Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AdaptationPersonalityChange / GameOfThrones

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:[[center: [- '''Tropes for ''Series/GameOfThrones'''''\\
GameOfThrones/TropesA ([[AdaptationalAttractiveness/GameOfThrones Adaptational Attractiveness]], [[AdaptationalBadass/GameOfThrones Adaptational Badass]], [[AdaptationalHeroism/GameOfThrones Adaptational Heroism]], [[AdaptationalModesty/GameOfThrones Adaptational Modesty]], [[AdaptationalVillainy/GameOfThrones Adaptational Villainy]], [[AdaptationalWimp/GameOfThrones Adaptational Wimp]], [[AdaptationDistillation/GameOfThrones Adaptation Distillation]], [[AdaptationDyeJob/GameOfThrones Adaptation Dye-Job]], [[AdaptationExpansion/GameOfThrones Adaptation Expansion]], [[AdaptationExplanationExtrication/GameOfThrones Adaptation Explanation Extrication]], [[AdaptationInducedPlotHole/GameOfThrones Adaptation-Induced Plot Hole]], [[AdaptationNameChange/GameOfThrones Adaptation Name Change]], '''Adaptation Personality Change''', [[AdaptedOut/GameOfThrones Adapted Out]], [[AgeLift/GameOfThrones Age Lift]], [[AnimalMotifs/GameOfThrones Animal Motifs]], [[AscendedExtra/GameOfThrones Ascended Extra]], [[AssholeVictim/GameOfThrones Asshole Victim]], [[AsYouKnow/GameOfThrones As You Know]]) | GameOfThrones/TropesB ([[BadassBoast/GameOfThrones Badass Boast]], [[BaitAndSwitch/GameOfThrones Bait-and-Switch]], [[BullyingADragon/GameOfThrones Bullying a Dragon]]) | GameOfThrones/TropesCToD ([[CallBack/GameOfThrones Call-Back]], [[CanonForeigner/GameOfThrones Canon Foreigner]], [[CompositeCharacter/GameOfThrones Composite Character]], [[CruelAndUnusualDeath/GameOfThrones Cruel and Unusual Death]], [[DeathByAdaptation/GameOfThrones Death by Adaptation]], [[DemotedToExtra/GameOfThrones Demoted to Extra]], [[DueToTheDead/GameOfThrones Due to the Dead]]) | GameOfThrones/TropesEToF ([[EstablishingCharacterMoment/GameOfThrones Establishing Character Moment]], [[FamousLastWords/GameOfThrones Famous Last Words]], [[FanDisservice/GameOfThrones Fan Disservice]], [[FantasyCounterpartCulture/GameOfThrones Fantasy Counterpart Culture]], [[Foil/GameOfThrones Foil]], [[Foreshadowing/GameOfThrones Foreshadowing]]) | GameOfThrones/TropesGToK ([[HateSink/GameOfThrones Hate Sink]], [[JerkassHasAPoint/GameOfThrones Jerkass Has a Point]]) | GameOfThrones/TropesLToO ([[Leitmotif/GameOfThrones Leitmotif]], [[OhCrap/GameOfThrones Oh, Crap!]]) | GameOfThrones/TropesPToS ([[PragmaticAdaptation/GameOfThrones Pragmatic Adaptation]], [[RealityEnsues/GameOfThrones Reality Ensues]]) | GameOfThrones/TropesTToZ ([[WhamEpisode/GameOfThrones Wham Episode]])]]]]-]

Added: 665

Changed: 150

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sam. In the books, he's a complete ShrinkingViolet who improves only very gradually and insists, "It was the dragonglass that slew it, not me," while in the show he likes to brag up his accomplishments: "How many brothers can say they've killed a White Walker ''and'' a Thenn? I might be the first in history!" Similarly, in the books he's "almost as frightened of brothels as the haunted forest," while in the show he constantly [[CovertPervert goes on about girls]] (Grenn and Edd {{lampshade|Hanging}} this) and asks, "Don't you think it's a bit unfair, making us take our vows while they sneak off for a little Sally on the side?"

