stripped down to nothing, while the other woman is scantily clad in the pond in the background.

----
!!''Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe'' provides examples of:

* ArtImitatesArt: Manet had a deep understanding of art history, having based the painting off of ''Judgement of Paris'' (ca. 1515) by Marcantonio Raimondi and Raphael, ''Pastoral Concert'' by Giorgione or Titian, ''The Tempest'' by Giorgione and ''La Partie Carrée'' by Antoine Watteau.
* DiningInTheBuff: Depicts one of the women enjoying the picnic completely naked.
* MenAreStrongWomenArePretty: Downplayed. The men are fully-clothed in Parisian fashion. One of the women is wearing a white dress that is made transparent due to her time in the water, while the other is completely naked, the blue dress and hat beside her implying that she had stripped where they had laid out their picnic.
* NippleAndDimed: Her nipples are completely covered by her arm and the shadow it casts, though there is {{Sideboob}}.
* OurNudityIsDifferent: In a case of YourNormalIsOurTaboo, one of the reasons behind the painting's controversy is due to the figures in the painting were modern, the clothed figures wearing fashionable Parisian hinting at the painting being set in modern times. At the time, nude men and women depicted in paintings were normally goddesses and other mythical figures, so the fact that the nude woman is a regular human without the pretense of myth and time was considered scandalous for its day.
* StylisticSuck: While much of the composition of the painting could be considered amateur, what makes it different is that Manet purposefully made these errors.
** The woman in the pond it too large for the amount of distance the painting implies her to be, with her thumb lining up with the man on the right's thumb to collapse the illusion of depth.
** The nude woman is depicted with an absence of contrast you would see from nudes in other paintings, critics commenting that the lighting looks as though it was done in a studio. What few shadows there are depicts them as stark compared to her light skin, the shadows almost outlining her figure.
** While the figures have impressive attention to detail, the grass and other details in the background looked loose and unfinished, something that would later define other Impressionist painters.

----

Top