Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AnachronismStew / IndianaJonesAndTheKingdomOfTheCrystalSkull

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the Army-[=McCarthy=] Hearings and subsequent censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s. This is especially the case given Indy and Charles speaking as though the hysteria has only just reached academia, and Indy passes through an anti-communist protest on campus.

to:

* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the Army-[=McCarthy=] Hearings and subsequent censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy.UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy, who drank himself to death in May. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s. This is especially the case given Indy and Charles speaking as though the hysteria has only just reached academia, and Indy passes through an anti-communist protest on campus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the Army-McCarthy Hearings and subsequent censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s. This is especially the case given Indy and Charles speaking as though the hysteria has only just reached academia, and Indy passes through an anti-communist protest on campus.

to:

* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the Army-McCarthy Army-[=McCarthy=] Hearings and subsequent censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s. This is especially the case given Indy and Charles speaking as though the hysteria has only just reached academia, and Indy passes through an anti-communist protest on campus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s. This is especially the case given Indy and Charles speaking as though the hysteria has only just reached academia.

to:

* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the Army-McCarthy Hearings and subsequent censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s. This is especially the case given Indy and Charles speaking as though the hysteria has only just reached academia.academia, and Indy passes through an anti-communist protest on campus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Considering the movie is supposed to be a pastiche of 1950s sci-fi, it's weird that it's built on alien tropes that basically originated from the 1970s UFO craze, such as AncientAstronauts,[[note]]Popularized by Erich von Däniken's ''Chariots of the Gods'' in 1968[[/note]] [[RoswellThatEndsWell Roswell]],[[note]]While the actual incident happened in 1947, it didn't enter UFO lore until 1978[[/note]] {{Crystal Skull}}s,[[note]]Started being linked to aliens as part of the New Age movement in the '70s[[/note]] and TheGreys.[[note]]Spielberg himself helped popularize them with ''Film/CloseEncountersOfTheThirdKind''. In the actual '50s, aliens were usually represented as LittleGreenMen.[[/note]] The conspiracy theories surrounding Area51 are even newer than that, dating from 1989.[[note]]Moreover, Area 51 was mostly known only to UFO buffs prior to ''Film/IndependenceDay'', a movie released just twelve years before ''Kingdom of the Crystal Skull''[[/note]] Granted, this comes with the in-universe excuse that if the UFO mythology were true, it would be true before it entered pop culture. Still, the FlyingSaucer at the end is probably the only bit of alien iconography that actually matches with how aliens were represented in the real 1950s.

to:

* Considering the movie is supposed to be a pastiche of 1950s sci-fi, it's weird that it's built on alien tropes that basically originated from the 1970s UFO craze, such as AncientAstronauts,[[note]]Popularized by Erich von Däniken's ''Chariots of the Gods'' in 1968[[/note]] [[RoswellThatEndsWell Roswell]],[[note]]While the actual incident happened in 1947, it didn't enter UFO lore until 1978[[/note]] {{Crystal Skull}}s,[[note]]Started being linked to aliens as part of the New Age movement in the '70s[[/note]] and TheGreys.[[note]]Spielberg himself helped popularize them with ''Film/CloseEncountersOfTheThirdKind''. In the actual '50s, aliens were usually represented as LittleGreenMen.[[/note]] The conspiracy theories surrounding Area51 are even newer than that, dating from 1989.[[note]]Moreover, Area 51 was mostly known only to UFO buffs prior to ''Film/IndependenceDay'', a movie released just twelve years before ''Kingdom of the Crystal Skull''[[/note]] Granted, this all comes with the in-universe excuse that if the UFO mythology were true, it would be true before it entered pop culture. Still, the FlyingSaucer at the end is probably the only bit of alien iconography that actually matches with how aliens were represented in the real 1950s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Considering the movie is supposed to be a pastiche of 1950s sci-fi, it's weird that it's built on alien tropes that basically originated from the 1970s UFO craze, such as Area51, [[RoswellThatEndsWell Roswell]], {{Crystal Skull}}s being linked to AncientAstronauts, and TheGreys. Granted, this comes with the in-universe excuse that if the UFO mythology were true, it would be true before it entered pop culture. Still, the FlyingSaucer at the end is probably the only bit of alien iconography that actually matches with how aliens were represented in the real 1950s.