to:

* Sam. In the books, he's a complete ShrinkingViolet who improves only very gradually and insists, "It was the dragonglass that slew it, not me," while in the show he likes to brag up his accomplishments: "How many brothers can say they've killed a White Walker ''and'' a Thenn? I might be the first in history!" Similarly, in the books he's "almost as frightened of brothels as the haunted forest," while in the show he constantly [[CovertPervert goes on about girls]] (Grenn and Edd {{lampshade|Hanging}} this) and asks, "Don't you think it's a bit unfair, making us take our vows while they sneak off for a little Sally on the side?"side?" He's also significantly less terrified of his father, being willing to steal Heartsbane from him and showing little concern at the possible reprisal.


Added DiffLines:

* In the books, Euron is a cosmopolitan, theatrical mastermind with megalomaniacal ambitions and a FauxAffablyEvil attitude. His show counterpart, while still flamboyant in his own way, is crude, unsubtle, and driven primarily by his sexual desires.
* Tyenne Sand is remarkably less subtle and manipulative than her book counterpart, who is unsettlingly good at faking innocence while perhaps being the most cruel of the Sand Snakes through the usage of poisons and assassination. There is little in the show to distinguish her from her more martial sisters.
* Cersei is significantly more mentally stable than in the books, lacking that version's extreme paranoia.

Changed: 1277

Removed: 1284

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sam:
** In the books, he's a complete ShrinkingViolet who improves only very gradually and insists, "It was [[spoiler: the dragonglass]] that slew it, not me," while in the show he likes to brag up his accomplishments: "How many brothers can say they've killed a White Walker ''and'' a Thenn? I might be the first in history!"
** Similarly, in the books he's "almost as frightened of brothels as the haunted forest," while in the show he constantly [[CovertPervert goes on about girls]] (Grenn and Edd {{lampshade|Hanging}} this) and asks, "Don't you think it's a bit unfair, making us take our vows while they sneak off for a little Sally on the side?"

to:

* Sam:
**
Sam. In the books, he's a complete ShrinkingViolet who improves only very gradually and insists, "It was [[spoiler: the dragonglass]] dragonglass that slew it, not me," while in the show he likes to brag up his accomplishments: "How many brothers can say they've killed a White Walker ''and'' a Thenn? I might be the first in history!"
**
history!" Similarly, in the books he's "almost as frightened of brothels as the haunted forest," while in the show he constantly [[CovertPervert goes on about girls]] (Grenn and Edd {{lampshade|Hanging}} this) and asks, "Don't you think it's a bit unfair, making us take our vows while they sneak off for a little Sally on the side?"



* Fat Walda is shy, demure and amenable unlike the jolly BigFun she is in the books.
* Sansa:
** The books never even imply that she was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and that she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger needs to remind her of in the same episode.
** In fact, despite the aloofness between them, in the books Jon recalls Sansa teaching him how to dance and talk to girls and Sansa thinks warmly of Jon in ''A Feast for Crows''. Moreover, this all comes across as an InformedFlaw within the show itself, as Sansa is never shown acting like this with Jon or even arguing with Arya about it.

to:

* Fat Walda in the show is shy, demure and amenable unlike the jolly BigFun she is in the books.
* Sansa:
**
Sansa. The books never even imply that she was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and that she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger needs to remind her of in the same episode.
**
episode. In fact, despite the aloofness between them, in the books Jon recalls Sansa teaching him how to dance and talk to girls and Sansa thinks warmly of Jon in ''A Feast for Crows''. Moreover, this all comes across as an InformedFlaw within the show itself, as Sansa is never shown acting like this with Jon or even arguing with Arya about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the original books, Renly is frivolous, charismatic and entitled, with a love for the fashion and romance of knightly pursuits. He seeks the throne simply because he has the support to do so. In the show, Renly is the complete opposite: a serious and intelligent man who hates bloodshed and must be convinced to seek the throne because he'll make a better ruler.

