This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.
Fix examples in Surprisingly Improved Sequel launched as Even Better Sequel: From YKTTW
Working Title: Even Better Sequel: From YKTTW
Prfnoff: I don't care that some people spoke against this split in YKTTW. Surprisingly Improved Sequel has definite problems, and I don't think two subjective trope pages are necessarily going to be worse than one. Sure, there will probably be Edit Wars, but we've put up with worse in So Bad Its Horrible, which also stands close to a similar subjective trope.
Charred Knight: Its annoying, and should be in gushing. Theirs a reason why I have repeatly deleted these very examples, its just an excuse to gush about shows you like. Also its subjective as hell, for example I felt that Toy Story 2 was probably the worst of Pixar's work just because it wasn't as inventive, fun, and well written, plus it had Joan Cusack's god awful voice.
I will remove my objection if you rename it Arguably Marginally Improved Sequel Of An Excellent First Film and you rewrite every single one of them to remove the gushing.
Eric DVH: This is about general consensus in the world at large, not your or my opinion (also, Toy Story 2 was awesome. The worst Pixar film was A Bug's Life, which happened to coincide with Antz, the only good animation Dreamworks has ever made.;-)