to:

* Considering the movie is supposed to be a pastiche of 1950s sci-fi, it's weird that it's built on alien tropes that basically originated from the 1970s UFO craze, such as Area51, AncientAstronauts,[[note]]Popularized by Erich von Däniken's ''Chariots of the Gods'' in 1968[[/note]] [[RoswellThatEndsWell Roswell]], Roswell]],[[note]]While the actual incident happened in 1947, it didn't enter UFO lore until 1978[[/note]] {{Crystal Skull}}s Skull}}s,[[note]]Started being linked to AncientAstronauts, aliens as part of the New Age movement in the '70s[[/note]] and TheGreys. TheGreys.[[note]]Spielberg himself helped popularize them with ''Film/CloseEncountersOfTheThirdKind''. In the actual '50s, aliens were usually represented as LittleGreenMen.[[/note]] The conspiracy theories surrounding Area51 are even newer than that, dating from 1989.[[note]]Moreover, Area 51 was mostly known only to UFO buffs prior to ''Film/IndependenceDay'', a movie released just twelve years before ''Kingdom of the Crystal Skull''[[/note]] Granted, this comes with the in-universe excuse that if the UFO mythology were true, it would be true before it entered pop culture. Still, the FlyingSaucer at the end is probably the only bit of alien iconography that actually matches with how aliens were represented in the real 1950s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Considering the movie is supposed to be a pastiche of 1950s sci-fi, it's weird that it's built on alien tropes that basically originated from the 1970s UFO craze, such as Area51, [[RoswellThatEndsWell Roswell]], {{Crystal Skull}}s, AncientAstronauts, and TheGreys. Granted, this comes with the in-universe excuse that if the UFO mythology were true, it would be true before it entered pop culture. Still, the FlyingSaucer at the end is probably the only bit of alien iconography that actually matches with how aliens were represented in the real 1950s.

to:

* Considering the movie is supposed to be a pastiche of 1950s sci-fi, it's weird that it's built on alien tropes that basically originated from the 1970s UFO craze, such as Area51, [[RoswellThatEndsWell Roswell]], {{Crystal Skull}}s, Skull}}s being linked to AncientAstronauts, and TheGreys. Granted, this comes with the in-universe excuse that if the UFO mythology were true, it would be true before it entered pop culture. Still, the FlyingSaucer at the end is probably the only bit of alien iconography that actually matches with how aliens were represented in the real 1950s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Considering the movie is supposed to be a pastiche of 1950s sci-fi, it's weird that it's built on alien tropes that basically originated from the 1970s UFO craze, such as Area51, [[RoswellThatEndsWell Roswell]], {{Crystal Skull}}s, AncientAstronauts, and TheGreys. Granted, this comes with the in-universe excuse that if the UFO mythology were true, it would be true before it entered pop culture. Still, the FlyingSaucer at the end is probably the only bit of alien iconography that actually matches with how aliens were represented in the real 1950s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s.

to:

* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s.
'50s. This is especially the case given Indy and Charles speaking as though the hysteria has only just reached academia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* 1957 is after the height of [=McCarthyism=], indeed three years after the censure of UsefulNotes/JosephMcCarthy. Yes, red-baiting continued to be a thing after that, but it's a thing even now to some extent, and the climate of fear portrayed in the film would be more accurate for the early '50s.



* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twin-cam V-twin first introduced in 1998, a fake kick-starter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.

to:

* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible available until 1972), twin-cam V-twin first introduced in 1998, a fake kick-starter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The digital displays in the rocket sled control room wouldn't exist until the late 1960s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twincam V-twin first introduced in 1999, a fake kickstarter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.
** It is possible for the film crew to go full {{Retraux}} on the bike, as aftermarket parts suppliers do produce reproduction parts for late-model bikes to look like their vintage counterparts. Or they could just get away with building or renting an old Panhead bike anyway.

to:

* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twincam twin-cam V-twin first introduced in 1999, 1998, a fake kickstarter kick-starter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.
** It is possible for the film crew to go full {{Retraux}} on the bike, as aftermarket parts suppliers do produce reproduction parts for late-model bikes to look like their vintage counterparts. Or they could just get away with building a replica Panhead from off the shelf parts or renting an old Panhead bike anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Soviet light truck used in the jungle is a 1961 GAZ 69.

to:

* The Soviet light truck used in the jungle is a 1961 GAZ 69.
69, though the GAZ 69 was produced from 1953 to 1972 with minor changes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Spalko's apparent veneration for UsefulNotes/JosefStalin is definitely not the Soviet party line of 1957, a year after UsefulNotes/NikitaKhrushchev[='s=] "secret speech" launched the de-Stalinization of the Soviet Union. It does make some sense if you assume that she's a Stalinist holdout in Khrushchev's regime, which would give her an air of RenegadeRussian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Aftermarket suppliers for Harleys e.g. Xzotic have produced cam and valve covers that resemble the Panhead models common during the 50s, so there\'s no reason they could goof on the bike.

Added DiffLines:

** It is possible for the film crew to go full {{Retraux}} on the bike, as aftermarket parts suppliers do produce reproduction parts for late-model bikes to look like their vintage counterparts. Or they could just get away with building or renting an old Panhead bike anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The pistol Mac pulls on Indy and Mutt is a Browning Hi-Power, but has an external extractor not introduced until 1963. It also has the high profile adjustable "beer can" rear sight introduced in 1971.

to:

* The pistol Mac pulls on Indy and Mutt is a Browning Hi-Power, but has an external extractor not introduced until 1963. It also has the high profile adjustable "beer can" rear sight introduced in 1971. Interestingly, it does have the correct "ring" hammer, which was replaced with a conventional spur hammer in 1972.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The pistols used by Soviet soldiers, KGB agents and Col. Dr. Spalko are Norinco Type 54, Chinese copy of the Tokarev TT-33. They have large grip mounted safeties (mandated by the ATF on imports in 1990, resulting in many Soviet-era TT-33s being drilled and retrofitted with safeties) and have distinct Norinco grips (no CCCP around the star). Soviet troops never used Chinese weaponry, for the simple reason that they could supply their own.

to:

* The pistols used by Soviet soldiers, KGB agents and Col. Dr. Spalko are Norinco Type 54, Chinese copy of the Tokarev TT-33. They have large grip mounted safeties (mandated by the ATF on imports in 1990, resulting in many Soviet-era TT-33s being drilled and retrofitted with safeties) and have distinct Norinco grips (no CCCP around the star). Soviet troops never used Chinese weaponry, for the simple reason that they could supply their own. Additionally, the TT-33 was removed from Soviet service in 1952 and replaced by the Makarov PM.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The map showing the trip to Peru has Belize instead of British Honduras. Belize was adopted in 1973.

to:

* The map showing the trip to Peru has Belize instead of British Honduras. The name Belize for the country was adopted in 1973.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Turns out Browning introduced the \"beer can\" rear sights in 1971.


* The pistol Mac pulls on Indy and Mutt is a Browning Hi-Power, but has an external extractor not introduced until 1963. It also has the higher profile adjustable "beer can" sights.

to:

* The pistol Mac pulls on Indy and Mutt is a Browning Hi-Power, but has an external extractor not introduced until 1963. It also has the higher high profile adjustable "beer can" sights.rear sight introduced in 1971.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Film/IndianaJonesAndTheKingdomOfTheCrustalSkull'' is set in 1957.

to:

''Film/IndianaJonesAndTheKingdomOfTheCrustalSkull'' ''Film/IndianaJonesAndTheKingdomOfTheCrystalSkull'' is set in 1957.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A Slip and Slide is set up at the nuclear test site. Whamo first introduced Slip and Slide in 1963.

to:

* A Slip and 'n Slide is set up at the nuclear test site. Whamo Wham-O first introduced Slip and 'n Slide in 1963.
1961.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* A Slip and Slide is set up at the nuclear test site. Whamo first introduced Slip and Slide in 1963.