to:

* In the original books, Renly is frivolous, charismatic charismatic, entitled and entitled, superficially charming, with a love for the fashion and romance of knightly pursuits.pursuits, but mainly an arrogant JerkJock and SleazyPolitician who was fiercely anti-intellectual. He seeks the throne simply because he has the support to do so. In the show, Renly is the complete opposite: a serious and serious, intelligent man (the intellectual of the Baratheon brothers) and bureaucratic genuine NiceGuy who hates bloodshed and must be convinced to seek the throne because he'll make a better ruler.ruler, as a result of AdaptationExpansion which explores Renly's private life much more than the novels do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tywin in the series never has a thought beyond what he needs to do to attain and keep power. In the show, we learn that he ''does'' have a softer side, at least with Arya. His true ruthlessness seems to be reserved for his own family and others he expects more of.

to:

* Tywin in the book series never has a thought beyond what he needs to do to attain and keep power. In the show, we learn that he ''does'' have a softer side, at least with Arya. His true ruthlessness seems to be reserved for his own family and others he expects more of.

Changed: 23

Removed: 866

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to discussion


* The show's version of Tyrion Lannister may as well be an entirely different character than the one in the books.
** [[CharacterizationMarchesOn While the show initially presents him as cynical deadpan snarker,]] Tyrion later seems to go out of his way to be an all-around NiceGuy to everyone he meets. His biggest contributions stem less from his brilliance and more so from the emotional support he provides for others.
** Tyrion's book counterpart is every bit as ruthless, greedy, lustful, and power-hungry as the other members of House Lannister. He maintains a prodigious degree of cunning, revels in exerting power over others, has a massive ego, and is capable of committing acts of great cruelty to those that cross him. His PetTheDog moments are reserved for those close to him and fellow outcasts, for whom he has a soft spot due to his status as a dwarf.



* Shae: Shae from the books was a GoldDigger who was only interested in Tyrion for his money and betrayed him when she got a better offer from Cersei. In the show she's a HookerWithAHeartOfGold who genuinely loves Tyrion. She still betrays him, but in the show it's because she's a WomanScorned after Tyrion tried to BreakHerHeartToSaveHer. The show also makes her more violent, threatening and/or attacking several characters with knives.

to:

* Shae: Shae from the books was a GoldDigger who was only interested in Tyrion for his money and betrayed him when she got a better offer from Cersei. In the show she's a HookerWithAHeartOfGold who genuinely loves Tyrion. She still betrays him, but in the show it's because she's a WomanScorned after Tyrion tried to BreakHerHeartToSaveHer. The show also makes her more violent, physically assertive, threatening and/or attacking several characters with knives.

Changed: 833

Removed: 2112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stannis's personality is pretty similar, and the show's version has progressed further in the story, so the twists in his character might get mirrored in the text.


* Shae:
** Shae from the books was a GoldDigger who was only interested in Tyrion for his money and betrayed him when she got a better offer from Cersei. In the show she's a HookerWithAHeartOfGold who genuinely loves Tyrion. She still betrays him, but in the show it's because she's a WomanScorned after Tyrion tried to BreakHerHeartToSaveHer.
** Also of note, there is her reaction upon being found by Tyrion in Tywin's bed after her betrayal. In the books, she desperately attempts to plead with Tyrion even as he strangles her to death, whereas her show counter-part immediately panics upon seeing Tyrion and grabs a knife, making his strangling of her more akin to self-defense.

to:

* Shae:
**
Shae: Shae from the books was a GoldDigger who was only interested in Tyrion for his money and betrayed him when she got a better offer from Cersei. In the show she's a HookerWithAHeartOfGold who genuinely loves Tyrion. She still betrays him, but in the show it's because she's a WomanScorned after Tyrion tried to BreakHerHeartToSaveHer.
** Also of note, there is her reaction upon being found by Tyrion in Tywin's bed after her betrayal. In the books, she desperately attempts to plead with Tyrion even as he strangles her to death, whereas her
BreakHerHeartToSaveHer. The show counter-part immediately panics upon seeing Tyrion and grabs a knife, making his strangling of also makes her more akin to self-defense.violent, threatening and/or attacking several characters with knives.



