Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Analysis / GreatOffscreenWar

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This has some interesting consequences even in [[ConstructedWorld fiction that doesn't reference WW2 in any way]]: whenever a post-War author introduces an off-screen war ExtyYearsFromNow, it will often take place about the same time ago in-story as the [=WW2=] did in RealLife at the moment of writing (give or take a decade).

to:

This has some interesting consequences even in [[ConstructedWorld fiction that doesn't reference WW2 in any way]]: whenever a post-War author introduces an off-screen war ExtyYearsFromNow, ExactlyExtyYearsAgo, it will often take place about the same time ago in-story as the [=WW2=] did in RealLife at the moment of writing (give or take a decade).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Without a link to that study, it sounds both preposterous and implausible simply by the scale of surveying all fiction since 1945


If we had to choose a definitive example of this to the PresentDay RealLife, it would probably be UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. While ''lots'' of wars have happened in the meantime, it was the [=WW2=] that had in one way or another shaped the modern world and affected its inhabitants for generations to come. And, of course, it will remain off-screen until a TimeMachine is invented. Someone did a study on this a few years ago. Of all the fiction books published in the English language since 1945, 95% of them, at some point, in some context, mention World War II. Even ''Literature/HarryPotter'' mentions it.

to:

If we had to choose a definitive example of this to the PresentDay RealLife, it would probably be UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. While ''lots'' of wars have happened in the meantime, it was the [=WW2=] that had in one way or another shaped the modern world and affected its inhabitants for generations to come. And, of course, it will remain off-screen until a TimeMachine is invented. Someone did It has also affected a study on this a few years ago. Of all the wide swathe of fiction books published in the English language since 1945, 95% of them, at some point, in some context, mention World War II. Even then; even ''Literature/HarryPotter'' mentions it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If we had to choose a definitive example of this to the PresentDay RealLife, it would probably be WorldWarII. While ''lots'' of wars have happened in the meantime, it was the [=WW2=] that had in one way or another shaped the modern world and affected its inhabitants for generations to come. And, of course, it will remain off-screen until a TimeMachine is invented. Someone did a study on this a few years ago. Of all the fiction books published in the English language since 1945, 95% of them, at some point, in some context, mention WorldWarII. Even ''Literature/HarryPotter'' mentions it.

to:

If we had to choose a definitive example of this to the PresentDay RealLife, it would probably be WorldWarII.UsefulNotes/WorldWarII. While ''lots'' of wars have happened in the meantime, it was the [=WW2=] that had in one way or another shaped the modern world and affected its inhabitants for generations to come. And, of course, it will remain off-screen until a TimeMachine is invented. Someone did a study on this a few years ago. Of all the fiction books published in the English language since 1945, 95% of them, at some point, in some context, mention WorldWarII.World War II. Even ''Literature/HarryPotter'' mentions it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace


If we had to choose a definitive example of this to the PresentDay RealLife, it would probably be WorldWarII. While ''lots'' of wars have happened in the meantime, it was the [=WW2=] that had in one way or another shaped the modern world and affected its inhabitants for generations to come. And, of course, it will remain off-screen until a TimeMachine is invented. Someone did a study on this a few years ago. Of all the fiction books published in the English language since 1945, 95% of them, at some point, in some context, mention WorldWarII. Even ''HarryPotter'' mentions it.

to:

If we had to choose a definitive example of this to the PresentDay RealLife, it would probably be WorldWarII. While ''lots'' of wars have happened in the meantime, it was the [=WW2=] that had in one way or another shaped the modern world and affected its inhabitants for generations to come. And, of course, it will remain off-screen until a TimeMachine is invented. Someone did a study on this a few years ago. Of all the fiction books published in the English language since 1945, 95% of them, at some point, in some context, mention WorldWarII. Even ''HarryPotter'' ''Literature/HarryPotter'' mentions it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
restoring from the cut RL section of the main article

Added DiffLines:

If we had to choose a definitive example of this to the PresentDay RealLife, it would probably be WorldWarII. While ''lots'' of wars have happened in the meantime, it was the [=WW2=] that had in one way or another shaped the modern world and affected its inhabitants for generations to come. And, of course, it will remain off-screen until a TimeMachine is invented. Someone did a study on this a few years ago. Of all the fiction books published in the English language since 1945, 95% of them, at some point, in some context, mention WorldWarII. Even ''HarryPotter'' mentions it.

This has some interesting consequences even in [[ConstructedWorld fiction that doesn't reference WW2 in any way]]: whenever a post-War author introduces an off-screen war ExtyYearsFromNow, it will often take place about the same time ago in-story as the [=WW2=] did in RealLife at the moment of writing (give or take a decade).

Arguably, this trope is particularly prevalent in Japan, given the country's complicated and somewhat contradictory approach to the second world war, and to warfare generally. There's a whole raft of cultural things that contribute to this, and most of them aren't in themselves unique to Japan, but the combination of all of them plus the political climate of the region cause a willful ignoring of WWII by general consensus in a way that doesn't really happen anywhere else. While it's not exactly taboo to discuss the second world war, there's a general sense that it's 'all in the past' and, while knowing about WWII is important for understanding the current state of affairs, there's no need to dwell on the country's past failures (other states nearby don't see it that way at all, of course). This social trend tends to carry over into culture, perhaps most notably in the general scarcity of military stories that aren't either pre-modern or science fiction. The point, though, is not that there's few modern-era war stories, more that the attitude of mentioning earlier wars as underlying causes without examining them too closely has found its way into Japanese fiction generally.
----

Top