* The pistol Mac pulls on Indy and Mutt is a Browning Hi-Power, but has an external extractor no tintroduced until 1963. It also has the higher profile adjustable "beer can" sights.

to:

* The pistol Mac pulls on Indy and Mutt is a Browning Hi-Power, but has an external extractor no tintroduced not introduced until 1963. It also has the higher profile adjustable "beer can" sights.

Added: 1638

Removed: 357

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!General:



* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twincam V-twin first introduced in 1999, a fake kickstarter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.




!!Vehicles:
* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twincam V-twin first introduced in 1999, a fake kickstarter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.



* The Soviet light truck used in the jungle is a 1961 GAZ 69.

to:

* The Soviet light truck used in the jungle is a 1961 GAZ 69.69.

!!Weapons:
* The pistols used by Soviet soldiers, KGB agents and Col. Dr. Spalko are Norinco Type 54, Chinese copy of the Tokarev TT-33. They have large grip mounted safeties (mandated by the ATF on imports in 1990, resulting in many Soviet-era TT-33s being drilled and retrofitted with safeties) and have distinct Norinco grips (no CCCP around the star). Soviet troops never used Chinese weaponry, for the simple reason that they could supply their own.
* The rifles carried by Soviet soldiers are Norinco Type-56 (fixed stock) and 56-1 (folding stock), Chinese copies of the AK-47 and AKS-47. The Type-56 has a smooth stamped receiver that resembles at a glance the AK-47's milled receiver as well as open top sights. Aside from Soviet troops not using Chinese weaponry, no AK-type rifle had a stamped receiver before 1959, and the Chinese in particular did not adopt it until 1963.
* The rocket launcher Indy uses is a Type-69, a Chinese copy of the RPG-7, and seems to be able to fire the PG-2 antitank grenade, which only the RPG-2 can do. The RPG-7 was introduced in 1961.
* The pistol Mac pulls on Indy and Mutt is a Browning Hi-Power, but has an external extractor no tintroduced until 1963. It also has the higher profile adjustable "beer can" sights.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twincam V-twin first introduced in 1999, a fake kickstarter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.

to:

* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twincam V-twin first introduced in 1999, a fake kickstarter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.brake.
* The map showing the trip to Peru has Belize instead of British Honduras. Belize was adopted in 1973.
* The gas masks used by the bio-hazard crew while decontaminating Indy of radiation are M-17 Gas Masks, which were not developed and used until 1959. Additionally, the M-17 mask is not designed for protection against radiation, making its use for radiation clean up incorrect and dangerous.
* The troop transport truck used by the Soviets in the jungle chase is an REO M-35, an American truck. Aside from moving the headlights, it's had little if any modification to imitate a Soviet [=ZiL=] 131. It also has a 1970s GM style side view mirror.
* The Soviet light truck used in the jungle is a 1961 GAZ 69.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''Film/IndianaJonesAndTheKingdomOfTheCrustalSkull'' is set in 1957.

* Indy says that he and Oxley were obsessed with crystal skulls - in particular the Mitchell-Hedges skull - in college. Mitchell-Hedges claimed that his daughter unearthed the skull during a dig in 1927, but did not actually begin making that claim until 1943. This is well beyond Indy's or Oxley's college years.
* Mutt's Harley Davidson is a 2007 FXSTS Softail Springer, with a hydraulic master cylinder for the front disc brake (neither were avaible until 1972), twincam V-twin first introduced in 1999, a fake kickstarter (not used by Harley since c. 1968), a belt-final drive instead of a chain, a non-stock fuel tank, and a steel plate covering the rear disc brake.

Top