* Brienne:
** She becomes more aggressive and brusque than her gentle and unfailingly kind WideEyedIdealist book counterpart, who recoils at the thought of killing and treats everyone around her with an unfailing fairness. In the show, possibly thanks to the writers age lifting her by close to a decade, she actively seeks vengeance over fulfilling her vows of protection and is considerably more bitter and cynical, harboring no delusions as to the state of Westeros, and projects a much colder exterior as a result — particularly when it comes to Davos and Melisandre, who she openly regards as opportunistic traitors.
** That being said, she's still bullheadedly honorable and rarely crosses over into being openly ''unkind'' — even when it comes to Podrick, whom she initially treats a mite harshly but ultimately takes under her wing after bonding with him and apologizing for her behavior.
** However, she still takes obvious pleasure in killing enemies, even if it's a wounded man who can't fight back, and gloating about it, while in the books Brienne has only ever killed in self-defense, and even though they were utterly vile people she never takes pleasure in it.
* Stannis also comes to mind. While he's a bit of a hardass in the books, the TV series turns him into a fanatic who sacrificed his own daughter. In the books he's more of a pragmatic atheist who isn't so willing to follow Melisandre, and is more conflicted about his actions.

to:

* Brienne:
** She becomes more aggressive
Brienne: While both versions of the character are stubborn, honorable and brusque than brave, in the show she's also self-confident, aggressive, brusque, judgmental and even cynical at time. This goes hand-in-hand with her gentle AgeLift and unfailingly kind AdaptationalAttractiveness. In the book, she's a shy, awkward WideEyedIdealist book counterpart, who recoils at the thought of killing and treats everyone around her with an unfailing fairness. In the show, possibly thanks to the writers age lifting her by close to a decade, she actively seeks vengeance over fulfilling her vows of protection extremely low self-esteem and is considerably more bitter and cynical, harboring no delusions as to the state of Westeros, and projects a much colder exterior as a result — particularly when it comes to Davos and Melisandre, who she openly regards as opportunistic traitors.
** That being said, she's still bullheadedly honorable and rarely crosses over into being openly ''unkind'' — even when it comes to Podrick, whom she initially treats a mite harshly but ultimately takes under her wing after bonding
with him and apologizing for a general aversion to violence in spite of her behavior.
** However, she still takes obvious pleasure
interest in killing enemies, even if it's a wounded man who can't fight back, and gloating about it, while in the books Brienne has only ever killed in self-defense, and even though they were utterly vile people she never takes pleasure in it.
* Stannis also comes to mind. While he's a bit of a hardass in the books, the TV series turns him into a fanatic who sacrificed his own daughter. In the books he's more of a pragmatic atheist who isn't so willing to follow Melisandre, and is more conflicted about his actions.
fighting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Both versions of Bronn are pretty close. Show!Bronn's increased affability is more a question of degree. Book!Bronn is fond of Tyrion and cracks jokes as well.


* Bronn from the books is simply a thuggish ProfessionalKiller whom Tyrion employs as his bodyguard. In the show he's an affable, witty PunchClockVillain who genuinely becomes friends with Tyrion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is a different trope


* An in-universe example with the play depicting Season 1:
** Joffrey is a well meaning but ineffective ruler.
** Cersei is kind and not at all involved in treason.
** Ned is a greedy buffoon.
** Tyrion is the villain responsible for everything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Improved readability


* Tywin in the series never has a thought beyond what he needs to do to attain and keep power. In the series, we learn that he ''does'' have a softer side, at least with Arya. His true ruthlessness seems to be reserved for his own family and others he expects more of.

to:

* Tywin in the series never has a thought beyond what he needs to do to attain and keep power. In the series, show, we learn that he ''does'' have a softer side, at least with Arya. His true ruthlessness seems to be reserved for his own family and others he expects more of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The show's version of Tyrion Lannister may as well be an entirely different character than the one in the books.
** [[CharacterizationMarchesOn While the show initially presents him as cynical deadpan snarker,]] Tyrion later seems to go out of his way to be an all-around NiceGuy to everyone he meets. His biggest contributions stem less from his brilliance and more so from the emotional support he provides for others.
**Tyrion's book counterpart is every bit as ruthless, greedy, lustful, and power-hungry as the other members of House Lannister. He maintains a prodigious degree of cunning, revels in exerting power over others, has a massive ego, and is capable of committing acts of great cruelty to those that cross him. His PetTheDog moments are reserved for those close to him and fellow outcasts, for whom he has a soft spot due to his status as a dwarf.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fat Walda is shy and demure, unlike the jolly BigFun she is in the books.

to:

* Fat Walda is shy shy, demure and demure, amenable unlike the jolly BigFun she is in the books.

Added: 2786

Changed: 3855

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the books Sam's a complete ShrinkingViolet who improves only very gradually and insists, "It was [[spoiler: the dragonglass]] that slew it, not me," while in the show he likes to brag up his accomplishments: "How many brothers can say they've killed a White Walker ''and'' a Thenn? I might be the first in history!" Similarly, in the books he's "almost as frightened of brothels as the haunted forest," while in the show he constantly [[CovertPervert goes on about girls]] (Grenn and Edd lampshade this) and asks, "Don't you think it's a bit unfair, making us take our vows while they sneak off for a little Sally on the side?"

to:

* Sam:
**
In the books Sam's books, he's a complete ShrinkingViolet who improves only very gradually and insists, "It was [[spoiler: the dragonglass]] that slew it, not me," while in the show he likes to brag up his accomplishments: "How many brothers can say they've killed a White Walker ''and'' a Thenn? I might be the first in history!" history!"
**
Similarly, in the books he's "almost as frightened of brothels as the haunted forest," while in the show he constantly [[CovertPervert goes on about girls]] (Grenn and Edd lampshade {{lampshade|Hanging}} this) and asks, "Don't you think it's a bit unfair, making us take our vows while they sneak off for a little Sally on the side?"



* The Waif is a {{Jerkass}} AlphaBitch who strikes, bullies, and denigrates Arya instead of the friendly and helpful mentor she is in the books.

to:

* The Waif is a {{Jerkass}} AlphaBitch who strikes, bullies, and denigrates Arya Arya, instead of the friendly and helpful mentor she is in the books.



* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and that she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger needs to remind her of in the same episode. In fact, despite the aloofness between them, in the books Jon recalls Sansa teaching him how to dance and talk to girls and Sansa thinks warmly of Jon in ''A Feast for Crows''. Moreover, this all comes across as an InformedFlaw within the show itself, as Sansa is never shown acting like this with Jon or even arguing with Arya about it.

to:

* Sansa:
**
The books never even imply Sansa that she was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and that she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger needs to remind her of in the same episode. episode.
**
In fact, despite the aloofness between them, in the books Jon recalls Sansa teaching him how to dance and talk to girls and Sansa thinks warmly of Jon in ''A Feast for Crows''. Moreover, this all comes across as an InformedFlaw within the show itself, as Sansa is never shown acting like this with Jon or even arguing with Arya about it.



* Prince Doran Martell. In the show he wants to stop the CycleOfRevenge consuming his family. In the books, he's been plotting against the Lannisters despite Lord Tywin and The Mountain both being dead. His schemes has already claimed the life of one of his sons.

to:

* Prince Doran Martell. In the show he wants to stop the CycleOfRevenge consuming his family. In the books, he's been plotting against the Lannisters despite Lord Tywin and The Mountain both being dead. His schemes has have already claimed the life of one of his sons.



