Follow TV Tropes

Following

Archived Discussion Main / HolyShitQuotient

Go To

This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.


Khym Chanur: Shouldn't that be the other way around, the number of "Holy shit!" moments divided by the number of scenes? As it is now defined in the entry, the HSQ decreases as the number of HS moments increase. But maybe I'm just missing something obvious.

Devil's Advocate: Yes.


I would've spelled it "eightch" rather than "aich". —Document N


Brickman: Having discussed this on the forums here I have switched the redirect and the actual page on this page, because "HSQ" is meaningless to someone who doesn't know what it is already (requiring you to read the page to even guess) while "Holy Shit Quotient" is self-explanatory.


Sean Tucker: Should we have a list of series/movies with notably high HSQ?

Tanto: No, because that would quickly become twisted into "anything that any troper anywhere likes".

Sean Tucker: Then make the criteria similar to So Bad Its Horrible. If only one troper and a few of his friends think that something has a high HSQ, it gets nuked. However, if something has an unquestionably gigantic HSQ (like 300 or Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann) then it stays.

LE Xicon 712: how about if we only put in the moments in which ALL the fandom agrees on

Top