* Shae from the books was a GoldDigger who was only interested in Tyrion for his money and betrayed him when she got a better offer from Cersei. In the show she's a HookerWithAHeartOfGold who genuinely loves Tyrion. She still betrays him, but in the show it's because she's a WomanScorned after Tyrion tried to BreakHerHeartToSaveHer. Also of note, there is her reaction upon being found by Tyrion in Tywin's bed after her betrayal. In the books, she desperately attempts to plead with Tyrion even as he strangles her to death, whereas her show counter-part immediately panics upon seeing Tyrion and grabs a knife, making his strangling of her more akin to self-defense.

to:

* Shae:
**
Shae from the books was a GoldDigger who was only interested in Tyrion for his money and betrayed him when she got a better offer from Cersei. In the show she's a HookerWithAHeartOfGold who genuinely loves Tyrion. She still betrays him, but in the show it's because she's a WomanScorned after Tyrion tried to BreakHerHeartToSaveHer. BreakHerHeartToSaveHer.
**
Also of note, there is her reaction upon being found by Tyrion in Tywin's bed after her betrayal. In the books, she desperately attempts to plead with Tyrion even as he strangles her to death, whereas her show counter-part immediately panics upon seeing Tyrion and grabs a knife, making his strangling of her more akin to self-defense.



* Brienne becomes more aggressive and brusque than her gentle and unfailingly kind WideEyedIdealist book counterpart, who recoiles at the thought of killing and treats everyone around her with an unfailing fairness. In the show, possibly thanks to the writers age lifting her by close to a decade, she actively seeks vengeance over fulfilling her vows of protection and is considerably more bitter and cynical, harboring no delusions as to the state of Westeros, and projects a much colder exterior as a result — particularly when it comes to Davos and Melisandre, who she openly regards as opportunistic traitors. That being said, she's still bullheadedly honorable and rarely crosses over into being openly ''unkind'' — even when it comes to Podrick, whom she initially treats a mite harshly but ultimately takes under her wing after bonding with him and apologizing for her behavior. However she still takes obvious pleasure in killing enemies, even if it's a wounded man who can't fight back, and gloating about it, while in the books Brienne has only ever killed in self-defense, and even though they were utterly vile people she never takes pleasure in it.
* Stannis also comes to mind. While he's a bit of a hardass in the books, the TV series turns him into a fanatic who sacrificed his own daughter. In the books he's more of a pragmatic atheist who isn't so willing to follow Melissandre, and is more conflicted about his actions.

to:

* Brienne Brienne:
** She
becomes more aggressive and brusque than her gentle and unfailingly kind WideEyedIdealist book counterpart, who recoiles recoils at the thought of killing and treats everyone around her with an unfailing fairness. In the show, possibly thanks to the writers age lifting her by close to a decade, she actively seeks vengeance over fulfilling her vows of protection and is considerably more bitter and cynical, harboring no delusions as to the state of Westeros, and projects a much colder exterior as a result — particularly when it comes to Davos and Melisandre, who she openly regards as opportunistic traitors. traitors.
**
That being said, she's still bullheadedly honorable and rarely crosses over into being openly ''unkind'' — even when it comes to Podrick, whom she initially treats a mite harshly but ultimately takes under her wing after bonding with him and apologizing for her behavior. However behavior.
** However,
she still takes obvious pleasure in killing enemies, even if it's a wounded man who can't fight back, and gloating about it, while in the books Brienne has only ever killed in self-defense, and even though they were utterly vile people she never takes pleasure in it.
* Stannis also comes to mind. While he's a bit of a hardass in the books, the TV series turns him into a fanatic who sacrificed his own daughter. In the books he's more of a pragmatic atheist who isn't so willing to follow Melissandre, Melisandre, and is more conflicted about his actions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Brienne becomes more aggressive and brusque than her gentle WideEyedIdealist book counterpart, actively seeking vengeance over fulfilling her vows of protection.

to:

* Brienne becomes more aggressive and brusque than her gentle and unfailingly kind WideEyedIdealist book counterpart, who recoiles at the thought of killing and treats everyone around her with an unfailing fairness. In the show, possibly thanks to the writers age lifting her by close to a decade, she actively seeking seeks vengeance over fulfilling her vows of protection.protection and is considerably more bitter and cynical, harboring no delusions as to the state of Westeros, and projects a much colder exterior as a result — particularly when it comes to Davos and Melisandre, who she openly regards as opportunistic traitors. That being said, she's still bullheadedly honorable and rarely crosses over into being openly ''unkind'' — even when it comes to Podrick, whom she initially treats a mite harshly but ultimately takes under her wing after bonding with him and apologizing for her behavior. However she still takes obvious pleasure in killing enemies, even if it's a wounded man who can't fight back, and gloating about it, while in the books Brienne has only ever killed in self-defense, and even though they were utterly vile people she never takes pleasure in it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Stannis also comes to mind. While he's a bit of a hardass in the books, the TV series turns him into a fanatic who sacrificed his own daughter. In the books he's more of a pragmatic atheist who isn't so willing to follow Melissandre, and is more conflicted about his actions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Prince Doran Martell. In the show he wants to stop the CycleOfRevenge consuming his family. In the books, he's been plotting against the Lannisters despite Lord Tywin and The Mountain both being dead. His schemes has already claimed the life of one of his sons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Brienne becomes more aggressive and brusque than her gentle WideEyedIdealist book counterpart, actively seeking vengeance over fulfilling her vows of protection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Robb Stark is a lot more confident and assertive in the show than in the books, where he's just a teenage boy trying to live up to the expectations placed on him. Similarly, many of Daenerys Targaryen's insecurities were erased after her dragons hatched, whereas her book counterpart at times struggled with feelings of being in over her head.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Dagmer Cleftjaw from the books only appears once, but it's established he's an HonoraryUncle figure to Theon Greyjoy. In the show he's TheCorrupter and a PoisonousFriend, convincing Theon to do darker and darker deeds to gain his men's respect and eventually betraying him after Theon's occupation of Winterfell fails. He's essentially a stand-in for Ramsay Bolton, who had the same role in the books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Bronn from the books is simply a thuggish ProfessionalKiller whom Tyrion employs as his bodyguard. In the show he's an affable, witty PunchClockVillain who genuinely becomes friends with Tyrion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Shae from the books was a GoldDigger who was only interested in Tyrion for his money and betrayed him when she got a better offer from Cersei. In the show she's a HookerWithAHeartOfGold who genuinely loves Tyrion. She still betrays him, but in the show it's because she's a WomanScorned after Tyrion tried to BreakHerHeartToSaveHer. Also of note, there is her reaction upon being found by Tyrion in Tywin's bed after her betrayal. In the books, she desperately attempts to plead with Tyrion even as he strangles her to death, whereas her show counter-part immediately panics upon seeing Tyrion and grabs a knife, making his strangling of her more akin to self-defense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Tywin in the series never has a thought beyond what he needs to do to attain and keep power. In the series, we learn that he ''does'' have a softer side, at least with Arya. His true ruthlessness seems to be reserved for his own family and others he expects more of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the original books, Renly is frivolous, charismatic and entitled, with a love for the fashion and romance of knightly pursuits. He seeks the throne simply because he has the support to do so. In the show, Renly is the complete opposite: a serious and intelligent man who hates bloodshed and must be convinced to seek the throne because he'll make a better ruler.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ellaria Sand has the exact opposite personality of her book counterpart. In the books, Ellaria was the OnlySaneMan trying to convince the Martells to let go of their feud with the Lannisters. Here, she's a WarHawk who wants to march to King's Landing or, barring that, to send Myrcella home in bits.

Added: 104

Removed: 104

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A lot of characters have had their [[AdaptationPersonalityChange personalities changed]] from the books:



A lot of characters have had their [[AdaptationPersonalityChange personalities changed]] from the books:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* An in-universe example with the play depicting Season 1:
** Joffrey is a well meaning but ineffective ruler.
** Cersei is kind and not at all involved in treason.
** Ned is a greedy buffoon.
** Tyrion is the villain responsible for everything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger feels the need to remind her of in the same episode. Book!Jon Snow recalls that Book!Sansa taught him how to dance and talk to girls, and while Sansa was indeed distant to Jon and aloof, she does think warmly of him in ''A Feast for Crows''. In the show, moreover, this comes across as InformedFlaw, as she is never shown acting like this with Jon, or arguing with Arya on this matter, in the show.

to:

* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and that she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger feels the need needs to remind her of in the same episode. Book!Jon Snow In fact, despite the aloofness between them, in the books Jon recalls that Book!Sansa taught Sansa teaching him how to dance and talk to girls, girls and while Sansa was indeed distant to Jon and aloof, she does think thinks warmly of him Jon in ''A Feast for Crows''. In the show, moreover, Moreover, this all comes across as InformedFlaw, an InformedFlaw within the show itself, as she Sansa is never shown acting like this with Jon, Jon or even arguing with Arya on this matter, in the show.about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger feels the need to remind her of in the same episode. However this comes across as InformedFlaw, as she is never shown acting like this in the show.

to:

* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger feels the need to remind her of in the same episode. However Book!Jon Snow recalls that Book!Sansa taught him how to dance and talk to girls, and while Sansa was indeed distant to Jon and aloof, she does think warmly of him in ''A Feast for Crows''. In the show, moreover, this comes across as InformedFlaw, as she is never shown acting like this with Jon, or arguing with Arya on this matter, in the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger feels the need to remind her of in the same episode.

to:

* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger feels the need to remind her of in the same episode. However this comes across as InformedFlaw, as she is never shown acting like this in the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----
A lot of characters have had their [[AdaptationPersonalityChange personalities changed]] from the books:

* In the books Sam's a complete ShrinkingViolet who improves only very gradually and insists, "It was [[spoiler: the dragonglass]] that slew it, not me," while in the show he likes to brag up his accomplishments: "How many brothers can say they've killed a White Walker ''and'' a Thenn? I might be the first in history!" Similarly, in the books he's "almost as frightened of brothels as the haunted forest," while in the show he constantly [[CovertPervert goes on about girls]] (Grenn and Edd lampshade this) and asks, "Don't you think it's a bit unfair, making us take our vows while they sneak off for a little Sally on the side?"
* In the books, Roose Bolton is a medieval health nut who drinks hippocras (spiced wine believed to have medicinal properties) and advocates the health benefits of prunes and leeching to the extent that many call him "the leech lord". The show has none of this, with even his adaptational TheTeetotaler trait based on alertness rather than health.
* The show's stern, formidable Mance Rayder is a far cry from the books' crafty, unassuming badass bard who sings, goes on secret adventures south of the Wall, and leads cavalry charges in his NonUniformUniform and winged helm.
* The Waif is a {{Jerkass}} AlphaBitch who strikes, bullies, and denigrates Arya instead of the friendly and helpful mentor she is in the books.
* In the books, Tommen is an adorable (if unprecocious) 8-year-old CheerfulChild whose idea of governance is playfully stamping decrees and plotting to outlaw [[StockYuck beets]]. In order to keep him in the same PuppetKing role despite an AgeLift into his teens, the show makes him a WeakWilled ExtremeDoormat.
* Tycho Nestoris of the Iron Bank is much sterner and more disapproving than the obliging clerk of the novels.
* Fat Walda is shy and demure, unlike the jolly BigFun she is in the books.
* The books never even imply Sansa was "awful" to Jon as they agree in "Book of the Stranger", only that they were never as close as Jon and Arya and she correctly referred to him as a half-brother which, oddly enough, is something Littlefinger feels the need to remind her of in the same episode.
----

Top